Collaborative study for the calibration of a replacement international standard for diphtheria toxoid adsorbed

We present the results of a collaborative study for the characterization of a preparation of diphtheria toxoid adsorbed, and its calibration in terms of the 3rd International Standard (IS) for Diphtheria Toxoid Adsorbed. Calibration was performed using established World Health Organization (WHO) and European Pharmacopoeia (Ph. Eur.) protection models. Two candidate toxoid preparations were included in the study, one of which was adopted as a replacement Ph. Eur. Biological Reference Preparation (BRP, batch 4) in February 2009. The second candidate preparation was found to have a unitage of 213 IU/ampoule based on the calibration by in vivo bioassay in 19 laboratories in 16 countries, and was established as the 4th IS for Diphtheria Toxoid Adsorbed by the WHO Expert Committee on Biological Standardization (ECBS) in October 2009.The study also assessed performance of the replacement standard in mouse and guinea pig serological assays which are used as alternative procedures for diphtheria potency testing. Participants tested both candidate preparations and potency was expressed in relative terms only. Results suggest that the replacement standard is suitable for use as the reference vaccine in serological assays and that the Vero cell assay may be suitable for calibration of future replacement standards.     

Calibration of replacement international standard and European pharmacopoeia biological reference preparation for tetanus toxoid, adsorbed.

Here we report the characterisation of a preparation of tetanus toxoid, adsorbed, and its calibration by 27 laboratories in 19 countries in a joint international collaborative study co-sponsored by World Health Organization (WHO) Expert Committee of Biological Standardization (ECBS) and the European Biological Standardisation Programme of European Directorate for the Quality of Medicines (EDQM), Council of Europe. Calibration was in terms of the Second International Standard (I.S.) for Tetanus Toxoid, Adsorbed, by the established WHO/European Pharmacopoeia (Ph Eur) challenge methods. The replacement standard preparation was found to have a unitage of 469 IU/ampoule on the basis of its calibration in guinea-pigs and 496 IU/ampoule on the basis of its calibration in mice. Assessment, both within the collaborative study and as part of candidate characterisation, indicated satisfactory stability of the candidate preparation. This study also provided some information on the effect of mouse strain on potency testing of tetanus vaccines. A limited assessment of the impact of the replacement standard on testing of current production batches of vaccines was also carried out by four manufacturers. This study did not directly address the serological approaches to potency testing. However, one laboratory offered data from mouse serology assay, which gave comparable estimates to in vivo mouse bioassay.Based on the results of this study and with the agreement of participants, the candidate standard was established as the Third International Standard for Tetanus Toxoid, Adsorbed (coded 98/552) by the WHO Expert Committee of Biological Standardization (ECBS) in November 2000. The same preparation was also established as the second Ph Eur Biological Reference Preparation (Ph Eur BRP, batch no. 2) by the Steering Committee of the Biological Standardisation Programme of the EDQM and approved by the European Pharmacopoeia Commission.     

Collaborative study for the calibration of a replacement International Standard for Tetanus Toxoid Adsorbed

We present the results of a collaborative study for the establishment of a replacement International Standard (IS) for Tetanus Toxoid Adsorbed. Two candidate preparations were included in the study, one of which was established as the 4th IS for Tetanus Toxoid Adsorbed at the WHO Expert Committee on Biological Standardization meeting in October 2010. This preparation was found to have a unitage of 490 IU/ampoule, based on calibration in guinea pig challenge assays. Results from mouse challenge assays suggest that the relative performance of two candidate preparations may differ significantly between guinea pigs and mice. The authors note that the number of laboratories that performed guinea pig challenge assays, which are used to calibrate and assign IU, is much lower than in previous collaborative studies and this may have implications for calibration of replacement standards in the future. The issue of assigning separate units to the IS for guinea pig and mouse assays is discussed. The study also assessed performance of the replacement standard in serological assays which are used as alternative procedures to challenge assays for tetanus potency testing. Results suggest that the replacement standard is suitable for use as the reference vaccine in serological assays.     

