Horse heart myoglobin reconstituted with a symmetrical heme. A circular dichroism study

Proton NMR studies on myoglobins and hemoglobins reconstituted with non-natural hemes, possessing different side chains in the pyrrolic rings, have provided interesting information for the understanding of the mechanism governing heme reorientation in the globin pocket, during synthesis of the native protein in vivo or in the reconstitution process in vitro. More recently, circular dichroism (CD) studies have been reported as a qualitative, alternative tool, with respect to 1H-NMR for detecting heme disorder in a reconstituted myoglobin or hemoglobin. In this paper, a CD study is reported on the reconstitution of horse heart myoglobin with protoheme XIII, a heme possessing true rotational symmetry about its alpha, gamma-meso axis. The results obtained show that the reconstitution product with this heme, which binds to the apoprotein with high affinity, not dissimilar from that of the natural heme, is characterized by a CD spectrum with bands possessing rotational strengths much lower than in the native protein. Furthermore, the CD changes detected as a function of time, during heme reorientation, in the case of natural heme, are absent when the apoprotein is reconstituted with protoheme XIII. These data provide independent evidence for reorientation of the natural heme, which follows its insertion into the protein matrix.     

Local dynamic properties of the heme pocket in native and solvent-induced molten-globule-like states of cytochrome c

We report the Soret absorption band, down to cryogenic temperature, of native and molten-globule-like state of horse heart cytochrome c. The band profile is analyzed in terms of vibronic coupling of the heme normal modes to the electronic transition in the framework of the Franck-Condon approximation. From the temperature dependence of the Gaussian broadening and of the peak position, we obtain information on the 'bath' of low frequency harmonic motions of the heme group within the heme pocket. The reported data indicate that, compared to the native state, the less rigid tertiary structure of the molten globule is reflected in a higher flexibility of the heme pocket and in greater conformational disorder, allowing the transduction of large-amplitude motion of the protein to the dynamics of the heme pocket.     

The structure of hemoglobin reconstituted with deuteroheme

The structure of horse methemoglobin reconstituted with deuteroheme, in which the heme vinyl substituents are replaced by hydrogens, has been compared with that of native horse methemoglobin by X-ray difference Fourier techniques. The tertiary structures of the two molecules are almost completely identical, with the exception of small perturbations in the globin which occur in direct response to the missing vinyls. These perturbations are, however, highly localized and do not propagate beyond the immediate vicinity of the hemes. Contrary to expectation, complete removal of these heme vinyls results in much less drastic structural changes than does replacement by ethyl substituents, as in methemoglobin reconstituted with mesoheme.     

Solution 1H NMR investigation of the seating and rotational "hopping" of centrosymmetric etioheme-I in myoglobin: effect of globin origin and its oxidation/spin state on heme dynamics

Solution 1H NMR spectroscopy was used to investigate the heme active-site structure and dynamics of rotation about the Fe-His bond of centrosymmetric etioheme-I reconstituted into sperm whale and horse myoglobin (Mb). Comparison of the NOESY cross-peak pattern and paramagnetic relaxation properties of the cyanomet complexes confirm a heme pocket that is essentially the same as Mb with either native protoheme or etioheme-I. Dipolar contacts between etioheme and the conserved heme pocket residues establish a unique seating of etioheme that conserves the orientation of the N-Fe-N vector relative to the axial His plane, with ethyl groups occupying the vinyl positions of protoheme. Saturation transfer between methyls on adjacent pyrroles in etioheme-reconstituted horse Mb in all accessible oxidation/spin states reveals rotational hopping rates that decrease dramatically with either loss of ligands or reduction of the heme, and correlate qualitatively with expectations based on the Fe-His bond strength and the rate of heme dissociation from Mb. The rate of hopping for etioheme in metMbCN, in contrast to hemes with propionates, is the same in the sperm whale and horse proteins.     

