Evaluation of alpha,beta-unsaturated ketone-based probes for papain-family cysteine proteases

The field of activity-based proteomics makes use of small molecule active site probes to monitor distinct subsets of enzymatic proteins. While a number of reactive functional groups have been applied to activity-based probes (ABPs) that target diverse families of proteases, there remains a continual need for further evaluation of new probe scaffolds and reactive functional groups for use in ABPs. In this study we evaluate the utility of the, alpha,beta-unsaturated ketone reactive group for use in ABPs targeting the papain-family of cysteine proteases. We find that this reactive group shows highly selective labeling of cysteine cathepsins in both intact cells and total cell extracts. We observed a variable degree of background labeling that depended on the type of tag and linker used in the probe synthesis. The relative ease of synthesis of this class of compounds provides the potential for further derivatization to generate new families of cysteine protease ABPs with unique specificity and labeling properties.     

Phosphatidylinositol 3,4,5-trisphosphate activity probes for the labeling and proteomic characterization of protein binding partners

Phosphatidylinositol polyphosphate lipids, such as phosphatidylinositol 3,4,5-trisphosphate [PI(3,4,5)P?], regulate critical biological processes, many of which are aberrant in disease. These lipids often act as site-specific ligands in interactions that enforce membrane association of protein binding partners. Herein, we describe the development of bifunctional activity probes corresponding to the headgroup of PI(3,4,5)P? that are effective for identifying and characterizing protein binding partners from complex samples, namely cancer cell extracts. These probes contain both a photoaffinity tag for covalent labeling of target proteins and a secondary handle for subsequent detection or manipulation of labeled proteins. Probes bearing different secondary tags were exploited, either by direct attachment of a fluorescent dye for optical detection or by using an alkyne that can be derivatized after protein labeling via click chemistry. First, we describe the design and modular synthetic strategy used to generate multiple probes with different reporter tags of use for characterizing probe-labeled proteins. Next, we report initial labeling studies using purified protein, the PH domain of Akt, in which probes were found to label this target, as judged by in-gel detection. Furthermore, protein labeling was abrogated by controls including competition with an unlabeled PI(3,4,5)P? headgroup analogue as well as through protein denaturation, indicating specific labeling. In addition, probes featuring linkers of different lengths between the PI(3,4,5)P? headgroup and photoaffinity tag led to variations in protein labeling, indicating that a shorter linker was more effective in this case. Finally, proteomic labeling studies were performed using cell extracts; labeled proteins were observed by in-gel detection and characterized using postlabeling with biotin, affinity chromatography, and identification via tandem mass spectrometry. These studies yielded a total of 265 proteins, including both known and novel candidate PI(3,4,5)P?-binding proteins.     

Comparative Assessment of Substrates and Activity Based Probes as Tools for Non-Invasive Optical Imaging of Cysteine Protease Activity

Recent advances in the field of non-invasive optical imaging have included the development of contrast agents that report on the activity of enzymatic targets associated with disease pathology. In particular, proteases have proven to be ideal targets for development of optical sensors for cancer. Recently developed contrast agents for protease activity include both small peptides and large polymer-based quenched fluorescent substrates as well as fluorescently labeled activity based probes (ABPs). While substrates produce a fluorescent signal as a result of processing by a protease, ABPs are retained at the site of proteolysis due to formation of a permanent covalent bond with the active site catalytic residue. Both methods have potential advantages and disadvantages yet a careful comparison of substrates and ABPs has not been performed. Here we present the results of a direct comparison of commercially available protease substrates with several recently described fluorescent ABPs in a mouse model of cancer. The results demonstrate that fluorescent ABPs show more rapid and selective uptake into tumors as well as overall brighter signals compared to substrate probes. These data suggest that the lack of signal amplification for an ABP is offset by the increased kinetics of tissue uptake and prolonged retention of the probes once bound to a protease target. Furthermore, fluorescent ABPs can be used as imaging reagents with similar or better results as the commercially available protease substrates.     

