Neck spine protects Daphnia pulex from predation by Chaoborus, but individuals with longer tail spine are at a greater risk

We tested the prey preference of Chaoborus sp. on Daphnia pulexwith different defensive morphologies. The protective functionof inducible morphological defences, such as neck spine andlonger tail spine, was evaluated Second instar D.pulex individualsof two clones differing in their strength of neck spine inductionwere offered as prey to both Chaoborus obscuripes and Chaoborusflavicans. We used logistic regression analysis to evaluatethe effect of morphometry on the vulnerability of Daphnia. Thepresence of a neck spine and increased total length protectedD.pulex from Chaoborus predation. However, individuals witha longer tail spine were more vulnerable to Chaoborus predationChaoborus obscuripes was able to eat daphnids with a neck spinedue to the larger gape size of this chaoborid. The smaller speciesC.flavicans almost always ate prey with no neck spine.     

Density-dependent effects of prey defences

In this study, we show that the protective advantage of a defence depends on prey density. For our investigations, we used the predator-prey model system Chaoborus-Daphnia pulex. The prey, D. pulex, forms neckteeth as an inducible defence against chaoborid predators. This morphological response effectively reduces predator attack efficiency, i.e. number of successful attacks divided by total number of attacks. We found that neckteeth-defended prey suffered a distinctly lower predation rate (prey uptake per unit time) at low prey densities. The advantage of this defence decreased with increasing prey density. We expect this pattern to be general when a defence reduces predator success rate, i.e. when a defence reduces encounter rate, probability of detection, probability of attack, or efficiency of attack. In addition, we experimentally simulated the effects of defences which increase predator digestion time by using different sizes of Daphnia with equal vulnerabilities. This type of defence had opposite density-dependent effects: here, the relative advantage of defended prey increased with prey density. We expect this pattern to be general for defences which increase predator handling time, i.e. defences which increase attacking time, eating time, or digestion time. Many defences will have effects on both predator success rate and handling time. For these defences, the predator’s functional response should be decreased over the whole range of prey densities. Received: 15 September 1999 / Accepted: 23 December 1999     

Morphological responses of four species of cyclomorphic Daphnia to a short-term exposure to the insecticide carbaryl

Four species of cyclomorphic Daphnia (D.pulex, D.galeata mendotae,D.retrocurva, D.lumholtzi) were exposed to the insecticide carbarylfor a short term (8–4 h) from the final embryonic stageto the first instar. Daphnia pulex formed neckteeth, and theremaining three Daphnia species developed high helmets and longtailspines. The results suggest that the development of suchprotuberant structures (anti-predator morphologies) in responseto the insecticide exposure is a general phenomenon in Daphnia,and that stimuli on the nervous system of Daphnia may inducethe morphological changes, which originally evolved as a responseto predator kairomone. Two clones of D.pulcx were examined anda clone which was more sensitive to the predator Chaobonts kairomonethan another developed more marked neckteeth in response tocarbaryl, suggesting that the sensitivity in morphological responseto the insecticide may be related to the sensitivity to thekairomone. ¹Present and permanent address: Regional Environment Division,National Institute for Environmental Studies Onogawa, Tsukuba,Ibaraki 305, Japan     

Competition, predation and the relative abundances of two species of Daphnia

We investigated the factors controlling the relative abundancesof two Daphnia species, D.pulex and D.laevis, in a small Wisconsinpond. D.pulex was the dominant Daphnia species in fall 1977and summer-fall 1978; D.laevis was the only Daphnia speciespresent in summer 1979. The abundance of D.laevis was positivelycorrelated with the abundance of the notonectid, Buenoa confusa.In predation trials, notonectides exhibited a distinct preferencefor D.pulex over similarly-sized D.laevis, but Chaoborus larvaefed at similar rates on both Daphnia species. Behavioral observationsrevealed that Buenoa adults were much less efficient at capturingD.laevis than D.pulex. Quantitative results of these predationtrials were combined with estimates of predator and prey densityand distribution to evaluate the effect of predation on thedaphnid populations. The effect of predation varied throughtime and microhabitat, and only infrequently could predationaccount for total prey mortality. D.laevis was most abundantat times and in places where Buenoa predation was most intense.Competition experiments illustrated the competitive superiorityof D.pulex over D.laevis. D.pulex was able to competitivelyexclude D.laevis in long term experiments, and D.pulex's fecunditywas higher than that of D.laevis in shorter experiments. Inlong-term experiments, Chaoborus larvae at natural densitieswere able to keep both Daphnia species at low, constant levelsand neither species clearly dominated when Chaoborus was present.The relative abundances of D.pulex and D.laevis were controlledby a complex of biotic and abiotic factors. Pond depth and predatordensity determined the intensity of predation on daphnid populations.When notonectid predation was intense, D.laevis dominated; whenthe intensity of predation by notonectids was low, D.pulex dominateddue to its superior competitive abilities. At different timesselective predation or high resource levels promoted the co-existenceof these two species. ¹Current address of both authors: Department of Biological Sciences,University of California, Santa Barbara, CA 93106, USA     

