Cellular retinoic acid-binding protein and the role of retinoic acid in the development of the chick embryo

The distribution of cellular retinoic acid-binding protein (CRABP) in four stages of chick development is described using an affinity-purified antibody against rat CRABP. CRABP is the protein to which retinoic acid (RA) binds when it enters cells and may reflect the requirement of those cells for RA. We found several discrete cell populations which showed high levels of immunoreactivity. Some were in the neural tube such as the commissural neurons and the dorsal roof plate. Some were of neural crest origin such as the dorsal root ganglia, sensory axons, sympathetic ganglia, and enteric ganglia. The remaining populations were certain connective tissue cells, limb bud cells, and the myotome. These results suggest that certain organ systems, particularly the nervous system, have a requirement for RA during development and they may further our understanding of the teratogenic effects of retinoids on the embryo.     

Retinoic acid-binding protein, rhombomeres and the neural crest.

We have investigated by immunocytochemistry the spatial and temporal distribution of cellular retinoic acid-binding protein (CRABP) in the developing nervous system of the chick embryo in order to answer two specific questions: do neural crest cells contain CRABP and where and when do CRABP-positive neuroblasts first arise in the neural tube? With regard to the neural crest, we have compared CRABP staining with HNK-1 staining (a marker of migrating neural crest) and found that they do indeed co-localise, but cephalic and trunk crest behave slightly differently. In the cephalic region in tissues such as the frontonasal mass and branchial arches, HNK-1 immunoreactivity is intense at early stages, but it disappears as CRABP immunoreactivity appears. Thus the two staining patterns do not overlap, but are complementary. In the trunk, HNK-1 and CRABP stain the same cell populations at the same time, such as those migrating through the anterior halves of the somites. In the neural tube, CRABP-positive neuroblasts first appear in the rhombencephalon just after the neural folds close and then a particular pattern of immunoreactivity appears within the rhombomeres of the hindbrain. Labelled cells are present in the future spinal cord, the posterior rhombencephalon up to rhombomere 6 and in rhombomere 4 thus producing a single stripe pattern. This pattern is dynamic and gradually changes as anterior rhombomeres begin to label. The similarity of this initial pattern to the arrangement of certain homeobox genes in the mouse stimulated us to examine the expression of the chicken Hox-2.9 gene. We show that at stage 15 the pattern of expression of this gene is closely related to that of CRABP. The relationship between retinoic acid, CRABP and homeobox genes is discussed.     

Localization of specific retinoid-binding sites and expression of cellular retinoic-acid-binding protein (CRABP) in the early mouse embryo

Retinoids (vitamin A derivatives) are important for normal embryogenesis and retinoic acid, an acidic derivative of vitamin A, was recently proposed to be an endogenous morphogen. Several retinoids are also potent teratogens. Using an autoradiographic technique, we have identified tissues and cells in early mouse embryos that are able to specifically accumulate a radiolabelled synthetic derivative of retinoic acid. Strong accumulation of radioactivity was seen in several neural crest derivatives and in specific areas of the CNS. Gel filtration analyses of cytosols from embryos that received the radiolabelled retinoid in utero suggested that cellular retinoic acid-binding protein (CRABP) was involved in the accumulation mechanism. Immunohistochemical localization confirmed that cells accumulating retinoids also expressed CRABP. Strong CRABP immunoreactivity was found in neural crest-derived mesenchyme of the craniofacial area, in visceral arches, in dorsal root ganglia and in cells along the gut and the major vessels of the trunk region. In CNS, CRABP expression and retinoid binding was largely restricted to the hindbrain, to a single layer of cells in the roof of the midbrain and to cells in the mantle layer of the neural tube. Our data suggest that cells in the embryo expressing CRABP are target cells for exogenous retinoids as well as endogenous retinoic acid. Retinoic acid may thus play an essential role in normal development of the CNS and of tissues derived from the neural crest. We propose that the teratogenic effects of exogenous retinoids are due to an interference with mechanisms by which endogenous retinoic acid regulates differentiation and pattern formation in these tissues.     

