Agar quality of commercial agarophytes from different geographical origins: 1. Physical and rheological properties

Six economically important species ofGracilaria, from a number of commercial sources around the world, andGracilariopsis lemaneiformis, collected from two Japanese localities, were used as the sources of raw material for the evaluation of agar quality. Agar-agar was extracted by pretreatment with various concentratrions of NaOH (0%, 3%, 5%, 7%, 10%) incubated at 80 °C for 2 h. Agar yield, viscosity, dynamic gelling and melting temperature and gel texture were determined for 1.5% agar gels. The highest agar yield was obtained fromG. gracilis from Argentina (39.5%), while the lowest was from BrazilianG. gracilis (13.37%). Dynamic gelling temperature was highest in the agar fromG. gracilis from Turkey (59 °C) and lowest in the non-alkali treated agar isolated fromG. edulis from Indonesia (46 °C). Melting temperature ranged from 96 °C in the agars from the JapaneseGracilariopsis andG. chilensis from Chile to 69 °C in the non-alkali treated agar fromG. edulis from Indonesia. In general, all species produced an agar with high gel strength after treatment with 5% NaOH, except forG. chilensis and the twoGracilariopsis species, which produced an agar with high gel strength after treatment with 3, 7 and 10% NaOH. The highest gel strength (2056 ± 13.6 cm^–2) and hardest gel (261 ± 19.89 g mm^–2) were obtained fromG. lemaneiformis from Japan (Oita Prefecture) after treatment with 7 and 10% NaOH respectively. The lowest gel strength (351 ± 93 cm^–2) was obtained fromG. gracilis from Brazil after treatment with 3% NaOH. The softest gel (66.31 ± 9.63 g mm^–2) was isolated fromG. tenuistipitata from China, after treatment with 3% NaOH. The most flexible gel (11.62 ± 0.31 g mm^–2 × 10²) was obtained fromG. chilensis from Chile after treatment with 3% NaOH.Author for correspondence     

Seasonal changes in the chemical and gelling characteristics of agar from Gracilaria verrucosa collected in Turkey

The chemical and gelling properties of agar from G. verrucosa collected from Izmit bay in Turkey at different months of the year were studied. Purification of agar was performed by using amylase treatment and isopropyl alcohol precipitation. The phycocolloid content was between 24.0–43.0% of the algal dry weight and was maximum in summer collected algae. Relative total sulfate and 3,6-anhydrogalactose content in the agar were determined from the ratios of infrared spectroscopy band intensities at 1250/2920 cm^–1 and 930/2920 cm^–1, respectively. 3,6-anhydrogalactose and sulfate contents were the highest in agar from algae collected from June until November and January until July, respectively. The gel strength of native agar were the highest from in autumn collected algae and increased to about 1250 N m^–2 after alkali treatment. Thus, this study demonstrated that G. verrucosa from Turkey produces an agar with optimal chemical and gelling properties after alkali-treatment in fall and winter collected algae and may be used for industrial agar production.     

Comparison of three gracilarioids: growth rate, agar content and quality

Three gracilarioid species, Gracilariopsis bailiniae and Gracilaria tenuistipitata from Vietnam and Gracilaria gracilis from Russia, were studied in order to determine whether Gracilaria gracilis might be a superior species for cultivation in brackish-water ponds for agar production compared with the Vietnamese species. The effects of different salinity levels on the growth rate and agar production as well as agar properties of three gracilarioid species were compared in controlled laboratory experiments. Gracilaria tenuistipitata and G. gracilis were tolerant to low salinity (∼10‰), whereas Gp. bailiniae died under these conditions. G. tenuistipitata showed superior growth among the three species examined. Gracilaria gracilis had the highest agar content [36.8–46.6% dry weight (dw)]. Agar yield from Vietnamese gracilarioids did not exceed 30% dw. Gel strength of native agar from Gracilaria gracilis was two-fold higher that from Vietnamese species (278 g cm⁻² vs 130 g cm⁻²). Alkali pretreatment increased gel strength significantly for Gracilaria gracilis (1.4-fold), and G. tenuistipitata and Gp. bailiniae (2.3-fold) compared with native agar. The results suggest that Gracilaria gracilis may be a suitable species for production of reasonably good quality agar.     

