Cartilage Fibrils of Mammals are Biochemically Heterogeneous: Differential Distribution of Decorin and Collagen IX

Cartilage fibrils contain collagen II as the major constituent, but the presence of additional components, minor collagens, and noncollagenous glycoproteins is thought to be crucial for modulating several fibril properties. We have examined the distribution of two fibril constituents—decorin and collagen IX—in samples of fibril fragments obtained after bovine cartilage homogenization. Decorin was preferentially associated with a population of thicker fibril fragments from adult articular cartilage, but was not present on the thinnest fibrils. The binding was specific for the gap regions of the fibrils, and depended on the decorin core protein. Collagen IX, by contrast, predominated in the population with the thinnest fibrils, and was scarce on wider fibrils. Double-labeling experiments demonstrated the coexistence of decorin and collagen IX in some fibrils of intermediate diameter, although most fibril fragments from adult cartilage were strongly positive for one component and lacked the other. Fibril fragments from fetal epiphyseal cartilage showed a different pattern, with decorin and collagen IX frequently colocalized on fragments of intermediate and large diameters. Hence, the presence of collagen IX was not exclusive for fibrils of small diameter. These results establish that articular cartilage fibrils are biochemically heterogeneous. Different populations of fibrils share collagen II, but have distinct compositions with respect to macromolecules defining their surface properties.     

The interaction of decorin core protein fragments with type I collagen.

To further define the molecular interaction between decorin and type I collagen we generated a 20 kD fragment containing the N-terminal half of the core protein by Endoproteinase Arg C digestion and a 40 kD fragment including all leucine-rich repeats in the central part of decorin core by cleavage with 2-nitro-5-thiocyanobenzoate. The fragments did not influence collagen fibril formation, even at high concentration, and radioactive fragments showed little binding to collagen fibrils. Our observations suggest that neither the N-terminal half nor the central leucine-rich repeats of the decorin core protein can, by itself, interact fully with fibrillar collagen.     

Effects of decorin proteoglycan on fibrillogenesis,ultrastructure, and mechanics of type I collagen gels

The proteoglycan decorin is known to affect both the fibrillogenesis and the resulting ultrastructure of in vitro polymerized collagen gels. However, little is known about its effects on mechanical properties. In this study, 3D collagen gels were polymerized into tensile test specimens in the presence of decorin proteoglycan, decorin core protein, or dermatan sulfate (DS). Collagen fibrillogenesis, ultrastructure, and mechanical properties were then quantified using a turbidity assay, 2 forms of microscopy (SEM and confocal), and tensile testing. The presence of decorin proteoglycan or core protein decreased the rate and ultimate turbidity during fibrillogenesis and decreased the number of fibril aggregates (fibers) compared to control gels. The addition of decorin and core protein increased the linear modulus by a factor of 2 compared to controls, while the addition of DS reduced the linear modulus by a factor of 3. Adding decorin after fibrillogenesis had no effect, suggesting that decorin must be present during fibrillogenesis to increase the mechanical properties of the resulting gels. These results show that the inclusion of decorin proteoglycan during fibrillogenesis of type I collagen increases the modulus and tensile strength of resulting collagen gels. The increase in mechanical properties when polymerization occurs in the presence of the decorin proteoglycan is due to a reduction in the aggregation of fibrils into larger order structures such as fibers and fiber bundles.     

Estimation of the binding force of the collagen molecule-decorin core protein complex in collagen fibril

Decorin belongs to the small leucine proteoglycans family and is considered to play an important role in extracellular matrix organization. Experimental studies suggest that decorin is required for the assembly of collagen fibrils, as well as for the development of proper tissue mechanical properties. In tendons, decorins tie adjoining collagen fibrils together and probably guarantee the mechanical coupling of fibrils. The decorin molecule consists of one core protein and one glycosaminoglycan chain covalently linked to a serine residue of the core protein. Several studies have indicated that each core protein binds to the surface of collagen fibrils every 67 nm, by interacting non-covalently to one collagen molecule of the fibril surface, while the decorin glycosaminoglycans extend from the core protein to connect to another decorin core protein laying on adjacent fibril surface. The present paper investigates the complex composed of one decorin core protein and one collagen molecule in order to obtain their binding force. For this purpose, molecular models of collagen molecules type I and decorin core protein were developed and their interaction energies were evaluated by means of the molecular mechanics approach. Results show that the complex is characterized by a maximum binding force of about 12.4 x 10(3) nN and a binding stiffness of 8.33 x 10(-8) N/nm; the attained binding force is greater than the glycosaminoglycan chain's ultimate strength, thus indicating that overloads are likely to damage the collagen fibre's mechanical integrity by disrupting the glycosaminoglycan chains rather than by causing decorin core protein detachment from the collagen fibril.     

