Characterization of a Highly Hop-Resistant Lactobacillus brevis Strain Lacking Hop Transport

Resistance to hops is a prerequisite for lactic acid bacteria to spoil beer. In this study we analyzed mechanisms of hop resistance of Lactobacillus brevis at the metabolism, membrane physiology, and cell wall composition levels. The beer-spoiling organism L. brevis TMW 1.465 was adapted to high concentrations of hop compounds and compared to a nonadapted strain. Upon adaptation to hops the metabolism changed to minimize ethanol stress. Fructose was used predominantly as a carbon source by the nonadapted strain but served as an electron acceptor upon adaptation to hops, with concomitant formation of acetate instead of ethanol. Furthermore, hop adaptation resulted in higher levels of lipoteichoic acids (LTA) incorporated into the cell wall and altered composition and fluidity of the cytoplasmic membrane. The putative transport protein HitA and enzymes of the arginine deiminase pathway were overexpressed upon hop adaptation. HorA was not expressed, and the transport of hop compounds from the membrane to the extracellular space did not account for increased resistance to hops upon adaptation. Accordingly, hop resistance is a multifactorial dynamic property, which can develop during adaptation. During hop adaptation, arginine catabolism contributes to energy and generation of the proton motive force until a small fraction of the population has established structural improvements. This acquired hop resistance is energy independent and involves an altered cell wall composition. LTA shields the organism from accompanying stresses and provides a reservoir of divalent cations, which are otherwise scarce as a result of their complexation by hop acids. Some of the mechanisms involved in hop resistance overlap with mechanisms of pH resistance and ethanol tolerance and as a result enable beer spoilage by L. brevis.     

Proteomic approach for characterization of hop-inducible proteins in Lactobacillus brevis

Resistance to hops is a prerequisite for the capability of lactic acid bacteria to grow in beer and thus cause beer spoilage. Bactericidal hop compounds, mainly iso-alpha-acids, are described as ionophores which exchange H+ for cellular divalent cations, e.g., Mn2+, and thus dissipate ion gradients across the cytoplasmic membrane. The acid stress response of Lactobacillus brevis TMW 1.465 and hop adaptation in its variant L. brevis TMW 1.465A caused changes at the level of metabolism, membrane physiology, and cell wall composition. To identify the basis for these changes, a proteomic approach was taken. The experimental design allowed the discrimination of acid stress and hop stress. A strategy for improved protein identification enabled the identification of 84% of the proteins investigated despite the lack of genome sequence data for this strain. Hop resistance in L. brevis TMW 1.465A implies mechanisms to cope with intracellular acidification, mechanisms for energy generation and economy, genetic information fidelity, and enzyme functionality. Interestingly, the majority of hop-regulated enzymes are described as manganese or divalent cation dependent. Regulation of the manganese level allows fine-tuning of the metabolism, which enables a rapid response to environmental (stress) conditions. The hop stress response indicates adaptations shifting the metabolism into an energy-saving mode by effective substrate conversion and prevention of exhaustive protein de novo synthesis. The findings further demonstrate that hop stress in bacteria not only is associated with proton motive force depletion but obviously implies divalent cation limitation.     

Membrane-bound ATPase contributes to hop resistance of Lactobacillus brevis

The activity of the membrane-bound H+-ATPase of the beer spoilage bacterium Lactobacillus brevis ABBC45 increased upon adaptation to bacteriostatic hop compounds. The ATPase activity was optimal around pH 5.6 and increased up to fourfold when L. brevis was exposed to 666 microM hop compounds. The extent of activation depended on the concentration of hop compounds and was maximal at the highest concentration tested. The ATPase activity was strongly inhibited by N,N'-dicyclohexylcarbodiimide, a known inhibitor of FoF1-ATPase. Western blots of membrane proteins of L. brevis with antisera raised against the alpha- and beta-subunits of FoF1-ATPase from Enterococcus hirae showed that there was increased expression of the ATPase after hop adaptation. The expression levels, as well as the ATPase activity, decreased to the initial nonadapted levels when the hop-adapted cells were cultured further without hop compounds. These observations strongly indicate that proton pumping by the membrane-bound ATPase contributes considerably to the resistance of L. brevis to hop compounds.     

