Streptomycin and lincomycin resistances are selective plastid markers in cultured Nicotiana cells

Summary Resistance to streptomycin and lincomycin in plant cell culture is used as a color marker: resistant cells are green whereas sensitive cells are white on the selective medium. Streptomycin and lincomycin at appropriate concentrations do not kill sensitive Nicotiana cells. The selective value of plastid ribosomal DNA mutations, conferring resistance to streptomycin and lincomycin, was investigated by growing heteroplastidic cells on a selective medium. The heteroplastidic cells were obtained by protoplast fusion, and contained a mixed population of streptomycin resistant plastids from the N. tabacum line Nt-SR1-Kan2, and lincomycin resistant plastids from the N. plumbaginifolia line Np-LR400-Hyg1. Clones derived from protoplast fusion were selected by kanamycin and hygromycin resistance, transgenic nuclear markers. Somatic hybrids were then grown on a selective streptomycin or lincomycin medium, or in the absence of either drug to a 50 to 100 mg size callus. Southern analysis of a polymorphic region of plastid DNA (ptDNA) revealed that somatic hybrids grown on streptomycin contained almost exclusively ptDNA from the streptomycin resistant parent, somatic hybrids grown on lincomycin contained almost exclusively ptDNA from the lincomycin resistant parent whereas somatic hybrids grown in the absence of either drug contained mixed parental plastids. Sensitive ptDNA was below detection level in most clones on selective medium, but could be recovered upon subsequent culture in the presence of the appropriate drug. The drugs streptomycin and lincomycin provide a powerful selection pressure that should facilitate recovery of plastid transformants.     

Interspecific protoplast fusion to rescue a cytoplasmic lincomycin resistance mutation into fertile Nicotiana plumbaginifolia plants

Summary A lincomycin-resistant cell line, LR105, was isolated in a mutagenized (0.1 mM N-ethyl-N-nitrosourea) callus culture initiated from a haploid Nicotiana sylvestris plant. The regenerated plants had an abnormal morphology and did not set viable seeds.Transfer of lincomycin resistance was attempted from the original N. sylvestris nuclear background into Nicotiana plumbaginifolia by protoplast fusion, since it was expected that resistance would be cytoplasmically coded. LR105 protoplasts were irradiated with a lethal dose (120 J kg^-1; ⁶⁰ Co source), fused with sensitive N. plumbaginifolia protoplasts and the colonies grown from the fused population were screened for lincomycin resistance. Expression of resistance was expected only if the cytoplasm of the irradiated cells had mixed with nonirradiated cytoplasm, and was reactivated as a result of cell fusion (Menczel et al. 1982).Plants were regenerated in 44 resistant clones. Plants in 41 clones had a N. plumbaginifolia nuclear genome. In three clones somatic hybrids were obtained. The resistant N. plumbaginifolia cybrid plants were fertile, unlike the original LR105 plants. Lincomycin resistance was inherited maternally in the eight clones in which crosses were made. In these clones the introduction of N. sylvestris chloroplasts into a N. plumbaginifolia nuclear background was confirmed by the SmaI restriction endonuclease pattern of the chloroplast DNA. The involvement of chloroplast DNA in determining lincomycin resistance is therefore implied.     

Impact of the stringency of cell selection on plastid segregation in protoplast fusion-derived Nicotiana regenerates

Summary Vegetative segregation of a mixed plastid population in protoplast fusion-derived cell lines can be directed by a selection favouring the multiplication of one of the parental plastid types. This report defines some of the critical conditions leading to a homogeneous plastid population in cybrid plants generated by protoplast fusion between Nicotiana plumbaginifolia and an albino and streptomycin-resistant N. tabacum plastid mutant. Light (1,500 lx) conferred a strong selective advantage to chloroplasts versus albino plastids, while the lack of this effect in dim light (300 lx) indicated that a sufficient light intensity is essential to the phenomenon. Selection on streptomycin-containing medium in the dark, however, led to the preferential multiplication of resistant plastids. Streptomycin selection of resistant chloroplasts in the light, consequently, results in a plastid selection of doubled stringency. In another experiment a definite, but leaky, selection for chloroplast recombination (selection for greening on streptomycin-containing medium in dim light) was used to reveal various recombination products. Protoplast fusion in fact resulted in cybrid plants showing only simple chimeric segregation of unchanged parental plastids. These results demonstrate the essential requirement for stringent plastid selection, as defined by cell culture conditions, to precede the formation of shoots expected to possess the desired plastid genetic composition.     

