A molecular dynamics study of the structural stability of HIV-1 protease under physiological conditions: the role of Na+ ions in stabilizing the active site

HIV-1 protease is most active under weakly acidic conditions (pH 3.5-6.5), when the catalytic Asp25 and Asp25' residues share 1 proton. At neutral pH, this proton is lost and the stability of the structure is reduced. Here we present an investigation of the effect of pH on the dynamics of HIV-1 protease using MD simulation techniques. MD simulations of the solvated HIV-1 protease with the Asp25/25' residues monoprotonated and deprotonated have been performed. In addition we investigated the effect of the inclusion of Na(+) and Cl(-) ions to mimic physiological salt conditions. The simulations of the monoprotonated form and deprotonated form including Na(+) show very similar behavior. In both cases the protein remained stable in the compact, "self-blocked" conformation in which the active site is blocked by the tips of the flaps. In the deprotonated system a Na(+) ion binds tightly to the catalytic dyad shielding the repulsion between the COO(-) groups. Ab initio calculations also suggest the geometry of the active site with the Na(+) bound closely resembles that of the monoprotonated case. In the simulations of the deprotonated form (without Na(+) ions), a water molecule bound between the Asp25 Asp25' side-chains. This disrupted the dimerization interface and eventually led to a fully open conformation.     

Population density analysis for determining the protonation state of the catalytic dyad in BACE1-tertiary carbinamine-based inhibitor complex

BACE1 is an aspartyl protease with a very relevant role in medicinal chemistry related to Alzheimer Disease since it has demonstrated to be a promising therapeutic target for inhibition and possible control for the progress of the peptide accumulation characteristic of this pathology. The enzymatic activity of this protein is given by the aspartic dyad, Asp93 and Asp289, which can adopt several protonation states depending on the chemical nature of its inhibitors, this is, monoprotonated, diprotonated and di-deprotonated states. In the present study, the analysis of the population density, for a series of protein-inhibitor molecular dynamics simulations, was carried out to identify the most feasible protonation state adopted by the catalytic dyad in the presence of tertiary carbinamine (TC) transition state analog inhibitors. The results revealed that the monoprotonated Asp289i state, in which the Asp93 and Asp289 residue side chains are deprotonated and protonated on the inner oxygen, respectively, is the most preferred in the presence of TC family inhibitors. This result was obtained after evaluating, for all 9 possible protonation state configurations, the individual and combined population densities of a set of parameters sensitive to protonation state of the Aspartic dyad, using an X-ray experimental BACE1/TC crystallographic structure as reference. This case study demonstrates again the usefulness of the concept of population density as a quantitative tool to establish the most stable system settings, among all possible, by measuring the level of occurrence of simultaneous events obtained from a sampling over time. These results will help to clear the phenomena related to the TCs inhibitory pathway, as well as assist in the design of better TC inhibitors against Alzheimer’s protease.     

Insights into the functional role of protonation states in the HIV-1 protease-BEA369 complex: molecular dynamics simulations and free energy calculations

The molecular mechanics Poisson-Boltzmann surface area (MM-PBSA) method combined with molecular dynamics (MD) simulations were used to investigate the functional role of protonation in human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) protease complexed with the inhibitor BEA369. Our results demonstrate that protonation of two aspartic acids (Asp25/Asp25′) has a strong influence on the dynamics behavior of the complex, the binding free energy of BEA369, and inhibitor–residue interactions. Relative binding free energies calculated using the MM-PBSA method show that protonation of Asp25 results in the strongest binding of BEA369 to HIV-1 protease. Inhibitor–residue interactions computed by the theory of free energy decomposition also indicate that protonation of Asp25 has the most favorable effect on binding of BEA369. In addition, hydrogen-bond analysis based on the trajectories of the MD simulations shows that protonation of Asp25 strongly influences the water-mediated link of a conserved water molecule, Wat301. We expect that the results of this study will contribute significantly to binding calculations for BEA369, and to the design of high affinity inhibitors.     

