On the binding of Thioflavin-T to HET-s amyloid fibrils assembled at pH 2

Amyloid fibrils are ordered β-sheet protein or peptide polymers. The benzothiazole dye Thioflavin-T (ThT) shows a strong increase in fluorescence upon binding to amyloid fibrils and has hence become the most commonly used amyloid-specific dye. In spite of this widespread use, the mechanism underlying specific binding and fluorescence enhancement upon interaction with amyloid fibrils remains largely unknown. Recent contradictory reports have proposed radically different modes of binding. We have studied the interaction of ThT with fibrils of the prion forming domain of the fungal HET-s prion protein assembled at pH 2 in order to try to gain some insight into the general mechanism of ThT-binding and fluorescence. We found that ThT does not bind to HET-s(218–289) fibrils as a micelle as previously proposed in the case of insulin fibrils. We have measured binding kinetics, affinity and stoichiometry at pH values above and below the pI of the HET-s(218–289) fibrils and found that binding is dramatically affected by pH and ionic strength. Binding is poor at acidic pH, presumably as a result of repulsive electrostatic interaction between the positively charged ThT molecule and the fibril surface. Finally, we found that ThT acquires chiral properties when it is fibril-bound. These results are discussed in relation to the different ThT-binding modes that have been proposed.     

Thioflavin T interaction with amyloid fibrils as an instrument for their studying

Benzthiazole dye thioflavin T (ThT) is widely used to study the formation and structure of amyloid fibrils. Nevertheless, till now there is no common opinion concerning molecular mechanisms of ThT binding to amyloid fibrils and the reasons of dramatic increase in its fluorescence quantum yield on incorporation into amyloid fibrils. Our data prove that ThT molecules incorporate in the amyloid fibrils in the monomeric form and there is no ground to suppose the formation of ThT dimers, eximers, or micells. It was shown that the increase in the quantum yield of ThT incorporated in amyloid fibrils was caused by restriction of benzthiazole and aminobenzene rings torsion fluctuations relative to each other. The use of equilibrium microdialysis allowed determining the absorption spectrum, the number of binding modes of ThT with insulin amyloid fibrils and for each mode determining the binding constants and the number of binding sites for each mode.     

Pitfalls associated with the use of Thioflavin-T to monitor anti-fibrillogenic activity

Thioflavin-T (ThT) is a cationic benzothiazole dye that displays enhanced fluorescence upon binding to amyloid fibrils. This property makes ThT the current reagent of choice for the quantification of amyloid fibrils. Herein, we investigate the main pitfalls associated with the use of ThT-based assays to monitor the fibrillation of α-synuclein (α-syn), a protein linked to Parkinson’s disease and other α-synucleinopathies. We demonstrated for the first time that ThT interacts with α-syn disordered monomer and accelerates the protein fibrillation in vitro. As a consequence, misleading conclusions may arise from the use of ThT-based real-time assays in the evaluation of anti-fibrillogenic compounds. Interestingly, NMR experiments indicated that C-terminal domain of α-syn is the main region perturbed by ThT interaction, similarly to that found for the pesticide paraquat, a well-documented accelerator of α-syn fibrillation. Moreover, we demonstrated that certain potent inhibitors of α-syn fibrillation, such as oxidized catecholamines and polyphenols, undergo spontaneous oxidation in aqueous solution, generating compounds that strongly quench ThT fluorescence. In light of these findings, we alert for possible artifacts associated to the measure of the anti-fibrillogenic activity based only on ThT fluorescence approach.     

Fluorescence quantum yield of thioflavin T in rigid isotropic solution and incorporated into the amyloid fibrils

In this work, the fluorescence of thioflavin T (ThT) was studied in a wide range of viscosity and temperature. It was shown that ThT fluorescence quantum yield varies from 0.0001 in water at room temperature to 0.28 in rigid isotropic solution (T/η→0). The deviation of the fluorescence quantum yield from unity in rigid isotropic solution suggests that fluorescence quantum yield depends not only on the ultra-fast oscillation of ThT fragments relative to each other in an excited state as was suggested earlier, but also depends on the molecular configuration in the ground state. This means that the fluorescence quantum yield of the dye incorporated into amyloid fibrils must depend on its conformation, which, in turn, depends on the ThT environment. Therefore, the fluorescence quantum yield of ThT incorporated into amyloid fibrils can differ from that in the rigid isotropic solution. In particular, the fluorescence quantum yield of ThT incorporated into insulin fibrils was determined to be 0.43. Consequently, the ThT fluorescence quantum yield could be used to characterize the peculiarities of the fibrillar structure, which opens some new possibilities in the ThT use for structural characterization of the amyloid fibrils.     