Reciprocity in predator–prey interactions: exposure to defended prey and predation risk affects intermediate predator life history and morphology

A vast body of literature exists documenting the morphological, behavioural and life history changes that predators induce in prey. However, little attention has been paid to how these induced changes feed back and affect the predators’ life history and morphology. Larvae of the phantom midge Chaoborus flavicans are intermediate predators in a food web with Daphnia pulex as the basal resource and planktivorous fish as the top predator. C. flavicans prey on D. pulex and are themselves prey for fish; as D. pulex induce morphological defences in the presence of C. flavicans this is an ideal system in which to evaluate the effects of defended prey and top predators on an intermediate consumer. We assessed the impact on C. flavicans life history and morphology of foraging on defended prey while also being exposed to the non-lethal presence of a top fish predator. We tested the basic hypothesis that the effects of defended prey will depend on the presence or absence of top predator predation risk. Feeding rate was significantly reduced and time to pupation was significantly increased by defended morph prey. Gut size, development time, fecundity, egg size and reproductive effort respond to fish chemical cues directly or significantly alter the relationship between a trait and body size. We found no significant interactions between prey morph and the non-lethal presence of a top predator, suggesting that the effects of these two biological factors were additive or singularly independent. Overall it appears that C. flavicans is able to substantially modify several aspects of its biology, and while some changes appear mere consequences of resource limitation others appear facultative in nature.     

Direct distributional response in Daphnia pulex to a predator kairomone

The hypothesis that zooplankton are capable of direct and differentiatedbehavioural responses to different biotic factors was tested.A multichamber flow-through technique enabled predeterminedfood levels of the green alga Scenedesmus acutus to be maintainedconstant throughout the experiments. By adding water from aculture of fourth instar Chaoborus flavicans larvae to one ofthe end chambers, a concentration gradient of the chemical substancewas established across the parallel chambers. Evidence is presentedfor a direct avoidance response in the water flea Daphnia pulexto a substance released by the predatory midge C.flavicans.This response occurs in the absence of visual cues and is independentof food availability. Finally, the results indicate that swarmingin D.pulex may occur in the absence of both light and predatorscent, but is influenced by food concentrations.     

Life history responses of Daphnia clones to toxic Microcystis at different food levels

We examined how the amount of food of good quality, Scenedrsmusobtusiusculus, influenced the toxic effects of the cyanobacteriumMicrocystu aeruginosa on Daphnia pulex in a 21 day life tableexperiment. Our results show that all life history traits studied,i.e. longevity, growth and reproduction, of D.pulex were negativelyaffected by toxic Microcystis. The detrimental effects on theselife history traits were less pronounced at increasing foodlevels. In addition, D.pule.x clones differed in their lifehistory responses to toxic Microcystis, suggesting that thepresence of toxic cyanobacteria may modify the outcome amongD.pulex clones.     

THE EVOLUTIONARY ECOLOGY OF AN ANTIPREDATOR REACTION NORM: DAPHNIA PULEX AND CHAOBORUS AMERICANUS

Ponds containing the parthenogenetic zooplankter Daphnia pulex with and without chaoborid predators were sampled over the course of a season. A significant (P < 0.05) Spearman rank correlation was found between predator density and the expression of an antipredator defense (neckteeth) by the Daphnia. The reaction norms (percent induction of a single genotype versus predator density) of clones isolated from predator-free and predator-rich habitats were determined in a laboratory setting. There was a statistically significant different response among the six clones tested (P < 0.05). Clones isolated from chaoborid ponds showed significantly greater sensitivity to the presence of predator than clones from predator-free ponds (P < 0.05). In the laboratory, food levels under which prey were cultured affected induction of the antipredator response. Highest induction was found at the lowest food level used.     

