Effects of Cations on Hormone Transport in Primary Roots of Zea mays

We examined the influence of aluminum and calcium (and certain other cations) on hormone transport in corn roots. When aluminum was applied unilaterally to the caps of 15 mm apical root sections the roots curved strongly away from the aluminum. When aluminum was applied unilaterally to the cap and ³H-indole-3-acetic acid was applied to the basal cut surface twice as much radioactivity (assumed to be IAA) accumulated on the concave side of the curved root as on the convex side. Auxin transport in the apical region of intact roots was preferentially basipetal, with a polarity (basipetal transport divided by acropetal transport) of 6.3. In decapped 5 mm apical root segments, auxin transport was acropetally polar (polarity = 0.63). Application of aluminum to the root cap strongly promoted acropetal transport of auxin reducing polarity from 6.3 to 2.1. Application of calcium to the root cap enhanced basipetal movement of auxin, increasing polarity from 6.3 to 7.6. Application of the calcium chelator, ethylene-glycol-bis-(β-aminoethylether)-N,N,N′, N′-tetraacetic acid, greatly decreased basipetal auxin movement, reducing polarity from 6.3 to 3.7. Transport of label after application of tritiated abscisic acid showed no polarity and was not affected by calcium or aluminum. The results indicate that the root cap is particularly important in maintaining basipetal polarity of auxin transport in primary roots of corn. The induction of root curvature by unilateral application of aluminum or calcium to root caps is likely to result from localized effects of these ions on auxin transport. The findings are discussed relative to the possible role of calcium redistribution in the gravitropic curvature of roots and the possibility of calmodulin involvement in the action of calcium and aluminum on auxin transport.     

Movement and Endogenous Levels of Abscisic Acid during Water-Stress-induced Abscission in Cotton Seedlings

In an effort to investigate possible involvement of abscisic acid (ABA) in foliar abscission processes, its movement and endogenous levels were examined in cotyledons taken from cotton seedlings (Gossypium hirsutum L.) subjected to varying degrees of water deficit, a condition which initiates leaf abscission. Using a pulse-labeling technique to avoid complications of uptake and exit from the tissue, ABA-1-¹⁴C movement was observed in both basipetal and acropetal directions in cotyledonary petioles taken from well watered, stressed, and rewatered plants. The label distribution patterns obtained after 1 and 3 hours of transport under all situations of water supply were diffusive in nature and did not change when tested under anaerobic conditions. The transport capacity of the petioles ranged from 3.6 to 14.4% ABA-1-¹⁴C transported per hour at estimated velocities of 0 to 2 millimeters per hour. Comparison of basipetal and acropetal movement indicated a lack of polarity under all conditions tested. These low transport capacities and slow velocities of movement, when compared to the active transport systems associated with auxin movement, as well as the lack of anaerobic effects and polarity, suggest that ABA movement in cotton cotyledonary petiole sections is facilitated by passive diffusion. Increases in free and bound ABA in the lamina with increased water stress did not correlate with patterns of cotyledonary abscission. Thus, no evidence was found to suggest that ABA is directly involved in stress-induced abscission processes.     

Adventitious rooting in hypocotyls of sunflower (Helianthus annuus) seedlings. IV. The role of changes in endogenous free and conjugated indole‐3‐acetic acid

We have studied the role of endogenous auxin on adventitious rooting in hypocotyls of derooted sunflower (Helianthus annuus L. var. Dahlgren 131) seedlings. Endogenous free and conjugated indole-3-acetic acid (IAA) were measured in three segments of hypocotyls of equal length (apical, middle, basal) by using gas chromatography-mass spectrometry with [¹³C₆]-IAA as an internal standard. At the time original roots were excised (0 h), the free IAA level in the hypocotyls showed an acropetally decreasing gradient, but conjugated IAA level increased acropetally; i.e. free to total IAA ratio was highest in the basal portion of hypocotyls. The basal portion is the region where most of root primordia were found. Some primordia were seen in this region within 24 h after the roots were excised. The quantity of free IAA in the middle portion of the hypocotyl increased up to 15 h after excision and then decreased. In this middle region there were fewer root primordia, and they could not be seen until 72 h. In the apical portion the amount of free IAA steadily increased and no root primordia were seen by 72 h. Surgical removal of various parts of the hypocotyl tissues caused adventitious root formation in the hypocotyl regions where basipetally transported IAA could accumulate. Reduction in the basipetal flow of auxin by N-1-naphthylphthalamic acid and 2,3,5-tri-iodobenzoic acid resulted in fewer adventitious roots. The fewest root primordia were seen if the major sources of endogenous auxin were removed by decapitation of the cotyledons and apical bud. Exogenous auxins promoted rooting and were able to completely overcome the inhibitory effect of 2,3,5-tri-iodobenzoic acid. Exogenous auxins were only partially able to overcome the inhibitory effect of decapitation. We conclude that in sunflower hypocotyls endogenously produced auxin is necessary for adventitious root formation. The higher concentrations of auxin in the basal portion may be partially responsible for that portion of the hypocotyl producing the greatest number of primordia. In addition to auxins, other factors such as wound ethylene and lowered cytokinin levels caused by excision of the original root system cuttings must also be important.     