Study on the binding of Thioflavin T to beta-sheet-rich and non-beta-sheet cavities

Amyloid fibril formation plays a role in more than 20 diseases including Alzheimer's disease. In vitro detection of these fibrils is often performed using Thioflavin T (ThT), though the ThT binding mode is largely unknown. In the present study, spectral properties of ThT in binding environments representing beta-sheet-rich and non-beta-sheet cavities were examined. Acetylcholinesterase and gamma-cyclodextrin induced a characteristic ThT fluorescence similar to that with amyloid fibrils, whereas beta-cyclodextrin and the beta-sheet-rich transthyretin did not. The cavities of acetylcholinesterase and gamma-cyclodextrin were of similar diameter and only these cavities could accommodate two ThT ions according to molecular modelling. Binding stoichiometry studies also showed a possible binding of two ThT ions. Thus, the characteristic ThT fluorescence is induced in cavities with a diameter of 8-9A and a length able to accommodate the entire length of the ThT ion. The importance of a cavity diameter capable of binding two ThT ions, among others, indicates that an excimer formation is a plausible mechanism for the characteristic fluorescence. We propose a similar ThT binding mode in amyloid fibrils, where cavities of an appropriate size running parallel to the fibril axis have previously been proposed in several amyloid fibril models.     

Direct observation of amyloid fibril growth monitored by thioflavin T fluorescence

Real-time monitoring of fibril growth is essential to clarify the mechanism of amyloid fibril formation. Thioflavin T (ThT) is a reagent known to become strongly fluorescent upon binding to amyloid fibrils. Here, we show that, by monitoring ThT fluorescence with total internal reflection fluorescence microscopy (TIRFM), amyloid fibrils of beta2-microgobulin (beta2-m) can be visualized without requiring covalent fluorescence labeling. One of the advantages of TIRFM would be that we selectively monitor fibrils lying along the slide glass, so that we can obtain the exact length of fibrils. This method was used to follow the kinetics of seed-dependent beta2-m fibril extension. The extension was unidirectional with various rates, suggesting the heterogeneity of the amyloid structures. Since ThT binding is common to all amyloid fibrils, the present method will have general applicability for the analysis of amyloid fibrils. We confirmed this with the octapeptide corresponding to the C terminus derived from human medin and the Alzheimer's amyloid beta-peptide.     

Analyzing thioflavin T binding to amyloid fibrils by an equilibrium microdialysis-based technique

A new approach for the determination of the amyloid fibril - thioflavin T (ThT) binding parameters (the number of binding modes, stoichiometry, and binding constants of each mode) is proposed. This approach is based on the absorption spectroscopy determination of the concentration of free and bound to fibril dye in solutions, which are prepared by equilibrium microdialysis. Furthermore, the proposed approach allowed us, for the first time, to determine the absorption spectrum, molar extinction coefficient, and fluorescence quantum yield of the ThT bound to fibril by each binding modes. This approach is universal and can be used for determining the binding parameters of any dye interaction with a receptor, such as ANS binding to proteins in the molten globule state or to protein amorphous aggregates.     

Interactions between amyloidophilic dyes and their relevance to studies of amyloid inhibitors

Amyloid fibrils are filamentous aggregates of peptides and proteins implicated in a range of neurodegenerative disorders such as Alzheimer's and Parkinson's diseases. It has been known almost since their discovery that these β-sheet-rich proteinacious assemblies bind a range of specific dyes that, combined with other biophysical techniques, are convenient probes of the process of amyloid fibril formation. Two prominent examples of such dyes are Congo red (CR) and Thioflavin T (ThT). It has been reported that in addition to having a diagnostic role, CR is an inhibitor of the formation of amyloid structures, and these two properties have both been explained in terms of the same specific noncovalent interactions between the fibrils and the dye molecules. In this article, we show by means of quartz-crystal microbalance measurements that the binding of both ThT and CR to amyloid fibrils formed by the peptide whose aggregation is associated with Alzheimer's disease, Aβ(1-42), can be directly observed, and that the presence of CR interferes with the binding of ThT. Light scattering and fluorescence measurements confirm that an interaction exists between these dyes that can interfere with their ability to reflect accurately the quantity of amyloid material present in a given sample. Furthermore, we show that CR does not inhibit the process of amyloid fibril elongation, and therefore demonstrate the ability of the quartz-crystal microbalance method not only to detect and study the binding of small molecules to amyloid fibrils, but also to elucidate the mode of action of potential inhibitors.     