Hop resistance in the beer spoilage bacterium Lactobacillus brevis is mediated by the ATP-binding cassette multidrug transporter HorA

Lactobacillus brevis is a major contaminant of spoiled beer. The organism can grow in beer in spite of the presence of antibacterial hop compounds that give the beer a bitter taste. The hop resistance in L. brevis is, at least in part, dependent on the expression of the horA gene. The deduced amino acid sequence of HorA is 53% identical to that of LmrA, an ATP-binding cassette multidrug transporter in Lactococcus lactis. To study the role of HorA in hop resistance, HorA was functionally expressed in L. lactis as a hexa-histidine-tagged protein using the nisin-controlled gene expression system. HorA expression increased the resistance of L. lactis to hop compounds and cytotoxic drugs. Drug transport studies with L. lactis cells and membrane vesicles and with proteoliposomes containing purified HorA protein identified HorA as a new member of the ABC family of multidrug transporters.     

Proteomic Approach for Characterization of Hop-Inducible Proteins in Lactobacillus brevis

Resistance to hops is a prerequisite for the capability of lactic acid bacteria to grow in beer and thus cause beer spoilage. Bactericidal hop compounds, mainly iso-α-acids, are described as ionophores which exchange H⁺ for cellular divalent cations, e.g., Mn²⁺, and thus dissipate ion gradients across the cytoplasmic membrane. The acid stress response of Lactobacillus brevis TMW 1.465 and hop adaptation in its variant L. brevis TMW 1.465A caused changes at the level of metabolism, membrane physiology, and cell wall composition. To identify the basis for these changes, a proteomic approach was taken. The experimental design allowed the discrimination of acid stress and hop stress. A strategy for improved protein identification enabled the identification of 84% of the proteins investigated despite the lack of genome sequence data for this strain. Hop resistance in L. brevis TMW 1.465A implies mechanisms to cope with intracellular acidification, mechanisms for energy generation and economy, genetic information fidelity, and enzyme functionality. Interestingly, the majority of hop-regulated enzymes are described as manganese or divalent cation dependent. Regulation of the manganese level allows fine-tuning of the metabolism, which enables a rapid response to environmental (stress) conditions. The hop stress response indicates adaptations shifting the metabolism into an energy-saving mode by effective substrate conversion and prevention of exhaustive protein de novo synthesis. The findings further demonstrate that hop stress in bacteria not only is associated with proton motive force depletion but obviously implies divalent cation limitation.     

啤酒花抗性机制的研究进展

酒花苦味酸是构成啤酒风味的重要组分,也是啤酒生产过程中的天然抑菌剂,酒花苦味酸通过降低pH梯度而抑制啤酒花敏感菌生长。研究发现,啤酒花抗性菌是通过膜上转运蛋白将酒花苦味酸泵出细胞外,以降低膜上的质子流速,维持了细胞内的pH梯度。结合近年来酒花抗性相关研究结果,讨论了细胞膜上酒花抗性相关组分与酒花抗性间的关系,提出了酒花抗性机制的模型。     

Membrane-Bound ATPase Contributes to Hop Resistance of Lactobacillus brevis

The activity of the membrane-bound H⁺-ATPase of the beer spoilage bacterium Lactobacillus brevis ABBC45 increased upon adaptation to bacteriostatic hop compounds. The ATPase activity was optimal around pH 5.6 and increased up to fourfold when L. brevis was exposed to 666 μM hop compounds. The extent of activation depended on the concentration of hop compounds and was maximal at the highest concentration tested. The ATPase activity was strongly inhibited by N,N′-dicyclohexylcarbodiimide, a known inhibitor of F_oF₁-ATPase. Western blots of membrane proteins of L. brevis with antisera raised against the α- and β-subunits of F_oF₁-ATPase from Enterococcus hirae showed that there was increased expression of the ATPase after hop adaptation. The expression levels, as well as the ATPase activity, decreased to the initial nonadapted levels when the hop-adapted cells were cultured further without hop compounds. These observations strongly indicate that proton pumping by the membrane-bound ATPase contributes considerably to the resistance of L. brevis to hop compounds.     

