Thermodynamic and biological evaluation of a thrombin binding aptamer modified with several unlocked nucleic acid (UNA) monomers and a 2'-C-piperazino-UNA monomer

Thrombin binding aptamer is a DNA 15-mer which forms a G-quadruplex structure and possess promising anticoagulant properties due to specific interactions with thrombin. Herein we present the influence of a single 2'-C-piperazino-UNA residue and UNA residues incorporated in several positions on thermodynamics, kinetics and biological properties of the aptamer. 2'-C-Piperazino-UNA is characterized by more efficient stabilization of quadruplex structure in comparison to regular UNA and increases thermodynamic stability of TBA by 0.28-0.44 kcal/mol in a position depending manner with retained quadruplex topology and molecularity. The presence of UNA-U in positions U3, U7, and U12 results in the highest stabilization of G-quadruplex structure (ΔΔG(37)(°)=-1.03kcal/mol). On the contrary, the largest destabilization mounting to 1.79 kcal/mol was observed when UNA residues were placed in positions U7, G8, and U9. Kinetic studies indicate no strict correlation between thermodynamic stability of modified variants and their binding affinity to thrombin. Most of the studied variants bind thrombin, albeit with decreased affinity in reference to unmodified TBA. Thrombin time assay studies indicate three variants as being as potent as TBA in fibrin clotting inhibition.     

Conformation and thermostability of oligonucleotide d(GGTTGGTGTGGTTGG) containing thiophosphoryl internucleotide bonds at different positions

The thrombin-binding aptamer d(GGTTGGTGTGGTTGG) (TBA) is an efficient tool for the inhibition of thrombin function. We have studied conformations and thermodynamic stability of a number of modified TBA oligonucleotides containing thiophosphoryl substitution at different internucleotide sites. Using circular dichroism such modifications were found not to disrupt the antiparallel intramolecular quadruplex specific for TBA. Nevertheless, the presence of a single thiophosphoryl bond between two G-quartet planes led to a significant decrease in the quadruplex thermostability. On the contrary, modifications in each of the loop regions either stabilized an aptamer structure or did not reduce its stability. According to the thrombin time test, the aptamer with thio-modifications in both TT loops (LL11) exhibits the same antithrombin efficiency as the original TBA. This aptamer shows better stability against DNA nuclease compared to that of TBA. We conclude that such thio-modification patterns are very promising for the design of anticoagulation agents.     

Stability and binding properties of a modified thrombin binding aptamer

Aptamer-based drugs represent an attractive approach in pharmacological therapy. The most studied aptamer, thrombin binding aptamer (TBA), folds into a well-defined quadruplex structure and binds to its target with good specificity and affinity. Modified aptamers with improved biophysical properties could constitute a new class of therapeutic aptamers. In this study we show that the modified thrombin binding aptamer (mTBA), ^3′GGT^5′-^5′TGGTGTGGTTGG^3′, which also folds into a quadruplex structure, is more stable than its unmodified counterpart and shows a higher thrombin affinity. The stability of the modified aptamer was investigated using differential scanning calorimetry, and the energetics of mTBA and TBA binding to thrombin was characterized by means of isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC). ITC data revealed that TBA/thrombin and mTBA/thrombin binding stoichiometry is 1:2 for both interactions. Structural models of the two complexes of thrombin with TBA and with mTBA were also obtained and subjected to molecular dynamics simulations in explicit water. Analysis of the models led to an improvement of the understanding of the aptamer-thrombin recognition at a molecular level.     

Unlocking G-quadruplex: Effect of unlocked nucleic acid on G-quadruplex stability

G-quadruplexes are common structural motifs in aptamers. UNA or unlocked nucleic acid is the latest nucleic acid modification. We have attempted to evaluate the impact of UNA modification on the structure and stability of G-quadruplex oligonucleotides for application in aptamer design. We show using CD spectroscopy that UNA modifications can cause structural transitions in some cases although they retain the inherent G- quadruplex signature. From UV melting studies we showed a position dependent effect of UNA modifications such that quadruplexes with UNA modified loops are further stabilized whereas UNA modifications in stem of the G-quadruplex significantly destabilize the structure. The impact of UNA modification on different nucleobases is also investigated. From the analysis of UV melting results, thermodynamic profile was computed and it was concluded that all the sequences are stable at 37 °C. Finally, a greater serum stability of the modified oligonucleotides in comparison with unmodified ones is also demonstrated. Overall, the position dependent effect of single UNA substitutions was observed and analysed.     