Interpreting trends in the binding of cyclic ureas to HIV-1 protease

The design of new HIV protease inhibitors requires an improved understanding of the physical basis of inhibitor/protein binding. Here, the binding affinities of seven aliphatic cyclic ureas to HIV-1 protease are calculated using a predominant states method and an implicit solvent model based upon finite difference solutions of the Poisson-Boltzmann equation. The calculations are able to reproduce the observed U-shaped trend of binding free energy as a function of aliphatic chain length. Interestingly, the decrease in affinity for the longest chains is attributable primarily to the energy cost of partly desolvating charged aspartic and arginine groups at the mouths of the active site. Even aliphatic chains too short to contact these charged groups directly are subject to considerable desolvation penalties. We are not aware of other systems where binding affinity trends have been attributed to long-ranged electrostatic desolvation of ionized groups. A generalized Born/surface area solvation model yields a much smaller change in desolvation energy with chain length and, therefore, does not reproduce the experimental binding affinity trends. This result suggests that the generalized Born model should be used with caution for complex, partly desolvated systems like protein binding sites. We also find that changing the assumed protonation state of the active site aspartyl dyad significantly affects the computed binding affinity trends. The protonation state of the aspartyl dyad in the presence of cyclic ureas is discussed in light of the observation that the monoprotonated state reproduces the experimental results best.     

The role of hydrogen bonding in the enzymatic reaction catalyzed by HIV-1 protease

The hydrogen-bond network in various stages of the enzymatic reaction catalyzed by HIV-1 protease was studied through quantum-classical molecular dynamics simulations. The approximate valence bond method was applied to the active site atoms participating directly in the rearrangement of chemical bonds. The rest of the protein with explicit solvent was treated with a classical molecular mechanics model. Two possible mechanisms were studied, general-acid/general-base (GA/GB) with Asp 25 protonated at the inner oxygen, and a direct nucleophilic attack by Asp 25. Strong hydrogen bonds leading to spontaneous proton transfers were observed in both reaction paths. A single-well hydrogen bond was formed between the peptide nitrogen and outer oxygen of Asp 125. The proton was diffusely distributed with an average central position and transferred back and forth on a picosecond scale. In both mechanisms, this interaction helped change the peptide-bond hybridization, increased the partial charge on peptidyl carbon, and in the GA/GB mechanism, helped deprotonate the water molecule. The inner oxygens of the aspartic dyad formed a low-barrier, but asymmetric hydrogen bond; the proton was not positioned midway and made a slightly elongated covalent bond, transferring from one to the other aspartate. In the GA/GB mechanism both aspartates may help deprotonate the water molecule. We observed the breakage of the peptide bond and found that the protonation of the peptidyl amine group was essential for the peptide-bond cleavage. In studies of the direct nucleophilic mechanism, the peptide carbon of the substrate and oxygen of Asp 25 approached as close as 2.3 A.     

Determination of the protonation state of the Asp dyad: conventional molecular dynamics versus thermodynamic integration

The protonation state of the Asp dyad is important as it can reveal enzymatic mechanisms, and the information this provides can be used in the development of drugs for proteins such as memapsin 2 (BACE-1), HIV-1 protease, and rennin. Conventional molecular dynamics (MD) simulations have been successfully used to determine the preferred protonation state of the Asp dyad. In the present work, we demonstrate that the results obtained from conventional MD simulations can be greatly influenced by the particular force field applied or the values used for control parameters. In principle, free-energy changes between possible protonation states can be used to determine the protonation state. We show that protonation state prediction by the thermodynamic integration (TI) method is insensitive to force field version or to the cutoff for calculating nonbonded interactions (a control parameter). In the present study, the protonation state of the Asp dyad predicted by TI calculations was the same regardless of the force field and cutoff value applied. Contrary to the intuition that conventional MD is more efficient, our results clearly show that the TI method is actually more efficient and more reliable for determining the protonation state of the Asp dyad.     

pH‐dependent conformational dynamics of beta‐secretase 1: A molecular dynamics study

Beta‐secretase 1 (BACE‐1) is an aspartyl protease implicated in the overproduction of β‐amyloid fibrils responsible for Alzheimer disease. The process of β‐amyloid genesis is known to be pH dependent, with an activity peak between solution pH of 3.5 and 5.5. We have studied the pH‐dependent dynamics of BACE‐1 to better understand the pH dependent mechanism. We have implemented support for graphics processor unit (GPU) accelerated constant pH molecular dynamics within the AMBER molecular dynamics software package and employed this to determine the relative population of different aspartyl dyad protonation states in the pH range of greatest β‐amyloid production, followed by conventional molecular dynamics to explore the differences among the various aspartyl dyad protonation states. We observed a difference in dynamics between double‐protonated, mono‐protonated, and double‐deprotonated states over the known pH range of higher activity. These differences include Tyr 71‐aspartyl dyad proximity and active water lifetime. This work indicates that Tyr 71 stabilizes catalytic water in the aspartyl dyad active site, enabling BACE‐1 activity.     

