Co-evolution of the legume-Rhizobium association

Summary A number of examples is given demonstrating the co-existence of pea genotypes and their specific Rhizobium, strains isolated within the same region.R. leguminosarum strains compatible with the cultivated pea have a narrow symbiotic range and they are widely distributed in European soils. This is presumably due to the narrow genetic base of the cultivated pea and its wide-spread cultivation in European soils. Rhizobium strains capable of nodulating a primitive pea line from Afghanistan were only found in soils of the Middle East and Central Asia. A more restricted distribution of specific Rhizobium strains was found for fulvum peas from Israel. Rhizobium strains effective with the fulvum pea were found in Israeli soils. A good example of co-evolution due to geographical isolation was found in south Turkey. Here a pea line was found which can form an effective symbiosis with local Rhizobium strains but not with strains from other parts of Turkey.     

Gene centres,a source for genetic variants in symbiotic nitrogen fixation: The symbiotic response of the cultivated pea toRhizobium leguminosarum strains from Europe and the Middle East

Summary Soil samples from several European countries; Sweden, the Netherlands, Spain, Italy and Greece, contained rhizobial populations capable of forming an effective symbiosis with the cultivated pea cv. Rondo from the Netherlands. The range of variation among the European Rhizobium strains, as expressed on pea cv. Rondo, was not so large and almost the same variation could be found within the rhizobial population within each country. Superior Rhizobium strains for the Dutch pea were not restricted to soils from the Netherlands but were also found in those from Sweden and Italy.Soils from Turkey and Israel also contained Rhizobium strains capable of nodulating pea cv. Rondo. However, the genetic variation among these Middle East Rhizobium strains was much larger than that of the European strains. When tested on pea cv. Rondo the majority of the Middle East strains belonged to the medium or low effective classes and only a few strains were comparable with European Rhizobium strains.Dutch Rhizobium strains induced effective nodules on both the Dutch pea cv. Rondo and the Swedish cv. L 110. However, in association with a Turkish Rhizobium strain effective nodules were formed on pea cv. Rondo and ineffective nodules on cv. L 110.We suggest that the genetic uniformity of EuropeanR. leguminosarum strains is the result of selection and domestication of Rhizobium strains originally derived from the gene centres of the pea plant.     

Symbiotic effectiveness of strains of Rhizobium leguminosarum biovar phaseoli isolated from soils of Rwanda

We have isolated 48 strains of Rhizobium leguminosarum biovar phaseoli from nodules of Phaseolus vulgaris L. cultivated on 32 different soils at 22 various locations in Rwanda, Central Africa. The symbiotic effectiveness of the strains was appraised in the greenhouse by measuring shoots dry matter and total plant nitrogen content after six weeks of growth. Of the strains tested 19%, 58% and 23% were rated very effective, effective and ineffective, respectively. A very significant correlation (r=0.96, P<0.01) was observed between shoots dry matter and total N content. By using the total nitrogen balance method, it was estimated that in the presence of a very effective strain, up to 86% of the N present in the shoots comes from N₂ fixation. No significant correlations were observed between the symbiotic effectiveness of the strains and the pH of the soils from which they originated, the tolerance of the strains to acidity or their ability to produce organic acids. The nine very effective strains selected were highly competitive against two ineffective strains with the two P. vulgaris cultivars Rubona-5 and Kiryumukwe.Contribution no 367, Station de recherches, Agriculture Canada.Contribution no 367, Station de recherches, Agriculture Canada.     

Soil P-status and cultivar maturity effects on pea-Rhizobium symbiosis

In a green-house experiment, five cultivars of Pisum sativum L. grown on soils from 10 different locations in Tunisia, showed significant differences in nodulation, shoot dry matter (shDM) yield and shoot nitrogen content (shNC). The effect of soil on biological nitrogen fixation, as evidenced by the number and weight of nodules, was mainly attributable to the available phosphorus content. Cate-Nelson ANOVA analysis established a critical value of soil test phosphorus (STP) of 20 mg P kg^–1 soil for nodule weight and number for the majority of cultivars. Within cultivars, nodulation varied with maturation period and was correlated with shoot NC. Thus, the overall interaction of soil-P content and cultivar-maturation period were correlated positively with nodulation and to symbiotic effectiveness of strains of Rhizobium leguminosarum bv. viceae indigenous to these soils. Based on an antibiotic susceptibility test and main variable factor analysis of the data obtained, 70 isolates of Rhizobia that nodulate pea, obtained from soils from agricultural sites throughout Tunisia, were identified as belonging to 18 distinct strains. These classes were identified on the basis of symbiotic efficiency parameters (shoot DM yield and shoot NC) as: ineffective (33 isolates), moderately effective (27 isolates), and efficient strains (10 isolates). This study shows that the Mateur site, an agricultural area for millennia in the northern region of Tunisia, harbors rhizobial strains that are highly efficient in fixing N₂ with peas. These results also indicate the importance of strain-cultivar interrelationships and specificity.     

