Molecular phylogeny of Zeacarpa (Ralfsiales,Phaeophyceae) proposing a new family Zeacarpaceae and its transfer to Nemodermatales

Zeacarpa leiomorpha is a crustose brown alga endemic to South Africa. The species has been tentatively placed in Ralfsiaceae, but its ordinal assignment has been uncertain. The molecular phylogeny of brown algae based on concatenated DNA sequences of seven chloroplast and mitochondrial gene sequences (atpB, psaA, psaB, psbA, psbC, rbcL, and cox1) of taxa covering most of the orders revealed the most related phylogenetic relationship of Z. leiomorpha to Nemoderma tingitanum (Nemodermatales) rather than Ralfsiaceae (Ralfsiales). Morphologically, Zeacarpa and Nemoderma share crustose thallus structure and multiple discoidal chloroplasts without pyrenoids in each cell, however, the formation of lateral unilocular zoidangia in tufts in loose upright filaments in Zeacarpa is distinctive in brown algae. Considering the relatively distant genetic divergence between the two taxa, comparable to that among families or orders in representative brown algae, in addition to the above‐mentioned unique morphological features, we propose the classification of Zeacarpa in a new family Zeacarpaceae in the order Nemodermatales.     

MOLECULAR PHYLOGENY OF DISCOSPORANGIUM MESARTHROCARPUM (PHAEOPHYCEAE) WITH A REINSTATEMENT OF THE ORDER DISCOSPORANGIALES1

A molecular phylogenetic analysis of the little‐studied filamentous brown alga Discosporangium mesarthrocarpum (Meneghini) Hauck using rbcL and partial 18S rDNA sequences revealed that the species forms a monophyletic clade with Choristocarpus tenellus (Kütz.) Zanardini that is sister to all other brown algae. Although D. mesarthrocarpum has unique disk‐shaped plurilocular reproductive organs, D. mesarthrocarpum and C. tenellus share the following basic morphological features, which are considered to be plesiomorphic characters in the brown algae: (1) apical (and diffuse) growth; (2) uniseriate, subdichotomously branched filaments; (3) multiple chloroplasts per cell without pyrenoids; and (4) lack of heterotrichy and of phaeophycean hairs. The rbcL DNA sequence of an Australian D. mesarthrocarpum specimen showed considerable deviation from Mediterranean and Macaronesian specimens. Therefore, the presence of a second species in the genus is suggested; however, the taxonomic treatment of this putative species is not pursued in the present report. Regarding the higher‐ranking systematic position of D. mesarthrocarpum, reinstatement of Discosporangiaceae and Discosporangiales is proposed, and the inclusion of Choristocarpaceae in the order is also suggested. Under short‐day and long‐day culture conditions at 15°C–25°C, Mediterranean D. mesarthrocarpum exhibited a direct type of life history, with a succession of uniseriate filamentous thalli bearing characteristic disk‐shaped plurilocular zoidangia, but thalli did not survive at 10°C and below.     

Characteristics and utility of nuclear-encoded large-subunit ribosomal gene sequences in phylogenetic studies of red algae

Primer sequences are described for amplifying and sequencing a large fragment (approximately 2500 b.p.) of the nuclear-encoded large-subunit ribosomal RNA gene (LSU) from red algae. In comparison to RuBisCo large-subunit gene (rbcL) and nuclear-encoded small-subunit ribosomal RNA gene (SSU) sequence data, LSU sequence data was intermediate in the number of phylogenetically informative positions and sequence divergence. Parsimony analysis of LSU sequences for 16 Gelidiales species resolved some nodes unresolved in rbcL and SSU parsimony trees. An analysis of LSU sequences from 13 species of red algae classified in 11 orders suggests that this gene may be useful in studies of higher-level relationships of red algae.     

