The Florey lecture, 1986. The regulatory biology of antibody formation

The regulatory biology of antibody formation entered a new phase of study with the development of selective theories of immunity. The discovery of the 'one cell - one antibody' dogma and the demonstration that only a small minority of B cells possessed receptors specific for a given antigen were consistent with Burnet's clonal selection hypothesis, which was later formally proven by preparing antigen-specific lymphocytes and inducing clonal activation in vitro. Clonal analysis has aided precise study of immunoregulation for both B and T lymphocytes. Clonal activation of B cells in the absence of T cells is now possible with high cloning efficiency. It requires the combined action of certain antigens and growth factors, collectively termed B-cell stimulatory factors (BSFS). Single cell analysis has shown that most BSFS so far tested, in contrast to most claims in the literature, possess the capacity (in synergy with antigen) to: stimulate B cells out of the G0 phase into active cell cycle; promote sequential mitotic divisions; and induce differentiation to active secretory status. This is clearly true for IL-1, IL-2, and BSF-p2. These multiple actions resemble those of the colony-stimulating factors in haemopoiesis. Regulation of antibody production by T lymphocytes can also be profitably analysed in clonal systems. The immunoregulatory problem of tolerance can also be analysed by means of clonal techniques. Studies are summarized which indicate that T-cell-mediated suppression and functional silencing of toleragen-specific lymphocytes are both cooperatively involved in many tolerance models. For the B lymphocyte, tolerance can be induced without an actual deletion of the cell involved; rather, the tolerant cell appears to have received and stored a negative signal, rendering it unresponsive to normally immunogenic stimuli. Thus, a state termed 'clonal anergy' has been induced within the cell. Functional clonal deletion has also been noted in several models to T-lymphocyte tolerance, but here it is not known whether clonal anergy or actual death of the relevant cell is at work. Self-tolerance sufficient to be consistent with good health need not mean a total absence of cells with any degree of self-reactivity. Indeed, it is clear that some B cells capable of forming antibody with some degree of affinity for self-constituents exist in the body, and can be activated, for example by lipopolysaccharide. The requirement is to limit the amount, affinity and duration of autoantibody production. A model suggesting how this may be achieved is presented.     

Studies on the control of antibody synthesis. XIV. Role of T cells in regulating antibody affinity.

The effect of limiting the number of helper T cells on the affinity of the primary antibody response to a T-dependent antigen (DNP-BGG) was evaluated in a cell transfer system. Lethally irradiated, thymectomized mice were reconstituted with either bone marrow or anti-brain θ antiserum plus complement-treated spleen as the source of B cells. In addition, they received various numbers of thymus cells as a source of helper T cells. The animals were immunized with DNP-BGG 1 day after cell transfer and their splenic anti-DNP PFC response was assayed for magnitude and affinity 3 weeks later. A marked restriction in helper T-cell activity resulted in a primary response which was of low magnitude, which lacked indirect PFC, and which had a very low affinity and restricted heterogeneity. When sufficient thymus cells were given to permit a switch to indirect plaque formation, a highly heterogeneous, high-affinity primary response was elicited. Further increase in the number of thymic cells resulted in a progressive increase in the magnitude of the primary response but had no effect on affinity. Thus, a reduction of 50% in the magnitude of the response as a consequence of limiting the number of T-helper cells had no effect on the affinity of the PFC. The results are consistent with the interpretation that the effect of restriction in T-cell help on antibody affinity is not due to a direct effect on precursors of high-affinity PFC but is secondary to inefficient selection for high-affinity cells when the degree of cell proliferation is markedly reduced.     

Quantitative analysis of peptides from myelin basic protein binding to the MHC class II protein,I-Au,which confers susceptibility to experimental allergic encephalomyelitis.