Crystal structures of modified myoglobins. I. Heme orientation and structural changes around heme in myoglobins reconstituted with isopemptoheme, pemptoheme, 2-ethyldeuteroheme, and 4-ethyldeuteroheme

The crystal structures of sperm whale metmyoglobins reconstituted with four modified hemes, isopemptoheme, pemptoheme, 2-ethyldeuteroheme, and 4-ethyldeuteroheme, have been determined and refined at 2.2 A resolution to R = 0.217, 0.218, 0.213, and 0.222, respectively. All the crystals of these myoglobins are isomorphous with that of native metmyoglobin. The structural changes of the modified myoglobin from the native myoglobin were examined on difference Fourier maps; the orientation of 4-ethyldeuteroheme in the heme pocket is such that the heme is rotated by 180 degrees about an axis through the alpha-gamma-meso carbons, whereas the orientations of the other three hemes are the same as that of the protoheme in the native myoglobin. The changes of the structures around the heme become greater in the order of isopemptoheme, 2-ethyldeuteroheme less than pemptoheme less than 4-ethyldeuteroheme. The magnitudes of the changes seem to be related to the oxygen affinities of these four reconstituted myoglobins.     

Optical band splitting and electronic perturbations of the heme chromophore in cytochrome C at room temperature probed by visible electronic circular dichroism spectroscopy

We have measured the electronic circular dichroism (ECD) of the ferri- and ferro-states of several natural cytochrome c derivatives (horse heart, chicken, bovine, and yeast) and the Y67F mutant of yeast in the region between 300 and 750 nm. Thus, we recorded the ECD of the B- and Q-band region as well as the charge-transfer band at approximately 695 nm. The B-band region of the ferri-state displays a nearly symmetric couplet at the B0-position that overlaps with a couplet 790 cm-1 higher in energy, which we assigned to a vibronic side-band transition. For the ferro-state, the couplet is greatly reduced, but still detectable. The B-band region is dominated by a positive Cotton effect at energies lower than B0 that is attributed to a magnetically allowed iron-->heme charge-transfer transition as earlier observed for nitrosyl myoglobin and hemoglobin. The Q-band region of the ferri-state is poorly resolved, but displays a pronounced positive signal at higher wavenumbers. This must result from a magnetically allowed transition, possibly from the methionine ligand to the dxy-hole of Fe3+. For the ferro-state, the spectra resolve the vibronic structure of the Qv-band. A more detailed spectral analysis reveals that the positively biased spectrum can be understood as a superposition of asymmetric couplets of split Q0 and Qv-states. Substantial qualitative and quantitative differences between the respective B-state and Q-state ECD spectra of yeast and horse heart cytochrome c can clearly be attributed to the reduced band splitting in the former, which results from a less heterogeneous internal electric field. Finally, we investigated the charge-transfer band at 695 nm in the ferri-state spectrum and found that it is composed of at least three bands, which are assignable to different taxonomic substates. The respective subbands differ somewhat with respect to their Kuhn anisotropy ratio and their intensity ratios are different for horse and yeast cytochrome c. Our data therefore suggests different substate populations for these proteins, which is most likely assignable to a structural heterogeneity of the distal Fe-M80 coordination of the heme chromophore.     

Etiohemin as a prosthetic group of myoglobin

Sperm whale myoglobin was reconstituted with etioheme and the stoichiometric complex formation was confirmed. The proton NMR spectrum of the deoxy myoglobin exhibits an NH signal from the proximal histidine at 78.6 ppm, indicating heme incorporation into the heme pocket to form the Fe-N(His-F8) bond. The appearance of a single set of the heme-methyl NMR signals shows that etioheme without acid side-chains specifically interacts with the surrounding globin. The visible spectral data suggest retention of a normal iron coordination structure. The functional and NMR spectral properties of etioheme myoglobin are similar to those of mesoheme myoglobin, reflecting the absence of the electron-withdrawing heme vinyl groups.     

1H NMR study of labile proton exchange in the heme cavity as a probe for the potential ligand entry channel in myoglobin

The exchange rates of heme cavity histidine nitrogen-bound protons in horse and dog metcyanomyoglobins have been determined at 40 degrees C as a function of pH by 1H NMR spectroscopy. They were compared to the results reported for the sperm whale homologue [Cutnell, J. D., La Mar, G. N., & Kong, S. B. (1981) J. Am. Chem. Soc. 103, 3567-3572]. The rate profiles suggest that the exchange follows EX2-type kinetics, and the relative rate values favor a penetration model over a local unfolding model. It was found that the behavior of protons located on the proximal side of the heme is similar in the three proteins. The distal histidyl imidazole NH, however, shows a highly accelerated hydroxyl ion catalyzed rate in horse and dog myoglobins relative to that in sperm whale myoglobin. NMR spectral and relaxational characteristics of the assigned heme cavity protons indicate that the global geometry of the heme pocket is highly conserved in the ground-state structure of the three proteins. We propose a model that attributes the different distal histidine exchange behavior to the relative dynamic stability of the distal heme pocket in dog or horse myoglobin vs. sperm whale myoglobin. This model involves a dynamic equilibrium between a closed heme pocket as found in metaquomyoglobin [Takano, T. (1977) J. Mol. Biol. 110, 537-568] and an open pocket as found in phenylmetmyoglobin [Ringe, D., Petsko, G. A., Kerr, D. E., & Ortiz de Montellano, P. R. (1984) Biochemistry 23, 2-4].(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

