Identification of a novel tumor-specific CTL epitope presented by RMA, EL-4, and MBL-2 lymphomas reveals their common origin

C57BL/6 mice generate a vigorous H-2Db-restricted CTL response against murine leukemia virus (MuLV)-induced tumors. For many years it has been suggested that this response is directed to an MuLV-encoded peptide as well as to a nonviral tumor-associated peptide. Recently, a peptide from the leader sequence of gag was demonstrated to be the MuLV-derived epitope. Here we describe the molecular identification of the tumor-associated epitope. Furthermore, we show that the CTL response against this epitope can restrict the outgrowth of MuLV-induced tumors in vivo. The epitope is selectively presented by the MuLV-induced T cell tumors RBL-5, RMA, and MBL-2 as well as by the chemically induced T cell lymphoma EL-4. Intriguingly, these tumors share expression of the newly identified epitope because they represent variants of the same clonal tumor cell line, as evident from sequencing of the TCR alpha- and beta-chains, which proved to be identical. Our research shows that all sources of RBL-5, RMA, RMA-S, MBL-2, and EL-4 tumors are derived from a single tumor line, most likely EL-4.     

Hierarchal Utilization of Different T-Cell Receptor Vβ Gene Segments in the CD8+-T-Cell Response to an Immunodominant Moloney Leukemia Virus-Encoded Epitope In Vivo

The CD8(+)-T-cell response to Moloney murine leukemia virus (M-MuLV)-associated antigens in C57BL/6 mice is directed against an immunodominant gag-encoded epitope (CCLCLTVFL) presented in the context of H-2D(b) and is restricted primarily to cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) expressing the Valpha3.2 and Vbeta5.2 gene segments. We decided to examine the M-MuLV response in congenic C57BL/6 Vbeta(a) mice which are unable to express the dominant Valpha3.2(+) Vbeta5.2(+) T-cell receptor (TCR) due to a large deletion at the TCR locus that includes the Vbeta5.2 gene segment. Interestingly, M-MuLV-immune C57BL/6 Vbeta(a) mice were still able to reject M-MuLV-infected tumor cells and direct ex vivo analysis of peripheral blood lymphocytes from these immune mice revealed a dramatic increase in CD8(+) cells utilizing the same Valpha3.2 gene segment in association with two different Vbeta segments (Vbeta3 and Vbeta17). Surprisingly, all these CTL recognized the same immunodominant M-MuLV gag epitope. Analysis of the TCR repertoire of individual M-MuLV-immune (C57BL/6 x C57BL/6 Vbeta(a))F(1) mice revealed a clear hierarchy in Vbeta utilization, with a preferential usage of the Vbeta17 gene segment, whereas Vbeta3 and especially Vbeta5.2 were used to much lesser extents. Sequencing of TCRalpha- and -beta-chain junctional regions of CTL clones specific for the M-MuLV gag epitope revealed a diverse repertoire of TCRbeta chains in Vbeta(a) mice and a highly restricted TCRbeta-chain repertoire in Vbeta(b) mice, whereas TCRalpha-chain sequences were highly conserved in both cases. Collectively, our data indicate that the H-2D(b)-restricted M-MuLV gag epitope can be recognized in a hierarchal fashion by different Vbeta domains and that the degree of beta-chain diversity varies according to Vbeta utilization.     

Immune response to Moloney murine leukemia virus nonviral, tumor-associated antigens fails to provide in vivo tumor protection.

Two distinct populations of CTL have previously been shown to be generated in lymphocyte cultures derived from the spleens of C57BL/6 mice that have rejected Moloney murine leukemia virus:Moloney sarcoma virus (MoMuLV:MSV)-induced tumors. One population is specific for MoMuLV viral Ag whereas the other appears to be directed against a nonviral, tumor-associated Ag (TAA). Using a virus-negative variant of the MoMuLV-induced lymphoma MBL-2 that has retained the expression of the MuLV:TAA, we attempted to further characterize the MuLV:TAA-specific CTL population. First, this same pattern of CTL reactivity was observed using a variety of immunization protocols indicating that the TAA-specific CTL population was not an artifact of the original immunization protocol but was a reproducible component of the MoMuLV CTL response. Moreover, CTL precursor frequency analysis indicates that the MuLV:TAA-specific CTL represent approximately 60% of the CTL detected in in vitro cytotoxicity assays. However, when the role of MuLV:TAA CTL in the in vivo rejection of MoMuLV-induced tumors was examined, no role for the MuLV:TAA-specific CTL response could be determined. Immunization protocols that had been shown to give rise to both CTL populations were capable of protecting mice from tumor development after a challenge with the parental MBL-2 tumor cell line but not the virus-negative variant MBLv cell line. In addition, immunization with the variant, shown to give rise to only MuLV:TAA-specific CTL capable of lysing both MBL-2 and MBLv in vitro, failed to protect mice from a tumor challenge of either cell type.     

