A collapsed state functions to self-chaperone RNA folding into a native ribonucleoprotein complex

Most large RNAs achieve their active, native structures only as complexes with one or more cofactor proteins. By varying the Mg(2+) concentration, the catalytic core of the bI5 group I intron RNA can be manipulated into one of three states, expanded, collapsed or native, or into balanced equilibria between these states. Under near-physiological conditions, the bI5 RNA folds rapidly to a collapsed but non-native state. Hydroxyl radical footprinting demonstrates that assembly with the CBP2 protein cofactor chases the RNA from the collapsed state to the native state. In contrast, CBP2 also binds to the RNA in the expanded state to form many non-native interactions. This structural picture is reinforced by functional splicing experiments showing that RNA in an expanded state forms a non-productive, kinetically trapped complex with CBP2. Thus, rapid folding to the collapsed state functions to self-chaperone bI5 RNA folding by preventing premature interaction with its protein cofactor. This productive, self-chaperoning role for RNA collapsed states may be especially important to avert misassembly of large multi-component RNA-protein machines in the cell.     

Structural basis for the self-chaperoning function of an RNA collapsed state

Prior to folding to a native functional structure, many large RNAs form conformationally collapsed states. Formation of the near-native collapsed state for the bI5 group I intron RNA plays an obligatory role in self-chaperoning assembly with its CBP2 protein cofactor by preventing formation of stable, misassembled complexes. We show that the collapsed state is essential because CBP2 assembles indiscriminately with the bI5 RNA in any folding state to form long-lived complexes. The most stable protein interaction site in the expanded state-CBP2 complex overlaps, but is not identical to, the native site. Folding to the collapsed state circumvents two distinct misassembly events: inhibitory binding by multiple equivalents of CBP2 and formation of bridged complexes in which CBP2 straddles cognate and noncognate RNAs. Strikingly, protein-bound sites in the expanded state RNA complex are almost the inverse of native RNA-RNA and RNA-protein interactions, indicating that folding to the collapsed state significantly reduces the fraction of RNA surfaces accessible for misassembly. The self-chaperoning function for the bI5 collapsed state is likely to be conserved in other ribonucleoproteins where a protein cofactor binds tightly at a simple RNA substructure or has an RNA binding surface composed of multiple functional sites.     

Near native structure in an RNA collapsed state

Many large RNAs form conformationally collapsed, but non-native, states prior to folding to the native state or assembling with protein cofactors. Although RNA collapsed states play fundamental roles in RNA folding and ribonucleoprotein assembly processes, their structures have been poorly understood. We obtained 12 high-quality structural constraints for the collapsed state formed by the catalytic core of the bI5 intron RNA using site-specific cross-linking mediated by a short-lived reactant. RNA tertiary structures in the collapsed and native states are indistinguishable, even though only the native state forms a solvent-inaccessible core. Thus, structural neighbors in the collapsed state, including several long-range tertiary interactions, are approximately as close in space as in the native state, but RNA packing is sufficiently loose or dynamic to allow access by solvent. Binding by the obligate CBP2 protein cofactor has almost no effect on structural neighbors reported by cross-linking, even though protein binding chases the RNA from the collapsed state to the native state. Protein binding thus appears to promote only the final few angstroms of RNA folding rather than mediate global conformational rearrangements in the catalytic core. The bI5 RNA collapsed state functions to self-chaperone ribonucleoprotein assembly because this conformationally restrained structure lies very near that of the native state and excludes structures that otherwise misassemble efficiently.     

CBP2 protein promotes in vitro excision of a yeast mitochondrial group I intron.

The terminal intron (bI2) of the yeast mitochondrial cytochrome b gene is a group I intron capable of self-splicing in vitro at high concentrations of Mg2+. Excision of bI2 in vivo, however, requires a protein encoded by the nuclear gene CBP2. The CBP2 protein has been partially purified from wild-type yeast mitochondria and shown to promote splicing at physiological concentrations of Mg2+. The self-splicing and protein-dependent splicing reactions utilized a guanosine nucleoside cofactor, the hallmark of group I intron self-splicing reactions. Furthermore, mutations that abolished the autocatalytic activity of bI2 also blocked protein-dependent splicing. These results indicated that protein-dependent excision of bI2 is an RNA-catalyzed process involving the same two-step transesterification mechanism responsible for self-splicing of group I introns. We propose that the CBP2 protein binds to the bI2 precursor, thereby stabilizing the catalytically active structure of the RNA. The same or a similar RNA structure is probably induced by high concentrations of Mg2+ in the absence of protein. Binding of the CBP2 protein to the unspliced precursor was supported by the observation that the protein-dependent reaction was saturable by the wild-type precursor. Protein-dependent splicing was competitively inhibited by excised bI2 and by a splicing-defective precursor with a mutation in the 5' exon near the splice site but not by a splicing-defective precursor with a mutation in the core structure. Binding of the CBP2 protein to the precursor RNA had an effect on the 5' splice site helix, as evidenced by suppression of the interaction of an exogenous dinucleotide with the internal guide sequence.     