Glycosaminoglycans show a specific periodic interaction with type I collagen fibrils

Current wisdom on intermolecular interactions in the extracellular matrix assumes that small proteoglycans bind collagen fibrils on highly specific sites via their protein core, while their carbohydrate chains interact with each other in the interfibrillar space. The present study used high-resolution scanning electron microscopy to analyse the interaction of two small leucine-rich proteoglycans and several glycosaminoglycan chains with type I collagen fibrils obtained in vitro in a controlled, cell-free environment. Our results show that most ligands directly influence the collagen fibril size and shape, and their aggregation into thicker bundles. All chondroitin sulphate/dermatan sulphate glycosaminoglycans we tested, except chondroitin 4-sulphate, bound to the fibril surface in a highly specific way and, even in the absence of any protein core, formed regular, periodic interfibrillar links resembling those of the intact proteoglycan. Only intact decorin, however, was able to organize collagen fibrils into fibres compact enough to mimic in vitro the superfibrillar organization of natural tissues. Our data indicate that multiple interaction patterns may exist in vivo, may explain why decorin- or biglycan-knockout organisms show milder effects than can be expected, and may lead to the development of better, simpler engineered biomaterials.     

In vitro collagen fibril assembly in glycerol solution: evidence for a helical cooperative mechanism involving microfibrils

Glycerol inhibits the in vitro self-association of monomeric collagen into fibrils and induces the dissociation of fibrils preassembled from NaBH4-reduced collagen. These effects were investigated in an effort to understand the mechanism of fibril assembly of the protein. In PS buffer (0.03 M NaPi and 0.1 M NaCl, pH 7.0) containing 0.1-1.0 M glycerol, the self-association of type I collagen from calf skin took place only if the protein concentration was above a critical value. This critical protein concentration increased with increasing glycerol concentration. Velocity sedimentation studies showed that below the critical protein concentration and under fibril assembly conditions, the collagen was predominantly in a monomeric state. Electron microscopic examinations revealed that the collagen aggregates formed above the critical concentration consisted mostly of microfibrils of 3-5-nm diameter along with some banded fibrils were found. Collagen treated with pepsin to remove its nonhelical telopeptides also self-associated into microfibrils and fibrils in the presence of glycerol, but the reaction did not exhibit any critical concentration. These results are consistent with a mechanism of in vitro collagen fibril assembly which involves the initial formation of microfibrils through a helical cooperative mechanism. They also suggest that contacts of the nonhelical telopeptides of each collagen with its neighboring molecules provide the necessary negative free energy change for the cooperativity and that subsequent lateral association of the microfibrils leads to banded fibrils.     

Collagen fibril formation in a wound healing model

Control of tissue composition and organization will be a key feature in the development of successful products through tissue engineering. However, the mechanism of collagen fibril formation, growth, and organization is not yet fully understood. In this study we have examined collagen fibril formation in a wound healing model in which the newly formed fibrils were kept distinct from preexisting tissue through use of a porous tubular biomaterial implant. Samples were examined after 4, 6, 14, and 28 days by light microscopy, in situ hybridization, and immunofluorescence microscopy. These showed a normal wound healing response, with significant collagen formation at 14 and 28 days. Individual collagen fibrils were isolated from these samples by gentle extraction in a gentamicin-containing buffer which allowed extraction of a large proportion of intact fibrils. Examination by transmission electron microscopy showed that approximately 80% of the intact fibrils showed a single polarity reversal, with both ends of each fibril comprising collagen amino-terminal domains; the remaining fibrils had no polarity reversal. All fibrils had similar diameters at both time points. Immunoelectron microscopy showed that all labeled fibrils contained both type I and III collagens. These data indicate that this wound healing model provides a system in which collagen fibril formation can be readily followed.     

