Double-strand breaks increase the incidence of genetic deletion associated with intermolecular recombination in bacteriophage T7

An in vitro DNA replication system based on extracts prepared from Escherichia coli cells infected with bacteriophage T7 was used to study deletion associated with the repair of double-strand breaks. The gene for T7 ligase was interrupted by a DNA insert which included 17-bp direct repeats. Deletion between the repeats restored the reading frame of the gene, and these DNA molecules could be detected by their ability to give rise to ligase-positive phage after in vitro packaging. T7 genomes that had a pre-existing double-strand break located between the direct repeats were incubated together with intact genomes which had the same direct repeats. Genetic markers placed on either side of the insert in the ligase gene allowed identification of the source of DNA molecules that underwent deletion between the direct repeats. This allowed an assessment of the participation of the molecules with strand breaks in the deletion process, under conditions where any mechanism could contribute to deletion. Approximately three-quarters of the T7 molecules that had lost the region between the direct repeats contained one or both of the partial genomes originally introduced into the reactions. About 50% of the genomes which had undergone deletion had recombined markers between the partial and intact genomes. The data demonstrate that double-strand breaks substantially enhance the contribution of intermolecular recombination to deletion. Received: 19 November 1996 / Accepted: 26 February 1997     

The effect of the length of direct repeats and the presence of palindromes on deletion between directly repeated DNA sequences in bacteriophage T7.

The frequency of genetic deletion between directly repeated DNA sequences in bacteriophage T7 was measured as a function of the length of the direct repeat. The non-essential ligase gene (gene 1.3) of bacteriophage T7 was interrupted with pieces of synthetic DNA bracketed by direct repeats of various lengths. Deletion of these 76 bp long inserts was too low to be measured when the direct repeats were less than 6 bp long. However, the frequency of deletion of inserts with longer direct repeats increased exponentially as the length of the repeats increased from 8 to 20 bp. When inverted repeats (palindromes) were designed in the midst of the insert there was essentially no increase in deletion frequency between 10 bp direct repeats. But, the same palindromic sequences increased the deletion frequency between 5 bp direct repeats by at least two orders of magnitude. Thus, in this system homology at the endpoints is a more important determinant of deletion frequency than is the presence of palindromes between the direct repeats.     

The Influence of Primary and Secondary DNA Structure in Deletion and Duplication between Direct Repeats in Escherichia Coli

We describe a system to measure the frequency of both deletions and duplications between direct repeats. Short 17- and 18-bp palindromic and nonpalindromic DNA sequences were cloned into the EcoRI site within the chloramphenicol acetyltransferase gene of plasmids pBR325 and pJT7. This creates an insert between direct repeated EcoRI sites and results in a chloramphenicol-sensitive phenotype. Selection for chloramphenicol resistance was utilized to select chloramphenicol resistant revertants that included those with precise deletion of the insert from plasmid pBR325 and duplication of the insert in plasmid pJT7. The frequency of deletion or duplication varied more than 500-fold depending on the sequence of the short sequence inserted into the EcoRI site. For the nonpalindromic inserts, multiple internal direct repeats and the length of the direct repeats appear to influence the frequency of deletion. Certain palindromic DNA sequences with the potential to form DNA hairpin structures that might stabilize the misalignment of direct repeats had a high frequency of deletion. Other DNA sequences with the potential to form structures that might destabilize misalignment of direct repeats had a very low frequency of deletion. Duplication mutations occurred at the highest frequency when the DNA between the direct repeats contained no direct or inverted repeats. The presence of inverted repeats dramatically reduced the frequency of duplications. The results support the slippage-misalignment model, suggesting that misalignment occurring during DNA replication leads to deletion and duplication mutations. The results also support the idea that the formation of DNA secondary structures during DNA replication can facilitate and direct specific mutagenic events.     

Deletion mutagenesis independent of recombination in bacteriophage T7.

Deletion between directly repeated DNA sequences in bacteriophage T7-infected Escherichia coli was examined. The phage ligase gene was interrupted by insertion of synthetic DNA designed so that the inserts were bracketed by 10-bp direct repeats. Deletion between the direct repeats eliminated the insert and restored the ability of the phage to make its own ligase. The deletion frequency of inserts of 85 bp or less was of the order of 10(-6) deletions per replication. The deletion frequency dropped sharply in the range between 85 and 94 bp and then decreased at a much lower rate over the range from 94 to 900 bp. To see whether a deletion was predominantly caused by intermolecular recombination between the leftmost direct repeat on one chromosome and the rightmost direct repeat on a distinct chromosome, genetic markers were introduced to the left and right of the insert in the ligase gene. Short deletions of 29 bp and longer deletions of approximately 350 bp were examined in this way. Phage which underwent deletion between the direct repeats had the same frequency of recombination between the left and right flanking markers as was found in controls in which no deletion events took place. These data argue against intermolecular recombination between direct repeats as a major factor in deletion in T7-infected E. coli.     

