The maximum oxygen consumption and aerobic scope of birds and mammals: getting to the heart of the matter

Resting or basal metabolic rates, compared across a wide range of organisms, scale with respect to body mass as approximately the 0.75 power. This relationship has recently been linked to the fractal geometry of the appropriate transport system or, in the case of birds and mammals, the blood vascular system. However, the structural features of the blood vascular system should more closely reflect maximal aerobic metabolic rates rather than submaximal function. Thus, the maximal aerobic metabolic rates of birds and mammals should also scale as approximately the 0.75 power. A review of the literature on maximal oxygen consumption and factorial aerobic scope (maximum oxygen consumption divided by basal metabolic rate) suggests that body mass influences the capacity of the cardiovascular system to raise metabolic rates above those at rest. The results show that the maximum sustainable metabolic rates of both birds and mammals are similar and scale as approximately the 0.88 +/- 0.02 power of body mass (and aerobic scope as approximately the 0.15 +/- 0.05 power), when the measurements are standardized with respect to the differences in relative heart mass and haemoglobin concentration between species. The maximum heart beat frequency of birds and mammals is predicted to scale as the -0.12 +/- 0.02 power of body mass, while that at rest should scale as -0.27 +/- 0.04.     

Routine and active metabolic rates of migrating adult wild sockeye salmon (Oncorhynchus nerka Walbaum) in seawater and freshwater

We present the first data on the differences in routine and active metabolic rates for sexually maturing migratory adult sockeye salmon (Oncorhynchus nerka) that were intercepted in the ocean and then held in either seawater or freshwater. Routine and active oxygen uptake rates (MO2) were significantly higher (27%-72%) in seawater than in freshwater at all swimming speeds except those approaching critical swimming speed. During a 45-min recovery period, the declining postexercise oxygen uptake remained 58%-73% higher in seawater than in freshwater. When fish performed a second swim test, active metabolic rates again remained 28%-81% higher for fish in seawater except at the critical swimming speed. Despite their differences in metabolic rates, fish in both seawater and freshwater could repeat the swim test and reach a similar maximum oxygen uptake and critical swimming speed as in the first swim test, even without restoring routine metabolic rate between swim tests. Thus, elevated MO2 related to either being in seawater as opposed to freshwater or not being fully recovered from previous exhaustive exercise did not present itself as a metabolic loading that limited either critical swimming performance or maximum MO2. The basis for the difference in metabolic rates of migratory sockeye salmon held in seawater and freshwater is uncertain, but it could include differences in states of nutrition, reproduction, and restlessness, as well as ionic differences. Regardless, this study elucidates some of the metabolic costs involved during the migration of adult salmon from seawater to freshwater, which may have applications for fisheries conservation and management models of energy use.     

Relative longevity and field metabolic rate in birds

Metabolism is a defining feature of all living organisms, with the metabolic process resulting in the production of free radicals that can cause permanent damage to DNA and other molecules. Surprisingly, birds, bats and other organisms with high metabolic rates have some of the slowest rates of senescence begging the question whether species with high metabolic rates also have evolved mechanisms to cope with damage induced by metabolism. To test whether species with the highest metabolic rates also lived the longest I determined the relationship between relative longevity (maximum lifespan), after adjusting for annual adult survival rate, body mass and sampling effort, and mass-specific field metabolic rate (FMR) in 35 species of birds. There was a strongly positive relationship between relative longevity and FMR, consistent with the hypothesis. This conclusion was robust to statistical control for effects of potentially confounding variables such as age at first reproduction, latitude and migration distance, and similarity in phenotype among species because of common phylogenetic descent. Therefore, species of birds with high metabolic rates senesce more slowly than species with low metabolic rates.     

