Evidence for distinct polygenic regulation of antibody responses to some unrelated antigens in lines of mice selected for high or low antibody responses to somatic antigen of Salmonella

The effect of the selective breeding of mice for high or low antibody production to complex immunogens is largely nonspecific, since it modifies the responsiveness of high (H) and low (L) lines to many antigens unrelated to the selection antigen. However, the nonspecific effect of the polygenic control operating in these lines is not a general feature. For example, the group of genes in selection IV, carried out for responsiveness to somatic antigen of Salmonella, does not modify the responses to sheep erythrocytes (SE). Despite equivalent responses in H and L mice of selection IV, a large variability was found in individual responses of F₂ interline hybrids, which demonstrates the presence of alleles with high or low effect on responses to SE. A selective breeding (Selection IV-A) was therefore initiated from this F₂ population for responsiveness to SE. A progressive interline divergence occurred during the first seven generations of selection; the interline separation was due to polygenic regulation (about four independent loci from a preliminary estimate).Equivalent responses to the s antigen of Salmonella are observed in the two lines. This constitutes additional evidence for distinct polygenic regulation of responses to SE and to somatic antigen. Moreover, the pattern of responses to several unrelated antigens (nonspecific effect) also differs between Selections IV and IV-A.Abbreviations H high responder lines - L low responder lines - s somatic antigen of Salmonella - f flagellar antigen of Salmonella - R response to selection - S selection differential - F₀ foundation population - h² heritability (realized) - RGG rabbit gamma globulin - CE chicken erythrocyte - HE human erythrocyte - PE pigeon erythrocyte - SE sheep erythrocyte     

Polygenic control of quantitative antibody responsiveness: restrictions of the multispecific effect related to the selection antigen

Among the differences observed between the various high (H) and low (L) antibody responder lines of mice resulting from distinct bidirectional selective breedings, one of the most puzzling is the variation in the multispecific effect, i. e., in the modification of antibody responses to antigens unrelated to those used during the selection. The best examples are the H and L lines of selection IV, selected on the basis of responses to somatic antigen of Salmonella which do not differ in their antibody responses to sheep erythrocytes (SE). However, a wide range of variability is observed in the responses of (H_IV x L_IV)F₂ hybrids to this antigen, and it was therefore hypothesized that distinct groups of genes might regulate antibody responses to SE and the somatic antigen. Indeed, a new selection (IV-A) for anti-SE responsiveness started from these (H_IV x L_IV)F₂ successfully produced a high and a low anti-SE responder line. The results of selection IV-A and the variance analysis of (H_IV-A × L_IV-A)F₂ hybrids are reported. They are roughly similar to those in selection I, also carried out for anti-SE responsiveness. In vivo attempts to identify the major regulatory mechanism which contributes to the interline difference indicate that the efficiency of macrophage accessory function has been modified in selection IV-A, as was observed in selection I, whereas this function did not differ in Hév and Lév lines. Probably in relation to the involvement of macrophage function there is a notable increase of the multispecific effect in selection IV-A when compared with selection IV. The results of selection IV-A demonstrate that responsiveness to heterologous erythrocytes and to somatic antigen of Salmonella are under separate polygenic control operating through distinct regulatory mechanisms. The choice of the selection antigen and immunization procedure is of major importance for defining the gene interaction operating in each selective breeding experiment and the extent of its multispecific effect.Abbreviations used in this paper f. ag. S. flagellar antigen of Salmonella - H high responder line (roman numeral is the selection number) - h₂ heritability - HE human erythrocytes - HoGG horse gamma globulin - L low responder line (roman numeral is the selection number) - PE pigeon erythrocytes - R response to selection - RGG rabbit gamma globulin - S selection differential - s. ag. S. somatic antigen of Salmonella - SE sheep erythrocytes     

Basal immunoglobulin serum concentration and isotype distribution in relation to the polygenic control of antibody responsiveness in mice

