Inhibition of pre-mRNA splicing by antisense RNA in vitro: effect of RNA containing sequences complementary to introns

The objective of the experiments described in this paper was to test the potential of antisense RNAs complementary to the internal portion of an intron to inhibit the splicing process and to determine the mechanism of such inhibition. The results obtained indicate that RNA fragments complementary to the internal portion of an intron can effectively inhibit the splicing of pre-mRNA. Inhibition was observed only with antisense RNA complementary to pre-mRNA suggesting that the inhibitory effect was due to the formation of a hybrid with the corresponding portion of the pre-mRNA's intron. The observed inhibition was not due to interference with possible intron elements essential for the splicing process, for the deletion of the sequences complementary to inhibitory antisense RNA from the corresponding pre-mRNA molecule did not affect the efficiency of a splicing reaction, and the addition of antisense RNA to pre-mRNA mutants carrying such deletions did not result in any inhibition. Our results indicate that the observed inhibition is a function of the length of the antisense RNA expressed as a fraction of an intron with which it interacts when antisense RNA is modified by incorporation of a "hinge" element, it loses its inhibitory potential suggesting that the inhibitory effect is probably due to limitation of conformational flexibility of an intron.     

Antisense RNA inhibits splicing of pre-mRNA in vitro.

Antisense RNAs complementary to human beta-globin pre-mRNA or to a chimeric globin/adenovirus E2a pre-mRNA specifically and efficiently inhibit pre-mRNA splicing in vitro. The level of inhibition depends on the length, position and concentration of the antisense RNA relative to the pre-mRNA substrate. Antisense RNAs complementary to sequences greater than 80 nucleotides downstream of the globin 3' splice site inhibit at least as efficiently as those extending across the splice sites. Thus splicing is sensitive to perturbations involving exon sequences some distance from the splice sites. Inhibition is mediated by factors which affect the annealing of antisense and substrate RNAs. Direct analysis of RNA duplex formation demonstrates the presence of an activity in HeLa cell nuclear extract which promotes the rapid annealing of complementary RNAs in an ATP-independent manner. Both annealing and inhibition are greatly reduced when antisense RNA is added to the splicing reaction greater than or equal to 5 min after substrate. This result may reflect a transition between an open structure, in which annealing of antisense RNA with pre-mRNA is facilitated, and a closed complex in which pre-mRNA is sequestered at an early stage of spliceosome assembly.     

Inhibition of c-erbA mRNA splicing by a naturally occurring antisense RNA.

The rat erbA alpha locus encodes two overlapping mRNAs, alpha 1 and alpha 2, which are identical except for their most 3' exons. alpha 1 mRNA encodes a thyroid hormone receptor, while alpha 2 encodes an altered ligand binding domain of unknown function. Previous studies have shown that the ratio of alpha 1 to alpha 2 is highest in cells expressing a high level of a third RNA, Rev-ErbA alpha mRNA, which is transcribed in the opposite direction and is complementary to alpha 2 but not alpha 1 mRNA. It was hypothesized that base pairing with Rev-ErbA alpha blocks splicing of alpha 2 mRNA, thereby favoring formation of the non-overlapping alpha 1. To test this model, a system was developed in which alpha 2 pre-mRNAs were accurately spliced in vitro. Splicing was inhibited by the addition of a 5-fold excess of antisense RNAs containing the 3' end of Rev-ErbA alpha mRNA. Both an antisense RNA extending across the 3' splice site and a shorter RNA complementary only to exon sequences efficiently blocked splicing. However, splicing was only inhibited by complementary RNAs. These observations are consistent with a mechanism in which base pairing with a complementary RNA regulates alternative processing of alpha 1 and alpha 2 mRNAs.     

Restoration of correct splicing of thalassemic beta-globin pre-mRNA by modified U1 snRNAs

The T-->G mutation at nucleotide 705 in the second intron of the beta-globin gene creates an aberrant 5' splice site and activates a 3' cryptic splice site upstream from the mutation. As a result, the IVS2-705 pre-mRNA is spliced via the aberrant splice sites leading to a deficiency of beta-globin mRNA and protein and to the genetic blood disorder thalassemia. We have shown previously that in cell culture models of thalassemia, aberrant splicing of beta-thalassemic IVS2-705 pre-mRNA was permanently corrected by a modified murine U7 snRNA that incorporated sequences antisense to the splice sites activated by the mutation. To explore the possibility of using other snRNAs as vectors for antisense sequences, U1 snRNA was modified in a similar manner. Replacement of the U1 9-nucleotide 5' splice site recognition sequence with nucleotides complementary to the aberrant 5' splice site failed to correct splicing of IVS2-705 pre-mRNA. In contrast, U1 snRNA targeted to the cryptic 3' splice site was effective. A hybrid with a modified U7 snRNA gene under the control of the U1 promoter and terminator sequences resulted in the highest levels of correction (up to 70%) in transiently and stably transfected target cells.     