Cultivation of Gracilaria verrucosa (Gracilariales,Rhodophyta) Strain G-16 for agar

The agarophyte, Gracilaria verrucosa Strain G-16, has been grown in sustained cultivation over a period of five years. During this period, a number of experiments were conducted to examine the productivity, agar yield and agar gel strength of this strain. Productivities range from 3–31 g dry wt m^–2 d^–1 and are generally highest in the summer when annual water temperatures and daily irradiances are highest. In the summer months agar yield from Strain G-16 appears to be lowest whereas the gel strength of the agars was highest (> 750 g cm^–2).     

Growth rates and agar properties of three gracilarioids in suspended open-water cultivation in St. Helena Bay, South Africa

Relative growth rates (RGRs), yields and agar characteristics of threegracilarioid isolates (Gracilariopsis sp. from St. Helena Bay, and Gracilaria gracilis isolates from Langebaan Lagoon and Saldanha Bay) weremeasured to assess the suitability of a site in St. Helena Bay for suspendedcultivation. The gracilarioids were grown on polypropylene ropes and`netlon' lines, and the RGRs were 4.0–11.0% d<sup>-1</sup> and 5.0–7.0%d<sup>-1</sup>, respectively. The RGR of the Langebaan isolate of G. gracilis grown on ropes was significantly higher than the RGR of otherisolates. The mean net yield for the Langebaan isolate grown on `netlon'lines was 2.6 ± 0.9 kg wet wt m^-2 30 day^-1. Thecultured gracilarioids were extracted for native and alkali treated agars. Themean native agar yield over the entire period was 39.0% dry wt. Alkalipretreatment reduced the yield by 55%, but significantly increased gelstrength. High gel strengths (>750 g cm^-2) were measured inagars from Gracilariopsis sp. and Saldanha Gracilaria gracilis inmid-summer and winter. The dynamic gelling and melting temperatures ofnative and alkali treated agars varied among the gracilarioids. The meangelling and melting temperatures of agars were about 39.0 ^°C and86.0 ^°C, respectively. The 3,6-AG content ranged from 29% to38% for native agars and 34–45% for alkali treated agars. While theseresults indicate that this site is suitable for gracilarioid cultivation, occasionallow-oxygen events in St. Helena Bay lead to production of hydrogensulphide in the sea water (`black tides'). Such events killed most inshorebiota (including seaweeds) in 1994 and 1998. This frequency (on average1–2 per decade) and duration (maximum 2 weeks) would have to beconsidered in planning commercial seaweed farming in St. Helena Bay.     

Seasonal agar yield and quality inGelidium canariensis (Grunow) Seoane-Camba (Gelidiales,Rhodophyta) from Gran Canaria,Spain

The seasonal effects on yield and gel properties ofGelidium canariensis agar were investigated at two intertidal populations at the northern coast of Gran Canaria. Physical and rheological properties were measured in 1.5% w/v solutions after treatment with alkali. No significant differences were found on agar characteristics between the two sites studied. The highest yields were obtained during summer with a maximum in June (27.8%) and minimum during late autumn and winter (18–18.6%). Overall quality was highest in winter (November–January), when gel strength peaked above 850 g cm^–2. The results showed an agar of industrial quality.     

Does storage time influence yield and agar properties in the tropical agarophyte Gracilaria cornea?

