Escherichia coli initiation factor 3 protein binding to 30S ribosomal subunits alters the accessibility of nucleotides within the conserved central region of 16S rRNA

Translational initiation factor 3 (IF3) is an RNA helix destabilizing protein which interacts with strongly conserved sequences in 16S rRNA, one at the 3' terminus and one in the central domain. It was therefore of interest to identify particular residues whose exposure changes upon IF3 binding. Chemical and enzymatic probing of central domain nucleotides of 16S rRNA in 30S ribosomal subunits was carried out in the presence and absence of IF3. Bases were probed with dimethyl sulfate (DMS), at A(N-1), C(N-3), and G(N-7), and with N-cyclohexyl-N'-[2-(N-methyl-4-morpholinio)ethyl] carbodiimide p-toluenesulfonate (CMCT), at G(N-1) and U(N-3). RNase T1 and nuclease S1 were used to probe unpaired nucleotides, and RNase V1 was used to monitor base-paired or stacked nucleotides. 30S subunits in physiological buffers were probed in the presence and absence of IF3. The sites of cleavage and modification were detected by primer extension. IF3 binding to 30S subunits was found to reduce the chemical reactivity and enzymatic accessibility of some sites and to enhance attack at other sites in the conserved central domain of 16S rRNA, residues 690-850. IF3 decreased CMCT attack at U701 and U793 and V1 attack at G722, G737, and C764; IF3 enhanced DMS attack at A814 and V1 attack at U697, G833, G847, and G849. Many of these central domain sites are strongly conserved and with the conserved 3'-terminal site define a binding domain for IF3 which correlates with a predicted cleft in two independent models of the 30S ribosomal subunit.     

N-terminal domain, residues 1-91, of ribosomal protein TL5 from Thermus thermophilus binds specifically and strongly to the region of 5S rRNA containing loop E.

In this work we show for the first time that the overproduced N-terminal fragment (residues 1-91) of ribosomal protein TL5 binds specifically to 5S rRNA and that the region of this fragment containing residues 80-91 is a necessity for its RNA-binding activity. The fragment of Escherichia coli 5S rRNA protected by TL5 against RNase A hydrolysis was isolated and sequenced. This 39 nucleotides fragment contains loop E and helices IV and V of 5S rRNA. The isolated RNA fragment forms stable complexes with TL5 and its N-terminal domain. Crystals of TL5 in complex with the RNA fragment diffracting to 2.75 A resolution were obtained.     

Structural changes in the 530 loop of Escherichia coli 16S rRNA in mutants with impaired translational fidelity.

The higher order structure of the functionally important 530 loop in Escherichia coli 16S rRNA was studied in mutants with single base changes at position 517, which significantly impair translational fidelity. The 530 loop has been proposed to interact with the EF-Tu-GTP-aatRNA ternary complex during decoding. The reactivity at G530, U531 and A532 to the chemical probes kethoxal, CMCT and DMS respectively was increased in the mutant 16S rRNA compared with the wild-type, suggesting a more open 530 loop structure in the mutant ribosomes. This was supported by oligonucleotide binding experiments in which probes complementary to positions 520-526 and 527-533, but not control probes, showed increased binding to the 517C mutant 70S ribosomes compared with the non-mutant control. Furthermore, enzymatic digestion of 70S ribosomes with RNase T1, specific for single-stranded RNA, substantially cleaved both wild-type and mutant rRNAs between G524 and C525, two of the nucleotides involved in the 530 loop pseudoknot. This site was also cleaved in the 517C mutant, but not wild-type rRNA, by RNase V1. Such a result is still consistent with a more open 530 loop structure in the mutant ribosomes, since RNase V1 can cut at appropriately stacked single-stranded regions of RNA. Together these data indicate that the 517C mutant rRNA has a rather extensively unfolded 530 loop structure. Less extensive structural changes were found in mutants 517A and 517U, which caused less misreading. A correlation between the structural changes in the 530 loop and impaired translational accuracy is proposed.     

