General acid-base catalysis in nucleobase amino proton exchange: cytidine

A useful property of DMSO solvent has been exploited to reveal a new catalytic route for cytidine amino proton exchange, relevant to exchange in the macromolecular state, but hidden in aqueous solution. Additional exchange mechanisms in aqueous monomeric cytidine (and adenosine) are obscured by the formation of a fast-exchanging endocyclic-protonated intermediate, which dominates the kinetics. Endocyclic nucleobase protonation could be circumvented in the presence of buffer conjugate acid by the use of DMSO/water solvent, permitting the first unequivocal observation buffer acid-catalyzed exchange from the neutral, unprotonated nucleobase, i.e., general acid catalysis. Because buffer ionization is greatly reduced in DMSO through anion desolvation, nucleobase protonation is suppressed in the presence of buffer acid. Evidence is presented to describe this catalytic route as one involving hydrogen bond formation between the buffer acid and the endocyclic protonation site, C(N-3). Since this same configuration is found in Watson-Crick hydrogen bonding, experiments are presented to demonstrate faster cytidine amino proton exchange with the formation of the G-C base pair in DMSO. The importance of this mechanism in past aqueous monomer studies and in the interpretation of macromolecular (DNA) hydrogen exchange is discussed.     

General Acid-Base Catalysis in Nucleobase Amino Proton Exchange: Cytidine

Abstract

A useful property of DMSO solvent has been exploited to reveal a new catalytic route for cytidine amino proton exchange, relevant to exchange in the macromolecular state, but hidden in aqueous solution. Additional exchange mechanisms in aqueous monomeric cytidine (and adenosine) are obscured by the formation of a fast-exchanging endocyclic-protonated intermediate, which dominates the kinetics. Endocyclic nucleobase protonation could be circumvented in the presence of buffer conjugate acid by the use of DMSO/water solvent, permitting the first unequivocal observation buffer acid-catalyzed exchange from the neutral, unprotonated nucleobase, i.e., general acid catalysis. Because buffer ionization is greatly reduced in DMSO through anion desolvation, nucleobase protonation is supressed m the presence of buffer acid. Evidence is presented to describe this catalytic route as one involving hydrogen bond formation between the buffer acid and the endocyclic protonation site, C(N-3). Since this same configuration is found in Watson-Crick hydrogen bonding, experiments are presented to demonstrate faster cytidine amino proton exchange with the formation of the G-C base pair in DMSO. The importance of this mechanism in past aqueous monomer studies and in the interpretation of macromolecular (DNA) hydrogen exchange is discussed.     

Exchange mechanisms for hydrogen bonding protons of cytidylic and guanylic acids.

The pH dependence of buffer catalysis of exchange of the C-4 amino protons of cyclic cytosine 2',3'-monophosphate (cCMP) and the N-1 proton of cyclic guanosine 2',3'-monophosphate (cGMP) conforms to an exchange mechanism, in which protonation of the nucleobases at C(N-3) AND G(N-7) establishes the important intermediates at neutral to acidic pH. Rate constants for transfer of the G(N-1) proton to H2O, OH-, phosphate, acetate, chloracetate, lactate, and cytosine (N-3) were obtained from 1H nuclear magnetic resonance line width measurements at 360 MHz and were used to estimate the pK or acidity of the exchange site in both the protonated and unprotonated nucleobase. These estimates reveal an increase in acidity of the G(N-1) site corresponding to 2 to 3 pK units as the G(N-7) site is protonated: At neutral pH the G(N-1) site of the protonated purine would be ionized (pK = 6.3). Determinations of phosphate, imidazole, and methylimidazole rate constants for transfer of the amino protons of cCMP provide a more approximate estimate of pK = 7 to 9 for the amino of the protonated pyrimidine. A comparison of the intrinsic amino acidity in the neutral and protonated cytosine is vitiated by the observation that OH- catalyzed exchange in the neutral base is not diffusion limited. This leads to the conclusion that protonation of the nucleobase effects a qualitative increase in the ability of the amino protons to form hydrogen bonds: from very poor in the neutral base to "normal" in the conjugate acid.     

