Altered immune response patterns in murine syngeneic pregnancy: presence of natural null suppressor cells in maternal spleen identifiable by monoclonal antibodies

Expression of certain autologous lymphocyte-activating antigenic determinants on the developing embryo is known to provide a stimulus for maternal anti-fetal autoproliferative responses. If left unregulated these responses could exert negative influences on the reproductive process by converting to autoaggressive forms of immune reactivity. In normal circumstances, immunological reactions of this nature are therefore likely to be under the control of pregnancy-associated immunoregulatory elements found within the maternal/fetal environment. In the present investigation we describe a naturally occurring splenic inhibitory cell type devoid of conventional T, B, and macrophage surface markers associated with syngeneic murine pregnancy that is capable of exerting potent immunosuppressive effects on an in vitro expression of fetal/newborn T cell autoreactivity, namely the autologous mixed lymphocyte reaction (AMLR). Maternal spleen cells inhibitory for AMLR were found to be highly resistant to cytotoxic pretreatment with a panel of conventional antisera directed against T cell-specific antigenic determinants. The non-T nature of the natural splenic suppressor cell was further indicated by experiments showing that purified spleen T cells had no inhibitory activity. Pregnancy spleen cell populations that were effectively depleted of macrophages retained full ability to inhibit AMLR. Maternal suppressor activity could be localized to the spleen cell population bearing receptors for the B cell-specific lectin, soybean agglutinin (SBA). A panel of monoclonal antibodies prepared against enriched populations of suppressor cells was screened and selected for specific reactivity using an ELISA against glutaraldehyde-fixed SBA+ spleen cell subpopulations from pregnant versus virgin animals. Several of the monoclonals developed against suppressor-enriched spleen cell populations from isopregnant as well as allopregnant animals were effective in reducing or eliminating suppressor cell activity following cytotoxic pretreatment in the presence of complement. The novel set of anti-suppressor monoclonal antibodies described here should prove useful in furthering the isolation and characterization of pregnancy-associated suppressor cells and in determining their relationship to natural suppressor cell populations described in other systems.     

Immunological nonreactivity of newborn mice: immaturity of T cells and selective action of neonatal suppressor cells

Mitogen-stimulated spleen cells from newborn mice do not synthesize mRNA for the 55-kDa interleukin-2 receptor (IL-2R). The kinetic of development after birth of ability to synthesize IL-2R correlated well with the functional immaturity of T cells, as was tested by responsiveness to T-cell mitogen concanavalin A (Con A). This functional immaturity of T cells was not due to the activity of neonatal suppressor cells (NSC) which inhibited immune responses induced by mitogens or antigens. The suppressor cells did not inhibit proliferation of spleen cells stimulated with IL-1 or IL-2, nor did they inhibited expression of genes for tumor necrosis factor (TNF)-beta, TNF-alpha, and IL-2R in stimulated cells from adult mice. The results thus show functional immaturity of T cells in newborn mice and selectivity of the immunosuppressive action of NSC, which allow for production and for functional activity of cytokines at a time when the specific immune system is not functional because of both immaturity and a selective activity of inhibitory cells.     

Regulation on murine T cell responses to autologous antigens by alpha-fetoprotein

Murine α-fetoprotein (AFP), a major component of fetal and newborn sera, was shown to exert potent immunosuppressive effects on autologous mixed lymphocyte reactions (AMLR) in vitro. Thus, the relatively vigorous proliferative response of newborn CBA/J thymocytes reacting in mixed cultures against adult syngeneic spleen cells was almost totally abrogated by 200 and 100 μg/ml AFP over the 6-day time course studied, with significant suppression still evident in the presence of 10 μg/ml AFP. In contrast, the maximum achievable suppression of parellel allogeneic MLRs was only 40 to 60%. The newborn thymocyte anti-adult syngeneic spleen AMLR was shown to be mediated by an Lyt 1⁺23^? T-cell subset reacting against Ia⁺ adult non-T stimulator cells. Newborn and adult AMLRs resulting from autochthonous T responder/non-T stimulator cell mixtures from individual animals were also found to be highly sensitive to AFP-mediated suppression. The fact that fetal-derived AFP could be shown to efficiently inhibit neonatal thymocyte responses to autologous antigens when tested in vitro in amounts 20 to 50 times lower than the levels present in fetal and newborn sera suggests a potentially important role for endogenous AFP in the regulation of autosensitization during ontogeny.     