Fusion-mediated transfer of triazine-resistant chloroplasts: Characterization of Nicotiana tabacum cybrid plants

Summary Terbutryn-resistant plastids of the Nicotiana plumbaginifolia TBR2 mutant were introduced into N. tabacum plants by protoplast fusion following X-irradiation of TBR2 protoplasts. The N. tabacum chloroplast recipient line, SR1-A15, carried mutant (albino) plastids. Following protoplast fusion, potential cybrid cell lines with an N. tabacum (SR1-A15) nucleus and N. plumbaginifolia (TBR2) chloroplasts were identified by their green color. The presence of TBR2 plastids in regenerated green N. tabacum plants was confirmed by hybridization with a chloroplast DNA probe and by the modified chloroplast fluorescence transients characteristic of the TBR2 mutant. Cybrid plants were resistant to high levels of atrazine (10 kg/ha). The protruding stigma and shorter than normal filaments of the cybrids resulted in male sterility. In the cybrids atrazine resistance was associated with reduced vigour, suggesting a causal relationship.     

Effect of radiation dosage on efficiency of chloroplast transfer by protoplast fusion in Nicotiana

Chloroplasts of Nicotiana tabacum SR1 were transferred into Nicotiana plumbaginifolia by protoplast fusion. The protoplasts of the organelle donor were irradiated with different lethal doses using a ⁶⁰Co source, to facilitate the elimination of their nuclei from the fusion products. After fusion induction, clones derived from fusion products and containing streptomycin-resistant N. tabacum SR1 chloroplasts were selected by their ability to green on a selective medium. When N. tabacum protoplasts were inactivated by iodoacetate instead of irradiation, the proportion of N. plumbaginifolia nuclear segregant clones was low (1–2%). Irradiation markedly increased this value: Using 50, 120, 210 and 300 J kg^-1 doses, the frequency of segregant clones was 44, 57, 84 and 70 percent, respectively. Regeneration of resistant N. plumbaginifolia plants with SR1 chloroplasts indicated that plastids can be rescued from the irradiated cells by fusion with untreated protoplasts. Resistant N. plumbaginifolia plants that were regenerated (43 clones studied) had diploid (2n = 2X = 20) or tetraploid chromosome numbers and were identical morphologically to parental plants. The absence of aneuploids suggests that in these clones irradiation resulted in complete elimination of the irradiated N. tabacum nuclei. Resistance is inherited maternally (five clones tested). The demonstration of chloroplast transfer and the presence of N. tabacum plastids in the N. plumbaginifolia plants was confirmed by chloroplast DNA fragmentation patterns after EcoRI digestion.     

Transmission of paternal chloroplasts in Nicotiana

Summary Transmission of paternal chloroplasts was observed in Nicotiana, considered to inherit organelles in a strictly maternal way. Plants carrying streptomycin resistant plastids were used as pollen donors. Cell lines with paternal plastids in the offspring were selected as green (resistant) sectors on calli induced from the seedlings on streptomycin-containing media. The presence of paternal plastids in the regenerated plants was confirmed by restriction analysis. In the Nicotiana plumbaginifolia xN. plumbaginifolia Np(SR1)3 and the N. plumbaginifolia Np(gos)29 xN. tabacum SR1 crosses 2.5% and 0.07% of the offspring were found to contain paternal (tabacum) plastids, respectively. These plants, however, carried maternal mitochondria exclusively. This sexual cybridization method offers a simple way to transfer chloroplasts solely, a goal not accessible by protoplast fusion.     