Developments in the taxonomy of silica‐scaled chrysophytes – from morphological and ultrastructural to molecular approaches

Taxonomy in silica‐scaled chrysophytes has gone through three morphological phases. From primary studies of the cell morphology in the 18th century, the focus was in the 20th century replaced by studies of the silica structures of the cell envelope. Now, in the latest decades the importance of DNA sequencing has been recognized, not only to support the taxonomic framework but also to obtain new understanding of taxonomic relations among particular taxa. In the first part of this review, we provide a historical overview of the developments in the taxonomy of scale‐bearing chrysophytes. In the second part, we present a phylogenetic reconstruction of chrysophyte algae, updated by newly obtained SSU rDNA and rbcL sequences of several isolated Synura, Mallomonas and Chrysosphaerella species. We detected significant incongruence between the phylogenies obtained from the different datasets, with the SSU rDNA phylogram being the most congruent with the morphological data. Significant saturation of the first rbcL codon position could indicate the presence of positive selection in the rbcL dataset. Within the Synurales, the relationships revealed by the phylogenetic analyses highlight the artificial infragenetic classification of Mallomonas and Synura, and the occurrence of cryptic diversity within a number of traditionally defined species. Finally, three new combinations are proposed based on the phylogenetic analyses: Tessellaria lapponica, Synura asmundiae and S. bjoerkii.     

GLOBAL SYSTEMATIC AND PHYLOGENETIC ANALYSIS OF SARGASSUM IN THE GULF OF MEXICO,CARIBBEAN AND PACIFIC BASIN

Sargassum is one of the most species‐rich genera in the brown algae with over 400 described species worldwide. The bulk of these species occurs in Pacific‐Indian ocean waters with only a small portion found on the Atlantic side of the Isthmus of Panama. Sargassum also has one of the most subdivided and complex taxonomic systems used within the algae. Systematic distinctions within the genus are further complicated by high rates of phenotypic variability in several key morphological characters. Molecular analyses in such systems should allow testing of systematic concepts while providing insights into speciation and evolutionary patterns. Global molecular phylogenetic analyses using both conserved and variable regions of the Rubisco operon (rbcL and rbcL‐IGS‐rbcS) were performed with species from the Gulf of Mexico, Caribbean, and Pacific basin. Results confirm earlier analyses based on rbcL‐IGS‐rbcS from Pacific species at the subgeneric and sectional level while providing additional insights into the systematics and phylogenetics on a global scale. For example, species east of the Isthmus of Panama form a distinct well‐resolved clade within the tropical subgenus. This result in sharp contrast to traditional systematic treatments but provides a window into the evolutionary history of this genus in the Pacific and Atlantic Ocean basins and a possible means to time speciation events.     

Undaria mitochondrial large subunit ribosomal DNA (Phaeophyceae, Alariaceae): Structural properties and use for phylogenetic analysis

We sequenced mitochondrial 23S ribosomal DNA (rDNA) from two Undaria species and compared them with homologous sequences from related brown algae. The 23S rDNA sequences from Undaria pinnatifida (Harvey) Suringar were 2707 bp in length, of which 1290–1292 sites were assigned to stem regions and the rest to loop regions in the rRNA secondary structure model. In Undaria undarioides (Yendo) Okamura, the sequences were 2708–2709 bp in length and 1290 sites were assigned to stems. There were three sequence types among the seven U. pinnatifida individuals examined and two among the four U. undarioides individuals. A maximum parsimony analysis of these sequence data with those from related brown algal species resolved a robust monphyly of each of the two Undaria species, suggesting the utilities of 23S rDNA for phylogeny at species or intraspecific level in brown algae. Accounting for variations among sequences parsimoniously, sequence changes were sorted into 423 events, of which 165 were mapped to stems of the secondary structure.     

Analysis of Adaptive Evolution and Coevolution of rbcL Gene in the Genus Galdieria (Rhodophyta)

To research the adaptive evolution and coevolution of the rbcL gene in the genus Galdieria, 36 sequences were selected. The bioinformatics of proteins encoded by rbcL genes of Galdieria were analyzed, and phylogenetic trees were constructed by the maximum-likelihood method. Then, adaptive evolution and coevolution were analyzed. The phylogenetic tree showed that the inner groups were clustered into four branches, in which the sequences of Galdieria maxima were divided into two small branches, and the posterior probability of each branch is above 94.9%. Eleven reliable positive selection sites were detected in the branched-site model, indicating that the rbcL protein-coding gene of Galdieria underwent adaptive evolution to adapt to extreme environments. Site 269 F is located in the loop 6 domain, while sites 272 D and 273 W are located in the 6-helix structure. Many coevolution pairs were detected, which were closely related to the hydrophobic and molecular weight correlation values of amino acids. The results are helpful to research the evolution process of freshwater red algae, to explore the changes of its essential genes and protein functions to adapt to different environmental pressures, and to understand the close relationship between amino acids in proteins and the molecular mechanism of evolution.     