Consequences of neural tube and notochord excision on the development of the peripheral nervous system in the chick embryo

Notochordectomy and neuralectomy were carried out either in one- or in two-step experiments on the chick embryo. The aim of this operation was to study the influence of the axial organs (notochord and neural tube) on the development of the ganglia of the peripheral nervous system. The neural crest cells from which most peripheral ganglion cells arise were labeled through the quail-chick marker system and their fate was followed under various experimental conditions. It appeared that the development of the dorsal root and sympathetic ganglia depends on survival and differentiation of somite-derived structures. In the absence of neural tube and notochord, somitic cells die rapidly, and so do the neural crest cells that are present in the somitic mesenchyme at that time. In contrast, those crest cells which can reach the mesenchymal wall of the aorta, the suprarenal glands, or the gut survive and develop normally into nerve and paraganglion cells. Differentiation of the neural crest- and placode-derived sensory ganglia of the head which develop in the cephalic mesenchyme is not affected by removal of notochord and encephalic vesicles. These results show that the peripheral ganglia are differentially sensitive to the presence of the neural tube and the notochord. Among the various ganglia of the peripheral nervous system, spinal and sympathetic ganglia are the only ones which require the presence of these axial structures. The neural tube allows both the spinal and the sympathetic ganglia to develop in the absence of the notochord. In contrast, if the notochord is left in situ and the neural tube removed, the spinal ganglia fail to differentiate and only sympathetic ganglia can develop.     

Domains of cellular retinoic acid-binding protein I (CRABP I) expression in the hindbrain and neural crest of the mouse embryo.

We describe here the distribution of cellular retinoic acid-binding protein I (CRABP I) in the head of the early mouse embryo from day 8 to day 13 of gestation, using both in situ hybridisation to localise mRNA and immunocytochemistry to localise protein. The distribution of mRNA and protein was found to be identical. CRABP I first appeared in part of the presumptive hindbrain of the presomite embryo and then became localised to rhombomeres 2, 4, 5 and 6. The only other area of expression in the cephalic neuroepithelium was in a part of the midbrain roof. The neural crest and its mesenchymal derivatives, the branchial arches, expressed CRABP I and crest could be seen streaming from the neuroepithelium of individual rhombomeres into particular branchial arches. This suggested a fate map could be constructed describing the rhombomeric origin of branchial arch mesenchyme. Later in development, axons throughout the hindbrain expressed CRABP I. The results are considered in terms of the role of retinoic acid in the specification of neuronal phenotype in the hindbrain and in axon outgrowth.     

Initial appearance and regional distribution of the neuron-glia cell adhesion molecule in the chick embryo

This study represents a global survey of the times of the first appearance of the neuron-glia cell adhesion molecule (Ng-CAM) in various regions and on particular cells of the chick embryonic nervous system. Ng-CAM, originally characterized by means of an in vitro binding assay between glial cells and brain membrane vesicles, first appears in development at the surface of early postmitotic neurons. By 3 d in the chick embryo, the first neurons detected by antibodies to Ng-CAM are located in the ventral neural tube; these precursors of motor neurons emit well-stained fibers to the periphery. To identify locations of appearance of Ng-CAM in the peripheral nervous system (PNS), we used a monoclonal antibody called NC-1 that is specific for neural crest cells in early embryos to show the presence of numerous crest cells in the neuritic outgrowth from the neural tube; neither these crest cells nor those in ganglion rudiments bound anti-Ng-CAM antibodies. The earliest neurons in the PNS stained by anti-Ng-CAM appeared by 4 d of development in the cranial ganglia. At later stages and progressively, all the neurons and neurities of the PNS were found to contain Ng-CAM both in vitro and in vivo. Many central nervous system (CNS) neurons also showed Ng-CAM at these later stages, but in the CNS, the molecule was mostly associated with neuronal processes (mainly axons) rather than with cell bodies; this regional distribution at the neuronal cell surface is an example of polarity modulation. In contrast to the neural cell adhesion molecule and the liver cell adhesion molecule, both of which are found very early in derivatives of more than one germ layer, Ng-CAM is expressed only on neurons of the CNS and the PNS during the later epoch of development concerned with neural histogenesis. Ng-CAM is thus a specific differentiation product of neuroectoderm. Ng-CAM was found on developing neurons at approximately the same time that neurofilaments first appear, times at which glial cells are still undergoing differentiation from neuroepithelial precursors. The present findings and those of previous studies suggest that together the neural cell adhesion molecule and Ng-CAM mediate specific cellular interactions during the formation of neuronal networks by means of modulation events that govern their prevalence and polarity on neuronal cell surfaces.     

