The use of integrating DNA vectors to analyse the molecular defects in ionising radiation-sensitive mutants of mammalian cells including ataxia telangiectasia

Integrating DNA vectors, encoding selectable recombinant genes, were used to assess rejoining and recombination in wild-type mammalian cells and their ionising radiation-sensitive mutants. To provide a simple model of an important radiation-induced lesion - the DNA double-strand break - the vectors were cut with restriction endonucleases at specific single sites. If these breaks were made in the coding sequence of a selectable gene, the fidelity of the rejoin/recombination process could be measured by survival of vector-transformed cells in selective medium. Rejoining was assessed using vectors without internal homologies, while recombination was measured using pairs of fragments or deletion vectors carrying homologous regions. Initial experiments were made with vectors carrying a single selectable gene but, to overcome potential artefacts, 2-gene vectors were then constructed where one gene acts as a linked marker and (unbroken) control for the other (broken) gene. Available data are reviewed to show that, compared to their respective wild-type counterparts: (1) an ataxia telangiectasia (A-T) cell line and the hamster irs1 mutant show a consistent reduction in the fidelity of rejoining double-strand breaks (while the hamster mutants irs2, irs3, xrs series, and EM9 show wild-type fidelity); (2) the hamster EM9 mutant shows a reduction in ability to recombine homologous vector fragments (while the A-T line and probably the xrs mutants show show wild-type abilities); and (3) the xrs mutants show a reduction in overall transformation frequency with vector DNA, whether broken or not, while the other mutants tested show approximately wild-type frequencies. A critical account of the techniques and data is given, together with speculations on the molecular nature of the processes which are defective in these mutants, leading to radiosensitivity.     

Evidence for Conservative (Two-Progeny) DNA Double-Strand Break Repair

The double-strand break repair models for homologous recombination propose that a double-strand break in a duplex DNA segment is repaired by gene conversion copying a homologous DNA segment. This is a type of conservative recombination, or two-progeny recombination, which generates two duplex DNA segments from two duplex DNA segments. Transformation with a plasmid carrying a double-strand gap and an intact homologous DNA segment resulted in products expected from such conservative (two-progeny) repair in Escherichia coli cells with active E. coli RecE pathway (recBC sbcA) or with active bacteriophage λ Red pathway. Apparently conservative double-strand break repair, however, might result from successive events of nonconservative recombination, or one-progeny recombination, which generates only one recombinant duplex DNA segment from two segments, involving multiple plasmid molecules. Contribution of such intermolecular recombination was evaluated by transformation with a mixture of two isogenic parental plasmids marked with a restriction site polymorphism. Most of the gap repair products were from intramolecular and, therefore, conservative (two-progeny) reaction under the conditions chosen. Most were conservative even in the absence of RecA protein. The double-strand gap repair reaction was not affected by inversion of the unidirectional replication origin on the plasmid. These results demonstrate the presence of the conservative (two-progeny) double-strand break repair mechanism. These experiments do not rule out the occurrence of nonconservative (one-progeny) recombination since we set up experimental conditions that should favor detection of conservative (two-progeny) recombination.     

Induction of recombination between homologous and diverged DNAs by double-strand gaps and breaks and role of mismatch repair.