Evidence for a composite phylogenetic origin of the plastid genome of the brown alga Pylaiella littoralis (L.) Kjellm

The nucleotide sequence and the 5 flanking region of the rbcL gene coding for the large subunit of ribulose bisphosphate-1,5-carboxylase/oxygenase of Pylaiella littoralis, a brown alga, has been determined and the deduced amino-acid sequence has been compared to those of various photosynthetic and chemoautotrophic Eubacteria, of a red alga and of green plastids (Euglena gracilis, green algae and higher plants). Unlike the rbcL genes of green plastids which are more closely related to those of cyanobacteria the P. littoralis rbcL gene is more closely related to that of a -purple bacterium, as was found for the rbcS gene of another chromophytic alga [Boczar et al., Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 86: 4996–4999, 1989]. Matrix data of homology between the rbcL gene of P. littoralis and the same gene of other organisms are presented. Based on our previous report, the gene coding for the 16S rRNA from P. littoralis is closely related to that of E. gracilis (Markowicz et al., Curr Genet 14: 599–608, 1988). We suggest that the large plastid DNA molecule of P. littoralis is a phylogenetically composite genome which probably resulted from mixed endosymbiosis events, or from a horizontal transfer of DNA.     

PHYLOGENETIC AFFINITIES OF “CHANTRANSIA” STAGES IN MEMBERS OF THE BATRACHOSPERMALES AND THOREALES (RHODOPHYTA)1

This study evaluated the phylogenetic relationship among samples of “Chantransia” stage of the Batrachospermales and Thoreales from several regions of the world based on sequences of two genes—the plastid‐encoded RUBISCO LSU gene (rbcL) and the nuclear SSU ribosomal DNA gene (SSU rDNA). All sequences of “Chantransia macrospora” were shown to belong to Batrachospermum macrosporum based on both molecular markers, confirming evidence from previous studies. In contrast, nine species are now associated with “Chantransia pygmaea,” including seven species of the Batrachospermales and two of the Thoreales. Therefore, the presence of “C. macrospora” in a stream can be considered reliable evidence that it belongs to B. macrosporum, whereas the occurrence of “C. pygmaea” does not allow the recognition of any particular species, since it is associated with at least nine species. Affinities of “Chantransia” stages to particular taxa were congruent for 70.5% of the samples comparing the rbcL and SSU analyses, which were associated with the same or closely related species for both markers. Sequence divergences have been reported in the “Chantransia” stage in comparison to the respective gametophyte, and this matter deserves further attention.     

A NEW BROWN ALGAL ORDER,ISHIGEALES (PHAEOPHYCEAE), ESTABLISHED ON THE BASIS OF PLASTID PROTEIN‐CODING rbcL,psaA, AND psbA REGION COMPARISONS1

The brown algal family Ishigeaceae currently includes a single genus, Ishige Yendo, with two species. The relationship of the family to other brown algal lineages is less studied in terms of their plastid ultrastructure and molecular phylogeny. We determined the sequences of rbcL from four samples of the two Ishige species and nine putative relatives and the psaA and psbA sequences from 37 representatives of the brown algae. Analyses of individual and combined data sets resulted in similar trees; however, the concatenated data gave greater resolution and clade support than each individual gene. In all the phylogenies, the Phaeophyceae was well resolved, the Ectocarpales being placed in a terminal position and the Ishigeaceae ending up in a basal position. From our ultrastructural study, we concluded that the pyrenoid is absent in the Ishigeaceae, despite the presence of a rudimentary pyrenoid in I. okamurae. These results suggest that the Ishigeaceae is an early diverging brown lineage. Our molecular and morphological data, therefore, lead us to exclude the Ishigeaceae from the Ectocarpales s.l., which have an elaborate pyrenoid, and to propose its own order Ishigeales ord. nov. The Ishigeales is distinguished by oligostichous structure of thalli, phaeophycean hairs formed within cryptostomata, unilocular sporangia transformed from terminal cortical cells, and plurilocular sporangia lacking sterile terminal cells. This study is the first to document the utility of the psaA and psbA sequences for brown algae and also the first report on the multigene phylogeny of the Phaeophyceae based on three protein‐coding plastid genes.     

