Protein Arcs May Form Stable Pores in Lipid Membranes

Electron microscopy and atomic force microscopy images of cholesterol-dependent cytolysins and related proteins that form large pores in lipid membranes have revealed the presence of incomplete rings, or arcs. Some evidence indicates that these arcs are inserted into the membrane and induce membrane leakage, but other experiments seem to refute that. Could such pores, only partially lined by protein, be kinetically and thermodynamically stable? How would the lipids be structured in such a pore? Using the antimicrobial peptide protegrin-1 as a model, we test the stability of pores only partially lined by peptide using all-atom molecular dynamics simulations in POPC and POPE/POPG membranes. The data show that, whereas pure lipid pores close rapidly, pores partially lined by protegrin arcs are stable for at least 300 ns. Estimates of the thermodynamic stability of these arcs using line tension data and implicit solvent calculations show that these arcs can be marginally stable in both zwitterionic and anionic membranes. Arcs provide an explanation for the observed ion selectivity in protegrin electrophysiology experiments and could possibly be involved in other membrane permeabilization processes where lipids are thought to participate, such as those induced by antimicrobial peptides and colicins, as well as the Bax apoptotic pore.     

Defect formation of lytic peptides in lipid membranes and their influence on the thermodynamic properties of the pore environment

We present an experimental study of the pore formation processes of small amphipathic peptides in model phosphocholine lipid membranes. We used atomic force microscopy to characterize the spatial organization and structure of alamethicin- and melittin-induced defects in lipid bilayer membranes and the influence of the peptide on local membrane properties. Alamethicin induced holes in gel DPPC membranes were directly visualized at different peptide concentrations. We found that the thermodynamic state of lipids in gel membranes can be influenced by the presence of alamethicin such that nanoscopic domains of fluid lipids form close to the peptide pores, and that the elastic constants of the membrane are altered in their vicinity. Melittin-induced holes were visualized in DPPC and DLPC membranes at room temperature in order to study the influence of the membrane state on the peptide induced hole formation. Also differential scanning calorimetry was used to investigate the effect of alamethicin on the lipid membrane phase behaviour.     

Defect formation of lytic peptides in lipid membranes and their influence on the thermodynamic properties of the pore environment

We present an experimental study of the pore formation processes of small amphipathic peptides in model phosphocholine lipid membranes. We used atomic force microscopy to characterize the spatial organization and structure of alamethicin- and melittin-induced defects in lipid bilayer membranes and the influence of the peptide on local membrane properties. Alamethicin induced holes in gel DPPC membranes were directly visualized at different peptide concentrations. We found that the thermodynamic state of lipids in gel membranes can be influenced by the presence of alamethicin such that nanoscopic domains of fluid lipids form close to the peptide pores, and that the elastic constants of the membrane are altered in their vicinity. Melittin-induced holes were visualized in DPPC and DLPC membranes at room temperature in order to study the influence of the membrane state on the peptide induced hole formation. Also differential scanning calorimetry was used to investigate the effect of alamethicin on the lipid membrane phase behaviour.     

Pore formation by a Bax-derived peptide: effect on the line tension of the membrane probed by AFM

Bax is a critical regulator of physiological cell death that increases the permeability of the outer mitochondrial membrane and facilitates the release of the so-called apoptotic factors during apoptosis. The molecular mechanism of action is unknown, but it probably involves the formation of partially lipidic pores induced by Bax. To investigate the interaction of Bax with lipid membranes and the physical changes underlying the formation of Bax pores, we used an active peptide derived from helix 5 of this protein (Bax-alpha5) that is able to induce Bax-like pores in lipid bilayers. We report the decrease of line tension due to peptide binding both at the domain interface in phase-separated lipid bilayers and at the pore edge in atomic force microscopy film-rupture experiments. Such a decrease in line tension may be a general strategy of pore-forming peptides and proteins, as it affects the energetics of the pore and stabilizes the open state.     