Intronic sequences and 3'' splice sites control Rous sarcoma virus RNA splicing.

cis-acting sequences of Rous sarcoma virus (RSV) RNA involved in control of the incomplete splicing that is part of the retroviral life cycle have been studied. The 5' and two alternative 3' splice sites, as well as negative regulator of splicing element in the intron, have been introduced into chimeric constructs, and their responsive roles in splicing inhibition have been evaluated by transient transfection experiments. Although the RSV 5' splice site was used efficiently in these assays, substrates containing either the RSV env or the RSV src 3' splice site were not spliced completely, resulting in 40 to 50% unspliced RNA. Addition of the negative regulator of splicing element to substrates containing RSV 3' splice sites resulted in greater inhibition of splicing (70 to 80% unspliced RNA), suggesting that the two elements function independently and additively. Deletion of sequences more than 70 nucleotides upstream of the src 3' splice site resulted in efficient splicing at this site, suggesting that inefficient usage is not inherent in this splice site but is instead due to to sequences upstream of it. Insertion of these upstream sequences into the intron of a heterologous pre-mRNA resulted in partial inhibition of its splicing. In addition, secondary structure interactions were predicted to occur between the src 3' splice site and the inhibitory sequences upstream of it. Thus, RSV splicing control involves both intronic sequences and 3' splice sites, with different mechanisms involved in the underutilization of the env and src splice acceptor sites.     

Sensitivity of splice sites to antisense oligonucleotides in vivo

A series of HeLa cell lines which stably express beta-globin pre-mRNAs carrying point mutations at nt 654, 705, or 745 of intron 2 has been developed. The mutations generate aberrant 5' splice sites and activate a common 3' cryptic splice site upstream leading to aberrantly spliced beta-globin mRNA. Antisense oligonucleotides, which in vivo blocked aberrant splice sites and restored correct splicing of the pre-mRNA, revealed major differences in the sensitivity of these sites to antisense probes. Although the targeted pre-mRNAs differed only by single point mutations, the effective concentrations of the oligonucleotides required for correction of splicing varied up to 750-fold. The differences among the aberrant 5' splice sites affected sensitivity of both the 5' and 3' splice sites; in particular, sensitivity of both splice sites was severely reduced by modification of the aberrant 5' splice sites to the consensus sequence. These results suggest large differences in splicing of very similar pre-mRNAs in vivo. They also indicate that antisense oligonucleotides may provide useful tools for studying the interactions of splicing machinery with pre-mRNA.     

Identification of the sequences responsible for the splicing phenotype of the regulatory intron of the L1 ribosomal protein gene of Xenopus laevis.

Splicing of the regulated third intron of the L1 ribosomal protein gene of Xenopus laevis has been studied in vivo by oocyte microinjection of wild-type and mutant SP6 precursor RNAs and in vitro in the heterologous HeLa nuclear extract. We show that two different phenomena combine to produce the peculiar splicing phenotype of this intron. One, which can be defined constitutive, shows the same features in the two systems and leads to the accumulation of spliced mRNA, but in very small amounts. The low efficiency of splicing is due to the presence of a noncanonical 5' splice site which acts in conjunction with sequences present in the 3' portion of the intron. The second leads to the massive conversion of the pre-mRNA into site specific truncated molecules. This has the effect of decreasing the concentration of the pre-mRNA available for splicing. We show that this aberrant cleavage activity occurs only in the in vivo oocyte system and depends on the presence of an intact U1 RNA.     

Comparison of Rous sarcoma virus RNA processing in chicken and mouse fibroblasts: evidence for double-spliced RNA in nonpermissive mouse cells.

