Research note: Field evaluation of epiphyte recruitment (Vertebrata lanosa,Rhodophyta) in different microsite types on host fronds (Ascophyllum nodosum,Phaeophyceae)

The seaweed Ascophyllum nodosum (Phaeophyceae, Fucales) often forms extensive beds in wave‐sheltered, rocky intertidal habitats on northern Atlantic shores. Since this alga is an ecosystem engineer that influences benthic biodiversity, it is important to understand the factors that regulate its performance. Epiphytism is known to affect the performance of macroalgal hosts. In this study, we investigated the effects of surface irregularities on A. nodosum fronds (wounds, branch axils, and lateral pits resulting from receptacle shedding) on the recruitment rate of its obligate epiphyte Vertebrata lanosa (=Polysiphonia lanosa, Rhodophyta, Ceramiales). For this purpose, we performed a field experiment in Nova Scotia, Canada. In June–July 2007, we created wounds on the surface of host fronds that mimicked the wounds that result from invertebrate grazing. At that time, we also mapped the position of epiphyte‐free lateral pits and branch axils on host fronds. In October 2007, after the reproductive season for V. lanosa, the percentage of microsites colonized by this epiphyte was statistically similar for wounds and lateral pits, but significantly lower for branch axils, although by a small difference (mean recruitment rates ranged between 37 and 50%). Since V. lanosa is known not to colonize smooth frond surfaces, our study suggests that the degree of epiphyte load on A. nodosum beds should largely be affected by the overall amount of surface irregularities, with little influence of the relative availability of each microsite type.     

Effect of epiphytism on reproductive and vegetative lateral formation in the brown, intertidal seaweed Ascophyllum nodosum (Phaeophyceae)

In the brown alga Ascophyllum nodosum (L) Le Jolis, a common species on sheltered Northern temperate rocky shores, gametes are produced in receptacles that emerge from small depressions (lateral pits) along the branched frond. These lateral pits are also the preferred settling site for the obligate epiphyte Polysiphonia lanosa (L) Tandy. Therefore, epiphytism can be expected to interfere with host reproductive output. The present study investigated the potential impact of the epiphyte on A. nodosum in two series of laboratory experiments that measured: (i) the direct shading of the host plant underneath an epiphyte canopy; and (ii) the development of receptacles in clean and epiphytised A. nodosum segments (excised from individual fronds) over a 6 month period. These experiments showed that light reaching emerged fronds underneath a dense epiphyte cover was reduced by 40%, and this was independent of the degree of desiccation the epiphyte experienced. Concurrently, in the growth study with epiphytised A. nodosum segments (segments with one clean and one epiphytised lateral pit) total receptacle biomass per epiphytised fragment was significantly reduced compared with clean segments (0.52 g and 1.25 g per gram of frond segment, respectively), although this effect was only significant in A. nodosum from sheltered shores. However, expressed as biomass per lateral pit, receptacle biomass in the remaining clean lateral pits in epiphytised segments was significantly increased in segments from both shores, demonstrating that A. nodosum can at least partially compensate for the loss of production resulting from epiphytism.     

ROLE OF SURFACE WOUNDS AND BROWN ALGAL EPIPHYTES IN THE COLONIZATION OF ASCOPHYLLUM NODOSUM (PHAEOPHYCEAE) FRONDS BY VERTEBRATA LANOSA (RHODOPHYTA)1