Binding Modes of Thioflavin-T to the Single-Layer β-Sheet of the Peptide Self-Assembly Mimics

Although the amyloid dye thioflavin-T (ThT) is among the most widely used tools in the study of amyloid fibrils, the mechanism by which ThT binds to fibrils and other β-rich peptide self-assemblies remains elusive. The development of the water-soluble peptide self-assembly mimic (PSAM) system has provided a set of ideal model proteins for experimentally exploring the properties and minimal dye-binding requirements of amyloid fibrils. PSAMs consist of a single-layer β-sheet (SLB) capped by two globular domains, which capture the flat, extended β-sheet features common among fibril-like surfaces. Recently, a PSAM that binds to ThT with amyloid-like affinity (low micromolar K_d) has been designed, and its crystal structure in the absence of bound ThT was determined. This PSAM thus provides a unique opportunity to examine the interactions of ThT with a β-rich structure. Here, we present molecular dynamics simulations of the binding of ThT to this PSAM β-sheet. We show that the primary binding site for ThT is along a shallow groove formed by adjacent Tyr and Leu residues on the β-sheet surface. These simulations provide an atomic-scale rationale for this PSAM's experimentally determined dye-binding properties. Together, our results suggest that an aromatic-hydrophobic groove spanning across four consecutive β-strands represents a minimal ThT binding site on amyloid fibrils. Grooves formed by aromatic-hydrophobic residues on amyloid fibril surfaces may therefore offer a generic mode of recognition for amyloid dyes.     

Binding mode of Thioflavin T in insulin amyloid fibrils

Amyloid fibrils share various common structural features and their presence can be detected by Thioflavin T (ThT). In this paper, the binding mode of ThT to insulin amyloid fibrils was examined. Scatchard analysis and isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) showed at least two binding site populations. The binding site population with the strongest binding was responsible for the characteristic ThT fluorescence. This binding had a capacity of about 0.1 moles of ThT bound per mole of insulin in fibril form. The binding capacity was unaffected by pH, but the affinity was lowest at low pH. Notably, presence of a third binding process prior to the other processes was suggested by ITC. Binding of ThT resulted in only minor changes in the fibril structure according to the X-ray diffraction patterns, where a slightly more dominant equatorial reflection at 16A relative to the intersheet distance of 11A was observed. No change in the interstrand distance of 4.8A was observed. On the basis of our results, we propose that ThT binds in cavities running parallel to the fibril axis, e.g., between the protofilaments forming the fibrils. Such cavities have been proposed previously in insulin fibrils and several other amyloid fibril models.     

The binding of thioflavin T and its neutral analog BTA-1 to protofibrils of the Alzheimer's disease Abeta(16-22) peptide probed by molecular dynamics simulations

Thioflavin T (ThT) is a fluorescent dye commonly used to stain amyloid plaques, but the binding sites of this dye onto fibrils are poorly characterized. We present molecular dynamics simulations of the binding of ThT and its neutral analog BTA-1 [2-(4'-methylaminophenyl)benzothiazole] to model protofibrils of the Alzheimer's disease Abeta(16-22) (amyloid beta) peptide. Our simulations reveal two binding modes located at the grooves of the beta-sheet surfaces and at the ends of the beta-sheet. These simulations provide new insight into recent experimental work and allow us to characterize the high-capacity, micromolar-affinity site seen in experiment as binding to the beta-sheet surface grooves and the low-capacity, nanomolar-affinity site seen as binding to the beta-sheet extremities of the fibril. The structure-activity relationship upon mutating charged ThT to neutral BTA-1 in terms of increased lipophilicity and binding affinity was studied, with calculated solvation free energies and binding energies found to be in qualitative agreement with the experimental measurements.     