The agar yield and quality characteristics of Gracilaria cornea from Yucatán, Mexico, werestudied during 18 months of storage. Biomass wasstored at a temperature of 22.1 ± 0.9 ^°Cand humidity of 59.8±3.6%. The agar contentvaried erratically, but the average value waspractically constant over the storage period with an average of 20.1 ± 1.5±. Gel strength, gelling and meltingtemperatures were negatively affected by the totalstorage time. No significant changes were found duringthe first five months for these characteristics withmean values of 1134 ± 57 g cm^-2, 40.8 ±0.4 ^°C and 91.2 ± 0.9 ^°Crespectively. Agar degradation was evident after thefifth month and accounted for a 17± loss in gelstrength and 7± in gelling and meltingtemperatures. Nevertheless, gel strength valuesremained around 930 ± 23 g cm^-2 with nosignificant changes until the end of the storageperiod. The decrease in gel strength showed asignificant relationship with decrease in3,6-anhydrogalactose but not variation in sulphatecontent. This was probably due to agar hydrolysiscaused by enzymatic processes of endogenous and/ormicrobial origin. These results suggest that thetropical G. cornea had a similar resistance todegradation during storage to that observed for G. chilensis, a cold water species. Agar qualityand yield in G. cornea after one and a half yearof storage are within the range of food grade agar.     

Seasonal variation in the physical properties of agar and biomass of Gracilaria sp. (chorda type) from Tosa Bay,southern Japan

Plants of Gracilaria sp.(chorda type), which grow along the coast of Uranouchi Inlet in Tosa Bay, southern Japan, showed the highest biomass in the summer (26 °C to 31 °C) and spring season (15.1 °C to 24.9 °C). Maximum biomass was 6952 g m^–2 in July, but gradually decreased in the autumn (30.5 °C in September to 20 °C in November) and winter (19.5 °C in December to 14.9 °C in February). Variation in yields and gel strength of the agars, were shown to depend on the time in the season. After alkali treatment (5% NaOH, 2 h) at three different temperatures (70, 80, and 90 °C), the agars showed gel strengths essentially that of commercial grade agars, with the best gel obtained at 80 °C. Maximum gel strength (1455 g cm^–2 of 1.5% agar gel) occurred in winter when the biomass and agar yield were low. Minimum gel strength was in spring. Gel strength was inversely correlated with agar yield, but was positively correlated with apparent viscosity. Maximum viscosity was 40 cP. in December. Gelling temperatures, pH of 1.5% agar gel, and moisture content in agars showed little variation.     

The yield,physical and chemical properties of agar gel from Gracilaria species (Gracilariales,Rhodophyta) of the Kenya coast

Six species of Gracilaria, G. corticata J. Agardh, G. crassa Harvey, G. millardetii J. Agardh, G. salicornia (J. Ag.) Dawson, G. verrucosa (Huds.) Papenfuss and Gracilaria sp, collected from different stations along the Kenya coast were studied. The yield of hot water native agar extract ranges from 8.1–30% of dry weight, with G. verrucosa and G. salicornia having the greatest and the least yield, respectively. The gel-strength of 1.5% agar solution was highest in G. verrucosa (220 g cm^–2) and lowest in G. corticata (< 60 g cm – 2) whereas the highest gelling temperature was recorded for Gracilaria sp. (40.4 °C) and the lowest in G. verrucosa (28.9 °C). 3,6 anhydrogalactose content was the highest in G. verrucosa and the lowest in G. corticata while sulphate content was higher in the latter.     

Studies on Gracilaria changii (Gracilariales,Rhodophyta) from Malaysian mangroves

Gracilaria changii, recorded from Malaysia and Thailand, is one of the more abundant agarophytic seaweeds found in Malaysia. A wild population of Gracilaria changii growing in mangroves was monitored for seasonal variation in agar content and gel strength as well as spore production. Agar yield and gel strength ranged from 12 to 25% dry weight and 294 to 563 g cm^–2, respectively, over a 15-month period. Gel strength but not yield was positively correlated with amount of rainfall. Cystocarps were observed throughout the study, but use of sporetraps showed that spore release peaked around July–August and January–February after the two monsoon periods.Mariculture of Gracilaria changii in shallow ponds in the mangroves, in an irrrigation canal and in a shrimp farm pond was conducted. Average growth rate of cuttings tied to monofilament lines was 3.3 ± 1.7% d^–1, 8.4 ± 1.8% d^–1 and 3.6 ± 1.6% d^–1 respectively. Cuttings were lost to siltation, wave action, predation and heavy epiphytisation.These studies show that Gracilaria changii has potential commercial application in the agar industry.     