Serum Ig concentration and isotype distribution were determined in the high (H) and low (L) responder lines selected for antibody response to complex immunogens. Data were recorded in normal and postimmunization sera from the H and L lines produced by five independent selective breedings (selections I, 11, III, IV, and V). Ig levels were much higher in H than in L mice of all the selections. In four selections this interline difference increased further after immunization with the selection antigens. This is in agreement with the general effect of the polygenic control of antibody responses operating in H and L lines. The Ig isotype profiles of normal sera were different in each line; however, similitudes were noticed between H and L lines in selections I and If. In contrast, in selections III, IV, and V a similar interline difference was observed: the lack of IgG2a isotype in L lines only. After immunization there were minor alterations of the isotype profiles except in the H lines of selections III and IV, in which a clear inverse modification of IgG₁ and IgG_2a proportions occurred. The characteristic pattern of each selection may be partially dependent on isotype-restricted regulatory effects in relation to the immunization procedure used for selective breeding.     

Murine responses to (Tyr-Glu-Ala-Gly)n: II. H-2 and non-H-2 gene effects

Mice of the H-2^b haplotype responded to the sequential polymer poly(Tyr-Glu-Ala-Gly) in the in vitro T-cell proliferative assay, irrespective of whether they were homozygous or heterozygous at the H-2^b locus. The antibody responses of the H-2^b congenic mice to this polymer were variable, with A.BY and BALB.B showing responses better than those of C57BL/6 and C57BL/10 strains. The antibody responses of the F₁ progeny of (responder × nonresponder) strains of mice to this polymer are generally lower than the responder parents. F₁ mice with C57BL/10 background were the poorest responders. Studies with F₂ mice and backcross progenies of selective breeding of high and low antibody responder (C57BL/6 × BALB/c) F₁ to high responder C57BL/6 mice indicated that both non-H-2 genes and H-2 gene dosage effects influenced the magnitude of the humoral antibody responses. Animals having low responder non-H-2 background and only half the dosage of the responder immune response genes has greatly diminished antibody responses.     

Genetically controlled IgM hyporesponsiveness to aK. pneumoniae polysaccharide

Examination of the immune response to aKlebsiella pneumoniae polysaccharide (K47-PS) has revealed that BALB/c mice demonstrate only a very weak primary response to this antigen. The low response does not result from either a peculiar dose response curve for BALB/c mice or from differing optimal antigen concentrations for high and low responder mice. Genetic analysis indicates that this variability of response is explicable assuming two alleles at a single locus; high responsiveness is dominant. Variability of response is probably not linked to theH-2 complex since the low and high responder mice, BALB/c and B10.D2/Sn new line, respectively, share the sameH-2 haplotype (H- 2_d). Tests of F₂s, backcrosses, and appropriate congenics have not shown evidence of linkage to sex, the albinism gene, the genes controlling coat color (agouti, black, brown), or the allotype-constant-region genes. The hyporesponsiveness is apparent only in the primary (IgM) response; hyperimmunization evokes similar antibody titers in high and low responding strains.     

Alteration in lymphocyte recognition repertoire during aging: II. Changes in the expressed T-cell receptor repertoire in aged mice and the persistence of that change after transplantation to a new differentiative environment

