Field resistance of transgenic burley tobacco lines and hybrids expressing the tobacco vein mottling virus coat protein gene

Fifty transgenic lines expressing the tobacco vein mottling virus (TVMV) coat protein (CP) gene in five genetic backgrounds were evaluated under field conditions for response to mechanic inoculation with TVMV, tobacco etch virus (TEV) and potato virus Y (PVY). TVMV CP transgenic lines conferred resistance to TVMV, TEV and PVY under field conditions. Combining two strategies, coat protein-mediated resistance (CPMR) coupled with an endogenous resistance gene (Virgin A Mutant, VAM) significantly extended the range and magnitude of virus resistance and provided a potential valuable new source of protection against potyviruses. CP transgenic lines lacking the VAM gene had high resistance to TEV, medium resistance to PVY, and a recovery phenotype to TVMV. A series of hybrids involving transgenic lines were generated and tested under field conditions for response to virus inoculation. One copy of TVMV-CP gene presented in lines homozygous for the VAM gene provided effective resistance to all three potyviruses. These studies also suggested that selection of a suitable recipient genotype was critical and that field evaluation was necessary in order to select elite resistant transgenic lines. Engineering viral CP genes into genotypes possessing some level of virus resistance could be critical to achieve an effective level of resistance.     

An Ry-mediated resistance response in potato requires the intact active site of the NIa proteinase from potato virus Y

Ry confers extreme resistance to all strains of potato virus Y (PVY). To identify the elicitor of the Ry-mediated resistance against PVY in potato, we expressed each of the PVY-encoded proteins in leaves of PVY-resistant (Ry) and -susceptible (ry) plants. For most of the proteins tested, there was no evident response. However, when the NIa proteinase was expressed in leaves of Ry plants, there was a hypersensitive response (HR). Proteinase active site mutants failed to induce the Ry-mediated response. The HR was also induced by the NIa proteinase from pepper mottle virus (PepMoV), which has the same cleavage specificity as the PVY enzyme, but not by the tobacco etch virus (TEV) or the potato virus A (PVA) proteinases that cleave different peptide motifs. Based on these results, we propose that Ry-mediated resistance requires the intact active site of the NIa proteinase. Although the structure of the active proteinase could have elicitor activity, it is possible that this proteinase releases an elicitor by cleavage of a host-encoded protein. Alternatively, the proteinase could inactivate a negative regulator of the Ry-mediated resistance response.     

Expression of Multiple Virus-derived Resistance Determinants in Transgenic Plants Does Not Lead to Additive Resistance Properties

Plants can be protected against infection by potyviruses by expressing different portions of potyviral genomes as transgenes. This strategy has proven effective with several potyvirus genes, including the Nla, Nlb, and coat protein coding regions. Given the effectiveness of separate potyvirus coding regions as determinants of resistance, we tested the hypothesis that combinations of potyvirus coding regions would provide additively greater protection of plants against potyviruses. For this, we compared transgenic plant lines that expressed either the coat protein (CP) or the Nla+Nlb+coat protein (NNC) coding regions from tobacco vein mottling virus (TVMV). We found that plants that carry the NNC gene combination were invariably less resistant to TVMV than were lines that contain a CP gene alone. Additionally, we found that NNC lines displayed virtually no resistance to tobacco etch virus (TEV), in contrast to the CP lines. We conclude that combining more than one virus-derived resistance determinant in a single construct is detrimental to the production of virus-resistant plants.     

Recessive resistance genes against potyviruses are localized in colinear genomic regions of the tomato ( Lycopersicon spp.) and pepper ( Capsicum spp.) genomes

Resistance against both Potato virus Y (PVY) and Tobacco etch virus (TEV) was identified in the wild tomato relative Lycopersicon hirsutum PI247087. Analysis of the segregation ratio in F(2)/F(3) and BC(1) interspecific progenies indicated that a single recessive gene, or two very tightly linked recessive loci, are involved in resistance to both potyviruses. This locus was named pot-1. Using amplified fragment length polymorphism markers and a set of L. hirsutum introgression lines, pot-1 was mapped to the short arm of tomato chromosome 3, in the vicinity of the recessive py-1 locus for resistance to corky root rot. Because of the occurrence of phenotypically similar genes in pepper ( Capsicum spp.), the comparative genetics of resistance to potyviruses between tomato and pepper was investigated. Unlike most of the comparative genetic studies on resistance genes, pot-1 was tightly flanked by the same restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP) markers than the pvr2/pvr5 locus for resistance to PVY and TEV from pepper. These results may indicate that recessive resistance genes against potyviruses evolve less rapidly than the majority of the dominant genes cloned so far, and consequently may belong to a different family of resistance genes.     

