Co-evolution of the agrocinopine opines and the agrocinopine-mediated control of TraR, the quorum-sensing activator of the Ti plasmid conjugation system

Conjugal transfer of Agrobacterium tumefaciens Ti plasmids is controlled by a hierarchical system in which opines, substrates produced by crown gall tumours, induce a quorum-sensing system. The cascade results from the control of expression of traR, the quorum-sensing activator, by a regulator responsive to the opine. In the two cases studied to date, the gene arrangements responsible for the cascade differ remarkably, suggesting that considerable diversity exists among the many Ti-like plasmids in the agrobacteria. In this study, we demonstrated that the novel Ti plasmid pTiChry5 is induced to transfer at high frequency by extracts from tumours initiated by strain Chry5. The purified inducer had the chemical and biological properties of agrocinopines C and D, a set of sugar phosphodiester opines known to induce transfer of another Ti plasmid, pTiBo542. The T-region of pTiChry5 contained a gene whose product, called Acs(Chry5), is virtually identical to the agrocinopine C+D synthase from the T-region of pTiBo542. The two genes are less closely related to acs of pTiC58, which is responsible for the production of agrocinopines A+B, a similar but not identical set of phosphodiester opines by tumours induced by strain C58. Agrocinopines A+B induce transfer of pTiC58 but did not induce transfer of pTi(Chry5). A single copy of traR was identified at the 11 o'clock region of pTi(Chry5), where it is part of a two-gene operon called arc(Chry5). Although altered by deletions, arc(Chry5) is related to the five-gene arc operon that controls the expression of traR on pTiC58. Expression of traR(Chry5) was induced by agrocinopines C+D and the opines isolated from Chry5 tumours but not by agrocinopines A+B. A mutation in traR(Chry5) abolished transfer, and transfer was restored by complementation in trans. We conclude that the agrocinopine opines and the corresponding opine-meditated conjugal regulatory regions of pTiChry5 and pTiC58 share a common origin, but that the opine signals for the two Ti plasmids have evolved divergently through changes in the opine synthase enzymes. The alterations in the opines, in turn, necessitated a co-evolutionary change in the opine recognition systems responsible for controlling expression of the traR genes on these two types of Ti plasmids.     

Isolation and properties of transfer regulatory mutants of the nopaline Ti-plasmid pTiC58

Summary Conjugal transfer of the nopaline Ti-plasmid pTiC58 is inducible by the phosphorylated opines, agrocinopines A and B. Although the uninduced level of transfer is negligible (< 10^–7 per donor), some transconjugants have been isolated from crosses performed in the absence of agrocinopine. These transconjugants harbour mutant Ti-plasmids that transfer constitutively (>10^–3 per donor). These mutants have several other correlated phenotypes including constitutive uptake of agrocinopine A, supersensitivity to agrocin 84 and the ability to prevent the excretion of agrocin 84 when they are present in the same cell as the agrocin 84 biosynthetic plasmid pAt-84a.     

Characterization of the acc operon from the nopaline-type Ti plasmid pTiC58, which encodes utilization of agrocinopines A and B and susceptibility to agrocin 84.

The acc locus from the Ti plasmid pTiC58 confers utilization of and chemotaxis toward agrocinopines A and B (A+B), as well as susceptibility to a highly specific antiagrobacterial antibiotic, agrocin 84. DNA sequence analyses revealed that acc is composed of eight open reading frames, accR and accA through accG. Previous work showed that accR encodes the repressor which regulates this locus, and accA codes for the periplasmic binding protein of the agrocinopine transport system (S. Beck Von Bodman, G. T. Hayman, and S. K. Farrand, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 89:643-647, 1992; G. T. Hayman, S. Beck Von Bodman, H. Kim, P. Jiang, and S. K. Farrand, J. Bacteriol. 175:5575-5584, 1993). The predicted proteins from accA through accE, as a group, have homology to proteins that belong to the ABC-type transport system superfamily. The predicted product of accF is related to UgpQ of Escherichia coli, which is a glycerophosphoryl diester phosphodiesterase, and also to agrocinopine synthase coded for by acs located on the T-DNA. The translated product of accG is related to myoinositol 1 (or 4) monophosphatases from various eucaryotes. Analyses of insertion mutations showed that accA through accE are required for transport of both agrocin 84 and agrocinopines A+B, while accF and accG are required for utilization of the opines as the sole source of carbon. Mutations in accF or accG did not abolish transport of agrocin 84, although we observed slower removal of the antibiotic from the medium by the accF mutant compared to the wild type. However, the insertion mutation in accF abolished detectable uptake of agrocinopines A+B. A mutation in accG had no effect on transport of the opines. The accF mutant was not susceptible to agrocin 84 although it took up the antibiotic. This finding suggests that agrocin 84 is activated by AccF after being transported into the bacterial cell.     