Protein-dependent transition states for ribonucleoprotein assembly

Native folding and splicing by the Saccharomyces cerevisiae mitochondrial bI5 group I intron RNA is facilitated by both the S. cerevisiae CBP2 and Neurospora crassa CYT-18 protein cofactors. Both protein-bI5 RNA complexes splice at similar rates, suggesting that the RNA active site structure is similar in both ribonucleoproteins. In contrast, the two proteins assemble with the bI5 RNA by distinct mechanisms and bind opposing, but partially overlapping, sides of the group I intron catalytic core. Assembly with CBP2 is limited by a slow, unimolecular RNA folding step characterized by a negligible activation enthalpy. We show that assembly with CYT-18 shows four distinctive features. (1) CYT-18 binds stably to the bI5 RNA at the diffusion controlled limit, but assembly to a catalytically active RNA structure is still limited by RNA folding, as visualized directly using time-resolved footprinting. (2) This mechanism of rapid stable protein binding followed by subsequent assembly steps has a distinctive kinetic signature: the apparent ratio of k(off) to k(on), determined in a partitioning experiment, differs from the equilibrium K(d) by a large factor. (3) Assembly with CYT-18 is characterized by a large activation enthalpy, consistent with a rate limiting conformational rearrangement. (4) Because assembly from the kinetically trapped state is faster at elevated temperature, we can identify conditions where CYT-18 accelerates (catalyzes) bI5 RNA folding relative to assembly with CBP2.     

A collapsed non-native RNA folding state

At physiological Mg2+ concentrations, the catalytic core of the bI5 group I intron does not fold into its native structure. In contrast, as judged by the global size, this RNA undergoes structural collapse at Mg 2+ concentrations much lower than required to drive folding of the RNA completely to the native state. The bI5 RNA therefore exists in equilibrium between expanded and collapsed non-native states. The activation energy of RNA folding from the collapsed state to the native state is negligible and the reaction is not accelerated by the addition of urea. This collapsed state is thus distinct from the kinetic traps observed during folding of other large RNAs. The collapsed non-native state forms readily in the case of bI5 RNA and may exist generically prior to assembly of other ribonucleoprotein holoenzymes, such as the ribosome.     

The Mrs1 Splicing Factor Binds the bI3 Group I Intron at Each of Two Tetraloop-Receptor Motifs

Most large ribozymes require protein cofactors in order to function efficiently. The yeast mitochondrial bI3 group I intron requires two proteins for efficient splicing, Mrs1 and the bI3 maturase. Mrs1 has evolved from DNA junction resolvases to function as an RNA cofactor for at least two group I introns; however, the RNA binding site and the mechanism by which Mrs1 facilitates splicing were unknown. Here we use high-throughput RNA structure analysis to show that Mrs1 binds a ubiquitous RNA tertiary structure motif, the GNRA tetraloop-receptor interaction, at two sites in the bI3 RNA. Mrs1 also interacts at similar tetraloop-receptor elements, as well as other structures, in the self-folding Azoarcus group I intron and in the RNase P enzyme. Thus, Mrs1 recognizes general features found in the tetraloop-receptor motif. Identification of the two Mrs1 binding sites now makes it possible to create a model of the complete six-component bI3 ribonucleoprotein. All protein cofactors bind at the periphery of the RNA such that every long-range RNA tertiary interaction is stabilized by protein binding, involving either Mrs1 or the bI3 maturase. This work emphasizes the strong evolutionary pressure to bolster RNA tertiary structure with RNA-binding interactions as seen in the ribosome, spliceosome, and other large RNA machines.     

