Conversion of a heme-based oxygen sensor to a heme oxygenase by hydrogen sulfide: effects of mutations in the heme distal side of a heme-based oxygen sensor phosphodiesterase (Ec DOS)

The heme-based oxygen-sensor phosphodiesterase from Escherichia coli (Ec DOS), is composed of an N-terminal heme-bound oxygen sensing domain and a C-terminal catalytic domain. Oxygen (O₂) binding to the heme Fe(II) complex in Ec DOS substantially enhances catalysis. Addition of hydrogen sulfide (H₂S) to the heme Fe(III) complex in Ec DOS also remarkably stimulates catalysis in part due to the heme Fe(III)–SH and heme Fe(II)–O₂ complexes formed by H₂S. In this study, we examined the roles of the heme distal amino acids, M95 (the axial ligand of the heme Fe(II) complex) and R97 (the O₂ binding site in the heme Fe(II)–O₂ complex) of the isolated heme-binding domain of Ec DOS (Ec DOS-PAS) in the binding of H₂S under aerobic conditions. Interestingly, R97A and R97I mutant proteins formed an oxygen-incorporated modified heme, verdoheme, following addition of H₂S combined with H₂O₂ generated by the reactions. Time-dependent mass spectroscopic data corroborated the findings. In contrast, H₂S did not interact with the heme Fe(III) complex of M95H and R97E mutants. Thus, M95 and/or R97 on the heme distal side in Ec DOS-PAS significantly contribute to the interaction of H₂S with the Fe(III) heme complex and also to the modification of the heme Fe(III) complex with reactive oxygen species. Importantly, mutations of the O₂ binding site of the heme protein converted its function from oxygen sensor to that of a heme oxygenase. This study establishes the novel role of H₂S in modifying the heme iron complex to form verdoheme with the aid of reactive oxygen species.     

Primary processes in heme-based sensor proteins

A wide and still rapidly increasing range of heme-based sensor proteins has been discovered over the last two decades. At the molecular level, these proteins function as bistable switches in which the catalytic activity of an enzymatic domain is altered mostly by binding or dissociation of small gaseous ligands (O₂, NO or CO) to the heme in a sensor domain. The initial “signal” at the heme level is subsequently transmitted within the protein to the catalytic site, ultimately leading to adapted expression levels of specific proteins. Making use of the photolability of the heme-ligand bond that mimics thermal dissociation, early processes in this intra-protein signaling pathway can be followed using ultrafast optical spectroscopic techniques; they also occur on timescales accessible to molecular dynamics simulations. Experimental studies performed over the last decade on proteins including the sensors FixL (O₂), CooA (CO) and soluble guanylate cyclase (NO) are reviewed with an emphasis on emerging general mechanisms. After heme-ligand bond breaking, the ligand can escape from the heme pocket and eventually from the protein, or rebind directly to the heme. Remarkably, in all sensor proteins the rebinding, specifically of the sensed ligand, is highly efficient. This ”ligand trap” property possibly provides means to smoothen the effects of fast environmental fluctuations on the switching frequency. For 6-coordinate proteins, where exchange between an internal heme-bound residue and external gaseous ligands occurs, the study of early processes starting from the unliganded form indicates that mobility of the internal ligand may facilitate signal transfer. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Oxygen Binding and Sensing Proteins.     

The FG loop of a heme-based gas sensor enzyme, Ec DOS, functions in heme binding, autoxidation and catalysis

Ec DOS is a heme-based gas sensor enzyme that catalyzes conversion from cyclic-di-GMP to linear-di-GMP in response to gas molecules, such as oxygen, CO and NO. Ec DOS contains an N-terminal heme-binding PAS domain and C-terminal phosphodiesterase domain. Based on crystal structures of the isolated heme-binding domain, it is suggested that the FG loop is involved in intra-molecular signal transduction to the catalytic domain. We generated nine full-length proteins mutated at ionic and non-ionic polar residues between positions 83 and 96 corresponding to the F-helix and FG loop, and examined the heme binding properties, autoxidation rates, and catalytic activities of mutant proteins. N84A and R85A mutant proteins displayed lower heme binding affinities, consistent with the finding that Asn84 interacts with propionate of protoporphyrin IX, and Arg85 with Asp40 on the heme proximal side. Autoxidation rates (0.058-0.54 min⁻¹) of R91A, S96A and K89A/R91A/E93A mutant proteins were significantly higher than that (0.0053 min⁻¹) of wild-type protein, suggesting that these residues in the FG loop form heme distal architecture conferring stability to the Fe(II)-O₂ complex. Catalytic activities of N84A and R85A mutant proteins with low heme affinity were significantly higher than those of wild-type protein in the absence of gas molecules. Accordingly, we propose that loss of heme binding enhances basal catalysis without the gas molecule, consistent with previous reports on heme inhibition of Ec DOS catalysis.     