Effects of phosphate and nitrate supply on productivity,agar content and physical properties of agar ofGracilaria strain G-16S

Gracilaria strain G-16S was cultured in various phosphorus (P) supply rates with low or high nitrogen (N) supply to determine the effects of nutrient supply on its productivity, agar content and physical properties of the agar. Productivity was reduced after four weeks of growth in zero P supply as plants reached 0.07% P tissue content (critical level), with fragmentation of these plants by six weeks (0.05% P; minimum viable level). Native agar content was higher in low P and high N, or low N conditions. Agar content appeared to increase with decreasing P under high N supply. This increase was not apparent with alkali treatment prior to extraction. Agar gel strength was greatly increased by alkali treatment. The highest gel strengths were obtained under high N supply at all P supply rates except zero P, and under low N supply at 12 M P week^–1. Native agar gel strengths showed a similar pattern on a lower scale. Melting temperatures were higher in agars with higher gel strengths. Dynamic gelling temperatures were generally high for alkali-treated agar, with agar from plants grown in zero P supply showing a slightly elevated gelling temperature. Melting and gelling temperatures of native agars with the highest gel strengths were in the same range as bacteriological agar. These results show that P and N supply affects productivity, agar content and agar physical properties, but the tradeoffs between a slightly higher agar quantity under nutrient limitation and higher agar quality under nutrient-replete conditions seem to favor the latter.     

Cultivation and carrageenan yield and quality ofKappaphycus alvarezii in the waters of Vietnam

The carrageenan-producing red algaKappaphycus alvarezii (Doty) Doty was brought to Vietnam from Japan in 1993. Branch fragments of this species were cultivated in a pond, lagoon, inlet and offshore in Vietnam for the first time. The best daily growth rate (DGR) of plants grown in the lagoon area attained 9–11 % day^–1 in May to June (cold season). The water temperature and salinity in this area ranged from 27.2–32.4 °C and 31.4–33.7 °C, respectively. DGR of plants grown in the inlet ranged from 7 to 9% day^–1 in June. Grazing by fish has been observed to occur in this area. The DGR of plants grown in the pond ranged from 5–6% in January–July, but decreased to less than 4% day^–1 in August (hot season). K. alvarezii in Vietnam showed a carrageenan yield of 18.8–24.6% and gel strength of 1566–1712 g cm^–2. These values are similar ones obtained fromK. alvarezii cultivated in the Philippines and Indonesia.     

Agars from Gelidium rex (Gelidiales,Rhodophyta)

Gelidium rex grows in the rocky intertidal of central Chile. Extraction of vegetative G. rex with water at 95 °C yielded 17.9% of agar with a gel strength value of 590 g cm^–2. The gel strength increased up to 1272 g cm^–2 when the alga was treated with alkali prior to extraction. Cystocarpic and tetrasporic thalli of G. rex were extracted with distilled water at 95 °C, affording soluble polysaccharides in 36.0% and 15.7% yield respectively. Polysaccharides of both life history phases were fractionated by chromatography on DEAE Sephadex. Elution with distilled water gave fractions devoid of sulfate; the fraction from cystocarpic plants contained 45.5% of 3,6-anhydrogalactose whereas the neutral fraction from tetrasporic plants contained 40.0% of 3,6-anhydrogalactose. Further elution with 0.1, 0.4, 0.8 and 1.5 molar aqueous solutions of KCl afforded four fractions for each polysaccharide. Chemical analysis of these fractions showed that the agars from cystocarpic and tetrasporic Gelidium rex are mixtures of related polysaccharides that range from neutral polymers to highly sulfated galactans.     