THE MOVEMENT OF IAA-C14 IN THE HYPOCOTYL OF PHASEOLUS VULGARIS

The amount of IAA-C¹⁴ transported basipetally through excised hypocotyl sections was strongly affected by the pH of the donor blocks, less so by the pH of the receivers. The effect of donor pH was mostly on uptake. The small amount of acropetal movement was not noticeably affected by pH. Sucrose added to the donor resulted in increased basipetal transport. The time-course of C¹⁴ movement into basal receivers followed a linear course from 1.5 to 3 hr as expected, but there was no net loss from the donors until after 30-45 min. The usual type of velocity calculation, which assumes uptake starting from zero time, would therefore be lower than the true value. Basipetal transport through segments cut from various positions in the hypocotyl and from seedlings of various ages was maximal in 6-8-day-old hypocotyl segments cut 25-30 mm below the cotyledons. Acropetal movement was minimal at all positions of all ages tested.     

Influence of 2,3,5-Triiodobenzoic Acid and 1-N-Naphthylphthalamic Acid on Indoleacetic Acid Transport in Carnation Cuttings: Relationship with Rooting

³H-IAA transport in excised sections of carnation cuttings was studied by using two receiver systems for recovery of transported radioactivity: agar blocks (A) and wells containing a buffer solution (B). When receivers were periodically renewed, transport continued for up to 8 h and ceased before 24 h. If receivers were not renewed, IAA transport decreased drastically due to immobilization in the base of the sections. TIBA was as effective as NPA in inhibiting the basipetal transport irrespective of the application site (the basal or the apical side of sections). The polarity of IAA transport was determined by measuring the polar ratio (basipetal/acropetal) and the inhibition caused by TIBA or NPA. The polar ratio varied with receiver, whereas the inhibition by TIBA or NPA was similar. Distribution of immobilized radioactivity along the sections after a transport period of 24 h showed that the application of TIBA to the apical side or NPA to the basal side of sections, increased the radioactivity in zones further from the application site, which agrees with a basipetal and acropetal movement of TIBA and NPA, respectively. The existence of a slow acropetal movement of the inhibitor was confirmed by using ³H-NPA. From the results obtained, a methodological approach is proposed to measure the variations in polar auxin transport. This method was used to investigate whether the variations in rooting observed during the cold storage of cuttings might be related to changes in polar auxin transport. As the storage period increased, a decrease in intensity and polarity of auxin transport occurred, which was accompanied by a delay in the formation and growth of adventitious roots, confirming the involvement of polar auxin transport in supplying the auxin for rooting. Received April 19, 1999; accepted December 2, 1999     

Polar transport and accumulation of indole-3-acetic acid during root regeneration by Pinus lambertiana embryos