Rous sarcoma virus, an avian retrovirus, transforms but does not replicate in mammalian cells. To determine to what extent differences in RNA splicing might contribute to this lack of productive infection, cloned proviral DNA derived from the Prague A strain of Rous sarcoma virus was transfected into mouse NIH 3T3 cells, and the viral RNA was compared by RNase protection with viral RNA from transfected chicken embryo fibroblasts by using a tandem antisense riboprobe spanning the three major splice sites. The levels of viral RNA in NIH 3T3 cells compared with those in chicken embryo fibroblasts were lower, but the RNA was spliced at increased efficiency. The difference in the ratio of unspliced to spliced RNA levels was not due to the increased lability of unspliced RNA in NIH 3T3 cells. Although chicken embryo fibroblasts contained equal levels of src and env mRNAs, spliced viral mRNAs in NIH 3T3 cells were almost exclusively src. In NIH 3T3 cells the env mRNA was further processed by using a cryptic 5' splice site located within the env coding sequences and the normal src 3' splice site to form a double-spliced mRNA. This mRNA was identical to the src mRNA, except that a 159-nucleotide sequence from the 5' end of the env gene was inserted at the src splice junction. Smaller amounts of single-spliced RNA were also present in which only the region between the cryptic 5' and src 3' splice sites was spliced out. The aberrant processing of the viral env mRNA in NIH 3T3 cells may in part explain the nonpermissiveness of these cells to productive Rous sarcoma virus infection.     

Splicing of a cap-proximal human Papillomavirus 16 E6E7 intron promotes E7 expression, but can be restrained by distance of the intron from its RNA 5' cap

Human papillomavirus 16 (HPV16) E6E7 pre-mRNA is bicistronic and has an intron in the E6 coding region with one 5' splice site and two alternative 3' splice sites, which produce E6(*)I and E6(*)II, respectively. If this intron remains unspliced, the resulting E6E7 mRNA expresses oncogenic E6. We found for the first time that the E6E7 pre-mRNA was efficiently spliced in vitro only when capped and that cellular cap-binding factors were involved in the splicing. The cap-dependent splicing of the E6E7 pre-mRNA was extremely efficient in cervical cancer-derived cells, producing mostly E6(*)I, but inefficient in cells transfected with a common retrovirus expression vector, pLXSN16E6E7, due to the large size of this vector's exon 1. Further studies showed that efficient splicing of the E6E7 pre-mRNA depends on the distance of the cap-proximal intron from the RNA 5' cap, with an optimal distance of less than 307nt in order to facilitate better association of U1 small nuclear RNA with the intron 5' splice site. The same was true for splicing of human beta-globin RNA. Splicing of the E6E7 RNA provided more E7 RNA templates and promoted E7 translation, whereas a lack of RNA splicing produced a low level of E7 translation. Together, our data indicate that the distance between the RNA 5' cap and cap-proximal intron is rate limiting for RNA splicing. HPV16 E6E7 pre-mRNA takes advantage of its small cap-proximal exon to confer efficient splicing for better E7 expression.     

Regulation of adenovirus alternative RNA splicing at the level of commitment complex formation.

The adenovirus late region 1 (L1) represents an example of an alternatively spliced gene where one 5' splice site is spliced to two alternative 3' splice sites, to produce two mRNAs; the 52,55K and IIIa mRNAs, respectively. Accumulation of the L1 mRNAs is temporally regulated during the infectious cycle. Thus, the proximal 3' splice site (52,55K mRNA) is used at all times during the infectious cycle whereas the distal 3' splice site (IIIa mRNA) is used exclusively late in infection. Here we show that in vitro splicing extracts prepared from late adenovirus-infected cells reproduces the virus-induced temporal shift from proximal to distal 3' splice site selection in L1 pre-mRNA splicing. Two stable intermediates in spliceosome assembly have been identified; the commitment complex and the pre-spliceosome (or A complex). We show that the transition in splice site activity in L1 alternative splicing results from an increase in the efficiency of commitment complex formation using the distal 3' splice site in extracts prepared from late virus-infected cells combined with a reduction of the efficiency of proximal 3' splice site splicing. The increase in commitment activity on the distal 3' splice site is paralleled by a virus-induced increase in A complex formation on the distal 3' splice site. Importantly, the virus-induced shift from proximal to distal L1 3' splice site usage does not require cis competition between the 52,55K and the IIIa 3' splice sites, but rather results from the intrinsic property of the two 3' splice sites which make them respond differently to factors in extracts prepared from virus-infected cells.     

RNA modulation, repair and remodeling by splice switching oligonucleotides

Targeting splicing by antisense oligonucleotides allows RNA modifications that are not possible with RNA interference or other antisense techniques that destine the RNA for destruction. By changing the ratio of naturally occurring splice variants the expression of mRNA is modulated. By preventing the use of an aberrant splice site created by a mutation and enforcing re-selection of correct splice sites the RNA is repaired. Antisense induced skipping of the exon that carries a nonsense mutation remodels the mRNA and restores the reading frame of the defective protein. All of the above approaches have clinical applications. Modulation of splice variants is particularly important since close to 60% of all genes code for alternatively spliced pre-mRNA.     

