Bacteriophage lysis: mechanism and regulation.

Bacteriophage lysis involves at least two fundamentally different strategies. Most phages elaborate at least two proteins, one of which is a murein hydrolase, or lysin, and the other is a membrane protein, which is given the designation holin in this review. The function of the holin is to create a lesion in the cytoplasmic membrane through which the murein hydrolase passes to gain access to the murein layer. This is necessary because phage-encoded lysins never have secretory signal sequences and are thus incapable of unassisted escape from the cytoplasm. The holins, whose prototype is the lambda S protein, share a common organization in terms of the arrangement of charged and hydrophobic residues, and they may all contain at least two transmembrane helical domains. The available evidence suggests that holins oligomerize to form nonspecific holes and that this hole-forming step is the regulated step in phage lysis. The correct scheduling of the lysis event is as much an essential feature of holin function as is the hole formation itself. In the second strategy of lysis, used by the small single-stranded DNA phage phi X174 and the single-stranded RNA phage MS2, no murein hydrolase activity is synthesized. Instead, there is a single species of small membrane protein, unlike the holins in primary structure, which somehow causes disruption of the envelope. These lysis proteins function by activation of cellular autolysins. A host locus is required for the lytic function of the phi X174 lysis gene E.     

Biochemical and genetic evidence for three transmembrane domains in the class I holin, lambda S

lambda S, the prototype class I holin gene, encodes three potential transmembrane domains in its 107 codons, whereas 21 S, the class II prototype spans only 71 codons and encodes two transmembrane domains. Many holin genes, including lambda S and 21 S, have the "dual-start" regulatory motif at the N terminus, suggesting that class I and II holins have the same topology. The primary structure of 21 S strongly suggests a bitopic "helical-hairpin" topology, with N and C termini on the cytoplasmic side of the membrane. However, lambda S chimeras with an N-terminal signal sequence show Lep-dependent function, indicating that the N-terminal domain of S requires export. Here the signal sequence chimera is shown to be sensitive to the missense change A52V, which blocks normal S function. Moreover, cysteine-modification studies in isolated membranes using a collection of S variants with single-cysteine substitutions show that the positions in the core of the 3 putative transmembrane domains of lambda S are protected. Also, S proteins with single-cysteine substitutions in the predicted cytoplasmic and periplasmic loops are more efficiently labeled in inverted membrane vesicles and whole cells, respectively. These data constitute direct evidence that the holin S(lambda) has three transmembrane domains and indicate that class I and class II holins have different topologies, despite regulatory and functional homology.     

Functional analysis of the phage T4 holin in a λ context

Phage lambda hybrids were constructed by inserting the t gene of phage T4 in place of the lambda holin gene, S. Induction of the hybrid phage resulted in lysis that was just as abrupt as, but occurred much earlier in the vegetative cycle than, that obtained with lambda, indicating that t is indeed a holin gene. Moreover, it was possible to impose lysis inhibition (LIN) on induction of the hybrid phage, but not of the parental lambda phage, by superinfection with LIN-competent T4. The imposition of the LIN state was found to depend on the allelic state of the rI and t genes of the superinfecting T4 phage, indicating that the LIN-sensitive state of the T holin is transient. Finally, induction of lysogens carrying both holin genes was shown to result in earlier triggering of lysis than with either holin gene alone. This result suggests that the two very dissimilar holins contribute additively to the physiology of the timing mechanism, or, less likely, that they interact to form one mass-action pool. In either case, these results imply a common pathway for holin timing and function.     

Export of the pneumococcal phage SV1 lysin requires choline‐containing teichoic acids and is holin‐independent

Streptococcus pneumoniae bacteriophages (phages) rely on a holin–lysin system to accomplish host lysis. Due to the lack of lysin export signals, it is assumed that holin disruption of the cytoplasmic membrane allows endolysin access to the peptidoglycan. We investigated the lysis mechanism of pneumococcal phage SV1, by using lysogens without holin activity. Upon phage induction in a holin deficient background, phage lysin was gradually targeted to the cell wall, in spite of lacking any obvious signal sequence. Our data indicate that export of the phage lysin requires the presence of choline in the teichoic acids, an unusual characteristic of pneumococci. At the bacterial surface, the exolysin remains bound to choline residues without inducing lysis, but is readily activated by the collapse of the membrane potential. Additionally, the activation of the major autolysin LytA, which also participates in phage‐mediated lysis, is equally related to perturbations of the membrane proton motive force. These results indicate that collapse of the membrane potential by holins is sufficient to trigger bacterial lysis. We found that the lysin of phage SV1 reaches the peptidoglycan through a novel holin‐independent pathway and propose that the same mechanism could be used by other pneumococcal phages.     

