Chromosomal fragmentation in dUTPase-deficient mutants of Escherichia coli and its recombinational repair

Recent findings suggest that DNA nicks stimulate homologous recombination by being converted into double-strand breaks, which are mended by RecA-catalysed recombinational repair and are lethal if not repaired. Hyper-rec mutants, in which DNA nicks become detectable, are synthetic-lethal with recA inactivation, substantiating the idea. Escherichia coli dut mutants are the only known hyper-recs in which presumed nicks in DNA do not cause inviability with recA, suggesting that nicks stimulate homologous recombination directly. Here, we show that dut recA mutants are synthetic-lethal; specifically, dut mutants depend on the RecBC-RuvABC recombinational repair pathway that mends double-strand DNA breaks. Although induced for SOS, dut mutants are not rescued by full SOS induction if RecA is not available, suggesting that recombinational rather than regulatory functions of RecA are needed for their viability. We also detected chromosomal fragmentation in dut rec mutants, indicating double-strand DNA breaks. Both the synthetic lethality and chromosomal fragmentation of dut rec mutants are suppressed by preventing uracil excision via inactivation of uracil DNA-glycosylase or by preventing dUTP production via inactivation of dCTP deaminase. We suggest that nicks become substrates for recombinational repair after being converted into double-strand DNA breaks.     

Patterns of chromosomal fragmentation due to uracil-DNA incorporation reveal a novel mechanism of replication-dependent double-stranded breaks

There is growing evidence that spontaneous chromosomal fragmentation, one of the main contributors to genetic instability, is intimately linked to DNA replication. In particular, we proposed before that uracil incorporation in DNA triggers chromosomal fragmentation due to replication fork collapse at uracil-excision intermediates. We tested predictions of this model at the chromosomal level in the dut mutants of Escherichia coli , by determining the relationship between DNA replication and patterns of fragmentation in defined chromosomal segments. Here we show that the uracil-DNA-triggered chromosomal fragmentation: (i) has a gradient that parallels the replication gradient, (ii) shows polarity within defined segments pointing towards replication origins and (iii) reorganizes to match induced replication gradients, confirming its dynamic pattern. Unexpectedly, these fragmentation patterns not only support the replication fork collapse model, but also reveal another mechanism of the replication-dependent chromosomal fragmentation triggered by uracil excision.     

The mutT defect does not elevate chromosomal fragmentation in Escherichia coli because of the surprisingly low levels of MutM/MutY-recognized DNA modifications

Nucleotide pool sanitizing enzymes Dut (dUTPase), RdgB (dITPase), and MutT (8-oxo-dGTPase) of Escherichia coli hydrolyze noncanonical DNA precursors to prevent incorporation of base analogs into DNA. Previous studies reported dramatic AT-->CG mutagenesis in mutT mutants, suggesting a considerable density of 8-oxo-G in DNA that should cause frequent excision and chromosomal fragmentation, irreparable in the absence of RecBCD-catalyzed repair and similar to the lethality of dut recBC and rdgB recBC double mutants. In contrast, we found mutT recBC double mutants viable with no signs of chromosomal fragmentation. Overproduction of the MutM and MutY DNA glycosylases, both acting on DNA containing 8-oxo-G, still yields no lethality in mutT recBC double mutants. Plasmid DNA, extracted from mutT mutM double mutant cells and treated with MutM in vitro, shows no increased relaxation, indicating no additional 8-oxo-G modifications. Our DeltamutT allele elevates the AT-->CG transversion rate 27,000-fold, consistent with published reports. However, the rate of AT-->CG transversions in our mutT(+) progenitor strain is some two orders of magnitude lower than in previous studies, which lowers the absolute rate of mutagenesis in DeltamutT derivatives, translating into less than four 8-oxo-G modifications per genome equivalent, which is too low to cause the expected effects. Introduction of various additional mutations in the DeltamutT strain or treatment with oxidative agents failed to increase the mutagenesis even twofold. We conclude that, in contrast to the previous studies, there is not enough 8-oxo-G in the DNA of mutT mutants to cause elevated excision repair that would trigger chromosomal fragmentation.     

