The physico-chemical characterization of casein-modified surfaces and their influence on the adhesion of spores from a Geobacillus species

To gain a better understanding of the factors influencing spore adhesion in dairy manufacturing plants, casein-modified glass surfaces were prepared and characterized and their effect on the adhesion kinetics of spores from a Geobacillus sp., isolated from a dairy manufacturing plant (DMP) was assessed using a flow chamber. Surfaces were produced by initially silanizing glass using (3-glycidyloxypropyl) trimethoxysilane (GPS) or (3-aminopropyl) triethoxysilane to form epoxy-functionalized (G-GPS) or amino-functionalized glass (G-NH₂) substrata. Casein was grafted to the G-GPS directly by its primary amino groups (G-GPS-casein) or to G-NH₂ by employing glutaraldehyde as a linking agent (G-NH₂-glutar-casein). The surfaces were characterised using streaming potential measurements, contact angle goniometry, infrared spectroscopy and scanning electron microscopy. The attachment rate of spores suspended in 0.1 M KCl at pH 6.8, was highest on the positively charged (+14 mV) G-NH₂ surface (333 spores cm^?2 s^?1) compared to the negatively charged glass (?22 mV), G-GPS (?20 mV) or G-GPS-casein (?21 mV) surfaces (162, 17 or 6 spores cm^?2 s^?1 respectively). Whilst there was a clear decrease in attachment rate to negatively charged casein-modified surfaces compared to the positively charged amine surface, there was no clear relationship between surface hydrophobicity and spore attachment rate.     

Individual and coupled effects of echinoderm extracts and surface hydrophobicity on spore settlement and germination in the brown alga Hincksia irregularis

Marine substrata possess cues that influence the behavior of fouling organisms. Initial adhesion of fouling algal zoospores to surfaces is also theorized to depend primarily upon interactions between substrata and spore cell bodies and flagellar membranes. In an effort to identify cues and surface characteristics that influence spore settlement and early development, the effects of bioactive echinoderm extracts, surface charge, and surface hydrophobicity were examined individually and in tandem on zoospore settlement and germination in Hincksia irregularis. Experiments utilizing 96-well plastic culture plates confirmed that spore settlement and germination were significantly affected by surface charge and hydrophobicity as well as by echinoderm metabolites, both individually and in tandem. Spore settlement rates in the dark over 30 min were > 400% higher on hydrophobic surfaces than on positively and negatively charged surfaces. Spore germling numbers were > 300% higher on hydrophobic surfaces than on positively and negatively charged surfaces when spores were allowed to settle in the light for 30 min and the settled spores allowed to subsequently germinate for 24 h. Spore germling numbers were consistently > 25% higher on hydrophobic surfaces than on positively and negatively charged surfaces when equal numbers of spores were allowed to completely settle in the light and subsequently germinate for 24 h. H. irregularis germ tube lengths were also significantly longer on positively charged plates than on negatively charged plates. All echinoderm extracts tested had significant effects on germination and settlement at levels below those of estimated ecological concentrations. Short-term (30 min) exposure and subsequent germination experiments indicated that higher concentrations of extracts had rapid toxic effects on algal spores. Synchronous effects of echinoderm extracts and plate charge upon spore settlement varied considerably and did not show a strong dose response relationship. Long-term (24 h) exposure of spores to echinoderm extracts had dosage dependent effects on germination and spore survival. The results of this study indicate that H. irregularis spores possess the capacity for complex responses to their environment, utilizing combined cues of surface charge, surface energy and biochemistry to determine where to settle and germinate. These responses may aid spores in the detection of suitable substrata and conditions for settlement in the marine environment.     

Individual and Coupled Effects of Echinoderm Extracts and Surface Hydrophobicity on Spore Settlement and Germination in the Brown Alga Hincksia irregularis