BACKGROUND: An important issue in autoimmune diseases mediated by T cells, such as experimental allergic encephalomyelitis (EAE), is the affinity of the disease-inducing determinants for MHC class II proteins. Tolerance, either due to clonal deletion or anergy induction, is thought to require high-affinity interactions between peptides and MHC molecules. Low-affinity binding is compatible with the hypothesis that breaking tolerance to self proteins does not have to occur for onset of disease. In contrast, a high-affinity interaction implies that an event leading to a breakdown of tolerance is central to the autoimmune process. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Detergent-solubilized and affinity-purified I-Au was incubated with varying concentrations of a set of peptides from myelin basic protein and a biotinylated peptide agonist. The specific complexes were separated from excess peptide by capture on antibody-coated plates, and the affinity of the peptides was measured by adding europium-labeled streptavidin and measuring the resultant fluorescence. RESULTS: The immunodominant and encephalitogenic determinant, Ac 1-11, was shown to bind to I-Au relatively poorly (IC50 = 100 microM), demonstrating that in this protein, immunodominance did not correlate with high-affinity binding. In contrast with the natural sequence, the ability of shorter analogs to induce EAE did correlate with their apparent affinity. CONCLUSIONS: The dominance of the natural determinant does not arise from a high-affinity interaction with the MHC class II molecule. This suggests that other mechanisms are operative and that the specific T cell for this peptide/MHC ligand is of high affinity.     

Carrier-specific suppression of antibody responses by antigen-specific glycosylation-inhibiting factors

We previously established an ovalbumin (OA)-specific T cell clone from spleen cells of BDF1 mice, which had been treated by i.v. injections of OA, and constructed antigen-specific T cell hybridomas from the T cell clone. One of the hybridomas constitutively released glycosylation-inhibiting factor (GIF) which lacked affinity for OA, and was called non-specific GIF. Incubation of the same hybridoma cells with OA-pulsed syngeneic macrophages or OA-pulsed B lymphoblastoid cells of BALB/c origin resulted in the formation of GIF molecules that had affinity for OA but not for bovine serum albumin or keyhole limpet hemocyanin. Both the OA-specific GIF and nonspecific GIF bound to monoclonal anti-lipocortin and possessed I-Jb determinants. The OA-specific GIF consisted of two species of molecules, of m.w. 80,000 and 30,000 to 40,000, respectively, whereas the nonspecific GIF from unstimulated cells had an m.w. of 15,000. Intravenous injections of OA-specific GIF or nonspecific GIF into BDF1 mice suppressed both the IgE and IgG1 anti-hapten antibody responses of the animals to dinitrophenyl derivatives of OA (DNP-OA), but OA-specific GIF was much more effective than nonspecific GIF in suppressing the antibody responses. When the same preparations of GIF were injected into DNP-KHL-primed mice, OA-specific GIF and nonspecific GIF were comparable in suppressing the anti-DNP antibody response. In contrast to the 40,000 m.w. species of OA-specific GIF, the 80,000 m.w. OA-specific GIF had carrier-specific suppressive effects. The similarities of antigen-specific GIF to antigen-specific TsF suggest that the phospholipase-inhibiting activity of the molecules may be involved in the immunosuppressive effects of some antigen-specific TsF.     

Regulation of the in vitro anamnestic antibody response by cyclic AMP. II. Antigen-dependent enhancement by exogenous prostaglandins of the E series.

The spleen cells from CFW/D mice injected with dimethylbenzanthracene-induced leukemia virus exhibited a progressive decline in the in vitro response to heterologous erythrocyte antigens in parallel with tumor growth. Cell transfer experiments revealed that this immunodepressed state may involve a B-cell defect rather than extrinsic factors in the cellular environment since: (i) nonresponsiveness could be transferred to irradiated non-tumor-bearing mice with spleen cells, and (ii) T cells from tumorbearing mice cooperated with normal bone marrow cells, but bone marrow from tumorbearing mice did not cooperate with normal T cells. In addition, T cells from the thymic tumor could cooperate with normal bone marrow cells upon transfer to irradiated recipients. TL 485-2 cells, a T-cell line derived from the tumor, could be specifically activated with SRBC thereby indicating that the virus transformed T cells were immunocompetent. Suppressor cells, which appeared in the spleen concomitant with immunodepression and tumor development, may directly raise B-cell thresholds for T-dependent triggering signals since the antibody response of spleen cells from tumor-bearing mice could be restored by adding agents such as LPS, 2 mercaptoethanol, or T cells exogenously preactivated in normal animals. The suppressor cell could be enriched by adherence to plastic and was removed by treatment with carbonyl iron. In addition, it was unlikely that the suppressor cell was a virus-infected cell since transformed, virus-infected cells from the tumor or TL 485-2 cells were not suppressive when added to spleen cells in vitro but rather resulted in a marked, polyclonal enhancement of the PFC response. The interaction of TL 485-2 cells and normal spleen cells resulted in the release of a stimulatory factor which increased DNA synthesis in resting cells as well as increasing PFC. The role of these enhancing factors and suppressor cells in controlling tumor growth remains to be elucidated.     

