Holliday intermediates and reaction by-products in FLP protein-promoted site-specific recombination.

Holliday structures are formed and resolved by FLP protein during site-specific recombination. These structures have been isolated and are visualized in both native and partially denatured states by electron microscopy. No single-strand breaks are found within the junction, indicating that the structure results from a reciprocal exchange of strands. These structures have properties consistent with being reaction intermediates. Double-strand cleavage products and "Y structures" are also detected and appear to be by-products of the reaction. The Y structures are three-armed branched molecules with a covalently closed junction located at the FLP recombination target site. Models are discussed, suggesting that both of these novel structures are made by aberrant cleavages during formation and resolution of the Holliday intermediate.     

Sequence of the loxP site determines the order of strand exchange by the Cre recombinase

Conservative site-specific recombinases of the integrase family carry out recombination via a Holliday intermediate. The Cre recombinase, a member of the integrase family, was previously shown to initiate recombination by cleaving and exchanging preferentially on the bottom strand of its loxP target sequence. We have confirmed this strand bias for an intermolecular recombination reaction that used wild-type loxP sites and Cre protein. We have examined the sequence determinants for this strand preference by selectively mutating the two asymmetric scissile base-pairs in the lox site (those immediately adjacent to the sites of cleavage by Cre). We found that the initial strand exchange occurs preferentially next to the scissile G residue. Resolution of the Holliday intermediate thus formed takes place preferentially next to the scissile A residue. Lys86, which contacts the scissile nucleotides in the Cre-lox crystal structures, was important for establishing the strand preference in the resolution of the loxP-Holliday intermediate, but not for the initiation of recombination between loxP sites.     

A biotin interference assay highlights two different asymmetric interaction profiles for lambda integrase arm-type binding sites in integrative versus excisive recombination

The site-specific recombinase integrase encoded by bacteriophage lambda promotes integration and excision of the viral chromosome into and out of its Escherichia coli host chromosome through a Holliday junction recombination intermediate. This intermediate contains an integrase tetramer bound via its catalytic carboxyl-terminal domains to the four "core-type" sites of the Holliday junction DNA and via its amino-terminal domains to distal "arm-type" sites. The two classes of integrase binding sites are brought into close proximity by an ensemble of accessory proteins that bind and bend the intervening DNA. We have used a biotin interference assay that probes the requirement for major groove protein binding at specified DNA loci in conjunction with DNA protection, gel mobility shift, and genetic experiments to test several predictions of the models derived from the x-ray crystal structures of minimized and symmetrized surrogates of recombination intermediates lacking the accessory proteins and their cognate DNA targets. Our data do not support the predictions of "non-canonical" DNA targets for the N-domain of integrase, and they indicate that the complexes used for x-ray crystallography are more appropriate for modeling excisive rather than integrative recombination intermediates. We suggest that the difference in the asymmetric interaction profiles of the N-domains and arm-type sites in integrative versus excisive recombinogenic complexes reflects the regulation of recombination, whereas the asymmetry of these patterns within each reaction contributes to directionality.     

DNA arms do the legwork to ensure the directionality of lambda site-specific recombination

The integrase protein of bacteriophage lambda (Int) catalyzes site-specific recombination between lambda phage and Escherichia coli genomes. Int is a tyrosine recombinase that binds to DNA core sites via a C-terminal catalytic domain and to a collection of arm DNA sites, distant from the site of recombination, via its N-terminal domain. The arm sites, in conjunction with accessory DNA-bending proteins, provide a means of regulating the efficiency and directionality of Int-catalyzed recombination. Recent crystal structures of lambda Int tetramers bound to synaptic and Holliday junction intermediates, together with new biochemical data, suggest a mechanism for the allosteric control of the recombination reaction through arm DNA binding interactions.     