Important roles of Tyr43 at the putative heme distal side in the oxygen recognition and stability of the Fe(II)-O2 complex of YddV, a globin-coupled heme-based oxygen sensor diguanylate cyclase

YddV from Escherichia coli (Ec) is a novel globin-coupled heme-based oxygen sensor protein displaying diguanylate cyclase activity in response to oxygen availability. In this study, we quantified the turnover numbers of the active [Fe(III), 0.066 min(-1); Fe(II)-O(2) and Fe(II)-CO, 0.022 min(-1)] [Fe(III), Fe(III)-protoporphyrin IX complex; Fe(II), Fe(II)-protoporphyrin IX complex] and inactive forms [Fe(II) and Fe(II)-NO, <0.01 min(-1)] of YddV for the first time. Our data indicate that the YddV reaction is the rate-determining step for two consecutive reactions coupled with phosphodiesterase Ec DOS activity on cyclic di-GMP (c-di-GMP) [turnover number of Ec DOS-Fe(II)-O(2), 61 min(-1)]. Thus, O(2) binding and the heme redox switch of YddV appear to be critical factors in the regulation of c-di-GMP homeostasis. The redox potential and autoxidation rate of heme of the isolated heme domain of YddV (YddV-heme) were determined to be -17 mV versus the standard hydrogen electrode and 0.0076 min(-1), respectively. The Fe(II) complexes of Y43A and Y43L mutant proteins (residues at the heme distal side of the isolated heme-bound globin domain of YddV) exhibited very low O(2) affinities, and thus, their Fe(II)-O(2) complexes were not detected on the spectra. The O(2) dissociation rate constant of the Y43W protein was >150 s(-1), which is significantly larger than that of the wild-type protein (22 s(-1)). The autoxidation rate constants of the Y43F and Y43W mutant proteins were 0.069 and 0.12 min(-1), respectively, which are also markedly higher than that of the wild-type protein. The resonance Raman frequencies representing ν(Fe-O(2)) (559 cm(-1)) of the Fe(II)-O(2) complex and ν(Fe-CO) (505 cm(-1)) of the Fe(II)-CO complex of Y43F differed from those (ν(Fe-O(2)), 565 cm(-1); ν(Fe-CO), 495 cm(-1)) of the wild-type protein, suggesting that Tyr43 forms hydrogen bonds with both O(2) and CO molecules. On the basis of the results, we suggest that Tyr43 located at the heme distal side is important for the O(2) recognition and stability of the Fe(II)-O(2) complex, because the hydroxyl group of the residue appears to interact electrostatically with the O(2) molecule bound to the Fe(II) complex in YddV. Our findings clearly support a role of Tyr in oxygen sensing, and thus modulation of overall conversion from GTP to pGpG via c-di-GMP catalyzed by YddV and Ec DOS, which may be applicable to other globin-coupled oxygen sensor enzymes.     

Ligand binding dynamics to the heme domain of the oxygen sensor Dos from Escherichia coli

In the heme-based oxygen sensor Dos from Escherichia coli, one of the axial ligands (Met 95) of a six-coordinate heme can be replaced by external ligands such as O(2), NO, and CO, which causes a switch in phosphodiesterase activity. To gain insight into the bidirectional switching mechanism, we have studied the interaction of ligands with the sensor domain DosH by flash photolysis experiments with femtosecond time resolution. The internal ligand can be photodissociated from the ferrous heme and recombines with time constants of 7 and 35 ps. This is somewhat slower than recombination of the external ligands NO, with which picosecond rebinding occurs with unprecedented efficiency (>99%) with a predominant phase of approximately 5 ps, and O(2) (97% in 5 ps, Liebl, U., Bouzhir-Sima, L., Négrerie, M., Martin, J.-L., and Vos, M. H. (2002) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 99, 12771-12776). Dissociated CO displays geminate rebinding in 1.5 ns with a very high yield (60%). Together these results indicate that the heme environment provides a very tight pocket for external ligands, presumably preventing frequent switching events. Additional CO dissociation and rebinding experiments on a longer time scale reveal that (a) Met 95 binding, in 100 micros, occurs in competition with bimolecular CO binding, and (b) subsequent replacement of Met 95 by CO on the millisecond time scale occurs faster than in rapid-mixing experiments, suggesting a slow further relaxation. A minimal ligand binding model is proposed that suggests that Met 95 displacement from the heme is facilitated by the presence of an external ligand in the heme environment. Furthermore, the orders of magnitude difference between Met 95 binding after dissociation of internal and external ligands, as well as the spectral characteristics of photodissociation intermediates, indicate substantial rearrangement of the heme environment associated with ligand sensing. Further remarkable observations include evidence for stable (>4 ns) photooxidation of six-coordinate ferrous heme, with a quantum yield of 4-8%.     