The effect of back-transplants of the embryonic gut wall on growth of the neural tube

Experiments in which the developing gut of avian embryos was back-transplanted to permit the bowel to interact with the developing neural tube were undertaken. Segments of intestine from 4-day quail embryos were implanted between the somites and neural tubes of chick embryos of 7 to 24 somites. The spinal cord responded to the presence of the bowel by enlarging unilaterally on the side of the graft. This effect encompassed both gray and white matter and was accompanied by the extension of neuritic projections from the spinal cord into the enteric grafts. The growth-promoting effect of enteric transplants was manifest at all levels of the neural tube where the grafts were made and led to enlargement of the brain as well as the spinal cord; however, truncal neural crest derivatives in the region of the grafts, such as developing sympathetic and spinal ganglia, were unaffected. Neither sham operations nor grafts of ciliary ganglion, lung, pancreas, mesonephros, or rudiment of the eye mimicked the action of the gut. The effect of the bowel was manifest as early as 24 hr following back-transplantation and was found to be due to an increase in the number of cells in the neuroepithelium. The cell responsible for the ability of the gut wall to enhance neuroepithelial proliferation was not identified, but the effect lacked species specificity and could be elicited in the absence of endoderm or neural crest derivatives in the explant. We propose that the musculoconnective tissue of the gut produces a short-range diffusible factor that induces mitogenic activity in the neuroepithelial cells of the neural tube, but not in the crest cells that form sympathetic or sensory ganglia. Since the gut is not normally in apposition to the neural tube, we suggest that the physiological targets of this factor are the specialized crest cells that colonize the bowel and give rise to the enteric nervous system.     

A vital dye analysis of the timing and pathways of avian trunk neural crest cell migration

To permit a more detailed analysis of neural crest cell migratory pathways in the chick embryo, neural crest cells were labelled with a nondeleterious membrane intercalating vital dye, DiI. All neural tube cells with endfeet in contact with the lumen, including premigratory neural crest cells, were labelled by pressure injecting a solution of DiI into the lumen of the neural tube. When assayed one to three days later, migrating neural crest cells, motor axons, and ventral root cells were the only cells types external to the neural tube labelled with DiI. During the neural crest cell migratory phase, distinctly labelled cells were found along: (1) a dorsolateral pathway, under the epidermis, as well adjacent to and intercalating through the dermamyotome; and (2) a ventral pathway, through the rostral portion of each sclerotome and around the dorsal aorta as described previously. In contrast to those cells migrating through the sclerotome, labelled cells on the dorsolateral pathway were not segmentally arranged along the rostrocaudal axis. DiI-labelled cells were observed in all truncal neural crest derivatives, including subepidermal presumptive pigment cells, dorsal root ganglia, and sympathetic ganglia. By varying the stage at which the injection was performed, neural crest cell emigration at the level of the wing bud was shown to occur from stage 13 through stage 22. In addition, neural crest cells were found to populate their derivatives in a ventral-to-dorsal order, with the latest emigrating cells migrating exclusively along the dorsolateral pathway.     

Tissue interactions affecting the migration and differentiation of neural crest cells in the chick embryo.

