Basal medium development for serum-free culture: a historical perspective

The evolution of basal synthetic formulations to support mammalian cell culture applications has been facilitated by the contributions of many investigators. Definition of minimally-required nutrient categories by Harry Eagle in the 1950's spawned an iterative process of continuous modification and refinement of the exogenous environment to cultivate new cell types and to support emerging applications of cultured mammalian cells. Key historical elements are traced, leading to the development of high potency, basal nutrient formulations capable of sustaining serum-free proliferation and biological production. Emerging techniques for alimentation of fed batch and continuous perfusion bioreactors, using partial nutrient concentrates deduced from spent medium analysis, can enhance medium utilization and bioreactor productivity.     

In vitro development of Cryptosporidium parvum in serum-free media

AIM: To compare commercially available serum-free media with common, standard, growth medium for their ability to support growth of Cryptosporidium parvum in HCT-8 cell cultures. METHODS AND RESULTS: Twelve serum-free media formulations with or without additional supplements were tested against a standard growth medium containing 2% FBS in HCT-8 cell cultures. After a 48-h incubation period, the level of parasite development was determined by ELISA. The extent of development in the serum-free media was determined as a percentage of infections compared with those obtained using a standard growth medium. CONCLUSIONS: Several of the serum-free media formulations, which included MDCK, UltraMDCK, PC-1, UltraCHO and UltraCulture, compared favourably with a traditional, standard growth medium. Moreover, increasing FBS concentrations to 10% actually resulted in an overall decrease in development in many cultures. SIGNIFICANCE AND IMPACT OF THE STUDY: Several serum-free medium formulations are available which allow development of C. parvumin vitro at levels comparable with standard media employing FBS. These serum-free media are particularly useful for applications, which may require a more defined medium without the presence of FBS. Moreover, the elimination of FBS as a variable allows investigators the ability to more closely regulate their experimental systems when growing C. parvum in cell cultures.     

Three-dimensional culture of human tumor cells under standardized medium conditions

The 3-dimensional culture of human tumor spheroids under standardized medium conditions may reveal information on specific biological parameters that could be masked in serum-supplemented media. Spheroids derived from human tumor cells are growth retarded in media free of serum. Ex-Cyte IV is a substance derived from human blood that can be used to improve growth in tissue culture. In this study the growth of spheroids from four different human tumor cell lines was studied when grown in medium free of serum, medium supplemented with varying concentrations Ex-Cyte IV, and medium supplemented with foetal calf serum (FCS). The parameters used for comparisons were growth rate, growth enhancement, clonogenicity and cell cycle distribution.The four cell lines showed different growth rates in serum-free medium, which were increased to different extents when Ex-Cyte IV or FCS were added. The growth enhancing effect induced by Ex-Cyte IV was differently concentration dependent for each cell line. The clonogenicity of cells grown as spheroids in serum-free medium was lower than in spheroids grown in supplemented media. There was no difference in clonogenicity between the differently supplemented media. All four cell lines responded to growth in serum-free medium with a drop in the S-phase and G2M phase.The present study provides a novel approach to the study of human tumor cells in 3-dimensional culture under defined conditions. The human serum derived substance Ex-Cyte IV may provide a method to obtain information on specific biological parameters that could be masked in serum-supplemented media.     

Human macrovascular endothelial cells: Optimization of culture conditions

Summary The purpose of this study is to identify optimal culture conditions to support the proliferation of human macrovascular endothelial cells. Two cell lines were employed: human saphenous vein endothelial cells (HSVEC) and human umbilical vein endothelial cells (HUVEC). The influence of basal nutrient media (14 types), fetal bovine serum (FBS), and mitogens (three types) were investigated in relation to cell proliferation. Additionally, a variety of extracellular matrix (ECM) substrate-coated culture dishes were also tested. The most effective nutrient medium in augmenting cell proliferation was MCDB 131. Compared to the more commonly used M199 medium, MCDB 131 resulted in a 2.3-fold increase in cell proliferation. Media containing 20% FBS increased cell proliferation 7.5-fold compared to serum-free media. Among the mitogens tested, heparin (50 μg/ml) and endothelial cell growth supplement (ECGS) (50μg/ml) significantly improved cell proliferation. Epithelial growth factor (EGF) provided no improvement in cell proliferation. There were no statistical differences in cell proliferation or morphology when endothelial cells were grown on uncoated culture plates compared to plates coated with ECM proteins: fibronectin, laminin, gelatin, or collagen types I and IV. The culture environment yielding maximal HSVEC and HUVEC proliferation is MCDB 131 nutrient medium supplemented with 2 mM glutamine, 20% FBS, 50 μg/ml heparin, and 50 μg/ml ECGS. The ECM substrate-coated culture dishes offer no advantage.     