The photoexcited triplet state as a probe of chromophore-protein interaction in myoglobin.

The photoexcited metastable triplet state of Mg(2+)-mesoporphyrin IX (MgMPIX) or Mg(2+)-protoporphyrin IX (MgPPIX) located in the heme pocket of horse myoglobin (Mb) was investigated by optical and electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectroscopy, and its properties were compared with the model complexes, MgMPIX, MgPPIX, and Mg2+ etioporphyrin I (MgETIOI), in noncoordinating and coordinating organic glasses. Zero-field splitting parameters, line shape, and Jahn-Teller distortion in the temperature range of 3.8-110 K are discussed in terms of porphyrin-protein interactions. The triplet line shapes for MgMPIXMb and MGPPIXMb show no temperature-dependent spectral line shape changes suggestive of Jahn-Teller dynamics, and it is concluded that the energy splitting is >> 150 cm-1, suggesting symmetry breaking from the anisotropy of intermal electric fields of the protein, and consistent with previous predictions (Geissinger et al. 1995. J. Phys. Chem. 99:16527-16529). Both MgMPIXMb and MgPPIXMb demonstrate electron spin polarization at low temperature, and from the polarization pattern it can be concluded that intersystem crossing occurs predominantly into in-plane spin sublevels of the triplet state. The splitting in the Q0.0 absorption band and the temperature dependence and splitting of the photoexcited triplet state of myoglobin in which the iron was replaced by Mg2+ are interpreted in terms of effects produced by electric field asymmetry in the heme pocket.     

Heme pocket disorder in myoglobin: reversal by acid-induced soft refolding

The protein folding process of heme proteins entails generation of not only a correct global polypeptide structure, but also a correct, functionally competent heme environment. We employed a variety of spectroscopic approaches to probe the structure and dynamics of the heme pocket of a recombinant sperm whale myoglobin. The conformational characteristics were examined by circular dichroism, time-resolved fluorescence spectroscopy, FTIR spectroscopy, and optical absorption spectroscopy in the temperature range 300-20 K. Each of these spectroscopic probes detected modifications confined exclusively to the heme pocket of the expressed myoglobin relative to the native protein. The functional properties were examined by measuring the kinetics of CO binding after flash-photolysis. The kinetics of the expressed myoglobin were more heterogeneous than those of the native protein. Mild acid exposure of the ferric derivative of the recombinant protein resulted in a protein with "nativelike" spectroscopic properties and homogeneous CO binding kinetics. The heme pocket modifications observed in this recombinant myoglobin do not derive from inverted heme. In contrast, when native apomyoglobin is reconstituted with the heme in vitro, the heme pocket disorder could be attributed exclusively to 180 degrees rotation of the bound heme [La Mar, G. N., Toi, H., and Krishnamoorthi, R. (1984) J. Am. Chem. Soc. 106, 6395-6401; Light, W. R., Rohlfs, R. J., Palmer, G., and Olson, J. S. (1987) J. Biol. Chem. 262, 46-52]. We conclude that exposure to low pH decreases the affinity of globin for the heme and allows an extended conformational sampling or "soft refolding" to a nativelike conformation.     

Identification of the titrating group in the heme cavity of myoglobin. Evidence for the heme-protein pi-pi interaction

The pH dependence of the proton NMR chemical shifts of met-cyano and deoxy forms of native and reconstituted myoglobins reflects a structural transition in the heme pocket modulated by a single proton with pK 5.1-5.6. Comparison of this pH dependence of sperm whale and elephant myoglobin and that of the former protein reconstituted with esterified hemin eliminates both the distal histidine as well as the heme propionates as the titrating residue. Reconstitution of sperm whale met-cyano myoglobin with hemin modified at the 2,4-positions leads to a systematic variation in the pK for the structural transition, thus indicating the presence of a coupling between the titrating group and the heme pi system. The results are consistent with histidine FG3 (His-FG3) being the titrating group, and a donor-acceptor pi-pi interaction between its imidazole and the heme is proposed.     