Marine substrata possess cues that influence the behavior of fouling organisms. Initial adhesion of fouling algal zoospores to surfaces is also theorized to depend primarily upon interactions between substrata and spore cell bodies and flagellar membranes. In an effort to identify cues and surface characteristics that influence spore settlement and early development, the effects of bioactive echinoderm extracts, surface charge, and surface hydrophobicity were examined individually and in tandem on zoospore settlement and germination in Hincksia irregularis. Experiments utilizing 96-well plastic culture plates confirmed that spore settlement and germination were significantly affected by surface charge and hydrophobicity as well as by echinoderm metabolites, both individually and in tandem. Spore settlement rates in the dark over 30?min were >?400% higher on hydrophobic surfaces than on positively and negatively charged surfaces. Spore germling numbers were >?300% higher on hydrophobic surfaces than on positively and negatively charged surfaces when spores were allowed to settle in the light for 30?min and the settled spores allowed to subsequently germinate for 24?h. Spore germling numbers were consistently >?25% higher on hydrophobic surfaces than on positively and negatively charged surfaces when equal numbers of spores were allowed to completely settle in the light and subsequently germinate for 24?h. H. irregularis germ tube lengths were also significantly longer on positively charged plates than on negatively charged plates. All echinoderm extracts tested had significant effects on germination and settlement at levels below those of estimated ecological concentrations. Short-term (30?min) exposure and subsequent germination experiments indicated that higher concentrations of extracts had rapid toxic effects on algal spores. Synchronous effects of echinoderm extracts and plate charge upon spore settlement varied considerably and did not show a strong dose response relationship. Long-term (24?h) exposure of spores to echinoderm extracts had dosage dependent effects on germination and spore survival. The results of this study indicate that H. irregularis spores possess the capacity for complex responses to their environment, utilizing combined cues of surface charge, surface energy and biochemistry to determine where to settle and germinate. These responses may aid spores in the detection of suitable substrata and conditions for settlement in the marine environment.     

Characterization of spore surfaces from a Geobacillus sp. isolate by pH dependence of surface charge and infrared spectra

Aims: The surfaces of spores from a Geobacillus sp. isolated from a milk powder production line were examined to obtain fundamental information relevant to bacterial spore adhesion to materials. Materials and Results: The surfaces of spores were characterized using transmission electron microscopy and infrared spectroscopy. Thin sections of spores stained with ruthenium red revealed an exosporium with a hair‐like nap around the spores. Attenuated total reflection infrared spectra of the spores exposed to different pH solutions on a ZnSe prism revealed that pH‐sensitive carboxyl and phosphodiester groups associated with proteins and polysaccharides contributed to the spore’s negative charge which was revealed by our previous zeta potential measurements on the spores. Lowering the pH to the isoelectric point of spores resulted in an increase in intensity of all spectral bands, indicating that the spores moved closer to the zinc selenide (ZnSe) surface as the charged surface groups were neutralized and the spore surface polymers compressed. The attachment of spores to stainless steel was threefold higher at pH 3 compared with pH 7. Conclusions: This research showed that spore attachment to surfaces is influenced by electrostatic interactions, surface polymer conformation and associated steric interactions. Significance and Impact of the Study: The adhesion of thermophilic spores is largely controlled by functional groups of surface polymers and polymer conformation.     

The measurement of Bacillus mycoides spore adhesion using atomic force microscopy,simple counting methods,and a spinning disk technique

An atomic force microscope has been used to study the adhesion of Bacillus mycoides spores to a hydrophilic glass surface and a hydrophobic-coated glass surface. AFM images of spores attached to the hydrophobic-coated mica surface allowed the measurement of spore dimensions in an aqueous environment without desiccation. The spore exosporium was observed to be flexible and to promote the adhesion of the spore by increasing the area of spore contact with the surface. Results from counting procedures using light microscopy matched the density of spores observed on the hydrophobic-coated glass surface with AFM. However, no spores were observed on the hydrophilic glass surface with AFM, a consequence of the weaker adhesion of the spores at this surface. AFM was also used to quantify directly the interactions of B. mycoides spores at the two surfaces in an aqueous environment. The measurements used "spore probes" constructed by immobilizing a single spore at the apex of a tipless AFM cantilever. The data showed that stretching and sequential bond breaking occurred as the spores were retracted from the hydrophilic glass surface. The greatest spore adhesion was measured at the hydrophobic-coated glass surface. An attractive force on the spores was measured as the spores approached the hydrophobic-coated surface. At the hydrophilic glass surface, only repulsive forces were measured during the approach of the spores. The AFM force measurements were in qualitative agreement with the results of a hydrodynamic shear adhesion assay that used a spinning disk technique. Quantitatively, AFM measurements of adhesive force were up to 4 x 10(3) times larger than the estimates made using the spinning disk data. This is a consequence of the different types of forces applied to the spore in the different adhesion assays. AFM has provided some unique insights into the interactions of spores with surfaces. No other instrument can make such direct measurements for single microbiological cells.     