Differential helix stabilities and sites pre-organized for tertiary interactions revealed by monitoring local nucleotide flexibility in the bI5 group I intron RNA

The local environment at adenosine residues in the bI5 group I intron RNA was monitored as a function of Mg(2+) using both the traditional method of dimethyl sulfate (DMS) N1 methylation and a new approach, selective acylation of 2'-amine substituted nucleotides. These probes yield complementary structural information because N1 methylation reports accessibility at the base pairing face, whereas 2'-amine acylation scores overall residue flexibility. 2'-Amine acylation robustly detects RNA secondary structure and is sensitive to higher order interactions not monitored by DMS. Disruption of RNA structure due to the 2'-amine substitution is rare and can be compensated by stabilizing folding conditions. Peripheral helices that do not interact with other parts of the RNA are more stable than both base paired helices and tertiary interactions in the conserved catalytic core. The equilibrium state of the bI5 intron RNA, prior to assembly with its protein cofactor, thus features a relatively loosely packed core anchored by more stable external stem-loop structures. Adenosine residues in J4/5 and P9.0 form structures in which the nucleotide is constrained but the N1 position is accessible, consistent with pre-organization to form long-range interactions with the 5' and 3' splice sites.     

Kinetic and thermodynamic framework for assembly of the six-component bI3 group I intron ribonucleoprotein catalyst

The yeast mitochondrial bI3 group I intron RNA splices in vitro as a six-component ribonucleoprotein complex with the bI3 maturase and Mrs1 proteins. We report a comprehensive framework for assembly of the catalytically active bI3 ribonucleoprotein. (1) In the absence of Mg(2+), two Mrs1 dimers bind independently to the bI3 RNA. The ratio of dissociation to association rate constants, k(off)/k(on), is approximately equal to the observed equilibrium K(1/2) of 0.12 nM. (2) At magnesium ion concentrations optimal for splicing (20 mM), two Mrs1 dimers bind with strong cooperativity to the bI3 RNA. k(off)/k(on) is 15-fold lower than the observed K(1/2) of 11 nM, which reflects formation of an obligate intermediate involving one Mrs1 dimer and the RNA in cooperative assembly of the Mrs1-RNA complex. (3) The bI3 maturase monomer binds to the bI3 RNA at almost the diffusion-controlled limit and dissociates with a half-life of 1 h. k(off)/k(on) is approximately equal to the equilibrium K(D) of 2.8 pM. The bI3 maturase thus represents a rare example of a group I intron protein cofactor whose binding is adequately characterized by a one-step mechanism under conditions that promote splicing. (4) Maturase and Mrs1 proteins each bind the bI3 RNA tightly, but with only modest coupling (approximately 1 kcal/mol), suggesting that the proteins interact at independent RNA binding sites. Maturase binding functions to slow dissociation of Mrs1; whereas prior Mrs1 binding increases the bI3 maturase k(on) right to the diffusion limit. (5) At effective concentrations plausibly present in yeast mitochondria, a predominant assembly pathway emerges involving rapid, tight binding by the bI3 maturase, followed by slower, cooperative assembly of two Mrs1 dimers. In the absence of other factors, disassembly of all protein subunits will occur in a single apparent step, governed by dissociation of the bI3 maturase.     

Characterisation of the RNA binding properties of the coronavirus infectious bronchitis virus nucleocapsid protein amino-terminal region

The coronavirus nucleocapsid (N) protein binds viral RNA to form the ribonucleocapsid and regulate RNA synthesis. The interaction of N protein with viral RNA was investigated using circular dichroism and surface plasmon resonance. N protein underwent a conformational change upon binding viral RNA and the data indicated electrostatic interactions were involved in the binding of the protein to RNA. Kinetic analysis suggested the amino-terminal region facilitates long-range non-specific interactions between N protein and viral RNA, thus bringing the RNA into close proximity to N protein allowing specific contacts to form via a 'lure' and 'lock' mechanism.     

Small structural costs for evolution from RNA to RNP-based catalysis

Typical RNA-based cellular catalysts achieve their active structures only as complexes with protein cofactors, implying that protein binding compensates for some structural deficiencies in the RNA. An unresolved question was the extent to which protein-facilitation imposes additional structural costs, by requiring that an RNA maintain structures required for protein binding, beyond those required for catalysis. We used nucleotide analog interference to identify initially 71 functional group substitutions at phosphate, 2'-ribose, and adenosine base positions that compromise RNA self-splicing in the bI5 group I intron. Protein-facilitated splicing by CBP2 suppresses 11 of 30 interfering substitutions at the RNA backbone and a greater fraction, 27 of 41, at the adenosine base, including at structures conserved among group I introns. Only one substitution directly interferes with protein binding but not with self-splicing. This substitution, plus three adenosine base modifications that interfere more strongly in CBP2-dependent splicing than in self-splicing, yield a cost for protein facilitation of only four functional groups, as approximated by this set of analogs. The small observed structural cost provides a strong physical rationale for the evolutionary drive from RNA to RNP-based function in biology. Remarkably, the four extra requirements do not appear to report disruption of direct protein-RNA contacts and instead likely reflect design against misfolding rather than for maintenance of a protein-binding site.     

