Midtrimester abortion induced by a single intra-amniotic instillation of two dose schedules of 15(S)-15-methyl-prostaglandin F2α

Midtrimester abortion was successfully induced in a series of 20 patient by intra-amniotic instillation of 15(S)-15-methyl-prostaglandin F_2α with a mean abortion time of 17.78 hours. The patients in this study were divided into two groups, Groups I received on initial dose of 2.5 mg 15-ME-PGF_2α and aborted in a mean time of 16.26 hours. The patients in Group II received 3.0 mg 15-ME-PGF_2α and aborted in a mean time of 18.94 hours. There was no significant difference in the abortion time, occurrence of side effects or the initiation of uterine activity between Group I and Group II. Parous patients aborted somewhat faster than nulliparous patients but this difference was not significant. In this study 80% of the patients aborted in 24 hours or less, and the intra-amniotic instillation of 15-ME-PGF_2α was an effective abortifacient technique from the 15th to the 23rd week of gestation. The uterine response to intra-amniotic instillation of 15-ME-PGF_2α was characterized by the gradual appearance of low amplitude, high frequency contractions accompanied by a rise in baseline intrauterine tonus. Uterine activity developed gradually and peaked at 1:50 hours after intra-amniotic instillation of 15-ME-PGF_2α. In this small series 15-ME-PGF_2α administered via intra-amniotic instillation did not appear to have a distinct advantage over the naturally occurring PGF_2α administered by the same method for the induction of midtrimester abortion; a larger series is indicated to define the advantages of either technique.     

Serial intramuscular injections of 15(S)-15-methyl-prostaglandin F2α in the induction of abortion

Abortion was successfully induced in 62 of 68 patients in the 9th to the 26th week of pregnancy by serial intramuscular administration of 15(S)-15-methyl-prostaglandin F_2α (15-ME-PGF_2α). In 6 patients who failed to abort after 24 hours of prostaglandin administration, a concomitant infusion of oxytocin was initiated; 5 of these patients aborted within 12 hours of the combined therapy. A single patient failed to abort, even with the combined therapy, and underwent surgical evacuation. The mean abortion time in the 67 successful inductions was 14.56 hours. Parous patients aborted somewhat faster, mean 13.98 hours, as compared to nulliparous patients, mean 15.02 hours, but this difference was not statistically significant. In this study initial intramuscular injection of 100 μg 15-ME-PGF_2α was followed in 1 hour by 250 μg and then 250 μg every 2 hours with concomitant oxytocin therapy initiated after 24 hours. The results with this dose schedule were compared to the results obtained in a previous study with a higher dose schedule, an initial dose of 100 μg 15-ME-PGF_2α, followed in 1 hour by 250 μg then 500 μg every 2 hours. There was no significant difference in the mean abortion time and the incidence of side effects between the 2 dose schedules. The mean abortion time for patients with gestational ages of 16 weeks and less was the same with both dose schedules, however patients with gestational ages of 17 weeks and higher aborted somewhat faster with the higher dose schedule. It might therefore be advisable for patients with gestations of 17 weeks and higher to be treated with the higher dose schedule. In earlier gestations patients could be started on the lower schedule, and if abortion had not occurred within 15 hours the dose of 15-ME-PGF_2α could then be increased to 500 μg every 2 hours.     

Midtrimester abortion induced by single intra-amniotic instillation of two dose schedules of 15(S)-15-methyl-prostaglandin F2alpha.

Midtrimester abortion was successfully induced in a series of 20 patient by intraamniotic instillation of 15(S)-15-methyl-prostaglandin F2alpha with a mean abortion time of 17.78 hours. The patients in this study was divided into two groups, Groups 1 received an initial dose of 2.5 mg 15-ME-PGF2alpha and aborted in a mean time of 16.26 hours. The patients in Group II received 3.0 mg 15-ME-PGF2alpha and aborted in a mean time of 18.94 hours. There was no significant difference in the abortion time, occurrence of side effects or the initiation of uterine activity between Group I and Group II. Parous patients aborted somewhat faster than nulliparous patients but this difference was not significant. In this study 80% of the patients aborted in 24 hours or less, and the intra-amniotic instillation of 15-ME-PGF2alpha was an effective abortifacient technique from the 15th to the 23rd week of gestation. The uterine response to intra-amniotic instillation of 15-ME-PGF2alpha was characterized by the gradual appearance of low amplitude, high frequency contractions accompanied by a rise in baseline intrauterine tonus. Uterine activity developed gradually and peaked at 1:50 hours after intraamniotic instillation of 15-ME-PGF2alpha. In this small series 15-ME-PGF2alpha administered via intra-amniotic instillation did not appear to have a distinct advantage over the naturally occuring PGF2alpha administered by the same method for the induction of midtrimester abortion; a large series in indicated to define the advantage of either technique.     

