VLR Recognition of TLR5 Expands the Molecular Characterization of Protein Antigen Binding by Non-Ig-based Antibodies

Variable lymphocyte receptors (VLRs) are unconventional adaptive immune receptors relatively recently discovered in the phylogenetically ancient jawless vertebrates, lamprey and hagfish. VLRs bind antigens using a leucine-rich repeat fold and are the only known adaptive immune receptors that do not utilize an immunoglobulin fold for antigen recognition. While immunoglobulin antibodies have been studied extensively, there are comparatively few studies on antigen recognition by VLRs, particularly for protein antigens. Here we report isolation, functional and structural characterization of three VLRs that bind the protein toll-like receptor 5 (TLR5) from zebrafish. Two of the VLRs block binding of TLR5 to its cognate ligand flagellin in functional assays using reporter cells. Co-crystal structures revealed that these VLRs bind to two different epitopes on TLR5, both of which include regions involved in flagellin binding. Our work here demonstrates that the lamprey adaptive immune system can be used to generate high-affinity VLR clones that recognize different epitopes and differentially impact natural ligand binding to a protein antigen.     

In vitro selection and characterization of DARPins and Fab fragments for the co-crystallization of membrane proteins: The Na(+)-citrate symporter CitS as an example

The determination of 3D structures of membrane proteins is still extremely difficult. The co-crystallization with specific binding proteins may be an important aid in this process, as these proteins provide rigid, hydrophilic surfaces for stable protein-protein contacts. Also, the conformational homogeneity of the membrane protein may be increased to obtain crystals suitable for high resolution structures. Here, we describe the efficient generation and characterization of Designed Ankyrin Repeat Proteins (DARPins) as specific binding molecules for membrane proteins. We used both phage display and ribosome display to select DARPins in vitro that are specific for the detergent-solubilized Na(+)-citrate symporter CitS of Klebsiella pneumoniae. Compared to classical hybridoma technology, the in vitro selection systems allow a much better control of the structural integrity of the target protein and allow the use of other protein classes in addition to recombinant antibodies. We also compared the selected DARPins to a Fab fragment previously selected by phage display and demonstrate that different epitopes are recognized, unique to each class of binding molecules. Therefore, the use of several classes of binding molecules will make suitable crystal formation and the determination of their 3D structure more likely.     

Definition of the immunogenic forms of modified human LDL recognized by human autoantibodies and by rabbit hyperimmune antibodies

Humans and laboratory animals recognize human modified LDL as immunogenic. Immune complexes (ICs) isolated from human sera contain malondialdehyde-modified LDL (MDA-LDL) and N (epsilon)(carboxymethyl)lysine-modified LDL (CML-LDL) as well as antibodies reacting with MDA-LDL, copper-oxidized LDL (OxLDL), CML-LDL, and advanced glycosylation end product (AGE)-modified LDL. OxLDL and AGE-LDL antibodies isolated from human sera recognize the same LDL modifications and do not react with modified non-LDL proteins. Rabbit antibodies have different reactivity patterns: MDA-LDL antibodies react strongly with MDA-LDL and MDA-BSA but weakly with OxLDL; OxLDL antibodies react strongly with OxLDL and weakly with MDA-LDL; CML-LDL antibodies react with CML-LDL > CML-BSA > AGE-LDL > OxLDL; AGE-LDL antibodies react strongly with AGE-LDL, react weakly with OxLDL, and do not react with CML-LDL. Thus, human and rabbit antibodies seem to recognize different epitopes. Capture assays carried out with all rabbit antibodies showed binding of apolipoprotein B-rich lipoproteins isolated from ICs, suggesting that laboratory-generated epitopes are expressed by in vivo-modified LDL, although they are not necessarily recognized by the human immune system. Thus, the definition of immunogenic forms of modified LDL eliciting human autoimmune responses requires the isolation and characterization of autoantibodies and modified LDL from human samples, whereas rabbit antibodies can be used to detect in vivo-modified human LDL.     