Interdomain interactions within the two-component heme-based sensor DevS from Mycobacterium tuberculosis

DevS is the sensor of the DevS-DevR two-component regulatory system of Mycobacterium tuberculosis. This system is thought to be responsible for initiating entrance of this bacterium into the nonreplicating persistent state in response to NO and anaerobiosis. DevS is modular in nature and consists of two N-terminal GAF domains and C-terminal histidine kinase and ATPase domains. The first GAF domain (GAF A) binds heme, and this cofactor is thought to be responsible for sensing environmental stimuli, but the function of the second GAF domain (GAF B) is unknown. Here we report the RR characterization of full-length DevS (FL DevS) as well as truncated proteins consisting of the single GAF A domain (GAF A DevS) and both GAF domains (GAF A/B) in both oxidation states and bound to the exogenous ligands CO, NO, and O2. The results indicate that the GAF B domain increases the specificity with which the distal heme pocket of the GAF A domain interacts with CO and NO as opposed to O2. Specifically, while two comparable populations of CO and NO adducts are observed in GAF A DevS, only one of these two conformers is present in significant concentration in the GAF A/B and FL DevS proteins. In contrast, hydrogen bond interactions at the bound oxygen in the oxy complexes are conserved in all DevS constructs. The comparison of the data obtained with the O2 complexes with those of the CO and NO complexes suggests a model for ligand discrimination which relies on a specific hydrogen-bonding network with bound O2. It also suggests that interactions between the two GAF domains are responsible for transduction of structural changes at the heme domain that accompany ligand binding/dissociation to modulate activity at the kinase domain.     

The Aer2 receptor from Vibrio cholerae is a dual PAS‐heme oxygen sensor

The diarrheal pathogen Vibrio cholerae navigates complex environments using three chemosensory systems and 44–45 chemoreceptors. Chemosensory cluster II modulates chemotaxis, whereas clusters I and III have unknown functions. Ligands have been identified for only five V. cholerae chemoreceptors. Here, we report that the cluster III receptor, VcAer2, binds and responds to O₂. VcAer2 is an ortholog of Pseudomonas aeruginosa Aer2 (PaAer2) but differs in that VcAer2 has two, rather than one, N‐terminal PAS domain. We have determined that both PAS1 and PAS2 form homodimers and bind penta‐coordinate b‐type heme via an Eη‐His residue. Heme binding to PAS1 required the entire PAS core, but receptor function also required the N‐terminal cap. PAS2 functioned as an O₂‐sensor [ , 19 μM], utilizing the same Iβ Trp (W276) as PaAer2 to stabilize O₂. The crystal structure of PAS2‐W276L was similar to that of PaAer2‐PAS but resided in an active conformation mimicking the ligand‐bound state, consistent with its signal‐on phenotype. PAS1 also bound O₂ [ , 12 μM], although O₂ binding was stabilized by either a Trp residue or Tyr residue. Moreover, PAS1 appeared to function as a signal modulator, regulating O₂‐mediated signaling from PAS2 and resulting in activation of the cluster III chemosensory pathway.     

Phosphodiesterase A1, a regulator of cellulose synthesis in Acetobacter xylinum, is a heme-based sensor

The phosphodiesterase A1 protein of Acetobacter xylinum, AxPDEA1, is a key regulator of bacterial cellulose synthesis. This phosphodiesterase linearizes cyclic bis(3'-->5')diguanylic acid, an allosteric activator of the bacterial cellulose synthase, to the ineffectual pGpG. Here we show that AxPDEA1 contains heme and is regulated by reversible binding of O(2) to the heme. Apo-AxPDEA1 has less than 2% of the phosphodiesterase activity of holo-AxPDEA1, and reconstitution with hemin restores full activity. O(2) regulation is due to deoxyheme being a better activator than oxyheme. AxPDEA1 is homologous to the Escherichia coli direct oxygen sensor protein, EcDos, over its entire length and is homologous to the FixL histidine kinases over only a heme-binding PAS domain. The properties of the heme-binding domain of AxPDEA1 are significantly different from those of other O(2)-responsive heme-based sensors. The rate of AxPDEA1 autoxidation (half-life > 12 h) is the slowest observed so far for this type of heme protein fold. The O(2) affinity of AxPDEA1 (K(d) approximately 10 microM) is comparable to that of EcDos, but the rate constants for O(2) association (k(on) = 6.6 microM(-)(1) s(-)(1)) and dissociation (k(off) = 77 s(-)(1)) are 2000 times higher. Our results illustrate the versatility of signal transduction mechanisms for the heme-PAS class of O(2) sensors and provide the first example of O(2) regulation of a second messenger.     