A highly selective Hsp90 affinity chromatography resin with a cleavable linker

Over 200 proteins have been identified that interact with the protein chaperone Hsp90, a recognized therapeutic target thought to participate in non-oncogene addiction in a variety of human cancers. However, defining Hsp90 clients is challenging because interactions between Hsp90 and its physiologically relevant targets involve low affinity binding and are thought to be transient. Using a chemo-proteomic strategy, we have developed a novel orthogonally cleavable Hsp90 affinity resin that allows purification of the native protein and is quite selective for Hsp90 over its immediate family members, GRP94 and TRAP 1. We show that the resin can be used under low stringency conditions for the rapid, unambiguous capture of native Hsp90 in complex with a native client. We also show that the choice of linker used to tether the ligand to the insoluble support can have a dramatic effect on the selectivity of the affinity media.     

A Simple and Effective Cleavable Linker for Chemical Proteomics Applications

The study of metabolically labeled or probe-modified proteins is an important area in chemical proteomics. Isolation and purification of the protein targets is a necessary step before MS identification. The biotin-streptavidin system is widely used in this process, but the harsh denaturing conditions also release natively biotinylated proteins and non-selectively bound proteins. A cleavable linker strategy is a promising approach for solving this problem. Though several cleavable linkers have been developed and tested, an efficient, easily synthesized, and inexpensive cleavable linker is a desirable addition to the proteomics toolbox. Here, we describe the chemical proteomics application of a vicinal diol cleavable linker. Through easy-to-handle chemistry we incorporate this linker into an activity-based probe and a biotin alkyne tag amenable for bioorthogonal ligation. With these reagents, background protein identifications are significantly reduced relative to standard on-bead digestion.The covalent modification of proteins by small molecules within a complex proteome is a major theme in chemical biology and proteomics. An effective method for the detection of posttranslational modifications of proteins is the metabolic incorporation of modified biomolecules such as tagged carbohydrates or lipids (1). Reversible interactions of enzyme inhibitors, natural products, or drugs can be detected when one appends photocrosslinking agents, thereby facilitating target discovery (2, 3). A particularly interesting example of protein labeling is activity-based protein profiling (ABPP)¹ (4, 5), which utilizes the intrinsic catalytic activity of a target enzyme for the covalent attachment of an affinity or visualization tag. ABPP makes use of small molecules (activity-based probes (ABPs)) that react with the active form of a specific enzyme or enzyme class by means of a “warhead,” which is often derived from a mechanism-based enzyme inhibitor (Fig. 1A). DCG-04, for example, is based on the naturally occurring inhibitor E-64 and targets the papain family of cysteine proteases via covalent attachment of the epoxysuccinate group to the active site cysteine (Fig. 1B) (6).Open in a separate windowFig. 