Summary The relation of indoleacetic acid (IAA) transport to accumulation of auxin at the base of cuttings and to polar root formation was investigated with small cuttings from germinating embryos of Pinus lambertiana.The transport of endogenous auxin participates in regeneration of roots. This is shown by the facts that (1) more than 40% of the cuttings rooted without addition of exogenous indoleacetic acid; (2) the first regeneration always occurred at the basal tip of a slanting cut; and (3) 2,3,5-triiodobenzoic acid (TIBA), a specific inhibitor of auxin transport, totally inhibited rooting. Addition of IAA to the medium increased the number of roots formed per rooting hypocotyl.Sections of hypocotyls excised from dormant embryos and tested immediately after 2 h hydration were capable of polar transport of IAA. This polarity increased during the first 3 days of culture because of a marked increase in basipetal transport. Culturing the cuttings in 1 M IAA for 3–5 days doubled both the basipetal transport of 1-¹⁴C-IAA by hypocotyl segments and the accumulation of radioactivity at the base of cuttings.The extent of the accumulation at the base of cuttings was similar at early (2 days, first mitoses) and late stages (5 days, organized meristem) of regeneration and was not affected by removal of the regenerating region immediately prior to uptake and transport of ¹⁴C-IAA. The accumulation was inhibited by TIBA. In terms of increase in wet and dry weight and mitotic activity, the cotyledons rather than the regenerating root meristems were the most actively growing region of the cuttings. The upper part of the hypocotyl elongated more than the region of the slanting cut where regeneration was occurring.These results provide no support for the idea that the regenerating root controls the direction of polar transport by acting as a sink. The results are consistent with the view that polar auxin transport delivers auxin to the base of the cutting and raises the local concentration to levels sufficient to promote root formation.     

Polar Movement of Indole-3-acetic Acid-C in Roots of Lens and Phaseolus

A critical review of the few papers on IAA-¹⁴C movement in roots revealed apparent contradictions, as well as flaws in experimental design that would be apt to cause artifacts. The movement of ¹⁴C from IAA-¹⁴C was studied in sections of Lens and Phaseolus roots, using a system 20 or more times as sensitive as any previously used. To make sure that our results with roots could be compared validly with published work on petioles and stems, we used the same techniques as we had earlier used for shoot structures. The results with Lens were similar in many ways to those for shoots: net movement into receiver blocks was very strongly polar, followed a linear course for several hours, and showed a velocity of the same order of magnitude as in shoots (and, in fact, very close in absolute value to that found in Coleus stem cylinders). Also, as with shoots, all the radioactivity in receiver blocks ran to the R_F of IAA. The time-course of loss of counts from donor blocks was similar to that found in shoots. The 2 most striking differences from shoots were 1) the very low percentage of added ¹⁴C that was moved into the receivers (about one-tenth of the values for bean petioles), and 2) the fact that the polar movement was acropetal in roots, rather than basipetal as in shoots. Results with Phaseolus roots were similar to those for Lens, although an additional complication with Phaseolus roots was the indication of a transitory stage of weak basipetal polarity in the first few hours after excising the section. This stage was followed in a few hours by a stronger acropetal polarity.     

Effect of Inversion on Growth and Movement of Indole-3-acetic Acid in Coleoptiles

The effect of a 180° displacement from the normal vertical orientation on longitudinal growth and on the acropetal and basipetal movement of ¹⁴C-IAA was investigated in Avena sativa L. and Zea mays L. coleoptile sections. Inversion inhibits growth in intact sections (apex not removed) and in decapitated sections supplied apically with donor blocks containing auxin. Under aerobic conditions, inversion inhibits basipetal auxin movement and promotes acropetal auxin movement, whereas under anaerobic conditions, it does not influence the movement of auxin in either direction. Inversion retards the basipetal movement of the peak of a 30-minute pulse of auxin in corn.

The inversion-induced inhibition of basipetal auxin movement is not explained by an effect of gravity on production, uptake, destruction, exit from sections, retention in tissue, or purely physical movement of auxin. It is concluded that inversion (a) inhibits basipetal transport, the component of auxin movement that is metabolically dependent, and as a result (b) inhibits growth and (c) promotes acropetal auxin movement.

     

Does the Induction of Flowering by Photoperiod Change the Polarity or Other Characteristics of Indole-3-acetic Acid Transport in Petioles for the Short Day Plant,Xanthium?

To test the hypothesis that photoinduction acts by changing the ability of the plant to transport hormones, rather than by changing the ability of organs to synthesize them, the transport of carboxy-labeled indole-3-acetic acid was measured in the short day plant Xanthium pensylvanicum. Plants grown under noninductive conditions were matched for developmental stage, then assigned by a mathematically random method to either short day or noninductive conditions of “short day + light break.” After the plants had been subjected to one to seven cycles, the movement of auxin was followed through sections cut from the middle of petioles of various ages. Photoinduction, even with as many as seven cycles, had no effect on auxin movement in either the basipetal or acropetal direction. Auxin movement in vegetative Xanthium was similar to that in Coleus and Phaseolus: strongly polar in a basipetal direction through younger petioles, but with polarity declining with increasing petiole age and concomitant decreasing elongation.     