Site-specific recombination at dif by Haemophilus influenzae XerC

Xer site-specific recombination at the Escherichia coli chromosomal site dif converts chromosomal dimers to monomers, thereby allowing chromosome segregation during cell division. dif is located in the replication terminus region and binds the E. coli site-specific recombinases EcoXerC and EcoXerD. The Haemophilus influenzae Xer homologues, HinXerC and HinXerD, bind E. coli dif and exchange strands of dif Holliday junctions in vitro. Supercoiled dif sites are not recombined by EcoXerC and EcoXerD in vitro, possibly as a consequence of a regulatory process, which ensures that in vivo recombination at dif is confined to cells that can initiate cell division and contain dimeric chromosomes. In contrast, the combined action of HinXerC and EcoXerD supports in vitro recombination between supercoiled dif sites, thereby overcoming the barrier to dif recombination exhibited by EcoXerC and EcoXerD. The recombination products are catenated and knotted molecules, consistent with recombination occurring with synaptic complexes that have entrapped variable numbers of negative supercoils. Use of catalytically inactive recombinases provides support for a recombination pathway in which HinXerC-mediated strand exchange between directly repeated duplex dif sites generates a Holliday junction intermediate that is resolved by EcoXerD to catenated products. These can undergo a second recombination reaction to generate odd-noded knots.     

The isomeric preference of Holliday junctions influences resolution bias by lambda integrase.

Lambda site-specific recombination proceeds by a pair of sequential strand exchanges that first generate and then resolve a Holliday junction intermediate. A family of synthetic Holliday junctions with the branch point constrained to the center of the 7 bp overlap region was used to show that resolution of the top strands and resolution of the bottom strands are symmetrical but stereochemically distinct processes. Lambda integrase is sensitive to isomeric structure, preferentially resolving the pair of strands that are crossed in the protein-free Holliday junction. At the branch point of stacked immobile Holliday junctions, the number of purines is preferentially maximized in the crossed (versus continuous) strands if there is an inequality of purines between strands of opposite polarity. This stacking preference was used to anticipate the resolution bias of freely mobile junctions and thereby to reinforce the conclusions with monomobile junctions. The results provide a strong indication that in the complete recombination reaction a restacking of helices occurs between the top and bottom strand exchanges.     

Action of site-specific recombinases XerC and XerD on tethered Holliday junctions.

In Xer site-specific recombination, two related recombinases, XerC and XerD, mediate the formation of recombinant products using Holliday junction-containing DNA molecules as reaction intermediates. Each recombinase catalyses the exchange of one pair of specific strands. By using synthetic Holliday junction-containing recombination substrates in which two of the four arms are tethered in an antiparallel configuration by a nine thymine oligonucleotide, we show that XerD catalyses efficient strand exchange only when its substrate strands are 'crossed'. XerC also catalyses very efficient strand exchange when its substrate strands are 'crossed', though it also appears to be able to mediate strand exchange when its substrate strands are 'continuous'. By using chemical probes of Holliday junction structure in the presence and absence of bound recombinases, we show that recombinase binding induces unstacking of the bases in the centre of the recombination site, indicating that the junction branch point is positioned there and is distorted as a consequence of recombinase binding.     

Xer-mediated site-specific recombination at cer generates Holliday junctions in vivo.

Normal segregation of the Escherichia coli chromosome and stable inheritance of multicopy plasmids such as ColE1 requires the Xer site-specific recombination system. Two putative lambda integrase family recombinases, XerC and XerD, participate in the recombination reactions. We have constructed an E. coli strain in which the expression of xerC can be tightly regulated, thereby allowing the analysis of controlled recombination reactions in vivo. Xer-mediated recombination in this strain generates Holliday junction-containing DNA molecules in which a specific pair of strands has been exchanged in addition to complete recombinant products. This suggests that Xer site-specific recombination utilizes a strand exchange mechanism similar or identical to that of other members of the lambda integrase family of recombination systems. The controlled in vivo recombination reaction at cer requires recombinase and two accessory proteins, ArgR and PepA. Generation of Holliday junctions and recombinant products is equally efficient in RuvC- and RuvC+ cells, and in cells containing a multicopy RuvC+ plasmid. Controlled XerC expression is also used to analyse the efficiency of recombination between variant cer sites containing sequence alterations and heterologies within their central regions.     

