Cell surface display of recombinant proteins on Staphylococcus carnosus.

A novel expression system for surface display of heterologous proteins on Staphylococcus carnosus cells has been developed. Taking advantage of the promoter and secretion signals, including a propeptide region, from the lipase gene of Staphylococcus hyicus and the cell wall-spanning and membrane-binding region of protein A from Staphylococcus aureus, efficient surface display of an 80-amino-acid peptide from a malaria blood stage antigen could be achieved. A serum albumin binding protein from streptococcal protein G was used both as a general reporter molecule and to increase the accessibility of the surface-displayed proteins. Immunoblotting, immunogold staining, and immunofluorescence on intact recombinant S. carnosus cells verified the presence of the propeptide, the malaria antigen, and the albumin-binding reporter protein on the bacterial surface. For the first time, fluorescence-activated cell sorting was used to analyze the presence of surface-displayed hybrid receptors on gram-positive bacteria.     

Engineering of a Staphylococcus carnosus surface display system by substitution or deletion of a Staphylococcus hyicus lipase propeptide

Surface display of recombinant proteins on bacteria and phages has become an important topic in bioscience. A system for the display of heterologous proteins on the surface of Staphylococcus carnosus employs the secretion signal and propeptide from a Staphylococcus hyicus lipase for translocation and since the propeptide is of considerable size (207 amino acids) and not processed in S. carnosus, we have investigated the possibility to delete or substitute the propeptide for smaller protein domains, to thereby improve the surface display system. A set of new vectors was constructed and the surface expression of model proteins was investigated by various methods, including fluorescence-activated cell sorting. The results suggest that the propeptide region indeed can be deleted when proteins which are easily secretable are displayed. In contrast, the propeptide seems to be advantageous for translocation of inefficiently secreted proteins. Moreover, our study also presents a rational strategy for how to monitor the engineering efforts for the optimization of a surface display system.     

Use of the pre-pro part of Staphylococcus hyicus lipase as a carrier for secretion of Escherichia coli outer membrane protein A (OmpA) prevents proteolytic degradation of OmpA by cell-associated protease(s) in two different gram-positive bacteria.

Heterologous protein secretion was studied in the gram-positive bacteria Bacillus subtilis and Staphylococcus carnosus by using the Escherichia coli outer membrane protein OmpA as a model protein. The OmpA protein was found to be translocated across the plasma membrane of both microorganisms. However, the majority of the translocated OmpA was similarly degraded in B. subtilis and S. carnosus despite the fact that the latter organism does not secrete soluble exoproteases into the culture medium. The finding that purified OmpA, which was added externally to the culture medium of growing S. carnosus cells, remained intact indicates that newly synthesized and exported OmpA is degraded by one or more cell-associated proteases rather than by a soluble exoprotease. Fusion of the mature part of OmpA to the pre-pro part of a lipase from Staphylococcus hyicus allowed the efficient release of the corresponding propeptide-OmpA hybrid protein into the supernatant and completely prevented the cell-associated proteolytic degradation of the mature OmpA, most likely reflecting an important function of the propeptide during secretion of its natural mature lipase moiety. The relevance of our findings for the biotechnological use of gram-positive bacteria as host organisms for the secretory production of heterologous proteins is discussed.     

Efficient secretion of Bacillus subtilis lipase A in Saccharomyces cerevisiae by translational fusion to the Pir4 cell wall protein

Both the secretion and the cell surface display of Bacillus subtilis lipase A (Lip A) in Saccharomyces cerevisiae was investigated using different domains of the cell wall protein Pir4 as translational fusion partners. LipA gene minus its leader peptide was fused inframe in two places of PIR4 to achieve cell wall targeting, or substituting most of the PIR4 sequence, after the signal peptide and the Kex2 processed subunit I of Pir4 to achieve secretion to the growth medium. Expression of the recombinant fusion proteins was investigated in a standard and a glycosylation-deficient strain of S. cerevisiae, grown in selective or rich medium. Fusion proteins intended to be retained at the cell wall were secreted to the growth medium, most likely as result of the degradation of the Pir4 moiety containing the cell wall retention domain, giving low levels of lipase activity. However, the fusion intended for secretion was efficiently secreted in a percentage of close to 90% and remained stable even in rich medium at high cell density cultures, yielding values of over 400 IU of lipase activity per milliliter of cell supernatant. This is, to our knowledge, the first report of the efficient production, as a secreted protein, of lipase A of B. subtilis in baker's yeast.     

