Phylogenetic comparative analysis of microsporogenesis in angiosperms with a focus on monocots

This paper presents the first broad overview of three main features of microsporogenesis (male meiosis) in angiosperms: cytokinesis (cell division), intersporal wall formation, and tetrad form. A phylogenetic comparative approach was used to test for correlated evolution among these characters and to make hypotheses about evolutionary trends in microsporogenesis. The link between features of microsporogenesis and pollen aperture type was examined. We show that the pathway associated with successive cytokinesis (cytoplasm is partitioned after each meiotic division) is restricted to wall formation mediated by centrifugally developing cell plates, and tetragonal (or decussate, T-shaped, linear) tetrads. Conversely, much more flexibility is observed when cytokinesis is simultaneous (two meiotic divisions completed before cytoplasmic partitioning). We suggest that the ancestral type of microsporogenesis for angiosperms, and perhaps for all seed plants, associated simultaneous cytokinesis with centripetal wall formation, resulting in a large diversity in tetrad forms, ranging from regular tetrahedral to tetragonal tetrads, including rhomboidal tetrads. From this ancestral pathway, switches toward successive cytokinesis occurred among basal angiosperms and monocots, generally associated with a switch toward centrifugal intersporal wall formation, whereas eudicots evolved toward an almost exclusive production of regular tetrahedral tetrads. No straightforward link is found between the type of microsporogenesis and pollen aperture type.     

Variations in the microsporogenesis of monosulcate palm pollen

Pollen morphology has been extensively studied in the Arecaceae, and pollen aperture organization is usually distal monosulcate, as in many monocot families. Much is known about the influence of microsporogenesis on aperture configuration, but the key processes during microsporogenesis responsible for aperture type, number and arrangement are still poorly understood. In order to clarify the developmental sequence underlying aperture type and organization in palm monosulcate pollen, a study of the characteristics of male postmeiotic development was carried out in representative species of four genera of subfamily Coryphoideae, and four genera of subfamily Arecoideae. We found evidence for the occurrence of successive cytokinesis in addition to simultaneous cytokinesis in three Coryphoideae species. Tetrad shape was highly diverse within all species. Our results reveal an unexpected diversity in microsporogenesis from which it may be possible to gain further insight into pollen evolution within the family.  © 2006 The Linnean Society of London, Botanical Journal of the Linnean Society , 2006, 151 , 93–102.     

Constraints and selection: insights from microsporogenesis in Asparagales

Developmental constraints have been proposed to interfere with natural selection in limiting the available set of potential adaptations. Whereas this concept has long been debated on theoretical grounds, it has been investigated empirically only in a few studies. In this article, we evaluate the importance of developmental constraints during microsporogenesis (male meiosis in plants), with an emphasis on phylogenetic patterns in Asparagales. Different developmental constraints were tested by character reshuffling or by simulated distributions. Among the different characteristics of microsporogenesis, only cell wall formation appeared as constrained. We show that constraints may also result from biases in the correlated occurrence of developmental steps (e.g., lack of successive cytokinesis when wall formation is centripetal). We document such biases and their potential outcomes, notably the establishment of intermediate stages, which allow development to bypass such constraints. These insights are discussed with regard to potential selection on pollen morphology.     

Links between early pollen development and aperture pattern in monocots

Summary. Although the pollen grains produced in monocots are predominantly monosulcate (or monoporate), other aperture types are also found within this taxonomic group, such as the trichotomosulcate, inaperturate, zonaperturate, di-, or triaperturate types. The aperture pattern is determined during the young-tetrad stage of pollen development and it is known that some features of microsporogenesis can constrain the aperture type. For example, trichotomosulcate pollen is always associated with simultaneous cytokinesis, a condition considered as derived in the monocots. Our observations of the microsporogenesis pathway in a range of monocot species show that this pathway is surprisingly variable. Our results, however preliminary, reveal that variation in microsporogenesis concerns not only cytokinesis but also callose deposition among the microspores and shape of the tetrads. The role played by these features in aperture pattern determination is discussed. Correspondence and reprints: Laboratoire Ecologie, Systématique et Evolution, Université Paris-Sud, 91405 Orsay Cedex, France.     

Release of developmental constraints on tetrad shape is confirmed in inaperturate pollen of Potamogeton

Background and Aims

Microsporogenesis in monocots is often characterized by successive cytokinesis with centrifugal cell plate formation. Pollen grains in monocots are predominantly monosulcate, but variation occurs, including the lack of apertures. The aperture pattern can be determined by microsporogenesis features such as the tetrad shape and the last sites of callose deposition among the microspores. Potamogeton belongs to the early divergent Potamogetonaceae and possesses inaperturate pollen, a type of pollen for which it has been suggested that there is a release of the constraint on tetrad shape. This study aimed to investigate the microsporogenesis and the ultrastructure of pollen wall in species of Potamogeton in order to better understand the relationship between microsporogenesis features and the inaperturate condition.

