DNA sequence dependent and independent conformational changes in multipartite operator recognition by lambda-repressor

Binding of regulatory proteins to multipartite DNA binding sites often occurs with protein-protein interaction, resulting in cooperative binding. The operators of bacteriophage lambda have several pairs of repressor binding sites (O(R)1-O(R)2, O(R)2-O(R)3, O(L)1-O(L)2, and O(L)2-O(L)3) separated by a variable number of base pairs, and thus, bacteriophage lambda is a model system for studying multipartite operator recognition by DNA-binding proteins. Near-UV circular dichroism spectra show that the DNA is distorted in O(R)1-O(R)2 and O(L)2-O(L)3 but much less so in O(R)2-O(R)3. Upon titration of lambda-repressor with single-operator sites O(R)1, O(R)2, and O(R)3, it was observed that the tryptophan fluorescence quenches to different degrees, suggesting different conformations of the protein in the three DNA-protein complexes. Acrylamide quenching of tryptophan fluorescence of lambda-repressor bound to these single operators also shows different Stern-Volmer constants, supporting the above conclusions. Titration of lambda-repressor with oligonucleotides containing pairs of operator sites also causes different degrees of fluorescence quenching. In particular, fluorescence quenching induced by O(R)1-O(R)2 binding is less than the quenching induced by either of the single operators alone, suggesting additional conformational changes upon establishment of protein-protein contact. Stern-Volmer constants obtained from acrylamide quenching of tryptophan fluorescence of lambda-repressor bound cooperatively to pairs of operator sites are different from those of the single-operator-site-bound repressors. For example, O(R)2-O(R)3-bound repressor has significantly higher acrylamide quenchable components than either of the O(R)2- or O(R)3-bound proteins, again suggesting additional conformational changes upon establishment of protein-protein contact. We conclude that the strategy of recognition of multipartite operator by lambda-repressor is complex and varied, involving conformational changes in both DNA and protein that are determined by the separation of the binding sites as well as the nucleic acid sequence.     

DNA-binding properties of a lac repressor mutant incapable of forming tetramers

The interaction of proteins bound to sites widely separated on the genome is a recurrent motif in both prokaryotic and eukaryotic regulatory systems. Lac repressor mediates the formation of "DNA loops" by the simultaneous interaction of a single protein tetramer with two DNA-binding sites. The DNA-binding properties of a Lac repressor mutant (LacIadi) deficient in the association of protein dimers to tetramers was investigated. The results of quantitative footprint and gel mobility-shift titrations suggest that the wild-type Lac repressor (LacI+) binds cooperatively to two operator sites separated by 11 helical turns on a linear DNA restriction fragment by the formation of a "looped complex." LacIadi binds to this two-site operator non-cooperatively and without formation of a looped complex. These results demonstrate that the dimer-tetramer association of LacI+ is directly responsible for its cooperative binding and its ability to mediate formation of a looped complex. The Iadi mutation disrupts the monomer-dimer as well as eliminating the dimer-tetramer association equilibria while the DNA binding affinity of LacIadi to a single site is unchanged relative to the wild-type protein. These results suggest that DNA binding and dimer-tetramer association are functionally unlinked. The similarity of the DNA-binding properties of LacIadi and Gal repressor, a protein believed to function by mediating the formation of a looped complex, are discussed.     

The CTXphi repressor RstR binds DNA cooperatively to form tetrameric repressor-operator complexes

CTX is a filamentous bacteriophage that encodes cholera toxin and integrates into the Vibrio cholerae genome to form stable lysogens. In CTX lysogens, gene expression originating from the rstA phage promoter is repressed by the phage-encoded repressor RstR. The N-terminal region of RstR contains a helix-turn-helix DNA-binding element similar to the helix-turn-helix of the cI/Cro family of phage repressors, whereas the short C-terminal region is unrelated to the oligomerization domain of cI repressor. Purified His-tagged RstR bound to three extended 50-bp operator sites in the rstA promoter region. Each of the RstR footprints exhibited a characteristic staggered pattern of DNase I-accessible regions that suggested RstR binds DNA as a dimer-of-dimers. In gel permeation chromatography and cross-linking experiments, RstR oligomerized to form dimers and tetramers. RstR was shown to be tetrameric when bound to operator DNA by performing mobility shift experiments with mixtures of RstR and a lengthened active variant of RstR. Binding of RstR to the high affinity O1 site could be fit to a cooperative model of operator binding in which two RstR dimers associate to form tetrameric RstR-operator complexes. The binding of RstR dimers to the left or right halves of O1 operator DNA was not observed in mobility shift assays. These observations support a model in which protein-protein contacts between neighboring RstR dimers contribute to strong operator binding.     