An artificial riboswitch for controlling pre-mRNA splicing

Riboswitches, as previously reported, are natural RNA aptamers that regulate the expression of numerous bacterial metabolic genes in response to small molecule ligands. It has recently been shown that these RNA genetic elements are also present near the splice site junctions of plant and fungal introns, thus raising the possibility of their involvement in regulating mRNA splicing. Here it is shown for the first time that a riboswitch can be engineered to regulate pre-mRNA splicing in vitro. We show that insertion of a high-affinity theophylline binding aptamer into the 3' splice site (3' ss) region of a model pre-mRNA (AdML-Theo29AG) enables its splicing to be repressed by the addition theophylline. Our results indicate that the location of 3' ss AG within the aptamer plays a crucial role in conferring theophylline-dependent control of pre-mRNA splicing. We also show that theophylline-mediated control of pre-mRNA splicing is highly specific by first demonstrating that a small molecule ligand similar in shape and size to theophylline had no effect on the splicing of AdML-Theo29AG pre-mRNA. Second, theophylline failed to exert any influence on the splicing of a pre-mRNA that does not contain its binding site. Third, theophylline specifically blocks the step II of the splicing reaction. Finally, we provide evidence that theophylline-dependent control of pre-mRNA splicing is functionally relevant.     

Reprogramming alternative pre-messenger RNA splicing through the use of protein-binding antisense oligonucleotides

Alternative pre-messenger RNA splicing is a major contributor to proteomic diversity in higher eukaryotes and represents a key step in the control of protein function in a large variety of biological systems. As a means of artificially altering splice site choice, we have investigated the impact of positioning proteins in the vicinity of 5' splice sites. We find that a recombinant GST-MS2 protein interferes with 5' splice site use, most efficiently when it binds upstream of that site. To broaden the use of proteins as steric inhibitors of splicing, we have tested the activity of antisense oligonucleotides carrying binding sites for the heterogeneous nuclear ribonucleoprotein A1/A2 proteins. In a HeLa cell extract, tailed oligonucleotides complementary to exonic sequences elicit strong shifts in 5' splice site selection. In four different human cell lines, an interfering oligonucleotide carrying A1/A2 binding sites also shifted the alternative splicing of the Bcl-x pre-mRNA more efficiently than oligonucleotides acting through duplex formation only. The use of protein-binding oligonucleotides that interfere with U1 small nuclear ribonucleoprotein binding therefore represents a novel and powerful approach to control splice site selection in cells.     

Exploitation of a thermosensitive splicing event to study pre-mRNA splicing in vivo.

The spliced form of MuSVts110 viral RNA is approximately 20-fold more abundant at growth temperatures of 33 degrees C or lower than at 37 to 41 degrees C. This difference is due to changes in the efficiency of MuSVts110 RNA splicing rather than selective thermolability of the spliced species at 37 to 41 degrees C or general thermosensitivity of RNA splicing in MuSVts110-infected cells. Moreover, RNA transcribed from MuSVts110 DNA introduced into a variety of cell lines is spliced in a temperature-sensitive fashion, suggesting that the structure of the viral RNA controls the efficiency of the event. We exploited this novel splicing event to study the cleavage and ligation events during splicing in vivo. No spliced viral mRNA or splicing intermediates were observed in MuSVts110-infected cells (6m2 cells) at 39 degrees C. However, after a short (about 30-min) lag following a shift to 33 degrees C, viral pre-mRNA cleaved at the 5' splice site began to accumulate. Ligated exons were not detected until about 60 min following the initial detection of cleavage at the 5' splice site, suggesting that these two splicing reactions did not occur concurrently. Splicing of viral RNA in the MuSVts110 revertant 54-5A4, which lacks the sequence -AG/TGT- at the usual 3' splice site, was studied. Cleavage at the 5' splice site in the revertant viral RNA proceeded in a temperature-sensitive fashion. No novel cryptic 3' splice sites were activated; however, splicing at an alternate upstream 3' splice site used at low efficiency in normal MuSVts110 RNA was increased to a level close to that of 5'-splice-site cleavage in the revertant viral RNA. Increased splicing at this site in 54-5A4 viral RNA is probably driven by the unavailability of the usual 3' splice site for exon ligation. The thermosensitivity of this alternate splice event suggests that the sequences governing the thermodependence of MuSVts110 RNA splicing do not involve any particular 3' splice site or branch point sequence, but rather lie near the 5' end of the intron.     

Natural base-pairing interactions between 5' splice site and branch site sequences affect mammalian 5' splice site selection.