Monoclonal antibodies obtained against G-protein epitopes: comparison of immunoreactions seen in the brain, retina and striated muscular tissue]

Monoclonal antibodies have been obtained against a purified fraction of brain G proteins containing the Gi alpha, G0 alpha, G beta, and G gamma subunits. After characterization, two monoclonal antibodies have been used to detect the cellular distribution of the two epitopes in neural, retinal and muscular tissues: ELISA, cross-dot and Western blot demonstrated that F.IV.5 is an anti-G beta antibody specific for the 36 kDa beta-subunit. ELISA, cross-dot and immunocytochemical distribution of the epitopes recognized by F.VII.9 suggested that this antibody recognizes epitopes which are also detected with polyclonal anti-G0 alpha antibodies. With both monoclonal antibodies, we confirmed that G proteins demonstrated a sub-membranous distribution as well as extensively cytoplasmic, axoplasmic or sarcoplasmic distributions in different cell types.     

Immunodominance of conformation-dependent B-cell epitopes of protein antigens

Immunodominance of conformational epitopes over linear ones in four proteins was quantified making use of the B-cell hybridoma technology. The proteins were immunized in their native forms into BALB/c mice, and clonal frequencies of B-cell hybridomas that produce antibodies to the native and denatured forms were determined, using ELISA and immunoblotting. All 16 monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) to Porphyromonas gingivalis fimbria were suggested to recognize conformational epitopes expressed by the oligomer. Ten out of 14 mAbs to Serratia marcescens fimbria and 13 of 15 mAbs to hen lysozyme were also specific to their conformational epitopes. In contrast, all 18 mAbs to a surface protein of Streptococcus mutans, termed PAc, reacted to both the native and denatured forms, thereby indicating the immunodominance of linear epitopes in this protein. The results suggest that B-cell epitopes of proteins possessing stable tertiary or quaternary structures are predominantly expressed by the higher-order structures.     

Recombinant renewable polyclonal antibodies

Only a small fraction of the antibodies in a traditional polyclonal antibody mixture recognize the target of interest, frequently resulting in undesirable polyreactivity. Here, we show that high-quality recombinant polyclonals, in which hundreds of different antibodies are all directed toward a target of interest, can be easily generated in vitro by combining phage and yeast display. We show that, unlike traditional polyclonals, which are limited resources, recombinant polyclonal antibodies can be amplified over one hundred million-fold without losing representation or functionality. Our protocol was tested on 9 different targets to demonstrate how the strategy allows the selective amplification of antibodies directed toward desirable target specific epitopes, such as those found in one protein but not a closely related one, and the elimination of antibodies recognizing common epitopes, without significant loss of diversity. These recombinant renewable polyclonal antibodies are usable in different assays, and can be generated in high throughput. This approach could potentially be used to develop highly specific recombinant renewable antibodies against all human gene products.     

Recombinant renewable polyclonal antibodies

Only a small fraction of the antibodies in a traditional polyclonal antibody mixture recognize the target of interest, frequently resulting in undesirable polyreactivity. Here, we show that high-quality recombinant polyclonals, in which hundreds of different antibodies are all directed toward a target of interest, can be easily generated in vitro by combining phage and yeast display. We show that, unlike traditional polyclonals, which are limited resources, recombinant polyclonal antibodies can be amplified over one hundred million-fold without losing representation or functionality. Our protocol was tested on 9 different targets to demonstrate how the strategy allows the selective amplification of antibodies directed toward desirable target specific epitopes, such as those found in one protein but not a closely related one, and the elimination of antibodies recognizing common epitopes, without significant loss of diversity. These recombinant renewable polyclonal antibodies are usable in different assays, and can be generated in high throughput. This approach could potentially be used to develop highly specific recombinant renewable antibodies against all human gene products.     

Detecting multiple proteins by Western blotting using same-species primary antibodies, precomplexed serum, and hydrogen peroxide

Western blot detection of multiple proteins is challenged by the need to use antibodies from the same species and the harsh stripping methods that can remove protein or reduce protein antigenicity. Quenching using 27% hydrogen peroxide was developed as an alternative to stripping to inhibit horseradish peroxidase used to detect secondary antibodies. To detect two epitopes with same-species primary antibodies, quenching was followed by incubation in a precomplexed mixture of primary and secondary antibodies for the second epitope plus serum from that species. Both methods will be valuable in specific detection of multiple proteins by Western blotting, and will save time, valuable samples, and reagents.     

Generation of epitope-specific antibodies to rat GHBP in the sheep using an interspecies switching strategy involving site-directed mutagenesis of ovine GHBP.