A single retroviral gag precursor signal peptide recognized by FBL-3 tumor-specific cytotoxic T lymphocytes.

Several dominant T-cell receptors of cytotoxic T-lymphocyte (CTL) clones specific for FBL-3 tumor antigen were clonally amplified in mixed lymphocyte tumor cell cultures derived from an individual immune mouse. Every CTL clone analyzed had a common specificity for a single epitope in the precursor to cell membrane-associated nonstructural gag-encoded protein, Pr75gag, which can be minimally identified by nine amino acid residues, SIVLCCLCL. This epitope is located within the hydrophobic signal sequence motif that mediates translocation of the protein into the endoplasmic reticulum. These novel observations suggest that expression of Pr75gag in FBL-3 tumor cells led to the amplification of CTLs which recognize the signal sequence of the nonstructural gag-encoded glycoprotein precursor.     

Further studies on the glycosylated gag gene products of Rauscher murine leukemia virus: identification of an N-terminal 45,000-dalton cleavage product

A glycosylated 45,000-Mr protein containing Rauscher murine leukemia virus p15 and p12 antigenic sites and tryptic peptides was identified in Rauscher murine leukemia virus-infected cells. This glycoprotein, termed gP45gag, was also shown to contain a single tryptic peptide also present in gPr80gag and its unglycosylated apoprotein precursor Pr75gag, but lacking in Pr65gag or Pr40gag. The presence of this peptide only in viral precursor proteins containing the so-called leader (L) sequence strongly suggests that gPr45gag is an N-terminal fragment of larger glycosylated gag polyproteins, composed of L sequences in addition to p15 and p12. The kinetics of appearance of radiolabeled gPr45gag and its disappearance during chase-incubation is suggestive of a precursor-like role for this intermediate gene product. An observed 27,000-Mr glycosylated polypeptide, termed gP27gag and containing p15 but not p12, p30, or p10 antigenic determinants, is a candidate cleavage product derived from gPr45gag. These observations suggest that gPr45gag and its putative cleavage product gP27gag represent an authentic pathway for intracellular processing of glycosylated core proteins.     

Identification of a viral antigen recognized by H-2-restricted cytolytic T lymphocytes on a murine leukemia virus-induced tumor

Monoclonal antibodies were produced against protein p30, a structural protein of murine leukemia viruses (MuLV) coded by the gag gene of MuLV. Three monoclonal antibodies of different isotypes (i.e., IgG-1, IgG-2a, and IgG-2b) were chosen for extensive analysis. These three antibodies bound to mouse tumor cells induced by Friend, Moloney, Rauscher, and Gross MuLV, but not to noninfected normal mouse spleen cells. The ability of these monoclonal antibodies to inhibit cytolytic T lymphocyte (CTL) activity by masking the antigens recognized by CTL on the target cell surface was studied in various CTL systems. It was found that the only CTL that were consistently inhibited in their lytic activity came from BALB.B (H-2b) mice immunized against syngeneic Gross MuLV-induced B.GV cells. These results thus showed that a subpopulation of BALB.B anti-Gross MuLV CTL recognized a Gross MuLV gag gene product expressed on the surface of B.GV cells.     

Cell-mediated immunity to Friend virus-induced leukemia. III. Characteristics of secondary cell-mediated cytotoxic response.