NUTRIENTS DO NOT INFLUENCE SWIMMING BEHAVIOR OR SETTLEMENT RATES OF ECTOCARPUS SILICULOSUS (PHAEOPHYCEAE) SPORES

Spores newly released from plurilocular sporangia of Ectocarpus siliculosus (Dillw.) Lyngb. sporophytes were assayed for chemotaxis to nutrients and for settlement stimulation by nutrients. To enable these measurements with relatively small volumes and numbers of released spores, we developed a computer-assisted motion-analysis assay for spore chemotaxis and verified the results with a more standard, capillary tube chemotaxis assay. The presence of a nutrient gradient did not influence the swimming behavior of E. siliculosus spores in the motion-analysis assay, and likewise no chemotactic effect was measured in the capillary tube assay. Microplate settlement assays previously utilized with bacteria and invertebrates were adapted for use with algal spores. E. siliculosus spores settled at higher rates on a hydrophobic plastic surface than on surfaces with either positively or negatively charged hydrophilic coatings. Nutrient mixtures had no effect on the rate of spore settlement on hydrophobic surfaces.     

Adhesion of the positively charged bacterium Stenotrophomonas (Xanthomonas) maltophilia 70401 to glass and Teflon.

Medical implants are often colonized by bacteria which may cause severe infections. The initial step in the colonization, the adhesion of bacteria to the artificial solid surface, is governed mainly by long-range van der Waals and electrostatic interactions between the solid surface and the bacterial cell. While van der Waals forces are generally attractive, the usually negative charge of bacteria and solid surfaces leads to electrostatic repulsion. We report here on the adhesion of a clinical isolate, Stenotrophomonas maltophilia 70401, which is, at physiological pH, positively charged. S. maltophilia has an electrophoretic mobility of +0.3 x 10(-8) m2 V-1 s-1 at pH 7 and an overall surface isoelectric point at pH 11. The positive charge probably originates from proteins located in the outer membrane. For this bacterium, both long-range forces involved in adhesion are attractive. Consequently, adhesion of S. maltophilia to negatively charged surfaces such as glass and Teflon is much favored compared with the negatively charged bacterium Pseudomonas putida mt2. While adhesion of negatively charged bacteria is impeded in media of low ionic strength because of a thick negatively charged diffuse layer, adhesion of S. maltophilia was particularly favored in dilute medium. The adhesion efficiencies of S. maltophilia at various ionic strengths could be explained in terms of calculated long-range interaction energies between S. maltophilia and glass or Teflon.     

Resumption of locomotion byAmoeba proteus readhering to different substrata

Summary Floating heterotactic cells ofAmoeba proteus were sedimented on untreated glass surfaces and on modified substrata, differing in their wettability and surface potential. About 95% of the amoebae readhere to the glass within 12 min and recover locomotive (polytactic) morphology within 13 min. The rate of locomotion resumption does not change significantly on styrene/methyl methacrylate co-polymers with contrasting hydrophilic sulfonic group surface densities. Almost all amoebae readhere within 3 min to the positively charged surface of polylysine-coated glass, but locomotive shape is only reassumed after 20 min by 95% of them. The polytactic cells are marked flattened on polylysine and move 2 1/2 times more slowly than on the glass. Floating amoebae never readhere to negatively charged gelatin gel; up to 25% become polytactic after 20 min, but they never resume locomotion. Indifference of amoebae to substratum wettability, and their prompt reaction to the positively or negatively charged surfaces, are discussed. The polylysine and gelatin gel substrata seem suitable for the study of adhesion dependent motor functions in amoebae.     

Forces involved in adhesion of Bacillus cereus spores to solid surfaces under different environmental conditions

H usmark , U. & R önner , U. 1990. Forces involved in adhesion of Bacillus cereus spores to solid surfaces under different environmental conditions. Journal of Applied Bacteriology 69 , 557–562.
The adhesion of Bacillus cereus spores (NCTC 2599) to hydrophobic and hydro-philic glass surfaces was studied when environmental conditions were varied. The spores were exposed in media of different polarities as well as different pH and ionic concentrations. With increasing ethanol concentrations, the polarity of the medium was decreased and the predominant force of attraction was found to be hydrophobic. The spore surface was uncharged at a pH around 3, at which value the spore was most adhesive to both hydrophobic and hydrophilic glass. This could be attributable to the absence of electrostatic repulsion. An increased ionic concentration of the bulk increased the degree of adhesion especially to the hydrophilic surfaces. This indicates the suppression of a solvation barrier at high ionic concentrations, when the polymers of the spore surface become dehydrated.     

