Saturation transfer, continuous wave saturation, and saturation recovery electron spin resonance studies of chain-spin labeled phosphatidylcholines in the low temperature phases of dipalmitoyl phosphatidylcholine bilayers. Effects of rotational dynamics and spin-spin interactions.

The saturation transfer electron spin resonance (STESR) spectra of 10 different positional isomers of phosphatidylcholine spin-labeled in the sn-2 chain have been investigated in the low temperature phases of dipalmitoyl phosphatidylcholine (DPPC) bilayers. The results of continuous wave saturation and of saturation recovery measurements on the conventional ESR spectra were used to define the saturation properties necessary for interpreting the STESR results in terms of the chain dynamics. Spin labels with the nitroxide group located in the center of the chain tended to segregate preferentially from the DPPC host lipids in the more ordered phases, causing spin-spin interactions which produced spectral broadening and had a very pronounced effect on the saturation characteristics of the labels. This was accompanied by a large decrease in the STESR spectral intensities and diagnostic line height ratios relative to those of spin labels that exhibited a higher degree of saturation at the same microwave power. The temperature dependence of the STESR spectra of the different spin label isomers revealed a sharp increase in the rate of rotation about the long axis of the lipid chains at approximately 25 degrees C, correlating with the pretransition of gel phase DPPC bilayers, and a progressive increase in the segmental motion towards the terminal methyl end of the chains in all phases. Prolonged incubation at low temperatures led to an increase in the diagnostic STESR line height ratios in all regions of the spectrum, reflecting the decrease in chain mobility accompanying formation of the subgel phase. Continuous recording of the central diagnostic peak height of the STESR spectra while scanning the temperature revealed a discontinuity at approximately 14-17 degrees C, corresponding to the DPPC subtransition which occurred only on the initial upward temperature scan, in addition to the discontinuity at 29-31 degrees C corresponding to the pretransition which displayed hysteresis on the downward temperature scan.     

Saturation transfer electron spin resonance of Ca2(+)-ATPase covalently spin-labeled with beta-substituted vinyl ketone- and maleimide-nitroxide derivatives. Effects of segmental motion and labeling levels.

The Ca2(+)-ATPase in native sarcoplasmic reticulum membranes was selectively spin-labeled for saturation transfer electron spin resonance (ESR) studies by prelabeling with N-ethylmaleimide and by using low label/protein ratios. Results with the nitroxide derivative of the standard sulphydryl-modifying reagent, maleimide, were compared with a series of six novel nitroxide beta-substituted vinyl aryl ketone derivatives which differed (with two exceptions) in the substituent at the ketone position. The two exceptions had a different electron withdrawing group at the alpha-carbon, to enhance further the electrophilic character of the beta-carbon. Although differing in their reactivity, all the conjugated unsaturated ketone nitroxide derivatives displayed saturation transfer ESR spectra indicative of much slower motion than did the maleimide derivative. The saturation transfer ESR spectra of maleimide-labeled Ca2(+)-ATPase therefore most likely contain substantial contributions from segmental motion of the labeled group. The effects of the level of spin labeling were also investigated. With increasing degree of spin label incorporation, the linewidths of the conventional ESR spectrum progressively increased and the intensity of the saturation transfer spectrum dropped dramatically, as a result of increasing spin-spin interactions. The hyperfine splittings of the conventional spectrum and the outer lineheight ratios of the saturation transfer spectrum remained relatively unchanged. Extrapolation back to zero labeling level yielded comparable values for the effective rotational correlation times deduced from the saturation transfer spectrum intensities and from the lineheight ratios, for the vinyl ketone label. For the maleimide label the extrapolated values from the integral are significantly lower than those from the lineheight ratios, probably because of the segmental motion. Comparison is made of the effective rotational correlation time for the vinyl ketone label with the predictions of hydrodynamic models for the protein diffusion, in a discussion of the aggregation state of the Ca2(+)-ATPase in the native sarcoplasmic reticulum membrane. The implications for the study of protein rotational diffusion and segmental motion, and of the proximity relationships between labeled groups, using saturation transfer ESR spectroscopy are discussed.     