Probing the Structure of the S105 Hole

For most phages, holins control the timing of host lysis. During the morphogenesis period of the infection cycle, canonical holins accumulate harmlessly in the cytoplasmic membrane until they suddenly trigger to form lethal lesions called holes. The holes can be visualized by cryo-electron microscopy and tomography as micrometer-scale interruptions in the membrane. To explore the fine structure of the holes formed by the lambda holin, S105, a cysteine-scanning accessibility study was performed. A collection of S105 alleles encoding holins with a single Cys residue in different positions was developed and characterized for lytic function. Based on the ability of 4-acetamido-4′-((iodoacetyl) amino) stilbene-2,2′-disulfonic acid, disodium salt (IASD), to modify these Cys residues, one face of transmembrane domain 1 (TMD1) and TMD3 was judged to face the lumen of the S105 hole. In both cases, the lumen-accessible face was found to correspond to the more hydrophilic face of the two TMDs. Judging by the efficiency of IASD modification, it was concluded that the bulk of the S105 protein molecules were involved in facing the lumen. These results are consistent with a model in which the perimeters of the S105 holes are lined by the holin molecules present at the time of lysis. Moreover, the findings that TMD1 and TMD3 face the lumen, coupled with previous results showing TMD2-TMD2 contacts in the S105 dimer, support a model in which membrane depolarization drives the transition of S105 from homotypic to heterotypic oligomeric interactions.     

Functional Analysis of a Class I Holin,P2 Y

Y is the putative holin gene of the paradigm coliphage P2 and encodes a 93-amino-acid protein. Y is predicted to be an integral membrane protein that adopts an N-out C-in membrane topology with 3 transmembrane domains (TMDs) and a highly charged C-terminal cytoplasmic tail. The same features are observed in the canonical class I lambda holin, the S105 protein of phage lambda, which controls lysis by forming holes in the plasma membrane at a programmed time. S105 has been the subject of intensive genetic, cellular, and biochemical analyses. Although Y is not related to S105 in its primary structure, its characterization might prove useful in discerning the essential traits for holin function. Here, we used physiological and genetic approaches to show that Y exhibits the essential holin functional criteria, namely, allele-specific delayed-onset lethality and sensitivity to the energization of the membrane. Taken together, these results suggest that class I holins share a set of unusual features that are needed for their remarkable ability to program the end of the phage infection cycle with precise timing. However, Y holin function requires the integrity of its short cytoplasmic C-terminal domain, unlike for S105. Finally, instead of encoding a second translational product of Y as an antiholin, as shown for lambda S107, the P2 lysis cassette encodes another predicted membrane protein, LysA, which is shown here to have a Y-specific antiholin character.     

Sizing the holin lesion with an endolysin-beta-galactosidase fusion

Double-stranded DNA phages require two proteins for efficient host lysis: the endolysin, a muralytic enzyme, and the holin, a small membrane protein. In an event that defines the end of the vegetative cycle, the lambda holin S acts suddenly to permeabilize the membrane. This permeabilization enables the R endolysin to attack the cell wall, after which cell lysis occurs within seconds. A C-terminal fusion of the R endolysin with full-length beta-galactosidase (beta-Gal) was tested for lytic competence in the context of the late-gene expression system of an induced lambda lysogen. Under these conditions, the hybrid R-beta-Gal product, an active tetrameric beta-Gal greater than 480 kDa in mass, was fully functional in lysis mediated by the S holin. Western blot analysis demonstrated that the lytic competence was not due to the proteolytic release of the endolysin domain of the R-beta-Gal fusion protein. The ability of this massive complex to be released by the S holin suggests that S causes a generalized membrane disruption rather than a regular oligomeric membrane pore. Similar results were obtained with an early lysis variant of the S holin and also in parallel experiments with the T4 holin, T, in an identical lambda context. However, premature holin lesions triggered by depolarization of the membrane were nonpermissive for the hybrid endolysin, indicating that these premature lesions constituted less-profound damage to the membrane. Finally, a truncated T holin functional in lysis with the endolysin is completely incompetent for lysis with the hybrid endolysin. A model for the formation of the membrane lesion within homo-oligomeric rafts of holin proteins is discussed.     

