Molecular Characterization of Duplicate Cytosolic Phosphoglucose Isomerase Genes in Clarkia and Comparison to the Single Gene in Arabidopsis

The nucleotide sequence of PgiC1-a which encodes a cytosolic isozyme of phosphoglucose isomerase (PGIC; EC 5.3.1.9) in Clarkia lewisii, a wildflower native to California, is described and compared to the previously published sequence of the duplicate PgiC2-a from the same genome. Both genes have the same structure of 23 exons and 22 introns located in identical positions, and they encode proteins of 569 amino acids. Exon and inferred protein sequences of the two genes are 96.4% and 97.2% identical, respectively. Intron sequences are 88.2% identical. The high nucleotide similarity of the two genes is consistent with previous genetic and biosystematic findings that suggest the duplication arose within Clarkia. A partial sequence of PgiC2-b was also obtained. It is 99.5% identical to PgiC2-a in exons and 99.7% in introns. The nucleotide sequence of the single PgiC from Arabidopsis thaliana was also determined for comparison to the Clarkia genes. The A. thaliana PgiC has 21 introns located at positions identical to those in Clarkia PgiC1 and PgiC2, but lacks the intron that divides Clarkia exons 21 and 22. The A. thaliana PGIC protein is shorter, with 560 amino acids, and differs by about 17% from the Clarkia PGICs. The PgiC in A. thaliana was mapped to a site 20 cM from restriction fragment length polymorphism marker 331 on chromosome 5.     

DNA polymorphism at the cytosolic phosphoglucose isomerase (PgiC) locus of the wild plant Arabidopsis thaliana

DNA variation in a 4.7-kb region of the cytosolic phosphoglucose isomerase (PgiC) locus was investigated for 21 ecotypes of Arabidopsis thaliana. The estimated nucleotide diversity was 0.0038, which was one-third of those in previously investigated loci. Since most of the nucleotide variations (93%) were singleton and doubleton, Tajima's test statistic was significantly negative. About 50% of nucleotide polymorphisms in exons were replacement, which caused significance in McDonald and Kreitman's test when compared with Arabis gemmifera and Cardaminopsis petraea. These results indicated that DNA polymorphism at the PgiC locus was not under neutrality. There were two divergent sequence types in the PgiC region, which were associated with allozyme variation. The Fast allozyme was shown to have originated from the Slow allozyme, since two outgroup species had the Slow form. A phylogenetic tree of ecotypes with the Fast allozyme had the shape of a star phylogeny. Mismatch distribution of the Fast allozyme ecotypes resembled that expected under an expanding population model. These results suggest positive selection for the Fast allozyme of the PGIC in A. thaliana.     

Origin and timing of the horizontal transfer of a PgiC gene from Poa to Festuca ovina

A segregating second locus, PgiC2, for the enzyme phosphoglucose isomerase (PGIC) is found in the grass sheep's fescue, Festuca ovina. We have earlier reported that a phylogenetic analysis indicates that PgiC2 has been horizontally transferred from the reproductively separated grass genus Poa. Here we extend our analysis to include intron and exon information on 27 PgiC sequences from 18 species representing five genera, and confirm our earlier finding. The origin of PgiC2 can be traced to a group of closely interrelated, polyploid and partially asexual Poa species. The sequence most similar to PgiC2 is found in Poa palustris with a divergence, based on synonymous substitutions, of only 0.67%. This value suggests that the transfer took place less than 600,000 years ago (late Pleistocene), at a time when most extant Poa and Festuca species already existed.     

The introgression of a functional nuclear gene from Poa to Festuca ovina

In sheep's fescue, Festuca ovina, genes coding for the cytosolic enzyme phosphoglucose isomerase, PGIC, are not only found at the standard locus, PgiC1, but also at a segregating second locus, PgiC2. We have used PCR-based sequencing to characterize the molecular structure and evolution of five PgiC1 and three PgiC2 alleles in F. ovina. The three PgiC2 alleles were complex in that they carried two gene copies: either two active genes or one active and one pseudogene. All the PgiC2 sequences were very similar to each other but highly diverged from the five PgiC1 sequences. We also sequenced PgiC genes from several other grass species. Phylogenetic analysis of these sequences indicates that PgiC2 has introgressed into F. ovina from the distant genus Poa. Such an introgression may, for example, follow from a non-standard fertilization with more than one pollen grain, or a direct horizontal gene transfer mediated by a plant virus.     