Life-history responses to Chuoborus of spined and unspined Daphniu pulex

Water-borne chemicals released by the larvae of the predatoryphantom midge Chaoborus are known to induce morphological modificationsin its prey Daphnia pulex: these cladocerans develop neck spineswhich may carry several teeth. Some work has shown that thesemorphological variations enhance the prey's chances of escape.but since these neck teeth are not fixed defence reactions,they are thought to entail some form of cost, such as delayedmaturation and reduced fecundity. In this study. the relationshipbetween morphological and life-history changes in four clonesof Daphnia pulex reared in the presence and absence of Chaoborusflavicans was examined. Special emphasis was placed on the genotypiccomparison of the modifications. While all four clones showeda delay in maturation time in the presence of Chaoborus, theneck spine responses differed markedly among the genotypes:one clone never had any neck teeth, another always producedone single tooth, and two clones produced varying numbers ofteeth per spine (means 2.9 and 4. respectively). These resultsindicate that there is no general pattern of neck teeth productioncorresponding to delayed maturation. What there appears to beis genetic variability in two independent and possibly adaptiveresponses. However, the clone without neck teeth was the onlyone which showed no predator-induced reduction in fecundity.Another common morphological response to Chaoborus was thatjuveniles of all clones developed elongated tail spines.     

Lagrangian description of zooplankton swimming trajectories

Three-dimensional swimming, in 20 trajectories of Daphnia pulex,was characterized in terms of its kinematic properties. Resultsshow that the random component was stronger than the deterministiccomponent at time scales >1–2 s. Such random movementsmay have evolved to outwit potential predators and prey.     

Complex effects of a kairomone of Chaoborus and an insecticide on Daphnia pulex

Daphnia pulex were reared in Chaoborus-conditioned water containingthe insecticide carbaryl, and their life history parametersand morphologies were investigated. The insecticide inhibitedthe animals' growth and reproduction and delayed their maturationtime more intensely in the chaoborus-conditioned water thanin the control Chaoborus-free water, indicating that a kairomoneof Chaoborus made the Daphnia more sensitive to the insecticide.The Chaoborus conditioned water induced neckteeth formationof D.pulex in instars 1–2 and elongated the intermoultingperiod of juveniles. The moulting to the spined morphs and elongationin duration of juvenile stages seemed to increase the risk ofdamage from the insecticide. The potential population growthrate of D.pulex in treatments was estimated as a possible fitnessindicator of the animals. It was reduced synergistically bythe kairomone of Chaoborus and the insecticide. Some individualskept neckteeth until the third or fourth instar stage when theywere exposed to sublethal concentrations of the insecticidein the Chaoborus-conditioned water. This was considered as aresult of synergistic effects of both the kairomone and theinsecticide. Insecticides may be a factor inducing further developmentof protuberant structures in cyclomorphic Daphnia in naturalwater bodies.     

Trophic ecology of an aquatic mite (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Piona carnea</Emphasis>) preying on <Emphasis Type="Italic">Daphnia pulex</Emphasis>: effects of predator density,nutrient supply and a second predator (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Chaoborus americanus</Emphasis>)

As compared to other aquatic invertebrates, relatively little is known about the ecology of predaceous, pelagic water mites. Studies to date do, however, show that water mites can be important components of aquatic food webs. Here, we used manipulative field experiments to better understand the trophic ecology of a predaceous water mite (Piona carnea). Three experiments were conducted that examined (i) the effect of P. carnea density on the per-capita interaction strength (PCIS) of P. carnea preying on zooplankton; (ii) how the effects of P. carnea predation change with prey productivity; and (iii) how P. carnea interacts with another pelagic predator (Chaoborus americanus) to affect a shared prey species (Daphnia pulex). Results from the first experiment showed that P. carnea can strongly impact D. pulex populations, and that the PCIS of P. carnea decreases with an increase in P. carnea density. The second experiment showed that the effects of P. carnea on D. pulex populations depend on bottom-up factors that influence D. pulex population biomass and the reproductive potential of a D. pulex population relative to its size. The third experiment uncovered a non-additive interaction between P. carnea and C. americanus that resulted in a risk reducing situation for D. pulex in the presence of both predators. Together these experiments show that P. carnea imposes a strong negative impact on D. pulex, that the magnitude of this negative impact is dependent on the P. carnea density and the productivity of the system, and that the trophic ecology of P. carnea is modified by coexisting predator species.     

No evidence of Wolbachia among Great Lakes area populations of Daphnia pulex (Crustacea: Cladocera)

Wolbachia endobacteria are commonly associated with a varietyof arthropod species as hosts and induce known changes in theirhosts’ life-history traits. Despite exhibiting severalWolbachia-like life-history traits, and despite being a commonmodel organism, the zooplankton Daphnia pulex has not been formallytested for infection with Wolbachia. Among 203 isolates exhibitinga range of life-history phenotypes, we found no evidence ofWolbachia. This leaves the genes of D. pulex as the most likelycause of its own life-history traits.     