Electron microscopic study of the repressor of bacteriophage λ and its interaction with operator DNA

The structure of purified phage λ repressor has been examined by high resolution electron microscopy. The repressor molecule appears predominantly as a tetramer of about 95 Å × 120 Å. We have proposed a model to account for the variety of aspects seen on the electron micrographs. Spreading DNA without protein film and use of uranyl formate staining allowed the simultaneous visualization of the DNA and the structure of the repressor molecule bound to it. Mapping the positions of λ repressor bound to whole λ DNA shows preferential binding to the region containing the operators. At high resolution multiple binding of repressor to the operator can be demonstrated. Depending on the amount of repressor present, rows of one to four repressor tetramers are seen on the DNA, confirming the model of the operator containing four binding sites for repressor. The bound repressor can consequently protect against nuclease digestion of operator pieces of approximately 30, 57, 87 and 111 base-pairs. The isolated operator appears in the electron microscope as short double-stranded DNA fragments which can be shown to rebind repressor.     

Cooperative and Anticooperative Effects in Binding of the First and Second Plasmid OsymOperators to a LacI Tetramer: Evidence for Contributions of Non-operator DNA Binding by Wrapping and Looping

The interaction oflacoperator DNA withlacrepressor (LacI) is a classic example of a genetic regulatory switch. To dissect the role of stoichiometry, subunit association, and effects of DNA length in positioning this switch, we have determined binding isotherms for the interaction of LacI with a high affinity (O^sym) operator on linearized plasmid (2500 bp) DNA over a wide range of macromolecular concentrations (10⁻¹⁴to 10⁻⁸M). Binding data were analyzed using a thermodynamic model involving four equilibria: dissociation of tetramers (T) into dimers (D), and binding of operator-containing plasmid DNA (O) to dimers and tetramers to form three distinct complexes, DO, TO, and TO₂. Over the range of con- centrations of repressor, operator, and salt (0.075 M K⁺to 0.40 M K⁺) investigated, we find no evidence for any significant thermodynamic effect of LacI dimers. Instead, all isotherms can be interpreted in terms of just two equilibria, involving only T and the TO and TO₂complexes. As a reference binding equilibrium, which we propose must approximate the DO binding interaction, we compare the plasmid O^symresults with our extensive studies of the binding of a 40 bp O^symDNA fragment to LacI. On this basis, we obtain a lower bound on the LacI dimer – tetramer equilibrium constant and values of the equilibrium constants for formation of TO and TO₂complexes.At a salt concentration of 0.40 M, the O^symplasmid binding data are consistent with a model with two independent and identical binding sites for operator per LacI tetramer, in which the binding to a site on the tetramer is only slightly more favorable than the reference binding interaction. Increasingly large deviations from the independent-site model are observed as the salt concentration is reduced; binding of a second operator to form TO₂becomes strongly disfavored relative to formation of TO at low salt concentrations (0.075 to 0.125 M). In addition, binding of both the first and second plasmid operator DNA molecules to the tetramer becomes increasingly more favorable than the reference binding interaction as [K⁺] is reduced from 0.40 M to 0.125 M. At 0.075 M K⁺, however, the strength of binding of the second plasmid operator DNA to the LacI tetramer is dramatically reduced; this interaction is much less favorable than binding the first plasmid operator DNA, and becomes much less favorable than the reference binding interaction. We propose that these differences arise from changes in the nature of the TO and TO₂complexes with decreasing salt concentration. At low salt concentration, we suggest the hypothesis that flanking non-operator sequences bind non-specifically (coulombically) by local wrapping, and that distant regions of non-operator DNA occupy the second operator-binding site by looping. We propose that wrapping stabilizes both 1:1 and 2:1 complexes at low salt concentration, and that looping stabilizes the 1:1 complex but competitively destabilizes the 2:1 TO₂complex at low salt concentration. These effects must play a role in adjusting the stability and structure of the LacI-lac operator repression complex as the cytoplasmic [K⁺] varies in response to changes in extracellular osmolarity.     

Crystal structure of the lambda repressor C-terminal domain octamer.