RdgB acts to avoid chromosome fragmentation in Escherichia coli

Bacterial RecA protein is required for repair of two-strand DNA lesions that disable whole chromosomes. recA mutants are viable, suggesting a considerable cellular capacity to avoid these chromosome-disabling lesions. recA-dependent mutants reveal chromosomal lesion avoidance pathways. Here we characterize one such mutant, rdgB/yggV, deficient in a putative inosine/xanthosine triphosphatase, conserved throughout kingdoms of life. The rdgB recA lethality is suppressed by inactivation of endonuclease V (gpnfi) specific for DNA-hypoxanthines/xanthines, suggesting that RdgB either intercepts improper DNA precursors dITP/dXTP or works downstream of EndoV in excision repair of incorporated hypoxathines/xanthines. We find that DNA isolated from rdgB mutants contains EndoV-recognizable modifications, whereas DNA from nfi mutants does not, substantiating the dITP/dXTP interception by RdgB. rdgB recBC cells are inviable, whereas rdgB recF cells are healthy, suggesting that chromosomes in rdgB mutants suffer double-strand breaks. Chromosomal fragmentation is indeed observed in rdgB recBC mutants and is suppressed in rdgB recBC nfi mutants. Thus, one way to avoid chromosomal lesions is to prevent hypoxanthine/xanthine incorporation into DNA via interception of dITP/dXTP.     

Role of exonuclease III in the base excision repair of uracil-containing DNA.

Mutants of Escherichia coli K-12 deficient in both exonuclease III (the product of the xth gene) and deoxyuridine triphosphatase (the dut gene product) are inviable at high temperatures and undergo filamentation when grown at such temperatures. In dut mutants, the dUTP pool is known to be greatly enhanced, resulting in an increased substitution of uracil for thymine in DNA during replication. The subsequent removal of uracil from the DNA by uracil-DNA glycosylase produces apyrimidinic sites, at which exonuclease III is known to have an endonucleolytic activity. The lethality of dut xth mutants, therefore, indicates that exonuclease III is important for this base-excision pathway and suggests that unrepaired apyrimidinic sites are lethal. Two confirmatory findings were as follows. (i) dut xth mutants were viable if they also had a mutation in the uracil-DNA glycosylase (ung) gene; such mutants should not remove uracil from DNA and should not, therefore, generate apyrimidinic sites. (ii) In the majority of the temperature-resistant revertants isolated, viability had been restored by a mutation in the dCTP deaminase (dcd) gene; such mutations should decrease dUTP production and hence uracil misincorporation. The results indicate that, in dut mutants, exonuclease III is essential for the repair of uracil-containing DNA and of apyrimidinic sites.     

Replication forks stalled at ultraviolet lesions are rescued via RecA and RuvABC protein-catalyzed disintegration in Escherichia coli

Ultraviolet (UV) irradiation is not known to induce chromosomal fragmentation in sublethal doses, and yet UV irradiation causes genetic instability and cancer, suggesting that chromosomes are fragmented. Here we show that UV irradiation induces fragmentation in sublethal doses, but the broken chromosomes are repaired or degraded by RecBCD; therefore, to observe full fragmentation, RecBCD enzyme needs to be inactivated. Using quantitative pulsed field gel electrophoresis and sensitive DNA synthesis measurements, we investigated the mechanisms of UV radiation-induced chromosomal fragmentation in recBC mutants, comparing five existing models of DNA damage-induced fragmentation. We found that fragmentation depends on active DNA synthesis before, but not after, UV irradiation. At low UV irradiation doses, fragmentation does not need excision repair or daughter strand gap repair. Fragmentation absolutely depends on both RecA-catalyzed homologous strand exchange and RuvABC-catalyzed Holliday junction resolution. Thus, chromosomes fragment when replication forks stall at UV lesions and regress, generating Holliday junctions. Remarkably, cells specifically utilize fork breakage to rescue stalled replication and avoid lethality.     