Ascophyllum nodosum (L.) Le Jol. forms extensive beds in wave‐sheltered, rocky intertidal habitats on the northwestern Atlantic coast. This fucoid seaweed is host to an obligate red algal epiphyte, Vertebrata lanosa (L.) T. A. Chr. [=Polysiphonia lanosa (L.) Tandy], and two facultative brown algal epiphytes, Elachista fucicola (Velley) Aresch. and Pylaiella littoralis (L.) Kjellm. Although V. lanosa can occur throughout most of the length of host fronds, it largely predominates in midfrond segments. The two brown algal epiphytes are restricted to distal segments. Through field experiments conducted in Nova Scotia, Canada, we tested the hypothesis that surface wounds are required for the colonization of distal segments of host fronds by V. lanosa. Distal tissues normally have a smooth surface because of their young age (A. nodosum fronds grow apically). By creating small wounds that mimicked grazing wounds distributed elsewhere on host fronds, we demonstrated that V. lanosa can colonize distal frond segments during the growth and reproductive season (summer and autumn). Approximately half of the artificial wounds were colonized by V. lanosa during this time. The experimental exclusion of both brown algal epiphytes from distal frond segments did not affect colonization by V. lanosa. Thus, we conclude that the absence of surface irregularities on distal segments of host fronds, specifically small wounds, is the main factor explaining the absence of V. lanosa there. We propose that further experimental work clarifying epiphyte distribution in host beds will enhance our ability to understand the functional role of epiphytes in intertidal ecosystems.     

ELECTRICAL IMPEDANCE IN ASCOPHYLLUM NODOSUM AND FUCUS VESTCULOSUS IN RELATION TO COOLING,FREEZING, AND DESICCATION1

Electrical impedance monitoring techniques appear to be useful in tracing the effect of cooling or desiccation upon the thallus of Fucus vesiculosus and Ascophyllum nodosum. These algae were found to be remarkably resistant to injury from freezing down to ?20 C even during midsummer and from desiccation up to 70% water loss, and in these properties were markedly different from land plants. Freezing point depressions, the degree of supercooling, activation energies of cooling-impedance curves, and the slope of these curves themselves were useful in disclosing differences between time of sampling, storage time, and indications of damage in tissue. No significant difference could be detected between the 2 species collected and tested at the same time. Significant differences occurred in F. vesiculosus between summer and winter, and in winter between submersed and intermittently exposed plants. Tracer ion uptake techniques confirmed that freezing to ?20 C did not kill tissues.     

Interactions of Patella and macroalgae with settling Semibalanus balanoides (L.)

Biological interactions affecting densities of settling and newly-settled Semibalanus balanoides (L.) have been investigated by manipulative field experiments on the Isle of Man.The effects of sweeping by fucoid clumps of different species and Patella browsing have been compared on moderately-exposed shores. Patella allowed barnacle settlement by preventing growth of competing green algae, but reduced post-settlement densities. Small clumps of Fucus spiralis L., F. vesiculosus L, and F. serratus L. all reduced settlement considerably more so than limpets. F. serratus had the greatest sweeping effect.Interactions between macroalgae and Semibalanus balanoides have been investigated at all levels on sheltered shores and low down on more exposed shores. In the Fucus spiralis and F. vesiculosus zones, post-settlement numbers were higher than in adjacent areas where the canopy was removed. Barnacles did not settle readily in the Ascophyllum zone in either experimental or control areas. Settlement occurred in the upper part of the Fucus serratus zone in experimental areas where the canopy was removed but not in control areas. No settlement occurred in either treatment or control areas lower in the F. serratus zone. At all levels on the shore fucoid canopies seemed to reduce cyprid settlement, but the effect was greatest amongst F. serratus where there was total prevention. High on the shore the effect of enhanced post-settlement survival under the canopy outweighs reduction of cyprid settlement thus there are greater numbers in the controls. Competition with red algal turfs was shown to set the lower limit of the barnacle zone on a vertical pier face.     

Characterization of microsatellite loci in the marine seaweed Ascophyllum nodosum (Phaeophyceae; Fucales)

Ascophyllum nodosum L. dominates rocky intertidal shores throughout the temperate North Atlantic. Six microsatellite loci were developed for A. nodosum using enriched libraries. The number of alleles ranged from 9 to 24 and heterozygosities from 0.2213 to 0.7785. Ascophyllum is monotypic. There was no cross‐reactivity observed with Fucus serratus, F. vesiculosus or F. evanescens.     

