A New Trend in the Experimental Methodology for the Analysis of the Thioflavin T Binding to Amyloid Fibrils

The studies on the determination of the characteristics of the amyloid fibril interaction with the dye were based on the analysis of the dependence of the ThT fluorescence intensity on its concentration in the solution containing the amyloid fibrils. In the present work, we revealed that this intuitive approach provided erroneous data. We propose a new approach which provides a means for characterizing the interaction of thioflavin T (ThT) with amyloid fibrils and for determining the binding stoichiometry and binding constants, absorption spectrum, molar extinction coefficient, and fluorescence quantum yield of the ThT bound to the sites of different binding modes of fibrils. The key point of this approach is sample preparation by equilibrium microdialysis. The efficiency of the proposed approach is demonstrated via the examination of the ThT binding to insulin and Aβ42 fibrils as well as to the native form of the Electrophorus electricus acetylcholinesterase. We show that the peculiarities of ThT interaction with amyloid fibrils depend on the amyloidogenic protein and on the binding mode. This approach is universal and can be used for the analysis of binding mechanism of any dye that interacts with its receptor. Therefore, the proposed approach represents an important addition to the existing arsenal of means for the diagnostics and therapy of the neurodegenerative diseases.     

Fluorescence quantum yield of thioflavin T in rigid isotropic solution and incorporated into the amyloid fibrils

In this work, the fluorescence of thioflavin T (ThT) was studied in a wide range of viscosity and temperature. It was shown that ThT fluorescence quantum yield varies from 0.0001 in water at room temperature to 0.28 in rigid isotropic solution (T/η→0). The deviation of the fluorescence quantum yield from unity in rigid isotropic solution suggests that fluorescence quantum yield depends not only on the ultra-fast oscillation of ThT fragments relative to each other in an excited state as was suggested earlier, but also depends on the molecular configuration in the ground state. This means that the fluorescence quantum yield of the dye incorporated into amyloid fibrils must depend on its conformation, which, in turn, depends on the ThT environment. Therefore, the fluorescence quantum yield of ThT incorporated into amyloid fibrils can differ from that in the rigid isotropic solution. In particular, the fluorescence quantum yield of ThT incorporated into insulin fibrils was determined to be 0.43. Consequently, the ThT fluorescence quantum yield could be used to characterize the peculiarities of the fibrillar structure, which opens some new possibilities in the ThT use for structural characterization of the amyloid fibrils.     

Study on the binding of Thioflavin T to beta-sheet-rich and non-beta-sheet cavities

Amyloid fibril formation plays a role in more than 20 diseases including Alzheimer's disease. In vitro detection of these fibrils is often performed using Thioflavin T (ThT), though the ThT binding mode is largely unknown. In the present study, spectral properties of ThT in binding environments representing beta-sheet-rich and non-beta-sheet cavities were examined. Acetylcholinesterase and gamma-cyclodextrin induced a characteristic ThT fluorescence similar to that with amyloid fibrils, whereas beta-cyclodextrin and the beta-sheet-rich transthyretin did not. The cavities of acetylcholinesterase and gamma-cyclodextrin were of similar diameter and only these cavities could accommodate two ThT ions according to molecular modelling. Binding stoichiometry studies also showed a possible binding of two ThT ions. Thus, the characteristic ThT fluorescence is induced in cavities with a diameter of 8-9A and a length able to accommodate the entire length of the ThT ion. The importance of a cavity diameter capable of binding two ThT ions, among others, indicates that an excimer formation is a plausible mechanism for the characteristic fluorescence. We propose a similar ThT binding mode in amyloid fibrils, where cavities of an appropriate size running parallel to the fibril axis have previously been proposed in several amyloid fibril models.     