Molecular mechanism of antimicrobial peptides: the origin of cooperativity

Based on very extensive studies on four peptides (alamethicin, melittin, magainin and protegrin), we propose a mechanism to explain the cooperativity exhibited by the activities of antimicrobial peptides, namely, a non-linear concentration dependence characterized by a threshold and a rapid rise to saturation as the concentration exceeds the threshold. We first review the structural basis of the mechanism. Experiments showed that peptide binding to lipid bilayers creates two distinct states depending on the bound-peptide to lipid ratio P/L. For P/L below a threshold P/L*, all of the peptide molecules are in the S state that has the following characteristics: (1) there are no pores in the membrane, (2) the axes of helical peptides are oriented parallel to the plane of membrane, and (3) the peptide causes membrane thinning in proportion to P/L. As P/L increases above P/L*, essentially all of the excessive peptide molecules occupy the I state that has the following characteristics: (1) transmembrane pores are detected in the membrane, (2) the axes of helical peptides are perpendicular to the plane of membrane, (3) the membrane thickness remains constant for P/L> or =P/L*. The free energy based on these two states agrees with the data quantitatively. The free energy also explains why lipids of positive curvature (lysoPC) facilitate and lipids of negative curvature (PE) inhibit pore formation.     

Molecular dynamics simulations of hydrophilic pores in lipid bilayers

Hydrophilic pores are formed in peptide free lipid bilayers under mechanical stress. It has been proposed that the transport of ionic species across such membranes is largely determined by the existence of such meta-stable hydrophilic pores. To study the properties of these structures and understand the mechanism by which pore expansion leads to membrane rupture, a series of molecular dynamics simulations of a dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine (DPPC) bilayer have been conducted. The system was simulated in two different states; first, as a bilayer containing a meta-stable pore and second, as an equilibrated bilayer without a pore. Surface tension in both cases was applied to study the formation and stability of hydrophilic pores inside the bilayers. It is observed that below a critical threshold tension of approximately 38 mN/m the pores are stabilized. The minimum radius at which a pore can be stabilized is 0.7 nm. Based on the critical threshold tension the line tension of the bilayer was estimated to be approximately 3 x 10(-11) N, in good agreement with experimental measurements. The flux of water molecules through these stabilized pores was analyzed, and the structure and size of the pores characterized. When the lateral pressure exceeds the threshold tension, the pores become unstable and start to expand causing the rupture of the membrane. In the simulations the mechanical threshold tension necessary to cause rupture of the membrane on a nanosecond timescale is much higher in the case of the equilibrated bilayers, as compared with membranes containing preexisting pores.     

Energy-independent translocation of cell-penetrating peptides occurs without formation of pores. A biophysical study with pep-1

Pep-1 is a cell-penetrating peptide (CPP) with the ability to translocate across biological membranes and introduce active proteins inside cells. The uptake mechanism used by this CPP is, as yet, unknown in detail. Previous results show that such a mechanism is endocytosis-independent and suggests that physical-chemical interactions between the peptide and lipid bilayers govern the translocation mechanism. Formation of a transmembrane pore has been proposed but this issue has always remained controversial. In this work the secondary structure of pep-1 in the absence/presence of lipidic bilayers was determined by CD and ATR-FTIR spectroscopies and the occurrence of pore formation was evaluated through electrophysiological measurements with planar lipid membranes and by confocal microscopy using giant unilamellar vesicles. Despite pep-1 hydrophobic domain tendency for amphipathic α-helix conformation in the presence of lipidic bilayers, there was no evidence for membrane pores in the presence of pep-1. Furthermore, alterations in membrane permeability only occurred for high peptide/lipid ratios, which induced the complete membrane disintegration. Such observations indicate that electrostatic interactions are of first importance in the pep-1-membrane interactions and show that pores are not formed. A peptide-lipid structure is probably formed during peptide partition, which favours peptide translocation.     

