Probing the structure of gal operator-repressor complexes. Conformation change in DNA

The gal operon is regulated by binding of Gal repressor to two operator loci, OE and OI, which are separated by 114 base pairs (bp). We have probed the actual operator DNA segments with and without Gal repressor occupation by characterizing the regions protected by repressor from DNase I digestion and dimethyl sulfate methylation. The segments which are protected from DNase I digestion in both OE and OI are about 22 bp long and seem to include 2-3 extra bp on either side of a 16-bp similar sequence containing an approximate dyad symmetry, with a consensus half-symmetry sequence GTG(G/T)AA-C. Repressor occupation hinders the reactivity of the consensus guanines in the four half-symmetry sequences, as shown by retardation of methylation at the N-7 positions by dimethyl sulfate owing to repressor binding. The protected guanines are symmetrically located. Since a dimeric Gal repressor affects symmetrically located bases, it is consistent with the notion that each half-operator is occupied by a repressor subunit. Because the N-7 positions of methylation of guanines lie in the major grooves and the protected guanines are located at positions 1, 3, 8 and the rotational 1', 3', and 8' in the 16-bp dyad symmetry, we suggest that Gal repressor establishes direct contacts with bases at 1, 3, 1', and 3' through two major grooves lying on one face of an operator helix and prevents reactivity of the guanines at 8 and 8' of a third major groove on the opposite face by changing the DNA helical structure at this position. Contacts at other positions are also discussed.     

Interaction of the Escherichia coli Gal repressor protein with its DNA operators in vitro

The binding of Escherichia coli Gal repressor to linear DNA fragments containing two binding sites (OE and OI) within the gal operon was analyzed in vitro with quantitative footprint and mobility-shift techniques. In vivo analysis of the regulation of the gal operon [Haber, R., & Adhya, S. (1988) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 85, 9683-9687] has suggested the role of a regulatory "looped complex" mediated by the association of Gal repressor dimers bound at OE and OI. The binding of Gal repressor to a single site can be described by a model in which monomer and dimer are in equilibrium and only the dimer binds to DNA. At pH 7.0, 25 mM KCl, and 20 degrees C, the binding and dimerization free energies are comparable, suggesting that the equilibrium governing the formation of dimers may be important to regulation. The two intrinsic binding constants, delta GI and delta GE, and a constant describing cooperativity, delta GIE, were determined by footprint titration analysis as a function of pH, [KCl], and temperature. Only at 4 and 0 degrees C was delta GIE negative, signifying cooperative binding. These results are thought to be due to a weak dimer to tetramer association interface. delta GE and delta GI had maximal values between pH 6 and pH 7. The dependence of these constants on [KCl] corresponded to the displacement of approximately 2 ion equiv. The temperature dependence could be described by a change in the heat capacity, delta Cp, of -2.3 kcal mol-1 deg-1. Mobility-shift titration experiments conducted at 20 and 0 degrees C yielded values for delta GIE that were consistent with those resolved from the footprint analysis. Unique values of delta GIE were determined by analysis of mobility-shift titrations of Gal repressor with wild-type operator subject to the constraint that delta GE = delta GI: a procedure that eliminates the need to simultaneously analyze wild-type titrations with titrations of OE- and OI- operators.     

TET repressor.tet operator complex formation induces conformational changes in the tet operator DNA.

The structural changes of the tet operator DNA upon binding of the TET repressor protein are examined by circular dichroism. For this purpose a 70 bp DNA fragment was prepared which contains both tet operators. About 67% of the base pairs of this DNA are involved in specific interaction with the TET repressor. A rather large change in the CD of the DNA is induced by binding of the TET repressor. The shape of the CD difference spectrum is similar to the respective difference found for the lac operator DNA upon complex formation with the lac repressor. However, the effect induced by the TET repressor on tet operator DNA seems to comprise both the specific and non-specific effect of the lac repressor on the structure of DNA [Culard, F. and Maurizot, J.C. (1981) Nucl. Acids Res. 9, 5157-5184]. Specificity of binding is confirmed by the lack of any effect of the TET repressor on the CD of a 95 bp lac operator containing DNA fragment, by the reduced mobility of TET repressor.tet operator complexes on polyacrylamide gels under CD conditions, and by a titration experiment of tet operator DNA with TET repressor employing the CD change. The latter experiment reveals a stoichiometry of four TET repressors per tet operon control region.     