Reassessment of phylogenetic relationships in Clarkia sect. Sympherica

Clarkia (Onagraceae) is a genus of 42 annual species, mostly native to California, that has served as a model for many studies of plant evolutionary biology, particularly morphological, cytological, and genetic divergence; reproductive isolation; and speciation. Section Sympherica is the largest section with eight diploid and one allotetraploid species. Species in the section have provided important evidence about the evolution of reproductive isolation (C. lingulata derived from C. biloba) and large morphological change (C. dudleyana thought to be sister to the morphologically distinct C. heterandra, recently transferred into Clarkia from the monotypic Heterogaura). Clarkia epilobioides, another diploid species in the section, was previously shown to be one parent of the allotetraploid C. delicata, the other parent being C. unguiculata from sect. Phaeostoma. Lewis and Lewis (1955) interpreted the parentage of C. delicata and other evidence of intersectional hybridization to mean that the diploid sections of the genus, though highly diverse, were closely related and should be maintained in the single genus Clarkia. Here we assess phylogenetic relationships among the species of sect. Sympherica and related species by analyzing the nucleotide sequences of PgiC1 and PgiC2, a pair of paralogous genes that encode the cytosolic isozyme of phosphoglucose isomerase (EC 5.3.1.9). The major results were the following: (1) C. unguiculata and both genomes of C. delicata are within a well-defined "Sympherica" clade; thus, C. delicata should not be considered an intersectional hybrid; (2) C. heterandra belongs in the clade and is closely related to C. unguiculata; and (3) on the evidence of PgiC1, C. dudleyana is not in the clade and is not closely related to C. heterandra.     

ELECTROPHORETIC EVIDENCE FOR GENETIC DIPLOIDY IN PSILOTUM NUDUM

Psilotum nudum (2n = 104) has been considered an ancient polyploid, having resulted from repeated cycles of hybridization and allopolyploidy. However, electrophoretic analysis indicates that this species is genetically diploid despite its high chromosome number. Sixteen enzymes, encoded by 28 loci, revealed in P. nudum the number of isozymes typical of diploid seed plants. There is, therefore, no evidence of polyploid gene expression for the enzymes analyzed. These results for Psilotophyta are similar to those obtained for other lineages of homosporous pteridophytes, i.e., Arthrophyta and homosporous Microphyllophyta and Pteridophyta, all of which should be considered genetically diploid. Several hypotheses have been proposed to explain these results, most notably 1) cycles of allopolyploidy followed by massive gene silencing, and 2) initiation of these lineages with high chromosome numbers, possibly via chromosomal fission. Discrimination between these hypotheses awaits testing with molecular genetic techniques.     

Evolutionary dynamics of the Pgk1 gene in the polyploid genus Kengyilia (Triticeae: Poaceae) and its diploid relatives

The level and pattern of nucleotide variation in duplicate gene provide important information on the evolutionary history of polyploids and divergent process between homoeologous loci within lineages. Kengyilia is a group of allohexaploid species with the StYP genomic constitutions in the wheat tribe. To investigate the evolutionary dynamics of the Pgk1 gene in Kengyilia and its diploid relatives, three copies of Pgk1 homoeologues were isolated from all sampled hexaploid Kengyilia species and analyzed with the Pgk1 sequences from 47 diploid taxa representing 18 basic genomes in Triticeae. Sequence diversity patterns and genealogical analysis suggested that (1) Kengyilia species from the Central Asia and the Qinghai-Tibetan plateau have independent origins with geographically differentiated P genome donors and diverged levels of nucleotide diversity at Pgk1 locus; (2) a relatively long-time sweep event has allowed the Pgk1 gene within Agropyron to adapt to cold climate triggered by the recent uplifts of the Qinghai-Tibetan Plateau; (3) sweep event and population expansion might result in the difference in the d(N)/d(S) value of the Pgk1 gene in allopatric Agropyron populations, and this difference may be genetically transmitted to Kengyilia lineages via independent polyploidization events; (4) an 83 bp MITE element insertion has shaped the Pgk1 loci in the P genome lineage with different geographical regions; (5) the St and P genomes in Kengyilia were donated by Pseudoroegneria and Agropyron, respectively, and the Y genome is closely related to the Xp genome of Peridictyon sanctum. The interplay of evolutionary forces involving diverged natural selection, population expansion, and transposable events in geographically differentiated P genome donors could attribute to geographical differentiation of Kengyilia species via independent origins.     