Do the high energy lifestyles of shorebirds result in high maximal metabolic rates? Basal and maximal metabolic rates in least and pectoral sandpipers during migration

Shorebirds have high resting and field metabolic rates relative to many other bird groups, and this is posited to be related to their high‐energy lifestyle. Maximum metabolic outputs for cold or exercise are also often high for bird groups with energetically demanding lifestyles. Moreover, shorebirds demonstrate flexible basal and maximal metabolic rates, which vary with changing energy demands throughout the annual cycle. Consequently, shorebirds might be expected to have high maximum metabolic rates, especially during migration periods. We captured least Calidris minutilla and pectoral C. melanotos sandpipers during spring and fall migration in southeastern South Dakota and measured maximal exercise metabolic rate (MMR; least sandpipers only), summit metabolic rate (M_sum, maximal cold‐induced metabolic rate) and basal metabolic rate (BMR, minimum maintenance metabolic rate) with open‐circuit respirometry. BMR for both least and pectoral sandpipers exceeded allometric predictions by 3–14%, similar to other shorebirds, but M_sum and MMR for both species were either similar to or lower than allometric predictions, suggesting that the elevated BMR in shorebirds does not extend to maximal metabolic capacities. Old World shorebirds show the highest BMR during the annual cycle on the Arctic breeding grounds. Similarly, least sandpiper BMR during migration was lower than on the Arctic breeding grounds, but this was not the case for pectoral sandpipers, so our data only partially support the idea of similar seasonal patterns of BMR variation in New World and Old World shorebirds. We found no correlations of BMR with either M_sum or MMR for either raw or mass‐independent data, suggesting that basal and maximum aerobic metabolic rates are modulated independently in these species.     

Are summit metabolism and thermogenic endurance correlated in winter-acclimatized passerine birds?

Small birds exhibiting marked winter improvement of cold tolerance also show elevated summit metabolic rates (maximum cold-induced metabolic rate) in winter relative to summer. However, relatively large increases in cold tolerance can occur with only minor increments of maximum cold-induced metabolic rate and geographic variation in cold tolerance is not always positively correlated with variation in maximum cold-induced metabolic rate. Thus, it is uncertain whether maximum cold-induced metabolic rate and cold tolerance are phenotypically correlated in small birds and no previous study has directly examined this relationship. I measured maximum cold-induced metabolic rate and cold tolerance (i.e., thermogenic endurance) over three winters in black-capped chickadees Poecile atricapillus, American tree sparrows Spizella arborea, and dark-eyed juncos Junco hyemalis. For raw thermogenic endurance data, residuals of maximum cold-induced metabolic rate and thermogenic endurance from mass regressions were significantly and positively correlated in juncos and tree sparrows, and their correlation approached significance for chickadees. Log10 transformation of thermogenic endurance and mass data gave similar results. These data provide the first direct evidence for a phenotypic correlation between maximum cold-induced metabolic rate and thermogenic endurance in small birds, although much of the variance in thermogenic endurance is explained by factors other than maximum cold-induced metabolic rate and the degree of correlation differs among species. Nevertheless, these data suggest that physiological adjustments producing elevated thermogenic endurance also produce elevated maximum cold-induced metabolic rate in small birds.     

Microclimates and energetics of free-living box turtles, Terrapene carolina, in South Carolina

We measured microclimate, field metabolic rates (FMRs), water flux, and activity patterns of telemetered box turtles (Terrapene carolina) in South Carolina from September 1987 to October 1988. Turtles were inactive for most of the winter and were active only sporadically during the rest of the year. Using the doubly labeled water method, we found that water flux averaged 8.8, 18.9, and 26.4 mL kg(-1) d(-1) in winter, spring, and summer/fall, respectively. FMR for the same periods averaged 0.028, 0.065, and 0.124 mL CO(2) g(-1) h(-1). Differences in FMR among seasons were significant but not between sexes. Using operative temperatures, we predicted standard and maximum metabolic rates of turtles. In winter, FMR was elevated above standard metabolic rates and close to maximum metabolic rates, whereas in spring and summer/fall, FMR fell midway between standard and maximum metabolic rates. We used a model to predict metabolic rates, geographical distribution, and potential reproductive output of box turtles across latitudes in eastern North America. Low FMR and low annual reproductive output may allow box turtles to survive and flourish in unpredictable resource environments by minimizing costs and risks, thereby maintaining greater lifetime reproductive success.     

