'Proteomineering': has the mine been excavated?

Evaluation of: Di Girolamo F, Boschetti E, Chung MC, Guadagni F, Righetti PG. 'Proteomineering' or not? The debate on biomarker discovery in sera continues. J. Proteomics 74(5), 589-594 (2011). The combinatorial peptide ligand library in association with mass spectrometry can greatly enhance the dynamic range of the analysis of low- and very low-abundance proteins constituting the vast majority of species in any sample. When compared with untreated samples, the increment in detection of low-abundance species appears to be at least fourfold. Recently, the combinatorial peptide ligand library has been challenged; however, it has been clearly demonstrated in the evaluated paper that the protocols for elution of the captured polypeptides make the difference. Therefore, the solid-phase ligand library made of hexapeptides remains a promising and unique tool for biomarker discovery.     

"Proteomineering" or not? The debate on biomarker discovery in sera continues

The performance of sera pre-treatments for biomarker discovery has been recently assessed as very poor not only for immuno-subtraction, in turn evaluated as a tool unable to look deep into the low-abundance proteome (LAP) and thus incapable to lead to any novel biomarker discovery (J Proteome Res 2010;9:4982-4991), but also for combinatorial peptide ligand libraries (CPLL) (Proteomics 2010;10:1416-1425). The performance of both tools has been given as enabling to barely detect a meagre 25% more as compared to control, untreated sera. Meanwhile, other studies indicated the extreme effectiveness of peptide libraries to enlarge the knowledge of proteome compositions. In this contradictory situation we are here re-evaluating some protocol aspects and report that indeed CPLL is an excellent tool, able to dig really deep into the low-abundance proteome. The problem is that in those reports under-optimized capture and elution protocols had been adopted. With the protocols here reported, namely (a) abandoning the step of adding 150mM salt to the sample; (b) capture at three different pH values (pH 4.0, 7.0 and 9.3) and (c), most importantly, eluting from CPLL beads in 4% boiling SDS in the presence of 25mM DTT, we can largely expand the windows of visibility. In particular, it is here shown that a common elution protocol adopted in several reports, in 4M urea and 1% CHAP, barely elutes about 15% of the captured species. Nevertheless if the CPLL beads thus treated are further eluted with boiling SDS-DTT, an additional 80% is recovered.     

The proteome buccaneers: how to unearth your treasure chest via combinatorial peptide ligand libraries

The latest advances in combinatorial peptide ligand libraries, with their unique performance in discovering low-abundance species in proteomes, are reviewed here. Explanations of mechanism, potential applications, capture of proteomes at different pH values to enhance the total catch and quantitative elutions, such as boiling in the presence of 5% sodium dodecyl sulfate and 3% dithiothreitol are included. The reproducibility of protein capture among different experiments with the same batch of beads or with different batches is also reported to be very high, with coefficient of variations in the order of 10–20%. Miniaturized operations, consisting of capture with as little as 20 or even 5 µl of peptide beads are reported, thus demonstrating that the described technology could be exploited for routine biomarker discovery in a biomedical environment. Finally, it is shown that the signal of captured proteins is linear over approximately three orders of magnitude, ranging from nM to µM, thus ensuring that differential quantitative proteomics for biomarker discovery can be fully implemented, providing species do not saturate their ligands.     

Hexapeptide combinatorial ligand libraries: the march for the detection of the low-abundance proteome continues

After 10 years of extensive proteomic research, it has become increasingly apparent that new technologies are sorely needed for detecting the low-abundance proteome-those proteins (up to 50% in any proteome) whose concentration in tissues or cells falls below the detection limits of currently available methodologies. Here we survey one such method: a combinatorial ligand library (called ProteoMiner), comprising dozens of millions of hexapeptides capable of interacting with most, if not all, proteins in any given proteome. They act by drastically reducing the signal of high-abundance species while increasing the level of the low-abundance components to bring their signal within the detection limit of present-day tools. Such a library has been tested against a number of human biological fluids, such as sera, urine, cerebrospinal fluid as well as against cell lysates (e.g., platelets, red blood cells) with interesting results.     