The role of initial spore adhesion in pellet and biofilm formation in Aspergillus niger

Fungi grow on a great variety of organic and inorganic materials. Colony establishment and growth on solid surfaces require adhesion of spores and hyphae to the substrate, while cell-to-cell interactions among spores and/or hyphae are a prerequisite for the development of three-dimensional mycelial structures such as pellets or biofilms. Surface adherence has been described as a two-step process, comprised of the initial attachment of ungerminated conidia followed by further adhesion of the forming germ tubes and growing hyphae. In the present study, we analyzed the contribution of adhesion of ungerminated spores to pellet and biofilm formation in Aspergillus niger. Mutants deficient in melanin biosynthesis were constructed by the deletion of the alb1 gene, encoding a polyketide synthase essential for pigment biosynthesis. Δalb1 conidia have an altered surface structure and changed physicochemical surface properties. Spore aggregation in liquid culture as well as spore surface attachment differ between the wild type and the mutant in a pH-dependent manner. In liquid culture further pellet formation is unaffected by altered spore-spore interactions, indicating that germ tube and hyphal adherence can compensate for deficiencies in the initial step of spore attachment. In contrast, under conditions promoting adhesion of Δalb1 conidia to polymer surfaces the mutant forms more stable biofilms than the wild type, suggesting that initial spore adhesion supports sessile growth.     

Forces involved in adhesion of Bacillus cereus spores to solid surfaces under different environmental conditions

The adhesion of Bacillus cereus spores (NCTC 2599) to hydrophobic and hydrophilic glass surfaces was studied when environmental conditions were varied. The spores were exposed in media of different polarities as well as different pH and ionic concentrations. With increasing ethanol concentrations, the polarity of the medium was decreased and the predominant force of attraction was found to be hydrophobic. The spore surface was uncharged at a pH around 3, at which value the spore was most adhesive to both hydrophobic and hydrophilic glass. This could be attributable to the absence of electrostatic repulsion. An increased ionic concentration of the bulk increased the degree of adhesion especially to the hydrophilic surfaces. This indicates the suppression of a solvation barrier at high ionic concentrations, when the polymers of the spore surface become dehydrated.     

Recovery of Spores from Thermophilic Dairy Bacilli and Effects of Their Surface Characteristics on Attachment to Different Surfaces

Spores from four Geobacillus spp. were isolated from a milk powder manufacturing line in New Zealand. Liquid sporulation media produced spore yields of ~10⁷ spores ml⁻¹; spores were purified using a two-phase system created with polyethylene glycol 4000 and 3 M phosphate buffer. The zeta potentials of the spores from the four isolates ranged from −10 to −20 mV at neutral pH, with an isoelectric point between pH 3 and 4. Through contact angle measurements, spores were found to be hydrophilic and had relative hydrophobicity values of 10 to 40%, as measured by the microbial adhesion to hexadecane assay. The most hydrophilic spore isolate with the smallest negative charge attached in the highest numbers to Thermanox and stainless steel (1 × 10⁴ spores cm⁻²), with fewer spores attaching to glass (3 × 10³ spores cm⁻²). However, spores produced by the other three strains attached in similar numbers (P > 0.05) to all substrata (~1 × 10³ spores cm⁻²), indicating that there was no simple relationship between individual physicochemical interactions and spore adherence. Therefore, surface modifications which limit the attachment of one strain may not be effective for all stains, and control regimens need to be devised with reference to the characteristics of the particular strains of concern.     