Analyzing thioflavin T binding to amyloid fibrils by an equilibrium microdialysis-based technique

A new approach for the determination of the amyloid fibril - thioflavin T (ThT) binding parameters (the number of binding modes, stoichiometry, and binding constants of each mode) is proposed. This approach is based on the absorption spectroscopy determination of the concentration of free and bound to fibril dye in solutions, which are prepared by equilibrium microdialysis. Furthermore, the proposed approach allowed us, for the first time, to determine the absorption spectrum, molar extinction coefficient, and fluorescence quantum yield of the ThT bound to fibril by each binding modes. This approach is universal and can be used for determining the binding parameters of any dye interaction with a receptor, such as ANS binding to proteins in the molten globule state or to protein amorphous aggregates.     

Binding mode of Thioflavin T and other molecular probes in the context of amyloid fibrils—current status

Because understanding amyloid fibrillation in molecular detail is essential for development of strategies to control amyloid formation and overcome neurodegenerative disorders, increased understanding of present molecular probes as well as development of new probes are of utmost importance. To date, the binding modes of these molecular probes to amyloid fibrils are by no means adequately described or understood, and the large number of studies on Thioflavin T (ThT) and Congo Red (CR) binding have resulted in models that are incomplete and conflicting. Different types of binding sites are likely to be present in amyloid fibrils with differences in binding modes. ThT may bind in channels running parallel to the long axis of the fibril. In the channels, ThT may bind in either a monomeric or dimeric form of which the molecular conformation is likely to be planar. CR may bind in grooves formed along the β-sheets as a planar molecule in either a monomeric or supramolecular form.     

Direct observation of amyloid fibril growth monitored by thioflavin T fluorescence

Real-time monitoring of fibril growth is essential to clarify the mechanism of amyloid fibril formation. Thioflavin T (ThT) is a reagent known to become strongly fluorescent upon binding to amyloid fibrils. Here, we show that, by monitoring ThT fluorescence with total internal reflection fluorescence microscopy (TIRFM), amyloid fibrils of beta2-microgobulin (beta2-m) can be visualized without requiring covalent fluorescence labeling. One of the advantages of TIRFM would be that we selectively monitor fibrils lying along the slide glass, so that we can obtain the exact length of fibrils. This method was used to follow the kinetics of seed-dependent beta2-m fibril extension. The extension was unidirectional with various rates, suggesting the heterogeneity of the amyloid structures. Since ThT binding is common to all amyloid fibrils, the present method will have general applicability for the analysis of amyloid fibrils. We confirmed this with the octapeptide corresponding to the C terminus derived from human medin and the Alzheimer's amyloid beta-peptide.     

Binding Modes of Thioflavin-T to the Single-Layer β-Sheet of the Peptide Self-Assembly Mimics

Although the amyloid dye thioflavin-T (ThT) is among the most widely used tools in the study of amyloid fibrils, the mechanism by which ThT binds to fibrils and other β-rich peptide self-assemblies remains elusive. The development of the water-soluble peptide self-assembly mimic (PSAM) system has provided a set of ideal model proteins for experimentally exploring the properties and minimal dye-binding requirements of amyloid fibrils. PSAMs consist of a single-layer β-sheet (SLB) capped by two globular domains, which capture the flat, extended β-sheet features common among fibril-like surfaces. Recently, a PSAM that binds to ThT with amyloid-like affinity (low micromolar K_d) has been designed, and its crystal structure in the absence of bound ThT was determined. This PSAM thus provides a unique opportunity to examine the interactions of ThT with a β-rich structure. Here, we present molecular dynamics simulations of the binding of ThT to this PSAM β-sheet. We show that the primary binding site for ThT is along a shallow groove formed by adjacent Tyr and Leu residues on the β-sheet surface. These simulations provide an atomic-scale rationale for this PSAM's experimentally determined dye-binding properties. Together, our results suggest that an aromatic-hydrophobic groove spanning across four consecutive β-strands represents a minimal ThT binding site on amyloid fibrils. Grooves formed by aromatic-hydrophobic residues on amyloid fibril surfaces may therefore offer a generic mode of recognition for amyloid dyes.     