Murine natural suppressor cells in the newborn, in bone marrow, and after cyclophosphamide. Genetic variations and dependence on IFN-gamma

Natural suppressor (NS) cells are potent, Ag nonspecific, MHC-unrestricted inhibitors of immune responses. Murine NS activity is found in several situations, including adult bone marrow (BM) and neonatal/newborn spleen, and spleen following total lymphoid irradiation, after BM transplantation and after cyclophosphamide (CY) treatment. Using three of these situations (adult BM, newborn spleen, and spleen after CY treatment), the strain distribution of NS cell activity was assessed. A wide variation in potency is seen in both naturally occurring (adult BM and newborn spleen) and induced (after CY treatment) NS cell activity. Up to 10-fold differences in NS activity are seen between high and low NS strains. This reflects an intrinsic genetic variation between mouse strains in both naturally occurring and CY-induced NS cell activity. Thus, a strain with high NS activity at birth, has high NS activity in its BM as an adult and in its spleen after CY treatment. Of the strains tested, B10.D2 has the highest NS cell activity while BALB/c has the lowest, and the F1 between these two strains is intermediate in NS activity. Finally, the NS cell activity from all strains tested required IFN-gamma for expression of its inhibitory activity.     

Immunodepressive effect of cell populations with varying erythropoietic activity in embryos and newborn mice

The cells of liver from the 11-12 day old embryos and of spleen from newborn mice were transplanted to adult syngeneic recipients immunized by the ram erythrocytes. The immune response in the recipient spleens was estimated by the number of antibody-forming cells. The cells of embryonic liver and of newborn spleen suppressed the immune response in recipients to a great extent. The immunodepressive effect obtained was similar to suppression due to the transfer of cell populations from the mice in which erythropoiesis was stimulated by hypoxia of phenylhydrazine. The splenocytes of adult control mice and the cells of spleen from 6-9 day old mice did not exert such an effect. The rabbit antiserum to erythroid cells relieved the suppressor effect of the embryonic liver and neonatal spleen cells, as well as of the other erythropoietic populations. A conclusion is drawn on participation of cells-suppressors of the erythroid nature in the mechanisms of immunological non-responsiveness at the early ontogenetic stages in mice.     

Role of I-J in neonatal suppression

Spleen cells from neonatal mice belonging to strains with the I-J-b or I-J-k genotype, were treated with anti-I-Jb or anti-I-Jk antibody and complement. This reduces their suppressor cell activity as demonstrated by a decrease in the ability to suppress the mixed-lymphocyte reactivity of adult spleen cells. Injection of anti-I-J antibody into neonatal mice also reduces splenic suppressor cell activity prematurely. The removal of suppressor cells from neonatal spleen does not result in an immediate increase in mixed-lymphocyte reactivity (cell-mediated immunity) but does hasten the development of mixed-lymphocyte reactivity in the young mice. The results are discussed in light of the hypothesis that suppressor cells inhibit the function of immunocompetent cells in the neonatal mouse and control the development of immunocompetence.     