Staphylococcal surface display of immunoglobulin A (IgA)- and IgE-specific in vitro-selected binding proteins (affibodies) based on Staphylococcus aureus protein A.

An expression system designed for cell surface display of hybrid proteins on Staphylococcus carnosus has been evaluated for the display of Staphylococcus aureus protein A (SpA) domains, normally binding to immunoglobulin G (IgG) Fc but here engineered by combinatorial protein chemistry to yield SpA domains, denoted affibodies, with new binding specificities. Such affibodies, with human IgA or IgE binding activity, have previously been selected from a phage library, based on an SpA domain. In this study, these affibodies have been genetically introduced in monomeric or dimeric forms into chimeric proteins expressed on the surface of S. carnosus by using translocation signals from a Staphylococcus hyicus lipase construct together with surface-anchoring regions of SpA. The recombinant surface proteins, containing the IgA- or IgE-specific affibodies, were demonstrated to be expressed as full-length proteins, localized and properly exposed at the cell surface of S. carnosus. Furthermore, these chimeric receptors were found to be functional, since recombinant S. carnosus cells were shown to have gained IgA and IgE binding capacity, respectively. In addition, a positive effect in terms of IgA and IgE reactivity was observed when dimeric versions of the affibodies were present. Potential applications for recombinant bacteria with redirected binding specificity in their surface proteins are discussed.     

Evidence for importance of the Staphylococcus hyicus lipase pro-peptide in lipase secretion, stability and activity

Abstract To investigate the function of the pro-peptide (PP) region of the Staphylococcus hyicus exolipase, restriction sites were created in the lipase gene to facilitate the construction of deletions in this region. Lipase gene expression was carried out in Staphylococcus carnosus . In the presence of the entire PP region, the 86-kDa pro-lipase was efficiently exported, had high lipolytic activity, and hardly any degradation products were seen in Western blot analysis. In addition to the 86-kDa pro-lipase, the membrane fraction contained a 106-kDa immunoreactive form. If the PP was completely or partially deleted, signal peptide processing, lipase secretion, lipase activity and/or lipase stability were impaired. The results obtained with lipase PP deletion mutants indicate that the PP region may have two functional domains. The N-terminal region of the lipase PP appears to be more important for lipase activity and the C-terminal portion for lipase secretion and proteolytic stability. In the presence of only the C-terminal part of the PP lipase, secretion was hardly affected. However, the activity of the extracellular lipase was markedly reduced. If only a small portion of the C-terminal part of the PP was present, lipase secretion was again markedly reduced and no lipase activity was detectable. In the presence of the N-terminal half of the PP region, lipase secretion was affected to a lesser extent. However, the resulting 60-kDa form, which showed comparably good specific lipase activity, suffered severe proteolytic degradation.     

Expression of functional recombinant human growth hormone in transgenic soybean seeds

We produced human growth hormone (hGH), a protein that stimulates growth and cell reproduction, in genetically engineered soybean [Glycine max (L.) Merrill] seeds. Utilising the alpha prime (α') subunit of β-conglycinin tissue-specific promoter from soybean and the α-Coixin signal peptide from Coix lacryma-jobi, we obtained transgenic soybean lines that expressed the mature form of hGH in their seeds. Expression levels of bioactive hGH up to 2.9% of the total soluble seed protein content (corresponding to approximately 9?g?kg(-1)) were measured in mature dry soybean seeds. The results of ultrastructural immunocytochemistry assays indicated that the recombinant hGH in seed cotyledonary cells was efficiently directed to protein storage vacuoles. Specific bioassays demonstrated that the hGH expressed in the soybean seeds was fully active. The recombinant hGH protein sequence was confirmed by mass spectrometry characterisation. These results demonstrate that the utilisation of tissue-specific regulatory sequences is an attractive and viable option for achieving high-yield production of recombinant proteins in stable transgenic soybean seeds.     

