Analysis of cloned T cell function. I. Dissection of cloned T cell proliferative responses using cyclosporin A

CsA interferes in a specific manner with the expansion of T cell clones in that it inhibits the antigen-driven component of the proliferative responses made by cloned helper T cells, cloned conventional cytolytic T cells, and cloned helper-independent cytolytic T cells. Cloned helper T cells and helper-independent cytolytic T cells, which share the ability to proliferate when cultured with specific alloantigen, fail to proliferate when cultured with specific alloantigen, fail to proliferate in response to this stimulus in the presence of CsA (10 to 100 ng/ml). In contrast, the proliferation observed when these cells are cultured with exogenous growth factors (but not alloantigen) is little influenced by as much as 1000 ng/ml CsA. When cloned helper T cells or helper-independent cytotoxic T cells are cultured with alloantigen plus exogenous growth factor, additive or synergistic proliferation occurs. However, CsA (10 to 1000 ng/ml) blocks only the component of proliferation induced by alloantigen, and leaves the lymphokine-driven component intact. CsA has similar effects on the proliferation of cloned conventional cytolytic T cells. Thus, CsA separates cloned T cell proliferation into two components: one driven by contact with alloantigens, the other driven by contact with mitogenic lymphokines.     

Cytolytic T lymphocyte clones that proliferate autonomously to specific alloantigenic stimulation. II. Relationship of the Lyt-2 molecular complex to cytolytic activity, proliferation, and lymphokine secretion

Previous analyses of the inhibitory effects of anti-Lyt-2 monoclonal antibodies (mAb) on cytolytic activity suggested that Lyt-2/3 antigens expressed on the surface of murine cytolytic T lymphocytes (CTL) are involved in antigen recognition. In the present study, we investigated the effects of anti-Lyt-2 mAb (in the absence of complement) on the functional activities of H-2K/D-specific Lyt-2+ CTL clones that proliferate to antigenic stimulation in the absence of helper T cells or added interleukin 2 (IL 2) and secrete lymphokines. For those clones that were inhibited in cytolysis by anti-Lyt-2 mAb, a parallel inhibition of antigen-dependent proliferation and lymphokine secretion (interferon, macrophage-activating factor) was observed. Inhibition of proliferation or lymphokine secretion could be overcome by the addition of IL 2 or lectin, respectively. Collectively, these results would strongly suggest that anti-Lyt-2 mAb were inhibiting CTL antigen recognition. Not all CTL clones, however, were inhibited in cytolysis by anti-Lyt-2 mAb, in which case proliferation and lymphokine secretion were similarly unaffected. This heterogeneity of Lyt-2+ CTL clones in their susceptibility to inhibition of cytolytic activity, proliferation, and lymphokine secretion by anti-Lyt-2 mAb is discussed in the context of a model proposing that Lyt-2/3 molecules function to stabilize the interaction between CTL receptors and the corresponding target/stimulating cell antigens. Such a stabilization may be required by CTL possessing few and/or low affinity receptors.     

Regulation of cytotoxic lymphocyte precursors. II. The effect of interleukin-2 and interferon-gamma on the apparent specificity of effector cells

The influence of lymphokines on the frequency and specificity of antigen-induced cytolytic T cells was investigated. Removal of an acid-labile factor(s) from supernatants produced by concanavalin A (Con A)-stimulated rat splenocytes was shown to increase the specificity of cytolytic T-cell clones as determined by their ability to distinguish between antigen modified and unmodified target cells. The overall frequency of cytolytic T cell precursors (antigen specific as well as nonspecific) was reduced in the presence of acid-pretreated rat Con A supernatant as compared to untreated rat Con A supernatant. Neither the addition of interleukin 2 nor interferon-gamma could substitute for this acid-labile factor. These data indicate that an additional lymphokine(s) contributes to the in vitro activation of nonspecific killer cells.     