Comparison of resistance to potyviruses within Solanaceae: infection of potatoes with tobacco etch potyvirus and peppers with potato A and Y potyviruses

The reaction of several cultivated potato varieties (Solarium tuberosum L.) to three strains of tobacco etch potyvirus (TEV-F, TEV-Mex21 and TEV-ATCC) and the reaction of several pepper lines (Capsicum annuum L. and C. chinense L.) to two strains of potato Y potyvirus (PVY^O and PVY^N) and one strain of potato A potyvirus (PVA-M) was tested. The potato varieties included in this study carried resistance genes against PVY, PVA and potato V potyvirus, but all were susceptible to TEV and developed mottle and mosaic symptoms. TEV was readily transmitted by mechanical inoculation from tobacco and potato to potato, whereas transmission from pepper to potato occurred infrequently. TEV was transmitted through potato tubers, and from pepper to potato plants by aphids. Lack of detectable systemic infection following graft-inoculation indicated extreme resistance to PVY^O and PVA in several pepper lines. No pepper line was systemically infected with PVY^N following mechanical inoculation (graft-inoculation was not carried out with PVY^N). The development of necrotic lesions following mechanical and graft-inoculation indicated hypersensitive response to PVY^O in several pepper lines which resembled the resistance responses to these potyvirus strains in potato. Results of this study together with previous work indicate that C. annuum cv. Avelar is resistant to four potyviruses [PVY, PVA, pepper mottle potyvirus (PepMoV) and some isolates of TEV]; C. annuum cv. Criollo de Morelos and C. chinense PI 152225 and PI 159236 are resistant to three potyviruses (PVY, PepMoV and PVA; and PVY, PepMoV and TEV, respectively); C. annuum 9093–1 and 92016–1 are resistant to PVY and PepMoV; and C. annuum cv. Jupiter and C. annuum cv. RNaky are resistant to PVY^N and PVA.     

Genetic variability of Potato virus Y (PVY) and Tobacco etch virus (TEV) from naturally infected pepper fields in the Hatay region of Turkey

The genetic structure of Potato virus Y (PVY) and Tobacco etch virus (TEV) (Potyvirus) populations was investigated in pepper fields in two regions in Turkey. The diversity of PVY and TEV populations according to coat protein (CP) and VPg coding regions showed some similarity. All the isolates built a monophyletic group due to a single introduction event or multiple introductions of genetically similar isolates. All the isolates of both viruses showed evidence to the diversification for a long time. Based on VPg and CP sequences, all PVY isolates corresponded to clade C1. Turkish potyvirus isolates were only able to break the pvr2¹ resistance allele and therefore belonged to pathotype (0,?1). The Pvr4 dominant gene was found to be efficient and durable against PVY but not at all efficient against TEV. Consequently, the pvr2² resistance allele, efficient resistance against PVY and TEV pathotype (0,?1) isolates, would be the most suitable strategy to control potyviruses.     

Combining a host gene and a tobacco vein mottling virus coat protein gene for broad and effective resistance to potyviruses in tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum L.)

Over 100 transgenic tobacco lines in five genetic backgrounds were transformed with the tobacco vein mottling virus (TVMV) coat protein (CP) gene. Transgenic lines were initially tested for their reaction to inoculation with a TVMV systemic strain (TVMV-S) and a potato virus Y common strain (PVY-O). Of the 104 TVMV CP lines 60% were classified as resistant to PVY-O, whereas only 30% of these same lines were resistant to TVMV-S. A subset of six PVY-O-resistant transgenic lines and four control lines were tested for their reaction to a local isolate of TVMV, tobacco etch virus (TEV) and five isolates of PVY. The same ten lines were also tested for responses to a serial dilution of inoculum for two PVY isolates, PVY-KY1 and PVY-NN. Transgenic lines carrying an endogenous resistance gene known as Virgin A mutant (VAM) had greater resistance and a broader spectrum of resistance than did transgenic lines without the VAM gene. This additive effect of the endogenous resistance gene and coat protein-mediated resistance (CPMR) was not overcome by the highest inoculum concentration. The results indicate that the additive effect of the VAM gene and CPMR could extend the effectiveness of CPMR in controlling potiviruses. These findings could have important implications for plant improvement programs using CPMR against potyvirus diseases.     