By employing the 125IUdR release cytotoxicity assay, we have been able to measure the primary and secondary cell-mediated cytotoxic response of C57BL/6 mice to FBL-3 cells, a syngeneic Friend virus-induced leukemia. It was found that the secondary cell-mediated cytotoxic response occurred more rapidly after challenge (within 3 days) than the primary response, and the levels of reactivity were considerably higher. As in the primary response, the secondary cytotoxic reactivity of spleen cells was T cell dependent, being eliminated by pretreatment with anti-theta antibody plus complement. However, the secondary reactivity of pertioneal exudate (PE) cells was not entirely T-cell dependent. The specificity of the secondary cytotoxic response was analyzed by primary or secondary immunization with various tumor cells and by testing of cytotoxic lymphocytes against a variety of target cells. When spleen cells were used for testing, only tumor cells induced by Friend, Moloney, or Rauscher (FMR) leukemia viruses could produce secondary cell-mediated cytotoxic responses against FBL-3 cells. This correlated well with the specificity observed in the in vivo tumor transplantation protection studies. Similarly, spleen cells immune to FBL-3 had appreciable cytotoxicity against tumor cells induced by FMR viruses. The FBL-3 immune mice also gave significant protection against the challenge of FMR leukemias. When PE cells were used for testing, they gave higher levels of cytotoxicity against tumor cells induced by FMR viruses, but also gave less, but appreciable, cytotoxicity against non-FMR tumors. The latter reactivity might be related to the antigens induced by the murine endogenous type C viruses.     

Dissecting the Immune Response to Moloney Murine Sarcoma/Leukemia Virus-Induced Tumors by Means of a DNA Vaccination Approach

The intramuscular inoculation of Moloney murine sarcoma/leukemia (M-MSV/M-MuLV) retroviral complex gives rise to sarcomas that undergo spontaneous regression due to the induction of a strong immune reaction mediated primarily by cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL). We used a DNA-based vaccination approach to dissect the CTL response against the Gag and Env proteins of M-MSV/M-MuLV in C57BL/6 (B6) mice and to evaluate whether plasmid DNA-immunized mice would be protected against a subsequent challenge with syngeneic tumor cells expressing the viral antigens. Intramuscular DNA vaccination induced CTL against both Gag and Env proteins. A detailed analysis of epitopes recognized by CTL generated in mice inoculated with the whole virus and with the Gag-expressing plasmid confirmed the presence of an immunodominant peptide in the leader sequence of Gag protein (Gag_85–93, CCLCLTVFL) that is identical to that described in B6 mice immunized with Friend MuLV-induced leukemia cells. Moreover, CTL generated by immunization with the Env-encoding plasmid recognized a subdominant Env peptide (Env_189–196, SSWDFITV), originally described in the B6.CH-2^bm13 mutant strain. B6 mice immunized with the Gag-expressing plasmid were fully protected against a lethal tumor challenge with M-MuLV-transformed MBL-2 leukemia cells, while vaccination with the Env-expressing plasmid resulted in rejection of the tumor in 44% of the mice and in increased survival of an additional 17% of the animals. Taken together, these results indicate the existence of a hierarchy in the capacity of different structural viral proteins to induce a protective immune response against retrovirus-induced tumors.     

Nucleotide sequence of AKV murine leukemia virus.

AKV is an endogenous, ecotropic murine leukemia virus that serves as one of the parents of the recombinant; oncogenic mink cell focus-forming viruses that arise in preleukemic AKR mice. I report the 8,374-nucleotide-long sequence of AKV, as determined from the infectious molecular clone AKR-623. The 5'-leader sequence of AKV extends to nucleotide 639, after which lies a long open reading frame encoding the gag and pol gene products. The reading frame is interrupted by a single amber codon separating the gag and pol genes. The pol gene overlaps the env gene within the 3' region of the AKV genome. The nucleotide sequence of the 5' region of AKV reveals the following features. (i) The 5'-leader sequence lacks any AUG codon to initiate translation of gPr80gag, suggesting that gPr80gag is not required for the replication of AKV. (ii) A short portion of the leader region diverges in sequence from the closely related Moloney murine leukemia virus and appears to be related to a sequence highly repeated in eucaryotic genomes. (iii) As in Moloney murine leukemia virus, there is a potential RNA secondary structure flanking the amber codon that separates the gag and pol genes. This structure might function as a regulatory protein binding site that controls the relative levels of synthesis of the gag and pol precursors. The nucleotide sequence of the 3' region of AKV is compared with sequences reported previously from both infectious and noninfectious molecular clones of AKV.     