SEASONALITY OF MICROBIAL FOULING ON ASCOPHYLLUM NODOSUM (L.) LEJOL., FUCUS VESICULOSUS L., POLYSIPHONIA LANOSA (L.) TANDY AND CHONDRUS CRISPUS STACKH1

The nature and seasonal extent of microbial fouling on Ascophyllum nodosum (L.) LeJol., Fucus vesiculosus L., Polysiphonia lanosa (L.) Tandy and Chondrus crispus Stackh. were observed by scanning electron microscopy. Bacterial filaments and smaller rod and coccoid forms dominated the fouling communities on all species, with pennate diatoms constituting a minor component in contrast to results with plastic substrates on which pennate diatoms dominated and preceded bacterial colonization. The total percent microbial coverage on the surfaces of all four seaweed species was determined by monthly stereological analyses of representative composite micrographs. These showed a simultaneous decline between April and May which could represent the die-off of the cold water bacterial flora when water temperature increased past the threshold for obligate psychrophiles. Microbial colonization patterns were directly correlated (P = 0.005) with maximum coverage in April and November–December and reduced levels from May to October. Significant inverse (P < 0.041) correlations between total percent coverage and water temperature indicate distinct seasonal cycles, however, the patterns of dominance by filamentous bacteria and rod and coccoid forms were markedly different. Total coverage patterns of both rhodophytes showed no apparent seasonal cycle and were not related to water temperature. Rod and coccoid bacteria were apparently suppressed year round on P. lanosa relative to the other species. These interspecific differences in seasonal fouling patterns are discussed in light of possible modes of regulation, especially algal antibiosis.     

MICROSENSOR MEASUREMENTS OF THE EXTERNAL AND INTERNAL MICROENVIRONMENT OF FUCUS VESICULOSUS (PHAEOPHYCEAE)1

We investigated the O₂, pH, and irradiance microenvironment in and around the tissue of the brown alga Fucus vesiculosus L. using microsensors. Microsensors are ideal tools for gaining new insights into what limits and controls macroalgal activity and growth at very fine spatial (<100 μm) and temporal (seconds) scales. This first microsensor investigation of a fucoid macroalga revealed differences in the microenvironment and metabolic activities at the level of different cell layers and thallus structures. F. vesiculosus responded quickly to rapid shifts in irradiance resulting in a highly dynamic microenvironment around and within its thallus. In combination with detailed morphological studies and molecular approaches, microsensors offer a promising toolbox to quantitatively describe structural and functional adaptations of macroalgae to environmental conditions, such as flow and light climate, as well as their physiological responses to environmental stressors.     

Effects of filamentous algae and deposited matter on the survival of Fucus vesiculosus L. germlings in the Baltic Sea

As a result of increased nutrient levels in the Baltic Sea during thepast 50 years, mass developments of filamentous algae have become a commonfeature along the Swedish east coast and deposition of organic matter has alsoincreased. To test whether these two factors have any effects on the early lifestages of Fucus vesiculosus a number of laboratory andfield studies were conducted. The amount of epilithic and epiphytic filamentousalgae on F. vesiculosus and the amount of deposited matterin the littoral zone were quantified during the two reproductive periods ofF. vesiculosus, early summer (May–June) and lateautumn (September–October). Both filamentous algae (Cladophoraglomerata) and deposited matter (introduced either before or aftersettlement of fertilized eggs) were shown to significantly decrease the numberof surviving germlings. The survival of germlings seeded on stones withfilamentous algae, or seeded on culture dishes concurrently with the lowestconcentration of deposited matter (0.1 g dm^–2),was 5% or less. In the field, the amount of filamentous algae was significantlyhigher during F. vesiculosus summer reproduction, whereasthe amount of deposited matter collected in traps was significantly higherduring the period of autumn reproduction. The greatest biomass of filamentousalgae was observed at sheltered sites. Based on the negative effects offilamentous algae and deposited matter on Fucusrecruitmentand the observation of local and seasonal differences in abundance offilamentous algae and deposition, we suggest that the prerequisites for thesurvival of either summer or autumn-reproducing populations of F.vesiculosus in the Baltic Sea may differ locally.     