Methods

The microsporogenesis was investigated using both light and epifluorescence microscopy. The ultrastructure of the pollen grain was studied using transmission electron microscopy.

Key Results

The cytokinesis is successive and formation of the intersporal callose wall is achieved by centrifugal cell plates, as a one-step process. The microspore tetrads were tetragonal, decussate, T-shaped and linear, except in P. pusillus, which showed less variation. This species also showed a callose ring in the microsporocyte, and some rhomboidal tetrads. In the mature pollen, the thickening observed in a broad area of the intine was here interpreted as an artefact.

Conclusions

The data support the view that there is a correlation between the inaperturate pollen production and the release of constraint on tetrad shape. However, in P. pusillus the tetrad shape may be constrained by a callose ring. It is also suggested that the lack of apertures in the pollen of Potamogeton may be due to the lack of specific sites on which callose deposition is completed. Moreover, inaperturate pollen of Potamogeton would be better classified as omniaperturate.Key words: Alismatales, callose, microsporogenesis, pollen aperture, Potamogeton illinoensis, P. polygonus, P. pusillus, tetrad shape     

Using the biomass-ratio and idiosyncratic hypotheses to predict mixed-species litter decomposition

Background and Aims

Microsporogenesis leading to monosulcate pollen grains has already been described for a wide range of monocot species. However, a detailed study of additional callose deposition after the completion of the cleavage walls has been neglected so far. The study of additional callose deposition in monosulcate pollen grain has gained importance since a correlation between additional callose deposition and aperture location has recently been revealed.

Methods

Microsporogenesis is described for 30 species belonging to eight families of the monocots: Acoraceae, Amaryllidaceae, Alstroemeriaceae, Asparagaceae, Butomaceae, Commelinaceae, Liliaceae and Xanthorrhoeaceae.

Key Results

Five different microsporogenesis pathways are associated with monosulcate pollen grain. They differ in the type of cytokinesis, tetrad shape, and the presence and shape of additional callose deposition. Four of them present additional callose deposition.

Conclusions

In all these different microsporogenesis pathways, aperture location seems to be linked to the last point of callose deposition.     

Diversity and evolution of microsporogenesis in Bromeliaceae

In this study, we explore the features of microsporogenesis in Bromeliaceae and, in particular, the diversity and evolution of additional callose deposits. Cytokinesis type, cell wall formation, tetrad form and patterns of additional callose deposition after intersporal wall formation were studied in 12 species of Bromeliaceae (each from a different genus) presenting four different aperture patterns. Microsporogenesis is highly conserved, with successive cytokinesis, centrifugal cell plate formation and predominantly tetragonal and decussate tetrads, as in many monocots, but five different patterns of additional callose deposition were recorded. The optimization of patterns of additional callose deposition on the phylogeny of Bromeliaceae reveals convergences. Additional callose deposition is a variable and labile feature of microsporogenesis in Bromeliaceae and is linked, to some extent, to aperture pattern. © 2014 The Linnean Society of London, Botanical Journal of the Linnean Society, 2014, 176 , 36–45.     

Formation and function of a new pollen aperture pattern in angiosperms: The proximal sulcus of Tillandsia leiboldiana (Bromeliaceae)

Pollen grains are generally surrounded by an extremely resistant wall interrupted in places by apertures that play a key role in reproduction; pollen tube growth is initiated at these sites. The shift from a proximal to distal aperture location is a striking innovation in seed plant reproduction. Reversals to proximal aperture position have only very rarely been described in angiosperms. The genus Tillandsia belongs to the Bromeliaceae family, and its aperture pattern has been described as distal monosulcate, the most widespread aperture patterns recorded in monocots and basal angiosperms. Here we report developmental and functional elements to demonstrate that the sulcate aperture in Tillandsia leiboldiana is not distal as previously described but proximal. Postmeitotic tetrad observation indicates unambiguously the proximal position of the sulcus, and in vitro germination of pollen grains confirms that the aperture is functional. This is the first report of a sulcate proximal aperture with proximal germination. The observation of microsporogenesis reveals specific features in the patterns of callose thickenings in postmeiotic tetrads.     