Calibration of replacement international standards of diphtheria and tetanus toxoids for use in flocculation test

The 1st International Reference Reagents (IRR) of Diphtheria and Tetanus Toxoids for Flocculation Test (DIFT and TEFT) were established by the WHO in 1988. These reagents are essential for the standardization of assays used to calculate Lf units of toxoids. Candidate replacement materials were provided by several European vaccine manufacturers and were formulated and freeze-dried at NIBSC. This paper provides a summary of the results of an international collaborative study including 18 laboratories from 16 countries, which examined the candidate replacement materials in a variety of methods. Materials 02/176 and 04/150 were proposed and adopted by the Expert Committee on Biological Standardization of WHO in October 2007 as 2nd WHO International Standards of Diphtheria and Tetanus Toxoid for use in Flocculation Test. The replacement standards were assigned the value of 1100 and 690Lf/ampoule, respectively, based on results of flocculation tests carried out using provided reagents. Material coded 02/176 fully complied with the WHO specifications for stability, residual moisture content, precision of fill and sterility. Stability of material coded 04/150 was slightly lower than expected but predictions were based only on 2-year data and were to be further monitored, post-adoption.     

Quantitative estimation of diphtheria and tetanus toxoids. 4. Toxoids as international reference materials defining Lf-units for diphtheria and tetanus toxoids

The Lf-unit, which is used in the control of diphtheria and tetanus toxoid production and in some countries also to follow immunization of horses for production of antitoxins, has hitherto been defined by means of antitoxin preparations. A diphtheria toxoid and a tetanus toxoid preparation, both freeze-dried, were examined in an international collaborative study for their suitability to serve as reference reagents in the flocculation tests and for defining the Lf-units. It was shown that flocculation tests using the reference toxoids are very reproducible and reliable and the WHO Expert Committee on Biological Standardization established: the toxoid called DIFT as the International Reference Reagent of Diphtheria Toxoid for Flocculation Test with a defined content of 900 Lf-units of diphtheria toxoid per ampoule; and the toxoid called TEFT as the International Reference Reagent of Tetanus Toxoid for Flocculation Test with a defined content of 1000 Lf-units of diphtheria toxoid per ampoule.     

Calibration and commutability assessment of the 1st International Standard for Diphtheria Antitoxin Human

The 1st International Standard for Diphtheria Antitoxin Human (coded 10/262) was established by the World Health Organization Expert Committee on Biological Standardization in 2012. This paper describes the production, characterization and calibration of the new standard which is intended for use in the standardization of assays used to measure diphtheria antibody responses in human serum. The new standard was calibrated in terms of the International Standard for Diphtheria Antitoxin Equine in an international collaborative study. A total of 8 participants from 8 different countries performed in vivo and/or in vitro toxin neutralization tests and returned data that was used to assign units to the proposed new standard. The new standard has a diphtheria antitoxin potency of 2 IU/ampoule and is predicted to be stable. A follow up study was performed to assess commutability of the new standard. The follow up study was an existing external quality assessment, modified to include the new standard. Results obtained suggest that the new standard is commutable, showing comparable behaviour to native human serum samples in the majority of the assays compared, and is therefore suitable for use as a reference preparation in assays used to measure the level of anti-diphtheria antibodies in human serum.     

Evaluation of Fourth International Standard for Whole Cell Pertussis Vaccine

Whole cell pertussis vaccine is still widely used in many countries. An International Standard is needed for its potency control. The Third International Standard for Pertussis Vaccine was prepared about 40 years ago and its replacement was recommended by the Expert Committee for Biological Standardisation (ECBS) of the WHO. Material in ampoules coded 94/532 was prepared as a candidate replacement and has been evaluated in international collaborative studies which consisted of two parts. The first part, to assess the suitability of the candidate standard by comparing it with the Second International Standard for Pertussis Vaccine (IS2) involved 14 laboratories in 11 countries. The second part to compare the candidate standard with the Third International Standard for Pertussis Vaccine (IS3) involved 16 laboratories in 14 countries. Since 1995 various other studies have included the international standards and the results of these are also considered in assessing likely continuity of the IU for potency of whole cell pertussis vaccine. The preparation in ampoules coded 94/532 was adopted by the WHO ECBS in October 2006 as the 4th International Standard for whole cell pertussis vaccine and assigned an activity of 40 IU per ampoule on the basis of the studies reported here.     