Contrasting observations on buffer catalysis of guanosine amino proton exchange.

The two amino protons of 3', 5'-cyclic guanosine monophosphate are shown to differ drastically in their solvent exchange properties: One is rapidly exchanging and sensitive to buffer catalysis; the other slow and insensitive. This observation accounts for the marked contrast between stopped-flow and NMR observations on buffer catalysis of amino proton exchange in guanosine monophosphates. The amino protons of guanine compounds traverse a "fast" solvent exchange position through the process of amino rotation, which together with kinetic considerations and comparative data on adenine and cytosine compounds, supports proposals of solvent exchange mediated by events at the guanine (N-3) site, rather than the (N-7) site. Exchange does not conform to rate expressions used by different workers for amino proton exchange.     

Buffer catalysis of amino proton exchange in compounds of adenosine, cytidine and their endocyclic N-methylated derivatives

The use of buffer catalysts having a wide range of pK (dissociation) values (4-12) provides the first estimates of two generally useful empirical parameters of amino proton exchange in compounds of adenine and cytosine. These are a nucleobase amino group dissociation constant (pKD) and the 'encounter frequency' for proton transfer (kD), which can be used to predict amino proton exchange rates. Values of amino pKD fall in the range 8.6-9.4 for the unsubstituted nucleobases and their endocyclic N-methylated derivatives. Similar values of kD are obtained for all nucleobases (1 X 10(8) M-1 s-1). These constants were obtained from a statistical fit of second-order catalytic rate constants for amino proton exchange, measured by amino 1H-NMR lineshape at varying field frequencies (100, 300 and 360 MHz). These results confirm the requirement for buffer conjugate base formation and nucleobase protonation, but point to a different mechanism of exchange at low pH; most probably direct amino protonation for adenine, but not for cytosine compounds. Anionic buffer conjugate bases (phosphate and acetate) show a greater catalytic effect than neutral (nitrogen) bases, especially with cytosine compounds. The use of high concentrations of sodium perchlorate to sharpen amino 1H resonances of 1-methyladenosine is examined, with respect to chemical and rotational exchange and NMR line broadening.     

Acid-induced exchange of the imino proton in G.C pairs.

Acid-induced catalysis of imino proton exchange in G.C pairs of DNA duplexes is surprisingly fast, being nearly as fast as for the isolated nucleoside, despite base-pair dissociation constants in the range of 10(-5) at neutral or basic pH. It is also observed in terminal G.C pairs of duplexes and in base pairs of drug-DNA complexes. We have measured imino proton exchange in deoxyguanosine and in the duplex (ATATAGATCTATAT) as a function of pH. We show that acid-induced exchange can be assigned to proton transfer from N7-protonated guanosine to cytidine in the open state of the pair. This is faster than transfer from neutral guanosine (the process of intrinsic catalysis previously characterized at neutral ph) due to the lower imino proton pK of the protonated form, 7.2 instead of 9.4. Other interpretations are excluded by a study of exchange catalysis by formiate and cytidine as exchange catalysts. The cross-over pH between the regimes of pH-independent and acid-induced exchange rates is more basic in the case of base pairs than in the mononucleoside, suggestive of an increase by one to two decades in the dissociation constant of the base pair upon N7 protonation of G. Acid-induced catalysis is much weaker in A.T base pairs, as expected in view of the low pK for protonation of thymidine.     

The significance of the aprotic solvent in monomer studies related to the primary subunit environment in the macromolecule

An advantage of aprotic polar solvent systems in the study of monomer interactions relevant to the macromolecular state is demonstrated with the measurement of nucleoside amino proton exchange rates in DMSO/water mixtures. The DMSO/water solvent provides the first unequivocal observation of general acid catalysis of nucleic acid amino proton exchange, which is undetectable in aqueous solution due to the formation of the endocyclic protonated nucleobase. Suppression of nucleobase protonation in the presence of buffer acid is a consequence of anion desolvation in the aprotic solvent. The detected route of general acid catalysis is demonstrated as a consequence of Watson-Crick H-bonding, leading to the implication that amino chemistry is modulated in the helical state to decrease amino proton lifetime in the closed macromolecular context of conformational information obtained by hydrogen exchange methods. This useful property of the aprotic solvent can be extended to monomeric studies pertaining to specific local site interactions affecting the function and conformation of proteins and nucleic acids.     