Site-directed antibodies to the growth hormone receptor could be potentially useful as growth hormone mimics but, in previous attempts, we found that antisera generated using peptides derived from growth hormone receptor sequences failed to recognize the intact protein. As an alternative approach to this problem, we have now adopted a strategy of epitope-switching between rat and ovine growth hormone receptors to produce rat epitopes in the correct structural context. Using site-directed mutagenesis, we altered the two dominant linear epitopes in the ovine growth hormone binding protein to the analogous sequences in rat growth hormone binding protein. Site A, between Thr28 and Leu34, is equivalent to epitope 1 in ovine growth hormone binding protein and site B, between Ser121 and Asp124, corresponds to epitope 5. The wild-type ovine growth hormone binding protein and the two mutant proteins were bacterially expressed, refolded and, following purification by metal-chelate affinity chromatography, used to raise antisera in sheep. We showed using RIA, in which wild-type ovine growth hormone binding protein acted as a competitor for the binding of rat growth hormone binding protein, that only the site A mutant protein elicited a specific anti-rat growth hormone binding protein response. This was confirmed in subsequent RIA studies using the antiserum to the site A mutant protein in which only peptides corresponding to the site A sequences in mutant ovine growth hormone binding protein and rat growth hormone binding protein, but not that in wild-type ovine growth hormone binding protein, were able to act as competitors for rat growth hormone binding protein. Antibodies specific for rat growth hormone binding protein could be separated from the antiserum to the site A mutant protein by means of affinity chromatography using immobilized wild-type ovine growth hormone binding protein to remove antibodies which cross-reacted with the ovine protein. The work lays the foundations for further studies in which the biological effects of these antibody fractions will be investigated and demonstrates an approach with general applicability in the production of antibodies directed towards specific epitopes on protein molecules.     

CENP-C, an autoantigen in scleroderma, is a component of the human inner kinetochore plate.

We have isolated and characterized a set of overlapping cDNA clones that encode the human centromere autoantigen centromere protein C (CENP-C). The identity of these clones has been established using several criteria. First, they were shown to encode a polypeptide that migrates at the expected position for CENP-C on SDS-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. Second, we have demonstrated that this polypeptide shares at least two epitopes with human CENP-C. Polyclonal antibodies were raised to fusion proteins encoded by nonoverlapping regions of the cDNA clones. These antibodies were shown to recognize a protein at a position appropriate for CENP-C on immunoblots of human chromosomal proteins. In addition, we used indirect immunofluorescence to demonstrate that these antibodies recognize centromeres of HeLa chromosomes in the expected pattern for CENP-C. Localization of CENP-C by immunoelectron microscopy reveals that this protein is a component of the inner kinetochore plate.     

Characterization of FimA in Porphyromonas gingivalis genotype IV

It has been reported that a large majority of periodontitis patients carry organisms with either type II or IV-fimA, while type I is the most prevalent fimA genotype among Porphyromonas gingivalis-positive healthy adults. Here we report characterization of recombinant fimbrial protein (rFimA) produced in Escherichia coli from genotype IV-fimA. In SDS-PAGE and immunoblot analysis after partial dissociation, type IV-rFimA showed a ladder-like pattern representing oligomeric/polymeric forms of native fimbrial structure. Unlike anti-type I-native fimbriae which can only recognize conformational epitopes of the respective proteins, both anti-type IV-native fimbriae and anti-type IV-rFimA antibodies recognized conformational as well as linear epitopes in type IV-fimbriae. These results suggest that the type IV-rFimA proteins retain the native fimbrial antigenicity and the antigenicity of type IV-fimbriae is different from that of type I-fimbriae.     

Binding of human plasma proteins to Streptococcus pyogenes M protein determines the location of opsonic and non-opsonic epitopes

Antibodies directed against a pathogenic microorganism may recognize either protective or non-protective epitopes. Because antibodies elicited by a vaccine must be directed against protective epitopes, it is essential to understand the molecular properties that distinguish the two types of epitope. Here we analyse this problem for the antiphagocytic M protein of Streptococcus pyogenes, using the opsonizing capacity of antibodies to estimate their ability to confer protection in vivo. Our studies were focused on the M5 protein, which has three surface-exposed regions: the amino-terminal hypervariable region (HVR) and the B- and C-repeat regions. We first analysed the role of different M5 regions in phagocytosis resistance under non-immune conditions, employing chromosomal mutants expressing M5 proteins with internal deletions, and demonstrate that only the B-repeat region is essential for phagocytosis resistance. However, only antibodies to the HVR were opsonic. This apparent paradox could be explained by the ability of fibrinogen and albumin to specifically bind to the B- and C-repeats, respectively, causing inhibition of antibody binding under physiological conditions, while antibodies to the HVR could bind and promote deposition of complement. These data indicate that binding of human plasma proteins plays an important role in determining the location of opsonic and non-opsonic epitopes in streptococcal M protein.     