1.The cleavable linker strategy in ABPP. A, the elements of an ABP. B, the example ABP DCG-04, an epoxysuccinate-containing probe for clan CA cysteine proteases. DCG-04 is based on the naturally occurring protease inhibitor E-64. C, schematic strategy of cleavable linker-mediated target identification. D, the cleavage mechanism of a vicinal diol.Bulky fluorophore or biotin tags on chemical probes might interfere with efficient protein binding. Moreover, they can negatively influence the cell permeability of probes, which therefore limits their applicability in in vitro experiments. Bioorthogonal chemistries, such as the Bertozzi-Staudinger ligation (7) and the 1,3-bipolar cycloaddition of an azide and an alkyne (click chemistry) (8), allow tandem labeling strategies in which a biotin or a fluorophore is attached to an enzyme probe complex in a separate step. Consequently, the probes themselves only carry azide or alkyne groups as “mini-tags.” Tandem labeling using bioorthogonal chemistry has now become a widely used strategy to label biomolecules in lysates and in live cells (9–11).An essential step in ABPP, as well as in other chemical proteomics approaches, is the elucidation of the tagged proteins. This usually involves a biotin-mediated enrichment step followed by mass-spectrometry-based identification. Although the streptavidin-biotin interaction allows efficient enrichment as a result of the strong binding affinity (K_d ∼ 10⁻¹⁵ m), it also has limitations. The quantitative elution of biotinylated proteins requires harsh conditions (12), which lead to contamination of the sample by endogenous biotinylated and non-specifically bound proteins. These other proteins will be identified together with the real protein targets. Given that subsequent target validation with secondary assays can be a costly and time-consuming process, a reduction in false positive identifications is highly desirable. For cleaner protein identification, cleavable linker strategies (13) that allow the selective release of target proteins have been developed (Fig. 1C). The commercially available disulfide linker can be cleaved under mild conditions, but it suffers from premature cleavage in reducing media such as the intracellular environment and reducing buffers used for click chemistry and in vitro reactions of cysteine proteases. Therefore, a variety of alternative linkers for proteomics applications have been reported, including a sterically hindered disulfide (14), diazobenzenes (15–19), hydrazones (20, 21), silanes (22), light sensitive linkers (23–25), tobacco etch virus protease sensitive linkers (26, 27), and a levulinoyl-based linker (28). The synthesis of some of these linkers is lengthy or difficult to scale up, which limits their general application in chemical proteomics.Ideally, a cleavable linker is stable under a wide variety of conditions, is efficiently and selectively cleaved, and can be synthesized in a low number of easy chemical transformations. We aimed to meet these requirements by using a vicinal diol as a cleavable linker system. When vicinal diols are treated with sodium periodate (NaIO₄), the carbon–carbon bond is cleaved (Fig. 1D). Periodate treatment of proteins can result in side-reactions, such as the cleavage of linked carbohydrates or the oxidation of N-terminal serine and threonine residues. However, these N-termini rarely occur in proteins and are therefore of minor concern. In general, the mild, neutral conditions of periodate cleavage are compatible with proteins. This has been illustrated in the past, for example, by its application in the detection of protein–protein interactions (29) and the creation of unliganded MHC class I molecules (30). In this article, we report the chemical proteomics application of diol cleavable linker probes. We show that the synthesis of the linker and its probe derivatives is straightforward, that the linker is compatible with tandem click labeling, that enrichment and release of probe targets is efficient, and that the identification of targets takes place with significantly lower background than in on-bead digestion protocols.     