Transmission of paternal chloroplasts in tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum)

Medgyesy et al. (1986, Mol. Gen. Genet. 204, 195–198) have described in Nicotiana plumbaginifolia and in an interspecific cross involving N. plumbaginifolia and N. tabacum a procedure for selecting cell lines derived from seedlings carrying paternal chloroplasts by taking advantage of a plastid-encoded mutation which confers resistance to streptomycin. We have extended their demonstration of occasional transmission of chloroplasts through pollen to the case of an intraspecific cross in N. tabacum. The line used as maternal parent, ITB19(sua), displayed a cytoplasmic male sterility due to the presence of a cytoplasm originating from N. suaveolens. The line used as paternal parent, SR1, was fertile and possessed mutant chloroplasts conferring resistance to streptomycin. From cell lines derived from 204 seedlings, three were regenerated into streptomycin-resistant buds. The plants derived from these three clones were male-sterile. Their progeny, after crossing with a wild type tobacco line, XHFD8, was resistant to streptomycin. Tests of resistance of the seedlings to tentoxin and restriction analyses of the chloroplast DNA indicated that two clones still had the maternal chloroplasts and were thus probably new streptomycin-resistant mutants, whereas the third one had acquired the chloroplasts of the paternal parent, but had retained the mitochondria of the maternal parent.Abbreviations cp-DNA chloroplast DNA - mt-DNA mitochondrial DNA - Np Nicotiana plumbaginifolia - Nt Nicotiana tabacum     

Transfer of defined numbers of chloroplasts into albino protoplasts using an improved subprotoplast/protoplast microfusion procedure: Transfer of only two chloroplasts leads to variegated progeny

Summary A procedure is described by which it is possible to perform controlled microfusion of microscopically selected protoplast fusion partners with high efficiencies. The procedure is applied to fusion of Nicotiana tabacum (line 92V37, N. undulata cytoplasm) plastid albino protoplasts as a recipient and spontaneously formed subprotoplasts of green N. tabacum (line SRI) as donor. Products of individual electrofusion events are cloned via single cell nurse culture and the derived cell lines are analysed for the occurrence of variegated or green regenerating shoots, which are indicative of the establishment of the transferred organelles in the cell progeny. The plastid population in green regenerants recovered after the transfer of only two chloroplasts was demonstrated to have originated from the donor subprotoplast organelles by restriction analysis of total DNA using a plastome-specific probe.Some of the results described in this paper have been presented as posters at scientific meetings (Eigel and Koop 1989b; Eigel and Koop 1990)     

Exceptional inheritance of plastids via pollen in Nicotiana sylvestris with no detectable paternal mitochondrial DNA in the progeny

Plastids and mitochondria, the DNA‐containing cytoplasmic organelles, are maternally inherited in the majority of angiosperm species. Even in plants with strict maternal inheritance, exceptional paternal transmission of plastids has been observed. Our objective was to detect rare leakage of plastids via pollen in Nicotiana sylvestris and to determine if pollen transmission of plastids results in co‐transmission of paternal mitochondria. As father plants, we used N. sylvestris plants with transgenic, selectable plastids and wild‐type mitochondria. As mother plants, we used N. sylvestris plants with Nicotiana undulata cytoplasm, including the CMS‐92 mitochondria that cause cytoplasmic male sterility (CMS) by homeotic transformation of the stamens. We report here exceptional paternal plastid DNA in approximately 0.002% of N. sylvestris seedlings. However, we did not detect paternal mitochondrial DNA in any of the six plastid‐transmission lines, suggesting independent transmission of the cytoplasmic organelles via pollen. When we used fertile N. sylvestris as mothers, we obtained eight fertile plastid transmission lines, which did not transmit their plastids via pollen at higher frequencies than their fathers. We discuss the implications for transgene containment and plant evolutionary histories inferred from cytoplasmic phylogenies.     

Cytoplast-protoplast fusion for interspecific chloroplast transfer in Nicotiana

Summary Protoplasts of Nicotiana tabacum (SR1), carrying a maternally-inherited streptomycin resistance mutation, were enucleated by centrifugation through a Percoll gradient. The resulting cytoplasts containing resistant plastids, were fused with sensitive Nicotiana plumbaginifolia protoplasts. The SR1 cytoplasts, having no nuclei, were unable to form calli. All resistant clones recovered after fusion-induction were therefore supposed to be derived from interspecific cytoplast-protoplast fusion. N. plumbaginifolia plants regenerated in 17 out of the 75 resistant clones studied. Plants obtained from eight of these clones were resistant to streptomycin and inherited the resistance maternally, as expected when transferring SR1 plastids into the N. plumbaginifolia nuclear background. Plastid transfer in these plants has been confirmed by the EcoRI restriction pattern of the chloroplast DNA.In nine clones N. plumbaginifolia plants were sensitive although obtained from initially resistant clones. This phenomenon is explained by the maintenance of plastid heterogeneity on the selective streptomycin medium, and formation of plants from sensitive sectors on the non-selective regeneration medium.SR1 protoplasts, originally present as contaminants in the cytoplast preparation (2–7%) did not form colonies (or very rarely) after polyethylene glycol treatment. The nuclei from such protoplasts were recovered, however, in the interspecific somatic hybrids (56 clones), and in segregants having the SR1 nucleus but some cytoplasm from N. plumbaginifolia (2 clones). The majority (about 80%) of the recovered resistant clones therefore acquired the streptomycin resistance factor from the rare (2–7%) contaminating SR1 protoplasts. This is explained by the protoplasts being more stable during fusion induction.     