Maximum activities of some key enzymes of glycolysis, glutaminolysis, Krebs cycle and fatty acid utilization in bovine pulmonary endothelial cells

Despite the importance of endothelial cells little is known about their metabolic fuel requirements. To provide some information in this area, the maximum catalytic activities of key enzymes of important metabolic pathways have been measured in bovine pulmonary endothelial cells. The results suggest that both glucose and glutamine are important fuels for these cells: in addition, the oxidation of fatty acids may also be of quantitative significance. The activity of glutaminase in these cells was about 20-fold higher than that in lymphocyte, a cell which exhibits high rates of glutaminolysis. It is suggested that a high rate of glutamine metabolism by endothelial cells is important not only for energy provision but also for provision of nitrogen for biosynthetic purposes including production of local messengers.     

Dinosaur Metabolism and the Allometry of Maximum Growth Rate

The allometry of maximum somatic growth rate has been used in prior studies to classify the metabolic state of both extant vertebrates and dinosaurs. The most recent such studies are reviewed, and their data is reanalyzed. The results of allometric regressions on growth rate are shown to depend on the choice of independent variable; the typical choice used in prior studies introduces a geometric shear transformation that exaggerates the statistical power of the regressions. The maximum growth rates of extant groups are found to have a great deal of overlap, including between groups with endothermic and ectothermic metabolism. Dinosaur growth rates show similar overlap, matching the rates found for mammals, reptiles and fish. The allometric scaling of growth rate with mass is found to have curvature (on a log-log scale) for many groups, contradicting the prevailing view that growth rate allometry follows a simple power law. Reanalysis shows that no correlation between growth rate and basal metabolic rate (BMR) has been demonstrated. These findings drive a conclusion that growth rate allometry studies to date cannot be used to determine dinosaur metabolism as has been previously argued.     

Correlation between in vivo and in vitro metabolic measurements. Maximum capacity for urea synthesis.

Estimations of enzyme activity in vivo have been or can often only be done at unphysiological conditions. A main biochemical goal is to correlate in vivo and in vitro measurements. A possible approach to this problem is presented based on forcing metabolic activity in vivo to the maximum for a certain metabolic sequence. Since the urea synthesis system, including maximal rates of enzyme activities, is well known, we have compared in vitro maximum rates for the individual enzymes of urea synthesis with in vivo rates as judged by urea levels in blood of rats given large amounts of protein. The excellent agreement found between the calculated maximum activities from in vitro measurements to the time needed to metabolize a protein overload is presented and comments made on its significance and on the importance of maintaining protein intake at moderate levels, for the capacity of the urea system is limited. Since the intake of large quantities of protein increases the urea level in blood and in other tissues and since high urea levels are somewhat deleterious "per se" and particularly due to equilibrium with cyanate, ingestion of excessive amounts of protein is at best expensive and possibly hazardous.     

Heart rate as a measure of metabolic rate in teleost fishes; Salmo gairdneri, Salmo trutta and Gadus morhua

Measurements of oxygen consumption and heart rate showed that the range of variation in metabolic rate for any given heart rate in fish is too wide for any significant correlation to be used as a measure of metabolism as in some other vertebrates. By defining the maximum oxygen pulse a precise relationship can be established between maximum metabolic rate and heart rate. From field measurements of heart rate by telemetry useful information can be gained on metabolic rates.     

Energetics of the smallest: Do bacteria breathe at the same rate as whales?

Power laws describing the dependence of metabolic rate on body mass have been established for many taxa, but not for prokaryotes, despite the ecological dominance of the smallest living beings. Our analysis of 80 prokaryote species with cell volumes ranging more than 1,000,000-fold revealed no significant relationship between mass-specific metabolic rate q and cell mass. By absolute values, mean endogenous mass-specific metabolic rates of non-growing bacteria are similar to basal rates of eukaryote unicells, terrestrial arthropods and mammals. Maximum mass-specific metabolic rates displayed by growing bacteria are close to the record tissue-specific metabolic rates of insects, amphibia, birds and mammals. Minimum mass-specific metabolic rates of prokaryotes coincide with those of larger organisms in various energy-saving regimes: sit-and-wait strategists in arthropods, poikilotherms surviving anoxia, hibernating mammals. These observations suggest a size-independent value around which the mass-specific metabolic rates vary bounded by universal upper and lower limits in all body size intervals.     