The amino 1H resonances of oligonucleotide helices: d(CGCG)

An examination of the 1H NMR assignments and exchange properties of the amino resonances of the self-complementary tetramer, d(CGCG) was undertaken with regard to buffer effects, transfer of saturation from the water resonance and temperature dependence of amino 1H line shape and chemical shift. The lack of buffer effect on visible exchangeable proton resonances is evidence for the stringent requirement for nucleo-base protonation at pH values below neutrality, which is greatly reduced in the helical state. For this reason, sharp resonances are observed for both Watson-Crick and non-Watson-Crick cytosine amino protons for base-paired regions. Considerations of monomeric exchange mechanisms for the cytosine and guanine amino protons formed the basis for successful assignment and isolation of their resonances in the helical state by presaturation of the water resonance at selected pH values. Preirradiation of the water resonance at pH less than 6 would isolate the guanine amino 1H resonances of any self-complementary oligonucleotide, to exploit its high sensitivity as a useful proble of helix in equilibrium coil premelting.     

The Amino 1H Resonances of Oligonucleotide Helices: d(CGCG)

Abstract

An examination of the ¹H NMR assignments and exchange properties of the amino resonances of the self-complementary tetramer, d(CGCG) was undertaken with regard to buffer effects, transfer of saturation from the water resonance and temperature dependence of amino ¹H line shape and chemical shift. The lack of buffer effect on visible exchangeable proton resonances is evidence for the stringent requirement for nucleo-base protonation at pH values below neutrality, which is greatly reduced in the helical state. For this reason, sharp resonances are observed for both Watson-Crick and non-Watson-Crick cytosine amino protons for base-paired regions. Considerations of monomeric exchange mechanisms for the cytosine and guanine amino protons formed the basis for successful assignment and isolation of their resonances in the helical state by presaturation of the water resonance at selected pH values. Preirradiation of the water resonance at pH <6 would isolate the guanine amino ¹H resonances of any self-complementary oligonucleotide, to exploit its high sensitivity as a useful proble of helix ? coil premelting.     

Hydrogen-deuterium exchange in nucleosides and nucleotides. A mechanism for exchange of the exocyclic amino hydrogens of adenosine.

The pH dependence of the apparent first-order rate constant for the exchange of the exocyclic amino hydrogens of adenosine with deuterium from the solvent was measured by stopped-flow ultraviolet spectroscopy. This dependence shows acid catalysis, base catalysis, and spontaneous exchange at neutral pH values. A study of the effect of several buffers on the rates of exchange reveals both general acid and general base catalytic behavior for the exchange process. We propose a general mechanism for the exchange which requires N-1 protonated adenosine as an intermediate for the acid-catalyzed exchange and amidine anion for the base-catalyzed exchange. In both cases the rate-limiting step is the base-catalyzed abstraction of a proton from the exocyclic amino moiety. Evaluation of the rate constants predicts the equilibrium for the exocyclic amino/imino tautomers to be 6.3 times 10(3):1.     

Open states in native polynucleotides. II. Hydrogen-exchange study of cytosine-containing double helices.

Hydrogen-exchange studies of I · C and G · C double helices were carried out to test the generality of conclusions reached previously in studies of adenine-containing polymers (preceding paper). The cytosine amino group shows hydrogen-exchange behavior similar to the analogous group in adenine; a pH-independent pathway and a parallel general catalysis pathway require prior separation of the base-pair and pre-equilibrium protonation at the ring N. The cytosine amino group does, however, display greater sensitivity to specific and to general catalysis than found for adenine. In the G · C helix, the ring NH proton of guanine exchanges at the opening-limited rate, as does the analogous proton in A · U and A · T pairs, while the guanine amino protons exchange without a prior opening of structure. From the observed exchange rates and the known chemistry for the pH-independent reaction, one can calculate equilibrium opening constants of 4 × 10⁻³ for poly(rI) · poly(rC) and perhaps one tenth of that for poly(rG) · poly(rC). Also the opening rate constant for the G · C helix is 0.01 s⁻¹.These results, when applied to published exchange curves for DNA, indicate an equilibrium opening constant of 0.005, an opening rate constant of 0.04 s⁻¹, and a closing rate constant of 10 s⁻¹. (All values refer to studies at 0 °C.) These values point to the same kind of traveling-loop model for base-pair opening discussed previously for the opening reactions in adenine-containing double helices.     