Active site binding modes of curcumin in HIV-1 protease and integrase

Structure models for the interaction of curcumin with HIV-1 integrase (IN) and protease (PR) were investigated using computational docking. Curcumin was found to bind preferentially in similar ways to the active sites of both IN and PR. For IN, the binding site is formed by residues Asp64, His67, Thr66, Glu92, Thr93, Asp116, Ser119, Asn120, and Lys159. Docked curcumin contacts the catalytic residues adjacent to Asp116 and Asp64, and near the divalent metal (Mg2+). In the PR docking, the curcumin structure fitted well to the active site, interacting with residues Asp25, Asp29, Asp30, Gly27', Asp29', and Asp30'. The results suggest that o-hydroxyl and/or keto-enol structures are important for both IN and PR inhibitory actions. The symmetrical structure of curcumin seems to play an important role for binding to the PR protein, whereas the keto-enol and only one side of the terminal o-hydroxyl showed tight binding to the IN active site.     

Effects of protonation state of Asp181 and position of active site water molecules on the conformation of PTP1B

In protein tyrosine phosphatase 1B (PTP1B), the flexible WPD loop adopts a closed conformation (WPD_closed) in the active state of PTP1B, bringing the catalytic Asp181 close to the active site pocket, while WPD loop is in an open conformation (WPD_open) in the inactive state. Previous studies showed that Asp181 may be protonated at physiological pH, and ordered water molecules exist in the active site. In the current study, molecular dynamics simulations are employed at different Asp181 protonation states and initial positions of active site water molecules, and compared with the existing crystallographic data of PTP1B. In WPD_closed conformation, the active site is found to maintain its conformation only in the protonated state of Asp181 in both free and liganded states, while Asp181 is likely to be deprotonated in WPD_open conformation. When the active site water molecule network that is a part of the free WPD_closed crystal structure is disrupted, intermediate WPD loop conformations, similar to that in the PTPRR crystal structure, are sampled in the MD simulations. In liganded PTP1B, one active site water molecule is found to be important for facilitating the orientation of Cys215 and the phosphate ion, thus may play a role in the reaction. In conclusion, conformational stability of WPD loop, and possibly catalytic activity of PTP1B, is significantly affected by the protonation state of Asp181 and position of active site water molecules, showing that these aspects should be taken into consideration both in MD simulations and inhibitor design. © Proteins 2013. © 2012 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

Sensitive, soluble chromogenic substrates for HIV-1 proteinase

By replacement of the P1' residue in a capsid/nucleocapsid cleavage site mimic with 4-NO2-phenylalanine (Nph), an excellent chromogenic substrate, Lys-Ala-Arg-Val-Leu*Nph-Glu-Ala-Met, for HIV-1 proteinase (kappa cat = 20 s-1, Km = 22 microM) has been prepared. Substitution of the Leu residue in P1 with norleucine, Met, Phe, or Tyr had minimal effects on the kinetic parameters (kappa cat and kappa cat/Km) determined at different pH values, whereas peptides containing Ile or Val in P1 were hydrolyzed extremely slowly. The spectrophotometric assay has been used to characterize the proteinase further with respect to pH dependence, ionic strength dependence, and the effect of competitive inhibitors of various types.     

Thermodynamic linkage between the binding of protons and inhibitors to HIV-1 protease

The aspartyl dyad of free HIV-1 protease has apparent pK(a)s of approximately 3 and approximately 6, but recent NMR studies indicate that the aspartyl dyad is fixed in the doubly protonated form over a wide pH range when cyclic urea inhibitors are bound, and in the monoprotonated form when the inhibitor KNI-272 is bound. We present computations and measurements related to these changes in protonation and to the thermodynamic linkage between protonation and inhibition. The Poisson-Boltzmann model of electrostatics is used to compute the apparent pK(a)s of the aspartyl dyad in the free enzyme and in complexes with four different inhibitors. The calculations are done with two parameter sets. One assigns epsilon = 4 to the solute interior and uses a detailed model of ionization; the other uses epsilon = 20 for the solute interior and a simplified representation of ionization. For the free enzyme, both parameter sets agree well with previously measured apparent pK(a)s of approximately 3 and approximately 6. However, the calculations with an internal dielectric constant of 4 reproduce the large pKa shifts upon binding of inhibitors, but the calculations with an internal dielectric constant of 20 do not. This observation has implications for the accurate calculation of pK(a)s in complex protein environments. Because binding of a cyclic urea inhibitor shifts the pK(a)s of the aspartyl dyad, changing the pH is expected to change its apparent binding affinity. However, we find experimentally that the affinity is independent of pH from 5.5 to 7.0. Possible explanations for this discrepancy are discussed.     