Microsporogenesis and systematics of Aristolochiaceae

Within Aristolochiaceae, a secretory tapetum and orbicules are ubiquitous, but both simultaneous and successive types of microsporogenesis occur. Simultaneous cytokinesis is apparently plesiomorphic within the order Piperales, in which Aristolochiaceae are now placed. Successive microsporogenesis was found only in species of Aristolochia confined to a crown clade in the proposed phylogeny of this genus. In contrast to many other taxa, within Aristolochiaceae there is no strict relationship between microsporogenesis type and tetrad configuration, which is strongly influenced by spindle orientation, especially during meiosis II. There is also no direct correlation between microsporogenesis type and the aperture of mature pollen grains.     

Pollen aperture morphology in Arecaceae: Application within phylogenetic analyses,and a summary of record of palm-like pollen the fossil

For a monocotyledonous family, the Arecaceae possess unusually varied pollen, not only in aperture number and orientation, but also in exine ornamentation. Although the majority of species have monosulcate pollen, 17 aperture types, and 13 exine types, have been described. The family belongs to a minority of monocotyledonous families in which both successive and simultaneous cytokinesis occur. The aperture types that have been described for the Arecaceae can be separated into those associated with successive, and those associated with simultaneous, cytokinesis. Palms have a long fossil record, mainly leaves and pollen, but also fruits, stems, and roots. Flowers have also been recovered. Distinctive aperture and/or exine combinations, in the pollen of some species, have prompted comparisons with fossil pollen taxa, certainly from the Late Cretaceous onwards. Occurrences of various fossil pollen taxa, frequently associated with palms, are reviewed, and their morphologies, particularly aperture characteristics, are compared with those of living palm pollen. The systematic rarity of most palm aperture types places limitations on their value in cladistic analyses. Nevertheless, certain aperture characters are of value, and do contribute to a better understanding of the evolution and phylogeny of the family. The differences between aperture types and aperture characters are addressed. The seventeen aperture types are described, and the interpretation and use of aperture characters in cladistic analyses of the Arecaceae are discussed.     

Successive microsporogenesis in eudicots, with particular reference to Berberidaceae (Ranunculales)

The eudicot clade of angiosperms is characterised by simultaneous microsporogenesis and tricolpate pollen apertures. Successive microsporogenesis, where a distinct dyad stage occurs after the first meiotic division, is relatively rare in eudicots although it occurs in many early branching angiosperms including monocots. An extensive literature survey shows that successive microsporogenesis has arisen independently at least six times in eudicots, in five different orders, including Berberidaceae (Ranunculales). Microsporogenesis and pollen apertures were examined here using light and transmission electron microscopy in eleven species representing six genera of Berberidaceae. Successive microsporogenesis is a synapomorphy for the sister taxa Berberis and Mahonia (and possibly also Ranzania), the remaining genera are simultaneous. Callose wall formation in Berberis and Mahonia is achieved by centripetal furrowing, though centrifugal cell plates are more usual for this microsporogenesis type. This discrepancy could reflect the fact that the successive type in Berberidaceae is derived from the simultaneous type, and centripetal furrowing has been retained. Eudicots with successive microsporogenesis usually produce tetragonal or decussate tetrads, though occasional tetrahedral or irregular tetrads in Berberis and Mahonia indicate that the switch from simultaneous to successive division is incomplete or “leaky”. In contrast, linear tetrads produced by successive microsporogenesis in Asclepiadoideae (Apocynaceae s.l.) are the result of a highly specialised developmental pathway leading to the production of pollinia. Pollen in successive eudicots is dispersed as monads, dyads, tetrads, and as single grains in pollinia. Apertures are diverse, and patterns include spiraperturate, clypeate, irregular, monocolpate, diporate and inaperturate. It is possible that successive microsporogenesis, although rare, potentially occurs in other eudicots, for example, in species where pollen is inaperturate.     

Pollen and anther characters in monocot systematics

Pollen and anther characters are potentially informative in higher-level systematics of monocotyledons. Several characters of monocot pollen and anthers (tapetum type, microsporogenesis type and inaperturate pollen) are reviewed here in relation to recent phylogenetic concepts of the group, and new data are presented for some critical taxa. The first-branching monocotyledon, Acorus , has a secretory tapetum but most other early branching taxa (i.e., most Alismatales, except Tofieldia ) are plasmodial. The lilioid orders, Pandanales, Dioscoreales, Liliales and Asparagales are almost uniformly secretory. The tapetum is more diverse within the commelinoid clade. Successive microsporogenesis predominates in the monocotyledons although the simultaneous type is of systematic significance within some orders, such as Dioscoreales,Asparagales and Poales. Inaperturate pollen (either "functionally monoaperturate" or "omniaperturate") occurs in every major monocot group. It predominates in Alismatales and Zingiberales, and is a synapomorphy for some Liliales and Asparagales.     