Decreasing variability in your cell culture

Culturing mammalian cells has not significantly changed in almost 50 years. Typically, a synthetic basal medium is chosen to meet the environmental and nutritional requirements of a given cell line. Components, such as amino acids, vitamins, inorganic salts, and a carbon source such as glucose are commonly found in the classical basal media formulation. These basal formulations normally will not support cell growth alone, but must be further supplemented with animal serum, usually fetal bovine serum (FBS) at a concentration of 5-20%. Recent advances in serum-free and chemically defined media formulations have provided cell culturists with options. When considering FDA regulations and potential risks to human health when manufacturing biologics or considering cell therapies, eliminating serum is of paramount concern. For a large majority of researchers however, using classical media with serum builds on previous generations of research and makes cell culture easier to perform.     

Characterization of bovine oviduct epithelial cell monolayers cultured under serum-free conditions

Summary We have developed a culture system for early bovine embryos in serum-free media conditioned by oviduct cell monolayers. A gentle mechanical procedure for oviduct cell isolation has been applied for this purpose avoiding the use of proteolytic enzymes. The aim of the present study was to identify the cell types present in the monolayers and to examine their fate in primary culture in serum-free or in serum-containing media by means of electronmicroscopical, immunocytochemical, and biochemical analyses. The cell dissociation procedure yielded two cell populations: ciliary cells and secretory cells that gradually dedifferentiate during culture. These cells formed a confluent monolayer after 6 d of culture in Tissue Culture Medium 199 medium supplemented with 10% fetal calf serum. Confluent cells displayed a typical epithelial cell morphology as assessed by phase contrast and electron microscopy and all the cells contained cytokeratin filaments as determined by immunocytochemistry. The overall histoarchitecture of the monolayer was preserved after washing and further culture for 7 d in serum-free medium. However, some degenerative signs indicate that the serum-free culture should not be extended for more than 7 d. Confluent oviduct cells also maintained their metabolic and protein secretory activity when deprived of serum. Total protein content in the culture supernatant linearly increased as a function of time and numerous peaks were detected after separation of proteins by high performance ion exchange chromatography. Protein elution patterns were reproducible and most of the proteins present in the culture medium were neosynthesized as determined by the incorporation of radiolabeled amino acids into nondialyzable proteins.     

Growth of neural cell cultures in a chemically defined,serum-free culture medium

The composition of a serum-free, completely chemically defined culture medium which supports active growth of dissociated neural-cells in culture is described. This serum-free medium can also be used to grow many types of human cell lines without modification. It is the first report which describes the development of a wholly chemically defined, synthetic culture medium for growth of neural cells.     

Muscle cell culture as a tool in animal growth research

Muscle cell culture techniques have been used for several years in research on muscle growth and development. Several types of culture systems have been devised, including primary cultures from embryonic or postnatal muscle and myogenic cell lines. In addition, serum-free and serum-containing media have been developed to address specific muscle development questions. Many of these questions center around muscle cell differentiation and muscle cell physiology; and, more recently, muscle cell cultures have been used as bioassay tools for examining growth physiology in domestic animals. In our laboratory, skeletal muscle satellite cells have been studied in vitro to evaluate the effect of several protein hormones and growth factors on satellite cell proliferation and differentiation. Of the hormones examined, only the insulin-like growth factors/somatomedins and fibroblast growth factor have been shown to have a stimulatory effect on proliferation that could be physiologically significant. None of the major anterior pituitary hormones interacted directly with satellite cells to stimulate proliferation. With advances in serum-free medium formulations and cell separation techniques, more information can be obtained from experiments with muscle cell cultures. With appropriate design and interpretation, our knowledge of muscle growth in domestic animals will be expanded.     

Xeno-free chondrogenesis of bone marrow mesenchymal stromal cells: towards clinical-grade chondrocyte production

Current cell-based cartilage therapies relay on articular cartilage-derived autologous chondrocytes as a cell source, which possesses disadvantages, such as, donor site morbidity and dedifferentiation of chondrocytes during in vitro expansion. Due to these and other limitations, novel cell sources and production strategies are needed. Bone marrow-derived mesenchymal stromal cells (BM-MSCs) are a fascinating alternative, but they are not spontaneously capable of producing hyaline cartilage-like repair tissue in vivo. In vitro pre-differentiation of BM-MSCs could be used to produce chondrocytes for clinical applications. However, clinically compatible defined and xeno-free differentiation protocol is lacking. Hence, this study aimed to develop such chondrogenic differentiation medium for human BM-MSCs. We assessed the feasibility of the medium using three human BM-MSCs donors and validated the method by comparing BM-MSCs to three other cell types holding potential for articular cartilage repair. The effectiveness of the method was compared to conventional serum-free and commercially available chondrogenic differentiation media. The results show that the defined xeno-free differentiation medium is at least as efficient as conventionally used serum-free chondrogenic medium and performed significantly better on all cell types tested compared to the commercially available chondrogenic medium.     