Tagging and detection strategies for activity-based proteomics

The field of activity-based proteomics is a relatively new discipline that makes use of small molecules, termed activity-based probes (ABPs), to tag and monitor distinct sets of proteins within a complex proteome. These activity-dependant labels facilitate analysis of systems-wide changes at the level of enzyme activity rather than simple protein abundance. While the use of small molecule inhibitors to label enzyme targets is not a new concept, the past ten years have seen a rapid expansion in the diversity of probe families that have been developed. In addition to increasing the number and types of enzymes that can be targeted by this method, there has also been an increase in the number of methods used to visualize probes once they are bound to target enzymes. In particular, the use of small organic fluorophores has created a wealth of applications for ABPs that range from biochemical profiling of diverse proteomes to direct imaging of active enzymes in live cells and even whole animals. In addition, the advent of new bioorthogonal coupling chemistries now enables a diverse array of tags to be added after targets are labeled with an ABP. This strategy has opened the door to new in vivo applications for activity-based proteomic methods.     

Expression of atrial natriuretic factor as a cleavable fusion protein with chloramphenicol acetyltransferase in Escherichia coli

Recombinant fusion proteins containing human atrial natriuretic factor, ANF(1-28) joined to chloramphenicol acetyltransferase (CAT) via cleavable linker sequences have been produced in Escherichia coli. The linker sequences were designed to allow the release of authentic ANF(1-28) following proteolytic cleavage by enterokinase or thrombin, or chemical cleavage with 2-(2-nitrophenylsulphenyl)-3-methyl-3'-bromoindolenine. Proteins, containing ANF(1-28) fused to the carboxyl-terminal region of CAT (using the ScaI restriction site in the cat gene), were largely soluble in E. coli and were obtained in higher yield than analogues containing ANF(1-28) linked to shorter CAT sequences. The longer derivatives also retained CAT activity allowing subsequent purification by affinity chromatography.     

Alkyne derivatives of isocoumarins as clickable activity-based probes for serine proteases

Activity-based probes (ABPs) have found increasing use in functional proteomics studies. Recently, ABPs that can be employed in combination with click chemistry gained particular attention due to their flexible application in vitro and in vivo. Moreover, there is a continuous need for new ABPs that target small subsets of enzymes. We here report novel clickable ABPs based on the 4-chloro-isocoumarin (IC) electrophile, a mechanism-based inhibitor scaffold that covalently binds serine proteases. We describe the synthesis of a small library of IC ABPs containing an alkyne function and a set of diverse selectivity elements. The different substituents on the IC structure determine which proteases are bound, showing good correlation with the preferred substrate preferences. The IC ABPs can detect their target proteases in a proteome background in a sensitive manner (down to 0.007% of total protein). Furthermore, we show activity-dependent and selective labeling of endogenous proteases in a tissue proteome. These ICs therefore represent a valuable extension to already existing ABPs for serine proteases and may be instrumental in future elucidation of serine protease functions.     

Analyses of linker histone--chromatin interactions in situ.

Recent studies, using cytometric techniques based on fluorescence microscopy, have provided new information on how linker histones interact with chromatin in vivo or in situ. In particular, the use of green fluorescent proteins (GFPs) has enabled detailed studies of how individual H1 subtypes, and specific motifs in them, interact with chromatin in vivo. Furthermore, the development of cytochemical methods to study the interaction between linker histones and chromatin using DNA-binding fluorochromes as indirect probes for linker histone affinity in situ, in combination with highly sensitive and specific analytical methods, has provided additional information on the interactions between linker histones and chromatin in several cell systems. Such results verified that linker histones have a substantially higher affinity for chromatin in mature chicken erythrocytes than in frog erythrocytes, and they also indicated that the affinity decreased during differentiation of the frog erythrocytes. Furthermore, in cultured human fibroblasts, the linker histones showed a relatively high affinity for chromatin in interphase, whereas it showed a significantly lower affinity in highly condensed metaphase chromosomes. This method also enables the analysis of linker histone affinity for chromatin in H1-depleted fibroblasts reconstituted with purified linker histones. No consistent correlation between linker histone affinity and chromatin condensation has so far been detected.     

Development of bestatin-based activity-based probes for metallo-aminopeptidases

A novel set of activity-based probes (ABPs) for functionally profiling metallo-aminopeptidases was synthesized based on the bestatin inhibitor scaffold, the first synthesis of bestatin analogues using solid-phase techniques. These ABPs were shown to label metallo-aminopeptidases, using both a biotin and a fluorophore reporter, in an activity-dependent manner. This probe class was also shown to be amenable to 'click' chemistry labeling for possible use in live cells. Finally, we demonstrate that the ABPs are able to label an aminopeptidase in a complex proteome. Thus, these bestatin-based probes should have wide utility to functionally profile aminopeptidases in many biological systems.     

Use of Activity-Based Probes to Develop High Throughput Screening Assays That Can Be Performed in Complex Cell Extracts

Background

High throughput screening (HTS) is one of the primary tools used to identify novel enzyme inhibitors. However, its applicability is generally restricted to targets that can either be expressed recombinantly or purified in large quantities.

