New hybrids between Agropyron and wheat

Summary Intergeneric hybrids of Triticum aestivum (2n=42,AABBDD) with Agropyron ciliare (2n= 28,SSYY), A. trachycaulum (2n=28,SSHH), A. yezoense (2n=28,SSYY) and A. scirpeum (2n=28) are reported for the first time. F₁ hybrids of T. aestivum were also produced with A. intermedium (2n=42,E₁E₁E₂E₂Z₁Z₁) and A. junceum (2n=14,JuJu). All wheat-Agropyron hybrids were obtained by embryo rescue technique. Cultivars and reciprocal crosses differed for seed set, seed development and F₁ plant production. The F₁ hybrids were sterile. Attempts to obtain amphiploids were unsuccessful. However, backcross derivatives were obtained with wheat as the recurrent parent.The level of chromosome pairing in A. trachycaulum x wheat, A. yezoense x wheat and wheat x A. junceum hybrids provided no evidence of homologous or homoeologous pairing. Mean pairing frequencies in A. ciliare x wheat, wheat x A. scirpeum and wheat x A. intermedium hybrids indicated homoeologous or autosyndetic pairing. Ph gene was more effective in regulating homoeologous pairing in A. yezoense x wheat hybrids than in A. ciliare x wheat hybrid. Chromosome pairing data of BC₁ derivatives indicated that either some of the wheat chromosomes were eliminated or Agropyron chromosomes caused reduced pairing of wheat homologues.Contribution No. 82-653-J, Department of Plant Pathology, Kansas State Agricultural Experiment Station, Manhattan, Kan, USA     

Production,morphology, and cytogenetic analysis of Elymus caninus (Agropyron caninum) x Triticum aestivum F1 hybrids and backcross-1 derivatives

Summary Intergeneric hybrids were produced between common wheat, Triticum aestivum (2n=6x=42, AABBDD) and wheatgrass, Etymus caninus (Agropyron caninum) (2n=4x=28, SSHH) — the first successful report of this cross. Reciprocal crosses and genotypes differed for percent seed set, seed development and F₁ hybrid plant production. With E. caninus as the pollen parent, there was no hybrid seed set. In the reciprocal cross, seed set was 23.1–25.4% depending upon wheat genotype used. Hybrid plants were produced only by rescuing embryos 12–13 days post pollination with cv Chinese Spring as the wheat parent. Kinetin in the medium facilitated embryo germination but inhibited root development and seedling growth. The hybrids were vigorous, self sterile, and intermediate between parents. These had expected chromosome number (2n=5x=35, ABDSH), very little chromosome pairing (0.51 II, 0.04 III) and some secondary associations. The hybrids were successfully backcrossed with wheat. Chromosome number in the BC₁ derivatives varied 54–58 with 56 as the modal class. The BC₁ derivatives showed unusually high number of rod bivalents or reduced pairing of wheat homologues. These were sterile and BC₂ seed was produced using wheat pollen.     

Synthesis and cytological characterization of trigeneric hybrids involving durum wheat,Thinopyrum bessarabicum,and Lophopyrum elongatum

Summary In an attempt to transfer genes for salt tolerance and other desirable traits from the diploid wheatgrasses, Thinopyrum bessarabicum (2n=2x=14; JJ genome) and Lophopyrum elongatum (2n=2x=14; EE genome), into durum wheat cv Langdon (2n=4x=28; AABB genomes), trigeneric hybrids with the genomic constitution ABJE were synthesized and cytologically characterized. C-banding analysis of somatic chromosomes of the A, B, J, and E genomes in the same cellular environment revealed distinct banding patterns; each of the 28 chromosomes could be identified. They differed in the total amount of constitutive heterochromatin. Total surface area and C-banded area of each chromosome were calculated. The B genome was the largest in size, followed by the J, A, and E genomes, and its chromosomes were also the most heavily banded. Only 25.8% of the total chromosome complement in 10 ABJE hybrids showed association, with mean arm-pairing frequency (c) values from 0.123 to 0.180 and chiasma frequencies from 3.36 to 5.02 per cell. The overall mean pairing was 0.004 ring IV + 0.046 chain IV + 0.236 III + 0.21 ring II + 2.95 rod II + 20.771. This is total pairing between chromosomes of different genomes, possibly between A and B, A and J, A and E, B and J, B and E, and J and E, in the presence of apparently functional pairing regulator Ph1. Because chromosome pairing in the presence of Ph1 seldom occurs between A and B, or between J and E, it was inferred that pairing between the wheat chromosomes and alien chromosomes occurred. The trigeneric hybrids with two genomes of wheat and one each of Thinopyrum and Lophopyrum should be useful in the production of cytogenetic stocks to facilitate the transfer of alien genes into wheat.     