Cytolytic activity of antigen-specific T cells with helper phenotype

We have investigated an unusual cytolytic activity displayed in vitro by cloned T cells which have the cell surface phenotype of helper T cells. When the cloned T cells are cultured with the appropriate antigen and antigen-presenting cells (APC), the T cells become activated in that they produce lymphokines and proliferate in an antigen-specific and major histocompatibility complex-restricted manner. At the same time, these T cells cause lysis of the APC. In addition, innocent non-histocompatible bystander cells present in the cultures can also be killed. The cytolytic activity may be involved in a mechanism of immune regulation.     

Development and characterization of interleukin-2-independent antigen-specific human T cell clones that produce multiple lymphokines

The development of antigen-specific T lymphocyte lines and clones has greatly facilitated the investigation of T-cell recognition of and response to foreign antigens. In the present study, human antigen-specific helper T cell lines and clones which are completely independent of exogenous interleukin-2 (IL-2) have been developed by cyclic restimulation with the soluble antigen keyhole limpet hemocyanin (KLH) to which the T cell donor had previously been immunized. These T cells uniformly bear the OKT4 phenotype and were shown to require both histocompatible antigen-presenting cells (APC) and antigen for optimal proliferation. The T cell line was composed of a highly antigen-specific and clonable T cell population. Following four cycles of antigen stimulation, limiting dilution cloning analysis showed a Poisson distribution of clonable T cells with a precursor frequency of 0.62, and from 88 to 92% of viable clones were specific for the stimulating antigen. Individual clones were obtained which recognized KLH with either DR 1 (one parental Ia haplotype of the donor) or DR 2 (the other parental Ia haplotype) allogeneic APC, but not both. Following stimulation with KLH, the T cell clones produced IL-2. Peak amounts of IL-2 were assayable in the first 6 to 24 hr after stimulation. In contrast, virtually no IL-2 was detectable in supernatants at 72 to 96 hr, suggesting autoutilization by the proliferating T cells. In addition, some clones were also capable of producing both B cell growth factor and IL-2 following KLH stimulation. These IL-2-independent T cells appeared to be derived from a discrete Leu 8-negative subclass of T4⁺ cells and expressed the full complement of Ia antigen of the donor. Thus, soluble antigen-specific human helper T cell clones have been produced which can be maintained in the absence of exogenous IL-2, elaborate their own growth factors and other immunoregulatory lymphokines, and show fine DR-related restriction to either one or the other parental DR haplotypes in antigen-stimulated proliferative responses.     

Disparate functional properties of two interleukin 1-responsive Ly-1+2- T cell clones: distinction of T cell growth factor and T cell-replacing factor activities

We describe the properties of two Ly-1+2- T cell clones (Ly-1.14 and Ly-1.21), which are maintained in long-term culture in the absence of other cell types. The clones require media containing a source of interleukin 1 as well as interleukin 2. They retain physiologic responses to interleukin 1, which is required for optimal production of T cell lymphokines by these clones in response to concanavalin A (Con A). The two Ly-1+2- T cell clones differ in their production of lymphokines after stimulation by Con A. The supernatant of clone Ly-1.21 promotes the proliferation of T cells maintained in long-term culture, induces antibody synthesis in cultures of B cells and antigen, and induces the differentiation of cytolytic cells in cultures of thymocytes and antigen; these assays define the properties of T cell growth factor (TCGF), T cell-replacing factor for B cells (TRF-B), and T cell-replacing factor for cytolytic cells (TRF-C), respectively. In contrast, the supernatant of clone Ly-1.14 contains only TCGF activity and does not promote antibody synthesis by B cells or differentiation of cytolytic cells from thymocytes. The results indicates that TCGF and TRF activities reside on independent, although perhaps related, molecules.     