A spin-label study of membrane proteins and internal microviscosity of erythrocytes in hereditary spherocytosis

Electron spin resonance (ESR) spectra of erythrocyte membranes of patients with hereditary spherocytosis (HS) and of healthy controls labeled with a maleimide spin label did not differ significantly both before and after prolonged incubation at 37 degrees C. It suggests that the different behavior of spin-labeled HS erythrocyte membranes upon incubation at a higher temperature reported previously is due indeed to structural abnormalities of HS red cell membranes and not to alterations in their proteolytic activity. Measurements of the rotational correlation time of Tempamine spin probe demonstrated a significant elevation of internal microviscosity of erythrocytes in HS, more pronounced in non-splenectomized patients.     

Electron spin resonance study of human alpha 1-acid glycoprotein interaction with a spin labelled steroid.

The interaction of human alpha 1-acid glycoprotein (AAG) with a corticosteroid was studied using nitroxide labeled deoxycorticosterone and electron spin resonance (ESR) spectroscopy. The ESR spectra of the spin labeled steroid in the presence of AAG could be used to characterize the ligand-protein interaction at equilibrium without the need of a separation between bound and free species. An association constant Ka of 6.10(5) M-1 at 20 degrees C and a binding capacity of one site per mole protein were found. ESR spectra recorded at equilibrium at various temperatures allowed the calculation of enthalpy and entropy variations for the steroid-protein interaction; these thermodynamic parameters exhibited a rapid change above 45 degrees C which may be related to a protein conformational modification above this temperature, as detected by circular dichroism study. The ESR spectra width could be used to define a polar character for the spin label environment in the steroid binding site of AAG and to calculate an apparent rotational correlation time of 2.8 x 10(-8) sec for the steroid-protein complex in aqueous solution at 20 degrees C. It can be concluded that spin labeling and ESR methodology is of value in the study of steroid-protein interactions of biological significance above all because it can provide direct physico-chemical information concerning the local environment of the ligand in its binding site at equilibrium.     

Saturation transfer electron paramagnetic resonance on membrane-bound proteins. I-Rotational diffusion of rhodopsin in the visual receptor membrane.

We have applied the technique of saturation transfer electron paramagnetic resonance to the study of spin labeled membrane-bound bovine rhodopsin. Based on the comparison with theoretical and experimental spectra corresponding to isotropic slow motion, the present data leads to a rotational correlation time for the membrane-bound rhodopsin molecule of 20 μsec at 20°C. Bleaching does not appear to influence the motion of the protein while addition of glutaraldehyde (5%) stops its rotation completely. These results are in good agreement with what is known about the motion of the membrane-bound rhodopsin, establishing the applicability of the saturation transfer technique to the study of slow anisotropic motions of membrane-bound proteins.     

Specific spin labelling of the sugar-H(+) symporter, GalP, in cell membranes of Escherichia coli: site mobility and overall rotational diffusion of the protein

The D-galactose-H(+) symport protein (GalP) of Escherichia coli is a homologue of the human glucose transport protein, GLUT1. After amplified expression of the GalP transporter in E. coli, other membrane proteins were prereacted with N-ethylmaleimide in the presence of excess D-galactose to protect GalP. Inner membranes were then specifically spin labelled on Cys(374) of GalP with 4-maleimide-2,2,6,6-tetramethylpiperidine-1-oxyl. The electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectra are characteristic of a single labelling site in which the mobility of the spin label is very highly constrained. This is confirmed with other nitroxyl spin labels, which are derivatives of iodoacetamide and indanedione. Saturation transfer EPR spectra indicate that the overall rotation of the GalP protein in the membrane is slow at low temperatures (approx. 2 degrees C), but considerably more rapid and highly anisotropic at physiological temperatures. The rate of rotation about the membrane normal at 37 degrees C is consistent with predictions for a 12-transmembrane helix assembly that is less than closely packed.     