The three-dimensional structure of the lambda repressor C-terminal domain (CTD) has been determined at atomic resolution. In the crystal, the CTD forms a 2-fold symmetric tetramer that mediates cooperative binding of two repressor dimers to pairs of operator sites. Based upon this structure, a model was proposed for the structure of an octameric repressor that forms both in the presence and absence of DNA. Here, we have determined the structure of the lambda repressor CTD in three new crystal forms, under a wide variety of conditions. All crystals have essentially the same tetramer, confirming the results of the earlier study. One crystal form has two tetramers bound to form an octamer, which has the same overall architecture as the previously proposed model. An unexpected feature of the octamer in the crystal structure is a unique interaction at the tetramer-tetramer interface, formed by residues Gln209, Tyr210 and Pro211, which contact symmetry-equivalent residues from other subunits of the octamer. Interestingly, these residues are also located at the dimer-dimer interface, where the specific interactions are different. The structures thus indicate specific amino acid residues that, at least in principle, when altered could result in repressors that form tetramers but not octamers.     

Bending of synthetic bacteriophage 434 operators by bacteriophage 434 proteins.

The extent of DNA bending induced by 434 repressor, its amino terminal DNA binding domain (R1-69), and 434 Cro was studied by gel shift assay. The results show that 434 repressor and R1-69 bend DNA to the same extent. 434 Cro-induced DNA bends are similar to those seen with the 434 repressor proteins. On approximately 265 base pair fragments, the cyclic AMP receptor protein of Escherichia coli (CRP) produces larger mobility shifts than does 434 repressor. This indicates that the 434 proteins bend DNA to a much smaller extent than does CRP. The effects of central operator sequence on intrinsic and 434 protein-induced DNA bending was also examined by gel shift assay. Two 434 operators having different central sequences and affinities for 434 proteins display no static bending. The amount of gel shift induced by 434 repressor on these operators is identical, showing that the 434 repressor bends operators with different central sequences to the same extent. Hence, mutations in the central region of the operator do not influence the bent structure of the unbound or bound operator.     

Expression, purification, and functional characterization of the carboxyl-terminal domain fragment of bacteriophage 434 repressor.

The repressor protein of bacteriophage 434 binds to DNA as a dimer of identical subunits. Its strong dimerization is mediated by the carboxyl-terminal domain. Cooperative interactions between the C-terminal domains of two repressor dimers bound at adjacent sites can stabilize protein-DNA complexes formed with low-affinity binding sites. We have constructed a plasmid, pCT1, which directs the overproduction of the carboxyl-terminal domain of 434 repressor. The protein encoded by this plasmid is called CT-1. Cells transformed with pCT1 are unable to be lysogenized by wild-type 434 phage, whereas control cells are lysogenized at an efficiency of 1 to 5%. The CT-1-mediated interference with lysogen formation presumably results from formation of heteromeric complexes between the phage-encoded repressor and the plasmid-encoded carboxyl-terminal domain fragment. These heteromers are unable to bind DNA and thereby inhibit the repressor's activity in promoting lysogen formation. Two lines of evidence support this conclusion. First, DNase I footprinting experiments show that at a 2:1 ratio of CT-1 to intact 434 repressor, purified CT-1 protein prevents the formation of complexes between 434 repressor and its OR1 binding site. Second, cross-linking experiments reveal that only a specific heterodimeric complex forms between CT-1 and intact 434 repressor. This latter observation indicates that CT-1 interferes with 434 repressor-operator complex formation by preventing dimerization and not by altering the conformation of the DNA-bound repressor dimer. Our other evidence is also consistent with this suggestion. We have used deletion analysis in an attempt to define the region which mediates the 434 repressor-CT-1 interaction. CT-1 proteins which have more than the last 14 amino acids removed are unable to interfere with 434 repressor action in vivo.     

Two-hybrid system for characterization of protein-protein interactions in E. coli

The yeast two-hybrid system has been used to characterize many protein-protein interactions. A two-hybrid system for E. coli was constructed in which one hybrid protein bound to a specific DNA site recruits another to an adjacent DNA binding site. The first hybrid comprises a test protein, the bait, fused to a chimeric protein containing the 434 repressor DNA binding domain. In the second hybrid, a second test protein, the prey, is fused downstream of a chimeric protein with the DNA binding specificity of the lambda repressor. Reporters were designed to express cat and lacZ under the control of a low-affinity lambda operator. At low expression levels, lambda repressor hybrids weakly repress the reporter genes. A high-affinity operator recognized by 434 repressor was placed nearby, in a position that does not yield repression by 434 repressor alone. If the test proteins interact, the 434 hybrid bound to the 434 operator stabilizes the binding of the lambda repressor hybrid to the lambda operator, causing increased repression of the reporter genes. Reconstruction experiments with the fos and jun leucine zippers detected protein-protein interactions between either homodimeric or heterodimeric leucine zippers.     