Internal cleavage and trans-proteolytic activities of the VPg-proteinase (NIa) of tobacco etch potyvirus in vivo.

The NIa protein of plant potyviruses is a bifunctional protein containing an N-terminal VPg domain and a C-terminal proteinase region. The majority of tobacco etch potyvirus (TEV) NIa molecules are localized to the nucleus of infected cells, although a proportion of NIa is attached covalently as VPg to viral RNA in the cytoplasm. A suboptimal cleavage site that is recognized by the NIa proteinase is located between the two domains. This site was found to be utilized in the VPg-associated, but not the nuclear, pool of NIa. A mutation converting Glu-189 to Leu at the P1 position of the processing site inhibited internal cleavage. Introduction of this mutation into TEV-GUS, an engineered variant of TEV that expresses a reporter protein (beta-glucuronidase [GUS]) fused to the N terminus of the helper component-proteinase (HC-Pro), rendered the virus replication defective in tobacco protoplasts. Site-specific reversion of the mutant internal processing site to the wild-type sequence restored virus viability. In addition, the trans-processing activity of NIa proteinase was tested in vivo after introduction of an artificial cleavage site between the GUS and HC-Pro sequences in the cytoplasmic GUS/HC-Pro polyprotein encoded by TEV-GUS. The novel site was recognized and processed in plants infected by the engineered virus, indicating the presence of excess NIa processing capacity in the cytoplasm. The potential roles of internal NIa processing in TEV-infected cells are discussed.     

Evidence that the potyvirus P1 proteinase functions in trans as an accessory factor for genome amplification.

The tobacco etch potyvirus (TEV) polyprotein is proteolytically processed by three viral proteinases (NIa, HC-Pro, and P1). While the NIa and HC-Pro proteinases each provide multiple functions essential for viral infectivity, the role of the P1 proteinase beyond its autoproteolytic activity is understood poorly. To determine if P1 is necessary for genome amplification and/or virus movement from cell to cell, a mutant lacking the entire P1 coding region (delta P1 mutant) was produced with a modified TEV strain (TEV-GUS) expressing beta-glucuronidase (GUS) as a reporter, and its replication and movement phenotypes were assayed in tobacco protoplasts and plants. The delta P1 mutant accumulated in protoplasts to approximately 2 to 3% the level of parental TEV-GUS, indicating that the P1 protein may contribute to but is not strictly required for viral RNA amplification. The delta P1 mutant was capable of cell-to-cell and systemic (leaf-to-leaf) movement in plants but at reduced rates compared with parental virus. This is in contrast to the S256A mutant, which encodes a processing-defective P1 proteinase and which was nonviable in plants. Both delta P1 and S256A mutants were complemented by P1 proteinase expressed in a transgenic host. In transgenic protoplasts, genome amplification of the delta P1 mutant relative to parental virus was stimulated five- to sixfold. In transgenic plants, the level of accumulation of the delta P1 mutant was stimulated, although the rate of cell-to-cell movement was the same as in nontransgenic plants. Also, the S256A mutant was capable of replication and systemic infection in P1-expressing transgenic plants. These data suggest that, in addition to providing essential processing activity, the P1 proteinase functions in trans to stimulate genome amplification.     

Engineering virus resistance using a modified potato gene

Natural mutations in translation initiation factor eIF4E confer resistance to potyviruses in many plant species. Potato is a staple food crop plagued by several potyviruses, yet to date no known eIF4E-mediated resistance genes have been identified. In this study, we demonstrate that transgenic expression of the pvr1(2) gene from pepper confers resistance to Potato virus Y (PVY) in potato. We then use this information to convert the susceptible potato ortholog of this allele into a de novo allele for resistance to PVY using site-directed mutagenesis. Potato plants overexpressing the mutated potato allele are resistant to virus infection. Resistant lines expressed high levels of eIF4E mRNA and protein. The resistant plants showed growth similar to untransformed controls and produced phenotypically similar tubers. This technique disrupts a key step in the viral infection process and may potentially be used to engineer virus resistance in a number of economically important plant-viral pathosystems. Furthermore, the general public may be more amenable to the 'intragenic' nature of this approach because the transferred coding region is modified from a gene in the target crop rather than from a distant species.     