Reconstitution of holin activity with a synthetic peptide containing the 1-32 sequence region of EJh,the EJ-1 phage holin

Pneumococcal EJ-1 phage holin (EJh) is a hydrophobic polypeptide of 85 amino acid residues displaying lethal inner membrane disruption activity. To get an insight into holin structure and function, several peptides representing the different topological regions predicted by sequence analysis have been synthesized. Peptides were structurally characterized in both aqueous buffer and membrane environments, and their potential to induce membrane perturbation was determined. Among them, only the N-terminal predicted transmembrane helix increased the membrane permeability. This segment, only when flanked by the positive charged residues on its N-terminal side, which are present in the sequence of the full-length protein, folds into a major alpha-helix structure with a transmembrane preferential orientation. Fluorescein quenching experiments of N-terminal-labeled peptide evidenced the formation of oligomers of variable size depending on the peptideto-lipid molar ratio. The self-assembling tendency correlated with the formation of transmembrane pores that permit the release of encapsulated dextrans of various sizes. When analyzed by atomic force microscopy, peptide-induced membrane lesions are visualized as transbilayer holes. These findings are the first evidence for a lytic domain in holins and for the nature of membrane lesions caused by them.     

Rz/Rz1 lysis gene equivalents in phages of Gram-negative hosts

Under usual laboratory conditions, lysis by bacteriophage lambda requires only the holin and endolysin genes, but not the Rz and Rz1 genes, of the lysis cassette. Defects in Rz or Rz1 block lysis only in the presence of high concentrations of divalent cations. The lambda Rz and Rz1 lysis genes are remarkable in that Rz1, encoding an outer membrane lipoprotein, is completely embedded in the +1 register within Rz, which itself encodes an integral inner membrane protein. While Rz and Rz1 equivalents have been identified in T7 and P2, most phages, including such well-studied classic phages as T4, P1, T1, Mu and SP6, lack annotated Rz/Rz1 equivalents. Here we report that a search strategy based primarily on gene arrangement and membrane localization signals rather than sequence similarity has revealed that Rz/Rz1 equivalents are nearly ubiquitous among phages of Gram-negative hosts, with 120 of 137 phages possessing genes that fit the search criteria. In the case of T4, a deletion of a non-overlapping gene pair pseT.2 and pseT.3 identified as Rz/Rz1 equivalents resulted in the same divalent cation-dependent lysis phenotype. Remarkably, in T1 and six other phages, Rz/Rz1 pairs were not found but a single gene encoding an outer membrane lipoprotein with a C-terminal transmembrane domain capable of integration into the inner membrane was identified. These proteins were named "spanins," since their protein products are predicted to span the periplasm providing a physical connection between the inner and outer membranes. The T1 spanin gene was shown to complement the lambda Rz-Rz1- lysis defect, indicating that spanins function as Rz/Rz1 equivalents. The widespread presence of Rz/Rz1 or their spanin equivalents in phages of Gram-negative hosts suggests a strong selective advantage and that their role in the ecology of these phages is greater than that inferred from the mild laboratory phenotype.     

Characterization of the dual start motif of a class II holin gene

Holins are small membrane proteins that, at a genetically programmed time in a bacteriophage infective cycle, allow bacteriolytic enzymes, or endolysins, to escape to the periplasm and to attack the cell wall. Most holins fall into two sequence classes, I and II, based on the number of potential transmembrane domains (three for class I and two for class II). The prototype class I holin gene, S  ^λ, has a dual start motif and encodes not only the effector holin, S^λ105, but also an inhibitor, S^λ107, with a Met–Lys … extension at the terminus. The prototype class II holin gene of phage 21, S  ²¹, begins with the motif Met–Lys–Ser–Met … , and a potential RNA secondary structure overlaps the Shine–Dalgarno sequence. Here, we demonstrate that (i) two protein products are elaborated from S  ²¹, S²¹71 and S²¹68; (ii) the shorter product is required for lysis; (iii) the longer product, S²¹71, inhibits S  ²¹ function; and (iv) the Lys-2 residue is important for the inhibitor function. Moreover, the RNA stem–loop structure is involved in the downregulation of S²¹71 synthesis. However, our results suggest that, in S  ²¹, different segments of the single consensus Shine–Dalgarno sequence serve the two translational starts. These results show that the dual start motifs of class II holin genes are functionally homologous to those of class I holin genes.     