Fluorescence-quenching studies on a conformational transition within a domain of the beta 2 subunit of Escherichia coli tryptophan synthase

The fluorescence quenching by acrylamide of the single tryptophan residue in the beta 2 subunit of tryptophan synthase from Escherichia coli K12 is studied for different states of the protein: the native apo-enzyme and holo-enzyme, the nicked apo-protein and holo-protein and the isolated proteolytic fragment F1 corresponding to the N-terminal two thirds of beta 2. The quenching constants measured are used to estimate the accessibility of the tryptophan residue in these different forms. The results are discussed in terms of conformational transition within the F1 domain, occurring in the presence of the cofactor, pyridoxal 5'-phosphate, in the native enzyme. The proteolytic cleavage of the native enzyme is shown to render the nicked protein unable to undergo this conformational change.     

SHAPE analysis of long-range interactions reveals extensive and thermodynamically preferred misfolding in a fragile group I intron RNA

Most functional RNAs require proteins to facilitate formation of their active structures. In the case of the yeast bI3 group I intron, splicing requires binding by two proteins, the intron-encoded bI3 maturase and the nuclear encoded Mrs1. Here, we use selective 2'-hydroxyl acylation analyzed by primer extension (SHAPE) chemistry coupled with analysis of point mutants to map long-range interactions in this RNA. This analysis reveals two critical features of the free RNA state. First, the catalytic intron is separated from the flanking exons via a stable anchoring helix. This anchoring helix creates an autonomous structural domain for the intron and functions to prevent misfolding with the flanking exons. Second, the thermodynamically most stable structure for the free RNA is not consistent with the catalytically active conformation as phylogenetically conserved elements form stable, non-native structures. These results highlight a fragile bI3 RNA for which binding by protein cofactors functions to promote extensive secondary structure rearrangements that are an obligatory prerequisite for forming the catalytically active tertiary structure.     

CAP binding to B and Z forms of DNA.

We have examined the interaction between the cyclic AMP receptor protein (CAP) and a small DNA fragment containing its specific recognition sequence by circular dichroism spectroscopy. The binding of CAP to this fragment induces a B to "C-like" change in the CD spectrum, which is different from that observed for non-specific binding. A one-to-one (CAP dimer to DNA) binding stoichiometry was deduced from spectroscopic titration data, as was a non-specific binding site size of 17 bp/dimer. In addition, we have compared the non-specific binding affinity of CAP for the B and Z forms of synthetic DNA copolymers. A slight preference for the B form was found. These results do not support the recent specific suggestion that CAP binds to a left-handed form of DNA (1), but indicate more generally that an optically detectable conformational change takes place in DNA on binding CAP.     

The U2B'''' RNP motif as a site of protein-protein interaction.

The U2 snRNP contains two specific proteins, U2B' and U2A'. Neither of these proteins, on its own, is capable of specific interactions with U2 RNA. Here, a complex between U2B' and U2A' that forms in the absence of RNA is identified. Analysis of mutant forms of U2B' shows that the smallest fragment able to bind specifically U2 RNA (amino acids 1-88) is also the minimal region required for complex formation with U2A', and implies that this region must be largely structurally intact for U2A' interaction. Although this truncated U2B' fragment is capable of making specific protein--RNA and protein-protein interactions its structure, as measured by the ability to bind to U2A', appears to depend on the rest of the protein. Hybrids between U2B' and the closely related U1A protein are used to localize U2B' specific amino acids involved in protein-protein interaction. These can be divided into two functional groups. U2A' interaction with U2B' amino acids 37-46 permits binding to U2 RNA whereas interaction with U2B' specific amino acids between positions 14 and 25 reduces non-specific binding to U1 RNA. These two proteins may serve as a general example of how RNA binding may be modulated by protein-protein interaction in the assembly of RNPs, particularly since the region of U2' involved in interaction with U2A' consists mainly of a conserved RNP motif.     