Spin label saturation transfer ESR studies of protein-lipid interactions in Photosystem II-enriched membranes

Saturation transfer ESR has been used to study the dynamic behaviour of lipids in the appressed regions of thylakoid membranes from pea seedlings. Four different phospho- and galacto-lipid spin labels (phosphatidylcholine labelled at the 12 or 14 C-atom positions of the sn-2 chain, phosphatidylglycerol labelled at the 14-position of the sn-2 chain, and monogalactosyldiacylglycerol labelled at the 12-position of the sn-2 chain) were used to probe the lipid environment in photosystem II-enriched membranes prepared by detergent extraction. The ESR spectra show that the majority of the lipid in these preparations is strongly motionally restricted. Values for the effective rotational correlation times of the labelled chains were deduced from the lineheight ratios and integrals of thhe saturation transfer ESR spectra. The effective rotational correlation times were found to be in the 10⁵ range, indicating a very low lipid chain mobility which correlates with the low lipid content of these preparations. Comparison of the effective rotational correlation times deduced from the different diagnostic regions of the spectrum revealed little anisotropy in the chain mobility, indicating that the dominant motional mode was trans-gauche isomerization. The effective rotational correlation times deduced from the spectral integrals were similar to those deduced from the lineheight ratios, consistent with the absence of any appreciable fluid lipid component in these preparations. The results also indicate some selectivity of interaction between the lipid species, with phosphatidylcholine exhibiting appreciably slower motion than either phosphatidylglycerol or monogalactosyldiacylglycerol.     

Librational motion of an "immobilized" spin label: hemoglobin spin labeled by a maleimide derivative.

The spin label Tempo-maleimide, when "immobilized" in hemoglobin, is shown to exhibit motional fluctuation whose amplitude and/or frequency depend on temperature and solution conditions. These motional fluctuations are observable by several electron spin resonance techniques. For desalted hemoglobin the fluctuations are detectable at approximately -15 degrees C using saturation transfer techniques and at approximately +25 degrees C using line-width measurements of normal absorption spectra. In ammonium sulfate precipitated hemoglobin, however, motional fluctuations are not detectable by either technique up to at least 40 degrees C. The most probable mechanism for spin-label motion appears to be either fluctuations in protein conformation which affect the label binding site or conformational transitions of the nitroxide ring itself. These motional fluctuations are shown to introduce a librational character to the overall label motion during hemoglobin rotational diffusion, with the librational motion significantly affecting the use of spin-label spectral shapes to calculate hemoglobin rotational correlation times.     

Saturation transfer electron parametric resonance of an indane-dione spin-label. Calibration with hemoglobin and application to myosin rotational dynamics.

We have used a recently synthesized indane-dione spin label (2-[-oxyl-2,2,5,5-tetramethyl-3-pyrrolin-3-yl)methenyl]in dane-1,3-dione (InVSL) to study the rotational dynamics of myosin, with saturation-transfer electron paramagnetic resonance (ST-EPR). To determine effective rotational correlation times (tau effr) from InVSL spectra, reference spectra corresponding to known correlation times (tau r) were obtained from InVSL-hemoglobin undergoing isotropic rotational motion in aqueous glycerol solutions. These spectra were used to generate plots of spectral parameters vs. tau r. These plots should be used to analyze ST-EPR spectra of InVSL bound to other proteins, because the spectra are different from those of tempo-maleimide-spin-labeled hemoglobin, which have been used previously as ST-EPR standards. InVSL was covalently attached to the head (subfragment-1; S1) of myosin. EPR spectra and K/EDTA-ATPase activity showed that 70-95% of the heads were labeled, with > or = 90% of the label bound to either cys 707 (SH1) or cys 697 (SH2). ST-EPR spectra of InVSL-S1 attached to glass beads, bound to actin in myofibrils, or precipitated with ammonium sulfate indicated no submillisecond rotational motion. Therefore, InVSL is rigidly immobilized on the protein so that it reports the global rotation of the myosin head. The ST-EPR spectra of InVSL-myosin monomers and filaments indicated tau effr values of 4 and 13 microseconds, respectively, showing that myosin heads undergo microsecond segmental rotations that are more restricted in filaments than in monomers. The observed tau effr values are longer than those previously obtained with other spin labels bound to myosin heads, probably because InVSL binds more rigidly to the protein and/or with a different orientation. Further EPR studies of InVSL-myosin in solution and in muscle fibers should prove complementary to previous work with other labels.     