Interaction of lambda cro repressor with synthetic operator OR3 studied by competition binding with minor groove binders.

In the present work, we employ a combination of CD spectroscopy and gel retardation technique to characterize thermodynamically the binding of lambda phage cro repressor to a 17 base pair operator OR3. We have found that three minor groove-binding antibiotics, distamycin A, netropsin and sibiromycin, compete effectively with the cro for binding to the operator OR3. Among these antibiotics, sibiromycin binds covalently to DNA in the minor groove at the NH2 of guanine, whereas distamycin A and netropsin interact preferentially with runs of AT base pairs and avoid DNA regions containing guanine bases in the two polynucleotide strands. Only subtle DNA conformation changes are known to take place upon binding of these antibiotics. Both the CD spectral profiles and the results of the gel retardation experiments indicate that distamycin A and netropsin can displace cro repressor from the operator OR3. The binding of cro repressor to the OR3 is accompanied by considerable changes in CD in the far-UV region which appear to be attributed to a DNA-dependent structural transition in the protein. Spectral changes are also induced in the wavelength region of 270-290 nm. The CD spectral profile of the cro-OR3 mixture in the presence of distamycin A can be represented as a sum of the CD spectrum of the repressor-operator complex and spectrum of distamycin-DNA complex at the appropriate molar ratio of the bound antibiotic to the operator DNA (r). When r tends to the saturation level of binding the CD spectrum in the region of 270-360 nm approaches a CD pattern typical of complexes of the antibiotic with the free DNA oligomer. This suggests that simultaneous binding of cro repressor and distamycin A to the same DNA oligomer is not possible and that distamycin A and netropsin can be used to determine the equilibrium affinity constant of cro repressor to the synthetic operator from competition-type experiments. The binding constant of cro repressor to the OR3 is found to be (6 +/- 1).10(6)M-1 at 20 degrees C in 10 mM sodium cacodylate buffer (pH 7.0) in the presence of 0.1 M NH4F.     

Interaction of the Mnt repressor with 37-base pair synthetic operator DNA fragments. Importance of symmetric GC pairs

Mnt repressor is indirectly responsible for the maintenance of lysogeny of the phage P22. This repressor interacts with a 21-base pair operator DNA constituting within it a 17-base pair perfect 2-fold symmetric sequence whose bases make a direct contact with the protein. We have synthesized six 37-base pair DNAs consisting of 21 base pair natural operator and its modifications in which certain symmetrically situated GC base pairs were replaced systematically with ATs to understand their importance. The binding interaction studies of Mnt repressor to such natural and modified operator DNAs reported here indicate that the GCs close to the center of symmetry make major contacts with the protein whereas, GCs nearer to the periphery form weak contacts. Methylation protection experiments indicated that when the GCs near the center of symmetry were replaced with AT, the central GC became more accessible for dimethyl sulfate methylation with possible conformational change in DNA. The circular dichroism studies indicated that upon repressor binding conformational changes in DNA takes place with a possible increase in helicity of the repressor protein.     

Crystallographic analysis of Lac repressor bound to natural operator O1

Previous structures of Lac repressor bound to DNA used a fully symmetric "ideal" operator sequence that is missing the central G-C base-pair present in the three natural operator sequences. Here we have determined the X-ray crystal structure of a dimeric Lac repressor bound to a 22 base-pair DNA with the natural operator O1 sequence and the anti-inducer ONPF, at 4.0 A resolution. The natural operator is bent in the same way as the symmetric sequence, due to the binding of the hinge helices of the repressor to the minor groove at the central GCGG sequence of O1. Comparison of the structures of the repressor bound to the natural and symmetric operators shows very similar overall structures, with only slight rearrangements of the headpiece domains of the repressor. Analysis of crystals with iodinated DNA shows that the operator is uniquely positioned and allows for the sequence registration of the DNA relative to the repressor to be determined. The kink in the operator is centered between the left half-site and the central G-C base-pair of O1. Our results are most consistent with a previously proposed model in which, relative to the complex with the symmetric operator, the repressor accommodates binding to the natural operator sequence by shifting the position of the right headpiece by one base-pair step towards the center of O1.     