A comparative three-dimensional model of the carboxy-terminal domain of the lambda repressor and its use to build intact repressor tetramer models bound to adjacent operator sites

A model for residues 93-236 of the lambda repressor (1gfx) was predicted, based on the UmuD(') crystal structure, as part of four intact repressor molecules bound to two adjacent operator sites. The structure of region 136-230 in 1gfx was found to be nearly identical to the independently determined crystal structure of the 132-236 fragment, 1f39, released later by the PDB. Later, two more tetrameric models of the lambda repressor tetramer bound to two adjacent operator sites were constructed by us; in one of these, 1j5g, the N-domain and C-domain coordinates and hence monomer-monomer and dimer-dimer interactions are almost the same as in 1gfx, but the structure of the linker region is partly based on the linker region of the LexA dimer in 1jhe; in the other, 1lwq, the crystalline tetramer for region 140-236 has been coopted from the crystal structure deposited in 1kca, the operator DNA and N-domain coordinates of which are same as those in 1gfx and 1j5g, but the linker region is partly based on the LexA dimer structures 1jhe and 1jhh. Monomer-monomer interactions at the same operator site are stabilized by exposed hydrophobic side chains in beta-strands while cooperative interactions are mostly confined to beta(6) and some adjacent residues in both 1gfx and 1j5g. Mutational data, existence of a twofold axis relating two C-domains within a dimer, and minimization of DNA distortion between adjacent operator sites allow us to roughly position the C-domain with respect to the N-domain for both 1gfx and 1j5g. The study correlates these models with functional, biochemical, biophysical, and immunological data on the repressor in the literature. The oligomerization mode observed in the crystal structure of 132-236 may not exist in the intact repressor bound to the operator since it is shown to contradict several published biochemical data on the intact repressor.     

Stability of a Lac repressor mediated "looped complex"

The quantitation of the stability of a protein-mediated "looped complex" of the Lac repressor and DNA containing two protein-binding sites whose centers of symmetry are separated by 11 helical turns (114 bp) was accomplished by footprint and gel mobility-shift titration techniques. Lac repressor binding to this DNA was only moderately cooperative; a cooperative free energy of -1.0 kcal/mol was calculated in a model-independent fashion from the individual-site loading energies obtained from the footprint titration studies. In order to partition the cooperative binding energy into components representing the dimer-tetramer association of Lac repressor and the cyclization probability of the intervening DNA, advantage was taken of the presence of experimental measures that were in proportion to the concentration of the looped complex present in solution. One measure was the DNase I hypersensitivity observed in footprint titrations in bands located between the two binding sites. The second measure resulted from the electrophoretic resolution in the gel mobility-shift titrations of the band representing the doubly liganded "tandem complex" from the band representing the singly liganded complexes, including the looped complex. Analysis of the footprint and mobility-shift titration data utilizing this additional information showed that approximately 65% of the molecules present in solution are looped complexes at pH 7.0, 100 mM KCl, and 20 degrees C when the binding sites on the DNA are saturated with protein. Reconciliation of the observed low binding cooperativity and the high proportion of looped complexes could only be obtained when the titration data were analyzed by a model in which Lac repressor tetramers dissociate into dimers in solution. The proportion of looped complexes present in solution is highly dependent on the dimer-tetramer association constant, delta Gtet. This result is consistent with the determination by high-pressure fluorescence techniques that Lac repressor tetramers dissociate with an association free energy comparable to their DNA-binding free energies [Royer, C. A., Chakerian, A. E., & Matthews, K. S. (1990) Biochemistry 29, 4959-4966]. However, when the value of delta Gtet of -10.6 kcal/mol (at 20 degrees C) reported by Royer et al. (1990) is assumed, the titration data demand that tetramers bind DNA with much greater affinity than dimers: a result inconsistent with the destabilization of tetramers by the operator observed in the dimer-tetramer dissociation studies.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)     

Coupled energetics of lambda cro repressor self-assembly and site-specific DNA operator binding II: cooperative interactions of cro dimers