Structure of glycosylated and unglycosylated gag and gag-pol precursor proteins of Moloney murine leukemia virus

Precursor polyproteins containing translational products of the gag gene of Moloney murine leukemia virus were purified by gel electrophoresis and cleaved into large fragments by hydroxylamine, mild acid hydrolysis, or cyanogen bromide. The hydroxylamine cleavage method (specific for asparagine-glycine bonds) was adapted especially for this study. The electrophoretic mobility and antigenicity of the fragments and, in some cases, the presence or absence of [35S]methionine revealed detailed information on the structure of Pr65gag, gPr80gag, and Pr75gag (the unglycosylated variant of gPr80gag formed in vivo in the presence of tunicamycin or in vitro in a reticulocyte cell-free system). When compared with Pr65gag, gPr80gag contains 7,000 daltons of additional amino acids, presumably as, or as part of, a leader sequence at or very close to its N terminus. We present evidence that this leader may have replaced part of the p15 sequence. Furthermore, gPr80gag contains three separate carbohydrate groups. One is attached to the presumed leader sequence or to the p15 domain, and two are attached to the p30 domain. Each of the Moloney murine leukemia virus gag precursor proteins Pr65gag, gPr80gag, and Pr75gag corresponds with a read-through product into the pol gene. We designated these products Pr180gag-pol, gPr200gag-pol, and Pr190gag-pol (the unglycosylated variant of gPr200gag-pol), respectively. gPr200gag-pol contains all of the extra amino acids and carbohydrate groups present in gPr80gag and at least one carbohydrate group in its pol sequences.     

Naturally occurring TAP-dependent specific T-cell tolerance for a variant of an immunodominant retroviral cytotoxic T-lymphocyte epitope

Upon immunization and restimulation with tumors induced by the endogenous AKR/Gross murine leukemia virus (MuLV), C57BL/6 mice generate vigorous H-2K(b)-restricted cytotoxic T-lymphocyte (CTL) responses to a determinant (KSPWFTTL) derived from the p15E transmembrane portion of the viral envelope glycoprotein. By contrast, the highly homologous determinant RSPWFTTL, expressed by tumor cells induced by Friend/Moloney/Rauscher (FMR) MuLV, is not immunogenic, even when presented to the immune system as vaccinia virus-encoded cytosolic or endoplasmic reticulum (ER)-targeted minigene products. Such minigene products are usually highly immunogenic since they bypass the need for cells to liberate the peptide or transport the peptide into the ER by the transporter associated with antigen processing (TAP). Using KSPWFTTL-specific CTLs that cross-react with RSPWFTTL, we previously demonstrated that presentation of RSPWFTTL from its natural viral gene product is TAP dependent. Here, we show first that C57BL/6 mice express mRNA encoding RSPWFTTL but not KSPWFTTL and second that the ER-targeted RSPWFTTL minigene product is highly immunogenic in C57BL/6 mice with a targeted deletion in TAP1. These findings provide the initial demonstration of TAP-dependent tolerance induction to a specific self peptide and demonstrate that this contributes to the differential recognition of RSPWFTTL and KSPWFTTL by C57BL/6 mice.     

Mutation in the glycosylated gag protein of murine leukemia virus results in reduced in vivo infectivity and a novel defect in viral budding or release

All gammaretroviruses, including murine leukemia viruses (MuLVs), feline leukemia viruses, and gibbon-ape leukemia virus, encode an alternate, glycosylated form of Gag polyprotein (glyco-Gag or gPr80gag) in addition to the polyprotein precursor of the viral capsid proteins (Pr65gag). gPr80gag is translated from an upstream in-frame CUG initiation codon, in contrast to the AUG codon used for Pr65gag. The role of glyco-Gag in MuLV replication has been unclear, since gPr80gag-negative Moloney MuLV (M-MuLV) mutants are replication competent in vitro and pathogenic in vivo. However, reversion to the wild type is frequently observed in vivo. In these experiments, in vivo inoculation of a gPr80gag mutant, Ab-X-M-MuLV, showed substantially lower (2 log) initial infectivity in newborn NIH Swiss mice than that of wild-type virus, and revertants to the wild type could be detected by PCR cloning and DNA sequencing as early as 15 days postinfection. Atomic force microscopy of Ab-X-M-MuLV-infected producer cells or of the PA317 amphotropic MuLV-based vector packaging line (also gPr80gag negative) revealed the presence of tube-like viral structures on the cell surface. In contrast, wild-type virus-infected cells showed the typical spherical, 145-nm particles observed previously. Expression of gPr80gag in PA317 cells converted the tube-like structures to typical spherical particles. PA317 cells expressing gPr80gag produced 5- to 10-fold more infectious vector or viral particles as well. Metabolic labeling studies indicated that this reflected enhanced virus particle release rather than increased viral protein synthesis. These results indicate that gPr80gag is important for M-MuLV replication in vivo and in vitro and that the protein may be involved in a late step in viral budding or release.     

