Ribozyme catalysis revisited: is water involved?

Enzymatic catalysis by RNA was discovered 25 years ago, yet mechanistic insights are emerging only slowly. Thought to be metalloenzymes at first, some ribozymes proved more versatile than anticipated when shown to utilize their own functional groups for catalysis. Recent evidence suggests that some may also judiciously place structural water molecules to shuttle protons in acid-base catalyzed reactions.     

Structural insights into catalysis by βC-S lyase from Streptococcus anginosus

Hydrogen sulfide (H₂S) is a causative agent of oral malodor and may play an important role in the pathogenicity of oral bacteria such as Streptococcus anginosus. In this microorganism, H₂S production is associated with βC‐S lyase (Lcd) encoded by lcd gene, which is a pyridoxal 5′‐phosphate (PLP)‐dependent enzyme that catalyzes the α,β‐elimination of sulfur‐containing amino acids. When Lcd acts on L ‐cysteine, H₂S is produced along with pyruvate and ammonia. To understand the H₂S‐producing mechanism of Lcd in detail, we determined the crystal structures of substrate‐free Lcd (internal aldimine form) and two reaction intermediate complexes (external aldimine and α‐aminoacrylate forms). The formation of intermediates induced little changes in the overall structure of the enzyme and in the active site residues, with the exception of Lys234, a PLP‐binding residue. Structural and mutational analyses highlighted the importance of the active site residues Tyr60, Tyr119, and Arg365. In particular, Tyr119 forms a hydrogen bond with the side chain oxygen atom of L ‐serine, a substrate analog, in the external aldimine form suggesting its role in the recognition of the sulfur atom of the true substrate (L ‐cysteine). Tyr119 also plays a role in fixing the PLP cofactor at the proper position during catalysis through binding with its side chain. Finally, we partly modified the catalytic mechanism known for cystalysin, a βC‐S lyase from Treponema denticola, and proposed an improved mechanism, which seems to be common to the βC‐S lyases from oral bacteria. Proteins 2012;. © 2012 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

Human DNA polymerase η is pre-aligned for dNTP binding and catalysis

Pre-steady-state kinetic studies on Y-family DNA polymerase η (Polη) have suggested that the polymerase undergoes a rate-limiting conformational change step before the phosphoryl transfer of the incoming nucleotide to the primer terminus. However, the nature of this rate-limiting conformational change step has been unclear, due in part to the lack of structural information on the Polη binary complex. We present here for the first time a crystal structure of human Polη (hPolη) in binary complex with its DNA substrate. We show that the hPolη domains move only slightly on dNTP binding and that the polymerase by and large is pre-aligned for dNTP binding and catalysis. We also show that there is no major reorientation of the DNA from a nonproductive to a productive configuration and that the active site is devoid of metals in the absence of dNTP. Together, these observations lead us to suggest that the rate-limiting conformational change step in the Polη replication cycle likely corresponds to a rate-limiting entry of catalytic metals in the active site.     

Bi-site catalysis in F1-ATPase: does it exist?

The mechanism of action of F(1)F(0)-ATP synthase is controversial. Some favor a tri-site mechanism, where substrate must fill all three catalytic sites for activity, others a bi-site mechanism, where one of the three sites is always unoccupied. New approaches were applied to examine this question. First, ITP was used as hydrolysis substrate; lower binding affinities of ITP versus ATP enable more accurate assessment of sites occupancy. Second, distributions of all eight possible enzyme species (with zero, one, two or three sites filled) as fraction of total enzyme population at each ITP concentration were calculated, and compared with measured ITPase activity. Confirming data were obtained with ATP as substrate. Third, we performed a theoretical analysis of possible bi-site mechanisms. The results argue convincingly that bi-site hydrolysis activity is negligible, and may not even exist. Effectively, tri-site hydrolysis is the only mechanism. We argue that only tri-site hydrolysis drives subunit rotation. Theoretical analyses of possible bi-site mechanisms reveal serious flaws, not previously recognized. One is that, in bi-site catalysis, the predicted direction of subunit rotation is the same for both ATP synthesis and hydrolysis; a second is that infrequently occurring enzyme species are required.     

Enthalpy–entropy compensation and the isokinetic temperature in enzyme catalysis

Enthalpy–entropy compensation supposes that differences in activation enthalpy ?H ^? for different reactions (or, typically in biochemistry, the same reaction catalysed by enzymes obtained from different species) may be compensated for by differences in activation entropy ?S ^?. At the isokinetic temperature the compensation is exact, so that all samples have the same activity. These ideas have been controversial for several decades, but examples are still frequently reported as evidence of a real phenomenon, nearly all of the reports ignoring or discounting the possibility of a statistical artefact. Even for measurements in pure chemistry artefacts occur often, and they are almost inescapable in enzyme kinetics and other fields that involve biological macromolecules, on account of limited stability and the fact that kinetic equations are normally valid only over a restricted range of temperature. Here I review the current status and correct an error in a recent book chapter.     