A structure-activity relationship of a thrombin-binding aptamer containing LNA in novel sites

In this report, structural characterization, aptamer stability and thrombin of a new modified thrombin-ligand complex binding aptamer (TBA) containing anti-guanine bases and a loop position locked nucleic acid (LNA) are presented. NMR, circular dichroic spectroscopy and molecular modeling were used to characterize the three-dimensional structure of two G-quadruplexes. LNA-modification of the anti-guanosines yields G-quadruplexes that show affinity and inhibitory activity toward thrombin, whereas LNA-modification of a thymine nucleotide in the TGT loop increases the thermal stability of TBA. As assessed by denatured PAGE electrophoresis, all modified aptamers display an increase in environmental stability. The prothrombin time assay and fibrinogen assay showed that the aptamers still had good inhibitory activity, and 15 of them had the longest PT time. Therefore, the LNA modification is well suited to improve the physicochemical and biological properties of the native thrombin-binding aptamer.     

Modulation of i-motif thermodynamic stability by the introduction of UNA (unlocked nucleic acid) monomers

The influence of acyclic RNA derivatives, UNA (unlocked nucleic acid) monomers, on i-DNA thermodynamic stability has been investigated. The 22 nt human telomeric fragment was chosen as the model sequence for stability studies. UNA monomers modulate i-motif stability in a position-depending manner. The largest destabilization is observed for position C14, while UNA placed in position A12 causes significant increase of i-DNA thermodynamic stability. CD curves of UNA-modified variants imply no structural changes relative to the native i-motif.     

Synthesis, structural studies and biological properties of new TBA analogues containing an acyclic nucleotide

A new modified acyclic nucleoside, namely N(1)-(3-hydroxy-2-hydroxymethyl-2-methylpropyl)-thymidine, was synthesized and transformed into a building block useful for oligonucleotide (ON) automated synthesis. A series of modified thrombin binding aptamers (TBAs) in which the new acyclic nucleoside replaces, one at the time, the thymidine residues were then synthesized and characterized by UV, CD, MS, and (1)H NMR. The biological activity of the resulting TBAs was tested by Prothrombin Time assay (PT assay) and by purified fibrinogen clotting assay. From a structural point of view, nearly all the new TBA analogues show a similar behavior as the unmodified counterpart, being able to fold into a bimolecular or monomolecular quadruplex structure depending on the nature of monovalent cations (sodium or potassium) coordinated in the quadruplex core. From the comparison of structural and biological data, some important structure-activity relationships emerged, particularly when the modification involved the TT loops. In agreement with previous studies we found that the folding ability of TBA analogues is more affected by modifications involving positions 4 and 13, rather than positions 3 and 12. On the other hand, the highest anti-thrombin activities were detected for aptamers containing the modification at T13 or T12 positions, thus indicating that the effects produced by the introduction of the acyclic nucleoside on the biological activity are not tightly connected with structure stabilities. It is noteworthy that the modification at T7 produces an ON being more stable and active than the natural TBA.     

The effect on quadruplex stability of North-nucleoside derivatives in the loops of the thrombin-binding aptamer

Modified thrombin-binding aptamers (TBAs) carrying uridine (U), 2'-deoxy-2'-fluorouridine (FU) and North-methanocarbathymidine (NT) residues in the loop regions were synthesized and analyzed by UV thermal denaturation experiments and CD spectroscopy. The replacement of thymidines in the TGT loop by U and FU results in an increased stability of the antiparallel quadruplex structure described for the TBA while the presence of NT residues in the same positions destabilizes the antiparallel structure. The substitution of the thymidines in the TT loops for U, FU and NT induce a destabilization of the antiparallel quadruplex, indicating the crucial role of these positions. NMR studies on TBAs modified with uridines at the TGT loop also confirm the presence of the antiparallel quadruplex structure. Nevertheless, replacement of two Ts in the TT loops by uridine gives a more complex scenario in which the antiparallel quadruplex structure is present along with other partially unfolded species or aggregates.     

Different duplex/quadruplex junctions determine the properties of anti-thrombin aptamers with mixed folding

Mixed duplex/quadruplex oligonucleotides have attracted great interest as therapeutic targets as well as effective biomedical aptamers. In the case of thrombin-binding aptamer (TBA), the addition of a duplex motif to the G-quadruplex module improves the aptamer resistance to biodegradation and the affinity for thrombin. In particular, the mixed oligonucleotide RE31 is significantly more effective than TBA in anticoagulation experiments and shows a slower disappearance rate in human plasma and blood. In the crystal structure of the complex with thrombin, RE31 adopts an elongated structure in which the duplex and quadruplex regions are perfectly stacked on top of each other, firmly connected by a well-structured junction. The lock-and-key shape complementarity between the TT loops of the G-quadruplex and the protein exosite I gives rise to the basic interaction that stabilizes the complex. However, our data suggest that the duplex motif may have an active role in determining the greater anti-thrombin activity in biological fluids with respect to TBA. This work gives new information on mixed oligonucleotides and highlights the importance of structural data on duplex/quadruplex junctions, which appear to be varied, unpredictable, and fundamental in determining the aptamer functional properties.     