Novel heme: O2 bonding of possible relevance to oxygen utilizing heme and other proteins

Solid dipyridine hemes which are unreactive toward oxygen lose both pyridine ligands upon heating under vacuum to give a solid which takes up O₂, reversibly, one O₂ per heme. Replacement of ¹⁶O₂ by ¹⁸O₂ reduces only infrared bands near 1660 and 1590 cm^?1, frequencies near the vibrational band for gaseous O₂. No FeO bands are detected. EPR spectra reveal a free radical and ferric iron; Mössbauer, NMR and infrared spectra support an iron(III) oxidation state. Limited molecular weight data indicate a dimer. Possibly two dioxygen molecules are held sandwich fashion between two porphyrins via donor-acceptor interactions, which are facilitated by electron transfer from iron(II) into the porphyrin forming a π-anion. Such O₂ bonding is not found in oxy Hb and Mb or in oxyhemerythrin but may occur with cytochrome $\text{c}$ oxidase and other oxygen utilizing (or producing) heme and other proteins.     

Cytochrome c peroxidase is a mitochondrial heme-based H2O2 sensor that modulates antioxidant defense

Hydrogen peroxide (H₂O₂) is a key signaling molecule that also induces apoptosis. Thus, cells must rapidly sense and tightly control H₂O₂ levels. Well-characterized cellular responses to exogenous H₂O₂ involve oxidation of specific cytosolic protein-based thiols but sensing of H₂O₂ generated by mitochondrial respiration is less well described. Here we provide substantial biochemical evidence that the heme enzyme Ccp1 (cytochrome c peroxidase), which is targeted to the intermembrane space, functions primarily as a mitochondrial H₂O₂ sensing and signaling protein in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Key evidence for a sensing role for Ccp1 is the significantly higher H₂O₂ accumulation in ccp1-null cells(ccp1Δ) vs ccp1^W191F cells producing the catalytically inactive Ccp1^W191F variant. In fact, intracellular H₂O₂ levels (ccp1Δ>wildtype >ccp1^W191F) correlate inversely with the activity of the mitochondrial (and peroxisomal) heme catalase, Cta1 (ccp1Δ<wildtype <ccp1^W191F). Mitochondrial Sod2 activity also varies in the three strains (ccp1Δ>wildtype >ccp1^W191F) and ccp1Δ cells exhibit low superoxide levels. Notably, Ccp1^W191F is a more persistent H₂O₂ signaling protein than wild-type Ccp1, and this enhanced mitochondrial H₂O₂ signaling decreases the mitochondrial fitness of ccp1^W191F cells. However, these cells are fully protected from a bolus (0.4 mM) of exogenous H₂O₂ added after 12 h of growth, whereas the viability of ccp1Δ cells drops below 20%, which additionally associates Ccp1 with Yap1-dependent H₂O₂ signaling. Combined, our results strongly implicate Ccp1, independent of its peroxidase activity, in mitochondrial H₂O₂ sensing and signaling to maintain reactive oxygen species homeostasis.     

Nature of the displaceable heme-axial residue in the EcDos protein,a heme-based sensor from Escherichia coli

The EcDos protein belongs to a group of heme-based sensors that detect their ligands with a heme-binding PAS domain. Among these various heme-PAS proteins, EcDos is unique in having its heme iron coordinated at both axial positions to residues of the protein. To achieve its high affinities for ligands, one of the axial heme-iron residues in EcDos must be readily displaceable. Here we present evidence from mutagenesis, ligand-binding measurements, and magnetic circular dichroism, resonance Raman, and electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopies about the nature of the displaceable residue in the heme-PAS domain of EcDos, i.e., EcDosH. The magnetic circular dichroism spectra in the near-infrared region establish histidine-methionine coordination in met-EcDos. To determine whether in deoxy-EcDos coordination of the sixth axial position is also to methionine, methionine 95 was substituted with isoleucine. This substitution caused the ferrous heme iron to change from an exclusively hexacoordinate low-spin form (EcDosH) to an exclusively pentacoordinate high-spin form (M95I EcDosH). This was accompanied by a modest acceleration of the dissociation rates of ligands but a dramatic increase (60-1300-fold) in the association rate constants for binding of O(2), CO, and NO. As a result, the affinity for O(2) was enhanced 10-fold in M95I EcDosH, but the partition constant M = [K(d)(O(2))/K(d)(CO)] between CO and O(2) was raised to about 30 from the extraordinarily low EcDosH value of 1. Thus a major consequence of the increased O(2) affinity of this sensor was the loss of its unusually strong ligand discrimination.     