The influence of tetrad shape and intersporal callose wall formation on pollen aperture pattern ontogeny in two eudicot species

Background and Aims

In flowering plants, microsporogenesis is accompanied by various types of cytoplasmic partitioning (cytokinesis). Patterns of male cytokinesis are suspected to play a role in the diversity of aperture patterns found in pollen grains of angiosperms. The relationships between intersporal wall formation, tetrad shape and pollen aperture pattern ontogeny are studied.

Methods

A comparative analysis of meiosis and aperture distribution was performed within tetrads in two triporate eudicot species with contrasting aperture arrangements within their tetrads [Epilobium roseum (Onagraceae) and Paranomus reflexus (Proteaceae)].

Key Results and Conclusions

Intersporal wall formation is a two-step process in both species. Cytokinesis is first achieved by the formation of naked centripetal cell plates. These naked cell plates are then covered by additional thick, localized callose deposits that differ in location between the two species. Apertures are finally formed in areas in which additional callose is deposited on the cell plates. The recorded variation in tetrad shape is correlated with variations in aperture pattern, demonstrating the role of cell partitioning in aperture pattern ontogeny.     

Cytokinesis in plant male meiosis

In somatic cell division, cytokinesis is the final step of the cell cycle and physically divides the mother cytoplasm into two daughter cells. In the meiotic cell division, however, pollen mother cells (PMCs) undergo two successive nuclear divisions without an intervening S-phase and consequently generate four haploid daughter nuclei out of one parental cell. In line with this, the physical separation of meiotic nuclei does not follow the conventional cytokinesis pathway, but instead is mediated by alternative processes, including polar-based phragmoplast outgrowth and RMA-mediated cell wall positioning. In this review, we outline the different cytological mechanisms of cell plate formation operating in different types of PMCs and additionally focus on some important features associated with male meiotic cytokinesis, including cytoskeletal dynamics and callose deposition. We also provide an up-to-date overview of the main molecular actors involved in PMC wall formation and additionally highlight some recent advances on the effect of cold stress on meiotic cytokinesis in plants.     

Aperture variation in the pollen of Nelumbo (Nelumbonaceae)

The evolutionary and developmental origin of tricolpate pollen is of great interest because pollen of this kind defines a major clade of angiosperms (eudicots), a clade that is also well supported by molecular data. We examined evidence that tricolpate and monosulcate pollen types are produced alongside each other in the anthers of Nelumbo flowers, as has previously been reported. Observations of pollen in situ within individual anthers revealed mainly tricolpate pollen produced in tetrahedral tetrads, but also a small percentage of clearly aberrant pollen grains that have a great variety of aperture configurations. Previously published evidence for tetragonal tetrads is not supported, and previously reported monosulcate grains are part of a continuum of variation among the aberrant grains in aperture number, position and form. Other eudicots show similar variability in their pollen apertures. The variation in the pollen of Nelumbo is not exceptional, and may not be more significant than variation seen in the other taxa with regard to the origin of the tricolpate and tricolpate‐derived pollen characteristic of eudicots. Nevertheless further studies of aberrant pollen in Nelumbo and other eudicots, together with comparisons of pollen development in “normal” eudicots and closely related species that show radical, and developmentally fixed, reorganization of apertures and pollen polarity, may be helpful in understanding the processes that controlled the transition from the monosulcate to the tricolpate condition.     

毛百合小孢子发生和雄配子体发育过程的解剖学研究

在显微水平上对毛百合小孢子发生和雄配子体的发育过程与不同发育阶段花蕾的外部形态的相关性进行了研究.结果显示:毛百合每个花药具4个花粉囊,小孢子母细胞减数分裂属连续型,小孢子在四分体中的排列属左右对称型,也有少数四面体型.成熟花粉粒属2-细胞型,并有1个萌发沟.花粉囊壁由4层细胞构成,即表皮、药室内壁、中层、绒毡层.绒毡层细胞为腺质,出现多核现象.研究发现花蕾大小与小孢子各发育时期密切相关.     