Synthesis and metabolism of uracil-containing deoxyribonucleic acid in Escherichia coli

Significant amounts of uracil were found in the deoxyribonucleic acids (DNAs) of Escherichia coli mutants deficient in both uracil-DNA glycosylase (ung) and deoxyuridine 5'-triphosphate nucleotidohydrolase (dut) activities, whereas little uracil was found in the DNAs of wild-type cells and cells deficient in only one of these two activities. The amounts of uracil found in the DNAs of dut ung mutants were directly related to the growth temperature of the cultures, apparently because the deoxyuridine 5'-triphosphate nucleotidohydrolase synthesized by dut mutants was temperature sensitive. The dut mutant used failed to grow exponentially, became filamentous at temperatures above 25 degrees C, and exhibited a hyperrec phenotype; however, the ung mutation suppressed all of these effects. Although the dut ung mutants grew exponentially at all temperatures, their growth rates were always slower than the growth rate of the wild type. Since pool size measurements indicated that both deoxyuridine triphosphate and deoxythymidine triphosphate pools were markedly elevated in dut mutants, the reduced growth rate of dut ung cells apparently was due to the actual presence of uracil in the DNA, rather than to a deficiency of deoxyuridine triphosphate and deoxyribosylthymine triphosphate for DNA synthesis. The presence of uracil in E. coli donor DNA also markedly reduced the recombination frequency when the recipient cells were ung+, indicating that DNA repair commenced before the entering DNA could be replicated.     

dUTP pyrophosphatase is an essential enzyme in Saccharomyces cerevisiae.

dUTP pyrophosphatase (dUTPase; EC 3.6.1.23) catalyses the hydrolysis of dUTP to dUMP and PPi and thereby prevents the incorporation of uracil into DNA during replication. Although it is widely believed that dUTPase is essential for cell viability because of this role, direct evidence supporting this assumption has not been presented for any eukaryotic system. We have analysed the role of dUTPase (DUT1) in the life cycle of yeast. Using gene disruption and tetrad analysis, we find that DUT1 is necessary for the viability of S. cerevisiae; however, under certain conditions dut1 null mutants survive if supplied with exogenous thymidylate (dTMP). Analyses with isogenic uracil-DNA-glycosylase (UNG1) deficient or proficient strains indicate that in the absence of dUTPase, cell death results from the incorporation of uracil into DNA and the attempted repair of this damage by UNG1-mediated excision repair. However, in dut1 ung1 double mutants, starvation for dTMP causes dividing cells to arrest and die in all phases of the cell cycle. This latter effect suggests that the extensive stable substitution of uracil for thymine in DNA leads to a general failure in macromolecular synthesis. These results are in general agreement with previous models in thymine-less death that implicate dUTP metabolism. They also suggest an alternative approach for chemotherapeutic drug design.     

sbcB sbcC null mutations allow RecF-mediated repair of arrested replication forks in rep recBC mutants

We have proposed previously that, in Escherichia coli, blockage of replication forks can lead to the reversal of the fork. Annealing of the newly synthesized strands creates a double-stranded end adjacent to a Holliday junction. The junction is migrated away from the DNA end by RuvAB and can be cleaved by RuvC, while RecBCD is required for the repair of the double-stranded tail. Consequently, the rep mutant, in which replication arrests are frequent and fork reversal occurs, requires RecBCD for growth. We show here that the combination of sbcB sbcCD null mutations restores the viability to rep recBC mutants by activation of the RecF pathway of recombination. This shows that the proteins belonging to the RecF pathway are able to process the DNA ends made by the replication fork reversal into a structure that allows recombination-dependent replication restart. However, we confirm that, unlike sbcB null mutations, sbcB15, which suppresses all other recBC mutant defects, does not restore the viability of rep recBC sbcCD strains. We also show that ruvAB inactivation suppresses the lethality and the formation of double-stranded breaks (DSBs) in a rep recBC recF strain, totally deficient for homologous recombination, as well as in rep recBC mutants. This confirms that RuvAB processing of arrested replication forks is independent of the presence of recombination intermediates.     