Matricellular hevin regulates decorin production and collagen assembly

Matricellular proteins such as SPARC, thrombospondin 1 and 2, and tenascin C and X subserve important functions in extracellular matrix synthesis and cellular adhesion to extracellular matrix. By virtue of its reported interaction with collagen I and deadhesive activity on cells, we hypothesized that hevin, a member of the SPARC gene family, regulates dermal extracellular matrix and collagen fibril formation. We present evidence for an altered collagen matrix and levels of the proteoglycan decorin in the normal dermis and dermal wound bed of hevin-null mice. The dermal elastic modulus was also enhanced in hevin-null animals. The levels of decorin protein secreted by hevin-null dermal fibroblasts were increased by exogenous hevin in vitro, data indicating that hevin might regulate both decorin and collagen fibrillogenesis. We also report a decorin-independent function for hevin in collagen fibrillogenesis. In vitro fibrillogenesis assays indicated that hevin enhanced fibril formation kinetics. Furthermore, cell adhesion assays indicated that cells adhered differently to collagen fibrils formed in the presence of hevin. Our observations support the capacity of hevin to modulate the structure of dermal extracellular matrix, specifically by its regulation of decorin levels and collagen fibril assembly.     

The glycosaminoglycan chain of decorin plays an important role in collagen fibril formation at the early stages of fibrillogenesis

Decorin is a multifunctional small leucine-rich proteoglycan involved in the regulation of collagen fibrillogenesis. In patients with a variant of Ehlers-Danlos syndrome, about half of the secreted decorin lacks the single glycosaminoglycan side chain. Notably, these patients have a skin-fragility phenotype that resembles that of decorin null mice. In this study, we investigated the role of glycanated and unglycanated decorin on collagen fibrillogenesis. Glycosaminoglycan-free decorin, generated by mutating Ser4 of the mature protein core into Ala (DCN-S4A), showed reduced inhibition of fibrillogenesis compared with the decorin proteoglycan. Interestingly, using a 3D matrix generated by decorin-null fibroblasts, an increase in fibril diameter was found after the addition of decorin, and even greater effects were observed with DCN-S4A. To avoid potential side effects of artificial tags, adenoviruses containing decorin and DCN-S4A were used to transduce decorin-null fibroblasts prior to matrix formation. Both molecules were efficiently incorporated into the matrix, with no changes in collagen composition and network formation, or altered expression of the related proteoglycan biglycan. Both decorin and DCN-S4A mutants increased the collagen fibril diameter, with the latter showing the most prominent effects. These data show that at early stages of fibrillogenesis, the glycosaminoglycan chain of decorin has a reducing effect on collagen fibril diameter.     

Differential interactions of decorin and decorin mutants with type I and type VI collagens.

The small leucine-rich proteoglycan decorin can bind via its core protein to different types of collagens such as type I and type VI. To test whether decorin can act as a bridging molecule between these collagens, the binding properties of wild-type decorin, two full-length decorin species with single amino acid substitutions (DCN E180K, DCN E180Q), which previously showed reduced binding to collagen type I fibrils, and a truncated form of decorin (DCN Q153) to the these collagens were investigated. In a solid phase assay dissociation constants for wild-type decorin bound to methylated, therefore monomeric, triple helical type I collagen were in the order of 10(-10) m, while dissociation constants for fibrillar type I collagen were approximately 10(-9) m. The dissociation constant for type VI was approximately 10(-7) m. Using real-time analysis for a more detailed investigation DCN E180Q and DCN E180K exhibited lower association and higher dissociation constants to type I collagen, compared to wild-type decorin, deviating by at least one order of magnitude. In contrast, the affinities of these mutants to type VI collagen were 10 times higher than the affinity of wild-type decorin (K(D) approximately 10(-8) m). Further investigations verified that complexes of type VI collagen and decorin bound type I collagen and that the affinity of collagen type VI to type I was increased by the presence of decorin. These data show that decorin not only can regulate collagen fibril formation but that it also can act as an intermediary between type I and type VI collagen and that these two types of collagen interact via different binding sites.     