An international collaborative study on the First International Standard of bovine luteinizing hormone for immunoassay

An ampouled freeze-dried preparation of bovine pituitary luteinizing hormone (bLH), coded EHC-bLH-1, has been evaluated in an international collaborative study and shown to be suitable and sufficiently stable to serve as a standard for bLH. Eight laboratories provided immunoassay data, one laboratory provided receptor assay data, and bioassay data were obtained from 4 laboratories. The geometric mean potency estimate obtained by immunoassays, expressed as milliunits of the USDA bLH-B-5 preparation per ampoule, was 25.6, which is consistent with the result obtained by in-vivo bioassays. The geometric mean estimate obtained by receptor assays or by in-vitro bioassays was lower, i.e. 13.2 milliunits per ampoule. The reason for this discrepancy is currently under investigation. With the authorization of the Expert Committee on Biological Standardization of the World Health Organization this preparation was established in 1985 as the International Standard for Luteinizing Hormone, Bovine, for Immunoassay with a unitage of 25 mi.u. per ampoule.     

Report of a collaborative study to calibrate the Second International Standard for parvovirus B19 antibody

A collaborative study was undertaken to assess the suitability of a replacement for the First International Standard for parvovirus B19 IgG, human serum and to calibrate it in IU. The proposed standard, which is a pool of sera from 16 US blood donors, was assayed along with the First International Standard, a coded duplicate of the proposed standard and a plasma sample from a single blood donor. Nine laboratories from eight countries participated in the studies and five different assay kits were used. Two kits contained VP1+VP2, one kit contained VP1 only and two kits, one of which was used by five participants contained VP2 only. Differences in detection of the proposed standard and the individual plasma were observed with assay kits containing different antigens, VP1, VP2 or VP1+VP2. However, since VP1 is a minor capsid protein and on its own does not assemble into virus like particles and the dominant response in individuals appears to be against VP2, it was considered reasonable to utilize only the data from kits containing VP2 antigen for the calibration of the proposed standard. The results of this study demonstrated that the proposed standard coded 01/602 was suitable to serve as the replacement International Standard for parvovirus B19, serum IgG, and this preparation was established as the Second International Standard for parvovirus B19 antibody, plasma human, with an assigned unitage of 77 IU per ampoule by the Expert Committee on Biological Standardisation of the World Health Organisation in February 2003.     

Collaborative study for the establishment of a European Phamacopoeia Biological reference preparation for Bordetella pertussis mouse antiserum for serological potency testing of acellular pertussis vaccines.

A collaborative study was organised by the European Directorate For the Quality of Medicines (EDQM) to assess the suitability of a candidate mouse antiserum as a European Pharmacopoeia Biological reference preparation (BRP) for acellular pertussis vaccine potency testing. The candidate antiserum was obtained by immunising mice with a five-component acellular pertussis vaccine: pertussis toxin (PT), filamentous haemagglutinin (FHA), pertactin (PRN) and Fimbrial 2/Fimbrial 3 (Fim 2&3).The study has been divided into two separate phases. Phase I was a pre-qualification study including three laboratories. This phase was aimed at pre-qualifying the candidate BRP (cBRP) and at documenting the impact of differences in the antibody detection methodology enzyme linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) procedures on results of pertussis antisera calibration versus the currently used standard US standard pertussis antiserum (mouse) Lot 1 (SPAM-1) (United States Food and Drug Administration (USFDA) reference serum) and the cBRP. As no significant difference between the antibody titres determined by using the different ELISA methodologies was found, a large-scale study enrolling 13 laboratories (Phase II) was carried out, each participant performing its in-house methodology. Its aim was to calibrate the cBRP (in terms of the SPAM-1 reference) and to demonstrate its equivalence or superiority to internal references. The study showed that there was no difference in positive sera titres expressed relative to their corresponding internal reference (homologous situation) or the proposed standard (heterologous situation) reference. The cBRP can, therefore, reliably act as replacement for the in-house reference preparations. Further analysis of the outcome of this study enabled to assign to the cBRP a potency of 39, 138, 34 and 56 ELISA unit per millilitre, respectively, to its anti-PT, anti-FHA, anti-PRN and anti-Fim 2&3 antibody contents. The cBRP has been adopted by the European Pharmacopoeia Commission at its June 2000 session as Bordetella pertussis mouse anti-serum Ph Eur. BRP batch 1.     