Kinetic analysis of protonation of a specific site on a buffered surface of a macromolecular body

The kinetics of protonation of a specific site on a macromolecular structure (micelle) in buffered solution was studied with the purpose of evaluating the effect of buffer on the observed dynamics. The experimental system consisted of the following elements: Brij 58 micelles serving as homogeneous uncharged macromolecular bodies, bromocresol green, a well-adsorbed proton detector, and 2-naphthol-3,6-disulfonate as a proton emitter in the bulk. Imidazole was the mobile buffer while neutral red, which has a high affinity for the micellar surface, served as the immobile buffer. An intensive laser pulse ejects a proton from the proton emitter, and the subsequent proton-transfer reactions are measured by fast spectrophotometric methods. The dynamics of proton pulse in buffered solution are characterized by a very rapid trapping of the discharged protons by the abundant buffer molecules. This event has a major effect on the kinetic regime of the reaction. During the first 200 ns the proton flux is rate limited by free-proton diffusion. After this period, when the free-proton concentration decayed to the equilibrium level, the relaxation of the system is carried out by the diffusion of buffer. Thus in the buffered biochemical system, at neutral pH, most of proton flux between active sites and bulk is carried out by buffer molecules--not by diffusion of free protons. Surface groups on a high molecular weight body exchange protons among them at a very fast rate. This reaction has a major role on proton transfer from a specific site to the bulk.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Effect of buffer on kinetics of proton equilibration with a protonable group

The laser-induced proton pulse generates a massive, brief, proton pulse capable of perturbing biochemical equilibria. The time resolution of the monitoring system can follow the diffusion-controlled protonation of specific sites on macromolecular bodies [Gutman, M. (1984) Methods Biochem. Anal. 30, 1-103]. In order to apply this method in enzymology, one must first evaluate how the buffer capacity of biochemical systems (substrates and proteins) will affect the observed dynamics. Unlike equilibrium measurements, where buffer is an inert component, in kinetic studies buffer modulates the observed dynamics. In this paper we analyze the effect of buffer on the dynamics of protonation in a model system. We describe the experimental technique and introduce the mathematical formalism that determines the various rate constants involved in the reaction. The analysis of the experiments indicates that in buffered solution proton flux is carried by two mechanisms: (A) proton dissociation followed by free proton diffusion; (B) collisional proton transfer between small diffusing solutes. We demonstrate how to evaluate the contribution of each pathway to the overall proton flux.     

Kinetics of exchangeable protons in Z DNA: a UV resonance Raman study.

We have studied the hydrogen-deuterium exchange kinetics of the exchangeable protons of the poly(dG-dC).poly(dG-dC) in the Z form of the polymer, using resonance Raman spectroscopy with 257 nm and 284 nm excitation wavelengths. In our experimental conditions (4.5 M NaCl, phosphate buffer pH7, 2 degrees C) the two amino protons and the imino proton of guanine are exchanged with the same exchange half-time of 13 min, whereas the two amino protons of cytosine are exchanged with the same exchange half-time of 51 min.     