FLUORESCENCE EMISSION SPECTRA OF MARINE AND BRACKISH‐WATER ECOTYPES OF FUCUS VESICULOSUS AND FUCUS RADICANS (PHAEOPHYCEAE) REVEAL DIFFERENCES IN LIGHT‐HARVESTING APPARATUS1

The Bothnian Sea in the northerly part of the Baltic Sea is a geologically recent brackish‐water environment, and rapid speciation is occurring in the algal community of the Bothnian Sea. We measured low‐temperature fluorescence emission spectra from the Bothnian Sea and the Norwegian Sea ecotypes of Fucus vesiculosus L., a marine macroalga widespread in the Bothnian Sea. Powdered, frozen thallus was used to obtain undistorted emission spectra. The spectra were compared with spectra measured from the newly identified species Fucus radicans Bergström et L. Kautsky, which is a close relative of F. vesiculosus and endemic to the Bothnian Sea. The spectrum of variable fluorescence was used to identify fluorescence peaks originating in PSI and PSII in this chl c–containing alga. The spectra revealed much higher PSII emission, compared to PSI emission, in the Bothnian Sea ecotype of F. vesiculosus than in F. radicans or in the Norwegian Sea ecotype of F. vesiculosus. The results suggest that more light‐harvesting chl a/c proteins serve PSII in the Bothnian Sea ecotype of F. vesiculosus than in the two other algal strains. Treatment of the Bothnian Sea ecotype of F. vesiculosus in high salinity (10, 20, and 35 practical salinity units) for 1 week did not lead to spectral changes, indicating that the measured features of the Bothnian Sea F. vesiculosus are stable and not simply a direct result of exposure to low salinity.     

Quantitative studies on brown algal phenols. II. Seasonal variation in polyphenol content of Ascophyllum nodosum (L.) Le Jol. and Fucus vesiculosus (L.)

The content of extractable polyphenols in the brown algae Ascophyllum nodosum (L.) Le Jol. and Fucus vesiculosus (L.) was measured at ≈28-day intervals for one year. Colorimetric methods based on the Folin-Denis, Brentamine, and vanillin-H₂SO₄ reactions were used to estimate relative contents of polyphenols, and these values were converted to absolute contents using the gravimetric method introduced earlier. Relatively little error was introduced by variations in the qualitative composition of the extracted polyphloroglucinols.There appeared to be a significant temporal correlation between polyphenol content and the reproductive state of the algae. The content of polyphenols in A. nodosum was at a minimum (≈9–10% of dry matter) during the period of maximum fruit body shedding (late May), and reached a maximum (≈12–14% of dry matter) during the ‘winter season’. In F. vesiculosus, the minimum (≈8–10% of dry matter) was one to two months later, just before the period of maximum fertility, and thereafter rose to a maximum (≈11–13% of dry matter) during the period of sterility. These results furthermore suggest that the bulk of the polyphenols are not readily accessible as reserve components, and indicate that modifications may be needed in the ‘chemical defense’ and ‘waste product’ hypotheses concerning the significance of brown algal polyphenols.     

Production of fucoid brown algae <Emphasis Type="Italic">Ascophyllum nodosum</Emphasis> and <Emphasis Type="Italic">Fucus vesiculosus</Emphasis> in the White Sea

Year-round studies of photosynthesis and respiration in the fucoid brown algae Ascophyllum nodosum and Fucus vesiculosus in the White Sea were performed. The annual specific production of the macrophytes was determined to be 1314 and 1642 cal/g of wet weight for A. nodosum and F. vesiculosus, respectively. The total annual production of fucoids (4.88 × 10¹¹ kcal) comprised about 0.8% of the phytoplankton production in the White Sea.     