Prey and predator density‐dependent interactions under different water volumes

Predation is a critical ecological process that directly and indirectly mediates population stabilities, as well as ecosystem structure and function. The strength of interactions between predators and prey may be mediated by multiple density dependences concerning numbers of predators and prey. In temporary wetland ecosystems in particular, fluctuating water volumes may alter predation rates through differing search space and prey encounter rates. Using a functional response approach, we examined the influence of predator and prey densities on interaction strengths of the temporary pond specialist copepod Lovenula raynerae preying on cladoceran prey, Daphnia pulex, under contrasting water volumes. Further, using a population dynamic modeling approach, we quantified multiple predator effects across differences in prey density and water volume. Predators exhibited type II functional responses under both water volumes, with significant antagonistic multiple predator effects (i.e., antagonisms) exhibited overall. The strengths of antagonistic interactions were, however, enhanced under reduced water volumes and at intermediate prey densities. These findings indicate important biotic and abiotic contexts that mediate predator–prey dynamics, whereby multiple predator effects are contingent on both prey density and search area characteristics. In particular, reduced search areas (i.e., water volumes) under intermediate prey densities could enhance antagonisms by heightening predator–predator interference effects.     

UV radiation affects antipredatory defense traits in Daphnia pulex

In aquatic environments, prey perceive predator threats by chemical cues called kairomones, which can induce changes in their morphology, life histories, and behavior. Predator‐induced defenses have allowed for prey, such as Daphnia pulex, to avert capture by common invertebrate predators, such as Chaoborus sp. larvae. However, the influence of additional stressors, such as ultraviolet radiation (UVR), on the Daphnia–Chaoborus interaction is not settled as UVR may for instance deactivate the kairomone. In laboratory experiments, we investigated the combined effect of kairomones and UVR at ecologically relevant levels on induced morphological defenses of two D. pulex clones. We found that kairomones were not deactivated by UVR exposure. Instead, UVR exposure suppressed induced morphological defense traits of D. pulex juveniles under predation threat by generally decreasing the number of neckteeth and especially by decreasing the size of the pedestal beneath the neckteeth. UVR exposure also decreased the body length, body width, and tail spine length of juveniles, likely additionally increasing the vulnerability to Chaoborus predation. Our results suggest potential detrimental effects on fitness and survival of D. pulex subject to UVR stress, with consequences on community composition and food web structure in clear and shallow water bodies.     

Daphnia dominance and zooplankton community structure in fishless ponds

Predation by fish has commonly been viewed as a primary driverof spatial and seasonal variation in Daphnia dominance and thesize structure of zooplankton communities. Yet, previous researchsuggests that large Daphnia do not always dominate in the absenceof predation. As alternatives to the planktivory model, numerousmechanisms have been put forth, including the effect of resourcecompetition and its interaction with resource quantity and qualityand abiotic factors (e.g. temperature). Here results are presentedof a field survey of 18 fishless, permanent ponds in southwestMichigan in which spatiotemporal variation in Daphnia pulexabundance and several potential determinants of this variationare explored. Results revealed a large amount of variation inD. pulex incidence and relative biomass, with some ponds exhibitingseasonal losses, some having few or no Daphnia, and some beingdominated by D. pulex for the entire sample period. Redundancyanalysis of zooplankton composition and pond environmental variables(biotic and abiotic) showed no relationship between D. pulexbiomass and measures of Chaoborus abundance, algal resourceproduction, or algal resource quality (including seston C:N:P).Instead, pH and temperature (both of which covaried) showedthe strongest relationship with D. pulex biomass.     

Is competition important to arctic zooplankton community structure?

1. Daphnia pulex and Daphnia middendorffiana are commonly found in the Toolik Lake region of arctic Alaska. These two species are very similar morphologically, although their natural distributions differ markedly: D. pulex is restricted to shallow ponds, while D. middendorffiana is widely distributed and found in a variety of ponds and lakes. We compared the reproductive capabilities of D. pulex and D. middendorffiana grown under similar resource conditions and in the absence of the invertebrate predator Heterocope septentrionalis. In situ life table and mesocosm experiments were conducted in Toolik Lake and Dam Pond, habitats that have historically contained natural populations of D. middendorffiana, but never D. pulex. 2. Daphnia pulex exhibited a significantly higher net growth rate than D. middendorffiana in both life table and mesocosm experiments although D. pulex has never been found in either Toolik Lake or Dam Pond. Daphnia middendorffiana exhibited a negative net growth rate in Dam Pond, which had lower resource levels then Toolik Lake. Therefore, the smaller D. pulex appears to have a lower food threshold concentration than the larger D. middendorffiana. 3. Our results indicate that D. pulex is a superior resource competitor in the Toolik Lake region. These results combined with distributional patterns suggest that the restricted distribution of D. pulex in these arctic lakes and ponds cannot be explained by resource competition alone. We suggest that in the presence of H. septentrionalis, predation is an important factor structuring arctic zooplankton communities in the Toolik Lake region.     