Internal motions of transfer RNA: a study of exchanging protons by magnetic resonance

Proton exchange is a probe of macromolecular structure and kinetics. Its value is enhanced when the exchanging protons can be identified by nmr. After dilution of tRNA-H2O samples in D2O, slowly exchanging imino protons are observed, with exchange times ranging from minutes to days. In many cases they originate from the dihydro-uracil region. Most slow exchangers are sensitive to buffer catalysis. Extrapolation to infinite buffer concentration yields the life-time of the closed form, in a two-state model of each base-pair. As predicted by the model, the lifetime obtained by extrapolation is independent of the buffer. Typical lifetimes are 14 minutes for CG11 of yeast tRNAPhe at 17 degrees C, or 5 minutes for U8-A14 of yeast tRNA(Asp) at 20 degrees C, without magnesium. For most slow exchangers, magnesium increases the lifetime of the closed form, but moderately, by factors never more than five. The exchange rates of other, fast-exchanging, imino protons, as determined by line-broadening, are found to depend on buffer concentration. Base-pair lifetimes are determined as above. For instance UA6 of yeast tRNA(Phe) has a lifetime of 14 ms at 17 degrees C. Base-pairs 4 and 6 have shorter lifetimes than the rest of the acceptor stem. Imidazole is a good catalyst for proton exchange of both the long-and the short-lived base-pairs, whereas phosphate is not. Tris is efficient except for cases where, possibly, access is impeded by its size; magnesium reduces the efficiency of catalysis by tris buffer. From the variation of exchange time vs buffer concentration, one determines the buffer concentration for which the exchange rate from the open state is equal to the closing rate. Remarquably, this concentration takes comparable values for most base-pairs, whether short-lived or long-lived. Buffer effects have also been observed in poly(rA).poly(rU), for which we derive a lifetime of 2.5 ms at 27 degrees C, and in other polynucleotides. Some of the exchange times identified in the literature as base-pair lifetimes may instead reflect incomplete catalysis.     

Purification and biochemical characterization of a pyruvate-specific class II aldolase, HpaI

HpaI, a class II pyruvate-specific aldolase involved in the catabolic pathway of hydroxyphenylacetate, is overexpressed and purified. A previous suggestion that phosphate is involved in proton transfer of pyruvate, based on the crystal structure of the homologous 2-dehydro-3-deoxygalactarate aldolase, is not substantiated from biochemical studies with HpaI. Thus, specific activities of the enzyme for the substrate 4-hydroxy-2-ketopentanoate in sodium HEPES and Tris-acetate buffers are higher than in sodium phosphate buffer. The enzyme also catalyzed the partial reaction of pyruvate proton exchange with an initial rate of 0.77 mmol min(-)(1) mg(-)(1) in phosphate-free buffer, as monitored by nuclear magnetic resonance. Steady-state kinetic analysis shows that the enzyme is also able to catalyze the aldol cleavage of 4-hydroxy-2-ketohexanoate and 3-deoxy-d-manno-oct-2-ulosonic acid (KDO). The enzyme exhibits significant oxaloacetate decarboxylase activity, with a k(cat) value 2.4-fold higher than the corresponding value for the aldol cleavage of 4-hydroxy-2-ketopentanoate. Sodium oxalate, an analogue of the enolate intermediate of the enzyme-catalyzed reaction, is a competitive inhibitor of the enzyme, with a K(i) value of 5.5 microM. Replacement of an active site arginine residue (R70) with alanine by site-specific mutagenesis resulted in an enzyme that lacks both aldolase and decarboxylase activities. The mutant enzyme is also unable to catalyze pyruvate proton exchange. The dissociation constant for pyruvate in the R70A mutant, determined by fluorescence titration, is similar to that of the wild-type enzyme, indicating that pyruvate binding is not affected by this mutation. Together, the results show that R70 influences catalysis in HpaI, particularly at the pyruvate proton exchange step.     

Nuclear magnetic resonance study on the exchange behavior of the NH-N protons of a ribonucleic acid miniduplex

The exchange behavior of the guanine N(1) and uracil N(3) protons in the self-complementary hexanucleotide r(ApApGpCpUpU) has been studied at 5 degrees C in 80% H2O/20% D2O by proton NMR. Under these conditions, the hexanucleotide forms a stable miniduplex. The exchange rate of all Watson-Crick NH protons is unaffected by addition of trifluoroethylamine up to 0.07 M. On the other hand, addition of phosphate buffer, pH 6.9, enhances the exchange rate of the uracil N(3) protons of both terminal and internal A X U base pairs but does not influence the exchange rate of the guanine N(1) protons of the central G X C base pairs. Catalysis by increased phosphate concentrations results in an open-limited rate of the internal A X U base pairs with kex = 233 s-1, equivalent to a lifetime of 4.3 ms. The proton exchange of the central G X C is regulated by the opening rate of the central core of the miniduplex. On the other hand, the sensitivity of the exchange rate of internal as well as of terminal A X U base pairs can be explained by their reduced lifetime due to end "fraying" and a subsequent catalysis of the exchange process from the opened state. These results suggest that it may be possible to probe labilized parts of RNAs such as tRNA by gradual addition of the exchange catalyst phosphate and to monitor their exchange rates by proton NMR.     