Energy-independent translocation of cell-penetrating peptides occurs without formation of pores. A biophysical study with pep-1

Pep-1 is a cell-penetrating peptide (CPP) with the ability to translocate across biological membranes and introduce active proteins inside cells. The uptake mechanism used by this CPP is, as yet, unknown in detail. Previous results show that such a mechanism is endocytosis-independent and suggests that physical-chemical interactions between the peptide and lipid bilayers govern the translocation mechanism. Formation of a transmembrane pore has been proposed but this issue has always remained controversial. In this work the secondary structure of pep-1 in the absence/presence of lipidic bilayers was determined by CD and ATR-FTIR spectroscopies and the occurrence of pore formation was evaluated through electrophysiological measurements with planar lipid membranes and by confocal microscopy using giant unilamellar vesicles. Despite pep-1 hydrophobic domain tendency for amphipathic alpha-helix conformation in the presence of lipidic bilayers, there was no evidence for membrane pores in the presence of pep-1. Furthermore, alterations in membrane permeability only occurred for high peptide/lipid ratios, which induced the complete membrane disintegration. Such observations indicate that electrostatic interactions are of first importance in the pep-1-membrane interactions and show that pores are not formed. A peptide-lipid structure is probably formed during peptide partition, which favours peptide translocation.     

Molecular mechanism of antimicrobial peptides: The origin of cooperativity

Based on very extensive studies on four peptides (alamethicin, melittin, magainin and protegrin), we propose a mechanism to explain the cooperativity exhibited by the activities of antimicrobial peptides, namely, a non-linear concentration dependence characterized by a threshold and a rapid rise to saturation as the concentration exceeds the threshold. We first review the structural basis of the mechanism. Experiments showed that peptide binding to lipid bilayers creates two distinct states depending on the bound-peptide to lipid ratio P/L. For P/L below a threshold P/L*, all of the peptide molecules are in the S state that has the following characteristics: (1) there are no pores in the membrane, (2) the axes of helical peptides are oriented parallel to the plane of membrane, and (3) the peptide causes membrane thinning in proportion to P/L. As P/L increases above P/L*, essentially all of the excessive peptide molecules occupy the I state that has the following characteristics: (1) transmembrane pores are detected in the membrane, (2) the axes of helical peptides are perpendicular to the plane of membrane, (3) the membrane thickness remains constant for P/L ≥ P/L*. The free energy based on these two states agrees with the data quantitatively. The free energy also explains why lipids of positive curvature (lysoPC) facilitate and lipids of negative curvature (PE) inhibit pore formation.     

PB1-F2, an influenza A virus-encoded proapoptotic mitochondrial protein, creates variably sized pores in planar lipid membranes

A frameshifted region of the influenza A virus PB1 gene encodes a novel protein, termed PB1-F2, a mitochondrial protein that can induce cell death. Many proapoptotic proteins are believed to act at the mitochondrial outer membrane to form an apoptotic pore with lipids. We studied the interaction of isolated, synthetic PB1-F2 (sPB1-F2) peptide with planar phospholipid bilayer membranes. The presence of nanomolar concentrations of peptide in the bathing solution induced a transmembrane conductance that increased in a potential-dependent manner. Positive potential on the side of protein addition resulted in a severalfold increase in the rate of change of membrane conductance. sPB1-F2-treated membranes became permeable to monovalent cations, chloride, and to a lesser extent, divalent ions. Despite various experimental conditions, we did not detect the distinctive conductance levels typical of large, stable pores, protein channels, or even pores that are partially proteinaceous. Rather, membrane conductance induced by sPB1-F2 fluctuated and visited almost all conductance values. sPB1-F2 also dramatically decreased bilayer stability in an electric field, consistent with a decrease in the line tension of a lipidic pore. Since similar membrane-destabilizing profiles are seen with proapoptotic proteins (e.g., Bax) and the cytoplasmic helix of human immunodeficiency virus gp41, we suggest that the basis for sPB1-F2-induced cell death may be the permeabilization and destabilization of mitochondrial membranes, leading to macromolecular leakage and apoptosis.     