Screening of Ligand Binding on Melatonin Receptor Using Non-Peptide Combinatorial Libraries

Abstract

The screening of combinatorial libraries requires a deconvolution procedure to obtain, in fine, the most active compound of the starting library. the standard screening assays used in regular molecular pharmacology, have been poorly assessed when transposed to combinatorial chemistry-related experiments, particularly those involving large numbers of chemicals in a single assay. One key issue is the effect of the inactive analogs on the identification of the active ligand in mixtures. We chose melatonin receptors to measure the apparent affinity of a single ligand when tested alone or in mixtures of non-peptide low molecular weight compounds. Using ligands with IC₅₀ from the micro- to the picomolar range, mixed with increasingly complex mixtures of 5 to 20 or 25 inactive compounds, we analyzed the displacements from the mt₁ and MT₂ melatonin receptor subtypes of the radioligand 2-iodomelatonin (K_d= 25pmol/l and 200pmol/l, respectively). the behavior of equimolar mixtures in displacement curves led to the conclusion that the observed binding affinity reflects the dilution effect of mixing the active component with inactive compounds but does not reveal noticeable interactions which would interfere with the binding process. From the practical point of view, the concentrations of the active species in the binding assay should be large enough to displace significantly the radioligand, a requirement which may be limited by the solubility of the ligand mixtures. in contrast, previous observations with peptide libraries report that the dilution effect is often compensated by additive or synergic action of structurally related analogs, thus making possible the deconvolution of very large (typically up to 10⁷ compounds) peptide libraries.     

Low abundance protein enrichment for discovery of candidate plasma protein biomarkers for early detection of breast cancer

Molecular biomarkers of early stage breast cancer may improve the sensitivity and specificity of diagnosis. Plasma biomarkers have additional value in that they can be monitored with minimal invasiveness. Plasma biomarker discovery by genome-wide proteomic methods is impeded by the wide dynamic range of protein abundance and the heterogeneity of protein expression in healthy and disease populations which requires the analysis of a large number of samples. We addressed these issues through the development of a novel protocol that couples a combinatorial peptide ligand library protein enrichment strategy with isobaric label-based 2D LC-MS/MS for the identification of candidate biomarkers in high throughput. Plasma was collected from patients with stage I breast cancer or benign breast lesions. Low abundance proteins were enriched using a bead-based combinatorial library of hexapeptides. This resulted in the identification of 397 proteins, 22% of which are novel plasma proteins. Twenty-three differentially expressed plasma proteins were identified, demonstrating the effectiveness of the described protocol and defining a set of candidate biomarkers to be validated in independent samples. This work can be used as the basis for the design of properly powered investigations of plasma protein expression for biomarker discovery in larger cohorts of patients with complex disease.     

Exploration of the sea urchin coelomic fluid via combinatorial peptide ligand libraries

The urchin Paracentrotus lividus has been characterized via previous capture and enhancement of low-abundance proteins with combinatorial peptide ligand libraries (CPLL, ProteoMiner). Whereas in the control only 26 unique gene products could be identified, 82 species could be detected after CPLL treatment. Due to the overwhelming presence of two major proteins-the toposome (a highly glycosylated, modified calcium-binding, iron-less transferrin) and the major yolk proteins, belonging to the class of cell adhesion proteins-which constituted about 70% of the proteome of this biological fluid and strongly interfered with the capture of the minority proteome, no additional proteins could be detected. Yet, at present, this constitutes the most thorough investigation of the proteome of this biological fluid.     

Exploring the platelet proteome via combinatorial, hexapeptide ligand libraries

A combinatorial ligand library, composed of millions of diverse hexapeptide baits, able to capture and concentrate the "low-abundance" proteome while drastically cutting the concentration of the most abundant species, has been applied to the exploration of the soluble platelet proteome. Mass spectrometry analysis of untreated and library-treated platelets has resulted in the identification of 435 unique gene products. Of those, 147 entries (35% of the total) have not been described among the list of >1100 proteins in proteomic platelet investigations reported before. In addition, the analysis of excised spots from two-dimensional electrophoresis analysis allowed 57 other proteins to be added that were not found in LC-MS analysis, 33 of them not described before in proteomics studies, bringing the total number of new gene products to 180. Thus, the present data add a non-negligible number of species for continuing the "cartography" of the proteomic asset of platelets, in view of completing the mapping procedure for a deeper understanding of the physiology and pathology of this blood cell. Because the capturing process is performed under physiological conditions, by exploiting, for binding to the combinatorial library, the native protein configuration, the described technique is not adapted to capture highly hydrophobic proteins, which need strong denaturing and solubilizing conditions that are incompatible with our working procedure. Thus, our list reports essentially hydrophilic proteins, with negative GRAVY indexes.     