Product-specific validation of a serological potency test for release of Leptospira vaccines in the European Union

Historically in the European Union, all Leptospira vaccines were released using the European Pharmacopoeia (Ph. Eur.) hamster potency assay. Recently, there has been a shift toward alternatives that offer either refinement of testing or replacement of animals for product release. This is being driven by animal welfare concerns but also by a drive to have more consistent, cheaper, and faster batch release tests. This publication discusses one such example of a multicomponent canine vaccine that includes three Leptospira serovars and has recently been registered in the European Union. The potency release test is a refinement because it uses rabbit serology rather than hamster challenge. This publication covers the principles of the test method, challenges faced during its development and registration, and discussion about benefits and limitations of this method. It concludes with a view of how the use of serology testing could fit into an overall strategy to move to fully in vitro testing by adopting a consistency approach.     

Hepatitis A Immunoglobulin: An International Collaborative Study to Establish the Second International Standard

A collaborative study was carried out to assess the suitability of a candidate replacement material for the International Standard for hepatitis A immunoglobulin, which was found to be reactive for HCV RNA, and to calibrate it in International Units. The candidate standard, coded 97/646, was derived from a bulk of 16% immunoglobulin supplied by the Central Laboratory of the Netherlands Red Cross, Amsterdam, and diluted 1 in 2 in H2O resulting in a final immunoglobulin concentration of 8%. Sixteen laboratories from 11 countries participated in the study and contributed data from 64 assays performed using six commercial assay kits and four in-house methods. All assays were analysed as parallel line bioassays comparing assay response with log concentration. The overall mean potency of the candidate replacement immunoglobulin standard, 97/646, relative to the International Standard for hepatitis A immunoglobulin, was 98.6 IU/ml. A freeze-dried serum preparation, 97/648, was also calibrated in this study and had a potency of 22.64 IU/ml. The Second International Standard for hepatitis A immunoglobulin, human, was established by the World Health Organisation Expert Committee on Biological Standardisation in 1998 with a potency of 49 IU per ampoule when reconstituted in 0.5 ml.     

The International Standard for Endotoxin: evaluation in an international collaborative study

An ampouled preparation of bacterial endotoxin, coded 84/650, was evaluated in 35 laboratories in 12 countries for its suitability to serve as the International Standard for Endotoxin. The ampouled preparation was calibrated in terms of the USA National Standard, EC5, in Limulus Amoebocyte Lysate gelation, turbidimetric and chromogenic tests and in rabbit pyrogen tests. On the basis of the results reported here, with the agreement of the participants in the study, and with the authorization of the Expert Committee on Biological Standardization of the World Health Organization, the preparation coded 84/650 was established in 1986 as the International Standard for Endotoxin for Limulus Gelation Tests with an assigned unitage of 14,000 IU of endotoxin per ampoule.     

World Health Organization International Standard To Harmonize Assays for Detection of Mycoplasma DNA