Induction of midtrimester abortion by serial intravaginal administration of 15(S)-15-methyl-prostaglandin F2α (THAM) suppositories

Midtrimester abortion was successfully induced in 13 of 22 patients by serial intravaginal administration of 15(S)-15-methyl-prostaglandin F_2α (THAM) suppositories. Nine patients, 4 nulliparas and 5 multiparas, failed to abort after 24 hours of prostaglandin administration and a concomitant infusion of oxytocin was initiated. Seven of the nine patients aborted within 7 hours of the combined therapy and one patient on methadone maintainence aborted after 17.5 hours of combined therapy, 41.5 hours after the first dose of prostaglandin. A single patient failed to abort, despite the concomitant prostaglandin-oxytocin administration and underwent surgical evacuation. The mean abortion time for the 21 successful abortions was 22.56 hours. Nulliparous patients aborted somewhat faster, mean 21.79 hours, than multiparous patients, mean 23.80 hours, but this difference was not statistically significant. In this study, one patient aborted in less than 12 hours, and 62% of the successful cases aborted within 24 hours. The plasma levels of 15-ME-PGF_2α were analyzed by radioimmunoassay in 10 patients. Plasma prostaglandin levels rose significantly 30 minutes after the insertion of the first suppository, but there was a wide variation in levels from patient to patient. It was observed that the 2 patients with the highest levels had the fastest abortion times and episodes of gastro-intestinal side effects appeared related to a rise in prostaglandin levels. Sixty-four percent of the patients in this study had no gastro-intestinal side effect related to prostaglandin administration.     

Induction of second trimester abortion: Comparison between vaginal 15-methyl-PGF2α methyl ester and intra-amniotic PGF2α

The efficiency and acceptability of a single-dose, long-acting vaginal suppository containing 3.0 mg of 15-methyl PGF_2α methyl ester was compared with intra-amniotic administration of 50 mg of PGF_2α in 100 patients with a second trimester pregnancy termination. Within 24 hours, 78 per cent of the patients in the vaginal group and 92 per cent in the intra-amniotic group had aborted. The mean induction-abortion interval was 17.9 hours in the vaginal group and 15.8 hours in the intra-amniotic group.Gastrointestinal side-effects were more frequent, but the procedure was less painful, with vaginal 15-methyl PGF_2α methyl ester than with intra-amniotic PGF_2α.The vaginal route is technically simple for adaptation to large-scale use, but the high frequency of gastrointestinal side-effects still limits the acceptability of 15-methyl PGF_2α methyl ester in vaginal administration.     

Reassessment of systemic administration of prostaglandins for induction of midtrimester abortion

The present investigation was undertaken to evaluate the abortifacient efficacy of vaginal and intramuscular administration of different dose schedules of the 15-methyl analogues of prostaglandin F_2α.1. . Both 15-methyl-PGF_2α and 15-methyl-PGF_2α methyl ester can be absorbed from the vagina in sufficient amounts to induce abortion. The potency of the methyl ester was approximately twice that of the free acid. The most successful treatment schedule consisted of an initial dose of 0.5 mg of the methyl ester followed by 1.0 or 2.0 mg every third hour. On this treatment all patients aborted within 24 hours.2. . Initially 200 μg of 15-methyl-PGF_2α was given. The dose was increased to 400 μg or occasionally to 500 μg depending on the effect and tolerance of the patient and repeated every third hour. The treatment schedule resulted in a 100 per cent abortion rate and the mean induction-abortion interval was 16.1 hours.Both routes were associated with a higher frequency of side effects than that reported for intra-amniotic administration of 15-methyl-PGF_2α. It seems justified to conclude that the intra-amniotic route is preferable after the 14th week when the uterine cavity is easy to puncture but that vaginal or intramuscular injections of the compounds could be an alternative in late first trimester and early second trimester cases.     