Stimulation of suppressor cells in the bone marrow and spleens of high dose cyclophosphamide-treated C57Bl/6 mice

Systemic administration of a single dose (300 mg/kg) of cyclophosphamide (Cy) induced the appearance of a population of suppressor cells in the bone marrow and spleens of mice. Suppressor cells were assayed by their capacity to inhibit the concanavalin A (Con A) blastogenesis or the mixed-lymphocyte response of normal C57Bl/6 spleen cells. Cy-induced bone marrow (Cy-BM) suppressor cells were present as early as 4 days following Cy therapy and their activity gradually decreased over the next 2 weeks. Cy-induced splenic (Cy-Sp) suppressor cells were maximally present on Days 6 through 10 following Cy therapy. Studies were performed to characterize the suppressor cells of bone marrow obtained 4 days after Cy treatment and of normal bone marrow (N-BM). Some suppressor activity was present in normal bone marrow. N-BM suppressor cells resembled cells of the monocyte/macrophage lineage in that they were slightly adherent to Sephadex G-10, sensitive to L-leucine methyl ester (LME), and insensitive to treatment either with anti-T-cell antibody and complement or with anti-immunoglobulin antibody and complement. Their suppressive activity was abrogated by incubation with either indomethacin or catalase. Cy-BM suppressor cells were also resistant to treatment with anti-T-cell and anti-immunoglobulin antibody and complement but were not adherent to Sephadex G-10 and not sensitive to LME. Their suppressive activity was partially eliminated by indomethacin alone or in combination with catalase. We conclude that Cy chemotherapy induces the appearance of a population of immune suppressive cells and that these cells appear first in the bone marrow and subsequently in the spleen.     

In vitro activation of bone marrow-derived T-and non-T-cell subsets by alpha-fetoprotein

Alpha-Fetoprotein (AFP) is a major serum glycoprotein during embryonic and early postnatal life. A number of diverse biologic functions have been attributed to AFP, including osmotic and carrier function and immunosuppressive activity. In this study we demonstrate that AFP selectively stimulates in vitro proliferation of two distinct subsets of adult murine bone marrow cells. One population of AFP-reactive bone marrow cells expresses surface receptors for soybean agglutinin (SBA) lectin. SBA+ bone marrow cells are resistant to cytotoxic pretreatment with T-cell-specific antisera and are not retained on Ig-anti-Ig affinity columns. The absence of conventional T- and B-cell markers, coupled with the presence of SBA receptors, suggests that AFP-activated non-T bone marrow cells may belong to an immature set of B lymphocytes. A second population of AFP-responsive bone marrow cells expresses the Thy-1+ Lyt 1+2- phenotype characteristic of conventional mature adult T helper cells. The potential physiological relevance of the mitogenic effects of AFP on bone marrow cells with respect to immunoregulatory processes in the fetal/newborn environments is discussed.     

Suppressor activity in the spleen of neonatal mice.

Helper cells of T-cell origin are required for the in vitro proliferation of low numbers of adult mouse thymus cells in response to allogeneic spleen cells. These helper cells are present in the adult mouse spleen. We have demonstrated that neonatal mouse spleen cells lack the helper activity present in adult spleen cells. We have also shown that this lack of helper activity is the result of active suppression. The suppression is due to a suppressor cell which is present in high quantities in the neonatal spleen and can be eliminated by treatment with anti-θ serum and complement.     

Recruitment of null cells during graft versus host reactions in the chicken

Untreated SC (B2/B2) chicken spleen or thymus cells (2 × 10⁷) caused significantly increased [³H]thymidine incorporation in spleens of heavily irradiated FP (B15/B21) recipient chicks on Day 4 after iv injection. Mitomycin-treated SC spleen cells or spleen cells treated with rabbit anti-T-cell serum and complement failed to raise the [³H]thymidine incorporation over that in uninjected, bursa cell-injected or FP spleen cell-injected controls. However, the combination of mitomycin-treated spleen or thymus cells and anti-T-treated spleen cells caused an increased [³H]thymidine uptake, suggesting the recruitment of non-T cells into proliferation by alloreactive mitomycin-treated T cells. Bursa cells did not proliferate during GVH reactions even though they could be shown to undergo proliferation in vivo upon mitogen (lipopolysaccharide and dextran sulfate) stimulation. In contrast, anti-T-treated spleen cells from agammaglobulinemic chickens were recruited into proliferation, suggesting that the recruited cell was not only not a T cell, but also no pre-B or B cell and most likely represented a cell of the monocyte-macrophage series.     