MOLECULAR PHYLOGENY OF THE GREEN ALGAL ORDER PRASIOLALES (TREBOUXIOPHYCEAE,CHLOROPHYTA)1

The systematics of the Prasiolales was investigated by phylogenetic inference based on analyses of the rbcL and 18S rRNA genes for representatives of all four genera currently attributed to this order (Prasiococcus, Prasiola, Prasiolopsis, Rosenvingiella), including all type species. The rbcL gene had higher sequence divergence than the 18S rRNA gene and was more useful for phylogenetic inference at the ranks of genus and species. In the rbcL gene phylogeny, three main clades were observed, corresponding to Prasiola, Prasiolopsis, and Rosenvingiella. Prasiococcus was nested among species of Prasiola occurring in subaerial and supralittoral habitats. Trichophilus welckeri Weber Bosse, a subaerial alga occurring in the fur of sloths in Amazonia, was closely related to Prasiolopsis ramosa Vischer. The species of Prasiola were grouped into three well‐supported clades comprising (i) marine species, (ii) freshwater and terrestrial species with linear blades, and (iii) terrestrial species with rounded or fan‐shaped blades. Sequence divergence was unexpectedly low in the marine group, which included species with different morphologies. For the 18S rRNA gene, the phylogenetic analyses produced several clades observed for the rbcL gene sequence analysis, but, due to very little sequence variation, it showed considerably lower resolution for inference at the species and genus levels. Due to the low support of some internal branches, the results of the analyses did not allow an unambiguous clarification of the origin and the early evolution of the Prasiolales.     

New insights into diversity and selectivity of trentepohlialean lichen photobionts from the extratropics

Aerial green algae of Trentepohliaceae can form conspicuous free-living colonies, be parasites of plants or photobionts of lichen-forming ascomycetes. So far, their diversity in temperate regions is still poorly known as it has been mostly studied by phenotypic approaches only. We present new insights in the phylogenetic relationships of lichenized representatives from temperate and Mediterranean parts of Europe by analysis of 18S rRNA and rbcL gene fragments, and nuclear ITS sequence data. For this purpose we isolated the trentepohlialean photobionts from lichens representing different genera. Algal cultures from lichenized and free-living Trentepohliaceae were used to design new primers for amplification of the marker loci. We constructed a phylogenetic hypothesis to reveal the phylogenetic placements of lichenized lineages with 18S rRNA and rbcL sequences. ITS variation among the clades was substantial and did not allow including them in the general phylogenetic assessment, yet ITS appears to be a promising marker for DNA-barcoding approaches. Specific algae were found in particular lichen but the overall diversity of photobionts was limited. The multilocus tree does not support the current morphological classification of genera in Trentepohliaceae, suggesting that morphology is more variable than previously thought in this group of algae.     

PHYLOGENETIC ANALYSIS OF 32 STRAINS OF VAUCHERIA (XANTHOPHYCEAE) USING THE rbcL GENE AND ITS TWO FLANKING SPACER REGIONS1

The complete rbcL gene was sequenced for 21 species and 32 strains of Vaucheria and for five other Xanthophyceae (Asterosiphon dichotomus (Kützing) Rieth, Botrydium becharianum Vischer, B. cystosum Vischer, B. stoloniferum Mitra, Tribonema intermixtum Pascher). The psbA‐rbcL spacer, upstream of the rbcL gene, and the RUBISCO spacer between the rbcL and rbcS genes were also completely sequenced for the Vaucheria strains and Asterosiphon. The psbA‐rbcL spacer was the most variable region that was sequenced, and only the 3′ end of the spacer could be aligned. Phylogenetic analyses (maximum parsimony, neighbor joining, and maximum likelihood) were conducted using the DNA sequence and the amino acid sequence for the rbcL gene, and a second analysis was conducted using a portion of the psbA‐rbcL spacer +rbcL gene + RUBISCO spacer. All analyses showed that Vaucheria species formed monophyletic clades that corresponded with morphologically based subgeneric sections, including the section Racemosae. Species producing a gametophore (= fruiting branch, bearing both an antheridium and oogonium) formed a monophyletic clade in all analyses. The nongametophore species sometimes formed a monophyletic clade but other times formed a basal grade. Pair‐wise comparisons of nucleotides and amino acids showed that for some species, numerous nucleotide changes resulted in relatively few amino acid changes. Consequently, phylogenetic analysis of the amino acids produced numerous trees, which in a strict consensus tree resulted in numerous polychotomies. An original strain of V. terrestris that was deposited in two culture collections over 25 years ago had identical sequences, suggesting no rapid change was occurring in the sequenced regions. Two strains of V. prona, isolated from Europe and North America, had identical sequences. Other species, for which two or more strains were examined, had different sequences. These results suggest that cryptic species complexes exist within Vaucheria because the rbcL gene is a conservative gene that is identical in other protists.     