Characterization of intracellular precursor polyproteins of Moloney murine leukemia virus.

Intracellular Moloney murine leukemia viral precursor polyproteins were compared with mature viral proteins by immunoprecipitation and tryptic peptide mapping experiments. The results were consistent with precursor roles for Pr65gag, Pr200gag-pol, Pr135pol, and gPr83env. The glycosylated gag gene product gPr85gag, although containing sequences characteristic of all four core proteins plus additional sequences not found in Pr65gag, lacked a major tyrosine-containing p30 tryptic peptide, suggesting that gPr85gag is not processed to p30.     

Structure of glycosylated and unglycosylated gag polyproteins of Rauscher murine leukemia virus: carbohydrate attachment sites.

The structural relationships among the gag polyproteins Pr65gag, Pr75gag, and gPr80gag of Rauscher murine leukemia virus were studied by endoglycosidase H digestion and formic acid cleavage. Fragments were identified by precipitation with specific antisera to constituent virion structural proteins followed by one-dimensional mapping. Endoglycosidase H reduced the size of gPr80gag to that of Pr75gag. By comparing fragments of gPr80gag and the apoprotein Pr75gag, the former was shown to contain two mannose-rich oligosaccharide units. By comparing fragments of Pr65gag and Pr75gag, the latter was shown to differ from Pr65gag at the amino terminus by the presence of a leader peptide approximately 7,000 daltons in size. The internal and carboxyl-terminal peptides of the two unglycosylated polyproteins were not detectably different. The location of the two N-linked carbohydrate chains in gPr80gag has been specified. One occurs in the carboxyl-terminal half of the polyprotein at asparagine177 of the p30 sequence and the other is found in a 23,000-dalton fragment located in the amino-terminal region of gPr80gag and containing the additional amino acid sequences not found in Pr65gag plus a substantial portion of p15.     

Genetic analysis of myeloproliferative leukemia virus, a novel acute leukemogenic replication-defective retrovirus.

The myeloproliferative leukemia virus (MPLV) is a new acute leukemogenic, nonsarcomatogenic retroviral complex that is generated during the in vivo passage of a molecularly cloned Friend ecotropic helper virus. Examination of viral RNA expression in MPLV-producing cells revealed the presence of two distinct molecular species that hybridized with a long terminal repeat or an ecotropic env-specific probe but not with a xenotropic mink cell focus-forming virus env-specific probe derived from a spleen focus-forming virus: an 8.2-kilobase species corresponding to a full-length Friend murine leukemia virus (F-MuLV) and a deleted species with a genomic size of 7.4 kilobases. This deleted virus was biologically cloned by limiting dilutions and single cell cloning in Mus dunni fibroblasts. Three nonproducer clones with normal morphologies and containing one single integrated copy of the deleted virus were superinfected with F-MuLV, Moloney murine leukemia virus, Gross murine leukemia virus, mink cell focus-forming virus (HIX), or the amphotropic 1504 murine leukemia virus. All pseudotypes caused macroscopic and microscopic abnormalities in mice that were similar to those seen in the parental stock. A comparison of the physical maps of F-MuLV and MPLV, which was deduced from the restriction enzyme digests of unintegrated proviral DNAs, indicated that the MPLV-defective genome (i) is probably derived from F-MuLV, (ii) has conserved the F-MuLV gag and pol regions, and (iii) is deleted and rearranged in the env region in a manner that is clearly distinct from that of Friend or Rauscher spleen focus-forming viruses.     

Different abilities of Friend murine leukemia virus (MuLV) and Moloney MuLV to induce promonocytic leukemia are due to determinants in both psi-gag-PR and env regions.