Nucleic acid amplification technique (NAT)-based assays (referred to here as NAT assays) are increasingly used as an alternative to culture-based approaches for the detection of mycoplasma contamination of cell cultures. Assay features, like the limit of detection or quantification, vary widely between different mycoplasma NAT assays. Biological reference materials may be useful for harmonization of mycoplasma NAT assays. An international feasibility study included lyophilized preparations of four distantly related mycoplasma species (Acholeplasma laidlawii, Mycoplasma fermentans, M. orale, M. pneumoniae) at different concentrations which were analyzed by 21 laboratories using 26 NAT assays with a qualitative, semiquantitative, or quantitative design. An M. fermentans preparation was shown to decrease the interassay variation when used as a common reference material. The preparation was remanufactured and characterized in a comparability study, and its potency (in NAT-detectable units) across different NATs was determined. The World Health Organization (WHO) Expert Committee on Biological Standardization (ECBS) established this preparation to be the “1st World Health Organization international standard for mycoplasma DNA for nucleic acid amplification technique-based assays designed for generic mycoplasma detection” (WHO Tech Rep Ser 987:42, 2014) with a potency of 200,000 IU/ml. This WHO international standard is now available as a reference preparation for characterization of NAT assays, e.g., for determination of analytic sensitivity, for calibration of quantitative assays in a common unitage, and for defining regulatory requirements in the field of mycoplasma testing.     

The Second International Standard for anti-poliovirus sera types 1, 2 and 3.

The Second International Standard for anti-poliovirus sera types 1, 2 and 3 was established by the WHO Expert Committee on Biological Standardization in 1991 on the basis of an extensive collaborative study. Nine laboratories from eight countries participated and all used neutralizing antibody assays. The standard is a human serum pool which contains antibodies to all three poliovirus types and replaces the three previously established monovalent standards which were all hyperimmune monkey sera. The standard was assigned an activity of 25 IU of anti-poliovirus serum (type 1) human: 50 IU of anti-poliovirus serum (type 2) human; and 5 IU of anti-poliovirus serum (type 3) human. The study also showed significant interlaboratory differences in relative potency are observed when human sera are compared to hyperimmune monkey sera. It was therefore recommended that National laboratory references are established from human sera.     

WHO international reference reagents for human proinsulin and human insulin C-peptide

Candidate preparations for international reference reagents for immunoassays of human proinsulin and human insulin C-peptide were evaluated in an international collaborative study. With the authorization of the Expert Committee on Biological Standardization of WHO, the following preparations were established as international reference reagents: human proinsulin (84/611, nominal ampoule content 6 micrograms) and human insulin C-peptide (84/510, 10 micrograms). Each preparation is intended as a primary reference reagent for the calibration of immunoassays.     

International collaborative study by in vitro bioassays of the first international standard for porcine inhibin.

A lyophilized preparation of inhibin from porcine ovarian follicular fluid, ampoule code 86/690, was made internationally available as a research standard for in vitro bioassays in 1987. A study involving ten participants in eight countries assessed the stability and suitability of this research standard to serve as an international standard. Each of the participants used in vitro assays, the majority of which depended upon the inhibition of release of follicle-stimulating hormone from dispersed rat anterior pituitary cells. The research standard 86/690 was compared with coded ampoules of 86/690 stored under conditions of accelerated thermal degradation and with inhibins from different species. Intra- and interlaboratory variation for estimates of potency of a coded duplicate ampoule of the research standard provided the basis for comparisons of non-identical inhibins, but the fourfold variability of potency estimates for identical ampoules was such that no conclusions about the differences seen for non-identical inhibins could be made. Predictions of stability from consensus estimates of potency of ampoules that have undergone accelerated thermal degradation indicated that the research standard had satisfactory stability. On the basis of this study, the research standard 86/690 was deemed sufficiently stable and suitable to serve as a standard for in vitro bioassays and was established by the World Health Organization Expert Committee on Biological Standardization as the First International Standard for Porcine Inhibin. The possible presence, in biological extracts (standard or sample), of other bioactive proteins, such as activin and follistatin, complicates the quantitative interpretation of bioassay data. A standard of highly purified human inhibin is now required as a standard for immunoassays used for clinical research purposes; sufficient quantities of recombinant human inhibins have recently been donated for ampouling and evaluation by bio- and immunoassay in the subsequent phase of the standardization of inhibins.     

