The Homology of Cortical Microtubules in Platyhelminth Spermatozoa: a Comparative Immunocytochemical Study of Acetylated Tubulin

Spermatozoa of certain acoels, a group of primitive Platyhelminthes, and spermatozoa of the most derived Platyhelminthes, the Cercomeridea (parasitic Platyhelminthes), show a general morphological resemblance in that they are long filiform cells with two incorporated axonemes and longitudinal cortical microtubules. A possible way to test the homology of these cortical microtubules in the different groups is to analyze the presence/absence of post-translational modifications of tubulin. An indirect immunofluorescence study showed that the doublet microtubules of the sperm axonemes are labelled by an anti acetylated-alpha-tubulin antibody in all groups, irrespective of the axoneme pattern (9 + 0, 9 + 2 and non-trepaxonematan 9 + “1” in various acoels, and trepaxonematan 9 + “1” of the temnocephalid Troglocaridicola sp., the digenean Echinostoma caproni and the monopisthocotylean monogenean Pseudodactylogyrus sp.). Significant differences are found in the sperm cortical microtubules: they are acetylated in the acoel Actinoposthia beklemischevi, but not in the digenean E. caproni and the temnocephalid Troglocaridicola sp. These results suggest that the sperm cortical microtubules of the acoels are not homologous with the morphologically similar elements found in the higher Platyhelminthes.     

Ultrastructure of the spermatozoon of Parachristianella trygonis Dollfus, 1946 (Trypanorhyncha: Eutetrarhynchidae)

The ultrastructural organization of the mature spermatozoon of the trypanorhynch cestode Parachristianella trygonis is described by transmission electron microscopy. The spermatozoon is a long and filiform cell, tapered at both ends, lacking both mitochondrion and crested bodies. Its cytoplasm contains 2 axonemes of the 9+'1' pattern of the Trepaxonemata longitudinally displaced, parallel cortical microtubules, the nucleus and glycogen in form of both alpha-glycogen rosettes and beta-glycogen particles. The anterior extremity of the spermatozoon is characterized by the presence of an arclike row of up to 10 parallel cortical microtubules that partially surround the first axoneme. The present study emphasizes the ultrastructural similarity between mature spermatozoa of all 4 trypanorhynchs that have been studied to date. Nevertheless, several features, i.e., the characteristics of spermatozoa extremities, the absence of crested bodies, and the possible presence of an arclike layer of cortical microtubules, need a more thorough analysis or confirmation in some of these species.     

Ultrastructure of the spermatozoon of Bothriocotyle sp. (Cestoda: Bothriocephalidea), a parasite of Schedophilus velaini (Sauvage, 1879) (Perciformes: Centrolophidae) in Senegal

The mature spermatozoon of Bothriocotyle sp. is filiform and tapered at both extremities. It possesses 2 axonemes of unequal length, showing the 9 + "1" pattern of Trepaxonemata. The anterior extremity exhibits a crest-like body. Thereafter, the crest-like body disappears, and the first axoneme is surrounded by a ring of cortical microtubules (about 27 units) that persist until the appearance of the second axoneme. This ring of cortical microtubules is characteristic only for species of Bothriocephalidea and represents a very useful phylogenetic character. The spermatozoon cytoplasm is slightly electron-dense and contains numerous electron-dense granules of glycogen in several regions. The anterior and posterior extremities of the spermatozoon lack cortical microtubules. The posterior extremity of the spermatozoon of Bothriocotyle sp. possesses a nucleus and a disorganized axoneme, which also characterizes spermatozoa of the Echinophallidae studied to date.     