Costs of predator‐induced morphological defences in Daphnia

1. Inducible defences are advantageous because they protect the prey while limiting associated fitness costs. The presence of these costs is an essential component of this conditional strategy, since their absence would favour constitutive (fixed) defences. In some cases, however, these costs have been difficult to measure because of complex interactions between the defences themselves, resultant life history changes and the organism’s environment. 2. The pond‐dwelling water flea, Daphnia pulex, forms defensive neck spines in response to kairomones released by predatory larvae of the phantom midge, Chaoborus. This predator–prey interaction and the formation of these inducible defences have been well studied, but costs associated with the development of neck spines remain unclear. In this study, I address this problem by analysing the effect of Chaoborus kairomones on the life history responses (and fitness costs associated with these responses) of two clones of D. pulex that are from the same pond population, but differ greatly in their degree of neck spine development. 3. Both D. pulex clones exhibited the same predator‐induced shifts in life history: larger size at birth, reduced juvenile growth rate (producing a smaller size at maturity), delayed reproduction and a reduction in the number of neonates produced after the first clutch. Relative fitness decreased significantly and to the same degree (c. 10% reduction in r) in each clone. This observed fitness cost was not directly related to the neck spines per se since the cost was the same in both clones, despite their considerable differences in neck spine development. Rather, it appears to be indirectly related to this antipredator morphology via a combination of delayed reproduction and a set of life history trade‐offs (decreased growth rate, decreased reproduction after the first clutch) for increased neonate body size, which is necessary for neck spines to be effective defences. This suite of induced responses is probably a result of local adaptation of these two D. pulex clones to their common pond environment. 4. Costs of inducible defences do not always entail direct allocation costs associated with forming and maintaining a defence, but may also involve indirect life history responses that are specific to particular environmental situations. This local adaptation would explain the highly variable life history responses observed among D. pulex clones from different pond environments.     

Horizontal distribution of Daphnia pulex in response to toxic and non-toxic algal extracts

We studied the horizontal distribution of Daphnia pulex as aresponse to gradients of toxic extracts of two cyanobacteria,Microcystis aeruginosa and Oscillatoria agardhii and non-toxicextracts of the green alga Scenedesmus obtusiusculus. The experimentwas performed in the dark using a flow through system with fivechambers. Daphnia pulex aggregated at the inlet of Scenedesmusextract, but showed similar responses to extracts of toxic cyanobactenaand food-free medium. Chemical cues seem to affect food search,but do not effect Daphnia pulex's avoidance of toxic algae.     

Opportunistic omnivory impairs our ability to predict invasive species impacts from functional response comparisons

Comparing the relationship between resource use and resource availability (i.e. the functional response, FR) between two predators can provide useful insights on their relative predatory impacts. For instance in invasion ecology, an increase in the predation pressure on local prey populations can be predicted from a significant difference in FR revealing a higher FR for the invasive predator compared to the native trophic analogue it may replace. In traditional FR experiments, the focal prey species is the only source of food. This may lead to misinterpretations with opportunistic omnivores that are able to cope with different resource availabilities in their natural environment, and whose predation rate may therefore be modulated by the presence of alternative resources. To address this question, we compared the FR of two freshwater gammarid species known to behave as opportunistic omnivores: the invasive “killer shrimp” Dikerogammarus villosus and the native Gammarus pulex, in a treatment with a focal prey species as the only food source (the water flea Daphnia magna) and in a treatment with the focal prey and an alternative food source (Carpinus betulus leaves). D. villosus showed a significantly higher FR than G. pulex with water fleas only and providing leaf litter suppressed this difference. The predatory impact of D. villosus might therefore be modulated by the relative availability of live prey compared to the alternative food sources. Increasing the realism of FR experiments through the inclusion of abundant and easily accessible alternative resources, like leaf litter for benthic invertebrates, should refine the predictions made from FR comparisons.