Study of structure, base-pair opening kinetics and proton exchange mechanism of the d-(AATTGCAATT) self-complementary oligodeoxynucleotide in solution.

Using proton magnetic resonance, we have investigated the structure and the base-pair opening kinetics of the d-(AATTGCAATT) self-complementary duplex. All the non-exchangeable (except H5',5") and most exchangeable proton resonances have been assigned. The structure belongs to the B family. Imino proton exchange, measured by line broadening, longitudinal relaxation and magnetization transfer from water, is catalyzed by proton acceptors. The base-pair lifetimes, obtained by extrapolation of the exchange times to infinite concentration of ammonia are 2 and 3 milliseconds for internal A.Ts and 18 ms for G.C at 15 degrees C. In the absence of added catalysts, the imino proton of the first A.T base pair exchanges faster than that of the unpaired thymidine of the duplex formed by the sequence d-(AATTGCAATTT). This gives strong evidence for intrinsic exchange catalysis. The exchange of adenine amino protons from the closed state has been observed. Hence amino proton exchange is ill-suited for the investigation of base-pair opening kinetics.     

Kinetic and crystallographic studies of the role of tyrosine 7 in the active site of human carbonic anhydrase II

The rate limiting step in catalysis of bicarbonate dehydration by human carbonic anhydrase II (HCA II) is an intramolecular proton transfer from His64 to the zinc-bound hydroxide. We have examined the role of Tyr7 using site-specific mutagenesis and measuring catalysis by the ¹⁸O exchange method using membrane inlet mass spectrometry. The side chain of Tyr7 in HCA II extends into the active-site cavity about 7 Å from the catalytic zinc atom. Replacement of Tyr7 with eight other amino acids had no effect on the interconversion of bicarbonate and CO₂, but in some cases caused enhancements in the rate constant of proton transfer by nearly 10-fold. The variant Y7I HCA II enhanced intramolecular proton transfer approximately twofold; its structure was determined by X-ray crystallography at 1.5 Å resolution. No changes were observed in the ordered solvent structure in the active-site cavity or in the conformation of the side chain of the proton shuttle His64. However, the first 11 residues of the amino-terminal chain in Y7I HCA II assumed an alternate conformation compared with the wild type. Differential scanning calorimetry showed variants at position 7 had a melting temperature approximately 8 °C lower than that of the wild type.     

Reaction of triosephosphate isomerase with L-glyceraldehyde 3-phosphate and triose 1,2-enediol 3-phosphate

Triosephosphate isomerase catalyzes the isomerization and/or racemization reactions of L-glyceraldehyde 3-phosphate (LGAP), the enantiomer of the physiological substrate. The reaction is inhibited by the active site directed reagent glycidol phosphate. The amount of protonation product formation catalyzed by a fixed enzyme concentration is nearly independent of increasing steady-state concentrations of triose 1,2-enediol 3-phosphate caused by buffer catalysis of LGAP deprotonation. Therefore, enzymatic protonation of the enediol or enediolate, which could account for the observed enzymatic catalysis of LGAP isomerization and/or racemization, is at best a minor reaction. Instead LGAP reacts directly at the enzyme active site. Triosephosphate isomerase catalysis of the protonation of triose 1,2-enediol 3-phosphate was expected because of the strong evidence supporting an enediol reaction intermediate for the overall reaction catalyzed by isomerase. The most reasonable explanation for the failure to observe enzymatic protonation is that in solution the enediol undergoes beta elimination of phosphate (t 1/2 is estimated to be 10(-6) s) faster than it can diffuse to and form a complex with isomerase.