Order measurements in plasma membranes from Duchenne dystrophy fibroblasts

Plasma membranes have been isolated using different methods from Duchenne dystrophy and control human skin fibroblasts. Fluorescence techniques were utilized to resolve the rotational properties and the degree of hindered rotation of the fluorescent probe, 1,6-diphenyl-1,3,5-hexatriene in the membranes. Under specific conditions of fibroblast processing and membrane fractionation, plasma membranes from Duchenne fibroblasts showed significantly less order (0.0125 greater than P less than 0.0025) and less hindrance to probe rotation than membranes from control fibroblasts. The order differences did not seem to be the result of heterogeneity in the membrane environment sampled by the probe. The frequency dependence of the fluorescence lifetime for diphenylhexatriene indicated no measurable contribution by a short lifetime component. Analysis of diphenylhexatriene rotation in the plasma membranes using the 'wobbling-in-cone' theory suggested that both the angle of probe rotation (theta c) and the rotational rate (Dw) were important parameters in understanding the variations between Duchenne and control membranes at 16, 22 and 30 degrees C. Electron spin resonance studies with 5'-doxylstearic acid at 25 degrees C confirmed our fluorescence results. The segmental motion exhibited by the spin label revealed less order in the Duchenne membranes.     

Dynamic equilibrium between the two conformational states of spin-labeled tropomyosin

Tropomyosin was labeled with a maleimide nitroxide spin-label attached to cysteine-190 via a succinimido ring which was subsequently opened by incubation at alkaline pH. Electron spin resonance (ESR) spectra showed a temperature-dependent equilibrium, below the main unfolding transition of tropomyosin, between labels which were restricted in their motion (strongly immobilized), predominating at low temperatures, and those which were highly mobile (weakly immobilized), predominating at higher temperatures. These label states were associated with two protein states from a comparison of the ESR spectral changes with the thermal unfolding profile of tropomyosin. The strongly immobilized labels were associated with the completely folded molded and the weakly immobilized labels with a partially unfolded (in the cysteine-190 region) state which is an intermediate in the thermal unfolding of tropomyosin. A spectral subtraction technique was used to measure the concentration ratio of strongly and weakly immobilized labels from which an equilibrium constant, K, was determined at different temperatures. A linear van't Hoff plot was obtained, indicating that the spin-labeled protein is in thermal equilibrium between these two conformational states with delta H = 17 kcal/mol, delta S = 56 cal/(deg X mol), and K = 1.0 at 34 degrees C. An upper limit of 10(7) s-1 for the conformational fluctuation was estimated from the shapes and separation of the two ESR spectral components. In contrast to the label with the opened succinimido ring, the spin-label with an intact succinimido ring remained strongly immobilized on the protein, indicating that in the partially unfolded state the molecule retains structure in the cysteine-190 region.     

Rotational motion of yeast cytochrome oxidase in phosphatidylcholine complexes studied by saturation-transfer electron spin resonance

Cytochrome oxidase from yeast has been covalently labeled with a nitroxide derivative of maleimide and reconstituted in lipid-substituted complexes with dimyristoyl-, dioleoyl-, or dielaidoyl-phosphatidylcholine. The rotational mobility of the enzyme in the complexes has been studied as a function of temperature and time, and of lipid/protein ratio, using saturation-transfer electron spin resonance spectroscopy. For complexes with dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine, the rotational mobility of the protein decreases abruptly below the gel-to-fluid-phase transition. This change is accompanied by a lateral segregation of the protein, as seen by freeze-fracture electron microscopy, and by an increase in the activation energy for the enzymatic activity. A time-dependent decrease in the rotational motion of the protein is observed on incubating at temperatures in the fluid phase of the lipid. This corresponds with a time-dependent loss of enzyme activity observed on incubation at temperatures in the fluid phase, but not at temperatures in the gel phase, over a period of 3 h. The rotational mobility decreases with increasing protein concentration in the complexes, both in the fluid and in the gel phases. The dependence of the protein mobility on lipid/protein ratio can be interpreted quantitatively in terms of the effect of increased random protein-protein contacts in the fluid phase. The maximum limiting rotational correlation time for the protein diffusion at high lipid/protein ratios in the fluid phase is tau R[[ approximately equal to 25 microseconds, suggesting that the protein is present as either a monomer or more probably a dimer in the reconstituted membrane.     

Large-scale rotational motions of proteins detected by electron paramagnetic resonance and fluorescence.