Strain selection for pigeon pea Rhizobium under greenhouse conditions

Pigeon pea obtains N for growth by N₂ fixation although yield generally is not improved by either the inoculation of Rhizobium or by the application of N fertilizer in Puerto Rico. Sixteen strains ofRhizobium spp., different in geographical origin, were tested for N-fixing effectiveness, determined from comparisons with uninoculated controls, N controls and the standard strain 176A22. Inoculated treatments showed significant differences in nodulation, plant dry weight and %N. Several strain x plant combinations had higher N content than the N treatment, reflecting the ubiquity of effective strains and the possible lack of response of pigeon pea to inoculation or N fertilization. Strains superior in N₂ fixation were selected for testing for symbiotic effectiveness under field conditions.     

Selection of Rhizobium leguminosarum bv. viceae strains for inoculation of Pisum sativum L. cultivars: Analysis of symbiotic efficiency and nodulation competitiveness

From an analysis of 481 Rhizobium leguminosarum bv. viceae strains with 7 pea cultivars in pot and field experiments, we demonstrated that effective strains could be isolated from a rich medium-acid grey forest soil of the Oröl area (Central region of the European part of Russia) but not from a poor acid podzolic soil of the St. Petersburg area (North-West Russia). The proportion of the isolates significantly increasing N accumulation in pea plants (10.2%) is higher than that of strains increasing the shoot dry mass (4.6%) in the pot experiments. The mean values of the increase for N accumulation (33.8%) upon inoculation are also higher than for shoot mass (27.0%) in these experiments. N accumulation in the inoculated pea plants in the pot experiments was significantly correlated with seed yield and seed N accumulation in field experiments, while for shoot dry mass these correlations were either weak or not significant. Two-factor analysis of variance demonstrated that the contribution of plant cultivars to the variation of the major symbiotic efficiency parameters is higher (30.8–31.6%) and contributions of cultivar-strain specificity is lower (5.4–8.8%) than the contributions of strain genotypes (13.4–14.9%). We identified an ineffective R. leguminosarum bv. viceae strain 50 which can be used as a tester for assessing the nodulation competitiveness of the effective strains by an indirect method (analysis of dry mass and N accumulation in pea plants inoculated with the mixture of the tested effective strains and the tester strain). The relative competitive ability (RCA) determined by this method was 75.7–82.8% for strain 52 but only 10.5–13.8% for strain 250a; this difference was confirmed by a direct method (use of the streptomycin-resistant mutants). Results of screening of the diverse collection of 53 effective R. leguminosarum bv. viceae strains by the indirect method permits us to divide them into 3 groups (32 high-competitive, 10 medium-competitive and 11 low-competitive strains) but reveals no correlation between the competitiveness and symbiotic efficiency. N accumulation in the pea shoots is demonstrated to be a much more suitable criterion than the shoot mass for selection either of the highly-effective or of highly-competitive (by the indirect estimation) R. leguminosarum bv. viceae strains in the pot experiments.     