Role of HU and DNA supercoiling in transcription repression: specialized nucleoprotein repression complex at gal promoters in Escherichia coli

Efficient repression of the two promoters P1 and P2 of the gal operon requires the formation of a DNA loop encompassing the promoters. In vitro, DNA looping-mediated repression involves binding of the Gal repressor (GalR) to two gal operators (OE and OI) and binding of the histone-like protein HU to a specific locus (hbs) about the midpoint between OE and OI, and supercoiled DNA. Without DNA looping, GalR binding to OE partially represses P1 and stimulates P2. We investigated the requirement for DNA supercoiling and HU in repression of the gal promoters in vivo in strains containing a fusion of a reporter gene, gusA or lacZ, to each promoter individually. While the P1 promoter was found to be repressible in the absence of DNA supercoiling and HU, the repression of P2 was entirely dependent upon DNA supercoiling in vivo. The P2 promoter was fully derepressed when supercoiling was inhibited by the addition of coumermycin in cells. P2, but not P1, was also totally derepressed by the absence of HU or the OI operator. From these results, we propose that the repression of the gal promoters in vivo is mediated by the formation of a higher order DNA-multiprotein complex containing GalR, HU and supercoiled DNA. In the absence of this complex, P1 but not P2 is still repressed by GalR binding to OE. The specific nucleoprotein complexes involving histone-like proteins, which repress promoter activity while remaining sensitive to inducing signals, as discussed, may occur more generally in bacterial nucleoids.     

Regulation of the Bacillus subtilis W23 xylose utilization operon : interaction of the Xyl repressor with the xyl operator and the inducer xylose

Summary A crude protein extract of Bacillus subtilis W23 contains a sequence-specific DNA binding activity for the xyl operator as detected by the gel mobility shift assay. A xylR determinant encoded on a multicopy plasmid leads to increased expression of this binding activity. In situ footprinting analysis of the protein-DNA complex in a polyacrylamide gel shows that the xyl operator is sequence-specifically bound and protected from cleavage by copper-phenanthroline at 26 phosphodiester bonds on each strand. Quantitative competition assays for repressor binding reveal that a 25 by synthetic xyl operator cloned into a polylinker is bound with the same affinity as the operator in the wild-type xyl regulatory region. This confirms that no additional sites in the wild-type sequence contribute to repressor binding. The xyl operator consists of ten palindromic base pairs flanking five central non-palindromic base pairs. A mutational analysis shows that the sequence of the central base pairs contributes to recognition by the repressor protein and that the spacing of the palindromic elements is crucial for repressor binding. An operator half site is not bound by the repressor. In vivo and in vitro induction studies suggest that, of several structurally similar sugars, xylose is the only molecular inducer of the Xyl repressor.     

Specificity of the interaction between lambda cro repressor protein and operator DNA fragments

Cro repressor protein is known to interact with specific sites in the operator DNA. The cro protein of lambda phage was isolated and the mode of its interaction with three different DNA fragment, lambda-OR3 17mer, phi 80-OR2 19mer and CAP binding site 22-mer, were examined by the use of proton NMR. Some of the imino proton resonances of lambda-OR3 shifted and were broadened remarkably on addition of lambda-cro protein, which indicated the induction of conformational change with complexation. In the spectrum of phi 80-OR2 which has a six base pair sequence common to lambda-OR3 the signals of the common base pairs revealed slight shifts on addition of lambda-cro protein. The imino proton signals of the CAP site DNA, however, did not show any change at all on mixing with lambda-cro. Combining the data of photo CIDNP of lambda-cro, we could postulate the mode of interaction between lambda-cro repressor and operator DNA.     

NMR study of the interaction between the lac repressor and the lac operator

Binding of the lac repressor headpiece, the N-terminal region of the lac repressor, to the lac operator of Escherichia coli was studied by 1H-NMR spectroscopy. Two DNA fragments, of 51 base pairs and 62 base pairs, containing the lac operator region, were investigated. The signals of their hydrogen-bonded imino protons were well resolved in the 500-MHz NMR spectra. The spectra of the free lac operator DNA are similar to those obtained from ring-current-shift calculations for a B-DNA structure. Complex formation with the headpiece led to small but nevertheless characteristic changes in the spectra. The fact that very few imino resonances shifted upon addition of headpiece, as well as the variety in direction and size of these chemical shifts, indicate the formation of a specific complex between the lac repressor and the lac operator. The observed changes in the resonance positions exclude the intercalation of tyrosine residues of the headpiece between adjacent base pairs of the lac operator as well as the formation of a cruciform structure. They rather reflect a small conformational transition in the DNA itself, caused for example by an alteration in the tilt of a few base pairs or a shift of the keto-enol tautomeric equilibrium of the bases towards the enolic form.     