Tumour rejection after adoptive transfer of line-10-immune spleen cells is mediated by two T cell subpopulations

Summary The growth of line-10 tumours in naive guinea pigs is prevented by adoptive transfer of spleen cells that are hyperimmune to this hepatocellular carcinoma. To study the T cell subpopulations responsible for the adoptive transfer of immunity, various cell populations were removed from immune spleen cells using monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) and magnetic microspheres. Spleen cell subpopulations were identified by mAb after flow cytometry and rosette formation with the magnetic microspheres. mAb CT5 was confirmed to be a pan T cell marker, while the CT6 (anti-T-suppressor/cytotoxic) and CT7 (anti-T-cell) markers were present on two different T cell subpopulations. So our results show that CT7 mAb cannot be used as a pan T cell marker as was published previously. Moreover, the mAb H155 (anti-T-helper/inducer) reacted with the same T cell subpopulation recognized by CT7. So we designated this H155/CT7-positive subpopulation as T helper/inducer cells. Removal of the CT6-, CT7-, or the H155-positive T cells from the immune spleen cells resulted in loss of the in vitro poliferative response to line-10 tumour protein and tuberculin purified protein derivative (PPD). The H155/CT7(anti-T-helper/inducer)-positive spleen cells did not express MHC class II antigens as determined by mAb 25E3. In most experiments, elimination of MHC-class-II-positive cells did not change the in vitro proliferative response to line-10 protein, whereas the response to tuberculin PPD was completely abrogated. Immune spleen cells after depletion of CT6-, CT7- or H155-positive cells, failed to transfer immunity. However, after depletion of MHC-class-II-antigen-positive cells the line-10 immunity was still present, whereas the immune response to tuberculin PPD was lost. In conclusion, our data indicate that immunity to the line-10 tumour is the result of a cooperation between at least two different T cell subpopulations, the T helper/inducer (CT7/H155) cells and the T suppressor/cytotoxic cells (CT6). If this is a common feature, then the therapeutic approach of in vitro expanded TIL cells should take into consideration the requirement of two T cell subsets.     

Induction and amplification of T-lymphocyte proliferative responses to periodate and soybean agglutinin by human adult vascular endothelial cells

Human mononuclear phagocyte (M phi) populations were compared to adult human endothelial cells (HEC) for their respective abilities to influence the proliferative responses of purified human T lymphocytes to the mitogenic agents Na-m-periodate (IO-4), soybean agglutinin (SBA), or allogeneic cells. HEC and M phi were both capable of inducing proliferative responses of allogeneic T lymphocytes in mixed-lymphocyte culture. Under low cell density culture conditions, purified T-lymphocyte proliferative responses to IO-4 or SBA could be restored by addition of syngeneic M phi or HEC. At higher cell density culture conditions, proliferation of T cells to IO-4 could be amplified more by HEC than M phi. T-lymphocyte proliferative responses to SBA were amplified by addition of HEC but were suppressed by addition of M phi. These findings indicate that human adult HEC are unique and potent accessory cells for T lymphocytes. Furthermore, these findings demonstrate that accessory cell functions of HEC can be discriminated from those of M phi.     

Effector mechanisms in allograft rejection. II. Density, electrophoresis, and size fractionation of allograft-infiltrating cells demonstrating several classes of killer cells.

An analysis of killer cells infiltrating “sponge-matrix” allografts during rejection has been performed by preparative fractionation by density centrifugation, velocity sedimentation, and free flow cell electrophoresis and by the use of heterologous anti-T-cell sera. At the peak of rejection, 7 to 8 days after transplantation, the allograft is infiltrated by several classes of killer cells, most notably by non-T lymphocytes, monocytes/macrophages, and T lymphocytes. The predominant cell types capable of performing in vitro lysis of relevant target cells appeared to be monocytes and non-T lymphocytes. T lymphocytes formed only a minority of the killer cells at this stage of the response. In contrast, as also documented earlier, the predominant killer cells in the regional lymph nodes and the spleen of the graft recipient mice were T lymphocytes (blasts).     