THE GENOME CONSTITUTION AND PHYLOGENY OF ELYMUS AMBIGUUS

Two Elymus ambiguus Vasey & Scribn. collections from Utah and Idaho were 2n = 28, and the species behaved meiotically as an allotetraploid. The E. ambiguus plants were highly self-sterile, and they hybridized readily with Asian E. junceus Fisch. (2n = 14), E. karataviensis Roshev. (2n = 28), E. multicaulis Kar. & Kir. (2n = 28), and North American E. innovatus Beal (2n = 28). Chromosome pairing at metaphase-I in the E. ambiguus X E. junceus triploid hybrids indicated that one E. ambiguus genome was closely homologous with the E. junceus genome. Chromosome pairing in the tetraploid hybrids indicated that both E. ambiguus genomes were more or less homologous with the genomes of E. karataviensis, E. multicaulis, and E. innovatus. The basic genome formula of E. ambiguus may be written as JJXX, where J is the E. junceus genome and X is a genome of unknown origin. Chromosome pairing in the hybrids indicated that E. ambiguus is more closely related to North American E. innovatus than to the Asian species. The E. ambiguus X E. innovatus hybrids were the only hybrids that set seed. Gene flow between E. ambiguus and E. innovatus is biologically possible, but geographic separation of the species precludes natural introgression.     

A novel intergeneric hybrid in the Triticeae: Triticum aestivum x Psathyrost achys juncea

Summary Two hybrid embryos of intergeneric origin between Triticum aestivum cv Fukuho (2n=6x=42, AABBDD) and Psathyrostachys juncea (2n=2x=14, NN) were successfully rescued. One hybrid plant had the expected chromosome number of 28 (ABDN), whereas the second plant had 35 chromosomes. The average meiotic chromosome pairing in the 35-chromosome hybrid was 21.87 univalents + 6.38 bivalents + 0.11 trivalents + 0.009 quadrivalents, which indicates that two copies of the N genome were present. Chromosome pairing in the 28-chromosome hybrid was low (1.35 bivalents), and pointed out the lack of homology between the wheat genomes and the P. juncea genome. These new hybrids showed some necrosis and chlorosis, which caused severe floral abortion in the plant that had 35 chromosomes. These problems became gradually less severe after 18 months.Contrib. no. 372     

Production,morphology, and cytogenetics of Triticum aestivum (L.) Thell × Elymus scabrus (R. Br.) Love intergeneric hybrids obtained by in ovulo embryo culture

Summary Intergeneric hybrids were produced between common wheat, Triticum aestivum (2n=6x=42, AABBDD), and an apomictic Triticeae species, Elymus scabrus (syn. Agropyron scabrum) (2n=6x=42, HHSSSS), the first successful report of this cross. Nine tiny, underdeveloped, and structureless embryos were obtained in vitro only by in ovulo embryo culture at 4 days after pollination, which gave rise to five mature hybrid plants. All the hybrid plants were vigorous and possessed a phenotype intermediate to the two parents. There were 2n=6x=42 (ABDHSS) somatic chromosomes in the hybrids. There was little or no homology between the parental genomes, as shown by an overall meiotic chromosome association of 32.83 I + 4.08 rod II + 0.21 ring II + 0.18 III + 0.02 IV. The hybrids were completely sterile and so far backcrosses to wheat parent have not been successful. Alternate approaches to induce gene transfer(s) from E. scabrus to wheat are being attempted.Agriculture Canada Contribution No. 398.     