Proton NMR study of the myoglobin reconstituted with meso-tetra(n-propyl)hemin

Spectrophotometric titration of meso-tetra(n-propyl)hemin with sperm-whale apomyoglobin revealed their 1:1 complex formation. The purified reconstituted metmyoglobin bound with an equal molar amount of CN- and the second CN- ligation was not evidenced, suggesting that the hemin is not loosely attached to the globin surface, but incorporated into the heme pocket. The hyperfine-shifted proton NMR spectrum of the deoxy myoglobin revealed the proximal imidazole NH resonance at 85.1 ppm to indicate the formation of the Fe-N(His-F8) bond. The eight pyrrole protons of the hemin of myoglobin in the absence of external ligand were observed as a single peak at -16 ppm. This indicates the electronic symmetry of the hemin and the low-spin configuration of the heme iron. The pyrrole-proton NMR patterns of the cyanide and deoxy myoglobins were found to be remarkably temperature-dependent, which was consistently explained in terms of the free rotation of the prosthetic group. The NMR results suggest that introduction of meso-tetra(n-propyl)hemin totally disrupts the highly stereospecific heme-globin contacts, making the prosthetic group mobile in the heme cavity.     

Proton magnetic resonance study of the influence of heme 2,4 substituents on the exchange rates of labile protons in the heme pocket of myoglobin.

Four exchangeable protons with large hyperfine shifts are assigned in the heme pocket of sperm whale met-cyano myoglobin reconstituted with heme possessing acetyl groups, ethyl groups, bromines, and hydrogens at the 2,4 position, using both relaxation and chemical-shift data. The four protons arise from the ring NH's of the proximal (F8), distal (E7), and FG2 histidines, and the peptide NH of His F8. The similarity of all chemical shifts to those of the native protein as well as the invariance of the relaxation rates of the distal histidyl ring NH dictate essentially the same structure for the heme cavity of both native and reconstituted proteins. The exchange rates with bulk water of the four labile proteins in each modified protein were determined by saturation-transfer and line width methods. All four labile protons were found to have the same exchange rate as in the native protein for acetyl and ethyl 2,4 substituents; the two resolved labile protons in the derivative with 2,4 bromine were also unchanged. The reconstituted protein with hydrogens at the 2,4 position exhibited slower exchange rates for three of the four protons, indicating an increased dynamic stability of the heme pocket in the absence of bulky 2,4 substituents.     

1H NMR study of the role of heme carboxylate side chains in modulating heme pocket structure and the mechanism of reconstitution of cytochrome b5

1H nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy was used to assign the hyperfine-shifted resonances and determine the position of a side chain in the heme cavity of wild-type rat apocytochrome b5 reconstituted with a series of synthetic hemins possessing systematically perturbed carboxylate side chains. The hemins included protohemin derivatives with individually removed or pairwise shortened and lengthened carboxylate side chains, as well as (propionate)n(methyl)8-nporphine-iron(III) isomers with n = 1-3 designed to force occupation of nonnative propionate sites. The resonance assignments were effected on the basis of available empirical heme contact shift correlations and steady-state nuclear Overhauser effect measurements in the low-spin oxidized proteins. The failure to detect holoproteins with certain hemins dictates that the stable holoproteins, unlike the case of myoglobin, demand the axial iron-His bonds and cannot accommodate carboxylate side chains at interior positions in the binding pocket. Hence, the heme pocket interior in cytochrome b5 is judged much less polar and less sterically accommodating than that of myoglobin. The propionate occupational preference was greatest as the native 7-propionate site, but also possible at the nonnative crystallographic 5-methyl or 8-methyl positions. Only for a propionate at the crystallographic 8-methyl position was a significant perturbation of the native molecular/electronic structure observed, and this was attributed to an alternative propionate-protein hydrogen bond at the crystallographic 8-methyl position. The structures of the transient protein complexes detected only shortly after reconstitution reveal that the initial encounter complexes during assembly of holoprotein from apoprotein and hemin involve one of the two alternate propionate-protein links at either the 7-propionate or native 8-methyl position. In a monopropionate hemin, this leads to the characterization of a new type of heme orientational disorder involving rotation about a N-Fe-N axis.     