Changes in the T-lymphocyte alloreceptor repertoire associated with aging by exploring the frequency of cytotoxic T-lymphocyte precursors (CTLp) available for activation by various major histocompatibility complex (MHC) haplotypes in mice of different ages have been investigated. There was no consistent pattern of change in CTLp frequencies. Thus, for instance, while the frequency of responder C57Bl/6 CTLp for ATH alloantigen decreased with age, the frequency for C3H alloantigen increased. There was no significant change in the overall frequency of splenic CTLp (assessed irrespective of antigen specificity). No evidence was found that CTL produced by activated CTLp of aged mice were less specific in their lytic capacity that CTL produced by CTLp of young mice. However, by assaying responder CTLp cultures at limiting dilution we obtained evidence that the “burst size” (mean lytic capacity per responder well assayed at limiting dilution) was diminished with age of the donor of the CTLp pool. Furthermore, we obtained evidence that the apparent affinity of CTL for their target antigen was consistently decreased when those effector cells were derived from a pool of CTLp of aged mice. All of these changes reflected in mature T cells derived from aged mice were already apparent in the bone marrow stem cell pool of aged individuals and were not due to environmental influences alone, as assessed by the phenotype of T cells derived from young or old bone marrow stem cells transplanted to young or aged recipient mice. A final study has examined evidence for more subtle changes in the T-cell alloreceptor repertoire, reflecting heterogeneity in young or aged mice in the recognition repertoire associated with a given antigenic specificity. By preparing F₁ anti (parent anti-F₁)-suppressor cells directed against CTL from young parental mice (a, b, c), or aged parental mice (x, y, z), we have explored the heterogeneity in the anti-C3H alloreceptor repertoire in individual young or aged C57Bl/6 mice. Suppression by immunized F₁ animals was assessed in tissue culture (inhibition of mixed lymphocyte culture (MLC) responses) or in vivo (inhibition of lethal GvHD induced by inoculation of parental lymphocytes into sublethally irradiated F₁ hybrid mice). Irrespective of the assay system used, the data suggests that the receptor repertoire of aged T lymphocytes uses recognition structures different from those of young individuals, and that there is less individual-to-individual variation in the receptor repertoire of aged mice than in young mice.     

Salmonella typhimurium infection in high and low antibody responder mice: inverse correlation between antibody responsiveness and resistance to infection

Abstract Susceptibility to Salmonella typhimurium infection was compared in H (high Ab responder) and L (low Ab responder) mice obtained by several selective breeding experiments (Selections I, II, III, IV and IV A) [10,19,22]. H mice were always much more susceptible to infection than their L mice counterparts within a continuous LD 50 variation range. In three of the selections (I, II and IV A) the low responsiveness character is known to result mainly from rapid Ag degradation in L mice macrophages. It was hypothesized that resistance to multiplication of intracellular pathogens could be related to an increased catabolic activity towards Ag. This was actually demonstrated, in F₂ segregant hybrids of selection IV A, by the significant inverse correlation between capacity for Ab production and resistance to infection.     

Interaction ofH-2 and nonH-2 linked genes in the regulation of antibody response to a threshold dose of sheep erythrocytes

The antibody response to a threshold dose (¹⁰) of SE was studied in the High responder line (H) and the Low responder line (L) of mice obtained by bidirectional selective breeding for the character quantitative agglutinin response to an optimal dose of SE, and in interline hybrids: F₁, F₁ and both backcrosses. Whereas the interline difference in agglutinin responses at the optimal dose is due to the additive effect of about ten independently segregating loci, one of which isH-2 linked, the responsiveness to the threshold dose is determined by the effect of two loci. The direction of the dominance effect also varies with the antigen dose: high responsiveness is partially dominant at the optimal dose while at the threshold dose nonresponder character is partially dominant. The role of theH-2 linked locus was investigated. It has been demonstrated that on an identical background (equivalent to that of F₁ hybrids) this locus is responsible for 12% of the interline difference at the optimal antigen dose, and for 61% at the threshold antigen dose. For the two antigen doses, the quantitative effect of theH-2 locus is in agreement with the estimate of the number of loci obtained by variance analysis. The intervention of a second gene, non-H-2 linked, in the regulation of responsiveness to 10⁶ SE is demonstrated by appropriate assortative matings. The interaction between the two genes is discussed.     

Salmonella typhimurium infection in high and low antibody responder mice: inverse correlation between antibody responsiveness and resistance to infection

Susceptibility to Salmonella typhimurium infection was compared in H (high Ab responder) and L (low Ab responder) mice obtained by several selective breeding experiments (Selections I, II, III, IV and IV A). H mice were always much more susceptible to infection than their L mice counterparts within a continuous LD 50 variation range. In three of the selections (I, II and IV A) the low responsiveness character is known to result mainly from rapid Ag degradation in L mice macrophages. It was hypothesized that resistance to multiplication of intracellular pathogens could be related to an increased catabolic activity towards Ag. This was actually demonstrated, in F2 segregant hybrids of selection IV A, by the significant inverse correlation between capacity for Ab production and resistance to infection.     