Sequence homology is expected to influence recombination. To further understand mechanisms of recombination and the impact of reduced homology, we examined recombination during transformation between plasmid-borne DNA flanking a double-strand break (DSB) or gap and its chromosomal homolog. Previous reports have concentrated on spontaneous recombination or initiation by undefined lesions. Sequence divergence of approximately 16% reduced transformation frequencies by at least 10-fold. Gene conversion patterns associated with double-strand gap repair of episomal plasmids or with plasmid integration were analyzed by restriction endonuclease mapping and DNA sequencing. For episomal plasmids carrying homeologous DNA, at least one input end was always preserved beyond 10 bp, whereas for plasmids carrying homologous DNA, both input ends were converted beyond 80 bp in 60% of the transformants. The system allowed the recovery of transformants carrying mixtures of recombinant molecules that might arise if heteroduplex DNA--a presumed recombination intermediate--escapes mismatch repair. Gene conversion involving homologous DNAs frequently involved DNA mismatch repair, directed to a broken strand. A mutation in the PMS1 mismatch repair gene significantly increased the fraction of transformants carrying a mixture of plasmids for homologous DNAs, indicating that PMS1 can participate in DSB-initiated recombination. Since nearly all transformants involving homeologous DNAs carried a single recombinant plasmid in both Pms+ and Pms- strains, stable heteroduplex DNA appears less likely than for homologous DNAs. Regardless of homology, gene conversion does not appear to occur by nucleolytic expansion of a DSB to a gap prior to recombination. The results with homeologous DNAs are consistent with a recombinational repair model that we propose does not require the formation of stable heteroduplex DNA but instead involves other homology-dependent interactions that allow recombination-dependent DNA synthesis.     

High spontaneous mutation frequency in shuttle vector sequences recovered from mammalian cellular DNA.

The recombinant shuttle vector pSV2gpt was introduced into V79 Chinese hamster cells, and stable transformants expressing the Escherichia coli gpt gene were selected. Two transformants carrying tandem duplications of the plasmid at a single site were identified and fused to simian COS-1 cells. Plasmid DNA recovered from the heterokaryons was used to transform a Gpt- derivative of E. coli HB101, and the relative frequency of plasmids carrying a mutation in the gpt gene was determined. The high frequency of Gpt- plasmids (ca. 1%) was similar to that observed when plasmid was recovered from COS-1 cells which had been transfected with pSV2gpt. Most of the mutant plasmids had rearrangements in the region containing the gpt gene.     

Analyses of mutation in pSV2gpt-transformed CHO cells

We have developed a system to study mutations which affect expression of the E. coli xanthine-guanine phosphoribosyl transferase (XPRT) gene (gpt) in hypoxanthine-guanine phosphoribosyl transferase-deficient (HPRT-) Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells that have been transformed by the plasmid pSV2gpt. Several gpt-transformed cell lines have been isolated and characterized with respect to integrated pSV2gpt sequences, expression of the gpt gene, and cytotoxic and mutagenic responses to UV light. While the gpt-transformed CHO and wild-type CHO-K1-BH4 cell lines have similar cytotoxic responses to UV light, the gpt-transformed cell lines respond differently from the parental CHO-K1-BH4 cell line in terms of mutation induction. As with CHO-K1-BH4 HPRT mutants, spontaneous or induced XPRT mutants derived from the gpt+ cell lines can be selected for 6-thioguanine resistance (TGr). Analysis of cell-free extracts from a number of these TGr clones indicates that the mutant phenotype is due to the absence of XPRT activity. One transformant, designated AS52, has previously been described in limited detail. Here we describe additional characteristics of this cell line, as well as several related transformants.     

Recombination and deletion of sequences in shuttle vector plasmids in mammalian cells.

Shuttle vector plasmids were constructed with directly repeated sequences flanking a marker gene. African green monkey kidney (AGMK) cells were infected with the constructions, and after a period of replication, the progeny plasmids were recovered and introduced into bacteria. Those colonies with plasmids that had lost the marker gene were identified, and the individual plasmids were purified and characterized by restriction enzyme digestion. Recombination between the repeated elements generated a plasmid with a precise deletion and a characteristic restriction pattern, which distinguished the recombined molecules from those with other defects in the marker gene. Recombination among the following different sequences was measured in this assay: (i) the simian virus 40 origin and enhancer region, (ii) the AGMK Alu sequence, and (iii) a sequence from plasmid pBR322. Similar frequencies of recombination among these sequences were found. Recombination occurred more frequently in Cos1 cells than in CV1 cells. In these experiments, the plasmid population with defective marker genes consisted of the recombined molecules and of the spontaneous deletion-insertion mutants described earlier. The frequency of the latter class was unaffected by the presence of the option for recombination represented by the direct repeats. Both recombination and deletion-insertion mutagenesis were stimulated by double-strand cleavage between the repeated sequences and adjacent to the marker, and the frequency of the deletion-insertion mutants in this experiment was again independent of the presence of the direct repeats. We concluded that although recombination and deletion-insertion mutagenesis were both stimulated by double-strand cleavage, the molecules which underwent the two types of change were drawn from separate pools.     