Patterns of nucleotide variation in homoeologous regulatory genes in the allotetraploid Hawaiian silversword alliance (Asteraceae)

Genome-wide duplication (polyploidization) is prevalent in a large number of eukaryotic organisms and is particularly widespread in flowering plants. Polyploid species appear to vary from their diploid progenitors in a variety of ecologically important traits, suggesting that genome duplications provide a mechanism for ecological diversification. Studies of nucleotide variation at duplicate genes that arise via polyploidization allow us to infer the evolutionary forces that act on these polyploid loci. In an effort to examine the evolutionary dynamics of homoeologous loci, molecular population genetic analyses were undertaken for duplicate regulatory genes in the allopolyploid Hawaiian silversword alliance, a premier example of adaptive radiation. The levels and patterns of nucleotide variation for the floral homeotic genes ASAPETALA1 (ASAP1) and ASAPETALA3/TM6 (ASAP3/TM6) were studied in two species representing different lineages within the Hawaiian silversword alliance: Argyroxiphium sandwicense ssp. macrocephalum and Dubautia ciliolata ssp. glutinosa. Homoeologueous copies of ASAP1 and ASAP3/TM6 show differing levels and patterns of nucleotide polymorphism. Duplicate ASAP1 copies have similar levels of nucleotide diversity and haplotype structure in both species; by contrast, duplicate ASAP3/TM6 genes display different levels and patterns of variation in D. ciliolata ssp. glutinosa. Additionally, D. ciliolata ssp. glutinosa appears to be segregating for a moderate frequency null allele in one ASAP3/TM6 homoeologue. These results suggest that differing evolutionary forces can affect duplicate loci arising from allopolyploidization.     

Phylogeny and molecular evolution of the DMC1 gene in the polyploid genus Leymus (Triticeae: Poaceae) and its diploid relatives

The level and pattern of nucleotide variation in duplicate genes provide important information on the evolutionary history of polyploids and divergent processes between homoeologous loci within lineages. Leymus, a group of allopolyploid species with the NsXm genomes, is a perennial genus with a diverse array of morphology, ecology, and distribution in Triticeae. To estimate the phylogeny and molecular evolution of a single-copy DMC1 gene in Leymus and its diploid relatives,DMC1 homoeologous sequences were isolated from the sampled Leymus species and were analyzed with those from 30 diploid taxa representing 18 basic genomes in Triticeae. Sequence diversity patterns and genealogical analysis suggested that: (i) different Leymus species might derive their Ns genome from different Psathyrostachys species; (ii) Pseudoroegneria has contributed to the nuclear genome of some Leymus species, which might result from recurrent hybridization or incomplete lineage sorting; (iii) the Xm genome origin of Leymus could differ among species; (iv) rapid radiation and multiple origin might account for the rich diversity, numbers of species, and wide ecological adaptation of Leymus species; and (v) the DMC1 sequence diversity of the Ns genome in Leymus species was lower than that in the Psathyrostachys diploids, while the level of DMC1 sequence diversity in Leymus was higher than that in diploid Pseudoroegneria. Our results provide new insight on the evolutionary dynamics of duplicate DMC1 genes, polyploid speciation, and the phylogeny of Leymus species.     

Evidence for duplication and divergence of the structural gene for phosphoglucoisomerase in diploid species of clarkia

Formal genetic analysis of the mode of inheritance of the electrophoretic phenotypes for phosphoglucoisomerase (PGI) in the annual plants Clarkia rubicunda and C. xantiana showed that these diploid species have two and three genes, respectively, that specify PGI subunits. Electrophoretic examination of seven other diploid species of Clarkia revealed that species assigned to ancestral sections in the current taxonomy have two PGI genes, whereas more specialized species have three PGI genes. Together with evidence that diploid species in two closely related genera have two PGI genes, this suggests the third PGI gene arose within Clarkia. Intergenic heterodimers are formed between polypeptides specified by the third gene and one of the other PGI genes, indicating they have a high degree of structural similarity. The combined genetic, biochemical, and phylogenetic evidence suggests that the third PGI gene resulted from a process of gene duplication. The apparent Michaelis constants (F6P to G6P) of the most common electrophoretic variants of the ancestral gene in C. xantiana and in C. rubicunda are closely similar, but that of the duplicate enzyme is much higher. The intergenic heteromer has an intermediate value. Four alleles have been identified for the duplicate PGI gene in C. xantiana, including a null allele which eliminates the activity of its product. This allele is one of the few examples of a "silenced" duplicate gene. The ancestral and duplicate genes assort independently in C. xantiana. In conjunction with the substantial chromosomal rearrangements that characterize species of Clarkia, this may mean that the duplicate PGI marks a duplicated chromosomal segment that originated from a cross between partially overlapping reciprocal translocations rather than from unequal crossing over.     