Chromosome pairing in wheat-rye ABDR hybrids depends on the microsporogenesis pattern

The character of chromosome pairing in meiocytes was studied in F1 wheat-rye Triticum aestivum L. x Secale cereale L. (ABDR, 4x = 28) hybrids with three types of chromosome behavior: reductional, equational, and equational + reductional. A high variation of the frequencies of bivalents and ring univalents was observed in meiocytes with the reductional or equational + reductional type of chromosome behavior. The type of chromosome division was found to affect the bivalent and ring univalent frequencies. Chromosome pairing occurred in 10.28% of meiocytes with the reductional chromosome behavior, 0.93% of meiocytes with the equational chromosome behavior, and 10.81% of meiocytes with the equational + reductional chromosome behavior. On average, 0.13 bivalents per cell formed in meiocytes of the hybrid population. C-banding and genomic in situ hybridization (GISH) showed that both rye and wheat chromosomes produced ring univalents. The role of the Ph genes in regulating the bivalent formation in meiocytes with different types of chromosome behavior is discussed.     

Hybridization between Triticum aestivum L. and Agropyron michnoi Roshev.

Summary Intergeneric hybrids between Triticum aestivum cv Chinese Spring (2n=6x=42, AABBDD) and Agropyron michnoi Roshev. (2n=4x=28, PPPP) were obtained by embryo culture. Their spike characteristics were similar to those of common wheat but, unlike their parents, they were long-awned. The average meiotic chromosome pairing at MI of F₁ hybrids was: 6.39 I +3.75 rodII+8.64 ringII+0.81 III+0.30 IV+0.04 V, the bivalent and multivalent formation of which was much higher than expected from the genomic formulae. It is especially worthwhile to note that the F₁ hybrids were self-fertile, self set being 0.15%, and seeds were easily obtained from the backcross of f₁ plants with hexaploid and tetraploid wheats; here the seed set was more than 20.0%. The polyploid taxa and the position of A. Michnoi in Agropyron are discussed.     

Intergeneric hybrids between Triticum crassum and Hordeum vulgare

Summary Intergeneric hybrids between Triticum crassum (2n=6x=42) and Hordeum vulgare cv. Bomi were obtained at a frequency of 15% of pollinated florets. Meiotic chromosome pairing in the hybrids was not different from that observed in a polyhaploid of T. crassum indicating negligible pairing between chromosomes of the two species and secondly that the genome of H. vulgare had no effect on intergenomic pairing in T. crassum.Contribution No. 646 Ottawa Research Station     

The cytogenetic structure of Vicia sativa aggregate

Summary The cytogenetic structure of Vicia sativa aneuploid series was assessed by examination of the chromosome pairing in hybrids between types having 2n = 10, 2n = 12 and 2n = 14. Two different karyotypes were distinguished at both the 2n = 10 and 2n = 12 levels. Chromosome pairing in hybrids involved two 2n = 10 karyotypes, indicating that the parental lines differed by two translocations. A similar indication was obtained for the two 2n = 12 karyotypes employed. The meiotic behavior of the 2n = 10 x 2n = 12 hybrids indicated that the parental lines differed by up to three translocations, some of which involved unequal chromosome segments. It has been proposed that the 2n = 10 types were developed from the 2n = 12 via centric or tandem fusion and additional rearrangements further accelerated chromosome repatterning at the two 2n levels. Hybrids between the 2n = 14 V. sativa and the former 2n types had very irregular chromosome pairing and were highly sterile. It has been proposed that the 2n = 14 type is a relatively new evolvement in V. sativa because of its shorter complement in comparison with the other karyotypes. The subterraneous pods of the 2n = 14 type, a characteristic which is absent in other V. sativa types and in the entire genus Vicia, also supports an advanced, phylogenetic position. The 2n = 14 type probably arose from n = 7 gametes produced by the 2n= 12 x 2n = 10 hybrid and the establishment of the row 2n = 14 type was acquired through conspicuous chromosome deletions. In spite of its remarkable chromosomal variation, V. sativa can still be considered, for breeding purposes, as being one gene pool. The wild forms of V. sativa can thus be valuable sources for improving the cultivated vetch.     

Morphological, yield, cytological and molecular characterization of a bread wheat X tritordeum F1 hybrid