Binding mode of Thioflavin T in insulin amyloid fibrils

Amyloid fibrils share various common structural features and their presence can be detected by Thioflavin T (ThT). In this paper, the binding mode of ThT to insulin amyloid fibrils was examined. Scatchard analysis and isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) showed at least two binding site populations. The binding site population with the strongest binding was responsible for the characteristic ThT fluorescence. This binding had a capacity of about 0.1 moles of ThT bound per mole of insulin in fibril form. The binding capacity was unaffected by pH, but the affinity was lowest at low pH. Notably, presence of a third binding process prior to the other processes was suggested by ITC. Binding of ThT resulted in only minor changes in the fibril structure according to the X-ray diffraction patterns, where a slightly more dominant equatorial reflection at 16A relative to the intersheet distance of 11A was observed. No change in the interstrand distance of 4.8A was observed. On the basis of our results, we propose that ThT binds in cavities running parallel to the fibril axis, e.g., between the protofilaments forming the fibrils. Such cavities have been proposed previously in insulin fibrils and several other amyloid fibril models.     

Interactions between amyloidophilic dyes and their relevance to studies of amyloid inhibitors

Amyloid fibrils are filamentous aggregates of peptides and proteins implicated in a range of neurodegenerative disorders such as Alzheimer's and Parkinson's diseases. It has been known almost since their discovery that these β-sheet-rich proteinacious assemblies bind a range of specific dyes that, combined with other biophysical techniques, are convenient probes of the process of amyloid fibril formation. Two prominent examples of such dyes are Congo red (CR) and Thioflavin T (ThT). It has been reported that in addition to having a diagnostic role, CR is an inhibitor of the formation of amyloid structures, and these two properties have both been explained in terms of the same specific noncovalent interactions between the fibrils and the dye molecules. In this article, we show by means of quartz-crystal microbalance measurements that the binding of both ThT and CR to amyloid fibrils formed by the peptide whose aggregation is associated with Alzheimer's disease, Aβ(1-42), can be directly observed, and that the presence of CR interferes with the binding of ThT. Light scattering and fluorescence measurements confirm that an interaction exists between these dyes that can interfere with their ability to reflect accurately the quantity of amyloid material present in a given sample. Furthermore, we show that CR does not inhibit the process of amyloid fibril elongation, and therefore demonstrate the ability of the quartz-crystal microbalance method not only to detect and study the binding of small molecules to amyloid fibrils, but also to elucidate the mode of action of potential inhibitors.     

Michler's hydrol blue: a sensitive probe for amyloid fibril detection

Michler's hydrol blue (MHB) is investigated with respect to photophysical properties in varied solvent environment and when bound to insulin and lysozyme fibrils. The MHB chromophore is shown to act like a molecular rotor and bind well to amyloid fibrils, where it exhibits a characteristic red-shift in its excitation spectrum and an increase in the emission quantum yield upon binding. MHB is more sensitive to environmental changes than Thioflavin T (ThT) and furthermore, in contrast to the latter amyloid probe, can differentiate between insulin and lysozyme fibrils by a more red-shifted excitation spectrum for insulin fibrils. To support the experimental observations, time-dependent density functional theory (TDDFT) calculations were performed on MHB at several levels of theory. The predicted changes of spectral properties as a function of the environment are in good agreement with the experimental results. Linear dichroism (LD) is used to determine the orientation of the MHB within the fibrils. It was shown through LD and molecular modeling that MHB aligns itself preferentially parallel with the amyloid fiber at an angle of 14°-22° to the fibril axis and along the grooves of the β-sheet.     

On the binding of Thioflavin-T to HET-s amyloid fibrils assembled at pH 2

Amyloid fibrils are ordered β-sheet protein or peptide polymers. The benzothiazole dye Thioflavin-T (ThT) shows a strong increase in fluorescence upon binding to amyloid fibrils and has hence become the most commonly used amyloid-specific dye. In spite of this widespread use, the mechanism underlying specific binding and fluorescence enhancement upon interaction with amyloid fibrils remains largely unknown. Recent contradictory reports have proposed radically different modes of binding. We have studied the interaction of ThT with fibrils of the prion forming domain of the fungal HET-s prion protein assembled at pH 2 in order to try to gain some insight into the general mechanism of ThT-binding and fluorescence. We found that ThT does not bind to HET-s(218–289) fibrils as a micelle as previously proposed in the case of insulin fibrils. We have measured binding kinetics, affinity and stoichiometry at pH values above and below the pI of the HET-s(218–289) fibrils and found that binding is dramatically affected by pH and ionic strength. Binding is poor at acidic pH, presumably as a result of repulsive electrostatic interaction between the positively charged ThT molecule and the fibril surface. Finally, we found that ThT acquires chiral properties when it is fibril-bound. These results are discussed in relation to the different ThT-binding modes that have been proposed.     