Direct spectroscopic measurements of rotational motions of proteins and large protein segments are crucial to understanding the molecular dynamics of protein function. Fluorescent probes and spin labels attached to proteins have proved to be powerful tools in the study of large-scale protein motions. Fluorescence depolarization and conventional electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) are applicable to the study of rotational motions in the nanosecond-to-microsecond time range, and have been used to demonstrate segmental flexibility in an antibody and in myosin. Very slow rotational motions, occurring in the microsecond-to-millisecond time range, are particularly important in supramolecular assemblies, where protein motions are restricted by association with other molecules. Saturation transfer spectroscopy (ST-EPR), a recently developed electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) technique that permits the detection of rotational correlation times as long as 1 ms, has been used to detect large-scale rotational motions of spin-labeled proteins in muscle filaments and in membranes, providing valuable insights into energy transduction mechanisms in these assemblies.     

Saturation transfer electron spin resonance study on the rotational diffusion of calcium- and magnesium-dependent adenosine triphosphatase in sarcoplasmic reticulum membranes.

The technique of saturation transfer electron spin resonance has been applied to study the rotational diffusion of spin-labeled Ca2+, Mg2+-dependent ATPase molecules in the membranes of sarcoplasmic reticulum vesicles. Comparison of the present data with those for spin-labeled hemoglobin undergoing isotropic rotation leads to a value of 2 X 10(-4) s for the apparent rotational correlation time at 20 degrees C for the membrane-bound protein. Consideration of the anisotropy of the Brownian rotation of the membrane-bound ATPase suggests that the true correlation time for the expected axial rotation may be somewhat smaller than the apparent value. An Arrhenius plot of the rotational motion shows a break, which is interpreted as indicating the occurrence of a conformational change of the ATPase molecule at about 15 degrees C.     

Determination of the correlation time of the lysozyme molecule and lysozyme-inhibitor complex using a spin-label method

Temperature relationships of rotational correlation times (tau M) of lysozyme molecules were studied using viscosity method based on the model of slow feebly anisotropic rotation of label N-O-group. Protein is mainly associated in 0.01 phosphate buffer (pH 7.3) at 5-30 degrees C. Formation of the complex of lysozyme with competitive inhibitor (3-N-AGA) leads to changes of tau M. It may be due to a decrease of polymerization degree and increase of the protein packing. It is suggested that two-component form of ESR spectra of different spin labeled proteins reflects their common ability for pulsations between more and less compact conformers due to the thermal relative movements of domains and subunits.     

Spin labeling of calcium-dependent phospholipid-binding proteins

Bovine lung annexins p32 and p34 were spin labeled with an iodoacetamidoproxyl spin label, a reagent that reportedly couples with protein methionine residues. Labeling conditions and stoichiometry were studied with the radiolabeled analogue [1-14C]iodoacetamide. As judged by this method, carboxamidomethylation of both p32 and p34 occurred up to a 0.7 mol ratio after 60 h of reaction at 37 degrees C and at pH 4. The two proteins retained Ca2(+)-dependent phospholipid-binding ability both in radiolabeled and in spin-labeled forms. Electron resonance spectra of spin-labeled p32 and p34 showed the features of a partially immobilized spin probe, with rotational correlation time values of 1.15 and 1.25 ns, respectively, which definitely indicate successful spin labeling. Quantitation of ESR spectra by computer double integration indicated 70% spin labeling of both proteins, as anticipated by radiolabeling. The use of spin-labeled p32 and p34 in the study of Ca2(+)-dependent interaction of annexins with biomembranes is proposed.     

Hyperthermic modification of bleomycin--DNA interaction detected by electron spin resonance

Electron spin resonance spectra of DNA labeled with each of four spin-labeling compounds have been studied to detect interaction between the antibiotic bleomycin and DNA. Only one of these labels, compound IV, resulted in a modified spectrum when bound to DNA and the latter was subjected to bleomycin. This property has been used to monitor DNA-bleomycin interactions under physiological and hyperthermic conditions. Bleomycin produced an increase in rotational correlation time of the residue bound to DNA at 37 degrees C and a significantly higher increase at 43 degrees C. Some effect was still detected with bleomycin at 37 degrees C after preheating at 43 degrees C. Parallel studies have revealed enhanced binding of 59Fe-bleomycin to DNA during and after hyperthermic treatment.     

Orientational dynamics of indane dione spin-labeled myosin heads in relaxed and contracting skeletal muscle fibers.