The two-step lysis system of pneumococcal bacteriophage EJ-1 is functional in Gram-negative bacteria: triggering of the major pneumococcal autolysin in Escherichia coli

The holin function Ejh of the pneumococcal bacteriophage EJ-1 has been characterized. It shows structural features similar to, and functionally complemented, the prototype member of the holin family. In Escherichia coli and Pseudomonas putida the Ejh product caused cellular death, and changes in cell morphology could be accounted for by lesions in the cytoplasmic membrane. Expression of ejh resulted in the inhibition of growth in a variety of phylogenetically distant bacterial genera, suggesting a broad spectrum of action. Concomitant expression of the ejh and ejl (encodes a lysin) genes led to lysis of E. coli and P. putida cells. Remarkably, the Ejl lysin was able to attack murein from bacteria lacking choline in their sacculi, which suggests that pneumococcal lysins have a broader substrate specificity than previously assumed. Furthermore, the Ejh holin was able to trigger activity of the major pneumococcal autolysin cloned and expressed in E. coli , and this raised new questions about the regulation of this model autolysin. A new function for holins in systems where the phage lysin is supposed to be associated with the membrane is proposed.     

Functional Analysis of the Two-Gene Lysis System of the Pneumococcal Phage Cp-1 in Homologous and Heterologous Host Cells

The two lysis genes cph1 and cpl1 of the Streptococcus pneumoniae bacteriophage Cp-1 coding for holin and lysozyme, respectively, have been cloned and expressed in Escherichia coli. Synthesis of the Cph1 holin resulted in bacterial cell death but not lysis. The cph1 gene was able to complement a lambda Sam mutation in the nonsuppressing E. coli HB101 strain to produce phage progeny, suggesting that the holins encoded by both phage genes have analogous functions and that the pneumococcal holin induces a nonspecific lesion in the cytoplasmic membrane. Concomitant expression of both holin and lysin of Cp-1 in E. coli resulted in cell lysis, apparently due to the ability of the Cpl1 lysozyme to hydrolyze the peptidoglycan layer of this bacterium. The functional analysis of the cph1 and cpl1 genes cloned in a pneumococcal mutant with a complete deletion of the lytA gene, which codes for the S. pneumoniae main autolysin, provided the first direct evidence that, in this gram-positive-bacterium system, the Cpl1 endolysin is released to its murein substrate through the activity of the Cph1 holin. Demonstration of holin function was achieved by proving the release of pneumolysin to the periplasmic fraction, which strongly suggested that the holin produces a lesion in the pneumococcal membrane.     

Genetic analysis of the T4 holin: timing and topology

The t protein of bacteriophage T4 shares with other holins the ability to cause the formation of a lethal membrane lesion which allows the phage endolysin to attack the peptidoglycan. Moreover, T, like other holins, acts in a saltatory manner at a precisely programmed time in the vegetative cycle. Unlike other holins, however, T has the unique ability to postpone its lethal function in response to a secondary infection by a T-even phage during the vegetative cycle. A signal transduction system that responds to the secondary infection is thought to be encoded by some of the numerous r genes, defined by mutations that abolish this lysis-inhibition (LIN) response. The primary structure of T differs from two main structural patterns found in more than 30 orthologous groups of holins. Genetic approaches were taken to probe the t sequence for features involved in membrane localization, functional timing and LIN regulation. Gene fusion analysis indicates that T has a single TMD near the N-terminus, with the bulk of the protein residing in the periplasm. Mapping and phenotypic analysis of deletion and point mutations in t indicates that the periplasmic domain of T is the major determinant of the timing mechanism and is involved in the LIN response.     

The C-terminal sequence of the lambda holin constitutes a cytoplasmic regulatory domain

The C-terminal domains of holins are highly hydrophilic and contain clusters of consecutive basic and acidic residues, with the overall net charge predicted to be positive. The C-terminal domain of lambda S was found to be cytoplasmic, as defined by protease accessibility in spheroplasts and inverted membrane vesicles. C-terminal nonsense mutations were constructed in S and found to be lysis proficient, as long as at least one basic residue is retained at the C terminus. In general, the normal intrinsic scheduling of S function is deranged, resulting in early lysis. However, the capacity of each truncated lytic allele for inhibition by the S107 inhibitor product of S is retained. The K97am allele, when incorporated into the phage context, confers a plaque-forming defect because its early lysis significantly reduces the burst size. Finally, a C-terminal frameshift mutation was isolated as a suppressor of the even more severe early lysis defect of the mutant SA52G, which causes lysis at or before the time when the first phage particle is assembled in the cell. This mutation scrambles the C-terminal sequence of S, resulting in a predicted net charge increase of +4, and retards lysis by about 30 min, thus permitting a viable quantity of progeny to accumulate. Thus, the C-terminal domain is not involved in the formation of the lethal membrane lesion nor in the "dual-start" regulation conserved in lambdoid holins. Instead, the C-terminal sequence defines a cytoplasmic regulatory domain which affects the timing of lysis. Comparison of the C-terminal sequences of within holin families suggests that these domains have little or no structure but act as reservoirs of charged residues that interact with the membrane to effect proper lysis timing.     