Moloney murine leukemia virus (M-MuLV) is capable of inducing promonocytic leukemia in 50% of adult BALB/c mice that have received peritoneal injections of pristane, but Friend MuLV strain 57 (F-MuLV) is nonleukemogenic under similar conditions. It was shown earlier that these differences could not be mapped to the U3 region of the virus long terminal repeat, indicating the probable influence of structural genes and/or R-U5 sequences. In this study, reciprocal chimeras containing exchanged structural genes and R-U5 sequences from these two closely related viruses were analyzed for differences in ability to induce disease. Results showed that two regions of F-MuLV, psi-gag-PR and env, when substituted for those of M-MuLV were dramatically disease attenuating. The 5'-most region, which is widely distributed, overlaps with the 5' end of the env intron and includes the RNA packaging region, psi, the entire gag coding region, and the viral protease coding region (PR) of pol. It was also found that reciprocal constructs having substitutions of both of these regions of M-MuLV in an F-MuLV background allowed full reestablishment of promonocytic leukemia. These leukemias were positive for c-myb rearrangements which are characteristic of M-MuLV-induced promonocytic leukemias. Neither region alone, however, was sufficient to produce disease with a greater incidence than 13%. Further studies demonstrated that the inability of viruses with psi, gag, PR, or env sequences from F-MuLV to induce leukemia in this model system was not due to their inability to replicate in hematopoietic tissue, to integrate into the c-myb locus early on after infection in vivo, or to express gag-myb mRNA characteristic of M-MuLV-induced preleukemic cells and acute leukemia.     

The nonstructural component of the Abelson murine leukemia virus polyprotein P120 is encoded by newly acquired genetic sequences.

The Abelson leukemia virus (AbLV) polyprotein P120 is compared to translational products representing the entire Moloney murine leukemia virus (MuLV) genome on the basis of [35S]methionine tryptic peptide composition. Three methionine-containing tryptic peptides present in Moloney Pr65gag are each shown to be present in both Pr75gag and in Pr180gag-pol. Of these, one peptide, corresponding to Moloney MuLV p12, but neither of two p30-specific peptides are present in AbLV P120. Among the 12 remaining methionine-containing peptides present in AbLV P120, many, if not all, are unique to AbLV P120 and not shared by either Moloney MuLV Pr180gag-pol or Pr82gag.     

Immune response of the mouse to the major core protein (p30) of ecotropic leukemia viruses.

Sera from normal C57BL/6 mice contained low titers of antibodies against proteins of MuLV. Sera from C57BL/6 mice that were immunized with allogeneic leukemia cells sometimes contained high-titered antibodies against the p15 protein of MuLV; these antibodies detected group-specific antigenic determinants of the p15 protein, since reactions were observed with the p15 proteins of both AKR and Moloney viruses. In contrast, antisera prepared in C57BL/6 mice against the AKR leukemia K36 reacted strongly with the p30 protein of MuLV, as well as with p15. Antibodies in the C57BL/6 anti-AKR K36 sera detected group-specific antigenic determinants of the p30 protein; reactions were observed with the C57BL/6 anti-AKR K36 serum and the p30 proteins of both AKR and Moloney viruses. It was concluded that mice do have the capacity to respond immunologically to antigenic determinants of the MuLV p30 protein, although in most circumstances this is not observed.     

Cell-mediated immunity to friend virus-induced leukemia. IV. In vitro generation of primary and secondary cell-mediated cytotoxic responses.

Primary and secondary cell-mediated cytotoxic responses to FBL-3 cells, a syngeneic Friend virus-induced leukemia in C57BL/6 mice, could be generated by in vitro techniques as tested by the 125IUdR release assay. The specificity of the cytotoxic reactions appeared to be directed against the Friend type-specific antigen and the FMR (Friend, Moloney, Rauscher) antigen which were also the major antigens for transplantation immunity to FBL-3. In comparison to the primary cytotoxic response, the secondary cytotoxic response was accelerated (detected at an earlier time after sensitization), enhanced (gave much higher levels of cytotoxicity), was also longer lasting, and could be induced by a wide dose range of tumor cells. The secondary response could only be induced with lymphocytes obtained from regressors that were resistant to FBL-3 challenge; lymphocytes from mice with progressive tumor growth had no detectable secondary response. It was found that both induction phase and the effector phase of cytotoxic responses were T cell dependent. The characteristics of these reactions were thus very similar to those obtained with in vivo immunization or challenge, providing a good correlation with in vivo tumor immunity.