Determination of membrane antigens by a covalent crosslinking method with monoclonal antibodies

Monoclonal antibodies that recognize cell surface proteins may serve as very useful tools for the study of the biological functions of membrane proteins. However, solubilization of the antigens with detergents may lead to major conformational changes of the protein, making their determination with monoclonal antibodies by immune blot or ordinary immunoprecipitation methods difficult. This is especially evident when the monoclonal antibodies recognize tertiary structures of the proteins in the membrane. We have generated two monoclonal antibodies which are specific for the cell surface antigens of multidrug-resistant human cell lines. However, the antigens of both monoclonal antibodies were difficult to detect by either immune blot or ordinary immunoprecipitation methods. We used a cleavable crosslinking reagent dithiobis(succinimidyl propionate) to covalently link the monoclonal antibody with its antigenic determinant in the membrane of intact cells. By this method, we were able to detect the antigens for these two monoclonal antibodies following solubilization, immunoprecipitation, and analysis by sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. This method should have wide applicability in determination of membrane antigens recognized by monoclonal antibodies when immune blot or ordinary immunoprecipitation methods are not successful.     

Epitope mapping of Escherichia coli cell division protein FtsZ with monoclonal antibodies.

A fusion between lacZ and ftsZ of Escherichia coli was constructed to obtain a beta-galactosidase-FtsZ fusion protein. This fusion protein was used to raise antibodies against cell division protein FtsZ. Six monoclonal antibodies were obtained, and they reacted with FtsZ from cytoplasm and membrane fractions. The epitopes in FtsZ were localized by studying the reactions of the monoclonal antibodies with fusion proteins truncated at the carboxy terminus and with fragments that were obtained by CNBr cleavage of purified FtsZ. Five different epitopes were defined. Epitopes I and III reacted with the same monoclonal antibody, without showing apparent amino acid homology. Epitope II was defined by monoclonal antibodies that cross-reacted with an unknown cytoplasmic 50-kDa protein not related to FtsZ. Epitopes IV and V were recognized by different monoclonal antibodies. All monoclonal antibodies reacted strongly under native conditions, so it is likely that the five epitopes are situated on the surface of native FtsZ. By using these data and computer analysis, a provisional model of FtsZ is proposed. The FtsZ protein is considered to be globular, with a hydrophobic pocket containing GTP-binding elements. Epitopes I and II are situated on each side of the hydrophobic pocket. Because the carboxy terminus contains epitope V, the carboxy terminus of FtsZ is likely oriented toward the protein's surface.     

Antigenic analysis of a major neutralization site of herpes simplex virus glycoprotein D, using deletion mutants and monoclonal antibody-resistant mutants.

Herpes simplex virus glycoprotein D is a component of the virion envelope and appears to be involved in attachment, penetration, and cell fusion. Monoclonal antibodies against this protein can be arranged in groups on the basis of a number of biological and biochemical properties. Group I antibodies are type common, have high complement-independent neutralization titers, and recognize discontinuous (conformational) epitopes; they are currently being used in several laboratories to study the functions of glycoprotein D. We have used a panel of neutralization-resistant mutants to examine the relationships between these antibodies in detail. We found that they can be divided into two subgroups, Ia and Ib, such that mutations selected with Ia antibodies have little or no effect on binding and neutralization by Ib antibodies and vice versa. In addition, Ia antibodies are able to bind deletion and truncation mutants of glycoprotein D that Ib antibodies do not recognize, suggesting that their epitopes are physically distinct. However, with one exception, Ia and Ib antibodies block each other strongly in binding assays with purified glycoprotein D, whereas antibodies from other groups have no effect. We have therefore defined the sum of the Ia and Ib epitopes as antigenic site 1.     

Monoclonal antibodies and mechanistic studies on recA protein.