Genetic control of “natural” killer lymphocytes in the mouse

Spleens from normal young mice contain lymphocytes that can kill certain in vitro grown Moloney lymphoma lines in a⁵¹Cr-release cytotoxicity test. A lymphoid cell without detectable T- or B-cell markers was previously shown to be responsible. Killing activity shows a marked dependence on the genotype of the donor mouse. When tested against a YAC line of strain A origin maintained in vitro spleens of A, A.CA, and A.SW mice had low activity, whereas CBA, C3H, C57L, and C57Bl spleens were highly active. In semisyngeneic F₁ crosses with strain A as one parent, reactivity resembled the opposite parental strain. Thus, (A×CBA)F₁, (A×C3H)F₁, (A×C57L)F₁, and (A×C57Bl)F₁ were reactive, whereas A×A.CA showed no significant activity. Analysis of the reactivity in (A×C57Bl)F₁×A backcross mice suggests that multiple genes are involved. Preliminary linkage analysis suggests at least oneH-2 linked factor. Another gene appears to be linked to theB (black) locus.     

Cytotoxic T-cell responses to H-Y:Ir genes and associative antigens map inH-2

The secondary cytotoxic responses to the male-specific antigen (H-Y) in mice showH-2 restriction so that the cytotoxic female cell must share the K- and/or D-end antigen with the male target cells. The association with the K and/or D end varies with differentH-2 haplotypes,e.g., H-2 ^b cytotoxic cells require the H-2D^b antigen(s) on the target cells, while cytotoxic cells fromH-2 ^b/H-2 ^d F₁ mice sensitized toH-2 ^d male cells kill only male targets having H-2K^d antigen(s). This association of H-Y with appropriate K/D antigens seems to be needed also in the induction of the cytotoxic response. Of the independent haplotypes, onlyH-2 ^b strains are capable of making secondary anti-H-Y responses and this trait seems to be dominant,i.e., the F₁ strains with oneH-2 ^b parent are able to produce anti-H-Y cytotoxic cells against both theH-2 ^b parent and the nonresponder parent. The mating of the two nonresponder strains may produce F₁ mice which are responders, thus suggestingIr gene complementation. Mapping data indicates that at least one of these complementary genes is located in theI-C region fork/s complementation.     

Polymorphism ofTcrb andTcrg genes in Biozzi mice: Segregation analysis of a newTcrg haplotype with antibody responsiveness

Tcrb andTcrg gene polymorphism was investigated in high (H) and low (L) responder Biozzi mice from selection I, II, and GS by Southern blot analysis with appropriateV andC probes. No polymorphism of theTcrb haplotype was detected between H and L mice in all selections which were all found to be of the BALB/c type. The H-I and H-II g genotype was of BALB/c and DBA/2 type, respectively. In contrast, a newTcrg haplotype shared by L-I and L-II mice was identified and characterized by C1, 2, 3, C4, V1, 2, 3, V5, and V6 restriction fragment length polymorphisms (RFLPs).Tcrg genotypes were not fixed in the GS selection and two additional new haplotypes were identified in two L-GS mice. An attempt was made to correlate the L-Ig genotype with the low responder status by analyzingg haplotypes among highest and lowest responder (H-1 x L-I)F₂ hybrids immunized with sheep red blood cells (SRBC). No correlation was found in this segregation study, whereas a highly significant one was established with theH-2 haplotype, a locus already known to participate in the genetic control of H-I/L-I difference. The lack of correlation between SRBC response and theTcrg genotype was consistent with the heterogenousg haplotypes found in mice of the GS selection. Together, the present results suggest that H and L mice have the sameTcrab potential repertoire and that T-cell receptor (Tcr) genes cannot be considered as immune response genes in this model. Our results also indicate that the F₂ segregation analysis, given a polymorphic gene, is suitable for an investigation of its immune response functions.     

From cell biology to immunology--a short trip

Immunologic memory and immunoglobulin allotype suppression are discussed as problems in Cell Biology. Memory, the ability of an animal after a first antigenic exposure to give a heightened and faster immune response upon a second exposure to the same antigen, is shown to be a property of bone marrow-derived cell lines. Expression of this memory depends on interaction with thymus-derived cells from either non-immunized or immunized mice. Chronic allotype suppression is described for the first time. It is initiated by in utero or neonatal exposure of (SJL × BALB/c)F₁ mice, allotype a/b, to anti b antibody. Suppression lasts for long periods and continues in irradiated recipients which have received lymphoid cells from suppressed donors. Selection against b allotype producing cell precursors can explain suppression.     