We have used electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectroscopy to study the orientation and rotational motions of spin-labeled myosin heads during steady-state relaxation and contraction of skinned rabbit psoas muscle fibers. Using an indane-dione spin label, we obtained EPR spectra corresponding specifically to probes attached to Cys 707 (SH1) on the catalytic domain of myosin heads. The probe is rigidly immobilized, so that it reports the global rotation of the myosin head, and the probe's principal axis is aligned almost parallel with the fiber axis in rigor, making it directly sensitive to axial rotation of the head. Numerical simulations of EPR spectra showed that the labeled heads are highly oriented in rigor, but in relaxation they have at least 90 degrees (Gaussian full width) of axial disorder, centered at an angle approximately equal to that in rigor. Spectra obtained in isometric contraction are fit quite well by assuming that 79 +/- 2% of the myosin heads are disordered as in relaxation, whereas the remaining 21 +/- 2% have the same orientation as in rigor. Computer-simulated spectra confirm that there is no significant population (> 5%) of heads having a distinct orientation substantially different (> 10 degrees) from that in rigor, and even the large disordered population of heads has a mean orientation that is similar to that in rigor. Because this spin label reports axial head rotations directly, these results suggest strongly that the catalytic domain of myosin does not undergo a transition between two distinct axial orientations during force generation. Saturation transfer EPR shows that the rotational disorder is dynamic on the microsecond time scale in both relaxation and contraction. These results are consistent with models of contraction involving 1) a transition from a dynamically disordered preforce state to an ordered (rigorlike) force-generating state and/or 2) domain movements within the myosin head that do not change the axial orientation of the SH1-containing catalytic domain relative to actin.     

Indanedione spin labelling of Na,K-ATPase

The indanedione series of vinyl ketone spin-labelling reagents has been extended in two ways: by increasing the length of the rigid spacer between the reactive centre and the nitroxide ring, or by introducing an electrophilic substituent (that could also hinder its rotation) at the bridge head position of the nitroxide ring. Three reagents of this new series have been used to spin label the Class II thiol groups of membranous Na,K-ATPase from Squalus acanthias. With a conjugated diene spacer, the majority of spin labels are strongly held but a minor population is relatively mobile at 37 degrees C. With a conjugated triene spacer, the nitroxide is still strongly held but a portion of the label is non-covalently bound. The 4-bromo-pyrroline derivative (with short vinyl spacer) is tightly held at the attachment site, and the conventional electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectra distinguish between the two enantiomeric structures which differ in their mobility at 37 degrees C. Saturation transfer EPR (ST-EPR) spectra of this label at 4 degrees C have been used to determine the dependence of the protein rotational mobility on ionic strength. Electrostatic repulsion contributes to the lateral interactions between Na,K-ATPase molecules.     

Temperature dependence of rotational dynamics of protein and lipid in sarcoplasmic reticulum membranes

We have investigated the relationship between function and molecular dynamics of both the lipid and the Ca-ATPase protein in sarcoplasmic reticulum (SR), using temperature as a means of altering both activity and rotational dynamics. Conventional and saturation-transfer electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) was used to probe rotational motions of spin-labels attached either to fatty acid hydrocarbon chains or to the Ca-ATPase sulfhydryl groups in SR. EPR studies were also performed on aqueous dispersions of extracted SR lipids, in order to study intrinsic lipid properties independent of the protein. While an Arrhenius plot of the Ca-ATPase activity exhibits a clear change in slope at 20 degrees C, Arrhenius plots of lipid hydrocarbon chain mobility are linear, indicating that an abrupt thermotropic change in the lipid hydrocarbon phase is not responsible for the Arrhenius break in enzymatic activity. The presence of protein was found to decrease the average hydrocarbon chain mobility, but linear Arrhenius plots were observed both in the intact SR and in extracted lipids. Lipid EPR spectra were analyzed by procedures that prevent the production of artifactual breaks in the Arrhenius plots. Similarly, using sample preparations and spectral analysis methods that minimize the temperature-dependent contribution of local probe mobility to the spectra of spin-labeled Ca-ATPase, we find that Arrhenius plots of overall protein rotational mobility also exhibit no change in slope. The activation energy for protein mobility is the same as that of ATPase activity above 20 degrees C; we discuss the possibility that overall protein mobility may be essential to the rate-limiting step above 20 degrees C.