Thermal Memory in Self-Assembled Collagen Fibril Networks

Collagen fibrils form extracellular networks that regulate cell functions and provide mechanical strength to tissues. Collagen fibrillogenesis is an entropy-driven process promoted by warming and reversed by cooling. Here, we investigate the influence of noncovalent interactions mediated by the collagen triple helix on fibril stability. We measure the kinetics of cold-induced disassembly of fibrils formed from purified collagen I using turbimetry, probe the fibril morphology by atomic force microscopy, and measure the network connectivity by confocal microscopy and rheometry. We demonstrate that collagen fibrils disassemble by subunit release from their sides as well as their ends, with complex kinetics involving an initial fast release followed by a slow release. Surprisingly, the fibrils are gradually stabilized over time, leading to thermal memory. This dynamic stabilization may reflect structural plasticity of the collagen fibrils arising from their complex structure. In addition, we propose that the polymeric nature of collagen monomers may lead to slow kinetics of subunit desorption from the fibril surface. Dynamic stabilization of fibrils may be relevant in the initial stages of collagen assembly during embryogenesis, fibrosis, and wound healing. Moreover, our results are relevant for tissue repair and drug delivery applications, where it is crucial to control fibril stability.     

Collagen type I and type V are present in the same fibril in the avian corneal stroma

The distribution, supramolecular form, and arrangement of collagen types I and V in the chicken embryo corneal stroma were studied using electron microscopy, collagen type-specific monoclonal antibodies, and a preembedding immunogold method. Double-label immunoelectron microscopy with colloidal gold-tagged monoclonal antibodies was used to simultaneously localize collagen type I and type V within the chick corneal stroma. The results definitively demonstrate, for the first time, that both collagens are codistributed within the same fibril. Type I collagen was localized to striated fibrils throughout the corneal stroma homogeneously. Type V collagen could be localized only after pretreatment of the tissue to partially disrupt collagen fibril structure. After such pretreatments the type V collagen was found in regions where fibrils were partially dissociated and not in regions where fibril structure was intact. When pretreated tissues were double labeled with antibodies against types I and V collagen coupled to different size gold particles, the two collagens colocalized in areas where fibril structure was partially disrupted. Antibodies against type IV collagen were used as a control and were nonreactive with fibrils. These results indicate that collagen types I and V are assembled together within single fibrils in the corneal stroma such that the interaction of these collagen types within heterotypic fibrils masks the epitopes on the type V collagen molecule. One consequence of the formation of such heterotypic fibrils may be the regulation of corneal fibril diameter, a condition essential for corneal transparency.     

Collagen phagocytosis by fibroblasts is regulated by decorin

Decorin is a small, leucine-rich proteoglycan that binds to collagen and regulates fibrillogenesis. We hypothesized that decorin binding to collagen inhibits phagocytosis of collagen fibrils. To determine the effects of decorin on collagen degradation, we analyzed phagocytosis of collagen and collagen/decorin-coated fluorescent beads by Rat-2 and gingival fibroblasts. Collagen beads bound to gingival cells by alpha2beta1 integrins. Binding and internalization of decorin/collagen-coated beads decreased dose-dependently with increasing decorin concentration (p < 0.001). Inhibition of binding was sustained over 5 h (p < 0.001) and was attributed to interactions between decorin and collagen and not to decorin-collagen receptor interactions. Both the non-glycosylated decorin core protein and the thermally denatured decorin significantly inhibited collagen bead binding (approximately 50 and 89%, respectively; p < 0.05). Mimetic peptides corresponding to leucine-rich repeats 1-3, encompassed by a collagen-binding approximately 11-kDa cyanogen bromide fragment of decorin and leucine-rich repeats 4 and 5, previously shown to bind to collagen, were tested for their ability to inhibit collagen bead binding. Although the synthetic peptide 3 alone exhibited saturable binding to collagen, neither peptides 3 nor 1 and 2 markedly inhibited phagocytosis. Leucine-rich repeat 3 bound to a triple helical peptide containing the alpha2 integrin-binding site of collagen. When collagen beads were co-incubated with peptides 3 and 4, inhibition of collagen phagocytosis (55%) was equivalent to intact native/recombinant core protein. Thus a novel collagen binding domain in decorin acts cooperatively with leucine-rich repeat 4 to mask the alpha2beta1 integrin-binding site on collagen, an important sequence for the phagocytosis of collagen fibrils.     