Interaction of Thioflavin T with amyloid fibrils of apolipoprotein A-I N-terminal fragment: Resonance energy transfer study

Apolipoprotein A-I is amenable to a number of specific mutations associated with hereditary systemic amyloidoses. Amyloidogenic properties of apoA-I are determined mainly by its N-terminal fragment. In the present study Förster resonance energy transfer between tryptophan as a donor and Thioflavin T as an acceptor was employed to obtain structural information on the amyloid fibrils formed by apoA-I variant 1-83/G26R/W@8. Analysis of the dye-fibril binding data provided evidence for the presence of two types of ThT binding sites with similar stoichiometries (bound dye to monomeric protein molar ratio ∼10), but different association constants (∼6 and 0.1 μM⁻¹) and ThT quantum yields in fibril-associated state (0.08 and 0.05, respectively). A β-strand–loop–β-strand structural model of 1-83/G26R/W@8 apoA-I fibrils has been proposed, with potential ThT binding sites located in the solvent-exposed grooves of the N-terminal β-sheet layer. Reasoning from the expanded FRET analysis allowing for heterogeneity of ThT binding centers and fibril polymorphism, the most probable locations of high- and low-affinity ThT binding sites were attributed to the grooves T16_Y18 and D20_L22, respectively.     

Binding mode of Thioflavin T and other molecular probes in the context of amyloid fibrils—current status

Because understanding amyloid fibrillation in molecular detail is essential for development of strategies to control amyloid formation and overcome neurodegenerative disorders, increased understanding of present molecular probes as well as development of new probes are of utmost importance. To date, the binding modes of these molecular probes to amyloid fibrils are by no means adequately described or understood, and the large number of studies on Thioflavin T (ThT) and Congo Red (CR) binding have resulted in models that are incomplete and conflicting. Different types of binding sites are likely to be present in amyloid fibrils with differences in binding modes. ThT may bind in channels running parallel to the long axis of the fibril. In the channels, ThT may bind in either a monomeric or dimeric form of which the molecular conformation is likely to be planar. CR may bind in grooves formed along the β-sheets as a planar molecule in either a monomeric or supramolecular form.     

l-Arginine reduces thioflavin T fluorescence but not fibrillation of bovine serum albumin

This work examines the effects of l-arginine (l-Arg) on the aggregation and amyloid fibrillation of bovine serum albumin (BSA). We demonstrate that l-Arg dose-dependently reduces thioflavin T (ThT) fluorescence of BSA within the l-Arg concentration range used (0–1.4 M). However, as revealed by electron microscopy, size exclusion chromatography, and dynamic light scattering results, l-Arg does not prevent amyloid-like fibril formation by BSA. We conclude that l-Arg competes against ThT for binding sites on BSA amyloid-like fibrils, leading to biased results in ThT fluorescence measurements. Moreover, the use of ThT fluorescence assay to screen for potential inhibitors against amyloid fibrillation can give misleading results.     

Thioflavin T fluorescence anisotropy: an alternative technique for the study of amyloid aggregation

The process of amyloid polymerisation raises keen interest in particular because of the biomedical impact of this process. A variety of analytical methods have been developed to monitor amyloid formation. Thioflavin T (ThT) is the most commonly used dye for detection of amyloid aggregation. Nevertheless, ThT fluorescence enhancement is strongly dependent of fibril morphology. In this study using the HET-s prion fibril model, we show that amyloid formation can be monitored by measuring ThT fluorescence anisotropy. Kinetic parameters obtained by this method are identical to those determined by CD spectrometry. We propose that ThT anisotropy represent an interesting, simple and alternative technique to analyze the amyloid formation process.     

On the origin of the stronger binding of PIB over thioflavin T to protofibrils of the Alzheimer amyloid-β peptide: a molecular dynamics study