Perforin rapidly induces plasma membrane phospholipid flip-flop

The cytotoxic cell granule secretory pathway is essential for host defense. This pathway is fundamentally a form of intracellular protein delivery where granule proteases (granzymes) from cytotoxic lymphocytes are thought to diffuse through barrel stave pores generated in the plasma membrane of the target cell by the pore forming protein perforin (PFN) and mediate apoptotic as well as additional biological effects. While recent electron microscopy and structural analyses indicate that recombinant PFN oligomerizes to form pores containing 20 monomers (20 nm) when applied to liposomal membranes, these pores are not observed by propidium iodide uptake in target cells. Instead, concentrations of human PFN that encourage granzyme-mediated apoptosis are associated with pore structures that unexpectedly favor phosphatidylserine flip-flop measured by Annexin-V and Lactadherin. Efforts that reduce PFN mediated Ca influx in targets did not reduce Annexin-V reactivity. Antigen specific mouse CD8 cells initiate a similar rapid flip-flop in target cells. A lipid that augments plasma membrane curvature as well as cholesterol depletion in target cells enhance flip-flop. Annexin-V staining highly correlated with apoptosis after Granzyme B (GzmB) treatment. We propose the structures that PFN oligomers form in the membrane bilayer may include arcs previously observed by electron microscopy and that these unusual structures represent an incomplete mixture of plasma membrane lipid and PFN oligomers that may act as a flexible gateway for GzmB to translocate across the bilayer to the cytosolic leaflet of target cells.     

A lipocentric view of peptide-induced pores

Although lipid membranes serve as effective sealing barriers for the passage of most polar solutes, nonmediated leakage is not completely improbable. A high activation energy normally keeps unassisted bilayer permeation at a very low frequency, but lipids are able to self-organize as pores even in peptide-free and protein-free membranes. The probability of leakage phenomena increases under conditions such as phase coexistence, external stress or perturbation associated to binding of nonlipidic molecules. Here, we argue that pore formation can be viewed as an intrinsic property of lipid bilayers, with strong similarities in the structure and mechanism between pores formed with participation of peptides, lipidic pores induced by different types of stress, and spontaneous transient bilayer defects driven by thermal fluctuations. Within such a lipocentric framework, amphipathic peptides are best described as pore-inducing rather than pore-forming elements. Active peptides bound to membranes can be understood as a source of internal surface tension which facilitates pore formation by diminishing the high activation energy barrier. This first or immediate action of the peptide has some resemblance to catalysis. However, the presence of membrane-active peptides has the additional effect of displacing the equilibrium towards the pore-open state, which is then maintained over long times, and reducing the size of initial individual pores. Thus, pore-inducing peptides, regardless of their sequence and oligomeric organization, can be assigned a double role of increasing the probability of pore formation in membranes to high levels as well as stabilizing these pores after they appear.     

PE and PS Lipids Synergistically Enhance Membrane Poration by a Peptide with Anticancer Properties

Polybia-MP1 (MP1) is a bioactive host-defense peptide with known anticancer properties. Its activity is attributed to excess serine (phosphatidylserine (PS)) on the outer leaflet of cancer cells. Recently, higher quantities of phosphatidylethanolamine (PE) were also found at these cells’ surface. We investigate the interaction of MP1 with model membranes in the presence and absence of POPS (PS) and DOPE (PE) to understand the role of lipid composition in MP1’s anticancer characteristics. Indeed we find that PS lipids significantly enhance the bound concentration of peptide on the membrane by a factor of 7–8. However, through a combination of membrane permeability assays and imaging techniques we find that PE significantly increases the susceptibility of the membrane to disruption by these peptides and causes an order-of-magnitude increase in membrane permeability by facilitating the formation of larger transmembrane pores. Significantly, atomic-force microscopy imaging reveals differences in the pore formation mechanism with and without the presence of PE. Therefore, PS and PE lipids synergistically combine to enhance membrane poration by MP1, implying that the combined enrichment of both these lipids in the outer leaflet of cancer cells is highly significant for MP1’s anticancer action. These mechanistic insights could aid development of novel chemotherapeutics that target pathological changes in the lipid composition of cancerous cells.     