Antigen-specific, MHC-restricted B cell activation by cell-free Th2 cell products. Synergy between antigen-specific helper factors and IL-4

Ag-specific and MHC-restricted Th clones of different Ag specificities and MHC haplotypes were tested for their ability to produce soluble factors capable of providing the signals required for B cell activation and IgG antibody production. Each of five Th clones tested generated significant helper activity in supernatants derived from coculture of the T cell clone with specific Ag and syngeneic APC. The same helper activity was detected in supernatants of clones stimulated with immobilized anti-CD3 antibody in the absence of Ag or APC. The secreted helper activity resembled the activity of the intact Th cells in that it was Ag-specific, carrier-hapten-linked and MHC-restricted. These T cell products functioned to activate only those B cells expressing MHC products which corresponded to the specificity of each Th clone. Thus, the specificity of the cell-free T cell product mimicked precisely that expressed by the intact Th cell and presumably mediated by the cell surface TcR. In addition to the apparent presence of specific helper factor in Th clone supernatants, a role for nonspecific lymphokines was also identified in these preparations. Although recombinant or purified IL-4 alone was not sufficient to stimulate hapten-primed B cells to secrete hapten-specific IgG antibodies, mAb specific for IL-4 blocked the induction of antibody secretion by Th cell supernatant. These results indicate that stimulation of B cells to produce hapten-specific IgG antibody requires at least two distinct signals: an Ag-specific T cell signal which is restricted by MHC products expressed on the B cells, and a nonspecific signal mediated at least in part by the lymphokine IL-4.     

Glucocorticoid inhibition of lymphokine secretion by alloreactive T lymphocyte clones

The effect of glucocorticoids on lymphokine production by T lymphocytes was examined by using long-term alloreactive T cell clones that secreted one or more of the lymphokines interleukin 2 (IL 2), interferon-gamma, macrophage-activating factor (MAF), and colony-stimulating factor when stimulated by an antigen or a mitogen. Production of all of these four lymphokines was inhibited when glucocorticoids were added at physiologic concentrations (10(-8) to 10(-6) M) to clones stimulated with concanavalin A (Con A). Clones were heterogeneous with respect to their sensitivity to glucocorticoid inhibition of MAF production; cytolytic clones were generally more resistant than noncytolytic clones. The glucocorticoid dexamethasone (Dex) and an IL 2-containing supernatant exerted opposing effects on clonal MAF production. Kinetics experiments showed that Dex inhibited MAF production by reducing the rate of secretion without causing a compensatory increase in the duration of secretion, whereas the IL 2 source increased the rate and the total amount of MAF secretion. Dex abrogated the effect of IL 2. Inhibition by Dex was apparent from the earliest time of detectable MAF production (about 4 hr after stimulation) and increased with longer exposure until production ceased (12 to 24 hr). Pre-exposure and removal of Dex before Con A stimulation also inhibited MAF release. Effects of Dex on lymphokine secretion by clones could be dissociated from effects on their growth in response to stimulator cells and IL 2. Factor production by the 16 clones tested was inhibited to some degree. Proliferation, however, by two of these clones (both cytolytic) was unaffected by Dex, whereas proliferation of two noncytolytic clones was strongly inhibited even in the presence of a saturating dose of IL 2.     

Interleukin 2 inhibits antigen-stimulated lymphokine synthesis in helper T cells by inhibiting calcium-dependent signalling

Certain L3T4+, Lyt-2- cloned murine helper T lymphocytes (HTL), when cultured with a high concentration of interleukin 2 (IL 2), become temporarily unresponsive to antigenic stimulation, as indicated by failure to proliferate and by reduced secretion of lymphokines when challenged with antigen. Exposure of cloned HTL to IL 2 also renders these cells less responsive to concanavalin A (Con A). Here we demonstrate that antigen-unresponsive HTL also accumulate reduced levels of lymphokine mRNA, thus indicating a pretranslational block of the response to antigen. However, HTL which had been pretreated with IL 2 and were unresponsive to antigen responded strongly to antigen + A23187 or to A23187 + PMA but failed to respond to antigen + PMA. With HTL made unresponsive to antigen or to Con A by exposure to IL 2, increases in intracellular calcium ion levels stimulated by Con A also were reduced. Thus, for mouse HTL clones, the IL 2-induced state of unresponsiveness to antigen or Con A appears to reflect an inability of such HTL to increase intracellular free calcium to a level sufficient for activation of lymphokine genes.     