Isolation and partial characterization of Fix− mutants from Rhizobium strain 32H1

Summary Eight ineffective mutant strains were isolated from N-methyl-N'-nitro-N-nitrosoguanidine mutagenized cultures of cowpea Rhizobium strain 32H1. Strains CR1, CR2, CR3, CR4, CR5 and CR6 induced more, but smaller, nodules than the wild type. With the exception of strain CR2, these mutant strains reduced less than 1% of the amount of acetylene reduced by the wild type, in both the free-living and symbiotic assays. Strain CR2 reduced acetylene in the free-living assay but not in the symbiotic assay. Strains CR7 and CR8 responded variably (5–20% of the wild type) in free-living and symbiotic acetylene reduction assays. Nodules also varied from small white to normal-sized pink nodules. The phenotypic characteristics of the mutant strains were consistant with all leguminous plants tested and were stable upon reisolation from nodules. Fully effective revertants were selected from 4 of the ineffective mutant strains by the use of the leguminous plant,Macroptilium lathyroides. Serology, patterns of resistance to anti-bacterial agents, phage-typing, and antibiotic resistance markers were used to confirm strain identification.Cooperative investigations of the United States Department of Agriculture, Agricultural Research Service and the North Carolina Agricultural Research Service, Raleigh, North Carolina. Paper no. 8834 of the Journal Series of the North Carolina Agricultural Research Service at Raleigh.     

Characterization of heat resistant mutant strains of Rhizobium sp. [Cajanus] for growth, survival and symbiotic properties

Fourteen heat resistant mutant strains were isolated from a wild-type strain (PP201, Nod⁺ Fix⁺) of Rhizobium sp. (Cajanus) by giving it a heat shock of 43°C. These mutant strains showed a greater increase in optical density (O.D.) and a higher viable cell count in both rhizospheric and non-rhizospheric soil at high temperature. Symbiotic studies showed that pigeon pea plants inoculated with a few mutant strains had ineffective nodules (Nod⁺ Fix⁻) under controlled temperature (43°C) conditions, but under natural high temperature (40–45°C) conditions, the host plants infected with all the mutant strains showed higher total shoot nitrogen than the plants inoculated with the parent strain. Four mutant strains (HR-3, HR-6, HR-10 and HR-12) were found to be highly efficient for all the symbiotic parameters, and thus have the potential to be used as bioinoculants in the North-Western regions of India during the summer season.     

Symbiotic properties of C4-dicarboxylic acid transport mutants of Rhizobium leguminosarum.

The transport of succinate was studied in bacteroids of an effective, streptomycin-resistant strain (GF160) of Rhizobium leguminosarum. High levels of succinate transport occurred, and the kinetics, specificity, and sensitivity to metabolic inhibitors were similar to those previously described for free-living cells. The symbiotic properties of two transposon (Tn5)-mediated C4-dicarboxylate transport mutants (strains GF31 and GF252) were determined. Strain GF31 formed ineffective nodules, and bacteroids from these nodules showed no succinate transport activity. Strain GF252 formed partially effective nodules, and bacteroids from these nodules showed about 50% of the succinate transport activity of the parent bacteroids. Another dicarboxylic acid transport mutant (Dct-), strain GFS5, isolated after N-methyl-N'-nitro-N-nitrosoguanidine mutagenesis, formed ineffective nodules. The ability to form ineffective nodules in strains GF31 and GFS5 was shown to correlate with the Dct- phenotype. The data indicate that the presence of a functional C4-dicarboxylic acid transport system is essential for N2 fixation to occur in pea nodules.     

Danish Rhizobium leguminosarum strains nodulating 'Afghanistan' pea (Pisum sativum)

A wild pea ( Pisum sativum L.) native to Afghanistan normally known to be resistant to nodulation with European strains of Rhizobium leguminosarum was nodulated early and effectively in field soil in Denmark. Isolates from nodules formed effective nodules abundantly on 'Afghanistan' on reinfection under aseptic conditions. Five types differing in isoenzyme composition pattern were found among 15 isolates from 'Afghanistan' nodules. None were identical with the 'Tom' strain from Turkey, which also forms effective nodules with 'Afghanistan'. The five types were also different with respect to isoenzyme pattern from Rhizobium leguminosarum strains isolated from a modern pea variety cultivated in the same field.     