The contribution of heme propionate groups to the conformational dynamics associated with CO photodissociation from horse heart myoglobin

Photoacoustic calorimetry and transient absorption spectroscopy were used to study conformational dynamics associated with CO photodissociation from horse heart myoglobin (Mb) reconstituted with either Fe protoporphyrin IX dimethylester (FePPDME), Fe octaethylporphyrin (FeOEP), or with native Fe protoporphyrin IX (FePPIX). The volume and enthalpy changes associated with the Fe-CO bond dissociation and formation of a transient deoxyMb intermediate for the reconstituted Mbs were found to be similar to those determined for native Mb (DeltaV1 = -2.5+/-0.6 ml mol(-1) and DeltaH1 = 8.1+/-3.0 kcal mol(-1)). The replacement of FePPIX by FeOEP significantly alters the conformational dynamics associated with CO release from protein. Ligand escape from FeOEP reconstituted Mb was determined to be roughly a factor of two faster (tau=330 ns) relative to native protein (tau=700 ns) and accompanying reaction volume and enthalpy changes were also found to be smaller (DeltaV2 = 5.4+/-2.5 ml mol(-1) and DeltaH2 = 0.7+/-2.2 kcal mol(-1)) than those for native Mb (DeltaV2 = 14.3+/-0.8 ml mol(-1) and DeltaH2 = 7.8+/-3.5 kcal mol(-1)). On the other hand, volume and enthalpy changes for CO release from FePPIX or FePPDME reconstituted Mb were nearly identical to those of the native protein. These results suggest that the hydrogen bonding network between heme propionate groups and nearby amino acid residues likely play an important role in regulating ligand diffusion through protein matrix. Disruption of this network leads to a partially open conformation of protein with less restricted ligand access to the heme binding pocket.     

Mini-myoglobin. Electron paramagnetic resonance and reversible oxygenation of the cobalt derivative.

Mini-myoglobin, obtained by limited proteolysis of horse heart myoglobin (residues 32 to 139), represents a good model for testing the correlation between an exon and a protein domain. We have shown that ligand binding kinetics, spectral and folding features of mini-myoglobin are very similar to those of native myoglobin. In order to develop further the analysis of the structure-function relationship in this mini-protein, mini-globin was reconstituted with the heme moiety in which iron is replaced by cobalt. The Soret absorption spectra of oxy and deoxy cobaltous mini-myoglobin are very similar to those of cobaltous myoglobin derivatives; in addition. Co-mini-myoglobin binds oxygen reversibly with an n value approximately 1 and a p50 value of 45 to 50 mm Hg (the same as Co-myoglobin). Oxy Co-mini-myoglobin shows a well-resolved electron paramagnetic resonance (e.p.r.) spectrum typical of an oxygenated hemoprotein, while the spectrum of the deoxy derivative, although similar to that of deoxy Co-myoglobin, displays a lower resolution of the complex hyperfine structure. Moreover, photodissociation experiments on oxy Co-mini-myoglobin allow e.p.r. detection of an intermediate state, already observed in most hemoproteins and diagnostic for the interaction of bound oxygen with the distal histidine residue. Thus, reconstitution of mini-globin with cobalt protoprophyrin IX has provided, for the first time, a stable oxygenated complex that reflects a correct folding of the protein surrounding the heme pocket and possesses the functional behaviour typical of a hemoprotein.     

Mini-myoglobin: preparation and reaction with oxygen and carbon monoxide

A domain of 108 amino acid residues (32 to 139), obtained by digestion of horse heart apomyoglobin with clostripain, was found to bind protoheme in a 1 to 1 molar ratio. This domain is 33 amino acid residues larger than the protein segment encoded by the central exon in seal myoglobin. Flash photolysis experiments have shown that reconstituted "mini-myoglobin" is very similar to myoglobin in the combination reaction with carbon monoxide and with oxygen, and in the oxygen replacement reaction by carbon monoxide. These experiments provide for the first time direct evidence for the presence of a structural and functional domain, closely corresponding to the segment encoded by the central exon of the myoglobin gene, which contains the information for binding the natural heme and for maintaining the native folding typical of a respiratory protein.     