Adhesion and viability of waterborne pathogens on p-DADMAC coatings

The attachment of waterborne pathogens onto surfaces can be increased by coating the surfaces with positive charge-enhancing polymers. In this paper, the increased efficacy of polydiallyldimethylammonium chloride (p-DADMAC) coatings on glass was evaluated in a parallel plate flow chamber with the use of waterborne pathogens (Raoultella terrigena, Escherichia coli, and Brevundimonas diminuta). p-DADMAC coatings strongly compensated the highly negative charges on the glass surface and even yielded a positively charged surface when applied from a 500 ppm solution. Whereas none of the strains adhered from water to glass due to electrostatic repulsion, R. terrigena and E. coli readily adhered in high numbers to p-DADMAC coated glass slides applied from 1, 100, or 500 ppm aqueous solutions. B. diminuta only adhered to a positively charged p-DADMAC coating applied from a 500 ppm solution. In addition, all p-DADMAC coatings indicated strong contact killing with the bacterial species used in this study by live/dead staining techniques. In summary, this paper demonstrates the potential of p-DADMAC coatings to strongly enhance bacterial adhesion. Moreover, once adhered, bacterial viability can be reduced by the positively charged ammonium groups in the coating.     

Mechanics and electrostatics of the interactions between osteoblasts and titanium surface

Due to oxidation and adsorption of chloride and hydroxyl anions, the surface of titanium (Ti) implants is negatively charged. A possible mechanism of the attractive interaction between the negatively charged Ti surface and the negatively charged osteoblasts is described theoretically. It is shown that adhesion of positively charged proteins with internal charge distribution may give rise to attractive interaction between the Ti surface and the osteoblast membrane. A dynamic model of the osteoblast attachment is presented in order to study the impact of geometrically structured Ti surfaces on the osteoblasts attachment. It is indicated that membrane-bound protein complexes (PCs) may increase the membrane protrusion growth between the osteoblast and the grooves on titanium (Ti) surface and thereby facilitate the adhesion of osteoblasts to the Ti surface. On the other hand, strong local adhesion due to electrostatic forces may locally trap the osteoblast membrane and hinder the further spreading of osteointegration boundary. We suggest that the synergy between these two processes is responsible for successful osteointegration along the titanium surface implant.     

Dependence of the initial adhesion of biofilm forming Pseudomonas putida mt2 on physico-chemical material properties

Bacterial adhesion is strongly dependent on the physico-chemical properties of materials and plays a fundamental role in the development of a growing biofilm. Selected materials were characterized with respect to their physico-chemical surface properties. The different materials, glass and several polymer foils, showed a stepwise range of surface tensions (γ(s)) between 10.3 and 44.7 mN m(-1). Measured zeta potential values were in the range between -74.8 and -28.3 mV. The initial bacterial adhesion parameter q(max) was found to vary between 6.6 × 10(6) and 28.1 × 10(6) cm(-2). By correlation of the initial adhesions kinetic parameters with the surface tension data, the optimal conditions for the immobilization of Pseudomonas putida mt2 were found to be at a surface tension of 24.7 mN m(-1). Both higher and lower surface tensions lead to a smaller number of adherent cells per unit surface area. Higher energy surfaces, commonly termed hydrophilic, could constrain bacterial adhesion because of their more highly ordered water structure (exclusion zone) close to the surface. At low energy surfaces, commonly referred to as hydrophobic, cell adhesion is inhibited due to a thin, less dense zone (depletion layer or clathrate structure) close to the surface. Correlation of q (max) with zeta potential results in a linear relationship. Since P. putida carries weak negative charges, a measurable repulsive effect can be assumed on negative surfaces.     

LIGHT BOUNDARIES AND THE COUPLED EFFECTS OF SURFACE HYDROPHOBICITY AND LIGHT ON SPORE SETTLEMENT IN THE BROWN ALGA HINCKSIA IRREGULARIS (PHAEOPHYCEAE) 1

We examined the effects of light and surface hydrophobicity individually and in tandem on Hincksia irregularis (Kützing) Amsler spore settlement. Hincksia irregularis spores were determined to be negatively phototactic by the use of computer‐assisted motion analysis. Spore settlement was significantly influenced by surface hydrophobicity and by light, individually and in tandem. Experiments conducted using culture plates modified to reduce well edge artifacts revealed significantly higher settlement on hydrophobic surfaces and in dark environments when compared with negatively charged surfaces and lighted environments. Experimental light/dark boundaries elicited distinct spore settlement responses, with spores displaying dissimilar settlement patterns on plates with different surface hydrophobicities. The results of this study indicate H. irregularis spores possess the capacity for complex responses to their environment. These complex responses may influence dispersal and aid spores in the detection of suitable settlement locations in marine microenvironments.     