Homologous Recombination between Autonomously Replicating Plasmids in Mammalian Cells

The ability of autonomously replicating plasmids to recombine in mammalian cells was investigated. Two deletion plasmids of the eukaryotic-prokaryotic shuttle vector pSV2neo were cotransfected into transformed monkey COS cells. Examination of the low molecular weight DNA isolated after 48 hr of incubation revealed that recombination between the plasmids had occurred. The DNA was also used to transform recA- E. coli. Yield of neoR colonies signified homologous recombination. Examination of the plasmid DNA from these colonies confirmed this view. Double-strand breaks in one or both of the input plasmids at the sites of deletion resulted in an enhancement of recombination frequency. The recombination process yielded monomeric and dimeric molecules. Examination of these molecules revealed that reciprocal recombination as well as gene conversion events were involved in the generation of plasmids bearing an intact neo gene. The COS cell system we describe is analogous to study of bacteriophage recombination and yeast random-spore analysis.     

The effect of monofunctional or difunctional platinum adducts and of various other associated DNA damage on the expression of transfected DNA in mammalian cell lines sensitive or resistant to difunctional agents

The effects of introducing various DNA damage into pSV2gpt DNA on the subsequent expression of xanthine guanine phosphoribosyltransferase (XGPRT), after its transfection into two Walker 256 cell lines, one which is inherently sensitive only to difunctional agents while the other shows a normal sensitivity, have been examined. Both the sensitive (WS) and the relatively resistant (WR) cell lines were shown to be equally capable of both ligation of DNA double-strand breaks (although the efficiency varied with the actual site of the break) introduced into pSV2gpt and homologous recombination of pSV2gpt fragments (recombination events are thought to be important in the repair of DNA-DNA interstrand crosslinks). Reacting the plasmid with either the difunctional platinum compound, Cisplatin, or the monofunctional reacting Pt(Dien) caused a dose-dependent decrease in the subsequent expression of XGPRT. This decrease was about the same with either agent in either cell line when expressed as a function of dose of drug. However, when the actual binding of platinum to DNA by these compounds was measured, a large difference (due to the higher specific binding of Pt(Dien) to DNA) in the effects of the difunctional, as opposed to the monofunctional agent, was apparent and this was a reflection of the relative cytotoxicities of these compounds towards mammalian cells. Although at doses of Cisplatin equitoxic to WS and WR cells 20-fold less Pt is bound to the DNA of WS cells, no significant difference was seen on the expression of pSV2gpt, reacted with this agent, between WS or WR cells. Based upon a knowledge of the proportions of adducts formed in DNA reacted with Cisplatin, the lesion that inactivates expression of XGPRT was probably the intrastrand crosslink and it was calculated that due to the size of the plasmid, the interstrand crosslink was unlikely to be present at these inactivating doses. It is suggested that the inherent sensitivity of WS cells only to difunctional agents is due to their response to such relatively rare lesions such as a DNA-DNA interstrand crosslink.     