Proton electron nuclear double resonance from nitrosyl horse heart myoglobin: the role of His-E7 and Val-E11

Electron nuclear double resonance (ENDOR) spectroscopy has been used to study protons in nitrosyl horse heart myoglobin (MbNO). (1)H ENDOR spectra were recorded for different settings of the magnetic field. Detailed analysis of the ENDOR powder spectra, using computer simulation, based on the "orientation-selection" principle, leads to the identification of the available protons in the heme pocket. We observe hyperfine interactions of the N(HisF8)-Fe(2+)-N(NO) complex with five protons in axial and with eight protons in the rhombic symmetry along different orientations, including those of the principal axes of the g-tensor. Protons from His-E7 and Val-E11 residues are identified in the two symmetries, rhombic and axial, exhibited by MbNO. Our results indicate that both residues are present inside the heme pocket and help to stabilize one particular conformation.     

Structure-dynamics-function relationships in Asian elephant (Elephas maximus) myoglobin. An optical spectroscopy and flash photolysis study on functionally important motions.

In this work we report the thermal behavior (10-300 K) of the Soret band lineshape of deoxy and carbonmonoxy derivatives of Asian elephant (Elephas maximus) and horse myoglobins together with their carbon monoxide recombination kinetics after flash photolysis; the results are compared to analogous data relative to sperm whale myoglobin. The Soret band profile is modeled as a Voigt function that accounts for the coupling with high and low frequency vibrational modes, while inhomogeneous broadening is taken into account with suitable distributions of purely electronic transition frequencies. This analysis makes it possible to isolate the various contributions to the overall lineshape that; in turn, give information on structural and dynamic properties of the systems studied. The optical spectroscopy data point out sizable differences between elephant myoglobin on one hand and horse and sperm whale myoglobins on the other. These differences, more pronounced in deoxy derivatives, involve both the structure and dynamics of the heme pocket; in particular, elephant myoglobin appears to be characterized by larger anharmonic contributions to soft modes than the other two proteins. Flash photolysis data are analyzed as sums of kinetic processes with temperature-dependent fractional amplitudes, characterized by discrete pre-exponentials and either discrete or distributed activation enthalpies. In the whole temperature range investigated the behavior of elephant myoglobin appears to be more complex than that of horse and sperm whale myoglobins, which is in agreement with the increased anharmonic contributions to soft modes found in the former protein. Thus, to satisfactorily fit the time courses for CO recombination to elephant myoglobin five distinct processes are needed, only one of which is populated over the whole temperature range investigated. The remarkable convergence and complementarity between optical spectroscopy and flash photolysis data confirms the utility of combining these two experimental techniques in order to gain new and deeper insights into the functional relevance of protein fluctuations.     

Sulfmyoglobin. Resonance Raman spectroscopic evidence for an iron-chlorin prosthetic group

The green heme protein sulfmyoglobin (SMb) has been suggested to contain a sulfur-modified iron chlorin prosthetic group. To evaluate this hypothesis, we have obtained high-frequency (greater than 1000 cm-1) resonance Raman spectra of both oxidized and reduced SMb with 457.9-, 488.0-, 514.5-, 568.2-, and 647.1-nm excitation. The SMb spectra are compared to those of native met- and deoxymyoglobin (Mb). Vibrational frequencies for SMb are generally similar to those of Mb, suggesting a high-spin state for both the Fe(III) and Fe(II) SMb species, as is typical of native Mb. However, major differences between SMb and Mb occur both for patterns of relative spectral intensities and for depolarization ratios. In particular, all B1g-depolarized porphyrin modes in the Mb spectra have become polarized, totally symmetric vibrational modes in the SMb spectra. These contrasts reflect a dramatic lowering of the effective symmetry for the SMb prosthetic group. Several new bands are observed in SMb spectra that are not present in spectra of either native Mb or iron protoporphyrin IX complexes. The observation of additional polarized bands flanking the oxidation state marker, V4, is of particular interest. In a parallel study, we compared the resonance Raman spectral properties of iron protoporphyrin IX-derived chlorins and metallo-octaethylchlorins with those of the analogous porphyrins: the chlorin spectra exhibited altered intensity patterns, an increased number of totally symmetric (polarized) vibrational bands, and several new vibrational bands, including one or two in the region of the oxidation state marker, V4. Thus, the resonance Raman spectral characteristics of SMb and metallo-chlorins are complementary and strongly support a chlorin prosthetic group for SMb. Furthermore, they establish testable criteria for investigating the prosthetic group structures of other green heme proteins by resonance Raman spectroscopy.