A novel plasmid curing method using incompatibility of plant pathogenic Ti plasmids in Agrobacterium tumefaciens

Ti (Tumor inducing) plasmids in Agrobacterium tumefaciens can transfer their T-DNA region into dicotyledonous plants, in which the expression of T-DNA genes causes plant tumors and the production of bacterial nutrients, e.g., opines such as nopaline. Naturally occurring Ti plasmids (pTi) are difficult to cure by conventional curing methods because of their high stability. Here, we developed a novel curing method based on plasmid incompatibility. For this, a curing plasmid, pMGTrep1, was newly constructed and subsequently introduced into A. tumefaciens strains harboring pTi by conjugation with Escherichia coli harboring pMGTrep1. The conjugation yielded 32-99% nopaline non-utilizing agrobacterial transconjugants in which pMGTrep1 replaced pTi due to incompatibility. Then, pMGTrep1-less derivatives of the transconjugants are easily selected in the presence of sucrose because pMGTrep1 contains a sucrose-sensitive sacB gene. This efficient method is directly applicable for curing plasmids with the same incompatibility group and shoud also applicable to other types of plasmids in Agrobacterium groups, including A. rhizogenes, by replacing the rep gene region of the curing plasmid with that of the corresponding incompatibility.     

Diversity of Opines and Opine-Catabolizing Bacteria Isolated from Naturally Occurring Crown Gall Tumors

The diversity of opines from 43 naturally occurring crown gall tumors on several plant species was analyzed for the presence of agropine, chrysopine, iminodiacid, an unidentified leucinopine-like iminodiacid (IDA-B), mannopine, octopine, nopaline, DL- and LL-succinamopine, leucinopine and heliopine. Opine utilization patterns of agrobacteria and fluorescent pseudomonads resident in a tumor were then analyzed and compared for agreement with the opine isolated from that tumor. Nopaline was the most common opine found and was detected in tumors from cherry, blackberry, grape, and plum. Octopine was not found, although octopine-catabolizing bacteria were isolated from several tumors. A new, previously undescribed iminodiacid of the succinamopine-leucinopine type (provisionally designated IDA-B) was isolated from tumors of wild blackberry. Field tumors from apple, blueberry and grape yielded no detectable opines, even though opine-utilizing bacteria were present. Bacterial isolates from plum and cherry showed the best correspondence between the opine in tumors (nopaline) and the presence of bacteria that catabolized that opine. However, several unusual opine catabolic combinations were identified, including isolates that catabolized a variety of opines but were nonpathogenic. More variability was observed among isolates from field tumors on the remaining plant species. We isolated novel mannopine-nopaline type agrobacteria from field tumors of cherry, plum and blackberry that induced tumors containing either mannopine (plus agropine) or nopaline, but not both. Epidemiologically, the galled plants from an area were not of clonal origin (same Ti plasmid), indicating that the field tumors from a small area were incited by more than one type of Ti plasmid.     

Genetic analysis of T-DNA transcripts in nopaline crown galls

Plant crown gall tumor cells result from the insertion and expression of a defined DNA sequence, called T-DNA, which is derived from the Ti plasmid, harbored by Agrobacterium tumefaciens strains. To study the function of the genes of the T-DNA of the nopaline Ti plasmid, pTiC58, a collection of mutants was isolated so that T-DNA genes are inactivated either separately or in various combinations. It was found that no single T-DNA gene or T-region border is absolutely essential for stable tumor formation. We have identified the gene responsible for synthesis in transformed cells of the phosphorylated sugar, agrocinopine, and at least three additional genes controlling the morphology of plant tumors. Two of these latter genes work together to inhibit shoot formation and ensure efficient tumorous growth. Inactivation of these genes can be suppressed by the addition of auxins. The third gene inhibits root formation and appears to play a role in the cytokinin-independent growth of transformed cells. Mutants missing all three genes do not induce tumors, nor shoot or root formation, although the mutant T-DNA sequence is transferred to plant cells.     