Human antibody response during sepsis against targets expressed by methicillin resistant Staphylococcus aureus

The identification of target structures is a prerequisite for the development of new treatment options, like antibody based therapy, against methicillin resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA). In this study we identified immunodominant structures which were expressed in vivo during sepsis caused by MRSA. Using human sera we compared the immune response of humans with MRSA sepsis with the immune response of normal individuals and asymptomatically colonized individuals. We identified and characterized four staphylococcal specific antigenic structures. One target is a staphylococcal protein of 29 kDa that exhibited 29% identity to secreted protein SceA precursor of Staphylococcus carnosus. The putative function of this protein, which was designated IsaA (immunodominant staphylococcal antigen), is unknown. The second target is an immunodominant protein of 17 kDa that showed no homology to any currently known protein. This immunodominant protein was designated IsaB. The third and fourth antigens are both immunodominant proteins of 10 kDa. One of these proteins showed 100% identity to major cold shock protein CspA of S. aureus and the other protein was identified as the phosphocarrier protein Hpr of S. aureus. The identified immunodominant proteins may serve as potential targets for the development of antibody based therapy against MRSA.     

The propeptide of the transforming growth factor-beta superfamily member, macrophage inhibitory cytokine-1 (MIC-1), is a multifunctional domain that can facilitate protein folding and secretion

Macrophage inhibitory cytokine-1 (MIC-1) is a divergent member of the transforming growth factor-beta (TGF-beta) superfamily. While it is synthesized in a pre-pro form, it is unique among superfamily members because it does not require its propeptide for correct folding or secretion of the mature peptide. To investigate factors that enable these propeptide independent events to occur, we constructed MIC-1/TGF-beta1 chimeras, both with and without a propeptide. All chimeras without a propeptide secreted less efficiently compared with the corresponding constructs with propeptide. Folding and secretion were most affected after replacement of the predicted major alpha-helix in the mature protein, residues 56-68. Exchanging the human propeptide in this chimera with either the murine MIC-1 or TGF-beta1 propeptide resulted in secretion of the unprocessed, monomeric chimera, suggesting a specific interaction between the human MIC-1 propeptide and mature peptide. Propeptide deletion mutants enabled identification of a region between residues 56 and 78, which is important for the interaction between the propeptide and the mature peptide. Cotransfection experiments demonstrated that the propeptide must be in cis with the mature peptide for this phenomenon to occur. These results suggest a model for TGF-beta superfamily protein folding.     

Signal peptide and propeptide optimization for heterologous protein secretion in Lactococcus lactis

Lactic acid bacteria are food-grade microorganisms that are potentially good candidates for production of heterologous proteins of therapeutical or technological interest. We developed a model for heterologous protein secretion in Lactococcus lactis using the staphylococcal nuclease (Nuc). The effects on protein secretion of alterations in either (i) signal peptide or (ii) propeptide sequences were examined. (i) Replacement of the native Nuc signal peptide (SP(Nuc)) by that of L. lactis protein Usp45 (SP(Usp)) resulted in greatly improved secretion efficiency (SE). Pulse-chase experiments showed that Nuc secretion kinetics was better when directed by SP(Usp) than when directed by SP(Nuc). This SP(Usp) effect on Nuc secretion is not due to a better antifolding activity, since SP(Usp):Nuc precursor proteins display enzymatic activity in vitro, while SP(Nuc):Nuc precursor proteins do not. (ii) Deletion of the native Nuc propeptide dramatically reduces Nuc SE, regardless of which SP is used. We previously reported that a synthetic propeptide, LEISSTCDA, could efficiently replace the native Nuc propeptide to promote heterologous protein secretion in L. lactis (Y. Le Loir, A. Gruss, S. D. Ehrlich, and P. Langella, J. Bacteriol. 180:1895-1903, 1998). To determine whether the LEISSTCDA effect is due to its acidic residues, specific substitutions were introduced, resulting in neutral or basic propeptides. Effects of these two new propeptides and of a different acidic synthetic propeptide were tested. Acidic and neutral propeptides were equally effective in enhancing Nuc SE and also increased Nuc yields. In contrast, the basic propeptide strongly reduced both SE and the quantity of secreted Nuc. We have shown that the combination of the native SP(Usp) and a neutral or acidic synthetic propeptide leads to a significant improvement in SE and in the quantity of synthesized Nuc. These observations will be valuable in the production of heterologous proteins in L. lactis.     