The morphological, yield, cytological and molecular characteristics of bread wheat X tritordeum F₁ hybrids (2n =6x = 42; AABBDH^ch) and their parents were analysed. Morphologically, these hybrids resembled the wheat parent. They were slightly bigger than both parents, had more spikelets per spike, and tillered more profusely. The hybrids are self-fertile but a reduction of average values of yield parameters was observed. For the cytological approach we used a double-target fluorescencein situ hybridization performed with total genomic DNA fromHordeum chilense L. and the ribosomal sequence pTa71. This technique allowed us to confirm the hybrid nature and to analyse chromosome pairing in this material. Our results showed that the expected complete homologous pairing (14 bivalents plus 14 univalents) was only observed in 9.59% of the pollen mother cells (PMCs) analysed. Some PMCs presented autosyndetic pairing of Hch and A, B or D chromosomes. The average number of univalents was higher in the wheat genome (6.8) than in the Hch genome (5.4). The maximum number of univalents per PMC was 20. We only observed wheat multivalents (one per PMC) but the frequency of trivalents (0.08) was higher than that of quadrivalents (0.058). We amplified 50 RAPD bands polymorphic between the F₁ hybrid and one of its parents, and 31 ISSR polymorphic bands. Both sets of markers proved to be reliable for DNA fingerprinting. The complementary use of morphological and yield analysis, molecular cytogenetic techniques and molecular markers allowed a more accurate evaluation and characterization of the hybrids analysed here.     

Analysis of meiosis in triticale (XTriticosecale Wittmack) X rye (Secale cereale L.) F1 hybrids at three ploidy levels

Summary Triticales (XTriticosecale Wittmack) at three ploidy levels (8x, 6x, 4x, x=7) were crossed with diploid rye (Secale cereale L.) to produce a solitary hypopentaploid hybrid (2n=32), and a number of tetraploid (2n=4x=28) and triploid (2n=3x=21) hybrids. The hybrids exhibited a morphology which was intermediate between the parents. The number of bivalents ranged from 1–7 (4.65 per cell) in hypopentaploid, from 2–12 (7.13 per cell) in tetraploid and from 4–9 (6.84 per cell) in triploid hybrids. In 4x and 3x hybrids, trivalents and quadrivalents were also observed at low frequencies (range 0–1; mean 0.01–0.03 per cell). Chiasmata frequency was highest in triploid hybrids (12.44 per cell), lowest in hypopentaploid (5.37 per cell) and intermediate in tetraploids (10.54 per cell). More than 7¹¹ were found in 39.7% pollen mother cells (PMC's) in the 4x hybrids and in 5.0% PMCs in 3x hybrids. It is concluded that an increase in the relative proportion of wheat chromosomes in the hybrids had a slight suppression effect on homologous as well as homoeologous pairing of rye chromosomes. Contrary to this, the relative increase in rye complement promoted homoeologous pairing between wheat chromosomes. In triploid hybrids, the chiasmata frequency as well as the c value were the highest, suggesting that in tetraploid hybrids rye chromosomes had a reduced pairing (low frequency of ring bivalents).     

Chromosome pairing in meiosis of partially fertile wheat/rye hybrids

The normal course of meiosis depends on regular pairing of homologous chromosomes. In intergeneric hybrids, including those of wheat, there is no chromosome pairing because there are no homologs. In F₁ wheat/rye hybrids, pairing is largely prevented by the pairing homoeologous1 (Ph1) gene. In its presence, there are only rare instances of pairing; most chromosomes are univalent, and their orientation at metaphase I initiates different pathways of the meiotic cycle. The meiotic-like pathway includes a combination of the reductional and the equational + reductional steps at AI followed by the second division. The resulting gametes are mostly non-functional. The mitotic-like pathway involves equational division of univalents at AI and the absence of the second division. Any fertility of wheat/rye hybrids depends on the production of unreduced gametes arising from meiotic restitution (mitotic-like division). We examined the meiotic pairing in wheat/rye hybrids created from wheat lines with single rye chromosome substitutions and Ph1 present. This guaranteed F₁ meiosis with one pair of rye homologs. All hybrids formed bivalents, but proportions of meiocytes with bivalents varied. In the meiocytes where bivalents were present, there was a higher tendency for the meiotic-like pathway, while in meiocytes where bivalent pairing failed, the tendency was stronger for the mitotic-like pathway. Among the equationally dividing cells, we observed more than 90 % of meiocytes without bivalents, where rye homologs did not form bivalents, too. The data indicate a potential application of wheat/rye lines in producing genetic stocks of amphidiploids with designated genomic constitutions.     