On the Deletion of Inverted Repeated DNA in Escherichia Coli: Effects of Length, Thermal Stability, and Cruciform Formation in Vivo

We have studied the deletion of inverted repeats cloned into the EcoRI site within the CAT gene of plasmid pBR325. A cloned inverted repeat constitutes a palindrome that includes both EcoRI sites flanking the insert. In addition, the two EcoRI sites represent direct repeats flanking a region of palindromic symmetry. A current model for deletion between direct repeats involves the formation of DNA secondary structure which may stabilize the misalignment between the direct repeats during DNA replication. Our results are consistent with this model. We have analyzed deletion frequencies for several series of inverted repeats, ranging from 42 to 106 bp, that were designed to form cruciforms at low temperatures and at low superhelical densities. We demonstrate that length, thermal stability of base pairing in the hairpin stem, and ease of cruciform formation affect the frequency of deletion. In general, longer palindromes are less stable than shorter ones. The deletion frequency may be dependent on the thermal stability of base pairing involving approximately 16-20 bp from the base of the hairpin stem. The formation of cruciforms in vivo leads to a significant increase in the deletion frequency. A kinetic model is presented to describe the relationship between the physical-chemical properties of DNA structure and the deletion of inverted repeats in living cells.     

Genetic deletions between directly repeated sequences in bacteriophage T7

Summary DNA sequence analysis of genetic deletions in bacteriophage T7 has shown that these chromosomal rearrangements frequently occur between directly repeated DNA sequences. To study this type of spontaneous deletion in more quantitative detail synthetic fragments of DNA, made by hybridizing two complementary oligonucleotides, were introduced into the non-essential T7 gene 1.3 which codes for T7 DNA ligase. This insert blocked synthesis of functional ligase and made the phage that carried an insert unable to form plaques on a host strain deficient in bacterial ligase. The sequence of the insert was designed so that after it is put into the T7 genome the insert is bracketed by direct repeats. Perfect deletion of the insert between the directly repeated sequences results in a wild-type phage. It was found that these deletion events are highly sensitive to the length of the direct repeats at their ends. In the case of 5 bp direct repeats excision from the genome occurred at a frequency of less than 10⁻¹⁰, while this value for an almost identical insert bracketed by 10 bp direct repeats was approximately 10⁻⁶. The deletion events were independent of a hostrecA mutation.     

The effect of the 3′ → 5′ exonuclease of T7 DNA polymerase on frameshifts and deletions

Both spontaneous frameshift mutation and deletion mutation were measured in a T7 phage deficient in the 3′ → 5′ exonuclease of T7 DNA polymerase. It was found that the absence of this exonuclease caused a marked increase in the revision of both plus one and minus one mutations. The exonuclease deficiency caused essentially no effect on the frequency of deletion between 10-bp direct repeats even when the segment between the direct repeats contained a 25-bp palindrome.     

Plasmid deletion formation between short direct repeats in Bacillus subtilis is stimulated by single-stranded rolling-circle replication intermediates

Summary The effects of the rolling-circle mode of replication and the generation of single-stranded DNA (ss DNA) on plasmid deletion formation between short direct repeats in Bacillus subtilis were studied. Deletion units consisting of direct repeats (9, 18, or 27 bp) that do or do not flank inverted repeats (300 bp) were introduced into various plasmid replicons that generate different amounts of ss DNA (from 0% to 40% of the total plasmid DNA). With ss DNA-generating rolling-circle-type plasmids, deletion frequencies between the direct repeats were 3- to 13-fold higher than in plasmids not generating ss DNA. When the direct repeats flanked inverted repeats the deletion frequencies in ss DNA-generating plasmids were increased by as much as 20- to 140-fold. These results support models for deletion formation based on template-switching errors during complementary strand synthesis of rolling-circle-type plasmids. The structural instability (deletion formation between short direct repeats) of the ss DNA-generating plasmid pTA1060 in B. subtilis was very low in the presence of a functional initiation site for complementary strand synthesis (minus origin). This observation suggests that it will be possible to develop stable host-vector cloning systems for B. subtilis.     