The Secretion of an Intrinsically Disordered Protein with Different Secretion Signals in Bacillus subtilis

In this study, a naturally unsecretory intrinsically disordered domain of nucleoskeletal-like protein (Nsp) was attempted to be secreted with different types of secretion signals in Bacillus subtilis. The results showed that Nsp can be secreted efficiently by all selected Sec-type signal peptides. Nsp was successfully exported when fused to Tat-type signal peptides but less efficient than Sec-type. The fusion protein with the non-classical extracellular proteins can be detected in the cell and extracellular milieu. This study further demonstrated that the mature protein plays an important role in protein secretion. Moreover, these results indicated that Nsp could be a useful tool to understand the individual roles of mature proteins and signal peptide in protein secretion, to evaluate the effect of conformation of mature proteins on their export pathway when coupled with Tat-type signal peptide, and to seek the signal of non-classical secretory proteins.     

The YSIRK-G/S motif of staphylococcal protein A and its role in efficiency of signal peptide processing

Many surface proteins of pathogenic gram-positive bacteria are linked to the cell wall envelope by a mechanism requiring a C-terminal sorting signal with an LPXTG motif. Surface proteins of Streptococcus pneumoniae harbor another motif, YSIRK-G/S, which is positioned within signal peptides. The signal peptides of some, but not all, of the 20 surface proteins of Staphylococcus aureus carry a YSIRK-G/S motif, whereas those of surface proteins of Listeria monocytogenes and Bacillus anthracis do not. To determine whether the YSIRK-G/S motif is required for the secretion or cell wall anchoring of surface proteins, we analyzed variants of staphylococcal protein A, an immunoglobulin binding protein with an LPXTG sorting signal. Deletion of the YSIR sequence or replacement of G or S significantly reduced the rate of signal peptide processing of protein A precursors. In contrast, cell wall anchoring or the functional display of protein A was not affected. The fusion of cell wall sorting signals to reporter proteins bearing N-terminal signal peptides with or without the YSIRK-G/S motif resulted in hybrid proteins that were anchored in a manner similar to that of wild-type protein A. The requirement of the YSIRK-G/S motif for efficient secretion implies the existence of a specialized mode of substrate recognition by the secretion pathway of gram-positive cocci. It seems, however, that this mechanism is not essential for surface protein anchoring to the cell wall envelope.     

Fluorescence-activated cell sorting of specific affibody-displaying staphylococci

Efficient enrichment of staphylococcal cells displaying specific heterologous affinity ligands on their cell surfaces was demonstrated by using fluorescence-activated cell sorting. Using bacterial surface display of peptide or protein libraries for the purpose of combinatorial protein engineering has previously been investigated by using gram-negative bacteria. Here, the potential for using a gram-positive bacterium was evaluated by employing the well-established surface expression system for Staphylococcus carnosus. Staphylococcus aureus protein A domains with binding specificity to immunoglobulin G or engineered specificity for the G protein of human respiratory syncytial virus were expressed as surface display on S. carnosus cells. The surface accessibility and retained binding specificity of expressed proteins were demonstrated in whole-cell enzyme and flow cytometry assays. Also, affibody-expressing target cells could be sorted essentially quantitatively from a moderate excess of background cells in a single step by using a high-stringency sorting mode. Furthermore, in a simulated library selection experiment, a more-than-25,000-fold enrichment of target cells could be achieved through only two rounds of cell sorting and regrowth. The results obtained indicate that staphylococcal surface display of affibody libraries combined with fluoresence-activated cell sorting might indeed constitute an attractive alternative to existing technology platforms for affinity-based selections.     

Signal Peptide and Propeptide Optimization for Heterologous Protein Secretion in Lactococcus lactis