PHYLOGENY OF ZYGNEMOPHYCEAE BASED ON COXIII GENE SEQUENCE DATA

Molecular phylogenetic analysis of the conjugating green algae (Class Zygnemophyceae) using nuclear (SSU rDNA) and chloroplast (rbcL) gene sequences has resolved hypotheses of relationship at the class, order, and family levels, but several key questions will require data from additional genes. Based on SSU and rbcL sequences, the Zygnemophyceae and Desmidiales are monophyletic, and families of placoderm desmids are distinct clades (Desmidiaceae, Peniaceae, Closteriaceae, and Gonatozygaceae). In contrast, the Zygnemataceae and Mesotaeniaceae are paraphyletic, although whether these two traditional families constitute a clade is uncertain. In addition, relationships of genera within families have proven resistant to resolution with these two oft‐used genes. We have sequenced the coxIII gene from the mitochondrial genome to address some of these ambiguous portions of the phylogeny of conjugating green algae. The coxIII gene is more variable than rbcL or SSU rDNA and offers greater resolving power for relationships of genera. We present preliminary analyses of coxIII sequences from each of the traditional families of Zygnemophyceae and contrast the resulting topologies with those derived from nuclear and chloroplast genes.     

PHYLOGENETIC ANALYSES OF THE BRYOPSIDALES (ULVOPHYCEAE,CHLOROPHYTA) BASED ON RUBISCO LARGE SUBUNIT GENE SEQUENCES1

Current taxonomy of the Bryopsidales recognizes eight families; most of which are further categorized into two suborders, the Bryopsidineae and Halimedineae. This concept was supported by early molecular phylogenetic analyses based on rRNA sequence data, but subsequent cladistic analyses of morphological characters inferred monophyly in only the Halimedineae. These conflicting results prompted the current analysis of 32 taxa from this diverse group of green algae based on plastid‐encoded RUBISCO large subunit (rbcL) gene sequences. Results of these analyses suggested that the Halimedineae and Bryopsidineae are distinct monophyletic lineages. The families Bryopsidaceae, Caulerpaceae, Codiaceae, Derbesiaceae, and Halimediaceae were inferred as monophyletic, however the Udoteaceae was inferred as non‐monophyletic. The phylogenetic position of two taxa with uncertain subordinal affinity, Dichotomosiphon tuberosus Lawson and Pseudocodium floridanum Dawes & Mathieson, were also inferred. Pseudocodium was consistently placed within the halimedinean clade suggesting its inclusion into this suborder, however familial affinity was not resolved. D. tuberosus was the inferred sister taxon of the Halimedineae based on analyses of rbcL sequence data and thus a possible member of this suborder.     

Diversity and distribution of foliose Bangiales (Rhodophyta) in West Greenland: a link between the North Atlantic and North Pacific

Greenland is a continental island in the northern part of the North Atlantic where the foliose Bangiales flora is poorly known. It is an important area for the study of algal biogeography because of the region’s glacial history, in which Greenland has been alternately exposed to or isolated from the North Pacific via the Bering Strait. A molecular study using 3′ rbcL + 5′ rbcL–S sequences was undertaken to assess the diversity of foliose Bangiales on the west coast of Greenland and rbcL sequences were used to study the Greenland flora in a larger phylogenetic and floristic context. New and historic collections document seven species in four genera from the west coast of Greenland. All species had a close link to North Pacific species, being either conspecific with them or North Atlantic–North Pacific vicariant counterparts.     