Transfer of antigen-encoding bone marrow under immune-preserving conditions deletes mature antigen-specific B cells in recipients and inhibits antigen-specific antibody production

Background aimsPathological activation and collaboration of T and B cells underlies pathogenic autoantibody responses. Existing treatments for autoimmune disease cause non-specific immunosuppression, and induction of antigen-specific tolerance remains an elusive goal. Many immunotherapies aim to manipulate the T-cell component of T–B interplay, but few directly target B cells. One possible means to specifically target B cells is the transfer of gene-engineered BM that, once engrafted, gives rise to widespread specific and tolerogenic antigen expression within the hematopoietic system.MethodsGene-engineered bone marrow encoding ubiquitous ovalbumin expression was transferred after low-dose (300-cGy) immune-preserving irradiation. B-cell responsiveness was monitored by analyzing ovalbumin-specific antibody production after immunization with ovalbumin/complete Freund's adjuvant. Ovalbumin-specific B cells and their response to immunization were analyzed using multi-tetramer staining. When antigen-encoding bone marrow was transferred under immune-preserving conditions, cognate antigen-specific B cells were purged from the recipient's preexisting B-cell repertoire and the repertoire that arose after bone marrow transfer.ResultsOVA-specific B-cell deletion was apparent within the established host B-cell repertoire as well as that developing after gene-engineered bone marrow transfer. OVA-specific antibody production was substantially inhibited by transfer of OVA-encoding BM and activation of OVA-specific B cells, germinal center formation and subsequent OVA-specific plasmablast differentiation were all inhibited. Low levels of gene-engineered bone marrow chimerism were sufficient to limit antigen-specific antibody production.ResultsThese data show that antigen-specific B cells within an established B-cell repertoire are susceptible to de novo tolerance induction, and this can be achieved by transfer of gene-engineered bone marrow. This adds further dimensions to the utility of antigen-encoding bone marrow transfer as an immunotherapeutic tool.     

Modulation of immune responses by suppressor T cells.

The activity of suppressor T cells has been demonstrated in almost every phase of the immune response. These regulatory cells modulate both humoral and cell-mediated immunity utilizing antigen-specific and nonspecific mechanisms. For comparative purposes two murine models are described, the nonspecific suppressor T cell stimulated by the mitogen concanavalin A and the antigen-specific suppressor T cell stimulated by injection of the synthetic terpolymer acid 60-L-alanine30-L-tyrosine10 (GAT) in nonresponder mice. These two T cells are similar to expression of Ly alloantigens, ability to inhibit antibody responses, and the mediation of suppression, at least in part, by soluble products. However, differences in radio-resistance and antigenic specificity of the suppressor T cells, as well as differences in molecular characteristics of the soluble factors and their targets suggest that these T cells regulate the immune response by different mechanisms. The relationship of these two suppressor T cells to other nonspecific and antigen-specific suppressor T cells is discussed.     

Mechanism of 8-mercaptoguanosine-mediated adjuvanticity: roles of clonal expansion and cellular recruitment

The mechanism by which increased numbers of antigen-responsive B cells are generated in the presence of antigen and the C8-substituted guanine ribonucleoside, 8-mercaptoguanosine (8MGuo), has been investigated. Augmentation of the primary humoral response of splenocytes to antigen cannot be ascribed to the additive effects of the underlying antigen-specific response and the nonspecific (polyclonal) response induced by 8MGuo. This is clear from a consideration of the magnitude of the responses involved, as well as from a murine model (the SJL mouse) that does not generate a nonspecific response to the substituted nucleoside but responds to it with the usual degree of immunoenhancement in the presence of antigen. Other approaches suggest that two mechanisms are involved in adjuvanticity, one whereby preexisting antigen-specific B cells undergo clonal expansion, and one in which cells not normally participating in the response are recruited in the absence of clonal expansion. The latter mechanism appears to be the dominant one insofar as models in which 8MGuo-induced proliferation fails to occur (such as after irradiation, or in the SJL mouse) nonetheless exhibit strong adjuvant effects. Analysis of precursor frequency of antigen-specific B cells indicates that for each mature, antigen-responsive B cell present in adult murine spleen, an average of four additional cells can be recruited by the conjoint actions of antigen and 8MGuo. One group subject to such recruitment is the immature antigen-specific B cell, whose degree of functional maturity is accelerated in the presence of antigen and 8MGuo.     