A series of microsurgical operations was performed in chick embryos to study the factors that control the polarity, position and differentiation of the sympathetic and dorsal root ganglion cells developing from the neural crest. The neural tube, with or without the notochord, was rotated by 180 degrees dorsoventrally to cause the neural crest cells to emerge ventrally. In some embryos, the notochord was ablated, and in others a second notochord was implanted. Sympathetic differentiation was assessed by catecholamine fluorescence after aldehyde fixation. Neural crest cells emerging from an inverted neural tube migrate in a ventral-to-dorsal direction through the sclerotome, where they become segmented by being restricted to the rostral half of each sclerotome. Both motor axons and neural crest cells avoid the notochord and the extracellular matrix that surrounds it, but motor axons appear also to be attracted to the notochord until they reach its immediate vicinity. The dorsal root ganglia always form adjacent to the neural tube and their dorsoventral orientation follows the direction of migration of the neural crest cells. Differentiation of catecholaminergic cells only occurs near the aorta/mesonephros and in addition requires the proximity of either the ventral neural tube (floor plate/ventral root region) or the notochord. Prior migration of presumptive catecholaminergic cells through the sclerotome, however, is neither required nor sufficient for their adrenergic differentiation.     

The differing effects of occipital and trunk somites on neural development in the chick embryo

In all higher vertebrate embryos the sensory ganglia of the trunk develop adjacent to the neural tube, in the cranial halves of the somite-derived sclerotomes. It has been known for many years that ganglia do not develop in the most cranial (occipital) sclerotomes, caudal to the first somite. Here we have investigated whether this is due to craniocaudal variation in the neural tube or crest, or to an unusual property of the sclerotomes at occipital levels. Using the monoclonal antibody HNK-1 as a marker for neural crest cells in the chick embryo, we find that the crest does enter the cranial halves of the occipital sclerotomes. Furthermore, staining with zinc iodide/osmium tetroxide shows that some of these crest-derived cells sprout axons within these sclerotomes. By stage 23, however, no dorsal root ganglia are present within the five occipital sclerotomes, as assessed both by haematoxylin/eosin and zinc iodide/osmium tetroxide staining. Moreover, despite this loss of sensory cells, motor axons grow out in these segments, many of them later fasciculating to form the hypoglossal nerve. The sclerotomes remain visible until stages 27/28, when they dissociate to form the base of the skull and the atlas and axis vertebrae. After grafting occipital neural tube from quail donor embryos in place of trunk neural tube in host chick embryos, quail-derived ganglia do develop in the trunk sclerotomes. This shows that the failure of occipital ganglion development is not the result of some fixed local property of the neural crest or neural tube at occipital levels. We therefore suggest that in the chick embryo the cranial halves of the five occipital sclerotomes lack factors essential for normal sensory ganglion development, and that these factors are correspondingly present in all the more caudal sclerotomes.     

Lack of beta1 integrins in enteric neural crest cells leads to a Hirschsprung-like phenotype

The enteric nervous system arises mainly from vagal and sacral neural crest cells that colonise the gut between 9.5 and 14 days of development in mice. Using the Cre-LoxP system, we removed beta1 integrins in the neural crest cells when they emerge from the neural tube. beta1-null enteric neural crest cells fail to colonise the gut completely, leading to an aganglionosis of the descending colon, which resembles the human Hirschsprung's disease. Moreover, beta1-null enteric neural crest cells form abnormal aggregates in the gut wall, leading to a severe alteration of the ganglia network organisation. Organotypic cultures of gut explants reveal that beta1-null enteric neural crest cells show impaired adhesion on extracellular matrix and enhanced intercellular adhesion properties. They display migration defects in collagen gels and gut tissue environments. We also provide evidence that beta1 integrins are required for the villi innervation in the small intestine. Our findings highlight the crucial roles played by beta1 integrins at various steps of enteric nervous system development.     