Induction of therapeutic abortion with a single dose of intra-amniotically administered prostaglandin F2α

To determine the abortifacient effectiveness and complications of a single intra-amniotic injection of 50 mg of Prostaglandin F_2α (PGF_2α), 40 gravidas were studied. While all subjects received a 50 mg dose of PGF_2α at the initiation of the trial with no additional oxytocics or surgical intervention until they had aborted or until the end of the 48-hour trial period, they received intramuscularly administered prochlorperazine by one of two dose schedules. Twenty-five Group I subjects received 10 mg of prochlorperazine whenever they requested medication for alleviation of nausea or vomiting, while 15 Group II subjects received 10 mg one-half hour prior to the administration of PGF_2α and at 6-hour intervals until they had aborted. Within the initial 24 hours, 77% of the subjects aborted while within the 48-hour trial period, 95% of the subjects aborted with a mean induction-to-abortion time of 19.1 hours for those aborting. Sixty-eight percent aborted completely, 28 percent aborted incompletely, and 5 percent failed to abort within the trial period. No serious complications were observed. The proportion of patients having no vomiting and the mean number of episodes of vomiting were significantly less in the Group II subjects than in the Group I subjects. No significant differences in the mean abortion times, cumulative abortion rates, or intra-amniotic pressures were noted between the two groups of subjects. It appears that the single intra-amniotic administration of 50 mg of PGF_2α results in practicable rates of abortion and the associated vomiting can be significantly attenuated with prochlorperazine without significantly altering the abortifacient or oxytocic effect of PGF_2α.     

Induction of abortion with intra-amniotic or intra-muscular 15(S)-15-methyl-prostaglandin F2α

In order to evaluate the efficacy and acceptability of 15(S)-15-methyl-prostaglandin F_2α (15-me-PGF_2α) for pregnancy termination, we induced 30 abortions with single intra-amniotic injections of 2,5 mg of 15-me-PGF_2α and 25 abortions with intra-muscular 15-me-PGF_2α administered 200 μg initially and 300 μg every third hour until 30 hrs or abortion. Abortion occurred within 30 hrs in 97 % of cases in the intra-amniotic group, with a mean abortion time of 17,6 hrs and in 80 % in the intramuscular group, with a mean abortion time of 15.0 hrs. Neither parity nor gestational age was significantly related to the abortifacient efficacy of 15-me-PGF_2α. No serious complications occurred. Vomiting (83–84 %) and diarrhoea (23–92 %) were the most common complaints. Uterine contractions were more painful if induction was effected with intra-amniotic rather than intramuscular injections. 15-me-PGF_2α appears to be an effective and practicable abortifacient which can be used intra-amniotically or intramuscularly according to the ease of amniocentesis.     

Induction of Abortion by Extra-amniotic Administration of Prostaglandins E2 and F2 α

The use of prostaglandins E₂ and F₂α, administered by extra-amniotic instillation, for the induction of abortion was studied in 94 patients in the first and second trimesters of pregnancy. Abortion was successfully induced in 87% of patients within 36 hours and in 94% within 48 hours. The mean abortion time was 22·4 hours. In 60% of patients abortion was complete.Though the differences were not statistically significant, on average multigravid patients aborted more quickly than primigravidae, while the mean abortion time in PGE₂-treated patients was less than in those receiving PGF₂α.No serious complications occurred. Some side effects were observed. Occasional vomiting was the commonest symptom but the incidence of side effects was lower than with alternative routes of administration. A leucocytosis was often noted but there were no significant instances of infection.The method has proved a safe and effective means of terminating pregnancies in the second trimester.     

Termination of second trimester pregnancy with intra-amniotic 15 (S) 15 methyl prostaglandin F2α — A two dose schedule study

Termination of second trimester pregnancy with intra-amniotic administration of 15 (S) 15 methyl prostaglandin F_2α (15 me F_2α) was attempted in fifty patients. One group (25 patients) was given 1 mg of the analogue and the other group received 2.5 mg. The abortifacient efficacy of 15 me F_2α was similar in both groups; over 90% of the patients aborted with a single dose. There was a higher incidence of vomiting, diarrhoea and incomplete abortions in the group treated with 2.5 mg 15 me F_2α. Although the mean injection-abortion interval in the 2.5 mg group was shorter, it is concluded that intra-amniotic administration of 1 mg 15 me F_2α provides a better regime, giving high efficacy with a single dose, a low incidence of side effects and greater safety in case of inadvertent entry of the intra-amniotic dose into systemic circulation.     

Prostaglandin E2 induced abortion with vaginal suppositories in a contraceptive diaphragm

Prostaglandin E₂, 20 mgm vaginal suppositories were administered to two groups of women seeking termination of pregnancy. One group had the suppository inserted inside a contraceptive diaphragm. Statistical comparisons were carried out for instillation to abortion time, side effects, and intra-uterine pressure parameters. The usage of the diaphragm significantly reduced side effects, and resulted in an instillation to abortion time of 12.8 ± 2.3 hours with no failures. The quantitative analysis of the uterine pressure recordings revealed activity significantly different than that seen with intra-amniotic or extra-ovular PG F_2α. The development of uterine activity simulates that of normal labor in that elevation of resting pressure does not occur and maximum active pressure evolves slowly.     