Holliday junction resolution in human cells: two junction endonucleases with distinct substrate specificities

Enzymatic activities that cleave Holliday junctions are required for the resolution of recombination intermediates and for the restart of stalled replication forks. Here we show that human cell-free extracts possess two distinct endonucleases that can cleave Holliday junctions. The first cleaves Holliday junctions in a structure- and sequence-specific manner, and associates with an ATP-dependent branch migration activity. Together, these activities promote branch migration/resolution reactions similar to those catalysed by the Escherichia coli RuvABC resolvasome. Like RuvC-mediated resolution, the products can be religated. The second, containing Mus81 protein, cuts Holliday junctions but the products are mostly non-ligatable. Each nuclease has a defined substrate specificity: the branch migration-associated resolvase is highly specific for Holliday junctions, whereas the Mus81-associated endonuclease is one order of magnitude more active upon replication fork and 3'-flap structures. Thus, both nucleases are capable of cutting Holliday junctions formed during recombination or through the regression of stalled replication forks. However, the Mus81-associated endonuclease may play a more direct role in replication fork collapse by catalysing the cleavage of stalled fork structures.     

Recombinant DNA formation in a cell-free system from Xenopus laevis eggs

A cell-free system is described which formed very high levels of recombinant DNA structures in 4 hr at 26°C. It consisted of a single fraction of a high speed supernatant prepared from an extract of unfertilized eggs of the frog Xenopus laevis. This fraction eluted at 0.16?0.18 M Tris homogenization buffer from a DEAE-cellulose column. When two partially homologous supercoiled DNA molecules of different contour lengths were incubated simultaneously in this system, high levels of heterologous figure eight DNA structures were formed and observed by electron microscopy. Subsequent cleavage of the newly formed figure eight structures with Bam HI and Eco RI restriction endonucleases gave rise to “α structures” and “χ structures.” The observed figure eight structures presumably represent the recombination intermediate predicted by the Holliday model for genetic recombination.     

Single Holliday junctions are intermediates of meiotic recombination

Crossing-over between homologous chromosomes facilitates their accurate segregation at the first division of meiosis. Current models for crossing-over invoke an intermediate in which homologs are connected by two crossed-strand structures called Holliday junctions. Such double Holliday junctions are a prominent intermediate in Saccharomyces cerevisiae meiosis, where they form preferentially between homologs rather than between sister chromatids. In sharp contrast, we find that single Holliday junctions are the predominant intermediate in Schizosaccharomyces pombe meiosis. Furthermore, these single Holliday junctions arise preferentially between sister chromatids rather than between homologs. We show that Mus81 is required for Holliday junction resolution, providing further in vivo evidence that the structure-specific endonuclease Mus81-Eme1 is a Holliday junction resolvase. To reconcile these observations, we present a unifying recombination model applicable for both meiosis and mitosis in which single Holliday junctions arise from single- or double-strand breaks, lesions postulated by previous models to initiate recombination.     

Sequential strand exchange by XerC and XerD during site-specific recombination at dif

Successful segregation of circular chromosomes in Escherichia coli requires that dimeric replicons, produced by homologous recombination, are converted to monomers prior to cell division. The Xer site-specific recombination system uses two related tyrosine recombinases, XerC and XerD, to catalyze resolution of circular dimers at the chromosomal site, dif. A 33-base pair DNA fragment containing the 28-base pair minimal dif site is sufficient for the recombinases to mediate both inter- and intramolecular site-specific recombination in vivo. We show that Xer-mediated intermolecular recombination in vitro between nicked linear dif "suicide" substrates and supercoiled plasmid DNA containing dif is initiated by XerC. Furthermore, on the appropriate substrate, the nicked Holliday junction intermediate formed by XerC is converted to a linear product by a subsequent single XerD-mediated strand exchange. We also demonstrate that a XerC homologue from Pseudomonas aeruginosa stimulates strand cleavage by XerD on a nicked linear substrate and promotes initiation of strand exchange by XerD in an intermolecular reaction between linear and supercoiled DNA, thereby reversing the normal order of strand exchanges.     