Comparative Surface Structure of 16S Ribosomal Ribonucleic Acid of 30S Ribosomes of Procaryotic Cells

Ribonuclease T(1) treatment of 30S ribosomes of Escherichia coli converts a large region at the 3' OH end of 16S ribosomal ribonucleic acid (rRNA) to low-molecular-weight RNA. The final 25 nucleotides at the 3' terminus of the molecule emerge relatively intact, whereas most of the region "upstream," for about 150 nucleotides, is converted to oligonucleotides. Identical enzyme treatment generates a fragment of about 60 nucleotides from the middle of 16S rRNA (section D'). To determine whether there are similar sequences in other bacteria, which occupy similar accessible surface locations, we treated 30S ribosomes from Azotobacter vinelandii and Bacillus stearothermophilus with RNase T(1). In each case, a fragment of RNA about 25 nucleotides in length containing the 3' OH end of 16S rRNA and a fragment of about 60 nucleotides in length similar, but not identical, in oligonucleotide composition to section D' of E. coli 16S rRNA were obtained from nuclease-treated 30S ribosomes. These data indicate that, although the primary structure at the 3' end and the middle (section D') of the various 16S rRNA's is not completely conserved, their respective conformations are conserved. A number of identical oligonucleotides were found in the low-molecular-weight fraction obtained from RNase T(1)-treated E. coli, A. vinelandii, and B. stearothermophilus 30S ribosomes. These results show that identical RNase T(1)-sensitive sequences are present in all three bacteria. Hydrolysis of these regions leads to the production of the fragments 25 and 60 nucleotides in length.     

Probing the assembly of the 3' major domain of 16 S ribosomal RNA. Quaternary interactions involving ribosomal proteins S7, S9 and S19

We have studied the effect of assembly of ribosomal proteins S7, S9 and S19 on the accessibility and conformation of nucleotides in 16 S ribosomal RNA. Complexes formed between 16 S rRNA and S7, S7 + S9, S7 + S19 or S7 + S9 + S19 were subjected to a combination of chemical and enzymatic probes, whose sites of attack in 16 S rRNA were identified by primer extension. The results of this study show that: (1) Protein S7 affects the reactivity of an extensive region in the lower half of the 3' major domain. Inclusion of proteins S9 or S19 with S7 has generally little additional effect on S7-specific protection of the RNA. Clusters of nucleotides that are protected by protein S7 are localized in the 935-945 region, the 950/1230 stem, the 1250/1285 internal loop, and the 1350/1370 stem. (2) Addition of protein S9 in the presence of S7 causes several additional effects principally in two structurally distal regions. We observe strong S9-dependent protection of positions 1278 to 1283, and of several positions in the 1125/1145 internal loop. These findings suggest that interaction of protein S9 with 16 S rRNA results in a structure in which the 1125/1145 and 1280 regions are proximal to each other. (3) Most of the strong S19-dependent effects are clustered in the 950-1050 and 1210-1230 regions, which are joined by base-pairing in the 16 S rRNA secondary structure. The highly conserved 960-975 stemp-loop, which has been implicated in tRNA binding, appears to be destabilized in the presence of S19. (4) Protein S7 causes enhanced reactivity at several sites that become protected upon addition of S9 or S19. This suggests that S7-induced conformational changes in 16 S rRNA play a role in the co-operativity of assembly of the 3' major domain.     

Localization of the binding site for protein S4 on 16 S ribosomal RNA by chemical and enzymatic probing and primer extension

We have examined the effect of binding ribosomal protein S4 to 16 S rRNA on the susceptibility of the RNA to a variety of chemical and enzymatic probes. We have used dimethyl sulfate to probe unpaired adenines (at N-1) and cytosines (at N-3), kethoxal to probe unpaired guanines (at N-1 and N-2) and cobra venom (V1) ribonuclease as a probe of base-paired regions of 16 S rRNA. Sites of attack by the probes were identified by primer extension using synthetic oligodeoxynucleotides. Comparison of probing results for naked and S4-bound rRNA shows: Protein S4 protects a relatively compact region of the 5' domain of 16 S rRNA from chemical and enzymatic attack. This region is bounded by nucleotides 27 to 47 and 394 to 556, and has a secondary structure characterized by the junction of five helical elements. Phylogenetically conserved irregular features (bulged nucleotides, internal loops and flanking unpaired nucleotides) and helical phosphodiester bonds of four of the helices are specifically protected in the S4-RNA complex. We conclude that this is the major, and possibly sole region of contact between 16 S rRNA and S4. Many of the S4-dependent changes mimic those observed on assembly of 16 S rRNA into 30 S ribosomal subunits. Binding of S4 causes enhanced chemical reactivity coupled with protection from V1 nuclease outside the S4 junction region in the 530, 720 and 1140 loops. We interpret these results as indicative of loss of structure, and suggest that S4 binding causes disruption of adventitious pairing in these regions, possibly by stabilizing the geometry of the RNA such that these interactions are prevented from forming.     