Cellular events in protein-tolerant inbred rats. III. Antigen-reactive B cells in rats tolerant to human serum albumin.

Rats tolerant to human serum albumin (HSA) were injected with selected lymphocyte populations and challenged with HSA plus adjuvant to test for loss of tolerance. Thoracic duct lymphocytes (TDL) from normal or immune rats, either untreated or depleted of Ig-bearing cells or HSA-binding cells by affinity chromatography were all equally effective in restoring the HSA antibody response in previously tolerant recipients. In contrast, recirculating B cells (TDL from B rats) were not effective. The results indicated that unresponsiveness to HSA was a lesion of the T- but not the B-cell compartment. However, antibody affinity failed to mature to a high level in tolerant rats that were restored with T cells, and the response of transferred primed B cells into unresponsive recipients was inhibited, suggesting that the tolerant state was not merely due to a T-cell deletion.     

Ontogeny of B-lymphocyte function: XIII. Kinetics of maturation of neonatal B lymphocytes to produce a heterogeneous antibody response to a T-independent antigen

The ontogeny of the capacity of a B-cell population to produce a heterogeneous, relatively high-affinity plaque-forming cell (PFC) response to the T-independent antigen trinitrophenylated-Ficoll (TNP-F) was studied in a cell transfer system. Lethally irradiated mice were reconstituted with liver cells from neonatal donors and were immunized with TNP-F at various times thereafter. In contrast to the results of our previous studies on the ontogeny of the response to T-dependent antigens, it was found that, in the cell transfer recipient, the response of an immature B-cell population to a T-independent antigen matures slowly (21–28 days). Furthermore, this maturation does not appear to require the presence of adult thymus cells as does the maturation of the response of a B-cell population to T-dependent antigens. Thus, it appears that the acquisition of the capacity of a B-cell population to produce a high-affinity, heterogeneous, PFC response to T-dependent and T-independent antigens occurs under different regulatory influences.     

The extent of affinity maturation differs between the memory and antibody-forming cell compartments in the primary immune response.

Immunization with protein-containing antigens results in two types of antigen-specific B cell: antibody forming cells (AFCs) producing antibody of progressively higher affinity and memory lymphocytes capable of producing high affinity antibody upon re-exposure to antigen. The issue of the inter-relationship between affinity maturation of memory B cells and AFCs was addressed through analysis of single, antigen-specific B cells from the memory and AFC compartments during the primary response to a model antigen. Only 65% of splenic memory B cells were found capable of producing high affinity antibody, meaning that low affinity cells persist into this compartment. In contrast, by 28 days after immunization all AFCs produced high affinity antibody. We identified a unique, persistent sub-population of bone marrow AFCs containing few somatic mutations, suggesting they arose early in the response, yet highly enriched for an identical affinity-enhancing amino acid exchange, suggesting strong selection. Our results imply that affinity maturation of a primary immune response occurs by the early selective differentiation of high affinity variants into AFCs which subsequently persist in the bone marrow. In contrast, the memory B-cell population contains few, if any, cells from the early response and is less stringently selected.     

Xenotransplantation and tolerance

The application of xenotransplantation faces daunting immunological hurdles, some of which might be overcome with the induction of tolerance. Porcine organs transplanted into primates are subject to several types of rejection responses. Hyperacute rejection mediated by naturally occurring xenoreactive antibodies and complement can be overcome without tolerance. Acute vascular rejection and cellular rejection, however, may present important opportunities for immunological tolerance, and humoral rejection might be approached by various mechanisms including (i) clonal deletion, (ii) anergy, (iii) immune deviation, (iv) induction of immunoregulatory or suppressor cells, or (v) veto cells. B-cell tolerance, useful for preventing humoral rejection, might be approached through clonal anergy. It remains to be determined, however, whether tolerance induction is required for xenotransplantation and by which means the various mechanisms of tolerance can be applied in the setting of xenotransplantation. Regardless, the study of tolerance will surely expand understanding of the physiology and pathophysiology of the immune system.     