Induction of abortion with intra-amniotic or intra-muscular 15(S)-15-methyl-prostaglandin F2α

In order to evaluate the efficacy and acceptability of 15(S)-15-methyl-prostaglandin F_2α (15-me-PGF_2α) for pregnancy termination, we induced 30 abortions with single intra-amniotic injections of 2,5 mg of 15-me-PGF_2α and 25 abortions with intra-muscular 15-me-PGF_2α administered 200 g initially and 300 g every third hour until 30 hrs or abortion. Abortion occurred within 30 hrs in 97 % of cases in the intra-amniotic group, with a mean abortion time of 17,6 hrs and in 80 % in the intramuscular group, with a mean abortion time of 15.0 hrs. Neither parity nor gestational age was significantly related to the abortifacient efficacy of 15-me-PGF_2α. No serious complications occurred. Vomiting (83–84 %) and diarrhoea (23–92 %) were the most common complaints. Uterine contractions were more painful if induction was effected with intra-amniotic rather than intramuscular injections. 15-me-PGF_2α appears to be an effective and practicable abortifacient which can be used intra-amniotically or intramuscularly according to the ease of amniocentesis.     

The effect of a 10 cm2, 0.5% 15-ME-PGF2α methyl ester intravaginal silastic device on abortion and plasma prostaglandin concentration

Intravaginal insetion of a 10 cm² silastic device with an 0.5% concentration of 15(S)-15-methyl-prostaglandin F_2α methyl ester alone successfully induced abortion in 27 of 48 patients in the midtrimester and in an additional 11 patients with a concomitant infusion of oxytocin. The mean abortion time for the 38 successful induction was 15.35 hours. In 8 of the 10 patients who failed to abort even with concomitant oxytocin therapy, abortion was induced by serial intramuscular injections of 15-ME-PGF_α; the remaining 2 failures underwent surgical evaccution. The plasma levels of 15-ME-PGF_2α methyl ester in the 11 patients studied varied widely over the first 2 hours after insertion of the device. The maximum mean level was achieved at 2 hours, maintained at 4 hours and then dropped sharply at 8 hours and declined over the abortion period in undelivered patients. Vomiting and diarrhea were the most common side effects and in general well tolerated by the patients. However, there was an adverse reaction in a single patient who experienced almost constant nausea, vomiting and diarrhea. The device was removed 1 hour 50 minutes after insertion and the patient aborted spontaneously 7 hours later. Intravaginal insertion of a silastic device is an effective means of prostaglandin abortion, but their investigation is required to determine the most effective device which would provide a slow, continuous release of the prostaglandin.     

Uterine trauma associated with midtrimester abortion induced by intra-amniotic prostaglandin F2α with and without concomitant use of oxytocin

Five of 80 (6.2%) nulliparous women sustained uterine trauma in association with midtrimester abortion induced by intra-amniotic prostaglandin F_2α and intravenous oxytocin. All five women suffered cervical lacerations, one extending to the lower uterine segment of the corpus and another associated with myometrial necrosis caused by cornual sacculation and ischemia. No uterine trauma was observed among 95 parous women aborted in the same fashion during this study. The different mechanisms of cervical dilatation in the parous woman and the nullipara are offered as an explanation for this difference. Thirty-nine other cases of uterine injury associated with the use of intra-amniotic prostaglandin F_2α from the literature were reviewed, and found to indicate that midtrimester abortion induced by intra-amniotic prostaglandin F_2α is associated with a significant risk of uterine trauma in the nullipara. The risk seems to increase with the use of oxytocin and with increasing gestational age.     

Mid-trimester abortion with intra-amniotic prostaglandin F2 alpha and intravenous oxytocin infusion

Induction of abortion in mid-trimester pregnancies were performed on 26 patients. The first 12 patients were treated by intra-amniotic instillation of Prostaglandin F2 alpha, with a mean dosage of 40.2 mg. and mean abortion time of 24 hours and 41 minutes (ten patients). Fourteen additional mid-trimester abortions were performed using identical protocol plus the addition of oxytocin by intravenous infusion two hours after injection of the prostaglandin. All patients aborted, with mean dosage of PGF2 alpha of 28.2 mg. and mean abortion time of 15 hours and 37 minutes.     