GENETIC AND MORPHOLOGICAL IDENTIFICATION OF FUCUS RADICANS SP. NOV. (FUCALES,PHAEOPHYCEAE) IN THE BRACKISH BALTIC SEA1

Brown seaweeds of the genus Fucus occupy a wide variety of temperate coastal habitats. The genus is evolutionary dynamic with recent radiations to form morphologically distinct taxa. In the brackish Baltic Sea, fucoids are the only perennial canopy‐forming macroalgae. The most northern populations of Fucus occur permanently submerged in extremely low salinity (3–5 psu). These are currently referred to as Fucus vesiculosus L. but are morphologically distinct with a narrow frond without bladders. We report here that a population of this unique morphotype is reproductively isolated from a truly sympatric population of common F. vesiculosus and conclude that the northern morphotype represents a previously undescribed species. We describe Fucus radicans sp. nov., which is attached and dioecious with broadly elliptic receptacles, characterized by a richly branched narrow flat frond (2–5 mm), short thallus (<26 cm), and a high capacity for vegetative recruitment of attached plants. Analysis of five highly polymorphic microsatellite DNA loci showed genetic differentiation between sympatric populations of F. radicans and F. vesiculosus, whereas allopatric populations of the same species revealed a coherent pattern of genetic variation. Sequences of the RUBISCO region in F. radicans were identical to or differing at only one to two dinucleotide positions from those of F. vesiculosus, indicating a recent common origin of the two species.     

COLONIZATION AND GROWTH OF ASCOPHYLLUM NODOSUM (PHAEOPHYTA) IN MAINE1

Colonization and growth of Ascophyllum nodosum (L.) Le Jol. were investigated in two Maine estuaries from 1972 to 1978. Following denudation of intertidal rock, substrata were initially colonized by Fucus vesiculosus L.; eventually, Ascophyllum supplanted Fucus, and became dominant in terms of percentage cover. Ascophyllum settled first and most densely in the low intertidal zone, but its fastest growth occurred in the mid-intertidal zone. Some, but not all, Ascophyllum germlings produced a vesicle within one year of colonization. The mean annual growth of A. nodosum was variable among sites, zones and years.     

The Influence of Salinity on the Rate of Dark Respiration and Structure of the Cells of Brown Algae Thalli from the Barents Sea Littoral

We studied the changes in the rate of dark respiration (DR) and structure of the cells in Ascophyllum nodosum and Fucus vesiculosus thalli during the incubation at 40, 34, 20, 10, and 2 salinity for 14 days. The changes in salinity affected the rate of DR and the structure of the thallus apical cells: the organelles swollen and were destroyed later. The effect of hyposalinity on the algae was more pronounced as compared to hypersalinity. The stress intensity directly increased with the degree of desalination. Further adaptation of the algae to low salinity enhanced DR and, hence, was an energy-dependent process. Despite higher DR rates (during the stress and adaptation) in F. vesiculosus as compared to A. nodosum, the seaweeds had similar pattern of adaptation to the variation of salinity. Different primary response of the seaweeds to 20 salinity was an important exception; apparently, the salinity around 20 is the limit of these species distribution in desalination zones.     

DETERMINING THE AFFINITIES OF SALT MARSH FUCOIDS USING MICROSATELLITE MARKERS: EVIDENCE OF HYBRIDIZATION AND INTROGRESSION BETWEEN TWO SPECIES OF FUCUS (PHAEOPHYTA) IN A MAINE ESTUARY1

The high degree of morphological plasticity displayed by species of the brown algal genus Fucus L. is well documented. Such variation is especially pronounced for those estuarine taxa lacking holdfasts (termed ecads) that often bear little resemblance to the attached species from which they are derived. To better understand the systematics of salt marsh fucoids, we developed a suite of four microsatellite‐containing loci capable of distinguishing between F. vesiculosus L. and F. spiralis L. The genetic markers were used to determine the relationships of the fucoid ecads F. vesiculosus ecad volubilis (Hudson) Turner and a muscoides‐like Fucus in the Brave Boat Harbor (ME, USA) estuary. Ecad populations had 2‐ to 3‐fold higher levels of heterozygosity than attached populations of F. vesiculosus and F. spiralis. Further, ecads were “intermediate” between F. vesiculosus and F. spiralis in their allele frequencies and genotype composition. Our data indicate that populations of muscoides‐like Fucus in Brave Boat Harbor mainly consist of F₁ hybrids between F. vesiculosus and F. spiralis, whereas F. vesiculosus ecad volubilis may arise through backcrosses between F. vesiculosus and other fertile hybrids. Finally, our data support the hypothesis that introgression has occurred between attached populations of F. vesiculosus and F. spiralis.     