Advanced Glycation End-Products Reduce Collagen Molecular Sliding to Affect Collagen Fibril Damage Mechanisms but Not Stiffness

Advanced glycation end-products (AGE) contribute to age-related connective tissue damage and functional deficit. The documented association between AGE formation on collagens and the correlated progressive stiffening of tissues has widely been presumed causative, despite the lack of mechanistic understanding. The present study investigates precisely how AGEs affect mechanical function of the collagen fibril – the supramolecular functional load-bearing unit within most tissues. We employed synchrotron small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) and carefully controlled mechanical testing after introducing AGEs in explants of rat-tail tendon using the metabolite methylglyoxal (MGO). Mass spectrometry and collagen fluorescence verified substantial formation of AGEs by the treatment. Associated mechanical changes of the tissue (increased stiffness and failure strength, decreased stress relaxation) were consistent with reports from the literature. SAXS analysis revealed clear changes in molecular deformation within MGO treated fibrils. Underlying the associated increase in tissue strength, we infer from the data that MGO modified collagen fibrils supported higher loads to failure by maintaining an intact quarter-staggered conformation to nearly twice the level of fibril strain in controls. This apparent increase in fibril failure resistance was characterized by reduced side-by-side sliding of collagen molecules within fibrils, reflecting lateral molecular interconnectivity by AGEs. Surprisingly, no change in maximum fibril modulus (2.5 GPa) accompanied the changes in fibril failure behavior, strongly contradicting the widespread assumption that tissue stiffening in ageing and diabetes is directly related to AGE increased fibril stiffness. We conclude that AGEs can alter physiologically relevant failure behavior of collagen fibrils, but that tissue level changes in stiffness likely occur at higher levels of tissue architecture.     

Fibrillogenesis of collagen types I, II, and III with small leucine-rich proteoglycans decorin and biglycan

Collagen has found use as a scaffold material for tissue engineering as well as a coating material for implants with a view to enhancing osseointegration through mimicry of the bone extracellular matrix in vivo. The aim of this study was to compare the collagen types I, II, and III with regard to their ability to bind the small leucine-rich proteoglycans (SLRPs) decorin and biglycan during fibrillogenesis in vitro in phosphate buffer. In addition, the influence of SLRPs on the proportion of collagen molecules incorporated into fibrils during fibrillogenesis in vitro at high and low ionic strength was investigated, as were their effects on the morphology of collagen fibrils and the speed of fibrillogenesis. Considerably more biglycan than decorin was bound by all three collagen types. Collagen II bound significantly more SLRPs in fibrils than collagen I and III. Decorin and biglycan decreased the proportion of collagen molecules of all three collagen types incorporated into fibrils in similar fashion. Biglycan affected neither fibril diameter nor the speed of fibrillogenesis. Decorin reduced the fibril diameter of all three collagen types. The differences in SLRP-binding ability between collagen types could be of significance when selecting collagen type and/or SLRPs as scaffold materials for tissue engineering or implant coatings.     

SLRP interaction can protect collagen fibrils from cleavage by collagenases

Decorin, fibromodulin and lumican are small leucine-rich repeat proteoglycans (SLRPs) which interact with the surface of collagen fibrils. Together with other molecules they form a coat on the fibril surface which could impede the access to collagenolytic proteinases. To address this hypothesis, fibrils of type I or type II collagen were formed in vitro and treated with either collagenase-1 (MMP1) or collagenase-3 (MMP13). The fibrils were either treated directly or following incubation in the presence of the recombinant SLRPs. The susceptibility of the uncoated and SLRP-coated fibrils to collagenase cleavage was assessed by SDS/PAGE. Interaction with either recombinant decorin, fibromodulin or lumican results in decreased collagenase cleavage of both fibril types. Thus SLRP interaction can help protect collagen fibrils from cleavage by collagenases.     

The mechanism of amyloid spherulite formation by bovine insulin

The formation of amyloid-containing spherulite-like structures has been observed in some instances of amyloid diseases, as well as in amyloid fibril-containing solutions in vitro. In this article we describe the structure and kinetics of bovine insulin amyloid fibril spherulites formed in the presence and absence of different salts and at different salt concentrations. The general spherulite structure consists of radially oriented amyloid fibrils, as shown by optical microscopy and environmental scanning electron microscopy. In the center of each spherulite, a "core" of less regularly oriented material is observed, whose size decreases when the spherulites are formed in the presence of increasing concentrations of NaCl. Similarly, amyloid fibrils form faster in the presence of NaCl than in its absence. A smaller enhancement of the rate of formation with salt concentration is observed for spherulites. These data suggest that both amyloid fibril formation and random aggregation occur concurrently under the conditions tested. Changes in their relative rates result in the different-sized cores observed in the spherulites. This mechanism can be likened to that leading to the formation of spherulites of polyethylene, in agreement with observations that polypeptide chains under partially denaturing conditions can exhibit behavior not dissimilar to that of synthetic polymers.     