Ultrastructural characteristics of the mature spermatozoon of the digenean Sclerodistomum italicum (Stossich, 1893) (Hemiuroidea,Sclerodistomidae) intestinal parasite of Hypocanthus amia (Teleostei,Carangidae)

The mature spermatozoon of Sclerodistomum italicum is filiform, tapered at both ends and shows the following features: 2 axonemes of the 9 + “1” pattern of the Trepaxonemata, mitochondrion, nucleus and parallel cortical microtubules. The specific features of the spermatozoon of S. italicum include the simultaneous presence of two types of extramembranous ornamentations, the presence of short cortical microtubules in the anterior part of the spermatozoon and the presence of only one bundle of cortical microtubules in the median part of the spermatozoon. Thus far these structures are known only in the Hemiuroidea. The presence of filamentous ornamentation in the anterior extremity of the spermatozoon has not previously been described in the Sclerodistomidae. Similar to spermatozoa of other hemiuroideans, S. italicum lack spine-like bodies described in spermatozoa of many digenean taxa. The posterior extremity of the spermatozoon exhibits the same ultrastructural characteristics typical of the Hemiuroidea.     

Ultrastructural study of the spermatozoon of Heterolebes maculosus (Digenea,Opistholebetidae), a parasite of the porcupinefish Diodon hystrix (Pisces,Teleostei)

This paper describes the ultrastructure of the mature spermatozoon of Heterolebes maculosus. It is the first study of this kind concerning the Opistholebetidae (Platyhelminthes, Digenea). The ultrastructural elements observed in the spermatozoon are: two axonemes with 9+“1” pattern of Trepaxonemata and their attachment zones, two mitochondria, a nucleus, cortical microtubules, external ornamentation of the plasma membrane and spine-like bodies. The number and the disposition of cortical microtubules, the organisation of 11 cortical microtubules disposed in semi-circle around the first mitochondrion in the external ornamentation region and the organisation of the posterior part of the spermatozoon are discussed. Three principal types of posterior part of digenean spermatozoa are proposed. The similarity between the spermatozoon of the Opistholebetidae H. maculosus and Opecoelidae enables us to confirm that these two families are closely related.     

Ultrastructure of the spermatozoon of the digenean Cricocephalus albus (Kuhl & van Hasselt, 1822) Looss, 1899 (Platyhelminthes, Pronocephaloidea, Pronocephalidae), parasite of “the hawksbill sea turtle” Eretmochelys imbricata (Linnaeus, 1766) in Senegal

The mature spermatozoon of Cricocephalus albus is filiform, tapered at both ends and shows the following features: 2 axonemes of different lengths presenting the 9 + “1” trepaxonematan pattern, 2 bundles of parallel cortical microtubules, a mitochondrion and a nucleus. Nevertheless, the particularity of the spermatozoon of C. albus is its anterior extremity with an apical electron-dense material associated with extramembranar ornamentation, a cytoplasmic dorsolateral expansion and spine-like bodies. To our knowledge, such an anterior extremity of the spermatozoon has not previously been described from a species of the superfamily Pronocephaloidea. Our study provides new data on the mature gamete of C. albus in order to improve our understanding of the pronocephaloidean phylogenetic relationships.     

Immunocytochemical study of tubulin in the 9+‘1’ sperm axoneme of a monogenean (Platyhelminthes), Pseudodactylogyrus sp.

The spermatozoon of the monopisthocotylean monogenean Pseudodactylogyrus sp. (a gill parasite of eels) has a single axoneme showing a 9+‘1’ pattern, a nucleus and a mitochondrion, but has no cortical microtubules. This species thus provides a very simple model for the study of tubulin in the 9+‘1’ axonemes of the Platyhelminthes, in contrast with digenean sperm which have a more complex spermatozoon with two such axonemes and cortical microtubules. Indirect immunofluorescence labelling of tubulin shows that the elongating spermatids, initially lying in all directions in the early stages, are arranged as parallel elements in further stages. The number of spermatids in an isogenic group could also be precisely counted and equals 32. Nuclear labelling with fluorescent dyes shows that the nuclei, first located in the common mass of the spermatids, later elongate and migrate into the growing spermatids, and that the nucleus is located in the central part of the mature spermatozoon, with the two extremities devoid of nucleus. Labelling with antibodies directed against acetylated, tyrosinated, and polyglutamylated tubulin gave positive results, thus indicating that these post-translational modifications of tubulin are present in the axoneme of spermatids and spermatozoa of monopisthocotylean monogeneans.     