Morphogenesis in Selaginella: II. Auxin Transport in the Root (Rhizophore)

The rhizophore of Selaginella willdenovii Baker develops from the ventral angle meristem. The morphological nature of this organ has been in dispute. The purpose of this investigation was to obtain physiological evidence to support the contention that the rhizophore is a root and not a shoot. This was accomplished by studying the movement of ³H-indoleacetic acid and ¹⁴C-indoleacetic acid in Selaginella rhizophores. In 6-millimeter tissue segments, twice as much radioactivity accumulated in acropetal receivers as in basipetal. During 1 hour of transport in intact roots auxin traveled twice as far in the acropetal direction as basipetal. A significant amount of radioactivity transported in the tissue was found to co-chromatograph with cold indoleacetic acid. Decarboxylation accounted for 10% loss of activity from donors. The data provide sufficient physiological evidence that this organ is morphogenetically a root.     

The transport of indole-3-acetic Acid in boron- and calcium-deficient sunflower hypocotyl segments

Transfer of sunflower (Helianthus annuus L. cv Russian Mammoth) seedlings from complete nutrient solution to solutions deficient in either boron or calcium resulted in a steady decline in the rate of auxin transport, compared to seedlings that remained in the complete solution. In seedlings transferred to solutions deficient in both B and Ca, the decline in auxin transport was greater than seedlings deficient in only one element. The transfer of B- or Ca-deficient seedlings back to the complete solution prevented further decline in auxin transport, but auxin transport did not increase to the same level as seedlings maintained in complete solution. The significant reduction in auxin transport during the early stages of B or Ca deficiency was not related to (a) reduced growth rate of the hypocotyl, (b) increased acropetal movement of auxin, or (c) lack of respiratory substrates in the hypocotyl. In addition, no difference was found in the water-extractable total and ionic Ca in B-deficient and control nondeficient hypocotyls, indicating a direct effect of B on auxin transport, rather than indirectly by affecting Ca absorption. The rate of auxin transport in hypocotyls deficient in either B or Ca, was inversely correlated with K⁺ leakage and rate of respiration. The data presented strongly support the view that there are separate sites for B and Ca in the basipetal transport of the plant hormone indoleacetic acid.     

Maintenance of polarity of auxin movement by basipetal transport

The polar, basipetal transport of indoleacetic acid helps to maintain polarity of auxin movement in coleoptiles of Avena sativa L. by opposing acropetal diffusion. This conclusion is supported by 3 different kinds of experiments. In all 3 experiments, sections took up ¹⁴C carboxyl-labeled indole-3-acetic acid anaerobically, and the distribution of auxin within all sections was similar at the end of uptake.

[List: see text]

     

Effects of hypergravity on the elongation growth in radish and cucumber hypocotyls

The elongation growth of the hypocotyls of radish and cucumber seedlings was examined under hypergravity in a newly developed centrifuge (Kasaharaet al. 1995). The effects of hypergravity on elongation growth differed between the two species. The rate of elongation of radish hypocotyls was reduced under basipetal hypergravity (H+20g) but not under acropetal hypergravity (H-13g), as compared to growth under the control conditions (C+1g and C-1g). In cucumber hypocotyls, elongation growth was inhibited not only by basipetal but also by acropetal hypergravity. Under these conditions, the reduction in the elongation growth of both radish and cucumber hypocotyls was accompanied by an increase in their thickness. Although no distinct differences in relative composition of neutral sugars were found, the amounts of cell-wall components (pectic substances, hemicelluloses and cellulose) per unit length of hypocotyls were increased by exposure to hypergravity.     

Basipetally polarised transport of [3H]gibberellin A1 and [14C]gibberellin A3, and acropetal polarity of [14C]indole-3-acetic acid transport,in stelar tissues of Phaseolus coccineus roots

Summary Movement of both [³H]GA₁ and [¹⁴C]GA₃ through root segments from P. coccineus seedlings was basipetally polarised. The basipetal/acropetal ratio of radioactivity from [³H]GA₁ in agar receiver blocks was 9.2 for apical, elongating segments, and 4.0 for more basal, non-elongating segments. Polarity of gibberellin transport was restricted to the stele, and absent from cortical tissues. Transport of [¹⁴C]IAA through root segments to agar receivers was preferentially acropetal, particularly so in the stele. Despite the existence of basipetal polarity of gibberellin transport in the root, [³H]GA₁ injected into cotyledons moved into and acropetally along the seedling root.     