Base sequence-specific interactions of operator DNA fragments with the lambda-cro repressor coupled with changes in their conformations.

The mechanism of interaction of the operator DNA with the lambda-cro repressor protein was investigated using proton n.m.r. and photo CIDNP. Three kinds of DNA duplexes, the lambda-OR3 17-mer, phi80-OR2 19-mer and CRP binding site 22-mer, were prepared, and all of their imino proton resonances of the complexes with lambda-cro were assigned to individual base pairs. By monitoring the assigned signals of the DNA fragments and lambda-cro, it was found that in the complex of lambda-cro with lambda-OR3, two subunits of the cro dimer bind to the right and left halves of the OR3, respectively, and the bidentate binding induces a structural distortion in the middle of the 17-mer. lambda-cro itself also undergoes a conformational change including loosening of the dimeric form. In the complex of lambda-cro with phi 80-OR2, which has a 6-bp sequence common to that of lambda-OR3, one subunit of the cro dimer seems to bind specifically to the common part. However, there is only a slight conformational change in the cro dimer. In the mixture of the CRP binding site 22-mer and lambda-cro, soft contact without any conformational change was observed between them.     

Lac repressor - lac operator interaction. Circular dichroism study.

The interaction between lac repressor and a small operator DNA fragment have been examined by circular dichroism spectroscopy. The binding of lac repressor on the operator induces a conformation change of the DNA which is different from that observed upon non specific binding on non operator DNA. The CD titration curve indicates that the stoechiometry of interaction is complex. A two operators-one repressor complex was found. This result was confirmed by a gel filtration experiment.     

1H NMR and optical spectroscopic investigation of the sequence-dependent dimerization of a symmetrical cyanine dye in the DNA minor groove

A symmetrical cyanine dye was previously shown to bind as a cofacial dimer to alternating A-T sequences of duplex DNA. Indirect evidence suggested that dimerization of the dye occurred in the minor groove. 1H NMR experiments reported here verify this model based on broadening and shifting of signals due to protons on carbon 2 of adenine and imino protons at the central five A-T pairs of the 11 base pair duplex: 5'-GCGTATATGCG-3'/3'-CGCATATACGC-5'. This binding mode is similar to that of distamycin A, even though the dye lacks the hydrogen-bonding groups used by distamycin for sequence-specific recognition. Surprisingly, the third base pair (G-C) was also implicated in the binding site. UV-vis experiments were used to compare the extent of dimerization of the dye for 11 different sequence variants. These experiments verified the importance of a G-C pair at the third position: replacing this pair with A-T suppressed dimerization. These results indicate that the dye binding site spans six base pairs: 5'-GTATAT-3'. The initial G-C pair seems to be important for widening the minor groove rather than for making important contacts with the dye molecules since inverting its orientation to C-G or replacing it with I-C still led to favorable dimerization of the dye.     

Comparison of the structures of operator DNA free and in complex with lambda repressor

The structures of operator DNA unbound and in complex with lambda repressor protein are compared. The conformation of the left 10 base pairs of a lambda right regulatory operator DNA sequence has been previously determined in solution using nuclear magnetic resonance techniques and the structure of a homologous left regulatory operator DNA bound to lambda repressor N-terminal domain had been previously solved using X-ray crystallography. The DNA adopts an overall linear B-form DNA both in the absence and presence of lambda repressor. Superimpositioning of the DNA structures reveals small differences between them that are due to the binding of protein and not to the different techniques used for their determination.     

lac Operator nucleosomes. 2. lac Nucleosomes can change conformation to strengthen binding by lac repressor