A protein has various epitopes, and a monoclonal antibody specifically binds to the protein by recognizing 1 of the epitopes. This characteristic of the monoclonal antibody has opened various new approaches in a wide variety of research works. In studies about recA protein and its promoted various reactions relating to genetic recombination, anti-recA protein-monoclonal antibodies are very useful to analyse reaction mechanisms and to detect transition in the higher order-structure of the protein, as well as to measure the amounts of recA protein in vitro or in vivo and to identify the related proteins. In this article, we will review studies on recA protein in which monoclonal antibodies were used as major tools. By using anti-recA protein-monoclonal IgGs as specific inhibitors, the partial reactions of the homologous pairing and strand exchange promoted by recA protein were separated, and by use of a set of anti-recA protein IgGs the stages of activation of recA protein in the above reactions were discriminated.     

Rapid determination of antigenic epitopes in human NGAL using NMR

The recent remarkable rise in biomedical applications of antibodies and their recombinant constructs has shifted the interest in determination of antigenic epitopes in target proteins from the areas of protein science and molecular immunology to the vast fields of modern biotechnology. In this article, we demonstrated that measuring binding induced changes in two‐dimensional NMR spectra enables rapid determination of antibody binding footprints on target protein antigens. Such epitopes recognized by six high‐affinity monoclonal murine antibodies (mAbs) against human neutrophil gelatinase‐associated lipocalin (NGAL) were determined by measuring chemical shifts or broadening of peaks in ¹H‐¹⁵N‐TROSY HSQC and ¹H‐¹³C HSQC spectra of isotope‐labeled NGAL occurring upon its binding to the antibodies. Locations of the epitopes defined by the NMR studies are in good agreement with the results of antibody binding pairing observed by dual‐color fluorescence cross‐correlation spectroscopy. In all six cases, the antibodies recognize conformational epitopes in regions of relatively rigid structure on the protein. None of the antibodies interact with the more flexible funnel‐like opening of the NGAL calyx. All determined epitope areas in NGAL reflect the dimensions of respective antibody binding surface (paratopes) and contain amino acid residues that provide strong interactions. This NMR‐based approach offers comprehensive information on antigenic epitopes and can be applied to numerous protein targets of diagnostic or therapeutic interest. © 2010 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. Biopolymers 93: 657–667, 2010. This article was originally published online as an accepted preprint. The “Published Online” date corresponds to the preprint version. You can request a copy of the preprint by emailing the Biopolymers editorial office at biopolymers@wiley.com     

Prokaryotic gene fusion expression systems and their use in structural and functional studies of proteins

The ability to express and purify large quantity of proteins in bacteria has greatly impacted many aspects of biological research. These include their use as a source of reagent for biochemical and biophysical studies as well as a source of antigen for antibody production. Currently many different expression systems are available and new ones are being developed. These systems allow inducible expression of a desired protein as a fusion with an affinity tag for simple purification. The affinity tags can generally be removed by specific proteases which recognize cleavage sites engineered between the affinity tag and the desired protein. Presence of tags that encode epitopes of specific antibodies provide additional means for identification of recombinant proteins. This review provides an overview of some of the most commonly utilized expression systems and examples of the use of these proteins in biochemical and biophysical studies. I will also describe other available systems which may provide suitable alternative for expression of recombinant proteins.     

Immunochemical Properties of Ubiquitin Conjugates in the Paired Helical Filaments of Alzheimer Disease

Immunocytochemical and peptide sequencing studies indicate that the regulatory protein ubiquitin (Ub) is incorporated into the paired helical filaments (PHF) of Alzheimer disease. In this study, we showed that some antibodies raised to PHF recognize epitopes of Ub. Analysis of the Ub sequences recognized by the antibodies raised to PHF, along with the known specificity of several monoclonal antibodies raised to artificial Ub conjugates, indicates the immunochemical representation of Ub residues 34-76 in PHF. The Ub epitopes recognized by antibodies raised to PHF are distinct from those recognized by antibodies raised to artificial Ub conjugates in two respects. First, antibodies that are raised to PHF and that recognize Ub react with PHF equally, whether denatured or not, whereas those raised to artificial Ub conjugates show greater reaction after denaturation. Second, mapping of the epitopes recognized by two monoclonal antibodies to PHF onto Ub indicates a distinction in the Ub residues recognized, compared with monoclonal antibodies raised to artificial Ub conjugates. The proximity of their epitopes to the site of conjugation, as well as their affinity for PHF polypeptides, suggests that the PHF antibodies that recognize Ub may be directed specifically to Ub epitopes defined by the protein conjugated to Ub.