Deletion formation in bacteriophage T4

We have manipulated the dispensable region of the rIIB gene of bacteriophage T4 in order to study the generation of deletions involving direct repeats. We show that recombination between different parental chromosomes is one source of the deletions we have studied. We have also investigated the effects of structure, base composition and distance on deletion formation. We demonstrate that the potential to form structure in single-stranded DNA has variable effects on the frequency of deletion formation and conclude that, in some cases, slipped mispairing during DNA synthesis can make a substantial contribution to deletion frequencies. The G + C richness of the direct repeats involved in deletion formation is an important parameter of the frequency of deletion formation. We have confirmed that increasing the distance between direct repeats decreases deletion frequency.     

Structural plasmid instability in Bacillus subtilis: Effect of direct and inverted repeats

Summary Using precise excision as a model system, we have quantified the effect of direct repeats, inverted repeats and the size of the spacer between the repeats in the process of deletion formation in Bacillus subtilis. Both in the presence and absence of inverted repeats, the frequency of precise excision was strongly dependent on the direct repeat length. By increasing the direct repeat length from 9 bp to 18 and 27 bp, the precise excision frequency was raised by 3 and 4 orders of magnitude, respectively. In addition, irrespective of the direct repeat length, the presence of flanking inverted repeats enhanced the excision frequency by 3 orders of magnitude. Varying the inverted repeat length and the spacer size over a wide range did not significantly affect the excision frequencies. These results fit well into a model for deletion formation by slipped mispairing during replication of single-stranded plasmid DNA.     

High-frequency spontaneous deletion of DNA sequences flanked by direct DNA repeats which also contain an internal palindrome

The DNA sequences associated with a very high-frequency, spontaneous deletion event have been determined to be two 11-base direct repeats which also contain an internal 6-base palindrome. A parental M13 replicative form (RF) DNA harboring DNA fragments of the T4 denV gene contained these direct repeats and could only be maintained at 5% of the total RF DNA within an infected cell. The remaining RF DNA was deleted for all intervening sequences between the direct repeats (2.2-kb), but one copy of the direct repeat was retained after the deletion had occurred. This site-specific deletion was highly reproducible in that if parental-sized M13 RF DNA was gel purified and transformed back into cells, the deletion occurred at precisely the same sequence as before. Electron microscopic analyses of DNA extracted from cells transformed with parental-sized DNA revealed the presence of excised 2.2-kb double-stranded circular DNA molecules. This observation thus rules out a copy choice replication/deletion mechanism to account for this high-frequency deletion event.     

Repair of double-strand breaks by incorporation of a molecule of homologous DNA

An in vitro system based upon extracts of Escherichia coli infected with bacteriophage T7 was used to monitor repair of double-strand breaks in the T7 genome. The efficiency of double-strand break repair was markedly increased by DNA molecules ('donor' DNA) consisting of a 2.1 kb DNA fragment, generated by PCR, that had ends extending approximately 1 kb on either side of the break site. Repair proceeded with greater than 10% efficiency even when T7 DNA replication was inhibited. When the donor DNA molecules were labelled with 32P, repaired genomes incorporated label only near the site of the double-strand break. When repair was carried out with unlabelled donor DNA and [32P]-dCTP provided as precursor for DNA synthesis the small amount of incorporated label was distributed randomly throughout the entire T7 genome. Repair was performed using donor DNA that had adjacent BamHI and PstI sites. When the BamHI site was methylated and the PstI site was left unmethylated, the repaired genomes were sensitive to PstI but not to BamHI endonuclease, showing that the methyl groups at the BamHI recognition site had not been replaced by new DNA synthesis during repair of the double-strand break. These observations are most consistent with a model for double-strand break repair in which the break is widened to a small gap, which is subsequently repaired by physical incorporation of a patch of donor DNA into the gap.     

Limits to the role of palindromy in deletion formation.

We tested the effect of palindromy on deletion formation. This involved a study of reversion of insertion mutations in the pBR322 amp gene at a site where deletions end either in 9-bp direct repeats or in adjoining 4-bp direct repeats. Inserts of palindromic DNAs ranging from 10 to more than 26 bp and related nonpalindromic DNAs were compared. The frequency of deletions (selected as Ampr revertants) was stimulated by palindromy only at lengths greater than 26 bp. The 4-bp direct repeats, one component of which is located in the palindromic insert, were used preferentially as deletion endpoints with palindromes of at least 18 bp but not of 16 or 10 bp. We interpret these results with a model of slippage during DNA replication. Because deletion frequency and deletion endpoint location depend differently on palindrome length, we propose that different factors commit a molecule to undergo deletion and determine exactly where deletion endpoints will be.     