Hopped Beer: The Case For Cultivation

The history of hops, hopped beer, and hop cultivation is unclear and ambiguous. An assessment of the available literature reveals many contradictions, especially regarding the first use of hops in beer and the earliest incidence of hop cultivation. Historically, hops were used for a variety of purposes; now their primary use is as a preservative and flavoring in beer. Hop cultivation is poorly documented, but was certainly undertaken by the 10th century, most probably in response to the demand generated by beer-brewing. After comparing the literature and investigating source material, a chronology of hop use in beer and hop cultivation is proposed.     

Effects of pulsed electric fields on inactivation and metabolic activity of Lactobacillus plantarum in model beer

AIMS: Inactivation and sublethal injury of Lactobacillus plantarum at different pulsed electric field (PEF) strengths and total energy inputs were investigated to differentiate reversible and irreversible impacts on cell functionality. METHODS AND RESULTS: Lactobacillus plantarum was treated with PEF in model beer (MB) to determine critical values of field strength and energy input for cell inactivation. Below critical values, metabolic activity and membrane integrity were initially reduced without loss of viability. Above critical values, however, irreversible cell damage occurred. Presence of nisin or hop extract, during PEF treatment, resulted in an additional reduction of cell viability by 1;5 log cycles. Also, addition of the hop extract resulted in an additional two log cycles of sublethal injury. Partial reversibility of membrane damage was observed using propidium iodide (PI) uptake and staining. Inoculated MB containing hops was stored after PEF to evaluate the efficacy of such treatment for beer preservation. CONCLUSION: Cells were inactivated only above critical values of 13 kV x cm(-1) and 64 kJ x kg(-1); below these values cell damage was reversible. Storage experiments revealed that surviving cells were killed after 15 h storage in MB containing hops. SIGNIFICANCE AND IMPACT OF THE STUDY: Both reversible and irreversible cell damage due to PEF treatment was detected, depending on specific treatment conditions. The combination of PEF and hop addition is a promising nonthermal method of preservation for beer.     

Detection of resistance of lactic acid bacteria to a mixture of the hop analogue compounds tetrahydroiso-alpha-acids by noninvasive measurement of intracellular pH

AIMS: To examine the resistance of beer isolates of lactic acid bacteria (LAB) towards a mixture of tetrahydroiso-alpha-acids (Tetra) by growth experiments as well as by measurement of intracellular pH. METHODS AND RESULTS: Beer LAB isolates were identified to species level by SDS-PAGE of whole-cell proteins. Beer isolates of Lactobacillus brevis showed better ability for growth in the presence of Tetra than nonbeer isolates of the L. brevis or other species of LAB including beer and nonbeer isolates. The antimicrobial effect of Tetra was also examined by noninvasive measurement of intracellular pH by fluorescence ratio imaging microscopy for selected beer isolates of L. brevis and Pediococcus inopinatus. Strains of L. brevis showing limited decrease of intracellular pH during exposure to Tetra also showed better ability for growth in the presence of these compounds as well as in commercial beer products. CONCLUSIONS: It was possible to apply a method for noninvasive measurement of intracellular pH to predict the resistance of beer spoilage LAB towards the Tetra hop analogue compounds. SIGNIFICANCE AND IMPACT OF THE STUDY: This study demonstrated the usability of a new rapid method for detecting hop-resistant variants of known beer spoilage LAB species.     