On the mechanism of pore formation by melittin

The mechanism of pore formation of lytic peptides, such as melittin from bee venom, is thought to involve binding to the membrane surface, followed by insertion at threshold levels of bound peptide. We show that in membranes composed of zwitterionic lipids, i.e. phosphatidylcholine, melittin not only forms pores but also inhibits pore formation. We propose that these two modes of action are the result of two competing reactions: direct insertion into the membrane and binding parallel to the membrane surface. The direct insertion of melittin leads to pore formation, whereas the parallel conformation is inactive and prevents other melittin molecules from inserting, hence preventing pore formation.     

Mechanism of human erythrocyte hemolysis induced by short-chain phosphatidylcholines and lysophosphatidylcholine

The incorporation and accumulation of a certain amount of short-chain phosphatidylcholine or lysophosphatidylcholine into lipid bilayers of erythrocyte membranes is the first step causing membrane perturbation in the process of hemolysis. Accumulation of dilauroylglycerophosphocholine into membranes makes human erythrocytes "permeable cells"; Ions such as Na+ or K+ can permeate through the membrane, though large molecules such as hemoglobin can not. The "pore" formation was partially reproduced in liposomes prepared from lipids extracted from human erythrocyte membranes; C12:0PC induced the release of glucose from liposomes but did not significantly induce the release of dextran. It was suggested that the phase boundary between dilauroylglycerophosphocholine and the host membrane bilayer or dilauroylglycerophosphocholine rich domain itself behaves as "pores." Erythrocytes could expand to 1.5 times the original cell volume without any appreciable hemolysis when incubated with C12:0PC at 37 degrees C. The capacity of the erythrocytes to expand was temperature dependent. The capacity may play an important role in the resistance of the cells against lysis. The "permeable cell" stage could be hardly observed when erythrocytes were treated with didecanoylglycerophosphocholine and lysophosphatidylcholine. Perturbation induced by accumulation of didecanoylglycerophosphocholine or lysophosphatidylcholine may cause non specific destruction of membranes rather than formation of a kind of "pore."     

Peptides derived from apoptotic Bax and Bid reproduce the poration activity of the parent full-length proteins

Bax and Bid are proapoptotic proteins of the Bcl-2 family that regulate the release of apoptogenic factors from mitochondria. Although they localize constitutively in the cytoplasm, their apoptotic function is exerted at the mitochondrial outer membrane, and is related to their ability to form transbilayer pores. Here we report the poration activity of fragments from these two proteins, containing the first alpha-helix of a colicinlike hydrophobic hairpin (alpha-helix 5 of Bax and alpha-helix 6 of Bid). Both peptides readily bind to synthetic lipid vesicles, where they adopt predominantly alpha-helical structures and induce the release of entrapped calcein. In planar lipid membranes they form ion conducting channels, which in the case of the Bax-derived peptide are characterized by a two-stage pattern, a large conductivity and lipid-charge-dependent ionic selectivity. These features, together with the influence of intrinsic lipid curvature on the poration activity and the existence of two helical stretches of different orientations for the membrane-bound peptide, suggest that it forms mixed lipidic/peptidic pores of toroidal structure. In contrast, the assayed Bid fragment shows a markedly different behavior, characterized by the formation of discrete, steplike channels in planar lipid bilayers, as expected for a peptidic pore lined by a bundle of helices.     