Strain Differences in the Immunogenicity of Aggregated Human IgG and the Adjuvant Action of Lipopolysaccharide on the Low-Responder Strain of Mice

Strain differences in the antibody response to human IgG (HGG) were observed when aggregated HGG was injected intravenously. Lipopolysaccharide (LPS) administered subsequently markedly enhanced the antibody response to HGG in low responder C57BL/6 mice as compared with that in high responder DDD, C3H/He or (C57BL/6 × DDD)F₁ mice. Aggregate-free preparation of HGG at a dose of 0.5 mg induced immunological tolerance in all strains of mice tested. LPS injected subsequently converted tolerogenic, aggregate-free HGG into immunogen in DDD mice but not in C57BL/6 mice. To determine the correlation between adjuvanticity and mitogenicity of LPS, spleen cells from normal mice were cultured in the presence of LPS and ³H-thymidine uptake was measured. Spleen cells of DDD mice incorporated three times as much ³H-thymidine as those of C57BL/6 mice. There seems no strong correlation between both activities of LPS. The data obtained are discussed in terms of strain differences in the macrophage function for processing the antigen.     

High genetic susceptibility to ethanol withdrawal predicts low ethanol consumption

C57BL/6J (B6) inbred mice are well known to drink large amounts of alcohol (ethanol) voluntarily and to have only modest ethanol-induced withdrawal under fixed dose conditions. In contrast, DBA/2J (D2) mice are ``teetotallers' and exhibit severe ethanol withdrawal. Speculation that an inverse genetic relationship existed between these two traits was substantiated by meta-analysis of existing data collected in multiple genetic models, including large panels of standard and recombinant inbred strains, their crosses, and selectively bred mouse lines. Despite methodological differences among laboratories in measurement of both preference drinking and withdrawal, a nearly universal finding was that genotypes consuming large amounts of 10% ethanol (calculated as g/kg/day) during two-bottle choice preference drinking were genetically predisposed to low withdrawal scores in independent studies after either acute or chronic ethanol treatment. Conversely, low-drinking genotypes had higher withdrawal severity scores. The genetic relationship appears to be strongest in populations derived from B6 and D2, where data from more genotypes (BXD RIs, B6D2F₂s, BXD RI F₁s, and B6D2F₂-derived selectively bred lines) were available for analysis. Gene mapping studies in these populations identified four chromosome regions [on Chromosomes (Chrs) 1, 2, 4, and 15] where genes might potentially influence both traits. Among genotypes with greater genetic diversity (for example, a panel of standard inbred strains or selectively bred lines), the relationship was less pronounced. Thus, reduced susceptibility to the development of high alcohol use may be supported by increased genetic susceptibility to ethanol withdrawal symptoms. Received: 15 September 1998 / Accepted: 8 October 1998     

Polygenic control of the immune response to F antigen

The ability to produce an autoimmune response to F antigen in mice is underH-2-linked and non-H- 2-linkedIr-gene control. There is an absolute requirement for ak allele atH-2K orI-A in order to produce anti-F antibodies. Low and high responsiveness is controlled by a non-H-2-linkedIr gene which behaves in a similar fashion toIr-3, in that as the dose of F-antigen is lowered, low responders behave as high responders and vice versa. This conversion from low to high responsiveness also occurs within a month after ATX.— Most F₁ hybrids derived from (responder x nonresponder) parents bearing identical F-types behave as dominant nonresponders. As a result of ATX, such F₁ mice convert to high responders. This conversion occurs if the animals are not immunized before day 90. If they receive F antigen prior to that time, they remain nonresponders for 7–9 months. One F₁ combination — AKD2 — behaves as a dominant high responder. Genetic analysis showed that in the presence of ak allele atH-2K orI-A, a non-H-2-linkedIr gene inherited from the AKR mice determined dominant responsivenss. No manipulation of the immune response or combination of genes converted nonresponders lacking ak allele into responders. Such complex genetic control suggests regulation by a number of independently segregating loci whose function it is to limit the autoimmune response to F antigen.     