Methodology and Principal Findings

Here, we described a method to use activity-based probes (ABPs) to identify substrates that are sufficiently selective to allow HTS in complex biological samples. Because ABPs label their target enzymes through the formation of a permanent covalent bond, we can correlate labeling of target enzymes in a complex mixture with inhibition of turnover of a substrate in that same mixture. Thus, substrate specificity can be determined and substrates with sufficiently high selectivity for HTS can be identified. In this study, we demonstrate this method by using an ABP for dipeptidyl aminopeptidases to identify (Pro-Arg)₂-Rhodamine as a specific substrate for DPAP1 in Plasmodium falciparum lysates and Cathepsin C in rat liver extracts. We then used this substrate to develop highly sensitive HTS assays (Z’>0.8) that are suitable for use in screening large collections of small molecules (i.e >300,000) for inhibitors of these proteases. Finally, we demonstrate that it is possible to use broad-spectrum ABPs to identify target-specific substrates.

Conclusions

We believe that this approach will have value for many enzymatic systems where access to large amounts of active enzyme is problematic.     

Ligand association rates to the inner-variable-domain of a dual-variable-domain immunoglobulin are significantly impacted by linker design

The DVD-Ig^TM protein is a dual-specific immunoglobulin. Each of the two arms of the molecule contains two variable domains, an inner variable domain and an outer variable domain linked in tandem, each with binding specificity for different targets or epitopes. One area of on-going research involves determining how the proximity of the outer variable domain affects the binding of ligands to the inner variable domain. To explore this area, we prepared a series of DVD-Ig proteins with binding specificities toward TNFα and an alternate therapeutic target. Kinetic measurements of TNFα binding to this series of DVD-Ig proteins were used to probe the effects of variable domain position and linker design on ligand on- and off-rates. We found that affinities for TNFα are generally lower when binding to the inner domain than to the outer domain and that this loss of affinity is primarily due to reduced association rate. This effect could be mitigated, to some degree, by linker design. We show several linker sequences that mitigate inner domain affinity losses in this series of DVD-Ig proteins. Moreover, we show that single chain proteolytic cleavage between the inner and outer domains, or complete outer domain removal, can largely restore inner domain TNFα affinity to that approaching the reference antibody. Taken together, these results suggest that a loss of affinity for inner variable domains in this set of DVD-Ig proteins may be largely driven by simple steric hindrance effects and can be reduced by careful linker design.     

Activity-based protein profiling in bacteria: Applications for identification of therapeutic targets and characterization of microbial communities

Activity-based protein profiling (ABPP) is a robust chemoproteomic technique that uses activity-based probes to globally measure endogenous enzymatic activity in complex proteomes. It has been utilized extensively to characterize human disease states and identify druggable targets in diverse disease conditions. ABPP has also recently found applications in microbiology. This includes using activity-based probes (ABPs) for functional studies of pathogenic bacteria as well as complex communities within a microbiome. This review will focus on recent advances in the use of ABPs to profile enzyme activity in disease models, screen for selective inhibitors of key enzymes, and develop imaging tools to better understand the host–bacterial interface.     

A photo-cleavable biotin affinity tag for the facile release of a photo-crosslinked carbohydrate-binding protein

The use of photo-crosslinking glycoprobes represents a powerful strategy for the covalent capture of labile protein complexes and allows detailed characterization of carbohydrate-mediated interactions. The selective release of target proteins from solid support is a key step in functional proteomics. We envisaged that light activation can be exploited for releasing labeled protein in a dual photo-affinity probe-based strategy. To investigate this possibility, we designed a trifunctional, galactose-based, multivalent glycoprobe for affinity labeling of carbohydrate-binding proteins. The resulting covalent protein–probe adduct is attached to a photo-cleavable biotin affinity tag; the biotin moiety enables specific presentation of the conjugate on streptavidin-coated beads, and the photolabile linker allows the release of the labeled proteins. This dual probe promotes both the labeling and the facile cleavage of the target protein complexes from the solid surfaces and the remainder of the cell lysate in a completely unaltered form, thus eliminating many of the common pitfalls associated with traditional affinity-based purification methods.     