Pittsburgh compound B (PIB) is a neutral derivative of the fluorescent dye Thioflavin T (ThT), which displays enhanced hydrophobicity and binding affinity to amyloid fibrils. We present molecular dynamics simulations of binding of PIB and ThT to a common cross-β-subunit of the Alzheimer Amyloid-β peptide (Aβ). Our simulations of binding to Aβ(9-40) protofibrils show that PIB, like ThT, selectively binds to the hydrophobic or aromatic surface grooves on the β-sheet surface along the fibril axis. The lack of two methyl groups and charge in PIB not only improves its hydrophobicity but also leads to a deeper insertion of PIB compared to ThT into the surface grooves. This significantly increases the steric, aromatic, and hydrophobic interactions, and hence leads to stronger binding. Simulations on protofibrils consisting of the more-toxic Aβ(17-42) revealed an additional binding mode in which PIB and ThT insert into the channel that forms in the loop region of the protofibril, sandwiched between two sheet layers. Our simulations indicate that the rotation between the two ring parts of the dyes is significantly more restricted when the dyes are bound to the surface of the cross-β-subunits or to the channel inside the Aβ(17-42) cross-β-subunit, compared with free solution. The specific conformations of the dyes are influenced by small chemical modifications (ThT versus PIB) and by the environment in which the dye is placed.     

Specific in situ discrimination of amyloid fibrils versus α-helical fibres by the fluorophore NIAD-4

A wide range of human pathologies, including neurodegenerative diseases and other forms of amyloidosis, are associated with the formation of insoluble fibrillar protein aggregates known as amyloids. To gain insights into this process analytical methods are needed, which give quantitative data on the molecular events that are taking place. The dye Thioflavin T (ThT) is widely used for the spectroscopic determination of amyloid fibril formation. Different binding affinities to amyloids at neutral and acidic pH and the frequently observed poor binding at acidic pH are problematic in the use of the cationic ThT. The uncharged fluorescence probe [[5'-(4-hydroxyphenyl)[2,2'-bithiophen]-5-yl]methylene]-propanedinitrile (NIAD-4) has been recently designed by Swager and coworkers, in order to eliminate some of the limitations of ThT. Here we have used this novel dye for in vitro monitoring of the amyloid formation processes of de novo designed model peptides. Amyloid structures were successfully detected by NIAD-4 at neutral as well as acidic pH and no significant fluorescence was detectable in the presence of α-helical fibres. Thus, NIAD-4 proved to be a valuable alternative to ThT for spectroscopic studies on amyloid structures over a broad pH range.     

K114 (trans,trans)‐bromo‐2,5‐bis(4‐hydroxystyryl)benzene is an efficient detector of cationic amyloid fibrils

Cationic amyloid fibrils found in human semen enhance the transmission of the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) and thus, are named semen‐derived enhancer of virus infection (SEVI). The mechanism for the enhancement of transmission is not completely understood but it has been proposed that SEVI neutralizes the repulsion that exists between the negatively charged viral envelope and host cell membrane. Consistent with this view, here we show that the fluorescence of cationic thioflavin T (ThT) in the presence of SEVI is weak, and thus ThT is not an efficient detector of SEVI. On the other hand, K114 ((trans, trans)‐bromo‐2,5‐bis(4‐hydroxystyryl)benzene) forms a highly fluorescent, phenolate‐like species on the cationic surface of SEVI. This species does not form in the presence of amyloid fibrils from insulin and amyloid‐β protein, both of which are efficiently detected by ThT fluorescence. Together, our results show that K114 is an efficient detector of SEVI.     

Interference of low‐molecular substances with the thioflavin‐T fluorescence assay of amyloid fibrils

Abnormal fibrillization of amyloidogenic peptides/proteins has been linked to various neurodegenerative diseases such as Alzheimer's and Parkinson's disease as well as with type‐II diabetes mellitus. The kinetics of protein fibrillization is commonly studied by using a fluorescent dye Thioflavin T (ThT) that binds to protein fibrils and exerts increased fluorescence intensity in bound state. Recently, it has been demonstrated that several low‐molecular weight compounds like Basic Blue 41, Basic Blue 12, Azure C, and Tannic acid interfere with the fluorescence of ThT bound to Alzheimers' amyloid‐β fibrils and cause false positive results during the screening of fibrillization inhibitors. In the current study, we demonstrated that the same selected substances also decrease the fluorescence signal of ThT bound to insulin fibrils already at submicromolar or micromolar concentrations. Kinetic experiments show that unlike to true inhibitors, these compounds did neither decrease the fibrillization rate nor increase the lag‐period. Absence of soluble insulin in the end of the experiment confirmed that these compounds do not disaggregate the insulin fibrils and, thus, are not fibrillization inhibitors at concentrations studied. Our results show that interference with ThT test is a general phenomenon and more attention has to be paid to interpretation of kinetic results of protein fibrillization obtained by using fluorescent dyes. Copyright © 2011 European Peptide Society and John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.