Intergeneric hybridization and C-banding patterns inHordelymus (Triticeae,Poaceae)

Crosses ofHordelymus europaeus (2n = 4x = 28) with four genera in theTriticeae were attempted. Adult hybrids were obtained in combinations withHordeum bogdanii (2x),Hordeum depressum (4x), andSecale cereale (2x). The meiotic pairing was very low in the hybrids withH. bogdanii andSecale cereale (0.12 and 0.30 chiasmata/cell, respectively), whereas high pairing (9.90 chiasmata/cell) was found in hybrids withH. depressum due to autosyndetic pairing ofH. depressum chromosomes. The chromosome complement ofHordelymus europaeus comprised 16 metacentrics, 8 submetacentrics, and 4 SAT-chromosomes. The Giemsa C-banding patterns of the chromosomes were characterized by small to minute bands at no preferential positions. It is hypothesized thatHordelymus europaeus may genomically be closest related toTaeniatherum andPsathyrostachys spp.     

Cytology of F1 hybrids and chromosome number of F2 and BC1 progeny of the cross Bromus riparius x B. inermis

Summary Hybrids between B. inermis Leyss (2n=8x=56) and B. riparius Rehm. (2n=10x=70) were easily made. The F₁ hybrids had a fertility of 20%–50% under open pollination and backcrossing to B. inermis. Chromosome pairing in B. riparius was predominantly as bivalents (29.04–33.85 per cell for plant means). Bivalents also predominated in the F₁ hybrid (2n=9x=63) and there was a high level of pairing with no reduction in chiasma frequency. It was impossible to estimate the frequency of auto-versus allosyndetic pairing. Chromosome pairing in a hybrid between B. arvensis (2n=2x=14) and B. riparius confirmed that the B. riparius complement is capable of complete autosyndetic pairing. Chromosome numbers in the F₂ progeny ranged from 2n=56 to 72 but they were skewed towards 2n=63 to 70. Backcrosses ranged from 2n=56 to 63, as expected, with the distribution skewed towards 2n=56. Selection towards the 2n=56 level would be difficult in the F₂. Empirical observation suggested that cytoplasm had a major influence on morphology in the backcrosses. Additional studies are required to determine the best breeding scheme to introgress germ plasm between B. inermis and B. riparius.     

The effect of Secale cereale L. heterochromatin on wheat chromosome pairing

Metaphase-I chromosome association in PMCs of five F₁ hybrids 6x-triticale x T. turgidum (2n=5x=35 and genomes AABBR), and 13 plants from their backross or self offspring is reported. In wheat 18 chromosome arms and in rye 14 arms were recognized after C-banding and individually studied. Plants of backcross and F₂ showed variability for number and type of rye chromosomes, having in common the 28 durum wheat chromosomes (AABB). By testing meiotic association in plants with different rye chromosome constitutions, significant negative correlations were found. A clear negative effect of rye heterochromatin on pairing in wheat chromosomes is observed, the influence being more pronounced for large arms than for the short ones.     

Determination of the frequency of wheat-rye chromosome pairing in wheat x rye hybrids with and without chromosome 5B

Genomic in-situ hybridization (GISH) was used to determine the amount of wheat-rye chromosome pairing in wheat (Triticum aestivum) x rye (Secale cereale) hybrids having chromosome 5B present, absent, or replaced by an extra dose of chromosome 5D. The levels of overall chromosome pairing were similar to those reported earlier but the levels of wheat-rye pairing were higher than earlier determinations using C-banding. Significant differences in chromosome pairing were found between the three genotypes studied. Both of the chromosome-5B-deficient hybrid genotypes showed much higher pairing than the euploid wheat hybrid. However, the 5B-deficient hybrid carrying an extra chromosome 5D had significantly less wheat-rye pairing than the simple 5B-deficient genotype, indicating the presence of a suppressing factor on chromosome 5D. Non-homologous/non-homoeologous chromosome pairing was observed in all three hybrid genotypes. The value of GISH for assessing the level of wheat-alien chromosome pairing in wheat/alien hybrids and the effectiveness of wheat genotypes that affect homoeologous chromosome pairing is demonstrated.     

Synthesis and cytological characterization of trigeneric hybrids of durum wheat with and without Ph1.