Improvement of heme oxygenase-1-based heme sensor for quantifying free heme in biological samples

We recently reported a novel heme sensor using fluorescently labeled heme oxygenase-1; however, its inherent enzyme activity would be a potential obstacle in quantifying heme in biological samples. Here, we found that mutation of the catalytically important residue, Asp140, with histidine in the sensor not only diminished the heme degradation activity but also increased heme binding affinity. The sensor with a visible fluorophore was also found to be beneficial to avoid background emission from endogenous substance in biological samples. By using the improved heme sensor, we succeeded in quantifying free heme in rat hepatic samples for the first time.     

Role of distal arginine in early sensing intermediates in the heme domain of the oxygen sensor FixL

FixL is a bacterial heme-based oxygen sensor, in which release of oxygen from the sensing PAS domain leads to activation of an associated kinase domain. Static structural studies have suggested an important role of the conserved residue arginine 220 in signal transmission at the level of the heme domain. To assess the role of this residue in the dynamics and properties of the initial intermediates in ligand release, we have investigated the effects of R220X (X = I, Q, E, H, or A) mutations in the FixLH heme domain on the dynamics and spectral properties of the heme upon photolysis of O(2), NO, and CO using femtosecond transient absorption spectroscopy. Comparison of transient spectra for CO and NO dissociation with steady-state spectra indicated less strain on the heme in the ligand dissociation species for all mutants compared to the wild type (WT). For CO and NO, the kinetics were similar to those of the wild type, with the exception of (1) a relatively low yield of picosecond NO rebinding to R220A, presumably related to the increase in the free volume of the heme pocket, and (2) substantial pH-dependent picosecond to nanosecond rebinding of CO to R220H, related to formation of a hydrogen bond between CO and histidine 220. Upon excitation of the complex bound with the physiological sensor ligand O(2), a 5-8 ps decay phase and a nondecaying (>4 ns) phase were observed for WT and all mutants. The strong distortion of the spectrum associated with the decay phase in WT is substantially diminished in all mutant proteins, indicating an R220-induced role of the heme in the primary intermediate in signal transmission. Furthermore, the yield of dissociated oxygen after this phase ( approximately 10% in WT) is increased in all mutants, up to almost unity in R220A, indicating a key role of R220 in caging the oxygen near the heme through hydrogen bonding. Molecular dynamics simulations corroborate these findings and suggest motions of O(2) and arginine 220 away from the heme pocket as a second step in the signal pathway on the 50 ps time scale.     

Characterization of a direct oxygen sensor heme protein from Escherichia coli. Effects of the heme redox states and mutations at the heme-binding site on catalysis and structure

A protein containing a heme-binding PAS (PAS is from the protein names in which imperfect repeat sequences were first recognized: PER, ARNT, and SIM) domain from Escherichia coli has been implied a direct oxygen sensor (Ec DOS) enzyme. In the present study, we isolated cDNA for the Ec DOS full-length protein, expressed it in E. coli, and examined its structure-function relationships for the first time. Ec DOS was found to be tetrameric and was obtained as a 6-coordinate low spin ferric heme complex. Its alpha-helix content was calculated as 53% by CD spectroscopy. The redox potential of the heme was found to be +67 mV versus SHE. Mutation of His-77 of the isolated PAS domain abolished heme binding, whereas mutation of His-83 did not, suggesting that His-77 is one of the heme axial ligands. Ferrous, but not ferric, Ec DOS had phosphodiesterase (PDE) activity of nearly 0.15 min(-1) with cAMP, which was optimal at pH 8.5 in the presence of Mg(2+) and was strongly inhibited by CO, NO, and etazolate, a selective cAMP PDE inhibitor. Absorption spectral changes indicated tight CO and NO bindings to the ferrous heme. Therefore, the present study unequivocally indicates for the first time that Ec DOS exhibits PDE activity with cAMP and that this is regulated by the heme redox state.