Lipoteichoic acid is a major component of the Bacillus subtilis periplasm

Cryo-electron microscopy (cryo-EM) of frozen-hydrated specimens allows high-resolution observation of structures in optimally preserved samples. In gram-positive bacteria, this method reveals the presence of a periplasmic space between the plasma membrane and an often differentiated cell wall matrix. Since virtually nothing is known about the composition of its constituent matter (i.e., the periplasm), it is still unclear what structures (or mechanism) sustain a gram-positive periplasmic space. Here we have used cryo-EM of frozen-hydrated sections in combination with various labels to probe the model gram-positive organism Bacillus subtilis for major periplasmic components. Incubation of cells with positively charged gold nanoparticles showed almost similar levels of gold binding to the periplasm and the cell wall. On cells whose cell walls were enzymatically hydrolyzed (i.e., on protoplasts), a surface diffuse layer extending ~30 nm from the membrane was revealed. The thickness and density of this layer were not significantly altered after treatment with a nonspecific protease, whereas it was labeled with anti-lipoteichoic acid (LTA) antibodies conjugated to nanogold. Further, the LTA layer spans most of the thickness of the periplasmic space, which strongly suggests that LTA is a major component of the B. subtilis periplasm.     

Cell Wall Structure in Cells Adapted to Growth on the Cellulose-Synthesis Inhibitor 2,6-Dichlorobenzonitrile : A Comparison between Two Dicotyledonous Plants and a Graminaceous Monocot

Our previous work (E. Shedletzky, M. Shmuel, D.P. Delmer, D.T.A. Lamport [1990] Plant Physiol 94:980-987) showed that suspension-cultured tomato cells adapted to growth on the cellulose synthesis inhibitor 2,6-dichlorobenzonitrile (DCB) have a markedly altered cell wall composition, most notably a markedly reduced level of the cellulose-xyloglucan network. This study compares the adaptation to DCB of two cell lines from dicots (tomato [Lycopersicon esculentum] and tobacco [Nicotiana tabacum]) and a Graminaceous monocot (barley [Hordeum bulbosum] endosperm). The difference in wall structures between the dicots and the monocot is reflected in the very different types of wall modifications induced by growth on DCB. The dicots, having reduced levels of cellulose and xyloglucan, possess walls the major integrity of which is provided by Ca²⁺-bridged pectates because protoplasts can be prepared from these cells simply by treatment with divalent cation chelator and a purified endopolygalacturonase. The tensile strength of these walls is considerably less than walls from nonadapted cells, but wall porosity is not altered. In contrast, walls from adapted barley cells contain very little pectic material and normal to elevated levels of noncellulosic polysaccharides compared with walls from nonadapted cells. Surprisingly, they have tensile strengths higher than their nonadapted counterpart, although cellulose levels are reduced by 70%. Evidence is presented that these walls obtain their additional strength by an altered pattern of cross-linking of polymers involving phenolic components. Such cross-linking may also explain the observation that the porosity of these walls is also considerably reduced. Cells of adapted lines of both the dicots and barley are resistant to plasmolysis, suggesting that they possess very strong connections between the wall and the plasma membrane.     

Effects of high pressure on survival and metabolic activity of Lactobacillus plantarum TMW1.460

The application of high pressure (HP) for food preservation requires insight into mechanisms of HP-mediated cell injury and death. The HP inactivation in model beer of Lactobacillus plantarum TMW1.460, a beer-spoiling organism, was investigated at pressures ranging from 200 to 600 MPa. Surviving cells were characterized by determination of (i) cell viability and sublethal injury, (ii) membrane permeability to the fluorescent dyes propidium iodide (PI) and ethidium bromide (EB), (iii) metabolic activity with tetrazolium salts, and (iv) the activity of HorA, an ATP binding cassette-type multidrug resistance transporter conferring resistance to hop compounds. HP inactivation curves exhibited a shoulder, an exponential inactivation phase, and pronounced tailing caused by a barotolerant fraction of the population, about 1 in 10(6) cells. During exponential inactivation, more than 99.99% of cells were sublethally injured; however, no sublethal injury was detected in the barotolerant fraction of the culture. Sublethally injured cells were metabolically active, and loss of metabolic activity corresponded to the decrease of cell viability. Membrane damage measured by PI uptake occurred later than cell death, indicating that dye exclusion may be used as a fail-safe method for preliminary characterization of HP inactivation. An increase of membrane permeability to EB and a reduction of HorA activity were observed prior to the loss of cell viability, indicating loss of hop resistance of pressurized cells. Even mild HP treatments thus abolished the ability of cells to survive under adverse conditions.     