IgM induction in murine B hybridomas with Ia-restricted T cell clones: a monoclonal model for T and B cell interactions in antibody response

The mechanism of MHC-restricted T and B cell interactions in antibody response was studied with IgM-inducible B hybridomas and antigen-specific helper T cell clones. B hybridomas were prepared by fusion between splenic B cells from (CBA/N (H-2k) X BALB/c (H-2d)) F1 (NBF1) male mice and a B lymphoma cell line, M12.4.5. A B hybridoma clone, 1M70, which expressed I-Ad but not I-Ak determinants was chosen in the present study. IgM secretion was induced in 1M70 when it was cocultured with a "resting" KLH-specific and H-2d restricted helper T cell clone in the presence of KLH. A "resting" KLH-specific and H-2k restricted T cell clone did not induce IgM secretion in 1M70 even in the presence of KLH. However, when these KLH-specific T cell clones were activated by KLH and appropriate antigen presenting cells, both H-2d and H-2k restricted T cell clones induced IgM secretion in 1M70 even in the absence of KLH. A monoclonal anti-I-Ad antibody inhibited IgM secretion induced by a "resting" H-2d restricted T cell clone, but not by an "activated" T cell clone. These results indicated that T cell clones recognized antigens in the context of Ia molecules on B hybridomas in a MHC-restricted manner and were activated to produce B cell stimulatory factors which in turn acted on B hybridomas in a non-MHC-restricted manner and induced differentiation of B hybridomas into IgM secreting cells.     

Differential effects of two anti-apo-cytochrome c-specific monoclonal antibodies on the function of apo-cytochrome c-specific murine T cell clones

A murine monoclonal antibody (SJL 2-4) specific for the antigen apo-cytochrome c was shown to inhibit both antigen-induced proliferation and lymphokine secretion by an apo-cytochrome c-specific BALB/c helper T cell clone. The inhibition was specific because additional apo-cytochrome c-specific T cell clones were not inhibited by the same monoclonal antibody. Time course studies of the inhibition indicated that the initial 8 hr of contact between T cell clones and antigen-presenting cells were critical for activation of the T cell clones. Inhibition of T cell functions by antigen-specific antibodies appeared to correlate with the antibody-antigen binding constant because a second monoclonal antibody (Cyt-1-59), with identical specificity but with a lower affinity constant for apo-cytochrome c, had very little inhibitory effect on the proliferation or lymphokine secretion of apo-cytochrome c-specific T cell clones.     

Evaluation of Ia+ tumor cell lines and peritoneal exudate macrophages as accessory cells: differential requirements for the activation of certain T cell functions

Several Ia+ (BC3A, TA3, D1B) or Ia-inducible (WEHI-3, P388D1) tumor lines were tested for accessory cell function for the activation of antigen-specific T cell proliferation and for the induction of T helper cells that help B cells in antibody production. All lines were able to induce antigen-specific T cell proliferation in an MHC-restricted way, but none activated T helper cells to soluble antigens under all conditions tested. In comparison, starch-induced peritoneal exudate macrophages induced T cell proliferation as well as T cell help. Some of the lines tested induced nonspecific suppressor cells that were Ly-2-positive and partially or completely inhibited antibody responses. The induction of suppressor cells, however, is not the reason for the failure of the tumor lines to activate T helper cells. These data indicate that antigen-specific T cell proliferation and helper activity do not necessarily correlate.     

cAMP is an essential signal in the induction of antibody production by B cells but inhibits helper function of T cells

Dibutyryl cAMP and IL 1 were found to stimulate antigen-specific and polyclonal antibody production when added together to cultures of highly purified B cells. We propose that IL 1 and an elevation in cytoplasmic cAMP represent minimal signal requirements for B cell activation. In contrast to its effect on B cells, dibutyryl cAMP inhibited helper T cell activity. Cyclic AMP suppressed the production of IL 2 and T cell replacing factor (TRF) by T cells and thus abrogated the ability of helper T cells to enhance SRBC-specific antibody production by B cells. Cyclic AMP did not inhibit the generation by T cells of B cell growth factor (BCGF). BCGF, not normally detected in Con A supernatant, was found in the culture supernatant of spleen cells that were stimulated with Con A in the presence of cAMP. Our findings indicate that cAMP blocks the production of an inhibitor of BCGF activity. cAMP had no effect on the production by macrophages of IL 1.     