European regulatory framework and practices for veterinary Leptospira vaccine potency testing

In Europe, the legal basis for requirements for medicinal products is described in the European Pharmacopoeia (Ph. Eur.) In the European Union, the Ph. Eur. is supplemented by several guidelines issued by the European Medicines Agency. Immunological veterinary products must comply with the Ph. Eur. monograph on veterinary vaccines and the accompanying texts, as well as specific monographs. The Ph. Eur. includes monographs on canine leptospirosis and bovine leptospirosis vaccines (inactivated). Both monographs require that an immunogenicity test be performed once in the target species during the life of a vaccine. The hamster challenge test is applied for batch potency testing of canine vaccines. Alternatively, serological tests or suitable validated in vitro tests to determine the content of one or more antigenic components indicative of protection may be performed. Vaccines for use in cattle are tested in a serological test in guinea pigs. The acceptance criteria in alternative tests are set with reference to a batch of vaccine that has given satisfactory results in the immunogenicity test. At a January 2012 European workshop, the suitability of the hamster potency test was questioned and unanimous agreement was reached that moving toward complete in vitro testing is possible and should be promoted.     

World Health Organization International Standards for highly purified human, porcine and bovine insulins

The 4th International Standard (IS) for Insulin, established in 1958, consists of a mixture of relatively impure bovine and porcine insulins and is not suitable as a standard for the assay of highly purified single-species insulins presently used in the treatment of diabetes. Preparations of human, bovine and porcine crystalline insulins, representative of current highly purified therapeutic insulins, have now been studied in an international collaborative study carried out by twenty-three laboratories in fifteen countries. In the collaborative study described here, each of the three preparations was found to be suitable for use as a standard for insulin for bioassay and each was established by WHO in 1986 as an international standard. The 4th IS of Insulin bovine/porcine (code numbered 58/6) has been discontinued. Insulin preparations should now be calibrated in terms of International Units defined by the standard for the appropriate species: the International Standard for Insulin, Human, the International Standard for Insulin, Bovine, or the International Standard for Insulin, Porcine.     

European Multi-Centre Validation Study of NucliSens Extractor in Combination with HCV Amplicor 2·0 Assay for HCV-NAT Screening of Plasma Pools

The NucliSens Extractor in combination with the 2.0 version of the Roche Cobas HCV Amplicor test has been validated by five European blood screening laboratories in a multi-centre study. For testing the performance characteristics of this HCV-NAT method, the European Pharmacopoeia validation guidelines were followed. The CLB VQC reference reagents were used for testing robustness and sensitivity. After a technical improvement in the extraction stations, the NucliSens Extractor appeared to be contamination-free as was proved by testing negative controls alternating with samples containing a high HCV-RNA concentration. The Pelicheck HCV-RNA genotype 1 dilution panel was tested 74 times in the five laboratories and an overall 95% detection limit of 80 genome equivalents (geq)/ml was found. In one laboratory the Pelicheck panel was tested in 25 runs and here a 95% detection limit of 32 geq/ml was achieved. In this laboratory the Pelispy HCV-RNA run control samples of 140 geq/ml were consistently picked up in all extractor stations. In addition the laboratories have tested a WHO HCV-RNA genotype 1 standard dilution series 39 times and a Pelicheck HCV-RNA genotype 3 reference panel in 32 test runs. The limiting dilution analysis enabled us to compare the detection efficiency of the NucliSens-Amplicor method for the genoype 1 and genotype 3 isolates and to calibrate the reference reagents against each other. The combined Nuclisens-Amplicor method was found to detect the genotype 3 isolate in the Pelicheck HCV-RNA panels with 2-3 fold lower efficiency than the genotype 1 standard (assuming that the historical calibration of the genotype 3 against the genotype 1 standard is correct). In this study of a single method 1 IU of the WHO HCV-RNA standard was found to be equivalent to 5.1 geq of the VQC HCV-RNA standard (95% confidence intervals 3.1-9.1 geq). To avoid confusion with the use of the CLB VQC reagents we accept the NIBSC collaborative study in which calibration by a variety of methods showed that the Pelispy 380 geq/ml run control is equivalent to 100 IU/ml of the WHO standard. This multi-centre validation study demonstrates that the 95% detection limit of the NucliSens HCV Amplicor method lies far below the detection limits required by the international regulatory bodies.