Evolution of duplicate control regions in the mitochondrial genomes of metazoa: a case study with Australasian Ixodes ticks

To investigate the evolution pattern and phylogenetic utility of duplicate control regions (CRs) in mitochondrial (mt) genomes, we sequenced the entire mt genomes of three Ixodes species and part of the mt genomes of another 11 species. All the species from the Australasian lineage have duplicate CRs, whereas the other species have one CR. Sequence analyses indicate that the two CRs of the Australasian Ixodes ticks have evolved in concert in each species. In addition to the Australasian Ixodes ticks, species from seven other lineages of metazoa also have mt genomes with duplicate CRs. Accumulated mtDNA sequence data from these metazoans and two recent experiments on replication of mt genomes in human cell lines with duplicate CRs allowed us to re-examine four intriguing questions about the presence of duplicate CRs in the mt genomes of metazoa: (1) Why do some mt genomes, but not others, have duplicate CRs? (2) How did mt genomes with duplicate CRs evolve? (3) How could the nucleotide sequences of duplicate CRs remain identical or very similar over evolutionary time? (4) Are duplicate CRs phylogenetic markers? It appears that mt genomes with duplicate CRs have a selective advantage in replication over mt genomes with one CR. Tandem duplication followed by deletion of genes is the most plausible mechanism for the generation of mt genomes with duplicate CRs. Once duplicate CRs occur in an mt genome, they tend to evolve in concert, probably by gene conversion. However, there are lineages where gene conversion may not always occur, and, thus, the two CRs may evolve independently in these lineages. Duplicate CRs have much potential as phylogenetic markers at low taxonomic levels, such as within genera, within families, or among families, but not at high taxonomic levels, such as among orders.     

The expression of creatine kinase isozymes in Xenopus tropicalis,Xenopus laevis laevis,and their viable hybrid

Starch gel electrophoresis of creatine kinase (CK) isozymes of Xenopus tropicalis shows that at least two different genes code for CK in this diploid (2n=20) species. These genes seem to be orthologous to the CK-A and CK-C genes of extant crossopterygian fish. Additional isozymes may be interpreted either as products of duplicate genes or, more probably, as epigenetically modified forms of the homodimers A^tA^t and C^tC^t, respectively. The originally tetraploid species X. laevis laevis (2n=36), which may have arisen by hybridization of diploid ancestors some 30–40 million years ago, has retained expression of all duplicate CK-A and CK-C genes. Differential expression during ontogenesis (CK-A genes) and in different adult tissues (CK-C genes) indicates that divergence occurred not only with respect to the primary sequence of these duplicate genes, but also with respect to the regulation of their expression. In the interspecific hybrid X. 1. laevis × X. tropicalis, all parental CK genes appear to be expressed simultaneously in the heart. However, several subunit combinations cannot be detected on the zymograms.This work was supported by Swiss National Foundation for Scientific Research Grant 3.775.0.80.     

Evidence for duplication of the structural genes coding plastid and cytosolic isozymes of triose phosphate isomerase in diploid species of clarkia

Formal genetic analyses of the mode of inheritance of the multiple plastid and cytosolic isozymes of triose phosphate isomerase (TPI, EC 5.3.1.1) in annual diploid species of Clarkia (Onagraceae), native to California, suggest that each set of isozymes is specified by duplicate structural genes. In contrast, most diploid plant species possess one plastid and one cytosolic TPI isozyme each coded by a single locus. Linkage tests revealed that the two genes coding the plastid TPIs assort independently. Although the number of individuals sampled per species was small, the plastid isozymes were electrophoretically more variable than the cytosolic isozymes. The two gene duplications are the first reported that characterize an entire plant genus. Initial electrophoretic surveys of TPI in other genera of Onagraceae revealed that the duplication of the gene coding the plastid isozyme is apparently restricted to Clarkia, whereas that of the gene coding the cytosolic isozyme is present in most genera of the family. The separate phylogenetic distributions of the two duplications suggest that the processes that gave rise to them were unrelated.     