Interleukin 4 drives phytohemagglutinin-activated T cells through several cell cycles: No synergism between interleukin 2 and interleukin 4

Cell kinetic studies of T cells stimulated with the interleukin 2 (Il-2), Il-4, or both lymphokines were performed with conventional [3H]thymidine incorporation and with the bivariate BrdU/Hoechst technique. Il-2 and Il-4 are able to drive phytohemagglutinin-activated T cells through more than one cell cycle. Neither synergistic nor inhibitory effect on T-cell proliferation was seen for the stimulation with both Il-2 and Il-4 as compared with the effect of Il-2 alone. The quantitative data of the cell cycle distribution of phytohemagglutinin-activated T cells suggest that the population of Il-4-responsive cells is at least an overlapping population, if not a real subset of the population of the Il-2-responsive cells.     

Clonal analysis of antigen-specific interactions between T cells and genetically engineered B cells

In order to investigate T cell-B cell interactions we constructed monoclonal, antigen-specific T- and B-cell populations. The Ia+ B-cell lymphoma A20-2J was transfected with trinitrophenyl (TNP)-specific heavy (mu) and light (kappa) chain Ig genes. A hapten-carrier complex (TNP-keyhole limpet hemocyanin (KLH)) bound to the surface Ig expressed on the transfectant and was presented to carrier-specific T-cell hybridoma clones at markedly low doses of antigen (0.01 microgram/ml) and in an Ia-restricted fashion. Two responses were elicited in the responding T-cell clones: (i) high levels of IL-2 secretion (320 units/ml), and (ii) cytotoxicity directed against the antigen-presenting B cell. This cytotoxicity was inhibited by D-mannose and was directed against innocent bystander cells, unlike cytotoxicity mediated by NK cells or alloreactive cytotoxic T lymphocyte. Helper and cytotoxic functions were often present in different T-cell hybridomas but some clones exhibited both activities. One representative T-cell hybridoma exhibited strong helper function for TNP-primed splenic B cells as detected in a plaque-forming cell assay, but was cytotoxic toward antigen-presenting B cells. Such monoclonal assay systems for studying cognate interactions of heterogeneous T cells and specific antigen-presenting cells will provide us with valuable new approaches for the study of antigen-specific T-cell regulation of B-cell activation in immune responses.     

Functional heterogeneity of CD4-positive T-cell subsets: the correlation between effector functions and lymphokine secretion is limited

Several effector functions and the lymphokine secretion pattern of 30 antigen-specific CD4+ T-cell clones have been investigated. The clones were generated directly by limiting dilution cloning of nylon wool-purified T-cells obtained from KLH immunized BALB/c mice and avoiding an initial bulk culture phase. Using this approach the CD4+ T-cell clones were grouped into helper and nonhelper subsets. Among the helper subset, clones which helped B-cells for specific antibody production by either cognate or noncognate recognition were identified. Some but not all of these helper clones fitted into the Th1 and Th2 scheme, if the lymphokine secretion pattern was evaluated. Among the nonhelper subset CD4+ clones which killed activated APC in a MHC class II-restricted and antigen-specific manner were identified. In addition, one clone which suppressed B-cell antibody production mediated by helper clones was found. However, neither the suppression of antibody responses nor the inability of the nonhelper clones to help B-cells is due to the killing of B-cells. Various attempts were made to convert nonhelper into helper clones and helper into killer clones, without success. Thus, the functional properties of these clones are stable traits and not convertible by varying the experimental conditions.     