A LIGHT AND ELECTRON MICROSCOPIC STUDY OF RHIZOID DEVELOPMENT IN POLYSIPHONIA LANOSA (L.) TANDY1,2

The ontogeny of P. lanosa rhizoids was investigated by light and electron microscopy. A series of distinct, changes was recognized. Prior to penetration of the host, Ascophyllum nodosum, starch reserves were depleted and a large number of dictyosome vesicles accumulated in the cell. These appeared to have been discharged immediately prior to or during host, penetration with a concomitant increase in rhizoid wall thickness. Following initial penetration, the tip became highly convolute and dominated by ER, ribosomes, and mitochondria. Senescence was marked by almost complete, vacuolation of the cytoplasm, degeneration of most organelles, and the loss of color. These ultrastructural changes are correlated wth the habit of P. lanosa.     

Chemical settlement inhibition versus post-settlement mortality as an explanation for differential fouling of two congeneric seaweeds

It has been proposed that seaweed secondary metabolites, e.g. brown algal phlorotannins, may have an ecologically important function as a chemical defence against epiphytes, by acting against colonisation of epiphytic organisms. We tested whether the low epiphytic abundance on the invasive brown seaweed Fucus evanescens, compared to the congeneric F. vesiculosus, is due to a more effective chemical defence against epiphyte colonisation. A field survey of the distribution of the common fouling organism Balanus improvisus (Cirripedia) showed that the abundance was consistently lower on F. evanescens than on F. vesiculosus. However, contrary to expectations, results from experimental studies indicated that F. vesiculosus has a more effective anti-settlement defence than F. evanescens. In settlement experiments with intact fronds of the two Fucus species, both species deterred settlement by barnacle larvae, but settlement was lower on F. vesiculosus both in choice and no-choice experiments. Phlorotannins from F. vesiculosus also had a stronger negative effect on larval settlement and were active at a lower concentration than those from F. evanescens. The results show that Fucus phlorotannins have the potential to inhibit settlement of invertebrate larvae, but that settlement inhibition cannot explain the lower abundance of the barnacle Balanus improvisus on F. evanescens compared to F. vesiculosus. Assessment of barnacle survival in the laboratory and in the field showed that this pattern could instead be attributed to a higher mortality of newly settled barnacles. Observation suggests that the increased mortality was due to detachment of young barnacles from the seaweed surface. This shows that the antifouling mechanism of F. evanescens acts on post-settlement stages of B. improvisus.     

Isolation and cross‐species amplification of microsatellite loci from the fucoid seaweeds Fucus vesiculosus,F. serratus and Ascophyllum nodosum (Heterokontophyta,Fucaceae)

The Fucaceae is a family of brown seaweeds that dominate and frequently co‐occur on North Atlantic rocky shores. We developed nine polymorphic microsatellite markers for the fucoid seaweeds Fucus vesiculosus, F. serratus and Ascophyllum nodosum using a combined, enriched library. Six of these loci were polymorphic in at least two species, showing from two to eight alleles with heterozygosities ranging from 0.41 to 0.85. Loci were also tested on F. spiralis, revealing five polymorphic microsatellite loci in this species.     

GENETIC ISOLATION BETWEEN THREE CLOSELY RELATED TAXA: FUCUS VESICULOSUS,F. SPIRALIS,AND F. CERANOIDES (PHAOPHYCEAE)1

All traditional markers, both phenotypic and phylogenetic, have failed to discriminate between the taxa composing the Fucus vesiculosus L., F. spiralis L., and F. ceranoides L. species complex, particularly in Brittany (France), so we used five microsatellite markers to compare the allelic frequencies of populations of the three taxa in this region. The aim of this study was to assess whether the different populations were grouped according to their geographical location, their habitat (open coast versus estuary), or their a priori taxonomic assignment. Species‐specific alleles were identified at one locus, demonstrating the utility of microsatellite markers for recognizing the three taxa in Brittany. Moreover, our results clearly support the separation of F. vesiculosus, F. spiralis, and F. ceranoides into distinct species, independently of geography. We also identified genetic differentiation between estuarine and coastal populations of F. vesiculosus.