Effects of High Pressure on Survival and Metabolic Activity of Lactobacillus plantarum TMW1.460

The application of high pressure (HP) for food preservation requires insight into mechanisms of HP-mediated cell injury and death. The HP inactivation in model beer of Lactobacillus plantarum TMW1.460, a beer-spoiling organism, was investigated at pressures ranging from 200 to 600 MPa. Surviving cells were characterized by determination of (i) cell viability and sublethal injury, (ii) membrane permeability to the fluorescent dyes propidium iodide (PI) and ethidium bromide (EB), (iii) metabolic activity with tetrazolium salts, and (iv) the activity of HorA, an ATP binding cassette-type multidrug resistance transporter conferring resistance to hop compounds. HP inactivation curves exhibited a shoulder, an exponential inactivation phase, and pronounced tailing caused by a barotolerant fraction of the population, about 1 in 10⁶ cells. During exponential inactivation, more than 99.99% of cells were sublethally injured; however, no sublethal injury was detected in the barotolerant fraction of the culture. Sublethally injured cells were metabolically active, and loss of metabolic activity corresponded to the decrease of cell viability. Membrane damage measured by PI uptake occurred later than cell death, indicating that dye exclusion may be used as a fail-safe method for preliminary characterization of HP inactivation. An increase of membrane permeability to EB and a reduction of HorA activity were observed prior to the loss of cell viability, indicating loss of hop resistance of pressurized cells. Even mild HP treatments thus abolished the ability of cells to survive under adverse conditions.     

Flow cytometric assessment of membrane integrity of ethanol-stressed Oenococcus oeni cells

The practical application of commercial malolactic starter cultures of Oenococcus oeni surviving direct inoculation in wine requires insight into the mechanisms involved in ethanol toxicity and tolerance in this organism. Exposure to ethanol resulted in an increase in the permeability of the cytoplasmic membrane, enhancing passive proton influx and concomitant loss of intracellular material (absorbing at 260 nm). Cells grown in the presence of 8% (vol/vol) ethanol revealed adaptation to ethanol stress, since these cells showed higher retention of compounds absorbing at 260 nm. Moreover, for concentrations higher than 10% (vol/vol), lower rates of passive proton influx were observed in these ethanol-adapted cells, especially at pH 3.5. The effect of ethanol on O. oeni cells was studied as the ability to efficiently retain carboxyfluorescein (cF) as an indicator of membrane integrity and enzyme activity and the uptake of propidium iodide (PI) to assess membrane damage. Flow cytometric analysis of both ethanol-adapted and nonadapted cells with a mixture of the two fluorescent dyes, cF and PI, revealed three main subpopulations of cells: cF-stained intact cells; cF- and PI-stained permeable cells, and PI-stained damaged cells. The subpopulation of O. oeni cells that maintained their membrane integrity, i.e., cells stained only with cF, was three times larger in the population grown in the presence of ethanol, reflecting the protective effect of ethanol adaptation. This information is of major importance in studies of microbial fermentations in order to assign bulk activities measured by classical methods to the very active cells that are effectively responsible for the observations.     

Arginine- and Polyamine-Induced Lactic Acid Resistance in Neisseria gonorrhoeae

Microbe-derived lactic acid protects women from pathogens in their genital tract. The purpose of this study was to determine lactic acid susceptibility of Neisseria gonorrhoeae, and identify potential acid resistance mechanisms present in this pathogen. Tested in vitro, lactic acid killed all 10 gonococcal strains analyzed in a low pH-dependent manner. Full inactivation occurred at pH 4.5. At low pH, lactic acid treatment resulted in the entry of the DNA-binding fluorochrome propidium iodide into the microbial cells, suggesting that hydrogen ions from lactic acid compromise the integrity of the bacterial cell wall/membrane. Most likely, hydrogen ions also inactivate intracellular proteins since arginine rendered significant protection against lactic acid presumably through action of the gonococcal arginine decarboxylase, an enzyme located in the bacterial cytoplasm. Surprisingly, arginine also lessened lactic acid-mediated cell wall/membrane disruption. This effect is probably mediated by agmatine, a triamine product of arginine decarboxylase, since agmatine demonstrated a stronger protective effect on GC than arginine at equal molar concentration. In addition to agmatine, diamines cadaverine and putrescine, which are generated by bacterial vaginosis-associated microbes, also induced significant resistance to lactic acid-mediated GC killing and cell wall/membrane disruption. These findings suggest that the arginine-rich semen protects gonococci through both neutralization-dependent and independent mechanisms, whereas polyamine-induced acid resistance contributes to the increased risk of gonorrhea in women with bacterial vaginosis.     