A light sensitive recipient for the effective transfer of chloroplast and mitochondrial traits by protoplast fusion in Nicotiana

Summary A light sensitive mutant was used as a recipient in the transfer of chloroplasts from a wildtype donor. Gamma irradiated (lethal dose) mesophyll protoplasts of Nicotiana gossei were fused with mesophyll protoplasts of a N. plumbaginifolia line carrying light sensitive plastids from a N. tabacum mutant. After fusion, colonies containing wild-type plastids from the cytoplasm donor were selected by their green colour. Most of the regenerated plants had N. plumbaginifolia morphology, but were a normal green in colour. The presence of donor-type plastids was confirmed by the restriction pattern of chloroplast DNA in each plant analysed. These cybrids were fully male sterile with an altered flower morphology typical of certain types of alloplasmic male sterility in Nicotiana. The use of the cytoplasmic light sensitive recipient proved to be suitable for effective interspecific transfer of wild-type chloroplasts. The recombinant-type mitochondrial DNA restriction patterns and the male sterility of the cybrids indicated the co-transfer of chloroplast and mitochondrial traits. On leave from: Department of Genetics, Section of Biosciences, Martin Luther University, Domplatz 1, DDR-4020 Halle/ S., German Democratic Republic     

Culture of plant somatic hybrids following electrical fusion

Summary Electrically-induced protoplast fusion has been used to produce somatic hybrids between Nicotiana plumbaginifolia and Nicotiana tabacum. Following fusion of suspension culture protoplasts (N. plumbaginifolia) with mesophyll protoplasts (N. tabacum) heterokaryons were identified visually and their development was followed in culture. Because electrical fusion is a microtechnique, procedures were developed for culturing the heterokaryons in small numbers and at low density. The fusion and culture procedures described are rapid, uncomplicated and repeatable. Good cell viabilities indicate that the fusion procedure is not cytotoxic. Fused material was cultured 1–2 days at high density in modified K3 medium (Nagy and Maliga 1976). The heterokaryons were isolated manually and grown, at low density in conditioned media. Calli have been regenerated. Esterase isozyme patterns confirm the hybrid character of calli and clonally-derived plantlets recovered from these fusions.     

Metabolic complementation for a single gene function associated with partial and total loss of donor DNA in interspecific somatic hybrids

Summary We report here on the obtainment of interspecific somatic, asymmetric, and highly asymmetric nuclear hybrids via protoplast fusion. Asymmetric nuclear hybrids were obtained after fusion of mesophyll protoplasts from a nitrate reductase-deficient cofactor mutant of N. plumbaginifolia with irradiated (100 krad) kanamycin resistant leaf protoplasts of a haploid N. tabacum. Selection for nitrate reductase (NR) and/or kanamycin (Km) resistance resulted in the production of three groups of plants (NR⁺, NR⁺, Km^R, and NR^-Km^R). Cytological analysis of some hybrid regenerants showed the presence of numerous tobacco chromosomes and chromosome fragments, besides a polyploid N. plumbaginifolia genome (tetra or hexaploid). All the regenerants tested were male sterile but some of them could be backcrossed to the recipient partner. In a second experiment, somatic and highly asymmetric nuclear hybrids were obtained after fusion of mesophyll protoplasts from the universal hybridizer of N. plumbaginifolia with suspension protoplasts of a tumor line of N. tabacum. Selection resulted in two types of colonies: nonregenerating hybrid calli turned out to be true somatic hybrids, while cytological analysis of regenerants obtained on morphogenic calli did not show any presence of donor-specific chromosomes. Forty percent of the hybrid regenerants were completely fertile, while the others could only be backcrossed to the recipient N. plumbaginifolia. Since the gene we selected for is not yet cloned, we were not able to demonstrate the transfer of genetic material at the molecular level. However, since no reversion frequency for the nitrate reductase mutant is known, and due to a detailed cytological knowledge of both fusion partners, we feel confident in speculating that intergenomic recombination between N. plumbaginifolia and N. tabacum has occurred.     