Lactic acid bacteria are food-grade microorganisms that are potentially good candidates for production of heterologous proteins of therapeutical or technological interest. We developed a model for heterologous protein secretion in Lactococcus lactis using the staphylococcal nuclease (Nuc). The effects on protein secretion of alterations in either (i) signal peptide or (ii) propeptide sequences were examined. (i) Replacement of the native Nuc signal peptide (SP_Nuc) by that of L. lactis protein Usp45 (SP_Usp) resulted in greatly improved secretion efficiency (SE). Pulse-chase experiments showed that Nuc secretion kinetics was better when directed by SP_Usp than when directed by SP_Nuc. This SP_Usp effect on Nuc secretion is not due to a better antifolding activity, since SP_Usp:Nuc precursor proteins display enzymatic activity in vitro, while SP_Nuc:Nuc precursor proteins do not. (ii) Deletion of the native Nuc propeptide dramatically reduces Nuc SE, regardless of which SP is used. We previously reported that a synthetic propeptide, LEISSTCDA, could efficiently replace the native Nuc propeptide to promote heterologous protein secretion in L. lactis (Y. Le Loir, A. Gruss, S. D. Ehrlich, and P. Langella, J. Bacteriol. 180:1895–1903, 1998). To determine whether the LEISSTCDA effect is due to its acidic residues, specific substitutions were introduced, resulting in neutral or basic propeptides. Effects of these two new propeptides and of a different acidic synthetic propeptide were tested. Acidic and neutral propeptides were equally effective in enhancing Nuc SE and also increased Nuc yields. In contrast, the basic propeptide strongly reduced both SE and the quantity of secreted Nuc. We have shown that the combination of the native SP_Usp and a neutral or acidic synthetic propeptide leads to a significant improvement in SE and in the quantity of synthesized Nuc. These observations will be valuable in the production of heterologous proteins in L. lactis.     

Vector engineering to improve a staphylococcal surface display system

A previously developed expression system for surface display of heterologous proteins on the surface of Staphylococcus carnosus employs the secretion signals from a Staphylococcus hyicus lipase and the cell wall anchoring part of Staphylococcus aureus protein A (SpA) to achieve surface display of expressed recombinant proteins. The system has been successfully used in various applications but the vector has not been considered genetically stable enough to allow protein library display applications, which would be of obvious interest. A new set of vectors, differing in size and devoid of a phage f1 origin of replication, were constructed and evaluated in terms of bacterial growth characteristics and vector stability. Furthermore, surface expression of a model surface protein was monitored by an enzymatic whole-cell assay and flow cytometry. The engineered expression vectors demonstrated dramatically improved stability and growth properties and two of the novel vectors demonstrated retained high surface density of the displayed model protein. The flow cytometry was found to be a powerful tool for observing the surface density of displayed heterologous proteins, and would thus be a rational strategy for monitoring the optimisation of any surface display system. The implications of these improved display vectors for future protein library applications are discussed.     

General expression vectors for Staphylococcus carnosus enabled efficient production of the outer membrane protein A of Klebsiella pneumoniae

General expression vectors, designed for intracellular expression or secretion of recombinant proteins in the non-pathogenic Staphylococcus carnosus, were constructed. Both vector systems encode two different affinity tags, an upstream albumin binding protein and a downstream hexahistidyl peptide, and are furnished with cleavage sites for two site-specific proteases for optional affinity tag removal. To evaluate the novel vectors, the gene encoding the outer membrane protein A (OmpA) of Klebsiella pneumoniae was introduced into the vectors. Efficient production was demonstrated in both systems, although, as expected for OmpA fusions, somewhat better intracellularly, and the fusion proteins could be recovered as full-length products by affinity chromatography.     

The prepro-peptide of Mucor rennin directs the secretion of human growth hormone by Saccharomyces cerevisiae

An aspartic proteinase, Mucor pusillus rennin (MPR), of filamentous fungus Mucor pusillus, is efficiently secreted from a transformant of Saccharomyces cerevisiae containing the intact MPR gene. To test the usefulness of the MPR leader peptide in secretion of heterologous proteins from yeast cells, several plasmids encoding the fusion proteins composed of different parts of the NH2-terminal region of prepro-MPR and human growth hormone (hGH) were constructed. The parts of the leader peptide upstream of hGH were the whole prepro-peptide following the NH2-terminal region of mature MPR in JGH1, the intact pre-sequence and a part of the pro-sequence in JGH2, and the putative signal sequences of the NH2-terminal 18 and 22 amino acids in JGH3 and JGH7, respectively. When the hGH genes fused to these leader sequences were expressed in yeast cells under the control of the yeast GAL7 promoter, proteins of various sizes immunoreactive with the anti-hGH antibody were secreted into the medium. Among the plasmids mentioned above, JGH2 directed the greatest secretion of the protein of 23 kilodaltons in size, which contained the expected NH2-terminal amino acid sequence of an additional eight amino acids derived from the pro-peptide of MPR. The addition of the GAL10 terminator downstream of the hGH gene in JGH2 resulted in a greater than three- to fivefold increase in the secretion, whereas the insertion of the GAL4 gene, which is a positive regulator for the GAL system, had no significant effect. The improved yield of the total protein of hGH secreted into the medium reached approximately 10 mg/liter.     