Ultrastructure of sperms in Acoela (Acoelomorpha) and its concordance with molecular systematics

Abstract. The sperms of the Acoela, a group of lower worms, are filiform cells with 2 flagella incorporated into the cell body. Their axonemes can variously have 9+2, 9+1, or 9+0 patterns of microtubules; and singlet microtubules in the cell body can be arranged in axial or cortical positions. An analysis of phylogenetic relationships of acoels based on molecular characters (18S rDNA sequence data) showed that these patterns of microtubules, where known, fell into discrete monophyletic groups. To test this hypothesis, we have expanded the database of sperm characters by examining the ultrastructure of a further 10 species representing 4 acoel families. As expected, the Convolutidae fell into 2 unrelated groups: “small‐bodied convolutids”(Convoluta pulchra, Praeconvoluta tigrina, Pseudaphanostoma smithrii) having 9+2 axonemes and cortical microtubules, and “large‐bodied convolutids” (including Wulguru cuspidata) having 9+0 axonemes and axial microtubules. Also, as expected, a member of the Mecynostomidae (Paedomecynostomum bruneum) has 9+1 axonemes and axial microtubules. Members of a family that appears intermediate by molecular characters, the Otocelididae, significantly have a variety of patterns: axonemes with both 9+2 and 9+0 patterns (Notocelis gullmarensis) or just 9+2 (the other species), and either axial (Philocelis brueggemanni), both axial and cortical (N. gullmarensis) microtubules, or microtubules that bend between axial and cortical positions along the length of the sperm (Otocelis sandara). Members of the Dakuidae (Daku woorimensis) also belong to this intermediate group, having 9+2 axonemes and axial microtubules, while in a fifth otocelidid (Stomatricha hochbergi), sperm characters are like those of the “large‐bodied convolutids” (9+0 axonemes and axial microtubules). Characters of sperm morphology generally support the molecular hypothesis of relationships and confirm a suspected polyphyly of the families Convolutidae, Otocelididae, and Actinoposthiidae.     

Ultrastructural Observations on the Spermatozoon,Oocyte and Fertilization Process in Gonapodasmius,a Gonochoristic Trematode (Trematoda: Digenea: Didymozoidae)

Observations were performed in the uterus of a female Gonapodasmius sp., a gonochoristic didymozoid Trematode. The oocyte is a round cell 6 μm in diameter, which shows a ‘nucleolus-like cytoplasmic body’ and cortical granules. The spermatozoon is filiform, mobile and about 50 μm long. There is no acrosome. The anterior tip of the spermatozoon contains two centrioles made up of singlets and cortical microtubules with associated glycocalyx. The centrioles are continued as two axonemes of the classical 9 + ‘1’ pattern of flatworms, accompanied by a mitochondrion and a short row of cortical longitudinal microtubules. It is the posterior part of the sperm cell which contains the nucleus. At the outset of fertilization, the anterior part of the spermatozoon coils around the oocyte and penetrates it by lateral fusion. The posterior region of the spermatozoon, with the nucleus, is the last part to enter the oocyte, after passing through a perforation in the forming eggshell. The whole spermatozoon thus penetrates the female cell.     

Ultrastructural study of the male gamete of Pleurogonius truncatus Prudhoe, 1944 (Platyhelminthes, Digenea, Pronocephalidae) parasite of Eretmochelys imbricata (Linnaeus, 1766)

In Pronocephaloidea, the spermatozoa of only two species have been studied today. Because of this, we present in this work data concerning to a third specie, Pleurogonius truncatus Prudhoe, 1944. The mature spermatozoon of P. truncatus possesses two axonemes with the 9+"1" pattern typical of Trepaxonemata, mitochondrion, nucleus, parallel cortical microtubules, spinelike bodies, cytoplasmic expansion and an external ornamentation of the plasma membrane. A particularity of the spermatozoon of P. truncatus is in the ultrastructure of the anterior spermatozoon extremity with only cortical microtubules and ornamentation of the plasma membrane. This type of anterior extremity has never been described until today in Pronocephaloidea. On the other hand, the ultrastructure of the posterior extremity of the spermatozoon confirms that already described in Pronocephalidae.     