Longevity of animals in units of intrinsic time

We propose two different approaches to defining variable units of intrinsic time (physiological time units in a strict sense, or PTU). For continuously growing animals, we suggest the use of specific mass growth rates; and for animals that cease to grow at some point, we recommend specific metabolic rates. Longevity of animals in terms of PTU is equal to the total specific rate (per lifetime) of the respective processes. A method is proposed to describe age-related changes in respect of specific metabolic rates of non-growing constant-mass adult birds. Maximum PTU longevity values have been estimated for certain fish species (continuously growing animals), and birds (that cease growth). Estimates of the maximum PTU longevity across both passerine and non-passerine groups differ slightly and are actually estimates of the Rubner constant for birds.     

Metabolic Scaling: A New Perspective Based on Scaling of Glycolytic Enzyme Activities

The decline of mass specific aerobic metabolic rates with increasinganimal size has a long history of study in zoology. Attemptsto explain this phenomenon have generally been concerned onlywith aerobic metabolism and with estimators of muscle and skeletalstrength. Our finding of tremendous increases in mass-specificglycolytic enzyme activity in locomotory muscle with size insome species of pelagic fishes indicates that this approachhas been too narrow. It is necessary to consider total metabolicpower in any consideration of metabolic scaling in relationto skeletal strength or muscle power, since the anaerobic componentof muscle power is usually greater than the aerobic and oftenscales differently. We show that scaling of glycolytic powerappears to be much more variable among species than is scalingof aerobic power, and we suggest that the different glycolyticpower scaling patterns reflect selection for different sprintswimming abilities in fishes of different habits. The rathernarrow range of variation in aerobic scaling patterns suggeststhat they are the result of natural selection acting in thecontext of geometric constraints on maximum aerobic gas uptakeand transport. The glycolytic scaling data emphasize that therole of natural selection has usually been neglected in considerationsof scaling of metabolism while the role of the scaling of solidshas been overemphasized.     

Chasing away accurate results: exhaustive chase protocols underestimate maximum metabolic rate estimates in European perch Perca fluviatilis

Metabolic rates are one of many measures that are used to explain species' response to environmental change. Static respirometry is used to calculate the standard metabolic rate (SMR) of fish, and when combined with exhaustive chase protocols it can be used to measure maximum metabolic rate (MMR) and aerobic scope (AS) as well. While these methods have been tested in comparison to swim tunnels and chambers with circular currents, they have not been tested in comparison with a no-chase control. We used a repeated-measures design to compare estimates of SMR, MMR and AS in European perch Perca fluviatilis following three protocols: (a) a no-chase control; (b) a 3-min exhaustive chase; and (c) a 3-min exhaustive chase followed by 1-min air exposure. We found that, contrary to expectations, exhaustive chase protocols underestimate MMR and AS at 18°C, compared to the no-chase control. This suggests that metabolic rates of other species with similar locomotorty modes or lifestyles could be similarly underestimated using chase protocols. These underestimates have implications for studies examining metabolic performance and responses to climate change scenarios. To prevent underestimates, future experiments measuring metabolic rates should include a pilot with a no-chase control or, when appropriate, an adjusted methodology in which trials end with the exhaustive chase instead of beginning with it.     

Thermal conditions for successful breeding in Great Tits (Parus major L.)