Serum-free media for cultures of primitive and mature hematopoietic cells

The in vitro culture of human hematopoietic cells has many research and therapeutic applications. Traditionally, human hematopoietic cultures have been conducted using serum-containing media. The disadvantages inherent in the use of serum could be eliminated by the use of serum-free media. In this review, we summarize and discuss the current status of serum-free media for both mature and immature human hematopoietic cells. The mature hematopoietic cells discussed are of lymphoid (e.g., lymphokine activated killer cells and tumor infiltrating lymphocytes) and myeloid origin (e.g., monocytes/macrophages). The cultures of immature hematopoietic cells discussed are clonogenic and long-term cultures. In addition, we briefly review the types of human hematopoietic cells, their clinical applications, and the basic strategies and components used to formulate serum-free media, Finally, we outline future requirements and directions in the development of serum-free media for primitive hematopoietic cells.     

Stirred culture of peripheral and cord blood hematopoietic cells offers advantages over traditional static systems for clinically relevant applications

The ability to culture hematopoietic cells in readily characterizable and scalable stirred systems, combined with the capability to utilize serum-free medium, will aid the development of clinically attractive bioreactor systems for transplantation therapies. We thus examined the proliferation and differentiation characteristics of peripheral blood (PB) mononuclear cells (MNC), cord blood (CB) MNC, and PB CD34(+) cells in spinner flasks and (control) T-flask cultures in both serum-containing and serum-free media. Hematopoietic cultures initiated from all sources examined (PB MNC, CB MNC, and PB CD34(+) cells) grew well in spinner vessels with either serum-containing or serum-free medium. Culture proliferation in spinner flasks was dependent on both agitator design and RPM as well as on the establishment of critical inoculum densities (ID) in both serum-containing (2 x 10(5) MNC/mL) and serum-free (3 x 10(5) MNC/mL) media. Spinner flask culture of PB MNC in serum-containing medium provided superior expansion of total cells and colony-forming cells (CFC) at high ID (1.2 x 10(6) cells/mL) as compared to T-flask controls. Serum-free spinner culture was comparable, if not superior, to that observed in serum-containing medium. This is the first report of stirred culture of PB or CB MNC, as well as the first report of stirred CD34(+) cell culture. Additionally, this is the first account of serum-free stirred culture of hematopoietic cells from any source.     

Toxoplasma gondii antigens: recovery analysis of tachyzoites cultivated in Vero cell maintained in serum free medium

Vero cells have been used successfully in Toxoplasma gondii maintenance. Medium supplementation for culture cells with fetal bovine serum is necessary for cellular growth. However, serum in these cultures presents disadvantages, such as the potential to induce hypersensitivity, variability of serum batches, possible presence of contaminants, and the high cost of good quality serum. Culture media formulated without any animal derived components, designed for serum-free growth of cell lines have been used successfully for different virus replication. The advantages of protozoan parasite growth in cell line cultures using serum-free medium remain poorly studied. Thus, this study was designed to determine whether T. gondii tachyzoites grown in Vero cell cultures in serum-free medium, after many passages, are able to maintain the same antigenic proprieties as those maintained in experimental mice. The standardization of Vero cell culture in serum-free medium for in vitro T. gondii tachyzoite production was performed establishing the optimal initial cell concentration for the confluent monolayer formation, which was 1×10(6) Vero cell culture as initial inoculum. The total confluent monolayer formatted after 96 h and the best amount of harvested tachyzoites was 2.1×10(7) using parasite inoculum of 1.5×10(6) after 7 days post-infection. The infectivity of tachyzoites released from Vero cells maintained in serum-free medium was evaluated using groups of Swiss mice infected with cell-culture tachyzoites. The parasite concentrations were similar to those for mice infected with tachyzoites collected from other infected mice. The data from both in vivo and in vitro experiments showed that in at least 30 culture cell passages, the parasites maintained the same infectivity as maintained in vivo. Another question was to know whether in the several continued passages, immunogenic progressive loss could occur. The nucleotide sequences studied were the same between the different passages, which could mean no change in their viability in the lysate antigen. Thus, the antigen production by cell culture has clear ethical and cost-saving advantages. Moreover, the use of culture media formulated without any human or animal derived components, designed for serum-free growth of cell lines, successfully produced tachyzoites especially for antigen production.     