Neural crest cell migratory pathways in the trunk of the chick embryo

Neural crest cells migrate during embryogenesis to give rise to segmented structures of the vertebrate peripheral nervous system: namely, the dorsal root ganglia and the sympathetic chain. However, neural crest cell arise from the dorsal neural tube where they are apparently unsegmented. It is generally agreed that the somites impose segmentation on migrating crest cells, but there is a disagreement about two basic questions: exactly pathways do neural crest cells use to move through or around somites, and do neural crest cells actively migrate or are they passively dispersed by the movement of somite cells? The answers to both questions are critically important to any further understanding of the mechanisms underlying the precise distribution of the neural crest cells that develop into ganglia. We have done an exhaustive study of the locations of neural crest cells in chick embryos during early stages of their movement, using antibodies to neural crest cells (HNK-1), to neural filament-associated protein in growing nerve processes (E/C8), and to the extracellular matrix molecule laminin. Our results show that Some neural crest cells invade the extracellular space between adjacent somites, but the apparent majority move into the somites themselves along the border between the dermatome/myotome (DM) and the sclerotome. Neural crest cells remain closely associated with the anterior half of the DM of developing somites as they travel, suggesting that the basal lamina of the DM may be used as a migratory substratum. Supporting this idea is our observation that the development of the DM basal lamina coincides in time and location with the onset of crest migration through the somite. The leading front of neural crest cells advance through the somite while the length of the DM pathway remains constant, suggesting active locomotion, at least in this early phase of development. Neural crest cells leave the DM at a later stage of development to associate with the dorsal aorta, where sympathetic ganglia form, and to associate with newly emerging fibers of the ventral root nerve, where they presumably give rise to neuronal supportive cells. Thus we propose that the establishment of the segmental pattern of the peripheral ganglia and nerves depends on the timely development of appropriate substrata to guide and distribute migrating neural crest cells during the early stages of embryogenesis.     

Cellular retinoic acid binding protein is associated with mitochondria

We report that immunohistochemical staining for cellular retinoic acid-binding protein (CRABP) was restricted to the cytoplasm of cortical cells in bovine adrenal. In contrast, staining for the similar protein, cellular retinol-binding protein (CRBP), was found throughout these cells. After transfections of CRABP and CRBP into cultured cells, immunofluorescence analyses again revealed cytoplasmic restriction only for CRABP, with a pronounced punctate appearance. Use of organelle-specific fluorochromes indicated that CRABP immunofluorescence overlaid exactly with the pattern of the mitochondrial-specific fluorochrome. Confirmation of this association came with subcellular fractionation of the adrenal cortex. CRABP, but not CRBP, co-sedimented with the mitochondria, a novel finding for a member of this superfamily of cellular lipid-binding proteins.     

Origins and Developmental Potential of the Neural Crest

Neural crest cells are a migratory population that forms most of the peripheral nervous system, facial skeleton, and numerous other derivatives. These cells arise from the neural ectoderm and are first recognizable as discrete cells after neural tube closure. In this review, I summarize the results of studies from our laboratory on neural crest cell lineage and origin. Our recent experiments demonstrate that interactions between the presumptive neural plate and the nonneural ectoderm are likely to be instrumental in the induction of the avian neural crest. Juxtaposition of these tissues at early stages results in the formation of neural crest cells at the interface. However, neural crest cells do not appear to be segregated from other neuroepithelial cells; cell lineage studies have demonstrated that individual precursor cells within the neural tube can give rise to both neural crest and neural tube derivatives as diverse as sensory, commissural, and motor neurons. This suggests that individual neuroectodermal cells are multipotent, such that a precursor within the neural tube has the ability to form both neural tube (central nervous system) and neural crest (peripheral nervous system and other) derivatives. Further support for flexibility in the developmental program of neuroepithelial cells comes from experiments in which the cranial neural folds are ablated; this results in regulation by the remaining ventral neural tube cells to form neural crest cells after the endogenous neural crest is removed. At later stage of development, this regulative capacity is lost. Following their emigration from the neural tube, neural crest cells become progressively restricted to defined embryonic states. Taken together, these experiments demonstrate that: (1) the neural crest is an induced population that arises by interactions within the ectoderm; (2) initially, progenitor cells are multipotent, having the potential to form multiple neural crest and neural tube derivatives; and (3) with time, the precursors become progressively restricted to form neural crest derivatives and eventually to individual phenotypes.     