Effect of tolerance and of antibody mediated immune suppression on the avidity of the cellular and humoral immune response

Partial tolerance induction in adult rabbits although resulting in a marked depression of circulating antibody concentration, had no effect on either the avidity of the antibody synthesized at 2 weeks after immunization or the magnitude of the response of lymph node cells to stimulation by antigen in culture. A modest depression in the avidity of the cells responding to antigen in culture by an increase in thymidine incorporation was observed. Partial antibody mediated immune suppression was found to result in an increase in avidity of the residual circulating antibody and had no effect on the magnitude of the proliferative response induced by antigen in culture. Thus suppression appears to affect predominantly B-lymphocytes.     

Antigen presentation in acquired immunological tolerance

In acquired tolerance, previous exposure to antigen under certain conditions induces specific unresponsiveness instead of specific immunological memory. It has been studied as an approach to the mechanisms of self-tolerance that operate on immunocompetent T and B lymphocytes once they leave their sites of origin in the thymus and the bone marrow. Possible mechanisms involve induction of specific suppressor cells or inactivation of antigen-specific lymphocytes (clonal anergy) as a consequence of abortive antigen presentation, in which the antigen receptor is effectively engaged but certain poorly defined accessory signals the T lymphocytes require are lacking. We propose that small, resting B lymphocytes, which lack these accessory signals, are the inactivating antigen-presenting cells in acquired tolerance to proteins and to the class II transplantation antigens. B lymphocytes, which can use their antigen receptors to gather and process antigens that are present at very low concentrations, may play a role in self-tolerance. In addition, B lymphocytes and T lymphocytes rendered anergic by encounter with self antigens could persist as self-specific suppressor cells to block an autoimmune response of autoreactive clones that had escaped deletion or anergy.     

Regulation of the activation of cytotoxic T lymphocytes by prostaglandins and antigens

The present study demonstrated the presence of two suppressor circuits in the regulation of the in vitro activation and differentiation of cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL); these suppressor circuits were mediated by prostaglandins (PG) and antigens, respectively. In intrinsic suppression, the activation of cytotoxic precursor cells was regulated by the host endogenous production of PG. When the regulation by PG was removed (e.g., using indomethacin), lymphokine-induced cytotoxic cells (LICC) were generated. This activation process can be induced in the absence of antigen or mitogen stimulation. In extrinsic suppression, the presence of antigen induced the generation of antigen-nonspecific suppressor T cells to restrict the expansion of antigen-unrelated cytotoxic lymphocyte clones, whereas the antigen-specific CTL clones were spared. The generation of antigen-specific helper cells further augmented the antigen-specific CTL response. These findings indicate that both antigen specific suppressor T cells and antigen nonspecific suppressor T cells are involved in the regulation of CTL responses. These suppressor circuits not only play an active role in monitoring the activation of CTL clones, they also help to determine the specificity and magnitude of the CTL response.     

Antigen-nonspecific and specific suppression of lymphokine production in desensitized guinea pigs

Doubly immunized guinea pigs may be desensitized with respect to delayed hypersensitivity reactions against both antigens (anergy) by injection of large doses of either one. This anergic response therefore has both a specific and nonspecific component. The specific component of desensitization persists longer than the nonspecific one. In the present study, we have explored the mechanism of both antigen-specific and antigen-nonspecific suppression during the later stages of desensitization. Guinea pigs immunized with two antigens, DNP-KLH and DNP-EA, were desensitized with DNP-EA. The lymph node cells obtained from the animals 1 day after desensitization were unable to produce MIF in the presence of either antigen. The cells obtained 3, 5, and 7 days after desensitization were able to generate MIF when stimulated with the non-specific antigen (DNP-KLH), but not with specific antigen (DNP-EA). It was shown that both T- and non-T-cell fractions obtained 1 day after desensitization had the capacity to antigen-nonspecifically suppress MIF production. In contrast, if the cells were obtained 3 or 5 days after desensitization, T cells could inhibit only the antigen-specific production of MIF, while non-T cells were still capable of suppressing antigen-specific and nonspecific MIF production. Interestingly, when these two populations were mixed back again, it was now only suppressive to the specific antigen-induced MIF production. This latter observation indicates that nonspecific suppressor non-T cells may themselves be regulated by suppressor T cells. Furthermore, antigen-specific suppressor T cells were shown to produce soluble factor(s) which inhibited the production of MIF.     