Investigation of reduced serum and serum-free media for the cultivation of insect cells (Bm5) and the production of baculovirus (BmNPV)

An experimental study has been carried out to investigate the effectivenes of several reduced serum and serum-free media for the cultivation of an ovarian cell line, Bm5, of the lepidopteran insect Bombyx mori. Bm5 cell were successfully adapted to grow in a medium containing 5% serum and a serum-free medium (EX-CELL 400). On the other hand, this cell line could not be adapted to grow in several other media suggested in the literature, including IPL-41 + 2% fetal bovine serum (FBS), SF-900, and a serum-free medium (ISFM). Furthermore, a comparative study was conducted to determine the production levels of B. mori nuclear polyhedrosis virus (BmNPV) in Bm5 cells cultured in three different medium formulations. The production levels of BmNPV in adapted Bm5 cells grown in a 5% serum-supplemented medium and a serum-free medium (EX-CELL 400) were comparable to those obtained in Bm5 cells grown 10% serum-supplemented medium. (c) 1992 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

Factors controlling embryonic heart cell proliferation in serum-free synthetic media

Summary Embryonic chick cardiac cell cultures, plated on collagen-coated dishes, containing serum-free synthetic media proliferate actively. The basic medium contained Ham's F12 nutrient mixture, fetuin, ascorbic acid, and bovine serum albumin. This medium was supplemented with various combinations of factors; endothelial cell growth supplement (ECGS), epidermal growth factor (EGF), insulin (I), transferrin (T), selenium (S), hydrocortisone, and thyroxine or supplemented alone. Basic medium supplemented with ECGS alone contributes to the highest final cell density among all other factors used in various combinations or alone. The final cell density of the control culture with 2% fetal bovine serum was higher than those of all experimental cultures and an additional control culture grown in the basic medium. Combinations of factors without ECGS do not promote significant cell proliferation. Thyroxine is required to induce optimal differentiation and contractility of cardiac myocytes in vitro. Fibronectin and laminin did not show any more influence than collagen did on the growth and maintenance of cardiac myocytes in serum-free media. The proportion of cardiac muscle cells in ECGS-containing media was higher than those in other experimental media and control media with the exception of ECGS and ITS-containing medium that showed lower proportion of cardiac myocytes than that of serum-containing medium on Days 3 and 5. The profiles of incorporation of [³H]thymidine into DNA of heart cells in experimental and control cultures showed a peak in incorporation values within the first week of culture and subsequently declined. Autoradiography studies revealed that cardiac myocytes in culture supplemented with ECGS alone attained a peak in labeling index on Day 1 with approximately 62% labeled cells. Subsequently, the labeling indices declined. Cardiac myocytes grown in media without ECGS showed significantly lower labeling indices than those in ECGS-containing media. This study has demonstrated the influence of ECGS, EGF and ITS in promoting the growth of cardiac myocytes and also in contributing to the maintenance of contractile cardiac myocytes in serum-free, long-term culture. The influence of ECGS on heart cell proliferation is considered to be superior to that of EGF and ITS. This study was supported in part by a grant HL-25482 from the National Heart Lung and Blood Institute and a grant from the American Heart Association of Michigan.     

Vero细胞无血清培养技术的研究与应用

Vero细胞是世界卫生组织和我国生物制品规程认可的疫苗生产细胞系。随着对疫苗质量和安全性要求的不断提高,用无血清培养基取代含血清培养基培养Vero细胞已成为病毒疫苗生产的一个重要发展趋势。Vero细胞无血清培养的技术关键是研发或选择能支持细胞以贴附培养方式生长的无血清培养基。微载体培养是贴附依赖性细胞系规模化培养和病毒疫苗生产的有效技术途径。我们对Vero细胞无血清培养基的研发、Vero细胞无血清培养及病毒疫苗生产工艺做了讨论,对该领域存在的问题和发展策略进行了展望。     

Serum-free medium conditions for steroidogenesis of bovine follicular thecal cells cultured on collagen gel matrix