Gracilaria species (Gracilariaceae, Rhodophyta) from southeastern Australia, including a new species, Gracilaria perplexa sp. nov.: Morphology, molecular relationships and agar content

Select species of the agarophyte Gracilaria were studied from southeastern Australia. The morphology and anatomy of species is described and molecular relations are inferred based on plastid and mitochon‐drial DNA sequence data. Agar yields and qualities are determined for each species. Gracilaria chilensis, found in Tasmania and Victoria, is morphologically and molecularly similar to G. chilensis from New Zealand and Chile and has low agar yields of 11–16%. Gracilaria cliftonii from Victoria, has high crude agar yield (52%) and is molecularly uniform. Gracilaria perplexa sp. nov., known only from Botany Bay, New South Wales, has an agar yield of 39%. The agar of G. perplexa is unusual in requiring the addition of 0.1 mol L^?1 NaCl for alcohol precipitation and is cold‐water (25°C) soluble because of the very high sulfate ester content. Molecular phylogeny shows that G. perplexa is closely related to Gracilaria preissiana from western Australia, but differs from the latter in its reduced branching and narrower more terete axes.     

Chemical characteristics and gelling properties of agar from two Philippine Gracilaria spp. (Gracilariales, Rhodophyta)

The chemical structure of agars extracted from Philippine Gracilaria arcuata and G. tenuistipitata were determined by NMR and infrared spectroscopy. Agar with alternating 3-linked 6-O-methyl-β-D-galactopyranosyl and 4-linked 3,6-anhydro-2- O-methyl-α-L-galactopyranosyl units was isolated from G. arcuata, while the agar from G. tenuistipitata possesses the regular agarobiose repeating unit with partial methylation at the 6-position of the D-galactosyl residues. Both agars exhibit sulphate substitution at varying positions in the polymer. Chemical analyses reveal higher 3,6-anhydrogalactose and lower sulphate contents in alkali-modified than in native agar from both samples. Also, alkali modification enhanced agar gel strength and syneresis. Native G. arcuata agar produces a viscous solution (2000 cP at 75 °C) with a high gelling point (>60 °C) that forms a soft gel even after alkali modification (gel strength: <300 g cm⁻²). On the other hand, the agar from G. tenuistipitata exhibits gel qualities typical of most Gracilaria agars. This revised version was published online in June 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

The effect of phosphate concentration on growth and agar content of Gelidium robustum (Gelidiaceae,Rhodophyta) in culture

Phosphate concentration of the growth medium was found to affect the growth rate and agar yield of a clone of Gelidium robustum grown in the laboratory. To study differences in growth we used phosphate concentrations from 0 to 200 µM. To determine the effect of phosphate on agar yield and its properties we used concentrations from 0 to 20 µM. Growth rates generally increased with increasing phosphate concentration, with the highest growth rate (21% d^–1) obtained at 150 µM. Agar yield as percentage of fresh weight was highest (10%) in the algae grown with low phosphate concentrations, but agar yield as percentage of dry weight was highest(43%) at 20 µM of phosphate. Gel strength increased with phosphate concentration with a maximum of 160 g m^–2 for 0.75% gels for the cultures at 20 µM. Melting and gelling temperatures of the gels were also affected by phosphate concentration of the growth medium. Starch yield was highest in algae grown in low phosphate concentrations.     

Agar properties of two species of Gracilariaceae from the Gulf of California,Mexico

Agar properties of two potentially commercial important seaweeds from the Gulf of California were studied. Maximum yield in Gracilaria vermiculophylla (45.7%) occurred during the summer months, coinciding with high water temperatures (31°C) whereas minimum yields (11.6%) were obtained during the coldest months of the year when populations of this species diminish in the bay. Gracilariopsis longissima showed two yield peaks, one in spring and another in fall, before the maximum and minimum seawater temperatures. Gel strength in native agar from the two species was low (<22.5 g cm⁻²) for most of the year. G. vermiculophylla native agar showed a slight increase in gel strength from June to August, which were the hottest months. Maximum value was 85 g cm⁻¹ in August. Maximum gel strength in G. longissima was observed in October (91 g cm⁻¹), and an unusual native agar with no detectable gel strength was observed in March and April samples. Gelling temperatures range from 27.7 to 36.5°C in G. vermiculophyla and from 26.6 to 34.9°C in G. longissima, meanwhile melting points were 73.9 – 53.5°C and 75.5 – 56.6°C, respectively. Sulfate content was high, 6.3–13.9% in G. vermiculophylla and 1.9–11.9% in G. longissima, and on the other hand 3,6 anhydrogalactose content was low 12.1–26.7% and 9.1–23%, respectively compared to other species. Results obtained showed that mean native agar yields of Gracilaria vermiculophylla and Gracilariopsis longissima from the Gulf of California are comparable to other tropical Gracilaria. However, the low gel strength, high sulfate content and low 3,6 anhydrogalactose content observed in the native agar extracted from these species make this an agaroid, thus alternative methods of extraction should be used to evaluate the possibility of commercial utilization of both species.     