Sperm structure of Trichoptera. III. Hydropsychidae,polycentropodidae and philopotamidae (Annulipalpia)

Spermatozoa from 9 species belonging to 3 families of trichopteran suborder Annulipalpia (Philopotamidae : Philopotamus ludificatus, P. montanus, Wormaldia occipitalis, W. copiosa; Polycentropodidae: Plectrocnemia geniculata, Polycentropus mortoni, P. irroratus, Cyrnus trimaculatus; Hydropsychidae: Hydropsyche pellucidula) were studied by light, scanning, and transmission electron microscopy. The absence of axonemal dynein arms and a consequent sperm immotility are characteristic of the species studied. The presence of 7, rather than 2, central microtubules is shared by Polycentropodidae and some Philopotamidae. A greater variability in the sperm axoneme was found within Philopotamidae than in the other families. The species of the genus Wormaldia have an axial vesicle rather than microtubules and their axonemes have a 9 + 9 + 0 or 13 + 13 + 0 pattern. Hydropsychidae have spermatozoa provided with numerous finger-like appendages containing microtubular doublets. The progressive loss of sperm flagellum and motility within the group is discussed.     

Phylogenesis of spermatogenesis in Annulipalpia caddisflies: An ultrastructural analysis on philopotamidae spermiogenesis

Characters currently used in phylogenetic analyses are insufficient for determining the status of several families of the order Trichoptera (caddisflies). Comparative spermatology can contribute to solving this problem. In the suborder Integripalpia, the sperm axoneme displays the pattern of 9 + 2 pairs of parallel microtubules found in many animal species. In the suborder Annulipalpia, however, axonemes bear remarkable aberrations. Consistently, in Chimarra florida (Philopotamidae, Annulipalpia) we found that the number of central microtubules varies from zero to four in axonemes of the spermatids and that spermatozoa lack axonemes. We propose that, similarly, the axoneme pattern became unstable in the Annulipalpia ancestor, from which branched two phylogenetic lines having different kinds of axoneme aberrations: (a) families in which the number of central microtubules of the axoneme exceeds two (e.g., Philopotamidae, Polycentropodidae) and (b) families in which the number of central microtubules of the axoneme does not exceed two (e.g., Hydropsychidae).     

Electron microscope study of spermatogenesis in two cestodes acanthobothrium filicolle benedenii Loennberg, 1889 and Onchobothrium uncinatum (Rud., 1819) (Tetraphyllidea, Onchobothriidae) (author's transl)]

The spermatogenesis, spermatozoon differentiation and fine structure of Acanthobothrium filicolle benedenii Loennberg, 1889 and Onchobothrium uncinatum (Rud., 1819) were studied by means of light and electron microscopy. Spermatogenesis in both species is of the rosette type. During sperm differentiation, the five following stages have been distinguished: (1) formation of arching membranes and differentiation zone; (2) nuclear elongation; (3) formation of two flagella with a median cytoplasmic process; (4) flagellar rotation; (5) fusion of two flagella with the median cytoplasmic process induced by the migration of nucleus into the latter. The mature spermatozoa of both species are threadlike structures about 250 mum long. They consist of two axonemes of the platyhelminth type (9+1 pattern), elongated nucleus and cortical microtubules embedded in a cytoplasmic matrix containing numerus beta-glycogen particles. The body which appears on cross-sections as crest, lateral with respect to the axoneme, is present in both species. Such a body is reported for the first time in Cestode spermatozoa. There is no mitochondrion in the two Onchobothriidae sperms studied.     

Spermatogenesis and spermiogenesis in Didymocystis wedli Ariola, 1902 (Didymozoidae, Digenea).

The ultrastructure of the male reproductive system of Didymocystis wedli was studied for the first time, demonstrating spermiogenesis and spermatogenesis at different cell stages. The spermatozoa morphology was compared with that of other Digenea species. It was observed that the different cells of the spermatogenesis process follow the classic pattern reported for the majority of the parasitic platyhelminthes. During spermiogenesis, rootlet fibers, electrondense bodies and median cytoplasmic process were not observed. The mature spermatozoa of D. wedli were filiform, presenting nucleus, mitochondrion and two 9+1 axonemes, with a biflagellate distal extremity.     