Three-dimensional model of Escherichia coli ribosomal 5 S RNA as deduced from structure probing in solution and computer modeling.

The conformation of Escherichia coli 5 S rRNA was investigated using chemical and enzymatic probes. The four bases were monitored at one of their Watson-Crick positions with dimethylsulfate (at C(N-3) and A(N-1], with a carbodiimide derivative (at G(N-1) and U(N-3] and with kethoxal (at G(N-1, N-2]. Position N-7 of purine was probed with diethylpyrocarbonate (at A(N-7] and dimethylsulfate (at G(N-7]. Double-stranded or stacked regions were tested with RNase V1 and unpaired guanine residues with RNase T1. We also used lead(II) that has a preferential affinity for interhelical and loop regions and a high sensitivity for flexible regions. Particular care was taken to use uniform conditions of salt, magnesium, pH and temperature for the different enzymatic chemical probes. Derived from these experimental data, a three dimensional model of the 5 S rRNA was built using computer modeling which integrates stereochemical constraints and phylogenetic data. The three domains of 5 S rRNA secondary structure fold into a Y-shaped structure that does not accommodate long-range tertiary interactions between domains. The three domains have distinct structural and dynamic features as revealed by the chemical reactivity and the lead(II)-induced hydrolysis: domain 2 (loop B/helix III/loop C) displays a rather weak structure and possesses dynamic properties while domain 3 (helix V/region E/helix IV/loop D) adopts a highly structured and overall helical conformation. Conserved nucleotides are not crucial for the tertiary folding but maintain an intrinsic structure in the loop regions, especially via non-canonical pairing (A.G, G.U, G.G, A.C, C.C), which can close the loops in a highly specific fashion. In particular, nucleotides in the large external loop C fold into an organized conformation leading to the formation of a five-membered loop motif. Finally, nucleotides at the hinge region of the Y-shape are involved in a precise array of hydrogen bonds based on a triple interaction between U14, G69 and G107 stabilizing the quasi-colinearity of helices II and V. The proposed tertiary model is consistent with the localization of the ribosomal protein binding sites and possesses strong analogy with the model proposed for Xenopus laevis 5 S rRNA, indicating that the Y-shape model can be generalized to all 5 S rRNAs.     

Interaction of ribosomal proteins S6, S8, S15 and S18 with the central domain of 16 S ribosomal RNA from Escherichia coli

The co-operative interaction of 30 S ribosomal subunit proteins S6, S8, S15 and S18 with 16 S ribosomal RNA from Escherichia coli was studied by (1) determining how the binding of each protein is influenced by the others and (2) characterizing a series of protein-rRNA fragment complexes. Whereas S8 and S15 are known to associate independently with the 16 S rRNA, binding of S18 depended upon S8 and S15, and binding of S6 was found to require S8, S15 and S18. Ribonucleoprotein (RNP) fragments were derived from the S8-, S8/S15- and S6/S8/S15/S18-16 S rRNA complexes by partial RNase hydrolysis and isolated by electrophoresis through Mg2+-containing polyacrylamide gels or by centrifugation through sucrose gradients. Identification of the proteins associated with each RNP by gel electrophoresis in the presence of sodium dodecyl sulfate demonstrated the presence of S8, S8 + S15 and S6 + S8 + S15 + S18 in the corresponding fragment complexes. Analysis of the rRNA components of the RNP particles confirmed that S8 was bound to nucleotides 583 to 605 and 624 to 653, and that S8 and S15 were associated with nucleotides 583 to 605, 624 to 672 and 733 to 757. Proteins S6, S8, S15 and S18 were shown to protect nucleotides 563 to 605, 624 to 680, 702 to 770, 818 to 839 and 844 to 891, which span the entire central domain of the 16 S rRNA molecule (nucleotides 560 to 890). The binding site for each protein contains helical elements as well as single-stranded internal loops ranging in size from a single bulged nucleotide to 20 bases. Three terminal loops and one stem-loop structure within the central domain of the 16 S rRNA were not protected in the four-protein complex. Interestingly, bases within or very close to these unprotected regions have been shown to be accessible to chemical and enzymatic probes in 30 S subunits but not in 70 S ribosomes. Furthermore, nucleotides adjacent to one of the unprotected loops have been cross-linked to a region near the 3' end of 16 S rRNA. Our observations and those of others suggest that the bases in this domain that are not sequestered by interactions with S6, S8, S15 or S18 play a role involved in subunit association or in tertiary interactions between portions of the rRNA chain that are distant from one-another in the primary structure.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)     