Transformation of UV-hypersensitive Chinese hamster ovary cell mutants with UV-irradiated plasmids

Transfection of UV-hypersensitive, DNA repair-deficient Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cell lines and parental, repair-proficient CHO cells with UV-irradiated pHaprt-1 or pSV2gpt plasmids resulted in different responses by recipient cell lines to UV damage in transfected DNA. Unlike results that have been reported for human cells, UV irradiation of transfecting DNA did not stimulate the genetic transformation of CHO recipient cells. In repair-deficient CHO cells, proportionally fewer transformants were produced with increasing UV damage than in repair-proficient cells in transfections with the UV-irradiated hamster adenine phosphoribosyltransferase (APRT) gene contained in plasmid pHaprt-1. However, transfection of CHO cells with UV-irradiated pSV2gpt resulted in neither decline in transformation frequencies in repair-deficient cell lines relative to repair-proficient cells nor stimulation of genetic transformation by UV damage in the plasmid. Blot hybridization analysis of DNA samples isolated from transformed cells showed no dramatic changes in copy number or arrangement of transfected plasmid DNA with increasing UV dose. We conclude that the responses of recipient cells to UV-damaged transfecting plasmids depend both on the type of recipient cell and the characteristics of the genetic sequence used for transfection.     

V(D)J recombination in mammalian cell mutants defective in DNA double-strand break repair.

V(D)J recombination has been examined in several X-ray-sensitive and double-strand break repair-deficient Chinese hamster cell mutants. Signal joint formation was affected in four mutants (xrs 5, XR-1, V-3, and XR-V9B cells, representing complementation groups 1 through 4, respectively) defective in DNA double-strand break rejoining. Among these four, V-3 and XR-V9B were the most severely affected. Only in V-3 was coding joint formation also affected. Ataxia telangiectasia-like hamster cell mutants (V-E5 and V-G8), which are normal for double-strand break repair but are X ray sensitive, were normal for all aspects of the V(D)J recombination reaction, indicating that X-ray sensitivity is not the common denominator but that the deficiency in double-strand break repair appears to be. The abnormality at the signal joints consisted of an elevated incidence of nucleotide loss from each of the two signal ends. Interestingly, in complementation groups 1 (xrs 5) and 2 (XR-1), signal joint formation was within the normal range under some transfection conditions. This suggests that the affected gene products in these two complementation groups are not catalytic components. Instead, they may be either secondary or stochiometric components involved in the later stages of both the V(D)J recombination reaction and double-strand break repair. The fact that such factors can affect the precision of the signal joint has mechanistic implications for V(D)J recombination.     

The RecE recombination pathway mediates recombination between partially homologous DNA sequences: structural analysis of recombination products

Escherichia coli generalized recombination, utilizing the RecA RecB recombination pathway, requires large stretches (70-200 bp) of complete DNA sequence homology. In contrast, we have found that the RecE pathway can promote recombination between DNA with only short stretches of homology. A plasmid containing 10 partially homologous direct repeats was linearized by digestion with specific restriction enzymes. After transformation, a RecE+ (sbcA) host was able to circularize the plasmid by recombination between partially homologous direct repeat sequences. Recombination occurred in regions of as little as 6 bp of perfect homology. Recombination was enhanced in the regions adjacent to restriction sites used to linearize the plasmid, consistent with a role of double-strand breaks in promoting recombination. A mechanism is proposed in which the 5' exonuclease, ExoVIII, produces 3' single-stranded ends from the linearized plasmid. These pair with other sequences of partial homology. Partial homologies in the sequences flanking the actual join serve to stabilize this recombination intermediate. Recombination is completed by a process of "copy and join." This recombination mechanism requires less homology to stabilize intermediates than the degree of homology needed for mechanisms involving strand invasion. Its role in nature may be to increase genomic diversity, for example, by enhancing recombination between bacteriophages and regions of the bacterial chromosome.     

Failure to detect a DNA repair-related defect in the transfection of ataxia-telangiectasia cells by enzymatically restricted plasmid

We have transfected two SV40-transformed human fibroblast cell lines with plasmids in which double-strand breaks have been introduced by restriction enzymes, within or near the selected gene. Restriction of pSV2gpt with KpnI, as previously shown by Cox et al. (1986), reduced the frequency of transfection more in the ionizing radiation-sensitive ataxia-telangiectasia line AT5BIVA than in the resistant line MRC5V1. When the related plasmid pSV2neo was restricted with SmaI, the reduction in transfection was less in the ataxia-telangiectasia than in the normal cell line. Under our conditions, the apparent defect in transfection of AT5BIVA by pSV2gpt appears to be a result of the unusual sensitivity of the repair-deficient recipient to the selective agent. Loss of potential transfectants is exacerbated when transient gene expression is reduced by restriction of the plasmid. We suggest that a reduction in yield of transfectants with restricted plasmid in ataxia-telangiectasia cells cannot readily be used as evidence of a defect in DNA repair. Our results are also relevant to standard transfection experiments, since they emphasize the importance of optimizing selection when transient expression may be reduced, to ensure that potential transfectants are not killed by the selection regime.     