Alkylation of phosphorothioated thrombin binding aptamers improves the selectivity of inhibition of tumor cell proliferation upon anticoagulation

BackgroundRecently, aptamers have been extensively researched for therapy and diagnostic applications. Thrombin-binding aptamer is a 15 nt deoxyribonucleic acid screened by SELEX, it can specifically bind to thrombin and inhibit blood coagulation. Since it is also endowed with excellent antitumor activity, the intrinsic anticoagulation advantage converted to a main potential side effect for its further application in antiproliferative therapy.MethodsSite-specific alkylation was conducted through nucleophilic reaction of phosphorothioated TBAs using bromide reagents. Circular dichroism (CD) spectroscopy and surface plasmon resonance (SPR) measurements were used to evaluate anticoagulation activity, and a CCK-8 assay was used to determine cell proliferation activity.ResultsThe CD spectra of the modified TBAs were weakened, and their affinity for thrombin was dramatically reduced, as reflected by the K_D values. On the other hand, their inhibition of A549 cells was retained.ConclusionsIncorporation of different alkyls apparently disrupted the binding of TBA to thrombin while maintaining the antitumor activity.General significanceA new modification strategy was established for the use of TBA as a more selective antitumor agent.     

Effect of loop sequence and size on DNA aptamer stability

The thrombin aptamer is a 15-mer oligodeoxyribonucleotide that folds into a unimolecular quadruplex consisting of a stack of two guanine quartets connected by two external loops and one central loop and possesses a high affinity for thrombin. We have undertaken a systematic examination, in KCl, of the thermodynamic stability of thrombin aptamer analogues containing sequence modifications in one or more of the loops, as well as in the number of quartets. UV melting studies have been carried out to obtain the relevant thermodynamic parameters for these aptamers. van't Hoff analysis of these data, with a two-state model for unimolecular denaturation, gave excellent fits to the experimental observations. Thermodynamic analysis indicates that the central loop sequence in the parent aptamer is optimal for stability. Modifications in this or other loops can effect either DeltaH degrees, DeltaS degrees, or both. Addition of a single G at the 5'-end decreases stability while addition of a G at the 3'-end increases stability. Differential scanning calorimetry experiments on the thrombin aptamer reveal that a heat capacity change, not detected by UV measurements, accompanies the unfolding of the aptamer.     

Heat capacity changes associated with guanine quadruplex formation: an isothermal titration calorimetry study

This study addresses the temperature dependence of the enthalpy of formation for several unimolecular quadruplexes in the presence of excess monovalent salt. We examined a series of biologically significant guanine-rich DNA sequences: thrombin binding aptamer (TBA) (d(G(2)T(2)G(2)TGTG(2)T(2)G(2)), PS2.M, a catalytically active aptamer (d(GTG(3)TAG(3)CG(3)T(2)G(2))), and the human telomere repeat (HT) (d(AG(3)(T(2)AG(3))(3))). Using CD spectra and UV melting, we confirmed the presence of quadruplex structures and established the temperature range in which quadruplex conformation is stable. We then performed ITC experiments, adding DNA to a solution containing excess NaCl or KCl. In this approach, only several additions are made, and only the enthalpy of quadruplex formation is measured. This measurement was repeated at different temperatures to determine the temperature dependence of the enthalpy change accompanying quadruplex formation. To control for the effect of nonspecific salt interactions during DNA folding, we repeated the experiment by replacing the quadruplex-forming sequences with a similar but nonfolding sequence. Dilution enthalpies were also subtracted to obtain the final enthalpy value involving only the quadruplex folding process. For all sequences studied, quadruplex formation was exothermic but with an increasing magnitude with increasing temperature. These results are discussed in terms of the change in heat capacity associated with quadruplex formation.     