Interaction of Thioflavin T with amyloid fibrils of apolipoprotein A-I N-terminal fragment: Resonance energy transfer study

Apolipoprotein A-I is amenable to a number of specific mutations associated with hereditary systemic amyloidoses. Amyloidogenic properties of apoA-I are determined mainly by its N-terminal fragment. In the present study Förster resonance energy transfer between tryptophan as a donor and Thioflavin T as an acceptor was employed to obtain structural information on the amyloid fibrils formed by apoA-I variant 1-83/G26R/W@8. Analysis of the dye-fibril binding data provided evidence for the presence of two types of ThT binding sites with similar stoichiometries (bound dye to monomeric protein molar ratio ∼10), but different association constants (∼6 and 0.1 μM⁻¹) and ThT quantum yields in fibril-associated state (0.08 and 0.05, respectively). A β-strand–loop–β-strand structural model of 1-83/G26R/W@8 apoA-I fibrils has been proposed, with potential ThT binding sites located in the solvent-exposed grooves of the N-terminal β-sheet layer. Reasoning from the expanded FRET analysis allowing for heterogeneity of ThT binding centers and fibril polymorphism, the most probable locations of high- and low-affinity ThT binding sites were attributed to the grooves T16_Y18 and D20_L22, respectively.     

Effect of amino acid variations in the central region of human serum amyloid A on the amyloidogenic properties

Human serum amyloid A (SAA) is a precursor protein of the amyloid fibrils that are responsible for AA amyloidosis. Of the four human SAA genotypes, SAA1 is most commonly associated with AA amyloidosis. Furthermore, SAA1 has three major isoforms (SAA1.1, 1.3, and 1.5) that differ by single amino acid variations at two sites in their 104-amino acid sequences. In the present study, we examined the effect of amino acid variations in human SAA1 isoforms on the amyloidogenic properties. All SAA1 isoforms adopted α-helix structures at 4 °C, but were unstructured at 37 °C. Heparin-induced amyloid fibril formation of SAA1 was observed at 37 °C, as evidenced by the increased thioflavin T (ThT) fluorescence and β-sheet structure formation. Despite a comparable increase in ThT fluorescence, SAA1 molecules retained their α-helix structures at 4 °C. At both temperatures, no essential differences in ThT fluorescence and secondary structures were observed among the SAA1 isoforms. However, the fibril morphologies appeared to differ; SAA1.1 formed long and curly fibrils, whereas SAA1.3 formed thin and straight fibrils. The peptides corresponding to the central regions of the SAA1 isoforms containing amino acid variations showed distinct amyloidogenicities, reflecting their direct effects on amyloid fibril formation. These findings may provide novel insights into the influence of amino acid variations in human SAA on the pathogenesis of AA amyloidosis.     

RNA Aptamers Generated against Oligomeric Aβ40 Recognize Common Amyloid Aptatopes with Low Specificity but High Sensitivity