RNA-Dependent RNA Polymerase (NIb) of the Potyviruses Is an Avirulence Factor for the Broad-Spectrum Resistance Gene Pvr4 in Capsicum annuum cv. CM334

Potyviruses are one of the most destructive viral pathogens of Solanaceae plants. In Capsicum annuum landrace CM334, a broad-spectrum gene, Pvr4 is known to be involved in resistance against multiple potyviruses, including Pepper mottle virus (PepMoV), Pepper severe mosaic virus (PepSMV), and Potato virus Y (PVY). However, a potyvirus avirulence factor against Pvr4 has not been identified. To identify the avirulence factor corresponding to Pvr4 in potyviruses, we performed Agrobacterium-mediated transient expressions of potyvirus protein coding regions in potyvirus-resistant (Pvr4) and -susceptible (pvr4) pepper plants. Hypersensitive response (HR) was observed only when a RNA-dependent RNA polymerase (NIb) of PepMoV, PepSMV, or PVY was expressed in Pvr4-bearing pepper leaves in a genotype-specific manner. In contrast, HR was not observed when the NIb of Tobacco etch virus (TEV), a virulent potyvirus, was expressed in Pvr4-bearing pepper leaves. Our results clearly demonstrate that NIbs of PepMoV, PepSMV, and PVY serve as avirulence factors for Pvr4 in pepper plants.     

Expression of Chicken Cystatin for Improving Insect Resistance in Rice

To become mature and infectious, many viruses and insects require proteolytic cleavage, which can be specifically inhibited by proteinase inhibitors. Oryzacystatin (OC), the first-described cystatin originating from rice seed, consists of two molecular species, OC-I and OC-II, both of which have antiviral activity. These intrinsic rice cystatins show a narrow inhibition spectrum and ordinarily are present in rice seeds at insufficient levels for inhibiting the cysteine proteinases of rice insect pests. In addition, our comparison of inhibitory activity (Ki value) showed that chicken cystatin (Ki 5 × 10-12 M) was more powerful than other cystatins, such as OC-I (Ki 3.02 × 10-8 M) and OC-II (l(i 0.83 × 10-8 M). Chicken cystatin also possesses a wide inhibitory spectrum against various cysteine proteinases. Here, we introduced the insecticidal chicken cystatin 8ene into rice plants to improve their insect resistance. Four highly expressive, independent transgenic lines were identified. Molecular analyses revealed that the transferred 8ene was expressed stably in the independent transgenic lines. Therefore, introducing the insecticidal cysteine proteinase inhibitor 8ene into rice plants can be part of a general development strategy for pest control.     

Capsid protein-mediated recruitment of host DnaJ-like proteins is required for Potato virus Y infection in tobacco plants

The capsid protein (CP) of potyviruses is required for various steps during plant infection, such as virion assembly, cell-to-cell movement, and long-distance transport. This suggests a series of compatible interactions with putative host factors which, however, are largely unknown. By using the yeast two-hybrid system the CP from Potato virus Y (PVY) was found to interact with a novel subset of DnaJ-like proteins from tobacco, designated NtCPIPs. Mutational analysis identified the CP core region, previously shown to be essential for virion formation and plasmodesmal trafficking, as the interacting domain. The ability of NtCPIP1 and NtCPIP2a to associate with PVY CP could be confirmed in vitro and was additionally verified in planta by bimolecular fluorescence complementation. The biological significance of the interaction was assayed by PVY infection of agroinfiltrated leaves and transgenic tobacco plants that expressed either full-length or J-domain-deficient variants of NtCPIPs. Transient expression of truncated dominant-interfering NtCPIP2a but not of the functional protein resulted in strongly reduced accumulation of PVY in the inoculated leaf. Consistently, stable overexpression of J-domain-deficient variants of NtCPIP1 and NtCPIP2a dramatically increased the virus resistance of various transgenic lines, indicating a critical role of functional NtCPIPs during PVY infection. The negative effect of impaired NtCPIP function on viral pathogenicity seemed to be the consequence of delayed cell-to-cell movement, as visualized by microprojectile bombardment with green fluorescent protein-tagged PVY. Therefore, we propose that NtCPIPs act as important susceptibility factors during PVY infection, possibly by recruiting heat shock protein 70 chaperones for viral assembly and/or cellular spread.     