Loop residues of thrombin-binding DNA aptamer impact G-quadruplex stability and thrombin binding

The thrombin-binding DNA aptamer (TBA) 5′-d(GGTTGGTGTGGTTGG)-3′ forms a G-quadruplex that is necessary for binding to the coagulation factor thrombin. The stability of the G-quadruplex of TBA when bound to thrombin and potassium ion (K⁺) were investigated for the wild-type oligonucleotide and for mutants in which thymine residues were substituted by adenine. In the presence of thrombin, G-quadruplexes formed by oligonucleotides in which the fourth or thirteenth residues were changed (T4A and T13A, respectively) were more unstable than that of wild-type, whereas T3A, T7A, T9A and T12A were more stable. The opposite effect was observed in the presence of 100 mM K⁺: the G-quadruplexes formed by T4A and T13A were more stable and T3A, T7A, T9A and T12A were more unstable than that of wild-type. Isothermal titration calorimetry measurements indicated that the binding constant of the interaction between T3A, T7A, T9A and T12A mutants and thrombin at 25 °C were close to that of wild-type, whereas T13A was significantly lower and T4A did not appear to bind to thrombin. Therefore, the stabilization of the G-quadruplex structure of TBA by thrombin appears to be due to an interaction between certain thymine nucleobases rather than to the quadruplex structure. The present study demonstrates that thrombin stabilizes the G-quadruplex via the interaction with residues in the loops but not via direct stabilization of G-quartets.     

Selective recognition of parallel and anti-parallel thrombin-binding aptamer G-quadruplexes by different fluorescent dyes

G-quadruplexes (G4) have been found increasing potential in applications, such as molecular therapeutics, diagnostics and sensing. Both Thioflavin T (ThT) and N-Methyl mesoporphyrin IX (NMM) become fluorescent in the presence of most G4, but thrombin-binding aptamer (TBA) has been reported as the only exception of the known G4-forming oligonucleotides when ThT is used as a high-throughput assay to identify G4 formation. Here, we investigate the interactions between ThT/NMM and TBA through fluorescence spectroscopy, circular dichroism and molecular docking simulation experiments in the absence or presence of cations. The results display that a large ThT fluorescence enhancement can be observed only when ThT bind to the parallel TBA quadruplex, which is induced to form by ThT in the absence of cations. On the other hand, great promotion in NMM fluorescence can be obtained only in the presence of anti-parallel TBA quadruplex, which is induced to fold by K⁺ or thrombin. The highly selective recognition of TBA quadruplex with different topologies by the two probes may be useful to investigate the interactions between conformation-specific G4 and the associated proteins, and could also be applied in label-free fluorescent sensing of other biomolecules.     

NMR structure of the thrombin-binding DNA aptamer stabilized by Sr2+

The structure of thrombin-binding DNA aptamer complexed with a single Sr2+ ion (Sr2+:TBA complex) has been determined using NMR spectroscopy and restrained molecular dynamics simulations. The quadruplex structure for the Sr2+:TBA complex is similar in topology, but distinct in structure, from that previously reported for the K+:TBA complex. The inter-tetrad distance of the Sr2+:TBA complex is 3.8 angstroms, or 0.7 angstroms larger than in the K+:TBA complex. This substantial difference can be attributed to a different binding site for Sr2+ in the Sr2+:TBA complex than for K+ in the K+:TBA complex. The Sr2+:TBA complex assumes a 1:1 stoichiometry, and it is very likely that the Sr2+ ion simultaneously interacts with the eight O6 atoms of the two G-tetrads. The results indicate that quadruplex DNA structures are highly sensitive to the presence of specific metal ions. The binding of specific metal ions may modulate the biological activity of quadruplex DNA structures in vivo.     

Thrombin-aptamer recognition: a revealed ambiguity

Aptamers are structured oligonucleotides that recognize molecular targets and can function as direct protein inhibitors. The best-known example is the thrombin-binding aptamer, TBA, a single-stranded 15-mer DNA that inhibits the activity of thrombin, the key enzyme of coagulation cascade. TBA folds as a G-quadruplex structure, as proved by its NMR structure. The X-ray structure of the complex between TBA and human α-thrombin was solved at 2.9-Å resolution, but did not provide details of the aptamer conformation and the interactions with the protein molecule. TBA is rapidly processed by nucleases. To improve the properties of TBA, a number of modified analogs have been produced. In particular, a modified TBA containing a 5′-5′ polarity inversion site, mTBA, has higher stability and higher affinity toward thrombin with respect to TBA, although it has a lower inhibitory activity. We present the crystal structure of the thrombin–mTBA complex at 2.15-Å resolution; the resulting model eventually provides a clear picture of thrombin–aptamers interaction, and also highlights the structural bases of the different properties of TBA and mTBA. Our findings open the way for a rational design of modified aptamers with improved potency as anticoagulant drugs.     