Intermolecular plasmid recombination in fibroblasts from humans with DNA damage-processing defects

We have evaluated the ability of immortalized human fibroblasts to recombine transfected plasmid DNA. A number of cell lines from normal individuals and from patients with DNA damage-processing defects were examined. Two plasmid recombination substrates were derived from pSV2neo and contained nonoverlapping deletions in the aminoglycoside phosphotransferase II gene. Intermolecular recombination was assessed by two methods after cotransfection. In a short-term, extrachromosomal recombination assay, low molecular weight DNA was extracted from the human cells 48 h after transfection, and recombinant plasmids were detected by transformation into appropriate indicator bacteria. In a long-term stable recombination assay the fibroblasts were cotransfected and G418-resistant colonies allowed to form. By the former assay all but two cultures were recombination-proficient, whereas all were recombination-proficient by the latter assay. The efficiency of transfection of human cells with plasmids appears to be a major variable affecting recombination. Recombination can be stimulated by uv irradiation of plasmid DNA prior to transfection. Cells from patients with Fanconi anemia, ataxia telangiectasia, and xeroderma pigmentosum complementation groups A, C, D, E, and G are not defective at intermolecular plasmid recombination.     

Intramolecular homologous recombination in cells infected with temperature-sensitive mutants of vaccinia virus.

I have used a plasmid containing two copies of the Saccharmyces cerevisiae his3 gene to study intramolecular homologous recombination in vaccina virus-infected cells. Recombination of the plasmid was monitored by restriction enzyme digestion and Southern blot hybridization in cells infected with representatives from each of 32 complementation groups of temperature-sensitive mutants ts42 and ts17 did not replicate nor detectably recombine the input plasmid. All except one of the mutants that synthesized normal amounts of viral DNA and protein replicated and recombined the plasmid in a manner indistinguishable from wild-type virus. The remaining mutant, ts13, only poorly replicated and recombined the input plasmid. Thus, the processes of replication and recombination could not be separated by using this battery of mutants. Viral mutants defective in late protein synthesis were unable to resolve the vaccinia virus concatemer junction in plasmids but carried out intramolecular homologous recombination with plasmids as efficiently as did wild-type virus at the conditionally lethal temperature. This result distinguishes homologous recombination, which requires early gene products, from resolution of concatemer junctions, which requires additional late gene products.     

Homologous recombination and double-strand break repair in the transformation of Rhizopus oryzae

Genetic transformation of the Mucorales fungi has been problematic, since DNA transformed into the host rarely integrates and usually is mitotically unstable in the absence of selective pressure. In this study, transformation of Rhizopus oryzae was investigated to determine if the fate of introduced DNA could be predicted based on double-strand break repair and recombination mechanisms found in other fungi. A transformation system was developed with uracil auxotrophs of Rhizopus oryzae that could be complemented with the pyrG gene isolated in this work. DNA transformed as circular plasmids was maintained extrachromosomally in high-molecular-weight (>23 kb) concatenated arrangement. Type-I crossover integration into the pyrG locus and type-III pyrG gene replacement events occurred in approximately 1-5% of transformants. Linearization of the plasmid pPyr225 with a single restriction enzyme that cleaves within the vector sequence almost always resulted in isolates with replicating concatenated plasmids that had been repaired by end-joining recombination that restored the restriction site. The addition of a 40-bp direct repeat on either side of this cleavage site led to repair by homologous recombination between the repeated sequences on the plasmid, resulting in loss of the restriction site. When plasmid pPyr225 was digested with two different enzymes that cleave within the vector sequence to release the pyrG containing fragment, only pyrG gene replacement recombination occurred in transformants. Linearization of plasmid pPyr225 within the pyrG gene itself gave the highest percentage (20%) of type-I integration at the pyrG locus. However, end-joining repair and gene replacement events were still the predominant types of recombination found in transformations with this plasmid topology.     