Laminaria augmentation of intra-amniotic PGF2 for midtrimester pregnancy termination

In our hands, intra-amniotic PGF_2^α 40 mg for midtrimester pregnancy termination had a mean infusion to abortion interval of 29.4 hr. However, pretreatment of 230 patients with laminaria tents inserted 14–18 hr before PGF_2^α infusion resulted in a dramatically reduced time to abortion (14.3 hr mean) with a low incidence of gastrointestinal and other side effects. Laminaria tents inserted at the same time as PGF_2^α infusion in 26 patients also resulted in reduced time to abortion (18.6 hr mean). In the laminaria pretreated group, the infusion to abortion interval was indirectly related to the number of laminaria inserted and not to the nulliparous or parous state. Although we have made significant strides in shortening the abortion interval in the hospital, retained placentae and blood loss persist as problems related to the use of prostaglandin for abortion.     

Administration of prostaglandins by various routes for induction of abortion merits and demerits

Prostaglandin F_2α and its methyl analogues were used for induction of abortion in 598 patients with gestational age from 9 to 20 weeks. Different routes of administration were studied and varous dosages given. The incidence of gastrointestinal side effects were within acceptable range for all methods. Both intra-amniotic injections of 50 mg PGF_2α and 2.5 mg 15-methyl PGF_2α as well as intramuscular and vaginal administration of 15-methyl PGF_2α or its methyl ester, respectively, were highly effective in termination of pregnancy. The intramuscular route was, however, associated with the highest frequency of gastrointestinal side effects. If both efficacy and side effects were taken into consideration, the intra-amniotic and vaginal routes were superior. The ease of administration as well as the applicability over a wider range of gestation in termination of pregnancy may, however, in many situations speak in favour of the repeated vaginal administration of 15-methyl PGF_2α methyl ester.     

Laminaria augmentation of intra-amniotic PGF2α for midtrimester pregnancy termination

In our hands, intra-amniotic PGF₂α 40 mg for midtrimester pregnancy termination had a mean infusion to abortion interval of 29.4 hr. However, pretreatment of 230 patients with laminaria tents inserted 14–18 hr before PGF₂α infusion resulted in a dramatically reduced time to abortion (14.3 hr mean) with a low incidence of gastrointestinal and other side effects. Laminaria tents inserted at the same time as PGF₂α infusion in 26 patients also resulted in reduced time to abortion (18.6 hr mean). In the laminaria pretreated group, the infusion to abortion interval was indirectly related to the number of laminaria inserted and not to the nulliparous or parous state. Although we have made significant strides in shortening the abortion interval in the hospital, retained placentae and blood loss persist as problems related to the use of prostaglandin for abortion.     

Induced abortion in the 8–9th week of pregnancy with vaginally administered 15-methyl PGF2α methyl ester

15(S)15-methyl PGF_2α methyl ester was self-administered vaginally to terminate pregnancy in 42 women in the 8–9th week of gestation. Ten patients received a total of 6 mg of the compound over 15 hours (Group I) while the remaining 32 patients received 5.5 mg of the prostaglandin compound during a shorter period of time or 9 hours (Group II). If parts of the conceptus were expelled during treatment, surgical intervention was excluded. All patients were followed closely after treatment with repeated serum HCG assays and clinical examinations. All patients in Group II and eight out of ten patients in Group I aborted following treatment. In 33 of the 42 patients, the serum HCG levels and the clinical course following the expulsion of the conceptus indicated that abortion was complete. Gastro-intestinal side effects were minimal if anti-diarrheic agents were given prophylactically. The incidence of uterine pain was variable but could in most cases be controlled by oral or rectal administration of analgetics. The results of this study suggest that the use of this compound for termination of pregnancy may be safely extended through the 9th week of gestation and in certain cases be an alternative to the normal operative procedure.     

Preoperative dilatation of the cervix by single vaginal administration of 15-methyl-PGF2α-methyl ester

Two different vaginal suppositories have been developed suitable for one single treatment for preoperative dilatation of the cervix prior to vacuum aspiration in late first trimester abortion. The study included 60 patients equally distributed in one control group (Group I) where vacuum aspiration was performed without pretreatment; one group (Group II) where the patients obtained 2.0 mg 15-methyl-PGF_2α-methyl ester in a rapid releasing base six hours prior to operation and one group (Group III) where the prostaglandin dose was increased to 2.5 mg 15-methyl-PGF_2α-methyl ester and a more slow releasing base was used and the operation performed after 12 hours. The mean cervical dilatation at operation was in Group II 9 mm and in Group III 11 mm in comparison with 4.8 mm in the control group. The bleeding at the operation was also significantly reduced.