In the murine gene encoding the neuronal cell adhesion molecule (NCAM), the integrity of the 5' splice site of exon 18 (E18) is essential for regulation of alternative splicing. To further study the contribution of 5' splice site sequences, we used a simple NCAM pre-mRNA containing a portion of E18 fused to E19 and separated by a shortened intron. This RNA is spliced in vitro to produce five sets of lariat intermediates and products, the most abundant set displaying aberrant migration in acrylamide/urea gels. Base pairing interactions between positions +5 and +8 of the intron and positions -3 and -6 from the branch point were responsible for the faster migration of this set of lariat molecules. To test whether the duplex structure forms earlier and contributes to 5' splice site selection, we used NCAM substrates carrying the 5' splice sites of E17 and E18 in competition for the 3' splice site of E19. Mutations upstream of the major branch site improve E18/E19 splicing in NIH3T3 extracts, whereas compensatory mutations at positions +7 and +8 neutralize the effect of branch site mutations and curtail E18/E19 splicing. Our data suggest that duplex formation occurs early and interferes with the assembly of complexes initiated on the 5' splice site of NCAM E18. This novel type of intron interaction may exist in the introns of other mammalian pre-mRNAs.     

Deletion mutants that alter differential RNA processing in the E3 complex transcription unit of adenovirus

Region E3 of the adenovirus encodes about ten overlapping mRNAs (a to j) with different splicing patterns and with two RNA 3' end sites termed E3A and E3B. We have examined how deletions in 12 viable virus mutants affect differential RNA processing in E3. We assayed E3 mRNAs by the nuclease-gel and RNA blot procedures. Some deletions had no effect whereas others (e.g. deletion of a 3' splice or the E3A 3' end signal) had the anticipated effects on RNA processing. However, deletions in two regions had surprising effects. Deletions in one region (nucleotides 1691 to 2044) enhanced splicing at the upstream 951 5' splice site and the downstream 2157 and/or 2880 3' splice sites. Some of these deletions prevented RNA 3' end formation at the downstream E3A site. Deletion in the other region (nucleotides 2173 to 2237) enhanced an upstream splice site (951 to 2157) such that almost all pre-mRNA was processed into mRNA f. We suggest that these two regions contain cis-acting signals that regulate differential RNA processing. We discuss the results in terms of RNA folding and scanning models for splicing, as well as models for differential RNA 3' end formation at the E3A versus the E3B site.     

Probing the structure and function of U2 snRNP with antisense oligonucleotides made of 2'-OMe RNA

We have used oligonucleotides made of 2'-OMe RNA to analyze the role of separate domains of U2 snRNA in the splicing process. We show that antisense 2'-OMe RNA oligonucleotides bind efficiently and specifically to U2 snRNP and demonstrate that masking of two separate regions of U2 snRNA can inhibit splicing by affecting different steps in the spliceosome assembly pathway. Masking the 5' terminus of U2 snRNA does not prevent U2 snRNP binding to pre-mRNA but blocks subsequent assembly of a functional spliceosome. By contrast, masking of U2 sequences complementary to the pre-mRNA branch site completely inhibits binding of pre-mRNA. Hybrid formation at the branch site complementary region also triggers a specific change which affects the 5' terminus of U2 snRNA.     

Antisense probes targeted to an internal domain in U2 snRNP specifically inhibit the second step of pre-mRNA splicing.

Functional domains within the mammalian U2 snRNP particle that are required for pre-mRNA splicing have been analysed using antisense oligonucleotides. A comparison of the melting temperatures of duplexes formed between RNA and different types of antisense oligonucleotides has demonstrated that the most stable hybrids are formed with probes made of 2'-O-allyl RNA incorporating the modified base 2-aminoadenine. We have therefore used these 2'-O-allyl probes to target sequences within the central domain of U2 snRNA. Overlapping biotinylated 2'-O-allyloligoribonucleotides complementary to the stem loop Ila region of U2 snRNA (nucleotides 54-72) specifically affinity selected U2 snRNA from HeLa nuclear extracts. These probes inhibited mRNA production in an in vitro splicing assay and caused a concomitant accumulation of splicing intermediates. Little or no inhibition of spliceosome assembly and 5' splice site cleavage was observed for all pre-mRNAs tested, indicating that the oligonucleotides were specifically inhibiting exon ligation. This effect was most striking with a 2'-O-allyloligoribonucleotide complementary to U2 snRNA nucleotides 57-68. These results provide evidence for a functional requirement for U2 snRNP in the splicing mechanism occurring after spliceosome assembly.