Two beginnings for a single purpose: the dual-start holins in the regulation of phage lysis

For most large phages of both Gram-positive and Gram-negative bacteria, there appears to be a single pathway for achieving disruption of the host envelope, requiring at least two phage-encoded lysis functions (a holin and an endolysin). The holin is a small membrane protein which causes a non-specific lesion in the cytoplasmic membrane, which allows the endolysin to gain access to its substrate, the peptidoglycan. The scheduling of host lysis is effected by regulatory mechanisms which govern the synthesis and activity of the holin protein accumulating in the membrane. Accordingly, aspects of expression and function of holin genes are considered here, focusing mainly on the lambdoid S genes. This group of genes, of which lambda S is the prototype, are characterized by a dual-start motif consisting of two Met start codons separated by one or two codons, at least one of which specifies Arg or Lys. Two protein products are elaborated, differing only by two or three N-terminal residues but apparently possessing opposing functions: the shorter polypeptide is the active holin, or lysis-effector, whereas the longer polypeptide apparently acts as an inhibitor of holin function. Models will be considered which may account for the ability of the holin to form a 'hole' in the cytoplasmic membrane at a programmed time, as well as for the inhibitory properties of the longer product. Finally, we discuss recent results suggesting that the dual-start motif can be viewed as a level of regulation superimposed on a timing function intrinsic to the canonical holin structure.     

A novel lysis system in PM2, a lipid-containing marine double-stranded DNA bacteriophage

In this study we investigated the lysis system of the lipid-containing double-stranded DNA bacteriophage PM2 infecting Gram-negative marine Pseudoalteromonas species. We analysed wt and lysis-deficient phage-induced changes in the host physiology and ascribed functions to two PM2 gene products (gp) involved in lysis. We show that bacteriophage PM2 uses a novel system to disrupt the infected cell. The novelty is based on the following findings: (i) gp k is needed for the permeabilization of the cytoplasmic membrane and appears to play the role of a typical holin. However, its unique primary structure [53 aa, 1 transmembrane domain (TMD)] places it into a new class of holins. (ii) We have proposed that, unlike other bacteriophages studied, PM2 relies on lytic factors of the cellular origin for digestion of the peptidoglycan. (iii) gp l (51 aa, no TMDs) is needed for disruption of the outer membrane, which is highly rigidified by the divalent cations abundant in the marine environment. The gp l has no precedent in other phage lytic systems studied so far. However, the presence of open reading frame l-like genes in genomes of other bacterial viruses suggests that the same system might be used by other phages and is not unique to PM2.     

Clocking out: modeling phage-induced lysis of Escherichia coli

Phage lambda lyses the host Escherichia coli at a precisely scheduled time after induction. Lysis timing is determined by the action of phage holins, which are small proteins that induce hole formation in the bacterium's cytoplasmic membrane. We present a two-stage nucleation model of lysis timing, with the nucleation of condensed holin rafts on the inner membrane followed by the nucleation of a hole within those rafts. The nucleation of holin rafts accounts for most of the delay of lysis after induction. Our simulations of this model recover the accurate lysis timing seen experimentally and show that the timing accuracy is optimal. An enhanced holin-holin interaction is needed in our model to recover experimental lysis delays after the application of membrane poison, and such early triggering of lysis is possible only after the inner membrane is supersaturated with holin. Antiholin reduces the delay between membrane depolarization and lysis and leads to an earlier time after which triggered lysis is possible.     

Phages will out: strategies of host cell lysis

Most phages accomplish host lysis using a muralytic enzyme, or endolysin, and a holin, which permeabilizes the membrane at a programmed time and thus controls the length of the vegetative cycle. By contrast, lytic single-stranded RNA and DNA phages accomplish lysis by producing a single lysis protein without muralytic activity.