Analysis of subsite preferences of HIV-1 proteinase using MA/CA junction peptides substituted at the P3-P1' positions

The residues P3, P2, P1, and P1' of a peptide corresponding to the matrix/capsid protein junction in the HIV-1 gag protein (Ser-Gln-Asn-Tyr-Pro-Ile-Val) were systematically replaced and the effect of these single amino acid substitutions on the hydrolysis of each peptide by HIV-1 proteinase was studied. Subsites S1 and S1' of the enzyme showed explicit preference for hydrophobic moieties, but beta-branched amino acids and proline are not tolerated in S1. The S2 subsite shows a preference for small polar and apolar amino acids; it may be occupied by Asn, Asp, Glu, Cys, Ala, or Val, other substitutions, especially by Gln and Ser, prevent hydrolysis of the peptides. In subsite S3 all amino acids except proline can be accommodated.     

Caught in the Act: the 1.5 A resolution crystal structures of the HIV-1 protease and the I54V mutant reveal a tetrahedral reaction intermediate

HIV-1 protease (PR) is the target for several important antiviral drugs used in AIDS therapy. The drugs bind inside the active site cavity of PR where normally the viral polyprotein substrate is bound and hydrolyzed. We report two high-resolution crystal structures of wild-type PR (PRWT) and the multi-drug-resistant variant with the I54V mutation (PRI54V) in complex with a peptide at 1.46 and 1.50 A resolution, respectively. The peptide forms a gem-diol tetrahedral reaction intermediate (TI) in the crystal structures. Distinctive interactions are observed for the TI binding in the active site cavity of PRWT and PRI54V. The mutant PRI54V/TI complex has lost water-mediated hydrogen bond interactions with the amides of Ile50 and Ile50' in the flap. Hence, the structures provide insight into the mechanism of drug resistance arising from this mutation. The structures also illustrate an intermediate state in the hydrolysis reaction. One of the gem-diol hydroxide groups in the PRWT complex forms a very short (2.3 A) hydrogen bond with the outer carboxylate oxygen of Asp25. Quantum chemical calculations based on this TI structure are consistent with protonation of the inner carboxylate oxygen of Asp25', in contrast to several theoretical studies. These TI complexes and quantum calculations are discussed in relation to the chemical mechanism of the peptide bond hydrolysis catalyzed by PR.     

Mechanism of aspartyl proteinase action. VII. Noncovalent complexes of HIV-1 aspartyl proteinase with substrate and substrate-like inhibitors

A computer model of a noncovalent complex of HIV-1 aspartyl protease with substrate-like inhibitor JG-365 was a priori constructed by using the approaches of theoretical conformational analysis and molecular mechanics. The root mean square deviation of the calculated conformation of the inhibitor from the X-ray diffraction analysis data was 0.87 A. These results enabled the a priori calculation of the structure of noncovalent complex of HIV-1 protease with a hexapeptide fragment of its native specific substrate Ser-Gln-Asn-Tyr-Pro-Ile-Val. The only possible orientation of the cleavable peptide bond in this and the nucleophilic water molecule relative to the catalytically active Asp residues of the enzyme (Asp25 and Asp125) was found that provides for the chemical transformation of the substrate to a tetrahedral intermediate. An action mechanism of enzymes of this class was proposed on the basis of the analysis of calculated distances. We showed that neither steric distortion of the cleavable bond nor the formation of unfavorable contacts in molecules of the enzymes and their substrates accompany the optimum orientation of substrate molecules at the active sites of HIV-1 aspartyl proteases and rhizopuspepsin.     

Flavones are inhibitors of HIV-1 proteinase.