Diffusion as a probe of peptide-induced membrane domain formation

Recently, we have shown that association with an antimicrobial peptide (AMP) can drastically alter the diffusion behavior of the constituent lipids in model membranes (Biochemistry 49, 4672-4678). In particular, we found that the diffusion time of a tracer fluorescent lipid through a confocal volume measured via fluorescence correlation spectroscopy (FCS) is distributed over a wide range of time scales, indicating the formation of stable and/or transient membrane species that have different mobilities. A simple estimate, however, suggested that the slow diffusing species are too large to be attributed to AMP oligomers or pores that are tightly bound to a small number of lipids. Thus, we tentatively ascribed them to membrane domains and/or clusters that possess distinctively different diffusion properties. In order to further substantiate our previous conjecture, herein we study the diffusion behavior of the membrane-bound peptide molecules using the same AMPs and model membranes. Our results show, in contrast to our previous findings, that the diffusion times of the membrane-bound peptides exhibit a much narrower distribution that is more similar to that of the lipids in peptide-free membranes. Thus, taken together, these results indicate that while AMP molecules prompt domain formation in membranes, they are not tightly associated with the lipid domains thus formed. Instead, they are likely located at the boundary regions separating various domains and acting as mobile fences.     

Assembly mechanism of the oligomeric streptolysin O pore: the early membrane lesion is lined by a free edge of the lipid membrane and is extended gradually during oligomerization.

Streptolysin O (SLO) is a bacterial exotoxin that binds to cell membranes containing cholesterol and then oligomerizes to form large pores. Along with rings, arc-shaped oligomers form on membranes. It has been suggested that each arc represents an incompletely assembled oligomer and constitutes a functional pore, faced on the opposite side by a free edge of the lipid membrane. We sought functional evidence in support of this idea by using an oligomerization-deficient, non-lytic mutant of SLO. This protein, which was created by chemical modification of a single mutant cysteine (T250C) with N-(iodoacetaminoethyl)-1-naphthylamine-5-sulfonic acid, formed hybrid oligomers with active SLO on membranes. However, incorporation of the modified T250C mutant inhibited subsequent oligomerization, so that the hybrid oligomers were reduced in size. These appeared as typical arc lesions in the electron microscope. They formed pores that permitted passage of NaCl and calcein but restricted permeation of large dextran molecules. The data indicate that the SLO pore is formed gradually during oligomerization, implying that pores lined by protein on one side and an edge of free lipid on the other may be created in the plasma membrane. Intentional manipulation of the pore size may extend the utility of SLO as a tool in cell biological experiments.     

Lipid II induces a transmembrane orientation of the pore-forming peptide lantibiotic nisin

Nisin is an antimicrobial peptide produced by Lactococcus lactis and used as a food preservative in dairy products. The peptide kills Gram-positive bacteria via the permeabilization of the membrane, most probably via pore formation using the cell wall precursor Lipid II as its docking molecule. In this study, site-directed tryptophan spectroscopy was used to determine the topology of nisin in the Lipid II containing membrane, as a start to elucidate the mechanism of targeted pore formation. Three single tryptophan mutants were used, which are viable representatives of the wild-type peptide. The emission spectra of tryptophans located at the N-terminus, the center, and the C-terminus as well as quenching by acrylamide and spin-labeled lipids were investigated using model membrane vesicles composed of DOPC containing 1 mol % Lipid II. Nisin was shown to adopt an orientation where the most probable position of the N-terminus was found to be near the Lipid II headgroup at the bilayer surface, the position of the center of nisin was in the middle of the phospholipid bilayer, and the C-terminus was located near the interface between the headgroups and acyl chain region. These results were used to propose a model for the orientation of nisin in Lipid II containing membranes. Our findings demonstrated that Lipid II changes the overall orientation of nisin in membranes from parallel to perpendicular with respect to the membrane surface. The stable transmembrane orientation of nisin in the presence of Lipid II might allow us to determine the structure of the nisin-Lipid II pores in the lipid bilayer.