Effect of adaptation to ethanol on cytoplasmic and membrane protein profiles of Oenococcus oeni

The practical application of commercial malolactic starter cultures of Oenococcus oeni surviving direct inoculation in wine requires insight into mechanisms of ethanol toxicity and of acquired ethanol tolerance in this organism. Therefore, the site-specific location of proteins involved in ethanol adaptation, including cytoplasmic, membrane-associated, and integral membrane proteins, was investigated. Ethanol triggers alterations in protein patterns of O. oeni cells stressed with 12% ethanol for 1 h and those of cells grown in the presence of 8% ethanol. Levels of inosine-5'-monophosphate dehydrogenase and phosphogluconate dehydrogenase, which generate reduced nicotinamide nucleotides, were decreased during growth in the presence of ethanol, while glutathione reductase, which consumes NADPH, was induced, suggesting that maintenance of the redox balance plays an important role in ethanol adaptation. Phosphoenolpyruvate:mannose phosphotransferase system (PTS) components of mannose PTS, including the phosphocarrier protein HPr and EII(Man), were lacking in ethanol-adapted cells, providing strong evidence that mannose PTS is absent in ethanol-adapted cells, and this represents a metabolic advantage to O. oeni cells during malolactic fermentation. In cells grown in the presence of ethanol, a large increase in the number of membrane-associated proteins was observed. Interestingly, two of these proteins, dTDT-glucose-4,6-dehydratase and D-alanine:D-alanine ligase, are known to be involved in cell wall biosynthesis. Using a proteomic approach, we provide evidence for an active ethanol adaptation response of O. oeni at the cytoplasmic and membrane protein levels.     

The effect of ethanol on the phase behavior of membrane lipids extracted from Clostridium thermocellum strains

The phase behavior of aqueous dispersions of extracted lipids from Clostridium thermocellum wild-type and ethanol-tolerant C919 cells has been examined by DSC. The optimum growth temperature of this anaerobe is 60°C. The wild-type lipids exhibit a broad phase transition centered at 30°C; the C919 mutant lipids show a 10°C lower T_m. The direct addition of growth inhibiting concentrations of ethanol has no significant effect on T_m or headgroup mobility (monitored by ²H-NMR) of either set of lipids. In contrast, wild-type cells adapted to growth in ethanol exhibit a broadened and lower T_m (15–25°C plateau); C919 membrane lipids do not exhibit significantly altered phase behavior when adapted to growth in ethanol. Both wild-type and mutant membranes have fatty acid composition changes upon growth in ethanol, which increases lower-melting components. It is concluded that fatty acid changes which occur upon adaptation of the organism to growth in ethanol are secondary responses and not necessarily direct responses to alter membrane fluidity.     

Aspects of the resistance of lactic acid bacteria to hop bitter acids

Resistance to trans -isohumulone is found only in those lactic acid bacteria which can grow in beer. The degree of resistance could not be altered by plasmid curing, or mutation induced by u.v. light. Organisms resistant to trans -isohumulone were resistant to the related hop acids(-)-humulone and colupulone. Equally, organisms sensitive to trans -isohumulone were also sensitive to related compounds. No other features correlated with hop resistance, including cell morphology, colony morphology, pH range for growth, sugar utilization profile, products of metabolism, manganese requirement and sensitivity to superoxide radicals, expression of cellular proteins, and resistance or sensitivity to selected antibacterial agents.