Antiproliferative effect of IFN-gamma in immune regulation. III. Differential selection of TH1 and TH2 murine helper T lymphocyte clones using recombinant IL-2 and recombinant IFN-gamma

Supernatants collected after primary or secondary stimulation of spleen cells contain different arrays of lymphokines. Primary supernatants from spleen cells stimulated with Con A or allogeneic spleen cells (MLC-SF) contain IL-2 but little IL-4 or IGN-gamma; in contrast, secondary MLC-SF contains IL-2 as well as substantial IL-4 and IFN-gamma. Our laboratory previously had always used secondary MLC-SF for cloning T cells, and had routinely obtained TH1 helper T lymphocyte clones. In the present study, when primary Con A-SF was used as source of growth factors, TH2 and not TH1 clones were preferentially derived. Considering the possibility that IFN-gamma may be one important factor in determining whether TH1 or TH2 clones are preferentially obtained, clone derivation was then performed either in the presence of rIL-2 or rIL-2 plus rIFN-gamma. The majority of clones derived using rIL-2 alone were TH2 cells, whereas the majority of clones derived using rIL-2 plus rIFN-gamma were TH1 cells. Using either procedure, some clones were obtained that produced IL-2, IL-4, and IFN-gamma. These data are consistent with our previous observations that IFN-gamma inhibits the proliferation of TH2 but not TH1 clones, and suggest that the presence of IFN-gamma during an immune response would result in the preferential expansion of helper T lymphocytes of the TH1 phenotype. Our procedure for the differential selection of TH1 and TH2 clones reactive with the same Ag should be useful for designing in vitro systems for studying the function of these cell subsets in specific immune responses.     

Human immunodeficiency virus Tat induces functional unresponsiveness in T cells.

Soluble proteins of the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) might play a significant role in the pathogenesis of HIV infection. The addition of synthetic Tat peptides, but not that of the recombinant Nef or Vif protein, inhibited proliferative responses of CD4+ tetanus antigen-specific, exogenous interleukin-2 (IL-2)-independent T-cell clones in a dose-dependent manner. In addition, Tat peptides inhibited the anti-CD3 monoclonal antibody-induced proliferative responses of both purified CD4+ and CD8+ T cells. Tat did not affect proliferative responses induced by phorbol myristate acetate plus ionomycin. The Tat peptides at the concentrations used (0.1 to 3 micrograms/ml) did not affect the viability of the cells as determined by trypan blue exclusion. Treatment of Tat peptides with polyclonal Tat antibodies abrogated the inhibitory effect of Tat. Soluble Tat proteins secreted by HeLa cells transfected with the tat gene also inhibited antigen-induced proliferation of the T-cell clones. Tat inhibited the anti-CD3 monoclonal antibody-induced IL-2 mRNA expression and IL-2 secretion but did not affect IL-2 receptor alpha-chain mRNA or protein expression on peripheral blood T cells. Finally, treatment of T-cell clones with the Tat peptide did not affect the antigen-induced increase in intracellular calcium, hydrolysis of phosphatidyl inositol to inositol trisphosphate, or translocation of protein kinase C from the cytosol to the membrane. These studies demonstrate that the mechanism of the Tat-mediated inhibition of T-cell functions involves a phospholipase C gamma 1-independent pathway.     

Macrophages and T cells control distinct phases of B cell differentiation in the humoral immune response in vitro

The differentiation of B cells in the in vitro PFC-response to red blood cell antigen proceeds through 2 phases. Antigen-reactive B cells acquire the ability to interact with helper T cells in the first phase. This phase is controlled by macrophages through a mediator that they release (Interleukin 1 ([Il-1]). B cells convert into antibody-secreting cells (PFC) in the second phase, which is controlled by helper T cells or by a mediator that they release (T cell-replacing factors [TRF]). This is demonstrated in experiments in which Il-1 increases the number of B cells capable of responding to T cell help. The majority of antigen-reactive B cells reaches that state of differentiation within 40 hr of incubation with Il-1. After this time, the response of B cells depends no longer on the presence of Il-1 but on the presence of T cells or TRF. The presented data suggest that antigen-primed helper T cells (but not unprimed T cells) induce the release of Il-1 by macrophages, thereby also influencing the early phase of B cell differentiation.