A deletion in the simian virus 40 large T antigen impairs lytic replication in monkey cells in vivo but enhances DNA replication in vitro: new complementation function of T antigen.

We describe a new complementation function within the simian virus 40 (SV40) A gene. This function is required for viral DNA replication and virus production in vivo but, surprisingly, does not affect any of the intrinsic enzymatic functions of T antigen directly required for in vitro DNA replication. Other well-characterized SV40 T-antigen mutants, whether expressed stably from integrated genomes or in cotransfection experiments, complement these mutants for in vivo DNA replication and plaque formation. These new SV40 mutants were isolated and cloned from human cells which stably carry the viral DNA. The alteration in the large-T-antigen gene was shown by marker rescue and nucleotide sequence analysis to be a deletion of 322 bp spanning the splice-donor site of the first exon, creating a 14-amino-acid deletion in the large T antigen. The mutant gene was expressed in H293 human cells from an adenovirus vector, and the protein was purified by immunoaffinity chromatography. The mutant protein directs greater levels of DNA replication in vitro than does the wild-type protein. Moreover, the mutant protein reduces the lag time for in vitro DNA synthesis and can be diluted to lower levels than wild-type T antigen and still promote good replication, which is in clear contrast to the in vivo situation. These biochemical features of the protein are independent of the source of the cellular replication factors (i.e., HeLa, H293, COS 7, or CV1 cells) and the cells from which the T antigens were purified. The mutant T antigen does not transform Rat-2 cells. Several different models which might reconcile the differences observed in vivo and in vitro are outlined. We propose that the function of T antigen affected prepares cells for SV40 replication by activation of a limiting cellular replication factor. Furthermore, a link between the induction of a cellular replication factor and transformation by SV40 is discussed.     

Replication bypass and mutagenic effect of alpha-deoxyadenosine site-specifically incorporated into single-stranded vectors.

alpha-2'-Deoxyadenosine (alpha) is a major adenine lesion produced by gamma-ray irradiation of DNA under anoxic conditions. In this study, single-stranded recombinant M13 vectors containing alpha were constructed and transfected into Escherichia coli to assess lethal and mutagenic effects of this lesion. The data for alpha were further compared with those obtained with M13 vectors containing normal A or a model abasic site (F) at the same site. The transfection assay revealed that alpha constituted a moderate block to DNA replication. The in vivo replication capacity to pass through alpha was approximately 20% relative to normal A, but 20-fold higher than that of F constituting an almost absolute replication block. Similar data were obtained by in vitro replication of oligonucleotide templates containing alpha or F by E.coli DNA polymerase I. The mutagenic consequence of replicating M13 DNA containing alpha was analyzed by direct DNA sequencing of progeny phage. Mutagenesis was totally targeted at the site of alpha introduced into the vector. Mutation was exclusively a single nucleotide deletion and no base substitutions were detected. The deletion frequency associated alpha was dependent on the 3'-nearest neighbor base: with the 3'-nearest neighbor base T mutation (deletion) frequency was 26%, whereas 1% with the 3'-nearest neighbor base G. A possible mechanism of the single nucleotide deletion associated with alpha is discussed on the basis of the misinsertion-strand slippage model.     

In Vitro Direct Repeats-mediated Deletion During PCR Amplification

While conducting our research on mutations in the human blood platelet glycoprotein Ib-alpha (GPIbalpha) gene, we detected an unusual deletion of 84 bp. This deletion took place in vitro, during PCR and between two direct repeats. It was observed that the deletion could be detected either by the direct sequencing of the PCR product or after the latter's cloning into a plasmid. After observing a series of four sequenced clones from the same individual, we noticed that while three had the same 84-bp deletion, the fourth exhibited a shorter one. We also noted that there were no cases wherein both deleted and undeleted amplicons coexisted and that several point mutations occurred in the sequence surrounding the deletion. Such Taq errors are statistically more frequent in the "deletion prone DNA" than usual. Interestingly, the deletion was observed only in a DNA, which we call here "deletion prone DNA", whose structure might have been particularly reorganized. Indeed, the mung bean nuclease pre-treatment of this DNA prior to PCR prevented the deletion, thus strengthening the hypothesis that an intra-strand hairpin structure was involved in the deletion process. Direct repeats-mediated deletion is well known in vivo but this is the first report of such "in vitro direct repeats deletion".     