Auxin Transport as Related to Leaf Abscission during Water Stress in Cotton

Plant water deficits reduced the basipetal transport of auxin in cotyledonary petiole sections taken from cotton (Gossypium hirsutum L.) seedings. A pulse-labeling technique was employed to eliminate complications of uptake or exit of ¹⁴C-indoleacetic acid from the tissue. The transport capacity or the relative amount of radioactivity in a 30-minute pulse which was basipetally translocated was approximately 30% per hour in petioles excised from well watered seedlings (plant water potentials of approximately -4 to -8 bars). No cotyledonary leaf abscission took place in well watered seedlings. Plant water potentials from -8 to -12 bars reduced the transport capacity from 30 to 15% per hour, and although the leaves were wilted, cotyledonary abscission did not increase appreciably at these levels of stress. The threshold water potential sufficient to induce leaf abscission was approximately -13 bars and abscission increased with increasing stress while the auxin transport capacity of the petioles remained relatively constant (15% per hour). The basipetal transport capacity of well watered petioles tested under anaerobic conditions and acropetal transport tested under all conditions were typically less than basipetal transport under the most severe stress conditions. Cotyledonary abscission took place during and 24 hours after relief of stress with little or no abscission taking place 48 hours after relief of stress. Although the water potential returned to -4 bars within hours after rewatering the stressed plants, partial recovery of the basipetal transport capacity of the petioles was not apparent until 48 hours after rewatering, and at least 72 hours was required to return the transport capacity to near normal values. These data support the view that decreased levels of auxin reaching the abscission zone from the leaf blade influence the abscission process and further suggest that the length of time that the auxin supply is maximally reduced is more critical than the degree of reduction.     

Movement of Indoleacetic Acid in Coleoptiles of Avena sativa L. II. Suspension of Polarity by Total Inhibition of the Basipetal Transport

Acropetal and basipetal movement of indole-3-acetic acid through coleoptiles of Avena sativa L. was studied. Sections 10-mm long were supplied with either apical or basal sources containing C(14) carboxyl-labeled indoleacetic acid (10(-5)m). Anaerobic conditions inhibit metabolically dependent movement (transport) thus reducing basipetal but not acropetal movement. Total inhibition of basipetal transport abolishes the polarity of auxin uptake and movement. The nonpolar movement that remains in anaerobic sections is free diffusion with an average diffusion coefficient of approximately 1 x 10(-4) mm(2) per second. During an 8-hour diffusion, at least the first millimeter of the section comes to equilibrium at approximately the same concentration as the donor.Acropetal movement is probably by diffusion and is accompanied by an aerobic immobilization of indoleacetic acid that increases more than proportionally to concentration. Anaerobic conditions totally prevent this immobilization and reduce acropetal uptake but not the amount of indoleacetic acid moving into the upper parts of the section; there is, therefore, no evidence for acropetal transport.Polarity of auxin movement in aerobic coleoptile sections is achieved by strict basipetal transport of auxin. The basipetal transport may intensify the polarity by recycling auxin that is moving acropetally.     

THE TIME-COURSE OF POLAR MOVEMENT OF GIBBERELLIN THROUGH ZEA ROOTS

The polarity of movement of gibberellin through sections cut from near the root tips of Zea mays L. was studied, using methods like those we previously used in roots for auxin and in petioles for auxins, cytokinins, and gibberellic acid (GA-3). One μg GA-3 was added in a donor agar block and gibberellin activity in the receiver agar at the opposite end of the section was measured directly with a modified barley endosperm bioassay. The movement of gibberellin was away from the root tip (basipetal) and thus opposite in direction to the polarity of auxin through such root sections. The time-course of basipetal movement was dissimilar to that for gibberellin or auxin movement through petiole sections. It took 14-18 hr for gibberellin activity equivalent to 6 ng GA-3 to collect in the basal receivers on roots. Apical receivers showed activity equivalent to 1.6 ng GA-3 at 14-18 hr. Less than 0.01 ng equivalent GA-3 was collected from sections to which GA-3 was not added, so the 6 and 1.6 ng were almost entirely due to the added GA-3. These general conclusions were confirmed with an experiment using ¹⁴C-GA-3. A decline in activity in receivers was found in some experiments at 18 hr, paralleling earlier results with GA-3, IAA, and adenine in petioles and IAA in roots.     