Chromosomal lesion suppression and removal in Escherichia coli via linear DNA degradation

RecBCD is a DNA helicase/exonuclease implicated in degradation of foreign linear DNA and in RecA-dependent recombinational repair of chromosomal lesions in E. coli. The low viability of recA recBC mutants vs. recA mutants indicates the existence of RecA-independent roles for RecBCD. To distinguish among possible RecA-independent roles of the RecBCD enzyme in replication, repair, and DNA degradation, we introduced wild-type and mutant combinations of the recBCD chromosomal region on a low-copy-number plasmid into a DeltarecA DeltarecBCD mutant and determined the viability of resulting strains. Our results argue against ideas that RecBCD is a structural element in the replication factory or is involved in RecA-independent repair of chromosomal lesions. We found that RecBCD-catalyzed DNA degradation is the only activity important for the recA-independent viability, suggesting that degradation of linear tails of sigma-replicating chromosomes could be one of the RecBCD's roles. However, since the weaker DNA degradation capacity due a combination of the RecBC helicase and ssDNA-specific exonucleases restores viability of the DeltarecA DeltarecBCD mutant to a significant extent, we favor suppression of chromosomal lesions via linear DNA degradation at reversed replication forks as the major RecA-independent role of the RecBCD enzyme.     

Replication fork inhibition in seqA mutants of Escherichia coli triggers replication fork breakage

SeqA protein negatively regulates replication initiation in Escherichia coli and is also proposed to organize maturation and segregation of the newly replicated DNA. The seqA mutants suffer from chromosomal fragmentation; since this fragmentation is attributed to defective segregation or nucleoid compaction, two‐ended breaks are expected. Instead, we show that, in SeqA's absence, chromosomes mostly suffer one‐ended DNA breaks, indicating disintegration of replication forks. We further show that replication forks are unexpectedly slow in seqA mutants. Quantitative kinetics of origin and terminus replication from aligned chromosomes not only confirm origin overinitiation in seqA mutants, but also reveal terminus under‐replication, indicating inhibition of replication forks. Pre‐/post‐labelling studies of the chromosomal fragmentation in seqA mutants suggest events involving single forks, rather than pairs of forks from consecutive rounds rear‐ending into each other. We suggest that, in the absence of SeqA, the sister‐chromatid cohesion ‘safety spacer’ is destabilized and completely disappears if the replication fork is inhibited, leading to the segregation fork running into the inhibited replication fork and snapping the latter at single‐stranded DNA regions.     

Characterization of nascent DNA fragments produced by excision of uracil residues in DNA.

Nascent short DNA chains could result from repair of incorporated uracil residues or be intermediates in discontinuous replication. We have characterized short DNA chains having apyrimidinic/apurinic-sites at 5' ends, the expected intermediates of repair, to distinguish them from RNA-linked replication intermediates. We have synthesized model substrates for the repair products; d(pRib[32P]poly(T)) and d(Rib[32P]poly(T)). Alkaline hydrolysis of both substrates has produced [5'-32P]poly(dT). Nascent short DNA was prepared from an Escherichia coli sof (dut) mutant, in this strain fragments from excision repair of uracil residues accumulate. The products of alkaline treatment are hardly digested by spleen exonuclease which selectively degrades 5'-hydroxyl-terminated DNA. These two results show that alkaline hydrolysis of the uracil repair fragments produces 5'-phosphoryl-terminated DNA, whereas it is known that 5'-hydroxyl-terminated DNA is generated from RNA-linked DNA molecules. The two types of nascent fragments thus can be distinguished by the 5'-terminal structure produced by an alkaline hydrolysis.     

Multiple mutant of Escherichia coli synthesizing virtually thymineless DNA during limited growth.

The dut gene of Escherichia coli encodes deoxyuridine triphosphatase, an enzyme that prevents the incorporation of dUTP into DNA and that is needed in the de novo biosynthesis of thymidylate. We produced a conditionally lethal dut(Ts) mutation and isolated a phenotypic revertant that had a mutation in an unknown gene tentatively designated dus (for dut suppressor). The dus mutation restored the ability of the dut mutant to grow at 42 degrees C without restoring its enzymatic activity or thymidylate independence. A strain was constructed bearing, in addition to these mutations, ones affecting the following genes and their corresponding products: ung, which produces uracil-DNA N-glycosylase, a repair enzyme that removes uracil from DNA; deoA, which produces thymidine (deoxyuridine) phosphorylase, which would degrade exogenous deoxyuridine; and thyA, which produces thymidylate synthase. When grown at 42 degrees C in minimal medium containing deoxyuridine, the multiple mutant displayed a 93 to 96% substitution of uracil for thymine in new DNA. Growth stopped after the cellular DNA had increased 1.6- to 1.9-fold and the cell mass had increased 1.7- to 2.7-fold, suggesting a general failure of macromolecular biosynthesis. DNA hybridization confirmed that the uracil-containing DNA was chromosomal and that new rounds of initiation must have occurred during its synthesis.     