Substituted gamma-chromones were found to weakly inhibit HIV-1 proteinase, an important enzyme in the replication and processing of the AIDS virus. Chromones bearing hydroxyl substituents and a phenolic group at the 2-position (flavones) were the most active compounds and structure-activity relationships for a limited series of flavone inhibitors are presented. Dixon plots are reported and a possible mechanism for flavone-induced inhibition is proposed. The results are also compared with those for some structurally related non-peptidic inhibitors of HIV-1 proteinase. Since some flavonoid compounds have already been shown to have antiviral activity against AIDS, the present observations of anti-HIV-1 proteinase activity may be particularly significant.     

Inhibition of HIV-1 proteinase by metal ions.

1. Certain metal ions have been identified as inhibitors (IC50 1-20 microM) of the aspartic proteinase of Human Immunodeficiency Virus Type 1 (HIV-PR). 2. By contrast most simple metal ions do not inhibit this enzyme. 3. Those that did inhibit have in common a high charge/size ratio or "hard" acidic nature, preferring to combine covalently with oxygen donor ligands. 4. Some evidence from independent X-ray crystal structure determinations suggests that the metalloinhibitors identified here may bind in the active site of the enzyme via coordination to the carboxylate side chains of the essential active site residues Asp 25 and 125. 5. Although the measured inhibition is only microM, very few enzyme-inhibitor interactions can be taking place and so more complex metalloinhibitors with ligands that can also bind to peptide side chains of the enzyme might be significantly more potent inhibitors of HIV-PR and of viral replication.     

Inhibition of the aspartic proteinase from HIV-2

Kinetic constants were determined for the interaction of the HIV-2 aspartic proteinase with a synthetic substrate and a number of inhibitors at several pH values. Acetyl-pepstatin was more effective towards HIV-2 proteinase than the renin inhibitor, H-261; this effect is exactly the opposite from that observed previously for the proteinase from the HIV-1 AIDS virus.     

Analysis of the structure of HIV-1 protease complexed with a hexapeptide inhibitor. Part II: Molecular dynamic studies of the active site region

Six models of the catalytic site of HIV-1 protease complexed with a reduced peptide inhibitor, MVT-101, were investigated. These studies focused on the details of protonation of the active site, its total net charge and hydrogen bonding pattern, which was consistent with both the observed coplanar configuration of the acidic groups of the catalytic aspartates (Asp-25 and Asp-125) and the observed binding mode of the inhibitor. Molecular dynamic simulations using AMBER 4.0 indicated that the active site should be neutral. The planarity of the aspartate dyad may be due to the formation of two hydrogen bonds: one between the inner O_δ1oxygen atoms of the two catalytic aspartates and another between the O_δ2atom of Asp-125 and the nitrogen atom of the reduced peptide bond of the bound inhibitor. This would require two additional protonations, either of both aspartates, or of one Asp and the amido nitrogen atom of Nle-204. Our results favor the Asp-inhibitor protonation but the other one is not excluded. Implications of these findings for the mechanism of enzymatic catalysis are discussed. Dynamic properties of the hydrogen bond network in the active site and an analysis of the interaction energy between the inhibitor and the protease are presented. © 1997 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Three-dimensional model of a substrate-bound SARS chymotrypsin-like cysteine proteinase predicted by multiple molecular dynamics simulations: catalytic efficiency regulated by substrate binding

Severe acute respiratory syndrome (SARS) is a contagious and deadly disease caused by a new coronavirus. The protein sequence of the chymotrypsin-like cysteine proteinase (CCP) responsible for SARS viral replication has been identified as a target for developing anti-SARS drugs. Here, I report the ATVRLQ(p1)A(p1')-bound CCP 3D model predicted by 420 different molecular dynamics simulations (2.0 ns for each simulation with a 1.0-fs time step). This theoretical model was released at the Protein Data Bank (PDB; code: 1P76) before the release of the first X-ray structure of CCP (PDB code: 1Q2W). In contrast to the catalytic dyad observed in X-ray structures of CCP and other coronavirus cysteine proteinases, a catalytic triad comprising Asp187, His41, and Cys145 is found in the theoretical model of the substrate-bound CCP. The simulations of the CCP complex suggest that substrate binding leads to the displacement of a water molecule entrapped by Asp187 and His41, thus converting the dyad to a more efficient catalytic triad. The CCP complex structure has an expanded active-site pocket that is useful for anti-SARS drug design. In addition, this work demonstrates that multiple molecular dynamics simulations are effective in correcting errors that result from low-sequence-identity homology modeling.