Alteration of bacterial surface electrostatic potential and pH upon adhesion to a solid surface and impacts to cellular bioenergetics

In our previous study [Hong Y, Brown DG (2009) Appl Environ Microbiol 75(8):2346–2353], the adenosine triphosphate (ATP) level of adhered bacteria was observed to be 2–5 times higher than that of planktonic bacteria. Consequently, the proton motive force (Δp) of adhered bacteria was approximately 15% greater than that of planktonic bacteria. It was hypothesized that the cell surface pH changes upon adhesion due to the charge‐regulated nature of the bacterial cell surface and that this change in surface pH can propagate to the cytoplasmic membrane and alter Δp. In the current study, we developed and applied a charge regulation model to bacterial adhesion and demonstrated that the charge nature of the adhering surface can have a significant effect on the cell surface pH and ultimately the affect the ATP levels of adhered bacteria. The results indicated that the negatively charged glass surface can result in a two‐unit drop in cell surface pH, whereas adhesion to a positively charged amine surface can result in a two‐unit rise in pH. The working hypothesis indicates that the negatively charged surface should enhance Δp and increase cellular ATP, while the positively charged surface should decrease Δp and decrease ATP, and these results of the hypothesis are directly supported by prior experimental results with both negatively and positively charged surfaces. Overall, these results suggest that the nature of charge on the solid surface can have an impact on the proton motive force and cellular ATP levels. Biotechnol. Bioeng. 2010;105: 965–972. © 2009 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

Giardia lamblia attachment force is insensitive to surface treatments

Giardia lamblia cell populations show 90% detachment from glass under normal forces of 2.43+/-0.33 nN applied by centrifugation. Detachment forces were not significantly different for cells attached to positively charged, hydrophobic, or inert surfaces than for cells attached to plain glass. The insensitivity of attachment force to surface treatment is consistent with a suction-based mechanism of attachment.     

Removal kinetics of Bacillus cereus spores from a stainless steel surface exposed to constant shear stress 1 ‐ experimental system

The efficiency of cleaning in place procedures in dairy industries can be greatly affected by the presence of spore‐forming bacteria, which are able to adhere strongly to surfaces and to survive disinfection procedures. Microbial adhesion has been extensively studied, but very few studies have yet reported on the hydrodynamic removal of microorganisms, due to the lack of simple, routinely performable techniques. In this paper, a methodology using a coaxial cylinder double gap viscometer is described, to study the removal kinetics of Bacillus cereus spores from a stainless steel support under hydrodynamic conditions. This method was shown to be reproducible, sensitive and easy to perform, and allowed spore hydrodynamic removal kinetics to be studied as a function of both adhesion and detachment conditions. A high ionic strength attachment medium was shown to enhance adhesion forces, provided it did not contain macromolecules. An increase in shear stress was found to be favorable to spore detachment (4 to 5 times more spores were detached at 28 Pa than at 2 Pa), but removal kinetics were not found to be significantly different for 2 and 15 Pa. Thus, the effect of shear stress on spore removal kinetics may not be linear.     

Effect of NaOH (caustic wash) on the viability, surface characteristics and adhesion of spores of a Geobacillus sp. isolated from a milk powder production line

Aim: To investigate the viability, surface characteristics and ability of spores of a Geobacillus sp. isolated from a milk powder production line to adhere to stainless steel surfaces before and after a caustic (NaOH) wash used in clean‐in‐place regimes. Methods and Results: Exposing sessile spores to 1% NaOH at 65°C for 30 min decreased spore viability by two orders of magnitude. The zeta potential of the caustic treated spores decreased from ?20 to ?32 mV and they became more hydrophobic. Transmission electron microscopy revealed that caustic treated spores contained breaks in their spore coat. Under flow conditions, caustic treated spores suspended in 0·1 mol l^?1 KCl were shown to attach to stainless steel in significantly greater numbers (4·6 log₁₀ CFU cm^?2) than untreated spores (3·6 log₁₀ CFU cm^?2). Conclusions: This research suggests that spores surviving a caustic wash will have a greater propensity to attach to stainless steel surfaces. Significance of Study: The practice of recycling caustic wash solutions may increase the risk of contaminating dairy processing surfaces with spores.