The inheritance of a defective lipopolysaccharide response locus in C3H/HeJ mice

F₁ hybrid mice from crosses between the lipopolysaccharide (LPS) nonresponder strain C3H/HeJ and a variety of LPS responder strains show quantitative or codominant inheritance of mitogenic responsiveness to LPS. Backcross segregation ratios indicate that a defect at a single locus is responsible for the lack of responsiveness in C3H/HeJ mice. Autoradiographic studies show that the number of LPS-responsive cells in F₁ cultures is approximately half the number of responsive cells in parent cultures. Kinetic patterns of mitogenic responsiveness to LPS differ in F₁ hybrid and parent cultures. The kinetic patterns of responsiveness vary with the cell concentrations of the culture and appear to correlate with the number of LPS-responsive cells in F₁ and parent cultures.     

Genetic control of the immune response to (T,G)-A--L in C3H in equilibrium C57 tetraparental mice

When 15 C3H ? C57 tetraparental (allophenic) mice were analyzed for coat color, hemoglobin, and immunoglobulin allotype, all but two were shown to be chimeric. These 15 tetraparental mice were immunized with the synthetic polypeptide (T,G)-A--L, and the origin of the (T,G)-A--L-specific antibody produced was determined by using genetic markers (allotypes) on the immunoglobulin heavy chain constant region. Five tetraparental mice were high responders to (T,G)-A--L and had significant amounts of a (low responder) allotype antibody in their total serum. Three of these mice had significant amounts of anti-(T,G)-A--L antibody of the a (low responder) allotype. The antigen binding capacities of the a allotype fractions of these three were 4–5 times higher than the antigen binding capacities of immunized C3H (low responder) control mice. These results are compatible with the hypothesis that the inability of low-responder mice to produce significant amounts of anti-(T,G)-A--L antibody is a function of Ir-1A gene expression at the level of T cells.     

Divergent selection in a maize population for germination at low temperature in controlled environment: study of the direct response, of the trait inheritance and of correlated responses in the field

Improving cold tolerance in maize (Zea mays L.) is an important breeding objective, allowing early sowings which result in many agronomic advantages. Using as source the F₂ population of B73 × IABO78 single cross, we previously conducted four cycles of divergent recurrent selection for high (H) and low (L) cold tolerance level, evaluated as the difference (DG) between germination at 9.5 °C and at 25 °C in the germinator. Then, we pursued the divergent selection in inbreeding from S₁ to S₄. This research was conducted to study (1) the direct response to selection (by testing ten S₄ L and ten S₄ H lines), (2) the trait inheritance (in a complete diallel scheme involving four L and four H lines), (3) the associated responses for cold tolerance in the field (at early and delayed sowings) and (4) the responses for other traits, by testing the ten L and the ten H lines at usual sowing. Selection was effective, leading to appreciable and symmetric responses for DG. Variation among crosses was mainly due to additive effects and the ability to predict hybrid DG based on parental lines DG was appreciable. Associated responses for cold tolerance traits in the field were noticeable, though the relationship between DG and these traits was not outstanding. High tolerance was also associated with early flowering, short plants, less leaves, low kernel moisture, red and thin cob, and flint kernels. These divergently selected lines can represent valuable materials for undertaking basic studies and breeding works concerning cold tolerance.     

A hierarchy of responsiveness and the production of nonprecipitating antibodies to F antigen

The immune response to F antigen by a variety of inbred strains and F₁ hybrids has been studied. All of the mice responding to appropriate preparations of F antigen share ak allele atH-2K orI-A. In F₁ hybrids, however, this permissive gene is sometimes expressed as dominant responsiveness, while in other combinations as dominant nonresponsiveness. There appears to be a hierarchy of responsiveness among the responder strains tested. Finally, some strains produce nonprecipitating antibodies against F antigen which may represent a genetically controlled restriction of the response to this antigen.