A spatial and temporal analysis of dorsal root and sympathetic ganglion formation in the avian embryo

The present study explores the formation of the dorsal root and sympathetic ganglia in the trunk of the avian embryo. Particular emphasis was given to the timing of gangliogenesis and the relative positions of the neural crest-derived ganglia with respect to the somites. Neural crest cells and their derivatives were recognized by the HNK-1 antibody. The time at which neural crest cell coalesced to form ganglia was assessed by the state of cellular aggregation. The state of ganglionic differentiation was assessed by the expression of neurofilament proteins and the neural cell adhesion molecule (N-CAM). At the level of the 15th somite, neural crest cells were observed in the rostral half of the somite at stage 15, during active neural crest migration, and occupied the rostral two-thirds of the somite at progressive stages. HNK-1 positive cells appeared to be organized in three to four streams of cells oriented mediolaterally and dorsoventrally. The dorsal root ganglia and sympathetic ganglia were first detectable at stages 20 and 21, respectively. Both ganglionic rudiments were aligned with the rostral portion of the somite. The dorsal root ganglia occupied the rostral two-thirds of each somite, whereas cells in the sympathetic ganglia occupied a region corresponding to approximately one-third of each somite. At the time of condensation of the dorsal root ganglia, abundant neurofilament staining was observed within the ganglia. However, no N-CAM immunoreactivity was detected until three stages later at stage 23. In contrast, the sympathetic ganglia demonstrated both neurofilament and N-CAM immunoreactivity at the time of condensation. The observation that both dorsal root and sympathetic ganglia form in register with the rostral portion of somite suggests that cues localized at these axial levels, perhaps within the rostral somite, may influence the position where neural crest cells condense to form ganglia. In sensory ganglia, N-CAM expression does not correlate with the onset of gangliogenesis, suggesting that molecules other than N-CAM may play an important role in the aggregation of some neuronal populations.     

Distribution and levels of cellular retinol- and cellular retinoic acid-binding protein in various types of rat testis cells

The distribution and levels of cellular retinol-binding protein (CRBP) and cellular retinoic acid-binding protein (CRABP) were measured in rat testicular peritubular and Sertoli cells and in isolated rat pachytene spermatocytes and spermatids. Two Sertoli cell preparations, one containing some germ cells and another that had been osmotically shocked to destroy germ cells, were examined. CRBP and CRABP levels were measured by specific and sensitive radioimmunoassays. Testicular peritubular cell cytosol preparations were found to contain high levels of CRBP (1.48 +/- 0.87 microgram CRBP/mg protein) but CRABP could not be detected. The mean CRBP level in Sertoli cell preparations that contained some germ cells was 0.93 +/- 0.24 microgram CRBP/mg protein; this value was similar to the level of 1.11 +/- 0.20 microgram CRBP/mg protein measured for Sertoli cells free of germ cells. The level of CRABP found in Sertoli cell preparations containing germ cells (0.81 +/- 0.32 microgram CRABP/mg protein) was approximately five times greater than was observed in Sertoli cells free of germ cells (0.16 +/- 0.03 microgram CRABP/mg protein). CRBP and CRABP levels in cultured Sertoli cells were not affected by time in culture for up to five days of culture. Pachytene spermatocytes and spermatids were very enriched in CRABP (0.72 +/- 0.26 microgram CRABP/mg protein for spermatocytes and 0.65 +/- 0.21 microgram CRABP/ml protein for spermatids). A search for a high molecular weight retinol-binding protein did not demonstrate the existence of such a protein in Sertoli cell-conditioned medium. In summary, these studies provide quantitative information about the distribution of the cellular retinoid-binding proteins in the cell types that compose the rat testis.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Spatial and temporal expression of cellular retinoic acid binding protein (CRABP) along the anteroposterior axis in the central nervous system of mouse embryos

In the central nervous system of 11.5-day mouse embryos, the expression of CRABP was spatially restricted to the anteroposterior axis. CRABP was most strongly expressed in the rhombencephalon and the anterior part of the neural tube. In 14-day mouse embryo, CRABP drastically decreased in the brain and the anterior part of the neural tube. The transient expression and spatial distribution of CRABP in the central nervous system strongly suggest that retinoic acid is involved in the neurogenesis during development.