Cobalt and plant development: interactions with ethylene in hypocotyl growth

Co²⁺ promoted elongation of hypocotyl segments of light-grown cucumber (Cucumis sativus) seedlings. Time course and dose response data are presented and interactions with IAA, gibberellin, cyclohexanol, and cotyledons described. Segments without cotyledons responded to Co²⁺ only if grown in gas-tight vessels with IAA added. When bases of cotyledons were ringed with an inhibitor of auxin transport, Co²⁺ caused no growth promotion in the hypocotyl. Co²⁺ prevented lateral swelling of hypocotyls treated with supraoptimal IAA. Removal of ethylene from the atmosphere reduced the Co²⁺ response, but Co²⁺ did not counteract the inhibitory effect of increased ethylene levels. These results are consistent with the hypothesis that Co²⁺ promotes hypocotyl elongation by inhibiting ethylene production. The hypothesis was confirmed by a direct demonstration that Co²⁺, at growth-promoting concentrations, powerfully inhibited ethylene production in the cucumber hypocotyl.     

Auxin Transport in Roots: V. EFFECTS OF TEMPERATURE ON THE MOVEMENT OF IAA IN ZEA ROOTS

The effects of temperature on the polar movement of IAA through6-mm and 12-mm segments of Zea mays roots have been investigatedover the range from 1 to 50°C. At all temperatures an acropetal polar movement of IAA predominated,although at low temperatures and at 50°C the 6-mm segmentsshowed a transient basipetal polarity, before the persistentacropetal polarity developed. At 1°C the differences betweenacropetal and basipetal movement of IAA were less distinct thanat the other temperatures. There is, however, a marked metabolically-dependentacropetal movement of IAA through the tissues at 1°C, becausewhen the segments were deprived of oxygen the acropetal movementwas severely reduced while the basipetal movement was reducedto a smaller extent. At 1°C and at 5°C there was alwaysa persistent basipetal polarity of IAA movement through 6-mmand 12-mm segments under anaerobic conditions. The velocity of acropetal movement (mm h^–1) was the samethrough the 6-mm and the 12-mm segments and was markedly affectedby temperature. It increased from 1°C to a maximum valueof 8 mm h^–1 at 31°C and then decreased again at 40and 50°C. The velocity of basipetal movement could be assessedonly at 1 and 5°C at which temperatures it was greater thanthe velocity of acropetal movement, and virtually independentof segment length. The acropetal flux of IAA (cpm h^–1) was much less through12-mm segments than through 6-mm segments. For both lengthsof segment, however, the flux showed a complex relationshipwith ambient temperature, increasing from 1°C to a maximumat 10–15°C, declining to a minimum value at 31°Cand then rising again at 40 and 50°C. The basipetal fluxof IAA could be astimated only at 1 and 5°C at which itwas very much smaller than the acropetal flux. The amount of IAA in the receiver blocks increased linearlywith time at the lower temperatures. At temperatures withinthe range 15°C to about 31°C, however, the amount ofIAA in the receiver blocks began to decline if the transportperiods exceeded a certain length. The time at which this declinein the IAA in the receiver block began was related to the ambienttemperature. Chromatographic analysis indicated one radioactive substancein receiver blocks at the apical end of segments supplied withIAA-1-¹⁴C at the basal end after transport periods of 6 h at25°C, and 72 h at 5°C. The Rf of this substance wasclosely similar to that of the radioactive IAA supplied in thedonor blocks.     

Polarity of Indoleacetic Acid in young Coleus Stems

Young internodes of Coleus blumei Benth. have long been known for their sizable amount of acropetal indoleacetic acid movement. However, plants of the same clone, under improved growing conditions, now show almost absolute basipetal polarity of ¹⁴C-indoleacetic acid, as measured by liquid scintillation counting of ¹⁴C in the receiver cylinders of agar. The ratio of basipetal to acropetal movement is now as much as 85:1, instead of the 3:1 ratio found years ago under conditions providing slower growth.