Finding and Characterizing the Complexes of Drug Like Molecules with Quadruplex DNA: Combined Use of an Enhanced Hydroxyl Radical Cleavage Protocol and NMR

Structural information on the complexes of drug like molecules with quadruplex DNAs can aid the development of therapeutics and research tools that selectively target specific quadruplex DNAs. Screening can identify candidate molecules that require additional evaluation. An enhanced hydroxyl radical cleavage protocol is demonstrated that can efficiently provide structural information on the complexes of the candidate molecules with quadruplex DNA. NMR methods have been used to offer additional structural information about the complexes as well as validate the results of the hydroxyl radical approach. This multi-step protocol has been demonstrated on complexes of the chair type quadruplex formed by the thrombin binding aptamer, d(GGTTGGTGTGGTTGG). The hydroxyl radical results indicate that NSC 176319, Cain’s quinolinium that was found by screening, exhibits selective binding to the two TT loops. The NMR results are consistent with selective disruption of the hydrogen bonding between T4 and T13 as well as unstacking of these residues from the bottom quartet. Thus, the combination of screening, hydroxyl radical footprinting and NMR can find new molecules that selectively bind to quadruplex DNAs as well as provide structural information about their complexes.     

Site-specific replacement of the thymine methyl group by fluorine in thrombin binding aptamer significantly improves structural stability and anticoagulant activity

Here we report investigations, based on circular dichroism, nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy, molecular modelling, differential scanning calorimetry and prothrombin time assay, on analogues of the thrombin binding aptamer (TBA) in which individual thymidines were replaced by 5-fluoro-2′-deoxyuridine residues. The whole of the data clearly indicate that all derivatives are able to fold in a G-quadruplex structure very similar to the ‘chair-like’ conformation typical of the TBA. However, only ODNs TBA-F4 and TBA-F13 have shown a remarkable improvement both in the melting temperature (ΔT_m ≈ +10) and in the anticoagulant activity in comparison with the original TBA. These findings are unusual, particularly considering previously reported studies in which modifications of T4 and T13 residues in TBA sequence have clearly proven to be always detrimental for the structural stability and biological activity of the aptamer. Our results strongly suggest the possibility to enhance TBA properties through tiny straightforward modifications.     

Thermodynamics of RNA duplexes modified with unlocked nucleic acid nucleotides

Thermodynamics provides insights into the influence of modified nucleotide residues on stability of nucleic acids and is crucial for designing duplexes with given properties. In this article, we introduce detailed thermodynamic analysis of RNA duplexes modified with unlocked nucleic acid (UNA) nucleotide residues. We investigate UNA single substitutions as well as model mismatch and dangling end effects. UNA residues placed in a central position makes RNA duplex structure less favourable by 4.0–6.6 kcal/mol. Slight destabilization, by ∼0.5–1.5 kcal/mol, is observed for 5′- or 3′-terminal UNA residues. Furthermore, thermodynamic effects caused by UNA residues are extremely additive with ΔG°₃₇ conformity up to 98%. Direct mismatches involving UNA residues decrease the thermodynamic stability less than unmodified mismatches in RNA duplexes. Additionally, the presence of UNA residues adjacent to unpaired RNA residues reduces mismatch discrimination. Thermodynamic analysis of UNA 5′- and 3′-dangling ends revealed that stacking interactions of UNA residues are always less favourable than that of RNA residues. Finally, circular dichroism spectra imply no changes in overall A-form structure of UNA–RNA/RNA duplexes relative to the unmodified RNA duplexes.     

Quadruplex formation as a molecular switch to turn on intrinsically fluorescent nucleotide analogs

Quadruplexes are involved in the regulation of gene expression and are part of telomeres at the ends of chromosomes. In addition, they are useful in therapeutic and biotechnological applications, including nucleic acid diagnostics. In the presence of K⁺ ions, two 15-mer sequences d(GGTTGGTGTGGTTGG) (thrombin binding aptamer) and d(GGGTGGGTGGGTGGG) (G3T) fold into antiparallel and parallel quadruplexes, respectively. In the present study, we measured the fluorescence intensity of one or more 2-aminopurine or 6-methylisoxanthopterin base analogs incorporated at loop-positions of quadruplex forming sequences to develop a detection method for DNA sequences in solution. Before quadruplex formation, the fluorescence is efficiently quenched in all cases. Remarkably, G3T quadruplex formation results in emission of fluorescence equal to that of a free base in all three positions. In the case of thrombin binding aptamer, the emission intensity depends on the location of the fluorescent nucleotides. Circular dichroism studies demonstrate that the modifications do not change the overall secondary structure, whereas thermal unfolding experiments revealed that fluorescent analogs significantly destabilize the quadruplexes. Overall, these studies suggest that quadruplexes containing fluorescent nucleotide analogs are useful tools in the development of novel DNA detection methodologies.