Summary The development of temperature regulation in relation to the growth and age of the nestlings is described in a way permitting use of the data in a model designed to predict the range of temperature tolerance of broods of Great Tits in the nestling stage. Such a model is described in a second paper. The physiological part of that model is made up mainly of six equations (nos. 6, 10, 11, 12, 14 and 15), which are all presented and discussed here. It is shown in this paper that the development of temperature regulation is a function of body weight rather than of age. The level of the basal metabolic rate of nestling Great Tits is lower than that of adult passerines of comparable size. The basal metabolic rate of a newly hatched Great Tit is only about one fourthe of the metabolic rate expected from Lasiewski and Dawson's equation for adult passerine birds. This discrepancy diminishes gradually during the nestling period and disapears shortly before fledging.Basal and maximum metabolic rates, as well as the body temperatures coinciding with these rates, are described in allometric equations as functions of nestling body weight. The evaporative heat loss of the nestlings is described as a function of body weight and body temperature, and an estimate of the maximum amount of water available to them for evaporative heat loss is given. A distinction is made between a long-term risk of hyperthermia, which results in mortality through dehydration of the nestling body, and an immediate risk of hyperthermia, which occurs when the maximum rate at which nestlings can evaporate water is insufficient to cope with the required heat loss by water evaporation. It is concluded that this immediate risk of hyperthermia is the most important of the factors affecting the upper limit of the range of temperature tolerance.     

Biomechanics of Running Indicates Endothermy in Bipedal Dinosaurs

Background

One of the great unresolved controversies in paleobiology is whether extinct dinosaurs were endothermic, ectothermic, or some combination thereof, and when endothermy first evolved in the lineage leading to birds. Although it is well established that high, sustained growth rates and, presumably, high activity levels are ancestral for dinosaurs and pterosaurs (clade Ornithodira), other independent lines of evidence for high metabolic rates, locomotor costs, or endothermy are needed. For example, some studies have suggested that, because large dinosaurs may have been homeothermic due to their size alone and could have had heat loss problems, ectothermy would be a more plausible metabolic strategy for such animals.

Methodology/Principal Findings

Here we describe two new biomechanical approaches for reconstructing the metabolic rate of 14 extinct bipedal dinosauriforms during walking and running. These methods, well validated for extant animals, indicate that during walking and slow running the metabolic rate of at least the larger extinct dinosaurs exceeded the maximum aerobic capabilities of modern ectotherms, falling instead within the range of modern birds and mammals. Estimated metabolic rates for smaller dinosaurs are more ambiguous, but generally approach or exceed the ectotherm boundary.

Conclusions/Significance

Our results support the hypothesis that endothermy was widespread in at least larger non-avian dinosaurs. It was plausibly ancestral for all dinosauriforms (perhaps Ornithodira), but this is perhaps more strongly indicated by high growth rates than by locomotor costs. The polarity of the evolution of endothermy indicates that rapid growth, insulation, erect postures, and perhaps aerobic power predated advanced “avian” lung structure and high locomotor costs.     

High-Throughput Tissue Bioenergetics Analysis Reveals Identical Metabolic Allometric Scaling for Teleost Hearts and Whole Organisms

Organismal metabolic rate, a fundamental metric in biology, demonstrates an allometric scaling relationship with body size. Fractal-like vascular distribution networks of biological systems are proposed to underlie metabolic rate allometric scaling laws from individual organisms to cells, mitochondria, and enzymes. Tissue-specific metabolic scaling is notably absent from this paradigm. In the current study, metabolic scaling relationships of hearts and brains with body size were examined by improving on a high-throughput whole-organ oxygen consumption rate (OCR) analysis method in five biomedically and environmentally relevant teleost model species. Tissue-specific metabolic scaling was compared with organismal routine metabolism (RMO₂), which was measured using whole organismal respirometry. Basal heart OCR and organismal RMO₂ scaled identically with body mass in a species-specific fashion across all five species tested. However, organismal maximum metabolic rates (MMO₂) and pharmacologically-induced maximum cardiac metabolic rates in zebrafish Danio rerio did not show a similar relationship with body mass. Brain metabolic rates did not scale with body size. The identical allometric scaling of heart and organismal metabolic rates with body size suggests that hearts, the power generator of an organism’s vascular distribution network, might be crucial in determining teleost metabolic rate scaling under routine conditions. Furthermore, these findings indicate the possibility of measuring heart OCR utilizing the high-throughput approach presented here as a proxy for organismal metabolic rate—a useful metric in characterizing organismal fitness. In addition to heart and brain OCR, the current approach was also used to measure whole liver OCR, partition cardiac mitochondrial bioenergetic parameters using pharmacological agents, and estimate heart and brain glycolytic rates. This high-throughput whole-organ bioenergetic analysis method has important applications in toxicology, evolutionary physiology, and biomedical sciences, particularly in the context of investigating pathogenesis of mitochondrial diseases.     