The C-terminal extrahelical peptide of type I collagen and its role in fibrillogenesis in vitro

The formation in vitro of fibrils from type I acid-soluble calf skin collagen has been studied before and after removal of the extrahelical peptides with carboxypeptidase and with pepsin. Turbidimetric studies show that the mechanism of fibril growth in undigested collagen is similar to that in pepsin-digested collagen; following carboxypeptidase digestion, however, a different growth mechanism was apparent. The two mechanisms have been further characterized by electron microscopy. In the course of formation of fibrils from undigested collagen, “early fibrils” (short D-periodic fibrils that have both ends visible) occurred in the lag phase under the precipitating conditions employed here. After pepsin or carboxypeptidase digestion of the collagen no “early fibrils” were seen. In carboxypeptidase-digested collagen, lateral assembly was inhibited; after pepsin digestion, linear assembly was inhibited. Complete removal of the extrahelical peptides prevented fibril formation under the conditions used here. Electron-optical examination of segment-long-spacing (SLS) dimers established a more complete removal of the C-terminal peptide after carboxypeptidase digestion than after pepsin digestion. Analyses of staining patterns of SLS dimers and fibrils from undigested and digested samples showed that the C-terminal peptide in SLS crystallites and fibrils formed from undigested collagen is in a condensed conformation. A proposed conformation, in which condensation occurs predominantly in a hydrophobic region at the proximal end of the C-terminal peptide, is discussed in terms of a dual role for the C-terminal peptide in fibrillogenesis. One role, shared with the N-terminal peptide, is to participate in interactions between the 4D-staggered molecules leading to the formation of linear aggregates; the other is to participate in interactions between these linear aggregates giving rise to D-periodic aggregates and lateral (as well as linear) growth.     

Structural investigations on native collagen type I fibrils using AFM

This study was carried out to determine the elastic properties of single collagen type I fibrils with the use of atomic force microscopy (AFM). Native collagen fibrils were formed by self-assembly in vitro characterized with the AFM. To confirm the inner assembly of the collagen fibrils, the AFM was used as a microdissection tool. Native collagen type I fibrils were dissected and the inner core uncovered. To determine the elastic properties of collagen fibrils the tip of the AFM was used as a nanoindentor by recording force-displacement curves. Measurements were done on the outer shell and in the core of the fibril. The structural investigations revealed the banding of the shell also in the core of native collagen fibrils. Nanoindentation experiments showed the same Young's modulus on the shell as well as in the core of the investigated native collagen fibrils. In addition, the measurements indicate a higher adhesion in the core of the collagen fibrils compared to the shell.     

Ultrastructure of irregular collagen fibrils of shark mandible

Sawada T. and Inoue S. 2011. Ultrastructure of irregular collagen fibrils of shark mandible. —Acta Zoologica (Stockholm) 92 : 62–66. Collagen fibrillogenesis was investigated in developing fibrous connective tissue (tooth band) in shark mandible by transmission electron microscopy. Fibrils varied considerably in shape and size. Both thin and thick fibrils 40–200 and 400–500 nm in width, respectively, were observed, with the latter showing irregular contours. Examination of both transverse and longitudinal sections of fibril suggested that the irregular, thick fibrils were formed by fusion of the thin fibrils. This was in agreement with a previously proposed mechanism of collagen fibrillogenesis in a variety of tissues, in which formation of thin fibrils is followed by their coalescence into thicker fibrils. Detailed high resolution ultrastructural examination revealed decorin‐like, 4.5‐ to 5.5‐nm‐wide polygonal frames and 3‐nm‐wide ribbon‐like structures previously identified as chondroitin sulfate proteoglycan ‘double tracks’ localized within the interfibrillar spaces. These structures may be closely involved in collagen fibrillogenesis.