Mehercules, adhuc Bacchus! The debate on wine proteomics continues

The proteome of untreated white wines (a Recioto made with Garganega grapes from the Veneto region) was explored in depth via capture with combinatorial peptide ligand libraries (CPLL) at four different pH values: pH 2.2, 3.8, 7.2, and 9.3. The combined data on the discoveries in the four CPLL eluates, as well as in the collected bottle sediment, allowed the identification of 106 unique gene products belonging to Vitis vinifera, as well as of an additional 11 proteins released by the S. cerevisiae used in the fermentation process. Among the residual grape proteins detected in the Recioto wine, ca. 30% were categorized as medium to high-abundance species, vs 70% low-abundance ones. The detection of so many low-abundance species suggests that proteomic (coupled to peptidomic) data might be used for typing high-quality products (grand crus) to assess their genuineness and protect them from fraudulent imitations.     

Synthesis of A Polyaminooligonucleotide Combinatorial Library

Abstract

A new method of synthesis of phosphoramidite of 2′-deoxycytydine carrying a protected spermine moiety at N-4 position is described. A model oligodeoxyribonucleotide containing the specified nucleoside unit has been synthesised. A synthesis of a polyaminooligonucleotide combinatorial library was carried out. The analysis of the above library clearly shows that the presence of spermine moieties in oligodeoxyribonucleotides increases stability of their duplexes.     

Affinity purification of fibrinogen using a ligand from a peptide library.

An affinity resin containing the peptide ligand Phe-Leu-Leu-Val-Pro-Leu (FLLVPL) has been developed for the purification of fibrinogen. The ligand was identified by screening a solid-phase combinatorial peptide library using an immunostaining technique. The specific binding of fibrinogen to the ligand has been characterized by isothermal calorimetry and adsorption isotherms and is dominated by both hydrophobic interactions and ionic interactions with the N-terminal free amino group. The effective association constant of fibrinogen was substantially higher when the peptide was immobilized on the resin than in solution; moreover, it increased with increasing peptide density, suggesting a cooperative binding effect. A low ionic strength buffer at pH 4 was used successfully to elute adsorbed fibrinogen from the column with high purity, retention of factor XIII crosslinking activity, and minimal, if any, loss of biological function. This general approach to ligand selection and characterization can be used to develop peptide ligands for the affinity purification of diverse proteins on a large scale.     

Oxidized LDL at low concentration promotes in-vitro angiogenesis and activates nitric oxide synthase through PI3K/Akt/eNOS pathway in human coronary artery endothelial cells

There are many orphan G protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs), for which ligands have not yet been identified, in both vertebrates and invertebrates, such as Drosophila melanogaster. Identification of their cognate ligands is critical for understanding the function and regulation of such GPCRs. Indeed, the discovery of bioactive peptides that bind GPCRs has enhanced our understanding of mechanisms underlying many physiological processes. Here, we identified an endogenous ligand of the Drosophila orphan GPCR, CG34381. The purified ligand is a peptide comprised of 28 amino acids with three intrachain disulfide bonds. The preprotein is coded for by gene CG14871. We designated the cysteine-rich peptide “trissin” (it means for triple S–S bonds) and characterized the structure of intrachain disulfide bonds formation in a synthetic trissin peptide. Because the expression of trissin and its receptor is reported to predominantly localize to the brain and thoracicoabdominal ganglion, trissin is expected to behave as a neuropeptide. The discovery of trissin provides an important lead to aid our understanding of cysteine-rich peptides and their functional interaction with GPCRs.     