Significance of monosulcate pollen abundance in Mesozoic sediments

Monosulcate pollen was produced by at least six plant orders in the Mesozoic. Megafossils of these orders are abundant in many Mesozoic sediments, but dispersed monosulcate pollen grains are commonly less than 10% of total sporomorphs (spores and pollen) in a sample. This paper presents possible explanations for the different relative frequencies of megafossils and pollen grains of monosulcate-producing plants (some of the explanations apply to only a few taxa): fragility of the pollen exines, destruction of the pollen on the plant by insects, poor pollen dispersal because of zoophily and small plant size, and, probably most importantly, overrepresentation of the plants by their generally deciduous leaves. Mesozoic monosulcate pollen was different in several ways from pollen of modern gymnosperms; furthermore, monosulcate-producing plants were not as abundant in the Mesozoic vegetation as has been generally thought.     

Triaperturate pollen in the monocotyledons: configurations and conjectures

Triaperturate pollen are known in at least twenty seven genera of monocotyledons. Differences between aperture type and polarity indicate that the development of three apertures has occurred a number of times. Mode of cytokinesis during microsporogenesis is compared with differences in aperture configuration, to assess the extent to which this appears to influence aperture arrangement. Triapertury in monocot pollen tends to fall into one or another of three situations: 1) it is the normal state, 2) it is fairly common, but pollen with more or less apertures also occur in the taxon or sample, 3) it is a rare, or abnormal state for pollen which usually has less than three apertures. The various forms of triaperturate pollen are described, as well as monosulcate pollen of the orchid genera Cypripedium and Paphiopedilum, often misinterpreted as tri-sulcate, and the unusual extended trichotomosulcate pollen of Agrostocrinum (Hemerocallidaceae). Monosulcy, trichotomosulcy, and zonasulcy, with unusual and rare exceptions of zonasulcy in the eudicots, are aperture states shared exclusively with the basal dicots. Furthermore, to some extent all have links with the triaperturate condition in monocots and basal dicotyledons. This is discussed, as well as the association of tripory with polypory in monocots and basal dicots. The fossil pollen record is considered.This paper is dedicated to Klaus Kubitzki in recognition, not only for his extensive contribution to systematic botany, but also for his firm belief that pollen characteristics contribute to a better understanding of plant systematics and evolution.     

Microsporogenesis,microgametogenesis, and pollen morphology of <Emphasis Type="Italic">Ambrosia artemisiifolia</Emphasis> L. in China

Ambrosia artemisiifolia L. from Ambrosia of the Heliantheae of the Asteraceae family is a recognized harmful weed worldwide and one of the major invasive foreign plants in China. In this study, we investigated its reproductive features, focusing on its microsporogenesis, microgametogenesis, and pollen morphology. The results show that (1) Ambrosia artemisiifolia L. is a dicotyledonous plant and has spherical, tricolpate pollen grains with spiny outer wall; (2) its anther wall comprises four layers, namely epidermis, endothecium, middle layers, and amoeboid tapetum; (3) cytokinesis of microspore mother cells is successive; (4) most of tetrads are tetrahedral; and (5) mature pollen grains are three-celled. In conclusion, although Ambrosia artemisiifolia L. is a dicotyledonous plant with tricolpate pollen, its microsporogenesis is successive, which is different from typical dicots.     

Microsporogenesis in Monocotyledons

This paper critically reviews the distribution of microsporogenesistypes in relation to recent concepts in monocot systematics.Two basic types of microsporogenesis are generally recognized:successive and simultaneous, although intermediates occur. Theseare characterized by differences in tetrad morphology, generallytetragonal or tetrahedral, although other forms occur, particularlyassociated with successive division. Successive microsporogenesisis predominant in monocotyledons, although the simultaneoustype characterizes the ‘lower’ Asparagales. Simultaneousmicrosporogenesis also occurs inJaponolirion and Petrosavia(unplaced taxa), some Araceae, Aponogeton, Thalassia andTofieldia(Alismatales), Dioscorea, Stenomeris and Tacca (Dioscoreales),and some Commelinanae: Arecaceae (Arecales), and Cyperaceae,Juncaceae and Thurniaceae (Poales). Simultaneous microsporogenesisis of phylogenetic significance within some of these groups,for example, Asparagales, Dioscoreales and Poales. An intermediatetype is recorded in Stemonaceae (Pandanales), Commelinaceae(Commelinales) and in Eriocaulaceae and Flagellariaceae (Poales).There is little direct relationship between microsporogenesistype and pollen aperture type in monocots (except for trichotomosulcateand pantoporate apertures), although trichotomosulcate aperturesin monocot pollen, and equatorial tricolpate and tricolporateapertures in eudicot pollen, are all related to simultaneousmicrosporogenesis. Copyright 1999 Annals of Botany Company Microsporogenesis, monocotyledons, pollen apertures, phylogeny, tetrads, simultaneous, successive, systematics.