Effect of plant nutrient supply on nodule effectiveness and rhizobium strain competition for nodulation ofLotus pedunculatus

Summary The effect of nutrient supply on nodule formation and competition between Rhizobium strains for nodulation ofLotus pedunculatus was studied. Limiting plant growth by decreasing the supply of nutrients in an otherwise nitrogen-free medium, increased the size but decreased the number and the nitrogenase activity of nodules formed by a fast-growing strain of Lotus Rhizobium (NZP2037). In contrast decreasing nutrient supply caused only a small decline in the size, number and nitrogenase activity of nodules formed by a slow-growing strain (CC814s). Providing small quantities of NH₄NO₃ (50 to 250 g N) to plants grown with a normal supply of other nutrients stimulated nodule development by both Rhizobium strains and increased the nitrogenase activity of the NZP2037 nodules. Differences in the level of effectiveness (nitrogen-fixing ability) of nodules formed by different Rhizobium strains on plants grown with a normal supply of nutrients were less apparent when the plants were grown with decreased nutrient supply or when the plants were supplied with low levels of inorganic N.Inter-strain competition for nodulation ofL. pedunculatus between the highly effective slow-growing strain CC814s and 7 other fast- and slow-growing strains, showed CC814s to form 42 to 100% of the nodules in all associations. The greater nodulating competitiveness of strain CC814s prevailed despite changes in the nutrient supply to the host plant. A tendency was observed for partially effective Lotus Rhizobium strains to become more competitive in nodule formation when plant growth was supplemented with low levels of inorganic nitrogen.     

Effect of Inoculation with Various Rhizobia Strains on the Fatty Acid Composition of Peribacteroid and Bacteroid Membranes of the Nodule Symbiosomes

The fatty acid (FA) composition of bacteroid and peribacteroid membranes was studied in the symbiotic pairs differing in their nitrogen-fixing efficiency; the results are compared with the FA composition of plasmalemma and free-living rhizobia. The experiments involved lupine plants inoculated with strains of Bradyrhizobium lupini359a (Nod⁺Fix⁺) and 400 (Nod⁺Fix L) manifesting high and low nitrogen-fixing efficiency, respectively, and broad bean plants inoculated with strains of Rhizobium leguminosarum97 (Nod⁺Fix⁺) and 87 (Nod⁺Fix L) of high and low nitrogen-fixing efficiency, respectively. We showed that the rhizobia of the strains 359a and 97 were able to form nodules with peribacteroid membranes containing FA mainly or exclusively of plant origin. These strains were able to develop effective symbiotic pairs with legume plants. The use of strains 400 and 87 resulted in the formation of nodules with peribacteroid membranes containing typical bacterial (branched-chain) FAs; these strains were characterized by an ineffective symbiosis.     

Selection of Portuguese Rhizobium leguminosarum bv. trifolii strains for production of legume inoculants

From several native clover species, growing in six different soil types, 170 Rhizobium leguminosarum biovar trifolii strains were isolated, covering the central and southern regions of Portugal. The effectiveness of the strains varied from ineffective to highly effective on T. subterraneum cv. Clare and on T. fragiferum cv. Palestine, with a predominance of medium and high effectiveness on both host plants. The effectiveness was not influenced by provenence (soil or plant), except for the strains from the rankers soils and for the strains isolated from T. pratense, that were ineffective or medium effective on T. subterraneum.Selected strains were evaluated for effectiveness on T. subterraneum cv. Clare, using the commercial strain TA1 as reference. Several of the isolated strains were more effective than TA1, indicating that local strains may be used to produce better inoculants.     

Modification of symbiotic interaction of pea (Pisum sativum L.) andRhizobium leguminosarum by induced mutations

Summary In pea (Pisum sativum L.), mutants could be induced, modified in the symbiotic interaction withRhizobium leguminosarum. Among 250 M₂-families, two nodulation resistant mutants (K₅ and K₉) were obtained. In mutant K₅ the nodulation resistance was monogenic recessive and not Rhizobium strain specific. Out of 220 M₂-families one mutant nod₃ was found which could form nodules at high nitrate concentrations (15 mM KNO₃). This mutant nodulated abundantly with severalRhizobium strains, both in the absence and presence of nitrate. Probably as the result of a pleiotropic effect, its root morphology was also changed. Among 1800 M₂-families, five nitrate reductase deficient mutants were obtained and one of them (mutant E₁) was used to study the inhibitory effect of nitrate on nodulation and nitrogen fixation.The results of the present investigation show that pea mutants which are modified in their symbiosis withRhizobium leguminosarum, can readily be obtained. The significance of such mutants for fundamental studies of the legume-Rhizobium symbiosis and for applications in plant breeding is discussed.     