Enzymatic formation of biparental figure-eight molecules from plasmid DNA and their resolution in E. coli

A key intermediate in general genetic recombination is a structure in which two double-stranded DNA molecules are covalently linked by a single-strand crossover characteristic of a Holliday junction. When the DNA molecules are circular, the recombinant structures take the form of a figure eight. We have used purified E. coli enzymes to construct biparental figure-eight DNA molecules in vitro from the DNA of two partially homologous plasmids. When purified figure-eight structures are transfected into recA- E. coli cells, they are resolved to produce monomeric or dimeric plasmid progeny, apparently by the cutting and joining of the Holliday crossover. The maturation of figure-eight molecules in bacteria is characterized by the formation and recovery of both parental and recombinant types, cross-over at a frequency of up to 50% and the capability for mismatch repair at regions of hybrid DNA. In these three regards, the products of figure-eight maturation resemble recombinant chromosomes formed at meiosis. These observations show that biparental figure eights behave as recombination intermediates that can be resolved into mature recombinants without need for a functional recA+ gene product.     

Reversible inhibitors of lambda integrase-mediated recombination efficiently trap Holliday junction intermediates and form the basis of a novel assay for junction resolution

The bacteriophage lambda integrase catalyzes four site-specific recombination pathways with distinct protein and DNA requirements and nucleoprotein intermediates. Some of these intermediates are very transient and difficult to obtain in significant amounts, due to the high efficiency and processivity of integrase, the lack of requirements for external energy factors or metal ions, and the highly reversible nature of each of the intermediates. We have previously used mixture-based combinatorial libraries to identify hexapeptides that trap 40-60% of recombination substrates at the Holliday junction stage of the reaction. These inhibitors discriminate between the four pathways, blocking one of them (bent-L recombination) more severely than the others and blocking the excision pathway least. We presume that these differences reflect specific conformational differences of the nucleoprotein intermediates in each pathway. We have now identified new inhibitors of the excision pathway. One of these, WRWYCR, is over 50-fold more potent at inhibiting excision than the previously identified peptides. This peptide stably traps Holliday junction complexes in all recombination pathways mediated by integrase as well as Cre. This finding and other data presented indicate that the peptide's target is a common feature shared by the Holliday junction complexes assembled by tyrosine recombinases. We have taken advantage of reversible inhibition by the active peptides to develop a new assay for Holliday junction resolution. This assay is particularly useful for determining junction resolution rates in cases where complexes directly assembled on junction substrates undergo little or no catalysis.     

Dissecting the resolution reaction of lambda integrase using suicide Holliday junction substrates.

A reciprocal strand exchange between two DNA helices generates the crossed-strand intermediate, or Holliday junction, which is common to many pathways of homologous and site-specific recombination. The Int family of recombinases are unique in their ability to both make and resolve Holliday junctions. Previous experiments utilizing 'synthetic' att site Holliday junctions to study the mechanisms associated with the cleavage, transfer and ligation of DNA strands have been confined to studying reciprocal strand exchanges (a pair of temporally overlapping strand cleavages). To circumvent this limitation, we have designed synthetic suicide Holliday junctions that make it possible to monitor individual DNA strand cleavage events. These substrates contain a pre-existing nick in the vicinity of the Int binding site; when Int introduces a second nick into these substrates, the 5'OH nucleophile required for ligation (in either the forward or reverse reaction) is lost by diffusion, thus trapping the covalent protein-DNA intermediate. The results indicate that resolution (involving two partner Ints) is stimulated by additional 'cross-core' Ints as a result of enhanced cleavage rates, and not as a result of enhanced co-ordination of cleavage. Several models for the role of the 'cross-core' Ints during resolution are discussed, as well as the usefulness of these substrates for studying additional aspects of the Holliday junction resolution reaction.     

V(D)J recombination and the transgenic brain blues.

The existence of somatic, site-specific recombination in the central nervous system (CNS) has long been hypothesized but has been difficult to investigate experimentally. The finding that RAG-1, which is thought to encode a component of the site-specific recombination machinery of the immune system, is transcribed in the central nervous system (J.J.M. Chun et al., 1991, Cell 64:189-200), has renewed interest in this issue. Two groups (M. Kawaichi et al., 1991, J Biol Chem 266:18,376-18,394; M. Matsuoka et al., 1991, Science 254:81-86) have now reported the results of transgenic mouse experiments designed to determine whether cells of the CNS can perform a site-specific recombination reaction similar to that of lymphocytes. Despite extensive similarities in the design of the two experiments, they yielded discordant results and contradictory conclusions. An analysis of the two studies suggests some explanations for the discrepancies and leads us to two conclusions: first, that the CNS does not carry out the same somatic, site-specific recombination reaction as is found in the immune system and, second, that the question of whether other site-specific recombination processes occur in the brain remains open and largely unaddressed.     