Aptamers are useful molecular recognition tools in research, diagnostics, and therapy. Despite promising results in other fields, aptamer use has remained scarce in amyloid research, including Alzheimer''s disease (AD). AD is a progressive neurodegenerative disease believed to be caused by neurotoxic amyloid β-protein (Aβ) oligomers. Aβ oligomers therefore are an attractive target for development of diagnostic and therapeutic reagents. We used covalently-stabilized oligomers of the 40-residue form of Aβ (Aβ40) for aptamer selection. Despite gradually increasing the stringency of selection conditions, the selected aptamers did not recognize Aβ40 oligomers but reacted with fibrils of Aβ40, Aβ42, and several other amyloidogenic proteins. Aptamer reactivity with amyloid fibrils showed some degree of protein-sequence dependency. Significant fibril binding also was found for the naïve library and could not be eliminated by counter-selection using Aβ40 fibrils, suggesting that aptamer binding to amyloid fibrils was RNA-sequence-independent. Aptamer binding depended on fibrillogenesis and showed a lag phase. Interestingly, aptamers detected fibril formation with ≥15-fold higher sensitivity than thioflavin T (ThT), revealing substantial β-sheet and fibril formation undetected by ThT. The data suggest that under physiologic conditions, aptamers for oligomeric forms of amyloidogenic proteins cannot be selected due to high, non-specific affinity of oligonucleotides for amyloid fibrils. Nevertheless, the high sensitivity, whereby aptamers detect β-sheet formation, suggests that they can serve as superior amyloid recognition tools.     

Fibrillation of carrier protein albebetin and its biologically active constructs. Multiple oligomeric intermediates and pathways

We showed that the genetically engineered carrier-protein albebetin and its biologically active constructs with interferon-alpha(2) octapeptide LKEKKYSP or differentiation factor hexapeptide TGENHR are inherently highly amyloidogenic at physiological pH. The kinetics of fibrillation were monitored by thioflavine-T (ThT) binding and the morphological changes by atomic force microscopy. Fibrillation proceeds via multiple pathways and includes a hierarchy of amyloid structures ranging from oligomers to protofilaments and fibrils. Comparative height and volume microscopic measurements allowed us to identify two distinct types of oligomeric intermediates: pivotal oligomers ca. 1.2 nm in height comprised of 10-12 monomers and on-pathway amyloid-competent oligomers ca. 2 nm in height constituted of 26-30 molecules. The former assemble into chains and rings with "bead-on-string morphology", in which a "bead" corresponds to an individual oligomer. Once formed, the rings and chains remain in solution simultaneously with fibrils. The latter give rise to protofilaments and fibrils, and their formation is concomitant with an increasing level of ThT binding. The amyloid nature of filamentous structures was confirmed by a pronounced ThT and Congo red binding and beta-sheet-rich far-UV circular dichroism. We suggest that transformation of the pivotal oligomers into the amyloid-prone ones is a limiting stage in amyloid assembly. Peptides, either fused to albebetin or added into solution, and an increased ionic strength promote fibrillation of albebetin (net charge of -12) by counterbalancing critical electrostatic repulsions. This finding demonstrates that the fibrillation of newly designed polypeptide-based products can produce multimeric amyloid species with a potentially "new" functionality, raising questions about their safety.     

Identification of an amyloidogenic region on keratoepithelin via synthetic peptides

Mutations of keratoepithelin (KE) gene in human chromosome 5q31 have been linked with corneal epithelial or stromal dystrophies characterized by the abnormal deposits of amyloid fibrils and/or non-amyloid aggregations in corneal tissue. We report herein that synthetic peptide containing amino acid (a.a.) residues of 515-532 of native KE protein can readily form beta-sheet-containing amyloid fibrils in vitro. Amyloid fibrils formed in various conditions from short synthetic peptides (containing a.a. 515-532 and 515-525, respectively) were characterized by thioflavin T (ThT) fluorescence assay, Congo red staining, electron microscopy (EM) and circular dichroism (CD). Triple-N-methylation of the synthetic peptides prevented the beta-sheet polymerization and related amyloid fibril formation. Comparison study with ThT fluorescence further demonstrated that synthetic peptides containing corneal dystrophy-related mutations within this region formed amyloid fibrils to various extents. Our results suggest that each individual dystrophy-related mutation by itself does not necessarily potentiate amyloid fibril formation of KE. Roles of these intrinsically amyloidogenic foci in abnormal KE aggregations and amyloid deposits of stromal corneal dystrophies await further investigation.     