Ultrastructure of spermatogenesis and sperm development in Saccocoelioides godoyi Kohn & Froes, 1986 (Digenea, Haploporidae)

Ultrastructural observations of spermatogenesis and sperm development of Saccocoelioides godoyi, an intestinal parasite of Leporinus friderici (Bloch, 1794) are described. The irregular-shaped spermatogonia form a peripheral layer, and show a prominent nucleus. Spermatocytes are larger than spermatogonia, and in the early stage present synaptonemal complex. Spermatids show nuclei smaller than the spermatocytes. Spermiogenesis is characterized by outgrowth of the zone of differentiation, presenting basal bodies, separated by an intercentriolar body. At the end of this process, the spermatozoa are released into the residual cytoplasmic mass. The spermatozoa of S. godoyi are elongate, similar to the pattern described for other Digenea, showing nuclei, mitochondria and two axonemes with the 9+1 configuration. The peripheral cortical microtubules on the dorsal and ventral faces are laterally interrupted.     

Ultrastructural and immunocytochemical investigation of acoel sperms with 9 + 1 axoneme structure: new sperm characters for unraveling phylogeny in Acoela

Acoel sperm characters proved useful in deciphering acoel taxonomy. The phylogenetic value of sperm characters in closely related sub-groups or in a monophyletic taxon has not yet been assessed. We have investigated sperm ultrastructure in seven members of the monophyletic taxon Childia sensu (Tekle et al. J Zool Sys Evol Res 43(1):72–90, 2005) and in their closest relatives, the Mecynostomidae (four taxa). All members of Childia examined show little variation in their sperm ultrastructure. The common characters of Childia taxa are: 9 + 1 axoneme structure, the presence of six distal cytoplasmic microtubules in the absence of axial or cortical ones, long nucleus and extensive nucleus–flagella overlap. We have identified a new set of cytoplasmic microtubules lying in the centriolar end of the sperm cell, distal microtubules. The origin and phylogenetic significance of this character is discussed. The types and arrangement of cytoplasmic granules could be used as phylogenetic characters at a low taxonomic level. A loose membrane amorphous core type of granule was found to be a synapomorphy for the following clade within the taxon Childia: C. crassum + C. groenlandica + C. vivipara + C. brachyposthium + C. macroposthium. Sausage shaped granules are plesiomorphic among the taxa examined. The rest of the granule characters were found to be homoplasious. Sperm ultrastructural characters have again proven their concordance with molecular phylogeny. The only morphological synapomorphies known for the sister taxa Childia–Mecynostomidae, in the molecular phylogeny, are characters derived from sperm ultrastructure: distal microtubules arranged in two groups of three microtubules each and a 9 + 1 axoneme structure. The spermatozoa of Childia and Mecynostomidae show 9 + 1 axoneme configuration, seemingly similar to the 9 + ‘1’ axoneme pattern of the Platyhelminthes—Trepaxonemata. Using electron-microscope immunocytochemistry, we have demonstrated that, unlike the central cylinder of trepaxonematans, the central cylinder of the 9 + 1 axonemal pattern in acoels is immunoreactive to tubulin and contains a single central microtubule. Therefore, the 9 + 1 patterns in acoels and trepaxonematans are homoplasious.     

Spermatozoon ultrastructure of Aponurus laguncula (Digenea: Lecithasteridae), a parasite of Aluterus monoceros (Pisces: Teleostei)

The mature spermatozoon of Aponurus laguncula, a parasite of the unicorn leatherjacket Aluterus monoceros, was studied by transmission electron microscopy. The spermatozoon possesses 2 axonemes of the 9 + “1” trepaxonematan pattern, attachment zones, a nucleus, a mitochondrion, external ornamentation of the plasma membrane and cortical microtubules. The major features are the presence of: 1) external ornamentation in the anterior part of the spermatozoon not associated with cortical microtubules; 2) one mitochondrion; and 3) cortical microtubules arranged as a single field in the ventral side. The maximum number of microtubules is in the nuclear region. The extremities of the axonemes are characterized by the disappearance of the central core and the presence of microtubule doublets or singlets. This study is the first undertaken with a member of the Lecithasteridae and exemplifies the sperm ultrastructure for the superfamily Hemiuroidea.     