The prepro-peptide of Mucor rennin directs the secretion of human growth hormone by Saccharomyces cerevisiae.

An aspartic proteinase, Mucor pusillus rennin (MPR), of filamentous fungus Mucor pusillus, is efficiently secreted from a transformant of Saccharomyces cerevisiae containing the intact MPR gene. To test the usefulness of the MPR leader peptide in secretion of heterologous proteins from yeast cells, several plasmids encoding the fusion proteins composed of different parts of the NH2-terminal region of prepro-MPR and human growth hormone (hGH) were constructed. The parts of the leader peptide upstream of hGH were the whole prepro-peptide following the NH2-terminal region of mature MPR in JGH1, the intact pre-sequence and a part of the pro-sequence in JGH2, and the putative signal sequences of the NH2-terminal 18 and 22 amino acids in JGH3 and JGH7, respectively. When the hGH genes fused to these leader sequences were expressed in yeast cells under the control of the yeast GAL7 promoter, proteins of various sizes immunoreactive with the anti-hGH antibody were secreted into the medium. Among the plasmids mentioned above, JGH2 directed the greatest secretion of the protein of 23 kilodaltons in size, which contained the expected NH2-terminal amino acid sequence of an additional eight amino acids derived from the pro-peptide of MPR. The addition of the GAL10 terminator downstream of the hGH gene in JGH2 resulted in a greater than three- to fivefold increase in the secretion, whereas the insertion of the GAL4 gene, which is a positive regulator for the GAL system, had no significant effect. The improved yield of the total protein of hGH secreted into the medium reached approximately 10 mg/liter.     

Analysis of signals for secretion in the staphylococcal protein A gene.

Different constructs of the gene encoding staphylococcal protein A were introduced in Staphylococcus aureus and S. xylosus as well as Escherichia coli. The product of the gene without the cell wall anchoring domain was efficiently secreted in all three hosts. N-terminal sequencing of the affinity-purified mature protein revealed a common processing site after the alanine residue at position 36. In contrast, when an internal IgG-binding fragment of protein A (region B) was inserted after the protein A signal sequence, the product was poorly secreted and N-terminal sequencing revealed no processing at the normal site. This demonstrates that the structure of the polypeptide chain beyond the signal peptide cleavage site can affect cleavage. Another construct, containing the N-terminal IgG-binding part of the mature protein A (region E) followed by region B, gave correct processing and efficient secretion. Unexpectedly, the gene product, EB, was not only secreted and correctly processed, but was also excreted to the culture medium of E. coli. Secretion vectors containing the protein A signal sequence were constructed to facilitate secretion of foreign gene products. Insertion of the E. coli gene phoA, lacking its own promoter and signal sequence, led to efficient secretion of alkaline phosphatase both in E. coli and S. aureus.     

Engineering of staphylococcal surfaces for biotechnological applications

Novel surface proteins can be introduced onto bacterial cell surfaces by recombinant means. Here, we describe various applications of two such display systems for the food-grade bacteria Staphylococcus carnosus and Staphylococcus xylosus, respectively. The achievements in the use of such staphylococci as live bacterial vaccine delivery vehicles will be described. Co-display of proteins and peptides with adhesive properties to enable targeting of the bacteria, have significantly improved the vaccine delivery potential. Recently, protective immunity to respiratory syncytial virus (RSV) could be evoked in mice by intranasal immunization using such 'second generation' vaccine delivery systems. Furthermore, antibody fragments and other 'affinity proteins' with capacity to specifically bind a certain protein, e.g. Staphylococcus aureus protein A-based affibodies, have been surface-displayed on staphylococci as initial efforts to create whole-cell diagnostic devices. Surface display of metal-binding peptides, or protein domains into which metal binding properties has been engineered by combinatorial protein engineering, have been exploited to create staphylococcal bioadsorbents for potential environmental or biosensor applications. The use of these staphylococcal surface display systems as alternatives for display of large protein libraries and subsequent affinity selection of relevant binding proteins by fluorescence-activated cell sorting (FACS) will be discussed.