Detection of advanced oxidation protein products in patients with chronic kidney disease by a novel monoclonal antibody

Abstract

Advanced oxidation protein products (AOPP) as a biomarker of oxidative stress has been demonstrated in chronic kidney disease (CKD) patients; however, current methods to detect the accumulation of AOPP in serum and in tissues are limited and unreliable. This study generated a monoclonal antibody (mAb) designated 3F2, that reacts specifically with hypochlorous acid (HOCl)-modified proteins, but not with the native forms or with other types of oxidative modifications. Notably, mAb 3F2 recognizes the AOPP deposited in renal tissues of AOPP-treated rats and of patients with different kinds of CKD. Moreover, this mAb can almost completely inhibit the production of reactive oxygen species in RAW264.7 cells induced by AOPP (p < 0.001). In conclusion, mAb 3F2 can be used to detect AOPP specifically in serum and in tissues, and this antibody can potentially provide an important tool and new insight into research on diseases related to oxidative stress.     

Preliminary remarks on Orthodontium in Europe

Abstract

The recent discovery of an Orthodontium form in two localities in Holland led us to a revision of the species concerned, viz. the species published for Europe and the type-species of the genus, O. lineare Schwaegr. It has been shown that O. gracile var. heterocarpum Wats. agrees in nearly all characters with O. lineare. Consequently the name of the variety is regarded as synonym of the type-species. O. germanicum F. W. & K. Koppe also appears to belong here. O. gracile Schwaegr. ex Br. & Schimp., however, is distinct in some important characters and is retained as a separate species. The French O. Gaumei Allorge & Thériot is markedly distinct from the other European species but is closely related to the Asiatic O. infractum. The distribution of the three species is discussed.     

Interaction among proteins and peptide libraries in proteome analysis: pH involvement for a larger capture of species

When capturing proteins via combinatorial peptide ligand libraries, a method well known for drastically reducing the concentration of high-abundance proteins and substantially magnifying the signal of low-abundance species, thus leading to the discovery of a large number of proteins previously undetected in proteomes, we had constantly noticed that there would be a loss of species initially present in the untreated sample, to the tune of 5%, up to 15% in some cases. Such losses are a nuisance and hamper to some extent the unique performance of the method. In order to verify if such losses could be reduced and also to understand some mechanisms of the capture process, we introduce here an important variant to the capture operation, up to the present carried out in physiological saline at pH 7.2. In this novel protocol, the binding step is conducted at three different pH values, namely the standard one at pH 7.2, plus two additional processes, at acidic (pH 4.0) and alkaline (pH 9.3) pH values. Indeed the capture process is more extensive, with a number of additional species captured at the two pH extremes in sera and other proteomes. Interestingly, at pH 4.0 newly detected proteins were mostly acidic, while at the alkaline pH additional protein species were more evenly distributed throughout the pI range towards the alkaline area. The role of pH in the complex mechanism of binding among the hexapeptide library and the various proteomes being analyzed is discussed and evaluated. Due to significant changes in protein patterns with pH, recommendations are thus made to increase the possibility to find additional gene products illustrated by two examples (snake venom and leaf protein extract). Keeping under control the environmental pH when facing reproducibility studies or for comparative proteomics profiling is also a general rule suggested by this study.     

Synthesis of Polyaminooligonucleotides and Their Combinatorial Libraries

Abstract

A synthesis of phosphoramidites of 2′-deoxyadenosine and 2′-deoxyguanosine carrying a protected spermine moiety at N-6 and N-2 positions respectively is described. An approach to analyse properties of polyaminooligonucleotides using their synthetic combinatorial libraries is described and discussed. A synthesis of a polyaminooligonucleotide combinatorial library was carried out and the analysis of the library clearly showed that the presence of spermine moieties in oligodeoxyribonucleotides increases stability of their complexes.     