Wild grasses in the tribe Triticeae, some in the primary or secondary gene pool of wheat, are excellent reservoirs of genes for superior agronomic traits, including resistance to various diseases. Thus, the diploid wheatgrasses Thinopyrum bessarabicum (Savul. and Rayss) A. Love (2n = 2x = 14; JJ genome) and Lophopyrum elongatum (Host) A. Love (2n = 2x = 14; EE genome) are important sources of genes for disease resistance, e.g., Fusarium head blight resistance that may be transferred to wheat. By crossing fertile amphidiploids (2n = 4x = 28; JJEE) developed from F1 hybrids of the 2 diploid species with appropriate genetic stocks of durum wheat, we synthesized trigeneric hybrids (2n = 4x = 28; ABJE) incorporating both the J and E genomes of the grass species with the durum genomes A and B. Trigeneric hybrids with and without the homoeologous-pairing suppressor gene, Ph1, were produced. In the absence of Ph1, the chances of genetic recombination between chromosomes of the 2 useful grass genomes (JE) and those of the durum genomes (AB) would be enhanced. Meiotic chromosome pairing was studied using both conventional staining and fluorescent genomic in situ hybridization (fl-GISH). As expected, the Ph1-intergeneric hybrids showed low chromosome pairing (23.86% of the complement), whereas the trigenerics with ph1b (49.49%) and those with their chromosome 5B replaced by 5D (49.09%) showed much higher pairing. The absence of Ph1 allowed pairing and, hence, genetic recombination between homoeologous chromosomes. Fl-GISH analysis afforded an excellent tool for studying the specificity of chromosome pairing: wheat with grass, wheat with wheat, or grass with grass. In the trigeneric hybrids that lacked chromosome 5B, and hence lacked the Ph1 gene, the wheat-grass pairing was elevated, i.e., 2.6 chiasmata per cell, a welcome feature from the breeding standpoint. Using Langdon 5D(5B) disomic substitution for making trigeneric hybrids should promote homoeologous pairing between durum and grass chromosomes and hence accelerate alien gene transfer into the durum genomes.     

Spontaneous hybridization between a male-sterile oilseed rape and two weeds

Spontaneous interspecific hybrids were produced under natural conditions (pollination by wind and bees) between a male-sterile cybrid Brassica napus (AACC, 2n = 38) and two weeds Brassica adpressa (AdAd, 2n = 14) and Raphanus raphanistrum (RrRr, 2n = 18). After characterization by chromosome counts and isozyme analyses, we observed 512 and 3 734 inter-specific seeds per m² for the B. napus-B. adpressa and B. napus-R. raphanistrum trials respectively. Most of the hybrids studied had the expected triploid structure (ACX). In order to quantify the frequency of allosyndesis between the genomes involved in the hybrids, their meiotic behavior was compared to a haploid of B. napus (AC). For the B. napus-B. adpressa hybrids, we concluded that probably no allosyndesis occurred between the two parental genomes, and that genetic factors regulating homoeologous chromosome pairing were carried by the B. adpressa genome. For the B. napus-R. raphanistrum hybrids, high chromosome pairing and the presence of multivalents (in 9.16% of the pollen mother cells) indicate that recombination is possible between chromosomes of different genomes. Pollen fertility of the hybrids ranged from 0 to 30%. Blackleg inoculation tests were performed on the three parental species and on the interspecific hybrids. BC₁ production with the weeds and with rapeseed was attempted. Results are discussed in regard to the risk assessment of transgenic rapeseed cultivation, F₁ hybrid rapeseed variety production, and rapeseed improvement.     

Meiotic pairing in hybrids between tetraploid Triticale and related species: new elements concerning the chromosome constitution of tetraploid Triticale

Summary Two F5 strains of tetraploid triticale (2n= 4x=28), obtained from 6x triticaleX2 rye progenies, were crossed with diploid and tetraploid rye, some durum and bread wheats, and various 8x and 6x triticale lines. Meiosis in the different hybrid combinations was studied. The results showed that the haploid complement of these triticales consists of seven chromosomes from rye and seven chromosomes from wheat. High frequencies of PMCs showing trivalents were observed in hybrids involving the reference genotypes of wheat and triticale. These findings proved that several chromosomes from the wheat component have chromosome segments coming from two parental wheat chromosomes. The origin of these heterogeneous chromosomes probably lies in homoeologous pairing occurring at meiosis in the 6x triticaleX2x rye hybrids from which 4x triticale lines were isolated. A comparison among different hybrids combinations indicated that the involvement of D-genome chromosomes in homoeologous pairing is quite limited. In contrast, meiotic patterns in 4x triticale X 2x rye hybrids showed a quite high pairing frequency between some R chromosomes and their A and B homoeologues.