Uracil-DNA glycosylase affects mismatch repair efficiency in transformation and bisulfite-induced mutagenesis in Streptococcus pneumoniae.

The generalized mismatch repair system of Streptococcus pneumoniae (the Hex system) can eliminate base pair mismatches arising in heteroduplex DNA during transformation or by DNA polymerase errors during replication. Mismatch repair is most likely initiated at nicks or gaps. The present work was started to examine the hypothesis that strand discontinuities arising after removal of uracil by uracil DNA-glycosylase (Ung) can be utilised as strand discrimination signals. We show that mismatch repair efficiency is enhanced 3- to 6-fold when using uracil-containing DNA as donor in transformation. In order to assess the contribution of Ung to nascent strand discrimination for postreplication mismatch repair, we developed a positive selection procedure to isolate S. pneumoniae Ung- mutants. We succeeded in isolating Ung- mutants using this procedure based on chromosomal integration of uracil-containing hybrid DNA molecules. Cloning and characterization of the ung gene was achieved. Comparison of spontaneous mutation rates in strains either proficient or deficient in mismatch and/or uracil repair gave no support to the hypothesis that Ung plays a major role in targeting the Hex system to neosynthesized DNA strands. However Ung activity is responsible for the increased efficiency of mismatch repair observed in transformation with uracil-containing DNA. In addition Ung is involved in repair of bisulfite-treated transforming DNA.     

DNA intermediates at the Escherichia coli replication fork. II. Studies using dut and ung mutants in vitro.

The incorporation of uracil into and excision from DNA were studied in vitro using lysates on cellophane discs made from Escherichia coli strains with defects in the enzymes dUTPase (dut) and uracil-DNA glycosylase (ung).Results with dut ung lysates indicate that dUTP is competitively incorporated with dTTP at the replication fork. Such incorporation is not due to DNA polymerase I. There is a mild discrimination (2.5-fold) against incorporation of dUTP versus dTTP. These data, together with in vivo uracil incorporation data (Tye et al., 1978) permit a rough estimate of the pool of dUTP in vivo (~0.5% of the dTTP pool).These in vitro data indicate that uracil-DNA glycosylase is the initial step in at least 90% of uracil excision events. However, in a strain defective in uracil-DNA glycosylase (ung-1), uracil-containing DNA is still more subject to single-strand scission than non-uracil-containing DNA, albeit at a rate at least tenfold less than in an ung⁺ strain.A number of qualitative statements may also be made about different steps in uracil incorporation and subsequent excision and repair events. When high levels of dUTP are added in vitro, a dut ung⁺ strain has a higher steady-state level of uracil in newly synthesized DNA than does an isogenic dut⁺ ung strain. Thus the dUTPase in these lysates has a higher capacity to be overloaded than does the excision system (i.e. uracil DNA glycosylase). However, the DNA sealing system (presumably DNA polymerase I and DNA ligase) apparently can handle all single-strand interruptions being introduced by uracil excision at the maximal rate, at least so that DNA synthesis can continue.     