DNA-induced conformational changes in bacteriophage 434 repressor

Although bacteriophage 434 repressor binds to its specific DNA sites only as a dimer, formation of the dimers in solution occurs at concentrations three orders of magnitude higher than those needed to bind the 434 operator DNA. Our results suggest that both specific and non-specific DNA induce conformational changes in repressor that lead to formation of repressor dimers. The repressor conformational changes induced by DNA occur at concentrations much lower than those needed for binding of repressor, suggesting that the alternative conformations of repressor persist even if the protein is not in direct contact with DNA. Hence, DNA acts in a "catalytic" fashion to induce a steady-state amount of an alternative repressor conformation that has an enhanced affinity for its specific binding site. These findings suggest that the repressor conformer induced by non-specific DNA is the form of the repressor that is optimized for searching for DNA binding sites along non-specific DNA. Upon finding a binding site, the repressor protein undergoes an additional conformational change that allows it to "lock-on" to its specific site.     

Spectroscopic studies on lambda cro protein-DNA interactions

Spectroscopic (circular dichroism and fluorescence) and thermodynamic studies were conducted on lambda Cro-DNA interactions. Some base substitutions were introduced to the operator and the effects on the conformation of the complex and thermodynamic parameters for dissociation of the complex were examined. It was found that, (1) in the specific binding of Cro with DNA which has a (pseudo) consensus sequence, DNA is overwound, while in non-specific binding it is unchanged, or rather unwound; (2) substitution of central base-pairs or the introduction of a mismatched base-pair at the center of the operator reduces the extent of DNA conformational change on Cro binding and lessens the stability of the Cro-DNA complex, even though there is apparently no direct interaction between Cro and DNA at these positions; (3) stability of the complex increases with the degree of DNA conformational change of the same type during binding; (4) in some cases of specific binding, there are three states in the dissociation of the complex as observed by salt titration: two conformational states for the complex depending on salt concentration and, in non-specific binding, dissociation is a two-state transition; (5) the number of ions involved in interactions between Cro and 17 base-pair DNA is about 7.7 for NaCl titrations; (6) dissociation free energy prediction of the Cro-DNA complex by simple addition of the dissociation free energy change of a single base-pair substitution agrees with our experimental results when DNA overwinding occurs during binding, i.e. in specific binding.     

The bI4 group I intron binds directly to both its protein splicing partners, a tRNA synthetase and maturase, to facilitate RNA splicing activity

The imported mitochondrial leucyl-tRNA synthetase (NAM2p) and a mitochondrial-expressed intron-encoded maturase protein are required for splicing the fourth intron (bI4) of the yeast cob gene, which expresses an electron transfer protein that is essential to respiration. However, the role of the tRNA synthetase, as well as the function of the bI4 maturase, remain unclear. As a first step towards elucidating the mechanistic role of these protein splicing factors in this group I intron splicing reaction, we tested the hypothesis that both leucyl-tRNA synthetase and bI4 maturase interact directly with the bI4 intron. We developed a yeast three-hybrid system and determined that both the tRNA synthetase and bI4 maturase can bind directly and independently via RNA-protein interactions to the large bI4 group I intron. We also showed, using modified two-hybrid and three-hybrid assays, that the bI4 intron bridges interactions between the two protein splicing partners. In the presence of either the bI4 maturase or the Leu-tRNA synthetase, bI4 intron transcribed recombinantly with flanking exons in the yeast nucleus exhibited splicing activity. These data combined with previous genetic results are consistent with a novel model for a ternary splicing complex (two protein: one RNA) in which both protein splicing partners bind directly to the bI4 intron and facilitate its self-splicing activity.     

Immunochemical evidence for conformational flexibility and its modulation by specific ligands in the beta 2 subunit of Escherichia coli tryptophan synthase

The immunochemical reactivity of unfractionated antibodies elicited by denatured beta 2 subunits of Escherichia coli tryptophan synthase [L-serine hydro-lyase (adding indole) EC 4.2.1.20] with the homologous antigen and with the native enzyme is examined. These antibodies recognize the native apoenzyme nearly as well as the denatured protein. On the contrary, after binding of its cofactor, pyridoxal 5'-phosphate, the protein exhibits a much lower immunoreactivity toward these antibodies. This decrease of affinity becomes even more pronounced when the beta 2 protein interacts with the alpha subunit. Similarly, reduction of the Schiff base formed between the cofactor and the protein leads to a strong decrease of immunoreactivity. To account for these results, it is proposed that apo-beta 2 must be a dynamic flexible structure that easily exposes to the solvent regions of its polypeptide chain that normally are buried in its interior. The increase in rigidity of this structure upon binding of the cofactor, reduction of Schiff base, and formation of the alpha 2 beta 2 complex would then account for the decreased immunoreactivity of these various states of the native beta 2 protein.