The initiation site for recombination cog is at the 3′ end of the his-3 gene in Neurospora crassa

Summary The response of Nicotiana tabacum to tentoxin (chlorosis) is inherited with chloroplasts. N. tabacum var. Xanthi, a tentoxin-resistant line, was used to pollinate tentoxin-sensitive N. tabacum line 92, an alloplasmic male-sterile line containing N. undulata plastids. The seeds were mutagenized with nitrosomethylurea and germinated in the presence of tentoxin. Two percent of the seedlings had green sectors in their first true leaves. These plants were grown to maturity under non-selective conditions. Homogeneous tentoxin-resistant lines were obtained in the third generation. DNA analysis indicated, however, that selection for paternal plastids, rather than mutagenesis of maternal ones, had occurred in the tentoxin-resistant progeny. Mitochondria, which were not under selection pressure, were inherited maternally as expected. Inheritance of tentoxin-resistant paternal plastids did not require seed mutagenesis. Normally germinated seedlings that were kept under tentoxin selection consistently produced a low level of resistant green sectors in their first true leaves. Thus, normal, low-frequency transmission of paternal plastids in N. tabacum can be directly revealed by using tentoxin.     

Chloroplast transfer in Nicotiana based on metabolic complementation between irradiated and iodoacetate treated protoplasts

Protoplasts of a light sensitive plastome mutant of Nicotiana tabacum (2 n=48) were irradiated and fused with iodoacetate-treated Nicotiana plumbaginifolia (2 n=20) protoplasts. Treated parental protoplasts were unable to divide. Metabolic complementation, however, helped the recovery of interspecific fusion products which survived and formed calli. Altogether 40 clones were investigated. N. plumbaginifolia plants were obtained in 15 clones (38%), somatic hybrids in 23 clones, and both types of regenerates were found in 2 clones. Irradiation therefore significantly increased the frequency of segregant formation with the non-irradiated N. plumbaginifolia nuclei (the frequency was 1.4% in the absence of irradiation). Regenerated plants in most cases (31 out of 34) contained chloroplasts from the irradiated parent. In 6 clones plants were obtained with both types of chloroplast. Thus, irradiated N. tabacum chloroplasts had an improved chance of dominating the heterokaryonderived cells, many of which contained N. plumbaginifolia nucleus. The system described should be generally applicable for the transfer of chloroplasts without the use of selectable genetic markers.     

Influence of ploidy on plastome mutagenesis in Nicotiana

Summary A clear influence of ploidy was observed on the frequency of both spontaneous and nitroso-methylurea (NMU) induced, streptomycin-resistant, adventitious shoots developing on leaf explants of Nicotiana tabacum and N. plumbaginifolia. At nearly all NMU levels employed a significantly higher yield of resistant shoots was obtained from haploid compared with diploid leaf strips. At 1 mM NMU the differences were not significant and were absent when a high (1000 mg/1) selective concentration of streptomycin sulphate was used. The influence of ploidy is discussed in relation to the possible effect of plastome copy number on mutagenesis and sorting out of resistant plastids.     

Organelle transfer by microfusion of defined protoplast-cytoplast pairs

Summary Defined cybridization was performed by one-to-one electrofusion (microfusion) of preselected protoplast-cytoplast pairs of male-fertile, streptomycin-resistant Nicotiana tabacum and cytoplasmic male-sterile, streptomycin-sensitive N. tabacum cms (N. bigelovii), followed by microculture of the fusion products until plant regeneration. Dominant selectable markers, namely, kanamycin resistance (nptII) and hygromycin B resistance (hpt) genes had been previously integrated in the nuclear genomes of the otherwise almost fully isogenic parental strains using direct gene transfer to protoplasts. In addition to chromosome counts indicating the expected allotetraploid tobacco count of 48, the absence of the nucleus from the cytoplast donor line was confirmed by Southern blot hybridization using nptII and hpt probes, as well as by an in vitro selection test with leaf expiants and the corresponding enzyme assays for 30 cybrids. The cytoplasmic composition of the cybrids obtained was analyzed for chloroplast type using the streptomycin resistance/sensitivity locus. The fate of mitochondria in cybrids was checked by species-specific patterns in Southern analysis of restriction endonuclease digests of total DNA with N. sylvestris mitochondrial DNA probes.     