A versatile endonuclease IV from Thermus thermophilus has uracil-excising and 3'-5' exonuclease activity

Apurinic/apyrimidinic (AP) sites arise in DNA through the spontaneous loss of bases or through the release of damaged bases from DNA by DNA glycosylases. AP sites in DNA can be catalyzed by AP endonucleases such as exonuclease III and endonuclease IV, generating a 3'-hydroxyl group and a 5'-terminal sugar phosphate. Here, we have identified and characterized a novel endonuclease IV from a hyperthermophilic bacterium Thermus thermophilus designated as TthNfo. TthNfo efficiently removed AP site from double-stranded oligonucleotide substrate. No significant difference was observed in the rate of reaction of four bases opposite AP site with TthNfo. In addition, TthNfo possesses a 3'-5' exonuclease activity similar to that of Escherichia coli exonuclease III. Surprisingly, we found that TthNfo also catalyzes the excision of uracil from DNA. In comparison with other endonuclease IV proteins, the removal of uracil residue was unique to TthNfo. Based on these observations and the absence of exonuclease III in T. thermophilus, we suggest that versatile enzyme activities of TthNfo play an important role in counteracting DNA base damage in vivo.     

Production of clastogenic DNA precursors by the nucleotide metabolism in Escherichia coli

RdgB is a bacterial dNTPase with a strong in vitro preference for non-canonical DNA precursors dHapTP, dXTP and dITP that contain deaminated or aminogroup-modified purines. Utilization of these nucleotides by replisomes in rdgB mutants of Escherichia coli produces modified DNA, on which EndoV nicking near the base analogues initiates excision repair. Some EndoV-initiated excision events cause chromosomal fragmentation, which becomes inhibitory if recombinational repair is also inactivated (the rdgB recA co-inhibition). To reveal the sources and the identities of the non-canonical DNA precursors, intercepted by RdgB in E. coli , we characterized 17 suppressors of the rdgB recA co-inhibition. Ten suppressors affect genes of the RNA/DNA precursor metabolism, identifying the source of non-canonical DNA precursors. Comparing chromosomal fragmentation with the density of EndoV-recognized DNA modifications distinguishes three mechanisms of suppression: (i) reduction of the non-canonical dNTP production, (ii) inhibition of the base analogue excision from DNA and (iii) enhancement of the cell tolerance to chromosomal fragmentation. The suppressor analysis suggests IMP as the key intermediate in the synthesis of the clastogenic DNA precursor, most likely dITP.     

Isolation and partial characterization of a bacteriophage T5 mutant unable to induce thymidylate synthetase and its use in studying the effect of uracil incorporation into DNA on early gene expression.

A mutant of phage T5 which is unable to induce thymidylate synthetase was isolated. T5 thy mutants synthesized less DNA than did wild-type T5, and the burst size of progeny phage was correspondingly reduced two- to threefold in thy+ Escherichia coli. No DNA or progeny phage were made in E. coli thy hosts grown in the absence of exogenous thymine. When the T5 thy mutation was recombined with a T5 dut mutation (unable to induce dUTPase), replication resulted in progeny which contained significant amounts of uracil in their DNA, and these phage failed to produce plaques unless the plating host was deficient in uracil-DNA glycosylase. T5 phage containing various amounts of uracil in their DNA were prepared and used to determine the effect of uracil on the induction of the early enzyme dTMP kinase. The presence of uracil in the parental DNA increased the rate of induction of this enzyme by about 2.5-fold. The T5 thy gene was mapped and is located near the T5 frd gene on the B region of the T5 genome.     

Cisplatin induces DNA double-strand break formation in Escherichia coli dam mutants

Escherichia coli dam cells are more susceptible to the cytotoxic action of cisplatin than wildtype. Dam mutS or dam mutL bacteria, however, are resistant to this agent indicating that active mismatch repair sensitizes dam cells to cisplatin toxicity. Genetic data, obtained previously, were consistent with the generation and repair of cisplatin-induced double-strand breaks (DSBs). We measured DSB formation in temperature-sensitive dam recB mutants, after exposure to cisplatin, using pulse field gel electrophoresis and observed an increase in linear 100-300 kb DNA fragments corresponding to approximately 15-45 double strand breaks per genome. The formation of these DSBs was temperature and dose-dependent and was decreased in recBC bacteria at the permissive temperature or in dam(+) or mutS control strains. There was a three-fold increase in circa 2 mb linear chromosomal fragments in dam recBC strains at the non-permissive temperature compared to recBC alone. We show that dam priA strains are not viable suggesting that DSB formation is dependent on DNA replication restart. The sensitivity of priA mutants to cisplatin is also consistent with this conclusion.