DNA polymorphism in active gene and pseudogene of the cytosolic phosphoglucose isomerase (PgiC) loci in Arabidopsis halleri ssp. gemmifera

DNA variations in two PgiC loci were investigated in 15 strains of Arabidopsis halleri ssp. gemmifera. In a 5.5-kb region of the PgiC1 locus, 127 nucleotide substitutions and 33 length variations were observed. In a 6.0-kb region of the PgiC2 locus, 138 nucleotide substitutions and 33 length variations were observed. Frame shift, novel stop codons, and large length variations were observed in the PgiC2 coding region. These findings suggested that PgiC2 may be a pseudogene. The nucleotide diversities (pi) for the entire regions of both PgiC loci were approximately 0.0033. Tajima's test of both PgiC loci yielded significantly negative results. In the coding regions, the high proportions of replacement substitutions caused significant deviations from neutrality in McDonald and Kreitman's test. An excess of singletons and a high proportion of replacement polymorphic sites have been observed in the Adh and ChiA regions of A. halleri ssp. gemmifera. Thus, the A. halleri ssp. gemmifera population may not have reached equilibrium, and thus nonneutral patterns of DNA polymorphism were observed.     

Characterization of duplicated two cytosolic phosphoglucose isomerase (PgiC) loci in Arabidopsis halleri ssp. gemmifera

Arabidopsis halleri ssp. gemmifera has two cytosolic phosphoglucose isomerase (PgiC) loci. A 48-bp deletion was observed in the junction of exon 17 and intron 17 for a locus (PgiC2). PCR-RFLP analysis using cDNA template did not detect the PgiC2 locus. Another locus (PgiC1) has common structure with A. thaliana and expressed normally. A phylogenetic tree of PgiC sequences revealed that duplication of the two loci in A. gemmifera occurred after species splitting of A. thaliana and A. gemmifera. More than 12 kb region encompassing PgiC was sequenced for both loci. In both PgiC1 and PgiC2, sequence homologous to A. thaliana PgiC 5' upstream region was not detected. A gene located on chromosome 4 of A. thaliana was detected in the 5' upstream of PgiC2. This result suggested that the microsyntheny around the PgiC region between A. thaliana and A. gemmifera is not established.     

ARE LYCOPODS WITH HIGH CHROMOSOME NUMBERS ANCIENT POLYPLOIDS?

It has been established that the number of isozymes (different forms of an enzyme encoded by different gene loci) is highly conserved in diploid angiosperms and gymnosperms. In contrast, allopolyploid angiosperms display an increase in isozyme number due to the addition of divergent genomes. Lycopods (Microphyllophyta) are an ancient lineage of vascular plants having very high chromosome numbers. It has been maintained that lycopods acquired these high chromosome numbers through repeated episodes of polyploidy. Despite high chromosome numbers, however, lycopod species having the lowest chromosome numbers within genera possess the number of isozymes typical of diploid seed plants for all enzymes examined except triosephosphate isomerase. There is, therefore, no genetic evidence from enzyme electrophoresis for polyploidy in these plants. These results are comparable to findings for other homosporous pteridophytes including the ferns (Pteridophyta) and horsetails (Arthrophyta). Alternative hypotheses for widespread genetic diploidy in homosporous pteridophytes are 1) repeated cycles of allopolyploidy followed by gene silencing; 2) repeated cycles of autopolyploidy, which would result in duplicated, but not divergent genes for isozymes; 3) initiation of these lineages with relatively high chromosome numbers.     

EXTENSIVE GENE DUPLICATIONS IN DIPLOID EUPATORIUM (ASTERACEAE)

An electrophoretic study of isozyme number for seven soluble enzymes revealed extensive gene duplications in eight diploid species of American Eupatorium belonging to three morphological groups. The enzymes isocitrate dehydrogenase, phosphoglucomutase, phosphoglucose isomerase, 6-phosphogluconate dehydrogenase, and shikimate dehydrogenase occur as three to six isozymes in all species, whereas the minimal conserved number typical of diploid plants is two isozymes for each. Fructose 1, 6-biphosphate aldolase is expressed as multibanded pattern suggesting fixed heterozygosity in all examined species. It was not possible to document gene duplication for triosephosphate isomerase from the electrophoretic patterns. All species examined have a chromosome number of 2n = 20, which has been regarded as the basic diploid number for Eupatorium. However, the detection of extensive duplications suggests that 2n = 10 may be the original diploid chromosome number in Eupatorium and that plants with 2n = 20 are of polyploid origin. This hypothesis would mean that extensive duplications at isozyme gene loci have been maintained since the origin of the genus, despite chromosomal diploidization having occurred.