Appearance of lymphocyte surface markers and functional responses in neonatal and young rabbit spleens

We examined spleen cells from newborn to 1-month-old rabbits for easily detectable surface immunoglobulin, complement receptors, and for in vitro proliferative responsiveness to anti-immunoglobulin antisera and several mitogens. From birth through the first month of life about 15% of the cells from rabbit spleens had easily detectable surface immunoglobulin while about 45% had C3 receptors. In adults as many as 77% of the spleen cells had easily detectable surface Ig but the proportion with C3 receptors remained about 45%. The proliferative response to anti-allotype antisera was present at birth, and was at adult levels by 1 month of age. The proliferative response to pokeweed mitogen was low when cells were obtained during the first week of life but was comparable in magnitude to the response of adult cells by 2 weeks of age. In vitro responsiveness to concanavalin A was present at low levels at birth and increased sharply during the first week. We did not observe significant stimulation of spleen cells from neonatal to 4-week-old rabbits by lipopolysaccharide from Salmonella typhosa. Our data suggest that lymphocyte surface markers and functional responses appear asynchronously in spleen cells of developing rabbits.     

Inability of newborns' or pregnant women's monocytes to suppress pokeweed mitogen-induced responses

Although an excess of human adult blood adherent cells inhibits the pokeweed mitogen- (PWM) induced normal adult lymphocyte proliferation and B cell maturation into immunoglobulin-containing cells (ICC), adherent cells collected from newborn infants or pregnant women at time of delivery were unable to exert a similar suppressor activity. After activation by Concanavalin A (Con A), newborns' and pregnant women's adherent cells acquired a suppressor activity comparable to that of control adult adherent cells. The adherent suppressor cell was shown to be radioresistant (3000 rad), indicating its probable monocytic origin. Both monocyte-suppressor activities (MSA) observed in adulthood (spontaneously) and in the neonatal period (after activation) were dependent on prostaglandin E2 (PGE2) secretion, because they were abolished by indomethacin or a specific anti-PGE2 antiserum. Expression of MSA appeared to be under a negative regulation exerted by naturally occurring T suppressor lymphocytes present in the blood of newborns or pregnant women, because incubation of adult monocytes or Con A-activated newborn monocytes with newborns' or pregnant women's T lymphocytes resulted in a dramatic decrease of their MSA. These results strongly suggest that the lack of MSA in the neonatal period and in late pregnancy is a consequence of activation of T suppressor lymphocytes.     

Biological expressions of lymphocyte activation. IV. Concanavalin A-activated suppressor cells in mouse mixed lymphocyte reactions.

Thymus-derived lymphocytes (T cells) from mouse spleen, activated in vitro or in vivo with concanavalin A (Con A), suppress proliferative responses of syngenic lymphocytes in mixed lymphocyte reactions (MLR). Replication in vitro was not required for expression of suppressor activity by Con A-activated cells and was blocked in MLR by treating suppressor cells with mitomycin C or irradiation. Kinetics of MLR responses and viability of cultures were not altered by addition of activated suppressor cells. The data are consistent with a direct inhibitory effect of suppressor T cells on antigen-induced DNA replication. These observations extend a model previously described for regulation of antibody synthesis by Con A-activated T cells to control of cell-mediated immune responses. This model should be particularly useful in further definition of regulatory T cell subpopulations, and in investigation of interactions and relationships between such populations.     