Sequential mechanisms of cyclophosphamide-induced skin allograft tolerance including the intrathymic clonal deletion followed by late breakdown of the clonal deletion

The cellular basis of the transplantation tolerance in a model system of BALB/c (Mls-1b) mice rendered cyclophosphamide (CP)-induced tolerant to DBA/2 (Mls-1a) skin allograft was investigated by assessing V beta 6+ T cells. From our results, three major mechanisms that are essential to the CP-induced skin allograft tolerance were sequentially elucidated. The first mechanism was destruction of donor-Ag-stimulated T cells in the periphery by CP treatment. The second mechanism was intrathymic clonal deletion of donor-reactive T cells, such as V beta 6+ T cells, correlating strongly with intrathymic mixed chimerism. The clonal deletion, however, was not always essential for the maintenance of the skin allografts, because DBA/2 skin survived even after the clonal deletion terminated and V beta 6+ T cells reappeared in the periphery of the recipient BALB/c mice. The third mechanism was generation of tolerogen-specific suppressor T cells, especially in the late stage of the tolerance. In contrast, the clonal anergy that is evidenced by the specific suppression of mixed lymphocyte reaction in the recipient BALB/c mice after injecting with DBA/2 spleen cells alone was not considered as a significant mechanism in prolonging skin allograft survival because such anergic mice showed accelerated rejection of the skin allografts. These results may suggest practical hierarchy of the mechanisms of CP-induced allograft tolerance.     

Augmentation of the antibody response by antigen-specific glycosylation-enhancing factor

BDF1 mice were immunized with a protein antigen, such as ovalbumin (OA) or keyhole limpet hemocyanin (KLH), absorbed to aluminum hydroxide gel, and their spleen cells were stimulated by homologous antigen for the formation of glycosylation-enhancing factor (GEF). It was found that GEF obtained from OA-primed spleen cells had affinity for OA, whereas those derived from KLH-primed spleen cells had affinity for KLH. Nonspecific GEF, which was obtained by stimulation of normal spleen cells with pertussis toxin, failed to bind OA or KLH. Both antigen-specific GEF and nonspecific GEF are inactivated by phenylmethylsulfonyl fluoride, but not by N-alpha-p-tosyl-L-lysyl-chloromethyl ketone. Both factors can be partially purified by binding to p-aminobenzamidine agarose and elution with benzamidine. These findings suggest that not only non-specific GEF but also antigen-specific GEF are serine protease(s). The antigen-specific GEF consisted of two m.w. species, of 65 to 85 kilodaltons (Kd) and 40 to 55 Kd, whereas nonspecific GEF consisted of 50 to 70 Kd and 20 to 30 Kd molecules. The OA-specific GEF augmented the in vitro secondary indirect PFC response of DNP-OA-primed cells to the homologous antigen, but failed to affect the PFC response of DNP-KLH-primed cells to DNP-KLH. Similarly, KLH-specific GEF enhanced the response of DNP-KLH-primed cells but not the response of DNP-OA-primed cells. However, OA-specific GEF failed to replace the requirement for antigen-primed helper T cells. Antigen-specific GEF bound to alloantibodies reactive to the products of the I region of the major histocompatibility complex. The results collectively suggest that antigen-specific GEF is identical to antigen-specific augmenting factors described by other investigators.     

The central tolerance response to male antigen in normal mice is deletion and not receptor editing

It is widely accepted that developing T cells can undergo clonal deletion in the thymus in response to a high affinity self-Ag. This is largely based on studies of TCR transgenics. However, encounter with high affinity self-Ag can also result in receptor editing in TCR transgenic models. Because all TCR transgenics display ectopic receptor expression, the tolerance mechanism that predominates in normal mice remains an open question. When self-Ag drives receptor editing during T cell development, one expects to find in-frame, self-reactive TCRalpha joins on TCR excision circles (TRECs), which are the products of secondary V/J recombination in the TCRalpha locus. Such joins are not expected if clonal deletion occurs, because the progenitor cell would be eliminated by apoptosis. To test the relative utilization of receptor editing vs clonal deletion, we determined the frequency of in-frame, male-specific joins on TRECs in male and female HYbeta transgenic mice. In comparison with female HYbeta transgenic mice, our analysis showed a lower frequency of TRECs with male-reactive V17J57 joins in male mice. Thus, it would appear that receptor editing is not a predominant tolerance mechanism for this self-Ag.