Mutations at residues 282, 286, and 293 of phage lambda integrase exert pathway-specific effects on synapsis and catalysis in recombination

Bacteriophage lambda integrase (Int) catalyzes site-specific recombination between pairs of attachment (att) sites. The att sites contain weak Int-binding sites called core-type sites that are separated by a 7-bp overlap region, where cleavage and strand exchange occur. We have characterized a number of mutant Int proteins with substitutions at positions S282 (S282A, S282F, and S282T), S286 (S286A, S286L, and S286T), and R293 (R293E, R293K, and R293Q). We investigated the core- and arm-binding properties and cooperativity of the mutant proteins, their ability to catalyze cleavage, and their ability to form and resolve Holliday junctions. Our kinetic analyses have identified synapsis as the rate-limiting step in excisive recombination. The IntS282 and IntS286 mutants show defects in synapsis in the bent-L and excisive pathways, respectively, while the IntR293 mutants exhibit synapsis defects in both the excision and bent-L pathways. The results of our study support earlier findings that the catalytic domain also serves a role in binding to core-type sites, that the core contacts made by this domain are important for both synapsis and catalysis, and that Int contacts core-type sites differently among the four recombination pathways. We speculate that these residues are important for the proper positioning of the catalytic residues involved in the recombination reaction and that their positions differ in the distinct nucleoprotein architectures formed during each pathway. Finally, we found that not all catalytic events in excision follow synapsis: the attL site probably undergoes several rounds of cleavage and ligation before it synapses and exchanges DNA with attR.     

DNA Footprinting with the Hydroxyl Radical

The Fenton reaction of iron(II) EDTA with hydrgen peroxide, performed in the presence of ascorbateion. has proven to be useful as a probe of structure in DNA systems. Two aspects of this chemistry are discussed: the identity of the active DNA cleaving agent produced by this reagent, and the application of the Fenton reaction to the determination of the structure of the Holliday junction, the four-stranded DNA molecule that is a key intermediate in recombination. The cleavage pattern of the Holliday junction has pseudo-twofold symmetry, putting important constraints on possible structures.     

DNA Footprinting with the Hydroxyl Radical

The Fenton reaction of iron(II) EDTA with hydrgen peroxide, performed in the presence of ascorbateion. has proven to be useful as a probe of structure in DNA systems. Two aspects of this chemistry are discussed: the identity of the active DNA cleaving agent produced by this reagent, and the application of the Fenton reaction to the determination of the structure of the Holliday junction, the four-stranded DNA molecule that is a key intermediate in recombination. The cleavage pattern of the Holliday junction has pseudo-twofold symmetry, putting important constraints on possible structures.     

Mechanism of inhibition of site-specific recombination by the Holliday junction-trapping peptide WKHYNY: insights into phage lambda integrase-mediated strand exchange

Holliday junctions are central intermediates in site-specific recombination reactions mediated by tyrosine recombinases. Because these intermediates are extremely transient, only artificially assembled Holliday junctions have been available for study. We have recently identified hexapeptides that cause the accumulation of natural Holliday junctions of bacteriophage lambda Integrase (Int)-mediated reactions. We now show that one of these peptides acts after the first DNA cleavage event to stabilize protein-bound junctions and to prevent their resolution. The peptide acts before the step affected by site affinity (saf) mutations in the core region, in agreement with a model that the peptide stabilizes the products of strand exchange (i.e. Holliday junctions) while saf mutations reduce ligation of exchanged strands.Strand exchange events leading to Holliday junctions in phage lambda integration and excision are asymmetric, presumably because interactions between Int and some of its core-binding sites determine the order of strand cleavage. We have compared the structure of Holliday junctions in one unidirectional and in two bidirectional Int-mediated pathways and show that the strand cleavage steps are much more symmetric in the bidirectional pathways. Thus Int-DNA interactions which determine the order of top and bottom strand cleavage and exchange are unique in each recombination pathway.