Flavone Derivatives as Inhibitors of Insulin Amyloid-Like Fibril Formation

Several natural and synthetic flavone derivatives have been reported to inhibit formation of amyloid fibrils or to remodel existing fibrils. These studies suggest that the numbers and positions of hydroxyl groups on the flavone rings determine their effectiveness as amyloid inhibitors. In many studies the primary method for determining the effectiveness of inhibition is measuring Thioflavin T (ThT) fluorescence. This method demonstrably results in a number of false positives for inhibition. We studied the effects of 265 commercially available flavone derivatives on insulin fibril formation. We enhanced the effectiveness of ThT fluorescence measurements by fitting kinetic curves to obtain halftime of aggregation (t ₅₀). Maximal values of ThT fluorescence varied two fold or more in one third of all cases, but this did not correlate with changes in t ₅₀. Changes in t ₅₀ values were more accurate measures of inhibition of amyloid formation. We showed that without a change in an assay, but just by observing complete kinetic curves it is possible to eliminate numbers of false positive and sometimes even false negative results. Examining the data from all 265 flavones we confirmed previous observations that identified the importance of hydroxyl groups for inhibition. Our evidence suggests the importance of hydroxyl groups at locations 5, 6, 7, and 4’, and the absence of a hydroxyl group at location 3, for inhibiting amyloid formation. However, the main conclusion is that the positions are not additive. The structures and their effects must be thought of in the context of the whole molecule.     

In vitro characterization of lactoferrin aggregation and amyloid formation

Lactoferrin has previously been identified in amyloid deposits in the cornea, seminal vesicles, and brain. We report in this paper a highly amyloidogenic region of lactoferrin (sequence of NAGDVAFV). This region was initially identified by sequence comparison with medin, a 5.5 kDa amyloidogenic fragment derived from lactadherin. Subsequent characterization revealed that this peptide forms amyloid fibrils at pH 7.4 when incubated at 37 degrees C. Furthermore, although full-length lactoferrin does not by itself form amyloid fibrils, the protein does bind to the peptide fibrils as revealed by an increase in thioflavin T fluorescence and the presence of enlarged fibrils by transmission electron microscopy and polarized light microscopy. The binding of lactoferrin is a selective interaction with the NAGDVAFV fibrils. Lactoferrin does not bind to insulin or lysozyme fibrils, and the NAGDVAFV fibrils do not bind to soluble insulin or lysozyme. The lactoferrin appears to coat the peptide fibril surface to form mixed peptide/protein fibrils, but again there is no evidence for the formation of lactoferrin-only fibrils. This interaction, therefore, seems to involve selective binding rather than conventional seeding of fibril formation. We suggest that such a process could be generally important in the formation of amyloid fibrils in vivo since the identification of both full-length protein and protein fragments is common in ex vivo amyloid deposits.     

Investigation of the kinetics of insulin amyloid fibrils formation

Today, the investigation of the structure of ordered protein aggregates-amyloid fibrils, the influence of the native structure of the protein and the external conditions on the process of fibrillation-is the subject of intense investigations. The aim of the present work is to study the kinetics of formation of insulin amyloid fibrils at low pH values (conditions that are used at many stages of the isolation and purification of the protein) using the fluorescent probe thioflavin T. It is shown that the increase of the fluorescence intensity of ThT during the formation of amyloid fibrils is described by a sigmoidal curve, in which three areas can be distinguished: the lag phase, growth, and a plateau, which characterize the various stages of fibril formation. Despite the variation in the length of the lag phase at the same experimental conditions (pH and temperature), it is seen to drop during solution stirring and seeding. Data obtained by electron microscopy showed that the formed fibrils are long, linear filaments ～20 nm in diameter. With increasing incubation time, the fibril diameter does not change, while the length increases to 2–3 μm, which is accompanied by a significant increase in the number of fibril aggregates. All the experimental data show that, irrespective of the kinetics of formation of amyloid fibrils, their properties after the completion of the fibrillation process are identical. The results of this work, together with the previous studies of insulin amyloid fibrils, may be important for clarification the mechanism of their formation, as well as for the treatment of amyloidosis associated with the aggregation of insulin.