Protein dynamics and enzyme catalysis: the ghost in the machine?

One of the most controversial questions in enzymology today is whether protein dynamics are significant in enzyme catalysis. A particular issue in these debates is the unusual temperature-dependence of some kinetic isotope effects for enzyme-catalysed reactions. In the present paper, we review our recent model [Glowacki, Harvey and Mulholland (2012) Nat. Chem. 4, 169-176] that is capable of reproducing intriguing temperature-dependences of enzyme reactions involving significant quantum tunnelling. This model relies on treating multiple conformations of the enzyme-substrate complex. The results show that direct 'driving' motions of proteins are not necessary to explain experimental observations, and show that enzyme reactivity can be understood and accounted for in the framework of transition state theory.     

Kinetic mechanism of active site assembly and chemical catalysis of DNA polymerase β

It has been inferred from structural and computational studies that the mechanism of DNA polymerases involves subtle but important discrete steps that occur between binding and recognition of the correct dNTP and chemical catalysis. These steps potentially include local conformational changes involving active site residues, reorganization of Mg(2+)-coordinating ligands, and proton transfer. Here we address this broad issue by conducting extensive transient state kinetic analyses of DNA polymerase β (Pol β). We also performed kinetic simulations to evaluate alternative kinetic models. These studies provide some support for two-step subdomain closing and define constraints under which a kinetically significant prechemistry step can occur. To experimentally identify additional microscopic steps, we developed a stopped flow absorbance assay to measure proton formation that occurs during catalysis. These studies provide direct evidence that formation of the enzyme-bound 3'-O(-) nucleophile is rate determining for chemistry. We additionally show that at low pH the chemical step is rate limiting for catalysis, but at high pH, a postchemistry conformational step is rate limiting due to a pH-dependent increase in the rate of nucleotidyl transfer. Finally, we performed exhaustive analyses of [Mg(2+)] and pH effects. In contrast to published studies, the results suggest an irregular pH dependence of k(pol), which is consistent with general base catalysis involving cooperativity between two or more protonic residues. Overall, the results represent significant advancement in the kinetic mechanism of Pol β and also reconcile some computational and experimental findings.     

Structural insights into catalysis and dimerization enhanced exonuclease activity of RNase?J

RNase J is a conserved ribonuclease that belongs to the β-CASP family of nucleases. It possesses both endo- and exo-ribonuclease activities, which play a key role in pre-rRNA maturation and mRNA decay. Here we report high-resolution crystal structures of Deinococcus radiodurans RNase J complexed with RNA or uridine 5′-monophosphate in the presence of manganese ions. Biochemical and structural studies revealed that RNase J uses zinc ions for two-metal-ion catalysis. One residue conserved among RNase J orthologues (motif B) forms specific electrostatic interactions with the scissile phosphate of the RNA that is critical for the catalysis and product stabilization. The additional manganese ion, which is coordinated by conserved residues at the dimer interface, is critical for RNase J dimerization and exonuclease activity. The structures may also shed light on the mechanism of RNase J exo- and endonucleolytic activity switch.     

Virulence without catalysis: how can a pseudokinase affect host cell signaling?

A hallmark of the pathogenic lifestyle is the secretion of enzymes and other effectors that dysregulate host signaling. Intriguingly, the most potent virulence locus identified in the intracellular parasite Toxoplasma gondii encodes a family of related catalytically inactive protein kinases, or pseudokinases. Toxoplasma has in its kinome among the highest percentage of pseudokinases among all sequenced organisms, and the majority of these appear to be secreted into the host cell. We posit that the pseudokinase fold represents a particularly well-suited domain for functional diversification, discuss the relevance of gene expansion at these loci, and outline potential mechanisms by which a pseudokinase might affect host signaling.     

Transition-state ensemble in enzyme catalysis: possibility, reality, or necessity?