Summary Thecal cells isolated from bovine ovarian follicles were cultured with a serum-free basal medium or a serum-free complete medium in the presence or absence of collagen gel matrix, and their cellular proliferation and steroidogenesis were compared with those of cells cultured with a serum-containing medium. The cells cultured with the serum-free basal medium produced larger amounts of progesterone, androstenedione, and estradiol than the cells cultured with the serum-containing medium, but no appreciable cell proliferation was observed in the serum-free medium. Response of thecal cells to 8 bromo-cAMP, a steroidogenic agent, varied according to the type of steroid production examined and the type of culture medium used. In a cultivation period of 4 d, progesterone production was stimulated about five-fold by 8 bromo-cAMP in the serum-free complete medium on collagen gel matrix and in the serum-free basal medium without collagen matrix, whereas androstenedione production was stimulated about three- to fourfold in the serum-free complete medium on collagen gel matrix and in the serum-free basal medium with or without collagen matrix. Estradiol production, however, was significantly suppressed by 8 bromo-cAMP in the serum-free complete medium on collagen gel matrix and also in the serum-containing medium. Thus, among the conditions examined, the most suitable primary culture media for steroidogenesis of thecal cells were the serum-free media, especially serum-free complete medium on collagen gel matrix.     

Design of serum-free medium for suspension culture of CHO cells on the basis of general commercial media

The design of serum-free media for suspension culture of genetically engineered Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells using general commercial media as a basis was investigated. Subcultivation using a commercial serum-free medium containing insulin-like growth factor (IGF)-1 with or without FCS necessitated additives other than IGF-1 to compensate for the lack of FCS and improve cell growth. Suspension culture with media containing several combinations of growth factors suggested the effectiveness of addition of both IGF-1 and the lipid signaling molecule lysophosphatidic acid (LPA) for promoting cell growth. Subcultivation of CHO cells in suspension culture using the commercial serum-free medium EX-CELL™302, which contained an IGF-1 analog, supplemented with LPA resulted in gradually increasing specific growth rate comparable to the serum-containing medium and in almost the same high antibody production regardless of the number of generations. The culture with EX-CELL™302 supplemented with LPA in a jar fermentor with pH control at 6.9 showed an apparently higher cell growth rate than the cultures without pH control and with pH control at 6.8. The cell growth in the medium supplemented with aurintricarboxylic acid (ATA), which was much cheaper than IGF-1, in combination with LPA was synergistically promoted similarly to that in the medium supplemented with IGF-1 and LPA. In conclusion, the serum-free medium designed on the basis of general commercial media could support the growth of CHO cells and antibody production comparable to serum-containing medium in suspension culture. Moreover, the possibility of cost reduction by the substitution of IGF-1 with ATA was also shown.     

Rabbit chondrocytes maintained in serum-free medium : I. Synthesis and secretion of hydrodynamically-small proteoglycans

The biosynthesis of sulfated proteoglycan in vitro by rabbit articular chondrocytes in first passage monolayer culture maintained in fetal bovine serum (FBS) or in serum-free conditions was compared. Neosynthesized proteoglycan in the culture medium in the most dense fraction of an associative CsCl density gradient (fraction dAl) declined with increasing time under serum-free conditions, but not when cells were maintained in the presence of serum. After one day, the major peak of incorporated 35SO4 in medium fraction dAl eluted as a retarded peak (Kav 0.28) on Sepharose CL-2B, whether cells were maintained under serum-free or serum-containing conditions. The hydrodynamic size of proteoglycan monomer fraction dAlDl obtained after one day of exposure to serum-free culture media was smaller than dAlDl from serum-containing cultures. The hydrodynamic size of dAlDl obtained from serum-free culture media became even progressively smaller after 2 and 3 days' exposure to these conditions. Hydrodynamically small sulfated proteoglycans were identified in the cell-associated dAlDl fraction as early as one day after switching chondrocytes from serum-containing to serum-free medium. Culture medium fraction dAlDl from serum-free culture medium aggregated poorly when incubated with human hyaluronic acid (HA) in the presence of bovine link protein or when dialysed against bovine nasal cartilage proteoglycan aggregate. Proteoglycan monomer from serum-containing medium reaggregated more efficiently under both conditions. No change in the size of glycosaminoglycan chains was seen in the smaller proteoglycan subpopulations, nor was there any indication of marked changes in the glycosaminoglycan types.     

Characterization of different cell culture media for expression of recombinant antibodies in mammalian cells: Presence of contaminating bovine antibodies

Several new cell culture media designed specifically for the expression of recombinant antibodies in Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells were investigated for the presence of bovine IgG. Three serum-free media, three protein-free (animal component free) media, as well as one chemically defined medium were included in the study. Employing a combination of affinity chromatography (Protein G or A columns), SDS-PAGE analysis, and peptide mass fingerprinting, two of the serum-free media were found to contain bovine IgG in the range of approximately 0.5 mg/L. The other five media did not contain detectable levels of contaminating Protein A or G-binding proteins such as bovine IgG.