Microtubular system during spermiogenesis and in the spermatozoon of Convoluta saliens (platyhelminthes,acoela): Tubulin immunocytochemistry and electron microscopy

Spermiogenesis and the spermatozoon were studied in Convoluta saliens, an acoel platyhelminth, by transmission electron microscopy, labelling of nuclei and immunocytochemistry of tubulin with various antibodies. Spermiogenesis involves formation of a long spermatid shaft containing two axonemes. It is established that the nucleus, after a stage of elongation, does not migrate up to the distal extremity of the spermatid, and that the centriolar derivatives are located at the distal extremity of the shaft. This contrasts with the parasitic Platyhelminthes. The mature spermatozoon, 180 μm in length, comprises a nuclear region, 50 μm in length, and a cytoplasmic region, with a short region of overlap. The cytoplasmic region contains two lateral axonemes with a 9 + 2 pattern of microtubules, granules of two different sizes, and two rows of longitudinal microtubules in the center. Each row consists of 5–6 singlet microtubules, with links between them. Whereas the two axonemes are labelled by antibodies against alpha, acetylated‐alpha, and beta tubulin, the microtubule rows are labelled only by the anti‐beta‐tubulin antibody. This suggests that acetylation does not occur in this part of the cytoskeleton, and that the epitope recognized by the anti‐alpha‐tubulin antibody (DM1A) is different in these units. Mol. Reprod. Dev. 52:74–85, 1999. © 1999 Wiley‐Liss, Inc.     

Ultrastructure of Spermiogenesis in Acanthocotyle and Myxinidocotyle (Platyhelminthes,Monogenea, Acanthocotylidae)

Abstract Spermiogenesis was studied by transmission electron microscopy in the acanthocotylid monogeneans Myxinidocotyle californica (from Eptatretus stoutii) and Acanthocotyle lobianchi (from Raja clavata). In Myxinidocotyle and Acanthocotyle, the zone of differentiation shows two 9+‘1’ axonemes, the elongating nucleus and mitochondrion, and a single cortical cytoplasmic microtubule. This single microtubule is found in the mature spermatozoon of both species and was also noted in capsalids. This requires a modified definition of ‘pattern 2’ of spermatozoa which becomes: ‘spermatozoa with two axonemes and no cortical microtubules, except one single element much shorter than the spermatozoon’. A very unusual structure was found in Myxinidocotyle, but not in Acanthocotyle: the centriolar derivative of one of the 9+‘1’ axonemes is made up of 18 diverging singlets of unequal length associated with electron-dense cytoplasm. This seems to be the first case of a centriolar derivative without nine-fold symmetry associated with an axoneme with nine-fold symmetry.     

Sperm characters of the digenean Nephrotrema truncatum (Troglotrematidae): a kidney parasite of Crocidura russula (Soricidae) and their phylogenetic significance

ABSTRACT

Spermatological characteristics of the troglotrematid digenean Nephrotrema truncatum, a parasite of the shrew Crocidura russula, have been investigated by means of transmission electron microscopy. The ultrastructural study reveals that the mature spermatozoon of N. truncatum exhibits many ultrastructural characters previously described in most gorgoderoideans. These are two axonemes of the 9+‘1‘ trepaxonematan pattern, four attachment zones, a lateral expansion, an external ornamentation of the plasma membrane associated with spine-like bodies and cortical microtubules, and in the posterior part of the anterior spermatozoon region, two bundles of parallel cortical microtubules with the maximum number located in the anterior part of the spermatozoon, a nucleus, two mitochondria, and granules of glycogen. The obtained results are compared with those of other digeneans, particularly the Gorgoderoidea. The sperm cells gorgoderoideans are of type IV, characterised by a 9+‘1‘ pattern of axonemes, the presence of an external ornamentation associated with cortical microtubules and located in the posterior area of the anterior extremity, the presence of two bundles of cortical microtubules, the maximum number of cortical microtubules located in the anterior region of the spermatozoon, and the presence of generally two mitochondria. However, dicrocoeliids and troglotrematids have spermatozoa with ornamentation of the plasma membrane and lateral expansions.