ACC deaminase producing Pseudomonas putida strain PSE3 and Rhizobium leguminosarum strain RP2 in synergism improves growth, nodulation and yield of pea grown in alluvial soils

Plant growth promoting rhizobacteria affects the overall performance of plants by one or combination of mechanisms. However, little information is available on how ACC deaminase secreting bacteria enhance crop production. The present study aimed at identifying ACC deaminase producing and phosphate solubilizing bacterial strains and to assess their plant growth promoting activities. Additionally, the effect of two ACC deaminase positive bacterial strains Pseudomonas putida and Rhizobium leguminosarum on pea plants was determined to find a novel and compatible bacterial pairing for developing efficient inoculants for enhancing legume production and reducing dependence on chemical fertilizers. The isolated bacterial cultures were characterized biochemically and by 16S rRNA sequence analysis. The plant growth promoting activities was determined using standard microbiological methods. The impact of P. putida and R. leguminosarum, on pea plants was determined both in pots and in field environments. Of the total 40 bacterial strains, strain PSE3 isolated from Mentha arvenss rhizosphere and RP2 strain from pea nodules produced ACC deaminase, solubilized insoluble phosphate, synthesized indole acetic acid, ammonia, cyanogenic compounds, exopolysaccharides and had antifungal activity. The dual inoculation of P. putida strain PSE3 and R. leguminosarum strain RP2 had largest positive effect and markedly increased the growth, symbiotic characteristics, nutrient pool and quantity and quality of pea seeds. The measured parameters were further augmented when inoculated pea plants were grown in soils treated with urea or DAP. A significant variation in the measured parameters of pea plants was observed under both pot and field trials following microbial inoculation but the bacterial cultures did not differ significantly in growth promoting activities. The results suggest that ACC deaminase positive bacterial cultures endowed with multiple potential can be targeted to develop mixed inoculants for enhancing pea production and hence, to reduce dependence on synthetic fertilizers.     

Behavior of plasmid pJB5JI in Rhizobium huakuii under free-living and symbiotic conditions

The Rhizobium leguminosarum biovar viceae host-range plasmid pJB5JI was transferred into Rhizobium huakuii strains, both wild-type 7653R and its sym plasmid-cured mutant 7653R-1. Transconjugant 7653R-1 (pJB5JI) acquired the ability to form ineffective nodules on pea plants, whereas transconjugant 7653R (pJB5JI) could not do so, indicating that the indigenous symbiotic plasmid could restrict the functional expression of pJB5JI. On the other hand, transconjugant 7653R (pJB5JI) showed higher nitrogenase activity on A. sinicus and higher shoot dry weight than the recipient strain 7653R. The alien plasmid pJB5JI in both kinds of transconjugants remained stable during frequent transfer on culture media, but in part of the isolates from nodules formed by them the pJB5JI was not visualized on gel by the Eckhardt procedure. Southern hybridization with Tn5 and nod gene probes showed that these isolates still reserved, at least in part, DNA of pJB5JI, which was probably intergrated onto the chromosome of cells.     

Salt-tolerant rhizobia isolated from a Tunisian oasis that are highly effective for symbiotic N2-fixation with Phaseolus vulgaris constitute a novel biovar (bv. mediterranense) of Sinorhizobium meliloti

Nodulation of common bean was explored in six oases in the south of Tunisia. Nineteen isolates were characterized by PCR–RFLP of 16S rDNA. Three species of rhizobia were identified, Rhizobium etli, Rhizobium gallicum and Sinorhizobium meliloti. The diversity of the symbiotic genes was then assessed by PCR–RFLP of nodC and nifH genes. The majority of the symbiotic genotypes were conserved between oases and other soils of the north of the country. Sinorhizobia isolated from bean were then compared with isolates from Medicago truncatula plants grown in the oases soils. All the nodC types except for nodC type p that was specific to common bean isolates were shared by both hosts. The four isolates with nodC type p induced N₂-fixing effective nodules on common bean but did not nodulate M. truncatula and Medicago sativa. The phylogenetic analysis of nifH and nodC genes showed that these isolates carry symbiotic genes different from those previously characterized among Medicago and bean symbionts, but closely related to those of S. fredii Spanish and Tunisian isolates effective in symbiosis with common bean but unable to nodulate soybean. The creation of a novel biovar shared by S. meliloti and S. fredii, bv. mediterranense, was proposed.