A Replicational Model for DNA Recombination between Direct Repeats

DNA rearrangement (recombination) mediated by direct repeats is a major cause of genome instability. InEscherichia coli, direct repeats in close proximity can mediate efficientrecA-independent intramolecular recombi nation, which produces multiple products. Using plasmid substrates, three basic forms of products have been revealed: the monomeric deletion product and two dimeric products. The frequency of recombination has been shown to be affected by structural factors such as the length of the repeat and the distance between the repeats. We show here that these factors also affect the relative abundance of each form of product. Recombination between very short tandem repeats yields exclusively the monomeric product. Lengthening the repeats increases the abundance of the dimeric products. Increasing the distance separating the repeats sharply reduces the formation of the monomeric product. These results can be explained by a model for DNA rearrangement (recombination) involving DNA replication. We propose that misalignment of the repeats at the replication fork creates a recombinogenic intermediate that can be differentially processed to form the three basic products. The proposed sister-strand recombination mediated by direct repeats might be a general mechanism for deletion and/or amplification of repeated sequences in both prokaryotic and eukaryotic genomes.     

Dinucleotide repeat expansion catalyzed by bacteriophage T4 DNA polymerase in vitro

DNA replication normally occurs with high fidelity, but certain "slippery" regions of DNA with tracts of mono-, di-, and trinucleotide repeats are frequently mutation hot spots. We have developed an in vitro assay to study the mechanism of dinucleotide repeat expansion. The primer-template resembles a base excision repair substrate with a single nucleotide gap centered opposite a tract of nine CA repeats; nonrepeat sequences flank the dinucleotide repeats. DNA polymerases are expected to repair the gap, but further extension is possible if the DNA polymerase can displace the downstream oligonucleotide. We report here that the wild type bacteriophage T4 DNA polymerase carries out gap and strand displacement replication and also catalyzes a dinucleotide expansion reaction. Repeat expansion was not detected for an exonuclease-deficient T4 DNA polymerase or for Escherichia coli DNA polymerase I. The dinucleotide repeat expansion reaction catalyzed by wild type T4 DNA polymerase required a downstream oligonucleotide to "stall" replication and 3' --> 5' exonuclease activity to remove the 3'-nonrepeat sequence adjacent to the repeat tract in the template strand. These results suggest that dinucleotide repeat expansion may be stimulated in vivo during DNA repair or during processing of Okazaki fragments.     

In vitro repair of double-strand breaks accompanied by recombination in bacteriophage T7 DNA.

A double-strand break in a bacteriophage T7 genome significantly reduced the ability of that DNA to produce viable phage when the DNA was incubated in an in vitro DNA replication and packaging system. When a homologous piece of T7 DNA (either a restriction fragment or T7 DNA cloned into a plasmid) that was by itself unable to form a complete phage was included in the reaction, the break was repaired to the extent that many more viable phage were produced. Moreover, repair could be completed even when a gap of about 900 nucleotides was put in the genome by two nearby restriction cuts. The repair was accompanied by acquisition of a genetic marker that was present only on the restriction fragment or on the T7 DNA cloned into a plasmid. These data are interpreted in light of the double-strand gap repair mode of recombination.     

Evidence for two mechanisms of palindrome-stimulated deletion in Escherichia coli: single-strand annealing and replication slipped mispairing

Spontaneous deletion mutations often occur at short direct repeats that flank inverted repeat sequences. Inverted repeats may initiate genetic rearrangements by formation of hairpin secondary structures that block DNA polymerases or are processed by structure-specific endonucleases. We have investigated the ability of inverted repeat sequences to stimulate deletion of flanking direct repeats in Escherichia coli. Propensity for cruciform extrusion in duplex DNA correlated with stimulation of flanking deletion, which was partially sbcD dependent. We propose two mechanisms for palindrome-stimulated deletion, SbcCD dependent and SbcCD independent. The SbcCD-dependent mechanism is initiated by SbcCD cleavage of cruciforms in duplex DNA followed by RecA-independent single-strand annealing at the flanking direct repeats, generating a deletion. Analysis of deletion endpoints is consistent with this model. We propose that the SbcCD-independent pathway involves replication slipped mispairing, evoked from stalling at hairpin structures formed on the single-stranded lagging-strand template. The skew of SbcCD-independent deletion endpoints with respect to the direction of replication supports this hypothesis. Surprisingly, even in the absence of palindromes, SbcD affected the location of deletion endpoints, suggesting that SbcCD-mediated strand processing may also accompany deletion unassociated with secondary structures.