Correlation of viral RNA biosynthesis with glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase activity and host resistance

Changes in glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase (G6P DH; EC 1.1.1.49) activity caused by infection of tobacco ( Nicotiana tabacum L.) leaves with potato virus Y (PVY), cucumber mosaic virus, potato virus X, tobacco rattle virus and turnip mosaic virus, the subcellular localisation of G6P DH isozymes in mesophyll protoplasts derived from healthy and PVY-infected tobacco leaves, as well as G6P DH control and the relationship of its isozymes with the degree of tobacco resistance to PVY multiplication, were studied. The activities of G6P DH were markedly increased in locally and systemically infected leaves and the time courses of the activity linearly correlated with those of virus multiplication. In leaves infected with PVY, the activity time courses of the crude and the partially purified G6P DH were coincident. This probably indicates the involvement of coarse regulation of the enzyme. PVY content linearly correlated with enhanced G6P DH activity in leaf discs derived from susceptible, tolerant and resistant cultivars of tobacco. The increased activity of the enzyme in infected protoplasts and plant tissues was predominantly caused by the increased activity of chloroplastic isozymes. This was confirmed by the specific staining of isozymes after electrophoretic separation of chloroplastic proteins of tobacco leaves. These findings enable the degree of resistance to virus multiplication to be quantified for the use of gene manipulation and breeding.     

Host-Specific Involvement of the HC Protein in the Long-Distance Movement of Potyviruses

Plum pox virus (PPV) is a member of the Potyvirus genus that, in nature, infects trees of the Prunus genus. Although PPV infects systemically several species of the Nicotiana genus, such as N. clevelandii and N. benthamiana, and replicates in the inoculated leaves of N. tabacum, it is unable to infect systemically the last host. The long-distance movement defect of PPV was corrected in transgenic tobacco plants expressing the 5"-terminal region of the genome of tobacco etch virus (TEV), a potyvirus that infects systemically tobacco. The fact that PPV was unable to move to upper noninoculated leaves in tobacco plants transformed with the same TEV transgene, but with a mutation in the HC protein (HC-Pro)-coding sequences, identifies the multifunctional HC-Pro as the complementing factor, and strongly suggests that a defect in an HC-Pro activity is responsible for the long-distance movement defect of PPV in tobacco. Whereas PPV HC-Pro strongly intensifies the symptoms caused by potato virus X (PVX) in the PPV systemic hosts N. clevelandii and N. benthamiana, it has no apparent effect on PVX pathogenicity in tobacco, supporting the hypothesis that long-distance movement and pathogenicity enhancement are related activities of the potyviral HC proteins. The movement defect of PPV in tobacco could also be complemented by cucumber mosaic virus in a mixed infection, demonstrating that at least some components of the long-distance machinery of the potyviruses are not strictly virus specific. A general conclusion of this work is that the HC-Pro might be a relevant factor for controlling the host range of the potyviruses.     

Ectopic expression of a UDP-glucose:phenylpropanoid glucosyltransferase leads to increased resistance of transgenic tobacco plants against infection with Potato Virus Y

Transgenic tobacco plants over-expressing a salicylate- and pathogen-inducible glucosyltransferase (TOGT) acting on various phenylpropanoids show enhanced resistance against infection with potato virus Y (PVY). The transgenic plants are characterized by a several-fold increased glucosyltransferase activity in leaves as well as in roots. Under non-infectious conditions profiles of phenylpropanoids in leaves of transgenic lines were similar to that of controls. Feeding experiments with leaf-discs demonstrated a higher capacity for glucosylation of the coumarin scopoletin. After inoculation with PVY the transgenic lines showed similar formation of necrotic leaf lesions but significantly decreased levels of virus coat-protein when compared with control plants. Thus, our results imply that the activity of TOGT and the subsequent accumulation of glucosylated coumarins represent an important step in the cascade of events resulting in confinement of viral pathogens.