Rational design of an improved induction scheme for recombinant Escherichia coli

In Escherichia coli, strong overexpression of a recombinant protein has been shown to be deleterious due to a heavy metabolic burden on the host cell, which may completely cease cell growth before maximum product accumulation has occurred. Aiming at a reduction of very high product formation rates, we engineered E. coli strains by mutating the Leloir pathway for galactose metabolization, so that galactose can be utilized to induce lac derived promoters. The induction with galactose was effective in every strain and expression construct tested, and it reduced the metabolic burden on a highly overproducing clone so that cell growth and product accumulation could be maintained for several generations.     

Behavioral inference of diving metabolic rate in free-ranging leatherback turtles

Good estimates of metabolic rate in free-ranging animals are essential for understanding behavior, distribution, and abundance. For the critically endangered leatherback turtle (Dermochelys coriacea), one of the world's largest reptiles, there has been a long-standing debate over whether this species demonstrates any metabolic endothermy. In short, do leatherbacks have a purely ectothermic reptilian metabolic rate or one that is elevated as a result of regional endothermy? Recent measurements have provided the first estimates of field metabolic rate (FMR) in leatherback turtles using doubly labeled water; however, the technique is prohibitively expensive and logistically difficult and produces estimates that are highly variable across individuals in this species. We therefore examined dive duration and depth data collected for nine free-swimming leatherback turtles over long periods (up to 431 d) to infer aerobic dive limits (ADLs) based on the asymptotic increase in maximum dive duration with depth. From this index of ADL and the known mass-specific oxygen storage capacity (To(2)) of leatherbacks, we inferred diving metabolic rate (DMR) as To2/ADL. We predicted that if leatherbacks conform to the purely ectothermic reptilian model of oxygen consumption, these inferred estimates of DMR should fall between predicted and measured values of reptilian resting and field metabolic rates, as well as being substantially lower than the FMR predicted for an endotherm of equivalent mass. Indeed, our behaviorally derived DMR estimates (mean=0.73+/-0.11 mL O(2) min(-1) kg(-1)) were 3.00+/-0.54 times the resting metabolic rate measured in unrestrained leatherbacks and 0.50+/-0.08 times the average FMR for a reptile of equivalent mass. These DMRs were also nearly one order of magnitude lower than the FMR predicted for an endotherm of equivalent mass. Thus, our findings lend support to the notion that diving leatherback turtles are indeed ectothermic and do not demonstrate elevated metabolic rates that might be expected due to regional endothermy. Their capacity to have a warm body core even in cold water therefore seems to derive from their large size, heat exchangers, thermal inertia, and insulating fat layers and not from an elevated metabolic rate.     

Colonization and recovery of lotic epilithic communities: A metabolic approach

Community respiration and net primary productivity measurements from precleaned and disturbed substrates of various sizes were collected to examine the colonization and recovery rates of lotic epilithic communities in situ. The assumptions and limitations of the technique for monitoring metabolic recovery are discussed. The results indicate that substrate size and heterogeneity affect the rates of metabolic recovery; metabolic recovery of the heterotrophic community component generally occurs before the autotrophic; following a physical disturbance 13–21 days are required for metabolic recovery while pre-cleaned mixed and homogenous large sized substrates require 15–21 days; a temporary summer metabolic equilibrium appears to exist in the Sheep River, the duration of which is dependent on abiotic environmental variables. Future metabolic studies should include structure and composition measurements to attain maximum information on the recovery of epilithic communities.