RESOLVING EVOLUTIONARY RELATIONSHIPS AMONG THE BROWN ALGAE USING CHLOROPLAST AND NUCLEAR GENES1

The brown algae are one of the largest and most important groups of primary producers in benthic coastal marine environments. Despite their biological importance, consensus regarding their taxonomic or evolutionary relationships remains elusive. Our goal was to produce a taxon‐rich two‐gene (rbcL and LSU rDNA) phylogeny. Key species were sequenced to represent each order and family in the analyses across all 19 orders and ～40 families, including selected outgroups Schizocladiophyceae and Xanthophyceae. Our results are in sharp contrast to traditional phylogenetic concepts; the Ectocarpales are not an early diverging clade, nor do the Fucales diverge early from other brown algae. Rather, Choristocarpus is sister to the remaining brown algae. Other groups traditionally considered to have primitive features are actually recently diverged lineages, turning traditional phylogenetic concepts upside down. Additionally, our results allow for the assessment, in the broadest context, of many of the historical and more recent taxonomic changes, resulting in several emended groups along with proposals for two new orders (Onslowiales, Nemodermatales) and one new family (Phaeosiphoniellaceae).     

Molecular variation in Galdieria sulphuraria (Galdieri) Merola and its bearing on taxonomy

Cyanidium caldarium, Cyanidioschyzon merolae and Galdieria sulphuraria are three unicellular algae characteristic, of acid thermal environments. Recently, on the basis of morphological characters, three new species of Galdieria (G. partita, G. daedala, G. maxima ) isolated from acid-thermal springs in Russia have been instituted. A selected region of rbcL and the sequence of the intergenic spacer between the rbcL and rbcS have been amplified and sequenced from different Galdieria species and strains, in order to define molecular relationship among these interesting algae. The obtained cladogram shows that Cyanidium caldarium and Cyanidioschyzon merolae form a sister group which, in turn, is in a sister group relationship with Galdieria. This last genus is divided in two clades, one of which includes G. sulphuraria accessions from Naples (Italy), California, and Yellowstone and the other one includes G. sulphuraria accessions from Java (Indonesia) and from the Russian species. These results support the status of the genus Galdieria and suggest that G. daedala, G. maxima and G. partita are three very similar strains of G. sulphuraria; the rbcL variation within Galdieria accessions has a pattern which is broadly connected to the geographial distribution. The data obtained from the intergenic rbcL-rbcS spacer partly confirm those from the rbcL analysis.     

Phylogenetic analysis of Methanobrevibacter isolated from feces of humans and other animals

Comparative 16S rRNA gene sequence and genomic DNA reassociation analyses were used to assess the phylogenetic relationships of Methanobrevibacter fecal isolates. The 16S rRNA gene sequences of Methanobrevibacter smithii strain PS and the human fecal isolates B181 and ALI were essentially identical, and their genomic DNA reassociated at values greater than 94%. The analysis of 16S rRNA sequences of the horse, pig, cow, rat, and goose fecal isolates confirm that they are members of the genus Methanobrevibacter. They had a high degree of sequence similarity (97–98%) with the 16S rRNA gene of M. smithii, indicating that they share a common line of descent. The 16S rRNA genes of the horse and pig isolates had 99.3% sequence similarity. Sequence analysis of the 16S rRNA gene of the sheep fecal isolate showed that it formed a separate line of descent in the genus Methanobrevibacter. Genomic DNA reassociation studies indicate that the horse, pig, cow, and goose fecal isolates represent at least three new species. The horse and pig isolates were the only animal isolates that had > 70% genomic DNA reassociation and represent strains of a single species. The cow, goose, and sheep isolates had little or no genomic DNA reassociation with M. smithii or with each other. The relationship of the rat isolate to the other animal isolates was not determined. An evaluation of the relationship of 16S rRNA gene sequence similarity and genomic DNA reassociation of Methanobrevibacter and other methanogenic archaea indicated that genomic DNA reassociation studies are necessary to establish that two methanogenic organisms belong to the same species. Received: 17 November 1997 / Accepted: 16 January 1998