We have shown previously that lac repressor binds specifically and quantitatively to lac operator restriction fragments which have been complexed with histones to form artificial nucleosomes (203 base pair restriction fragment) or core particles (144 base pair restriction fragment. We describe here a quantitative method for determining the equilibrium binding affinities of repressor for these lac reconstitutes. Quantitative analysis shows that the operator-histone reconstitutes may be grouped into two affinity classes: those with an affinity for repressor close to that of naked DNA and those with an affinity 2 or more orders of magnitude less than that of naked DNA. All particles in the lac nucleosome preparations bind repressor with high affinity, but the lac core particle preparations contain particles of both high and low affinities for repressor. Formaldehyde cross-linking causes all high-affinity species to suffer a 100-fold decrease in binding affinity. In contrast, there is no effect of cross-linking on species of low affinity. Therefore, the ability of a particle to be bound tightly by repressor depends on a property of the particle which is eliminated by cross-linking. Control experiments have shown that chemical damage to the operator does not accompany cross-linking. Therefore, the property sensitive to cross-linking must be the ability of the particle to change conformation. We infer that the particles of low native affinity, like cross-linked particles, are of low affinity because of an inability to facilitate repressor binding by means of this conformational change. Dimethyl suberimidate cross-linking experiments show that histone-histone cross-linking is sufficient to preclude high-affinity binding. Thus, the necessary conformational change involves a nucleosome histone core event. We find that the ability of a particle to undergo a repressor-induced facilitating conformational change appears to depend on the position of the operator along the DNA binding path of the nucleosome core. We present a general model which proposes that nucleosomes are divided into domains which function differentially to initiate conformational changes in response to physiological stimuli.     

Interaction of lac repressor with alternating poly d (A-T) and poly d (G-C). Circular dichroism studies

The binding of lac repressor to poly d(A-T) and poly d(G-C) has been studied using circular dichroism. The results indicate that the binding induces the same conformational change of both polynucleotides and perturbs the same number of nucleic acid bases (28 bases). It is shown that in 0.1 M phosphate buffer the CD measurement can be used to determine the binding constant of lac repressor to poly d(A-T). Competition experiments performed at various salt concentrations show that the stronger interaction of lac repressor for poly d(A-T) than for poly d(G-C) is based on difference in the dissociation rate of the complexes whereas the association rate for both polymers are similar.     

Mutant λ Repressors with Increased Operator Affinities Reveal New, Specific Protein-DNA Contacts

The binding specificities of four mutant lambda cI repressor proteins with increased affinities for operator DNA were examined. Two mutant repressors (Glu34----Lys and Glu83----Lys) have the same specificity of binding as wild-type repressor, whereas two (Gly48----Ser and Gly48----Asn) have new binding specificities. The Gly48----Asn mutant repressor recognizes lambda operators with changes at base pair 3 with a different order of affinity than wild-type repressor, suggesting that the side chain of Asn48 makes additional specific DNA contacts at or near this base pair. When paired with a change that disrupts the specific interaction of the amino-terminal arm of lambda repressor with DNA (Lys4----Gln), one change that increases the affinity of repressor (Gly48----Ser) suppresses the binding defect of the Lys4----Gln repressor, resulting in a double mutant repressor with a new binding specificity different than that of both its parents and of wild type. These results lend strong support to the model of direct recognition of the lambda operator by lambda repressor proposed from the crystal structure of the repressor/operator complex.     

P22 c2 repressor-operator complex: mechanisms of direct and indirect readout

The P22 c2 repressor protein (P22R) binds to DNA sequence-specifically and helps to direct the temperate lambdoid bacteriophage P22 to the lysogenic developmental pathway. We describe the 1.6 A X-ray structure of the N-terminal domain (NTD) of P22R in a complex with a DNA fragment containing the synthetic operator sequence [d(ATTTAAGATATCTTAAAT)]2. This operator has an A-T base pair at position 9L and a T-A base pair at position 9R and is termed DNA9T. Direct readout: nondirectional van der Waals interactions between protein and DNA appear to confer sequence-specificity. The structure of the P22R NTD-DNA9T complex suggests that sequence-specificity arises substantially from lock-and-key interaction of a valine with a complementary binding cleft on the major groove surface of DNA9T. The cleft is formed by four methyl groups on sequential base pairs of 5'-TTAA-3'. The valine cleft is intrinsic to the DNA sequence and does not arise from protein-induced DNA conformational changes. Protein-DNA hydrogen bonding plays a secondary role in specificity. Indirect readout: it is known that the noncontacted bases in the center of the complex are important determinants of affinity. The protein induces a transition of the noncontacted region from B-DNA to B'-DNA. The B' state is characterized by a narrow minor groove and a zigzag spine of hydration. The free energy of the transition from B- to B'-DNA is known to depend on the sequence. Thus, the observed DNA conformation and hydration allows for the formulation of a predictive model of the indirect readout phenomenon.