Point mutations in the 23 S rRNA genes of four lincomycin resistant Nicotiana plumbaginifolia mutants could provide new selectable markers for chloroplast transformation

Summary Experiments designed to establish stable chloroplast transformation require selectable marker genes encoded by the chloroplast genome. The antibiotic lincomycin is a specific inhibitor of chloroplast ribosomal activity and is known to bind to the large ribosomal subunit. We have investigated a defined region of the chloroplast 23 S rRNA genes from four lincomycin resistant Nicotiana plumbaginifolia mutants and from wild-type N. plumbaginifolia. The mutants LR415, LR421 and LR446 have A to G transitions at positions equivalent to the nucleotides 2058 and 2059 in the Escherichia coli 23 S rRNA. The mutant, LR400, possesses a G to A transition at a position corresponding to nucleotide 2032 of the E. coli 23 S rRNA.     

Somatic hybridization in Nicotiana: Restoration of photoautotrophy to an albino mutant with defective plastids

Protoplasts of a cytoplasmic albino mutant of Nicotiana tabacum L. characterized by a deficient chloroplast genome were fused with protoplasts of a nitrate-reductase deficient mutant (NR^-) of N. tabacum. Somatic hybrids were obtained where the genome of the NR^- mutant was complemented by the cytoplasmic albino mutant which could synthesize an active nitrate reductase, and the chlorophyll deficiency in the albino mutant was restored by the chloroplasts from the NR^- mutant. Cybrids were also obtained in which the deficient plastids of the cytoplasmic albino mutant were replaced by normal chloroplasts from the NR^- mutant. The system used permitted a simple selection of the hybrids and the cybrids. The NR^- mutant was excluded at the cellular level by transfer of the cells to medium deficient in reduced nitrogen. The cytoplasmic albino mutant grew well on the selective nitrate medium. However, during callus formation, clear differences in the morphology and pigmentation of the calli were found which permitted selection for photoautotrophy at the callus level. The hybrid or cybrid nature of the plants was confirmed by examination of their morphology and chromosome number. Although the fusion partners come from the same species, only one plant showed the white-green variegated pattern typical of that of the cytoplasmic albino parent, indicating that segregation of plastids occurred during development of the calli and regeneration of the plants.     

Production of somatic hybrids between Daucus carota L. and Nicotiana tabacum

Protoplasts of a kanamycin-resistant (KR, nuclear genome), streptomycin-resistant (SR, chloroplast genome) and chlorophyll-deficient (A1, nuclear genome) Nicotiana tabacum (KR-SA) cell suspension cultures or X-ray-irradiated mesophyll protoplasts of kanamycin- and streptomycin-resistant green plants (KR-SR) were fused with protoplasts of a cytoplasmic male-sterile (CMS) Daucus carota L. cell suspension cultures by electrofusion. Somatic hybrid plants were selected for kanamycin resistance and the ability to produce chlorophyll. Most of the regenerated plants had a normal D. carota morphology. Callus induced from these plants possessed 23–32 chromosomes, a number lower than the combined chromosome number (66) of the parents, and were resistant to kanamycin, but they segregated for streptomycin resistance, which indicated that N. tabacum chloroplasts had been eliminated. Genomic DNA from several regenerated plants was analyzed by Southern hybridization for the presence of the neomycin phosphotransferase gene (NPTII); all of the plants analyzed were found to contain this gene. Mitochondrial (mt) DNA was analyzed by Southern hybridization of restriction endonuclease digests of mtDNA with two DNA probes, PKT5 and coxII. The results showed that the two plants analyzed possessed the mitochondria of D. carota. These results demonstrate that the regenerated plants are interfamilial somatic hybrids.