Balance between DNA‐binding affinity and specificity enables selective recognition of longer target sequences in vivo

Although genome‐editing enzymes such as TALEN and CRISPR/Cas9 are being widely used, they have an essential limitation in that their relatively high‐molecular weight makes them difficult to be delivered to cells. To develop a novel genome‐editing enzyme with a smaller molecular weight, we focused on the engrailed homeodomain (EHD). We designed and constructed proteins composed of two EHDs connected by a linker to increase sequence specificity. In bacterial one‐hybrid assays and electrophoresis mobility shift assay analyses, the created proteins exhibited good affinity for DNA sequences consisting of two tandemly aligned EHD target sequences. However, they also bound to individual EHD targets. To avoid binding to single target sites, we introduced amino acid mutations to reduce the protein–DNA affinity of each EHD monomer and successfully created a small protein with high specificity for tandem EHD target sequences.     

Ligand association rates to the inner-variable-domain of a dual-variable-domain immunoglobulin are significantly impacted by linker design

The DVD-Ig™ protein is a dual-specific immunoglobulin. Each of the two arms of the molecule contains two variable domains, an inner variable domain and an outer variable domain linked in tandem, each with binding specificity for different targets or epitopes. One area of on-going research involves determining how the proximity of the outer variable domain affects the binding of ligands to the inner variable domain. To explore this area, we prepared a series of DVD-Ig proteins with binding specificities toward TNFα and an alternate therapeutic target. Kinetic measurements of TNFα binding to this series of DVD-Ig proteins were used to probe the effects of variable domain position and linker design on ligand on- and off-rates. We found that affinities for TNFα are generally lower when binding to the inner domain than to the outer domain and that this loss of affinity is primarily due to reduced association rate. This effect could be mitigated, to some degree, by linker design. We show several linker sequences that mitigate inner domain affinity losses in this series of DVD-Ig proteins. Moreover, we show that single chain proteolytic cleavage between the inner and outer domains, or complete outer domain removal, can largely restore inner domain TNFα affinity to that approaching the reference antibody. Taken together, these results suggest that a loss of affinity for inner variable domains in this set of DVD-Ig proteins may be largely driven by simple steric hindrance effects and can be reduced by careful linker design.Key words: dual variable domain immunoglobulin, DVD-Ig, immunotherapy, variable domain, antibody engineering, dual-specific, linker     

An immuno-chemo-proteomics method for drug target deconvolution

Chemical proteomics is an emerging technique for drug target deconvolution and profiling the toxicity of known drugs. With the use of this technique, the specificity of a small molecule inhibitor toward its potential targets can be characterized and information thus obtained can be used in optimizing lead compounds. Most commonly, small molecules are immobilized on solid supports and used as affinity chromatography resins to bind targets. However, it is difficult to evaluate the effect of immobilization on the affinity of the compounds to their targets. Here, we describe the development and application of a soluble probe where a small molecule was coupled with a peptide epitope which was used to affinity isolate binding proteins from cell lysate. The soluble probe allowed direct verification that the compound after coupling with peptide epitope retained its binding characteristics. The PKC-alpha inhibitor Bisindolylmaleimide-III was coupled with a peptide containing the FLAG epitope. Following incubation with cellular lysates, the compound and associated proteins were affinity isolated using anti-FLAG antibody beads. Using this approach, we identified the known Bisindolylmaleimide-III targets, PKC-alpha, GSK3-beta, CaMKII, adenosine kinase, CDK2, and quinine reductase type 2, as well as previously unidentified targets PKAC-alpha, prohibitin, VDAC and heme binding proteins. This method was directly compared to the solid-phase method (small molecule was immobilized to a solid support) providing an orthogonal strategy to aid in target deconvolution and help to eliminate false positives originating from nonspecific binding of the proteins to the matrix.