Optimization and scale-up of a new photobleaching agar extraction process from Gracilaria lemaneiformis

An eco-friendly photobleaching extraction process for agar extraction from the red alga Gracilaria lemaneiformis was developed for the benefit of workers’ health and environmental safety. Here we report the optimization of key process parameters (alkali modification concentration, photobleaching duration, algal length and screen filter opening size) in order to scale up this new technique. The optimal conditions were found to be modification by 3–5% NaOH, photobleaching for 5 h, using algal fragments 2 –4 cm in length, and a filter screen with a 6 μm opening. A 20-L agar extraction reactor was thus constructed, and the scale-up of the agar extraction process was tested in six batch experiments. The resulting agar quality was similar to that of the laboratory-scale extraction. In addition, batch-to-batch reproducibility was excellent. The results demonstrate the excellent scale-up ability and potential application of this new photobleaching agar extraction process on a commercial scale. The agar yield and gel strength for 5% NaOH modified agar were 26.8% and 1,897 g cm⁻², while those for 3% NaOH modified agar were 28.2% and 1,287 g cm⁻², respectively. It is clear that the agar yield and quality can be manipulated via alkali modification in this new eco-friendly extraction to meet market demands.     

Seasonal variation in agar composition and properties from Gracilaria gracilis (Gracilariales,Rhodophyta) of the Patagonian coast of Argentina

Seasonal variation of agar from specimens of a commercially exploited population of Gracilaria gracilis (Stackhouse) Steentoft, Irvine & Farnham in the Patagonian coast of Argentina was studied. For each seasonal harvest, random samples of plants were pooled for subsequent polysaccharide extraction at different water temperatures and agar physico‐chemical properties and composition were determined. Both spring and summer plants yielded 30% and 41% of agar, respectively, which differed slightly in their at rest rheological behavior. Spring and summer plants produced strong gels (238 and 218 g cm^?2, respectively), but the latter gels had nil adhesiveness. In autumn plants, agar yield decayed to 19%, though the product still maintained similar gel strength (210 g cm^?2). Adhesiveness in this product was at least an order of magnitude higher than in the others, concomitant with a peak in the formation of tetraspores and carpospores. This suggests a biological role for the galactan in the initial attachment of spores to the substrate. But since fall corresponds to the settling of reproductive structures, caution should be taken to harvest the algae once spores have been shed from mother plants.     

Superior quality agar from <Emphasis Type="Italic">Gracilaria</Emphasis> species (Gracilariales,Rhodophyta) collected from the Gulf of Mannar,India

Gracilaria edulis, G. crassa, G. foliifera, and G. corticata are naturally occurring agarophytes of Indian waters. These agarophytes were evaluated for their agar contents using an improved process recently reported by us (US Patent 2005/0267296A1). The effect of different concentrations of NaOH in the alkali treatment was studied for optimizing the extraction conditions. These Gracilaria species of Indian waters produced agars, both native and alkali treated, with different properties confirming the heterogeneity of the agar polymers in this genera, as one would expect. Among these, G. edulis and G. crassa produced agar polymers having high gel strengths of 490 ± 8.16 and 800 ± 15.4 g cm⁻², respectively, with 8% NaOH treatment as opposed the low gel strength agars that have been reported in the literature to date.