Effect of injection of adult mouse peritoneal macrophages on suppressor cell activity in neonatal mice

Injection of adult mouse peritoneal exudate cells into newborn mice results in a premature decrease of splenic suppressor cell activity in the neonates. The effect becomes apparent 4–5 days after ip injection of 10–15 × 10⁶ thioglycollate-induced peritoneal exudate cells into mice on the day of birth. The macrophage in the peritoneal exudate is the responsible cell type. The effect is not H-2 restricted or strain limited. Heat-killed peritoneal exudate cells or peritoneal cells from unstimulated donors can also decrease neonatal suppressor cell activity prematurely. Adult spleen cells, injected into neonatal mice, do not affect suppressor cell activity. The data are discussed in light of the hypothesis that macrophages control suppressor activity in neonatal mice and that an increase in the number and/or function of macrophages shortly after birth results in a decrease in the number and/or function of suppressor cells, allowing for immunological competence to emerge.     

Further evidence for non-T-cell regulation of delayed hypersensitivity in the guinea pig.

The nature of the suppressor activity in the spleens of guinea pigs immunized with dinitrophenyl-bovine γ-globulin in Freund's incomplete adjuvant was investigated. An anti-T-cell serum was prepared in rabbits and, after extensive absorption, showed specific killing for T-lymphocytes. After treatment with this antiserum and complement, spleen cells from animals immunized with the antigen in Freund's complete adjuvant showed marked reduction in ability to transfer sensitivity to normal recipients. However, when immune spleen cells, treated in the same way, were transferred into antigen immunized animals which had been pretreated with cyclophosphamide, the suppressor activity was unaltered. These results confirm earlier impressions that the regulation of delayed hypersensitivity reactions in the guinea pig is normally mediated by non-T-cells.     

Human newborn autologous mixed lymphocyte response: frequency and phenotype of responders and xenoantigen specificity

The response of human newborn lymphocytes in autologous mixed lymphocyte culture was examined for specificity (by restimulation), responder cell phenotype, and responder cell frequency. When the newborn T cells were separated from non-T cells by rosetting with sheep erythrocytes (E) in fetal calf serum (FCS), approximately 1:20,000 T cells proliferated. These responders had specificity for E + FCS, were T4+, and were self-restricted. Significant numbers of responder T cells were not found when newborn T and non-T cells were separated by nylon wool. Responses in parallel autologous cultures of adult T cells showed that 1) adults had a higher frequency than newborns of E + FCS specific responders, 2) evidence for self specificity was lacking in restimulated cultures, and 3) occasional responses to antigen on the surface of monocytes could not be excluded.     

Neonatal immunity develops in a transgenic TCR transfer model and reveals a requirement for elevated cell input to achieve organ-specific responses

In recent years, it has become clear that neonatal exposure to Ag induces rather than ablates T cell immunity. Moreover, rechallenge with the Ag at adult age can trigger secondary responses that are distinct in the lymph node vs the spleen. The question addressed in this report is whether organ-specific secondary responses occur as a result of the diversity of the T cell repertoire or could they arise with homogeneous TCR-transgenic T cells. To test this premise, we used the OVA-specific DO11.10 TCR-transgenic T cells and established a neonatal T cell transfer system suitable for these investigations. In this system, neonatal T cells transferred from 1-day-old DO11.10/SCID mice into newborn (1-day-old) BALB/c mice migrate to the host's spleen and maintain stable frequency. The newborn BALB/c hosts were then given Ig-OVA, an Ig molecule carrying the OVA peptide, and challenged with the OVA peptide in CFA at the age of 7 wk; then their secondary responses were analyzed. The findings show that the lymph node T cells were deviated and produced IL-4 instead of IFN-gamma and the splenic T cells, although unable to proliferate or produce IFN-gamma, secreted a significant level of IL-2. Supply of exogenous IL-12 during Ag stimulation restores both proliferation and IFN-gamma production by the splenic T cells. This restorable form of splenic unresponsiveness referred to as IFN-gamma-dependent anergy required a transfer of a high number of neonatal DO11.10/SCID T cells to develop. Thus, the frequency of neonatal T cell precursors rather than repertoire diversity exerts control on the development of organ-specific neonatal immunity.