An Agrobacterium-transformed cell culture from the monocot Asparagus officinalis

Cultured stem fragments from the monocotyledonous plant Asparagus officinalis infected by the oncogenic bacterium Agrobacterium tumefaciens developed tumorous proliferations. This tissue was propagated in vitro on hormone-free culture medium. The T-DNA-encoded markers nopaline and agrocinopine were unambiguously detected in these tissues. The data demonstrate that stable T-DNA transfer as well as expression of T-DNA genes is possible in at least some monocotyledonous plants. This opens new possibilities for plant genetic engineering using the Ti plasmid as a gene vector.     

Kinetic suppression of translational errors by (p)ppGpp

Summary The conjugative behaviour of nopaline and agropine Ti-plasmids has been investigated. Using a technique which avoids enrichment of transconjugants on a mating medium we have shown that preculture in the presence of agrocinopines A or B of donor strains harbouring nopaline Ti plasmids promotes plasmid transfer whereas preculture of the same strains in the presence of nopaline has no such effect. Similarly, preculture in the presence of agrocinopines C or D promotes Ti-plasmid transfer from strains harbouring agropine Ti-plasmids.     

The interaction of Agrobacterium Ti-plasmid DNA and plant cells

The tumour-inducing plasmids of Agrobacterium tumefaciens (Ti-plasmids) reveal several interesting properties. They are catabolic plasmids, which, instead of rendering Agrobacterium strains capable of catabolizing compounds found in Nature, force a plant to synthesize these catabolites (denoted 'opines'). This situation is obtained by insertion of a segment of the Ti-plasmid (the T-DNA) into the plant nucleus, where T-DNA genes become expressed and intervene in the biosynthesis of these opines. Cells containing the T-DNA behave as neoplasms (crown gall cells). Southern blotting shows that the insertion process responsible for T-DNA transfer probably recognizes special sequences on the T-DNA since the length of the T-DNA segment observed in different, independently isolated tumour lines was found to be similar. For the nopaline Ti-plasmids both left-hand and right-hand borders were found to be constant. For the octopine plasmid the left border was constant and at least two classes of right-hand borders were found. Upon redifferentiation of the transformed plant cells, the T-DNA was found to be conserved in all somatic cells examined. However, small deletions at the border fragments of the T-DNA have been observed. The exact arrangement and copy number of the T-DNA in a nucleus is still under study, but genomic cloning has already revealed that an interspersed tandem arrangement is dominant in nopaline tumours. Clones containing both the right border of one T-DNA and the left border of the neighbouring tandem T-DNA were isolated. In order to identify the different T-plasmid encoded functions an extensive use was made of transposon insertion mutagenesis. When an antibiotic resistance transposon was inserted into the non-essential regions of the T-DNA, a linked transfer to the plant DNA of the transposon together with the T-DNA was observed. This indicates that Ti-plasmids are possible vectors for genetic engineering in plants. A strategy is described for insertion of any cloned DNA segment into the T-DNA.     

Crown gall transformation of lentil (Lens culinaris Medik.) with virulent strains of Agrobacterium tumefaciens

Summary Four diverse strains of Agrobacterium tumefaciens (C58, Ach5, GV3111, and A281) were capable of inducing tumors at a high frequency on inoculated stems of lentil (Lens culinaris Medik. cultivar Laird) in vivo, and on excised shoot apices in vitro. GV3111 and Ach5 produced the largest and heaviest tumors in vivo, while A281 produced the heaviest tumors in vitro. Tumor formation and opine production are indicative of plant cell transformation and tumors produced appropriate opines: nopaline (C58), octopine (Ach5 and GV3111), and agropine and mannopine (A281). Southern analysis of DNA from a tumor line produced by strain C58 showed that a T-DNA fragment had been transferred into the lentil genome.     

Genetic basis for opine secretion from crown gall tumour cells

Summary Plant cells neoplastically transformed by insertion of T-DNA from Ti plasmids of agrobacteria produce and secrete opines. Secretion of two of these opines (octopine and nopaline) is shown to require the expression of a single gene, which we designate ons.Dedicated to Professor Georg Melchers to celebrate his 50-year association with the journal     