Interaction of ribosomal proteins, S6, S8, S15 and S18 with the central domain of 16 S ribosomal RNA

We have constructed complexes of ribosomal proteins S8, S15, S8 + S15 and S8 + S15 + S6 + S18 with 16 S ribosomal RNA, and probed the RNA moiety with a set of structure-specific chemical and enzymatic probes. Our results show the following effects of assembly of proteins on the reactivity of specific nucleotides in 16 S rRNA. (1) In agreement with earlier work, S8 protects nucleotides in and around the 588-606/632-651 stem from attack by chemical probes; this is supported by protection in and around these same regions from nucleases. In addition, we observe protection of positions 573-575, 583, 812, 858-861 and 865. Several S8-dependent enhancements of reactivity are found, indicating that assembly of this protein is accompanied by conformational changes in 16 S rRNA. These results imply that protein S8 influences a much larger region of the central domain than was previously suspected. (2) Protein S15 protects nucleotides in the 655-672/734-751 stem, in agreement with previous findings. We also find S15-dependent protection of nucleotides in the 724-730 region. Assembly of S15 causes several enhancements of reactivity, the most striking of which are found at G664, A665, G674, and A718. (3) The effects of proteins S6 and S18 are dependent on the simultaneous presence of both proteins, and on the presence of protein S15. S6 + S18-dependent protections are located in the 673-730 and 777-803 regions. We observed some variability in our results with these proteins, depending on the ratio of protein to RNA used, and in different trials using enzymatic probes, possibly due to the limited solubility of protein S18. Consistently reproducible was protection of nucleotides in the 664-676 and 715-729 regions. Among the latter are three of the nucleotides (G664, G674 and A718) that are strongly enhanced by assembly of protein S15. This result suggests that an S15-induced conformational change involving these nucleotides may play a role in the co-operative assembly of proteins S6 and S18.     

On the role of protein S4 N-terminal residues 1 through 30 in 30S ribosome function.

30S ribosomal protein S4 contains a single cysteine residue at position 31. We have selectively cleaved the peptide bond adjacent to this residue using the reagent 2-nitro-5-thiocyanobenzoic acid. The two resultant fragments were purified. The smaller S4-fragment (1-30) was found to be incapable of interacting with 16S RNA directly. This fragment also is not incorporated into a particle reconstituted from 16S RNA and 20 purified proteins with S4 missing. In contrast, the large S4-fragment (31-203) appears to be fully functional in ribosome assembly. Replacement of S4 with this fragment in the reconstitution reaction leads to a complete 30S ribosome containing all 30S proteins. This particle has a full capacity to bind poly U but has lost all activity for poly U directed phe-tRNA binding. We therefore propose that the N-terminus of protein S4 is not critical for ribosome assembly but is essential for tRNA binding.     

Involvement of the mature domain in the in vitro maturation of Bacillus subtilis precursor 5S ribosomal RNA.

A precursor of 5S ribosomal RNA from Bacillus subtilis (p5A rRNA, 179 nucleotides in length) is cleaved by RNase M5, a specific maturation endonuclease which releases the mature 5S rRNA (m5, 116 nucleotides) and precursor fragments derived from the 5' (21 nucleotides) and 3' (42 nucleotides) termini of p5A rRNA. Previous results (Meyhack, B., et al. (1978) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 75, 3045) led to the conclusion that recognition elements in potential RNase M5 substrates mainly reside in the mature moiety of the precursor. Limited digestion of p5A rRNA with RNase T1 permitted the isolation of a number of test substrates which contained both precursor-specific segments and were unaltered in the immediate vicinity of the cleavage sites, but which differed in that more or less extensive regions of the mature moiety of the p5A rRNA were deleted. Tests of the capacity of these partial molecules to serve as substrates for RNase M5 indicate clearly that the enzyme recognizes the overall conformation of potential substrates, neglecting only the double-helical "prokaryotic loop" (Fox, G.E., & Woese, C.R. (1975) Nature (London) 256, 505).     