Proteins are not rigid structures; they are dynamic entities, with numerous conformational isomers (substates). The dynamic nature of protein structures amplifies the structural variation of the transition state for chemical reactions performed by proteins. This suggests that utilizing a transition state ensemble to describe chemical reactions involving proteins may be a useful representation. Here we re-examine the nature of the transition state of protein chemical reactions (enzyme catalysis), considering both recent developments in chemical reaction theory (Marcus theory for SN2 reactions), and protein dynamics effects. The classical theory of chemical reactions relies on the assumption that a reaction must pass through an obligatory transition-state structure. The widely accepted view of enzymatic catalysis holds that there is tight binding of the substrate to the transition-state structure, lowering the activation energy. This picture, may, however, be oversimplified. The real meaning of a transition state is a surface, not a single saddle point on the potential energy surface. In a reaction with a "loose" transition-state structure, the entire transition-state region, rather than a single saddle point, contributes to reaction kinetics. Consequently, here we explore the validity of such a model, namely, the enzymatic modulation of the transition-state surface. We examine its utility in explaining enzyme catalysis. We analyse the possibility that instead of optimizing binding to a well-defined transition-state structure, enzymes are optimized by evolution to bind efficiently with a transition-state ensemble, with a broad range of activated conformations. For enzyme catalysis, the key issue is still transition state (ensemble) stabilization. The source of the catalytic power is the modulation of the transition state. However, our definition of the transition state is the entire transition-state surface rather just than a single well-defined structure. This view of the transition-state ensemble is consistent with the nature of the protein molecule, as embodied and depicted in the protein energy landscape of folding, and binding, funnels.     

Class II α-mannosidase from Aspergillus fischeri: Energetics of catalysis and inhibition

Energetics of the catalysis of Class II α-mannosidase (E.C.3.2.1.24) from Aspergillus fischeri was studied. The enzyme showed K_cat/K_m for Man (α1-3) Man, Man (α1-2) Man and Man (α1-6) Man as 7488, 5376 and 3690 M^?1 min^?1, respectively. The activation energy, E_a was 15.14, 47.43 and 71.21 kJ/mol for α1-3, α1-2 and α1-6 linked mannobioses, respectively, reflecting the energy barrier in the hydrolysis of latter two substrates. The enzyme showed K_cat/K_m as 3.56 × 10⁵ and 4.61 × 10⁵ M^?1 min^?1 and E_a as 38.7 and 8.92 kJ/mol, towards pNPαMan and 4-MeUmbαMan, respectively. Binding of Swainsonine to the enzyme is stronger than that of 1-deoxymannojirimycin.     

Protein-enhanced decarboxylation of the covalent intermediate in benzoylformate decarboxylase--Desolvation or acid catalysis?

Benzoylformate decarboxylase (BFD) enhances the rate of decarboxylation of its key intermediate compared to the nonenzymic reaction by a factor of about 10⁶. It has been proposed that desolvation into a hydrophobic environment will lower the reaction barrier in TDP-dependent decarboxylases. The competition of thiamin thiazolone diphosphate (TTDP) with the cofactor thiamin diphosphate (TDP) provides a dynamic indication of the relative hydrophobicity of the cofactor binding site. BFD binds the more polar TDP tightly in the presence of excess TTDP. Therefore, desolvation would not be likely to occur during catalysis. Unlike TDP enzymes that have electron acceptors as substrates, decarboxylases require protonation to produce the precursor to the aldehyde product. A mechanism involving an associated acid that traps the carbanion generated upon C–C bond breaking will permit diffusional separation of carbon dioxide and generate the appropriate precursor to the product aldehdye. This would also account for avoidance of a competitive reaction. Hasson’s detailed structure of BFD shows a highly polar active site with histidines in the vicinity of the substrate. Reports of a reduction of k_cat to near the nonenzymic rate without a large effect on K_m upon specific replacement of these histidines with alanine fit this alternative. In TDP enzymes involving oxidation or condensation, an electrophilic substrate or second cofactor will be bound (and no proton will be required). This will acquire the electron density of the carbanion itself. In such cases, protonated side chains are not functional while hydrophobic environments would promote the internal transfer.     

Penicillin acylase immobilization depending on macromolecular crowding and catalysis in aqueous–organic medium

To enhance penicillin acylase (PA) performance, it was immobilized in mesocellular silica foams (MCFs) depended on macromolecular crowding and applied to catalysis in non-aqueous medium. Ficoll 70, dextran 10,000, dextran 40,000 and bovine serum albumin were co-assembled with PA. It was observed that specific activity of PA assembled in MCFs with dextran 10,000 in 80% cyclohexane (v/v) was 233.2 U/mg, 200% as that of PA assembled in MCFs in 80% cyclohexane and 323.5% as that of free PA in full aqueous medium. As content of alkane increased, activity of PA in MCFs with macromolecules varied slightly. In addition, PA co-immobilized with dextran 10 in MCFs retained 58.2% of its initial activity after heating at 50°C for 4 h, 1.2 times higher than that of PA immobilized alone in MCFs. The results showed that macromolecular crowding was favorable for immobilization of PA and its catalysis in suitable aqueous–organic medium.