Transformation of yeast with linearized plasmid DNA. Formation of inverted dimers and recombinant plasmid products

The molecular products of DNA double strand break repair were investigated after transformation of yeast (Saccharomyces cerevisiae) with linearized plasmid DNA. DNA of an autonomous yeast plasmid cleaved to generate free ends lacking homology with the yeast genome, when used in transformation along with sonicated non-homologous carrier DNA, gave rise to transformants with high frequency. Most of these transformants were found to harbor a head-to-head (inverted) dimer of the linearized plasmid. This outcome of transformation contrasts with that observed when the carrier DNA is not present. Transformants occur at a much reduced frequency and harbor either the parent plasmid or a plasmid with deletion at the site of the cleavage. When the linearized plasmid is introduced along with sonicated carrier DNA and a homologous DNA restriction fragment that spans the site of plasmid cleavage, homologous recombination restores the plasmid to its original circular form. Inverted dimer plasmids are not detected. This relationship between homologous recombination and a novel DNA transaction that yields rearrangement could be important to the cell, as the latter could lead to a loss of gene function and lethality.     

Effect of insertions, deletions, and double-strand breaks on homologous recombination in mouse L cells.

We have used DNA-mediated gene transfer to study homologous recombination in cultured mammalian cells. A family of plasmids with insertion and deletion mutations in the coding region of the herpes simplex type 1 thymidine kinase (tk) gene served as substrates for DNA-mediated gene transfer into mouse Ltk- cells by the calcium phosphate technique. Intermolecular recombination events were scored by the number of colonies in hypoxanthine-aminopterin-thymidine selective medium. We used supercoiled plasmids containing tk gene fragments to demonstrate that an overlap of 62 base pairs (bp) of homologous DNA was sufficient for intermolecular recombination. Addition of 598 bp of flanking homology separated from the region of recombination by a double-strand gap, deletion, or insertion of heterologous DNA increased the frequency of recombination by 300-, 20-, or 40-fold, respectively. Linearizing one of the mutant plasmids in a pair before cotransfer by cutting in the area of homology flanking a deletion of 104 bp or an insertion of less than 24 bp increased the frequency of recombination relative to that with uncut plasmids. However, cutting an insertion mutant of greater than or equal to 24 bp in the same manner did not increase the frequency. We show how our data are consistent with models that postulate at least two phases in the recombination process: homologous pairing and heteroduplex formation.     

Intermolecular homologous recombination in plants.

To study DNA topological requirements for homologous recombination in plants, we have constructed pairs of plasmids that contain nonoverlapping deletions in the neomycin phosphotransferase gene [APH(3')II], which, when intact, confers kanamycin resistance to plant cells. Protoplasts isolated from Nicotiana tabacum were cotransformed with complementary pairs of plasmids containing these truncated gene constructs. Homologous recombination or gene conversion within the homologous sequences (6 to 405 base pairs) of the protein-coding region of the truncated genes led to the restoration of the functional APH(3')II gene, rendering these cells resistant to kanamycin. Circular plasmid DNAs recombined very inefficiently, independent of the length of the homologous region. A double-strand break in one molecule only slightly increased the recombination frequency. The most favorable substrates for recombination were linear molecules. In this case, the recombination frequency was positively correlated with the length of the homologous regions. The recombination frequency of plasmids linearized at sites proximal to the deletion-homology junction was significantly higher than when linearization was distal to the homologous region. Vector homology within cotransformed plasmid sequences also increased the recombination frequency.