Role of conserved nucleotides in building the 16 S rRNA binding site for ribosomal protein S15

Ribosomal protein S15 recognizes a highly conserved target on 16 S rRNA, which consists of two distinct binding regions. Here, we used extensive site-directed mutagenesis on a Escherichia coli 16 S rRNA fragment containing the S15 binding site, to investigate the role of conserved nucleotides in protein recognition and to evaluate the relative contribution of the two sites. The effect of mutations on S15 recognition was studied by measuring the relative binding affinity, RNA probing and footprinting. The crystallographic structure of the Thermus thermophilus complex allowed molecular modelling of the E. coli complex and facilitated interpretation of biochemical data. Binding is essentially driven by site 1, which includes a three-way junction constrained by a conserved base triple and cross-strand stacking. Recognition is based mainly on shape complementarity, and the role of conserved nucleotides is to maintain a unique backbone geometry. The wild-type base triple is absolutely required for protein interaction, while changes in the conserved surrounding nucleotides are partially tolerated. Site 2, which provides functional groups in a conserved G-U/G-C motif, contributes only modestly to the stability of the interaction. Binding to this motif is dependent on binding at site 1 and is allowed only if the two sites are in the correct relative orientation. Non-conserved bulged nucleotides as well as a conserved purine interior loop, although not directly involved in recognition, are used to provide an appropriate flexibility between the two sites. In addition, correct binding at the two sites triggers conformational adjustments in the purine interior loop and in a distal region, which are known to be involved for subsequent binding of proteins S6 and S18. Thus, the role of site 1 is to anchor S15 to the rRNA, while binding at site 2 is aimed to induce a cascade of events required for subunit assembly.     

Specific ribosomal RNA recognition by a fragment of E. coli ribosomal protein S4 missing the C-terminal 36 amino acid residues.

We have previously investigated the role of the N-terminal region of ribosomal protein S4 to participate in 30S ribosome assembly and function (1-3). In this report we extend these studies to the two fragments produced by the chemical cleavage of protein S4 at the tryptophan residue 167. We find that the carboxyl terminal fragment (168-203) does not bind 16S RNA nor does it participate in assembly with the other 20 proteins from the 30S ribosome. In contrast, the larger fragment (1-167), does bind 16S RNA specifically. If the S4-fragment (1-167) is used to replace protein S4 in the complete 30S assembly reaction, all 20 of the other 30S proteins are incorporated. We conclude that the carboxyl terminal section of the protein S4 is not directly involved in binding 16S RNA or in the assembly of any of the other 30S proteins.     

Studies on the role of amino acid residues 31 through 46 of ribosomal protein S4 in the mechanism of 30 S ribosome assembly.

We have described previously the isolation of a large fragment of 30 S ribosomal protein S4 (Changchien &; Craven, 1976). This S4-fragment is produced by the digestion of the S4–16S RNA complex with trypsin and it retains a full capacity to associate specifically with 16S RNA. It was also demonstrated that the S4-fragment has approximately 46 amino acid residues missing from the N-terminus and an intact C-terminus (also shown by Newberry et al., 1977). Preliminary experiments with this S4-fragment indicated that it could not fully replace the intact protein S4 in the process of 30 S ribosome assembly in vitro.We have also recently reported (Changchien et al., 1978) the preparation of a new fragment of protein S4 which has only 30 amino acid residues cleaved from the N-terminus. This was achieved by the use of the reagent 2-nitro-5-thiocyanobenzoic acid which selectively modifies the cysteine residue at position 31 followed by a cleavage of the adjacent peptide bond.We have now fully characterized the capacity of these two fragments, S4-fragment (47–203) and S4-fragment(31–203), to participate in the 30 S ribosome assembly process in vitro. Using 2-dimensional polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis, we find that when S4-fragment(47–203) is a component of the in vitro assembly reaction, proteins S1, S2, S10, S18 and S21 fail to become incorporated into the final particle. In contrast, S4-fragment(31–203) appears to participate in the reconstitution reaction without impairment allowing the complete incorporation of all 20 proteins of the 30 S subunit. The resultant particle, containing the S4-fragment (31–203), is fully active in the binding of poly(U), but is completely inactive for non-enzymatic poly(U)-directed binding of Phe-tRNA (Changchien et al., 1978). These results suggest that residues 1 through 30 of protein S4 are not involved in the assembly of the 30 S ribosome, but are required for the proper construction of the tRNA binding site. In addition residues 31 through 46 must be somehow critically important for the assembly of proteins S1, S2, S10, S18 and S21. We present evidence to show that the absence of residues 31 through 46 of protein S4 prevents a conformational change in the structure of 16 S RNA which normally accompanies the RI to RI transition and that this results in the inability of these proteins to participate in the assembly process.     