The bacteriophage lambda relies on interactions of the cI and cro repressors which self assemble and bind the two operators (O(R) and O(L)) of the phage genome to control the lysogenic to lytic switch. While the self assembly and O(R) binding of cI have been investigated in detail, a more complete understanding of gene regulation by phage lambda also requires detailed knowledge of the role of cro repressor as it dimerizes and binds at O(R) sites. Since dimerization and operator binding are coupled processes, a full elucidation of the regulatory energetics in this system requires that the equilibrium constants for dimerization and cooperative binding be determined. The dimerization constant for cro has been measured as a prelude to these binding studies. Here, the energetics of cro binding to O(R) are evaluated using quantitative DNaseI footprint titration techniques. Binding data for wild-type and modified O(R) site combinations have been simultaneously analyzed in concert with the dimerization energetics to obtain both the intrinsic and cooperative DNA binding energies for cro with the three O(R) sites. Binding of cro dimers is strongest to O(R)3, then O(R)1 and lastly, O(R)2. Adjacently bound repressors exhibit positive cooperativity ranging from -0.6 to -1.0 kcal/mol. Implications of these, newly resolved, energetics are discussed in the framework of a dynamic model for gene regulation. This characterization of the DNA-binding properties of cro repressor establishes the foundation on which the system can be explored for other, more complex, regulatory elements such as cI-cro cooperativity.     

Dimerization specificity of P22 and 434 repressors is determined by multiple polypeptide segments.

The repressor protein of bacteriophage P22 binds to DNA as a homodimer. This dimerization is absolutely required for DNA binding. Dimerization is mediated by interactions between amino acids in the carboxyl (C)-terminal domain. We have constructed a plasmid, p22CT-1, which directs the overproduction of just the C-terminal domain of the P22 repressor (P22CT-1). Addition of P22CT-1 to DNA-bound P22 repressor causes the dissociation of the complex. Cross-linking experiments show that P22CT-1 forms specific heterodimers with the intact P22 repressor protein, indicating that inhibition of P22 repressor DNA binding by P22CT-1 is mediated by the formation of DNA binding-inactive P22 repressor:P22CT-1 heterodimers. We have taken advantage of the highly conserved amino acid sequences within the C-terminal domains of the P22 and 434 repressors and have created chimeric proteins to help identify amino acid regions required for dimerization specificity. Our results indicate that the dimerization specificity region of these proteins is concentrated in three segments of amino acid sequence that are spread across the C-terminal domain of each of the two phage repressors. We also show that the set of amino acids that forms the cooperativity interface of the P22 repressor may be distinct from those that form its dimer interface. Furthermore, cooperativity studies of the wild-type and chimeric proteins suggest that the location of cooperativity interface in the 434 repressor may also be distinct from that of its dimerization interface. Interestingly, changes in the dimer interface decreases the ability of the 434 repressor to discriminate between its wild-type binding sites, O(R)1, O(R)2, and O(R)3. Since 434 repressor discrimination between these sites depends in large part on the ability of this protein to recognize sequence-specific differences in DNA structure and flexibility, this result indicates that the C-terminal domain is intimately involved in the recognition of sequence-dependent differences in DNA structure and flexibility.     

Selection and design of high affinity DNA ligands for mutant single-chain derivatives of the bacteriophage 434 repressor

Single-chain repressor RRTRES is a derivative of bacteriophage 434 repressor, which contains covalently dimerized DNA-binding domains (amino acids 1-69) of the phage 434 repressor. In this single-chain molecule, the wild type domain R is connected to the mutant domain RTRES by a recombinant linker in a head-to-tail arrangement. The DNA-contacting amino acids of RTRES at the -1, 1, 2, and 5 positions of the a3 helix are T, R, E, S respectively. By using a randomized DNA pool containing the central sequence -CATACAAGAAAGNNNNNNTTT-, a cyclic, in vitro DNA-binding site selection was performed. The selected population was cloned and the individual members were characterized by determining their binding affinities to RRTRES. The results showed that the optimal operators contained the TTAC or TTCC sequences in the underlined positions as above, and that the Kd values were in the 1×10-12 mol/L-1×10-11mol/L concentration range. Since the affinity of the natural 434 repressor to its natural operator sites is in the 1×10-9 mol/L range, the observed binding affinity increase is remarkable. It was also found that binding affinity was strongly affected by the flanking bases of the optimal tetramer binding sites, especially by the base at the 5′ position. We constructed a new homodimeric single-chain repressor RTRESRTRES and its DNA-binding specificity was tested by using a series of new operators designed according to the recog-nition properties previously determined for the RTRES domain. These operators containing the con-sensus sequence GTAAGAAARNTTACN or GGAAGAAARNTTCCN (R is A or G) were recognized by RTRESRTRES specifically, and with high binding affinity. Thus, by using a combination of random selection and rational design principles, we have discovered novel, high affinity protein-DNA inter-actions with new specificity. This method can potentially be used to obtain new binding specificity for other DNA-binding proteins.