Combinatorial de novo design and application of a biomimetic affinity ligand for the purification of human anti‐HIV mAb 4E10 from transgenic tobacco

Monoclonal anti‐HIV antibody 4E10 (mAb 4E10) is one of the most broadly neutralizing antibodies against HIV, directed against a specific epitope on envelope protein gp41. In the present study, a combinatorial de novo design approach was used for the development of a biomimetic ligand for the affinity purification of mAb 4E10 from tobacco transgenic extract in a single chromatographic step. The biomimetic ligand (4E10lig) was based on a L ‐Phe/β‐Ala bi‐substituted 1,3,5‐triazine (Trz) scaffold (β‐Ala‐Trz‐L ‐Phe, 4E10lig) which potentially mimics the more pronounced electrostatic and hydrophobic interactions of mAb 4E10‐binding sequence determined by screening of a random peptide library. This library was comprised of Escherichia coli cells harboring a plasmid (pFlitrx) engineered to express a fusion protein containing random dodecapeptides that were inserted into the active loop of thioredoxin, which itself was inserted into the dispensable region of the flagellin gene. Adsorption equilibrium studies with this biomimetic ligand and mAb 4E10 determined a dissociation constant (K_D) of 0.41 ± 0.05 µM. Molecular modeling studies of the biomimetic ligand revealed that it can potentially occupy the same binding site as the natural binding core peptide epitope. The biomimetic affinity adsorbent was exploited in the development of a facile mAb 4E10 purification protocol, affording mAb 4E10 of high purity (approximately 95%) with good overall yield (60–80%). Analysis of the antibody preparation by SDS‐PAGE, enzyme‐linked immunosorbent assays (ELISA), and western blot showed that the mAb 4E10 was fully active and free of degraded variants, polyphenols, and alkaloids. Copyright © 2009 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Identification of olive (Olea europaea) seed and pulp proteins by nLC-MS/MS via combinatorial peptide ligand libraries

Different types of extraction protocols are described for identifying proteins in seed and pulp of olive (Olea europea), by employing both conventional extraction methods and capture with ProteoMiner as well as with in house-made combinatorial peptide ligand libraries (HM-CPLLs) at pH 7.4 and at pH 2.2. Thanks to the use of CPLLs, able to dramatically amplify the signal of low-abundance species, a quite large number of compounds has been indeed identified: 61 in the seed (vs. only four reported in current literature) and 231 in the pulp (vs. 56 described so far), the deepest investigation up to the present of the olive proteome. In the seed, it highlights the presence of seed storage proteins, oleosins and histones. In the pulp, the allergenic thaumatin-like protein (Ole e 13) was confirmed, among the other 231, as the most abundant protein in the olive pulp. The present research has also been undertaken with the aim of identifying proteins in olive oil and ascertaining the relative contribution of seed and pulp proteins in their presence, if any, in oils.     

mRNA display selection and solid‐phase synthesis of Fc‐binding cyclic peptide affinity ligands

Cyclic peptides are attractive candidates for synthetic affinity ligands due to their favorable properties, such as resistance to proteolysis, and higher affinity and specificity relative to linear peptides. Here we describe the discovery, synthesis and characterization of novel cyclic peptide affinity ligands that bind the Fc portion of human Immunoglobulin G (IgG; hFc). We generated an mRNA display library of cyclic pentapeptides wherein peptide cyclization was achieved with high yield and selectivity, using a solid‐phase crosslinking reaction between two primary amine groups, mediated by a homobifunctional linker. Subsequently, a pool of cyclic peptide binders to hFc was isolated from this library and chromatographic resins incorporating the selected cyclic peptides were prepared by on‐resin solid‐phase peptide synthesis and cyclization. Significantly, this approach results in resins that are resistant to harsh basic conditions of column cleaning and regeneration. Further studies identified a specific cyclic peptide—cyclo[Link‐M‐WFRHY‐K]—as a robust affinity ligand for purification of IgG from complex mixtures. The cyclo[Link‐M‐WFRHY‐K] resin bound selectively to the Fc fragment of IgG, with no binding to the Fab fragment, and also bound immunoglobulins from a variety of mammalian species. Notably, while the recovery of IgG using the cyclo[Link‐M‐WFRHY‐K] resin was comparable to a Protein A resin, elution of IgG could be achieved under milder conditions (pH 4 vs. pH 2.5). Thus, cyclo[Link‐M‐WFRHY‐K] is an attractive candidate for developing a cost‐effective and robust chromatographic resin to purify monoclonal antibodies (mAbs). Finally, our approach can be extended to efficiently generate and evaluate cyclic peptide affinity ligands for other targets of interest. Biotechnol. Bioeng. 2013; 110: 857–870. © 2012 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.