The structure of the RNA binding site of ribosomal proteins S8 and S15.

Proteins S8 and S15 from the 30 S ribosomal subunit of Escherichia coli were bound to 16 S RNA and digested with ribonuclease A. A ribonucleoprotein complex was isolated which contained the two proteins and three noncontiguous RNA subfragments totaling 93 nucleotides, that could be unambiguously located in the 16 S RNA sequence. We present a secondary structural model for the RNA moiety of the binding site complex, in which the two smaller fragments are extensively base-paired, respectively, to the two halves of the large fragment, to form two disconnected duplexes. Each of the two duplexes is interrupted by a small internal loop. This model is supported by (i) minimum energy considerations, (ii) sites of cleavage by ribonuclease A, and (iii) modification by the single strand-specific reagent kethoxal. The effect of protein binding on the topography of the complex is reflected in the kethoxal reactivity of the RNA moiety. In the absence of the proteins, 5 guanines are modified; 4 of these, at positions 663, 732, 733, and 741, are strongly protected from kethoxal when protein S15 is bound.     

Modified nucleotides in T1 RNase oligonucleotides of 18S ribosomal RNA of the Novikoff hepatoma.

The primary structure of 18S rRNA of the Novikoff hepatoma cells was investigated. Regardless of whether the primary sequence of 18S rRNA is finally determined by RNA sequencing methods or DNA sequencing methods, it is important to identify numbers and types of the modified nucleotides and accordingly the present study was designed to localize the modified regions in T1 RNase derived oligonucleotide. Modified nucleotides found in 66 different oligonucleotide sequences included 2 m62A, 1 m6A, 1 m7G, 1m1cap3psi, 7 Cm, 13 Am, 9 Gm, 11 Um, and 38 psi residues. A number of these modified nucleotides are now placed in defined sequences of T1 RNase oligonucleotides which are now being searched for in larger fragments derived from partial T1 RNase digests of 18S rRNA. Improved homochromatography fingerprinting (Choi et al. (1976) Cancer Res. 36, 4301) of T1 RNase derived oligonucleotides provided a distinctive pattern for 18S rRNA of Novikoff hepatoma ascites cells. The 116 spots obtained by homochromatography contain 176 oligonucleotide sequences.     

Area of 16S ribonucleic acid at or near the interface between 30S and 50S ribosomes of Escherichia coli.

To determine the region of 16S ribonucleic acid (RNA) at the interface between 30 and 50S ribosomes of Escherichia coli, 30 and 70S ribosomes were treated with T1 ribonuclease (RNase). The accessibility of 16S RNA in the 5' half of the molecule is the same in 30 and 70S ribosomes. The interaction with 50S ribosomes decreases the sensitivity to T1 RNase of an area in the middle of 16S RNA. A large area near the 3' end of 16S RNA is completely protected in 70S ribosomes. The RNA near the 3' end of the molecule and an area of RNA in the middle of the molecule appear to be at the interface between 30 and 50S ribosomes. One site in 16S RNA, 13 to 15 nucleotides from the 3' end, normally inaccessible to T1 RNase in 30S ribosomes, becomes accessible to T1 RNase in 70S ribosomes. This indicates a conformational change at the 3' end of 16S RNA when 30S ribosomes are associated with 50S ribosomes.