Succinamopine: a new crown gall opine

Agrobacterium tumefaciens strains can incite plant tumors consisting of transformed cells that synthesize novel metabolites called opines. The pattern of opine synthesis is dictated by plasmid-borne genes in the pathogen; additional plasmid genes confer on the pathogen the ability to catabolize the same pattern of opines synthesized. One group of A. tumefaciens strains, AT181, EU6, and T10/73, contains closely related tumor-inducing (Ti) plasmids that encode the ability to degrade the opine nopaline; but tumors incited by these strains do not synthesize nopaline. We demonstrated by Southern blot hybridization that AT181(pTi) has no DNA homologous to the nopaline synthase gene of pTi T37, a nopaline Ti plasmid that appears to be most closely related to this group based on fingerprint analysis. Tumors incited by these seemingly anomalous strains contain a new opine that we designate succinamopine. Its structure is analogous to that of nopaline, with asparagine replacing arginine. Evidence for the structure of succinamopine, as well as those of two related metabolites, succinamopine lactam and succinopine lactam, will be published elsewhere. Ability to catabolize succinamopine, succinamopine lactam, and succinopine lactam is encoded by pTi AT181, pTi EU6, and pTi T10/73, but not by any of 15 other Ti and root-inducing plasmids tested. Three avirulent strains tested did not catabolize succinamopine, succinamopine lactam, or succinopine lactam. We propose that pTi AT181, pTi EU6, and pTi T10/73 be designated the succinamopine Ti plasmids.     

Two unlinked T-DNAs can transform the same tobacco plant cell and segregate in the F1 generation

Summary The 200 kb Agrobacterium Ti-plasmid pTiT37 carries a 25 kb segment of T-DNA which it transfers to plant cells during crown-gall tumorigenesis. We have previously engineered into this T-DNA a pBR322-derived cloning vector which enabled us to rescue-clone full length T-DNA from the Ti-plasmid into a 36 kb MINI-Ti plasmid. We report here the deletion of oncogenes from MINI-Ti to produce Micro-Ti containing the nopaline synthase gene and the ampicillin resistance gene and origin of replication of pBR322, flanked by left and right T-DNA borders. Micro-Ti was recloned into the wide host range plasmid pRK290 and transformed into an A. tumefaciens strain carrying a helper plasmid that could supply Virulence (VIR) genes in trans. Using the octopine Ti-plasmid pTiB6-806 as a helper, transformed tobacco cells were obtained which produced both nopaline and octopine. Two cloned cell lines producing both opines were found to be hormone dependent and to produce fertile tobacco plants. We selfed one of these plants and found that the two opine markers segregated in the F1 progeny in a Mendelian fashion. This showed that the T-DNAs were not linked in the transformed plant genome. Southern blot analysis of the genomic DNA from the regenerated plant showed that only part of the (oncogenic) octopine T-DNA was present indicating that it had suffered a deletion in the auxin producing locus (tms region). Presence of the cytokinin autonomy locus presumably accounts for the abnormal rooting behavior of the F1 progeny seedlings containing this T-DNA.Abbreviations NAA Naphtalene acetic acid - IAA Indole-3-acetic acid - BA 6-benzylaminopurine - pCPA para-chlorophenoxyacetic acid Part of this work was presented for her doctoral thesis by A. JdF at the National Institute of Agronomy of Paris-Grignon, January 1983     

Regeneration of intact tobacco plants containing full length copies of genetically engineered T-DNA,and transmission of T-DNA to R1 progeny

Cloned DNA sequences encoding yeast alcohol dehydrogenase and a bacterial neomycin phosphotransferase have been inserted into the T-DNA of Agrobacterium tumefaciens plasmid pTiT37 at the “rooty” locus. Transformation of tobacco stem segments with the engineered bacterial strains produced attenuated crown gall tumors that were capable of regeneration into intact, normal tobacco plants. The yeast gene and entire transferred DNA (T-DNA) were present in the regenerated plants in multiple copies, and nopaline was found in all tissues. The plants were fertile, and seedlings resulting from self-pollination also contained intact and multiple copies of the engineered T-DNA. Expression of nopaline in the germinated seedlings derived from one regenerated plant was variable and did not correlate with the levels of T-DNA present in the seedlings. Preliminary evidence indicates that nopaline in progeny of other similarly engineered plants is more uniform. The disarming of pTiT37 by insertions at the “rooty” locus thus appears to produce a useful gene vector for higher plants.     

Agrocinopine A, a phosphorylated opine is secreted from crown gall cells

We showed that phosphorus-containing metabolites of crown gall tissues were all taken up by appropriate pTi+ agrobacteria. All but one were also taken up by pTi- bacteria. This one compound, produced by nopaline-, but not by octopine-type tumours, was the only phosphorylated organic compound actively secreted by healthy crown gall cells, and it appears to be agrocinopine A. Testing crown gall cell exudates may be a general procedure for the identification of opines by transformed plant cells.